Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
아빠가 쓰러진 이유가 나 때문이었다고?!

아빠는 루카스 덕분에 눈은 떴지만,
여전히 날 기억하지 못하고….

아빠에게 걸린 저주를 치료할 방법을 찾기 위해
제니트를 곁에 두고 있었지만….

“아빠!!!”

피를 토하며 쓰러져 버린 아빠.

알려줘, 루카스!
아빠를 살리려면 어떻게 해야 하는 거야?!

Chapter: 69-83

284 pages, Paperback

First published December 31, 2021

16 people are currently reading
356 people want to read

About the author

Spoon

210 books44 followers
Associated Names:
* SPOON
* 스푼 (Korean Profile)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
988 (57%)
4 stars
516 (30%)
3 stars
181 (10%)
2 stars
19 (1%)
1 star
7 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews
Profile Image for aradhya.
135 reviews
January 13, 2024
cliffhanger end!!!
as much as I was complaining that I wanted to see Lucas.. he really really came and with long hair... how majestic he was looking. i genuinely wanted to know how athy keep herself calm in front of him.. like how?????
the way he said to let me teach a lesson to your father, so he didn't need to see athy cry.. cute, cute, CUTE!!!
I'm pretty sure that something is wrong with that lord of alpheus! he really really hates claude so much, and now I hate him more than anything. this time, i couldn't say anything to Jeannette but she is really a fool and nothing else!!!
Profile Image for belle ☆ミ (thisbellereadstoo).
2,587 reviews174 followers
December 6, 2023
september 2023

completed: chapter 125

i absolutely loved this. athanasia was executed by her father in her previous life and now that she's back, she's trying to find a way to survive. somehow, in this life, athanasia got closer to her coldblooded father and they actually develop a father-daughter relationship. it's heartwarming to see how protective he became.
Profile Image for Lisa.
312 reviews1 follower
June 5, 2024
As always, GORGEOUS ART and such a captivating story. The amnesia plot thickens but we are getting through it! I’m so ready for the next volume already!
Profile Image for Mika (Hiatus).
589 reviews85 followers
July 22, 2025
It was very interesting and tense.

Athanasia didn't know why she cared so much about Athansia (the book character) and Jeanette felt unloved. It was very tense and lots of emotions and I actually like such types of books.

I didn't like how Lucas and Athansia came closer and they way they kissed eachother. As already said in previous reviews of the other books I can't accept such a love relationship knowing that Lucas is way older than Athanasia. I know that Athanasia is re-born and therefore not really a kid and I also got to know in this book that Lucas also knows this, but it still feels so weird and just wrong. I really hope it doesn't turn out like I think it will!

The season 2 ending was a bit weird and abrupt, especially as it didn't end together with this book but shortly before. And then the ending of this book actually was way better and exciting to continue reading.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Linh.
141 reviews9 followers
May 26, 2023
★★★
[3 stars]

Ch. 70 - 84

I know every story needs angst and something thrilling but this is actually turning my heart inside out. I haven’t cried for any part of this, I’m frustrated. It’s so hard to drop it, but it’s also so hard to continue it.

I loved the beginning with the high stakes and bonding but whatever it’s becoming is too much for me.

I have experience with continuing horrible manhwas from webtoon—cause I just didn’t have the heart to stop—so hopefully that’ll help me here! I just really want a HEA and I also wanna see how it plays out.
Profile Image for Carmen.
439 reviews32 followers
April 9, 2025
Copy/paste review for all the volumes:

I read this series online and now need to collect the physical copies. I’m curious if the epilogue/side stories will ever come to be as the creator notes stated that they would but I haven’t seen anything.

As a review of the completed series and not just the one volume I think this sits as a 4.5 ⭐️ if I could give halves.

I enjoy the twists/explanations of reincarnation into a novel verses regression plot that’s more similar to something like Dr Elise.

This one was tagged as romance along with the childcare isekai trope but honestly any romantic storyline for the female protagonist is very secondary to the plot and I personally don’t feel is concretely settled at the end of the main story. As the main plot is that of the FL and her relationship with her father I don’t think we need a solid romance. In something like Father I don’t want this Marriage that is a very good balance between her romance arc and her father daughter relationship arc. While there are a lot of similarities in the father/daughter arc between the two stories, this one doesn’t put as much weight on the romance but then the majority of this story is told while she is in the body of her childhood self. It would be icky if there was more weight on the romance.

I’m not sure why there couldn’t have been a more concrete conclusion to the love triangle as the story definitely favours the one ML as the end game but alas we are left with a “who knows what the future will bring” scenario.

As for the father/daughter relationship I think the backstory/explanation for his cold behaviour that resulted in her death in the novel is well explained and a justifiable one as me the reader to accept why I forgive him in the current life as redeemable. I think others I’ve read have the FL forgiving the father (or other family member) too easily because it wasn’t “them” that was mistreated in the previous “life” when I’m left unsatisfied because it looks like the only reason they are liked and survive in this life is because of luck or they made theirselves interesting or useful when really the father is trash and should just live the kid regardless. Thankfully we get more in this one.

I do wish that we did get a bit more in character development from the father when the plot switches him from cold to caring. We get the why and even some of his awkwardness as he adjusts and while HE doesn’t know that his actions led to her death in the novel he could be a bit more remorseful about the first 5 years of her life in this life where he was nonexistent. Its still good though and worth the read
Profile Image for Anne .
768 reviews4 followers
February 11, 2025
4.25 stars
Dieser Band war echt heftig. Man erfährt, was mit Claude los ist und auch, was Athanasia und Jeanette dabei bewirken. Athanasia möchte helfen und lernt mit Hilfe von Lukas, ihre Magie zu beherrschen. Auch das Verhältnis zu Claude scheint sich, trotz Gedächtnisverlust, zu bessern. Die kleine Rivalität zwischen Izekiel und Lukas ist ganz cute, und irgendwie tut mir das weiße Hündchen leid, dass er von allen übergangen wird. Und dieser Typ … dieser Typ. Er scheint Claudes älterer Bruder zu sein, der mit schwarzer Magie wieder lebt (?). Keine Ahnung, was dahinter steckt, aber ich hoffe, wir finden es bald heraus. Weil er ist der Übeltäter von allem; und er benutzt Jeanette und ich sorge mich, dass sie sich so sehr beeinflussen lässt, dass sie (unbewusst) die Seiten wechselt. Das story building und die plot twists sind so gut, und auch Athanasia wächst immer mehr. Die eine oder andere Sache zieht sich manchmal, aber ich liebe die Reihe weiterhin. Es ist toll, dass so eine Story mal mehr den Fokus auf eine Vater-Tochter-Beziehung legt anstatt nur auf Romance. Klar, liegt auch am Alter der Protagonistin, aber trotzdem. Sehr erfrischend, super spannend, und möchte es unbedingt weiterlesen.
Profile Image for Fernanda M..
537 reviews
May 7, 2024
⭐3.75⭐
Capítulos: 68 al 82.

Gracias al cielo me han regresado el alma al cuerpo :)))
Athanasia regresa al castillo usando magia de invisibilidad, se encuentra a Felix y aunque no la ve, la siente e intenta atacar aksja, siempre vimos el lado más cute y protector de Felix, por lo que verlo en mood ataque es sorprendente, Athy se reúne con su padre (fan de su cara cuando lo llama majestad y no papá jsja) y tienen la mitad de conversación de la novela, le cuestiona por como ha estado y le pide que se quede, los días pasan y por fiiiiin regresa Lucas, onda nos regalan una super escena de ambos y cuando Lucas se entera lo que paso solo piensa en matar al emperador por haber echo llorar a Athy, amooo, al final anuncia que Claude esta maldito, y nos confirman que Lucas sabe de Athy, hablando de sus dos muertes pasadas, ejecución y suicidio :((, Lucas no está especialmente interesado en ayudar al emperador, pero no quiere ver a Athy llorar, así que la ayuda, a cambio de un beso en la mejilla, NOOOO, son hermosos, en una comida con su padre le da chocolate y él se molesta, pero con la otra lo acepta, haciendo que Athy se moleste y diga que lo odia, pero Felix la consuela, le explica que solo acepto el de la otra por obligación y aguarda las apariencias, a diferencia de ella, con quien deja salir su personalidad, Ijekiel va a visitarla y también tienen santa escenaaaa, él admite que no haría lo que hizo por cualquiera, pero a mitad nos interrumpe Lucas, quien le arma escena AAAAA, se acerca demasiado al rostro de Athy y mira con superioridad a Ijekiel, a lo que Ijekiel le besa la mano a Athy mientras mira con superioridad a Lucas, nananana, besense todos, se marchan y Lucas le cuestiona si le gusta Ijekiel, ella da sus puntos buenos y Lucas la imita, besándole la mano, nananana, por otro lado el detector de padre protector de Claude se activa ajsjsks, haciéndolo sentir molesto de la nada. Hombre recupera tu memoria, ansío volver a verte en plan papá protector y celoso.
Athy acude a Felix y Lily para preguntar sobre el asunto, donde descubrimos que Felix es muy popular pero no obtiene declaraciones al estar siempre con el emperador, y Lily evita cualquier declaración e incluso usa a Felix de escudo para que nadie se le acerque ajsja, al final deja el pedo romántico de lado para concentrarse en su padre.
Los días pasan y aunque Claude sigue sin recordar, su relación con Athy mejora, ella le invita a pasear y él acepta, un poco decepcionado de escuchar que invitarán a la otra, pues Athy piensa demasiado en el bienestar de su papá, le pide a Felix que quite las plantas peligrosas, pero parece que lo hizo antes, aunque aún se mantiene preocupado por su hija, el día llega y salen al lago, donde la otra cae al agua y aunque Athy le pide a su papá que la ayude, Claude permanece impasible y solo reacciona cuando Athy se va a mojar :3, por lo que al final la salva y es regañado por Athy ajsjaj, neta como amo estos momentos.
Athy acude a Lucas para que le ayude con la magia y él acepta, comparándola con su padre, pues ambos trabajan duro, por otro lado Ijekiel habla con la otra para dejarle en claro que sus sentimientos por Athanasia son fuertes y que ella es la persona más preciada en su vida y por ende su prioridad, y AMO, a muchos les molesto, pero yo ame que dejara las cosas en claro desde el inicio, se enamoró y no piensa crear malentendidos, también descubrimos que en la historia original, cuando Ijekiel conoció a Athanasia también se enamoró, aun cuando estaba comprometido con la otra, por lo que me encanta más, pues no importa la historia, esos sentimientos estuvieron ahí desde el inicio.
Athanasia le muestra a su papá su avance en la magia, pero falla y él la guía, cuando sale bien, ella se emociona y él le felicita con una sonrisa, AAAAA, ESTA REGRESANDO.
Claude se encuentra confundido por sus cambios y recuerda a la mamá de Athy, diciendo que su hija saco lo obstinada de ella, pues nunca se rinde, y descubrimos que cuando la mamá muere, Claude completamente destruido por la perdida, usa magia negra para quitar todo sentimiento y recuerdo, por ello en la historia original él la odia, porque la magia la asocia a aquello que tiene que olvidar, por otro lado Athanasia pensando en lo mismo sintiéndose con el corazón rotó, llora por la verdadera Athy, pues nunca supo la verdadera razón por la que no fue amada :(((. Oh mi verdadera Athy, me dolerá toda la vida y odiare a tu padre toda la vida.

Con la otra, dolida por el rechazo de Ijekiel piensa en como aunque fue creada por el señor Blanco, su prioridad siempre fue su hijo, por lo que nunca vio una verdadera familia en ellos, y aunque le gusta lo que siente con Claude y Athy no puede evitar cuán bien se llevan padre e hija, sintiéndose dejada de lado en varias ocasiones, al salir se encuentra con su padre, quien nos da recuerdos con Claude y se siente ansioso pues sus planes están cambiando debido a sus interacciones con su hija, planta dudas en ella y la alimenta a conseguir su lugar en la familia real.
Al siguiente día, vuelven a tomar el té, Athy, Claude y la otra, pero el viento los orilla a entrar, y mientras caminan una tetera con té caliente va a caer a Athanasia, por lo que Claude a modo de reflejo, lo toma sin importar lastimarse, Athy se asusta y llama a Lucas por la condición de su padre y despide a la otra, y cuando Lucas llega siente un aura diferente en la otra.
Ondaaaaa, estoy amando que los momentos que adoro regresen, y aunque siento bastante pena por la otra, no puedo dejar de pedir que se aparte, la única razón por la que la mantienen cerca es el bienestar del emperador, ella cree que es por cariño y la intervención de su padre solo le está haciendo pensar tonterías, temo que haga algo malo (aunque sería bueno para las que la odian por nada akjs, tendrían una razón para odiarla sin límites), a mí de verdad no me desagrada, pero simplemente no, la quiero lejos.
Profile Image for R..
2,079 reviews
June 9, 2024
It's strange to see bits of how Claude used to act with Athy before, yet he clearly still doesn't remember her growing up with him to this point. Now it seems we have further complications with yet another curse added to the growing pile of magical dilemmas, and Claude was already dying as it was. Lucas doesn't seem to have much hope for saving Claude, but at the same time he really doesn't like seeing Athy cry. Jeanette meanwhile still believes she is Athy's sister and Athy and Claude just don't know about her yet, which is adding to her own loneliness and desperation to find where she fits in, especially as even Ezekiel has made it clear Athy is his priority as well. Claude's brother is causing a lot of trouble, though it seems other than Ezekiel's father, no one actually knows who he is or exactly what he is up to, and even he seems to now have misgivings, though it may be a case of too little far too late.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
1,779 reviews
July 7, 2024
There’s a lot of intrigue in this volume - Lucas finds his tower has been raided by “a rat,” Claude is clearly protective of Athy without understanding why, the mysterious guest is manipulating Jeannette, while appearing to be possessed…and it has a probably connection to Lucas, who really is an arrogant jerk and may have created a psycho by carelessly being mean to a kid 😓


Lily and Felix are cute - it’s funny that she uses him as a shield because she’s kinda popular, and his fellow knights think she has a crush. His relief that he didn’t follow their advice is adorable. Duke Alpheus is an oddity. On the one hand he doesn’t want to commit treason or go against the royal family, but what exactly does he think the outcome will be, when hosting the presumed-dead former emperor? Only one can be ruler, and Claude has been doing a decent job despite his lackadaisical and seemingly tyrannical disposition. As Athy observed, he’s actually quite diligent at ruling.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Serina.
62 reviews
May 18, 2024
I totally ship Lucas and Athy!!! Their relationship is developing so much (mostly on Lucas’s side).

Lucas seems to know something we don’t (neither does Athy) but he also seems to know she’s not from around that world. Apparently she’s “back”, maybe she has already lived through the novel she was talking about. there’s some weird dark magic stuff going on with “Mr.Patterson” and the Claude copy Athy saw in her dream.

Ezekiel finally came clean with his feelings with Jeanette, and other than that, a lot felt boring and repetitive - WHY ARE THEY ALWAYS AT THE LAKE AND WHY DOES SOMEONE HAVE TO FALL IN. It’s getting boring. Claude and Athy aren’t making much progress other than him being nicer since his memories got lost. It just feels like this series is slowly floating by.

While I don’t think much happened in this volume, the cliffhanger from the last got me on this one fast.
Profile Image for readwithnikkie.
86 reviews17 followers
May 3, 2022
I LOVE WMMAP. The art is phenomenal & the story is pretty good too….. BUTTT……
*** spoiler if you haven’t read or know the ending ***


We didn’t get to see Athy choose Lucas 😭 Apparently the novel is more romantic and such, which I’ll probably read asap because we didn’t get a proper ending IMO to this manhwa. I would of rated this 5 ⭐️ if we got to see her & Lucas. I know we may get a little more “side stories” but they didn’t mention them being anything of Athy & Lucas, so though I’m crossing my fingers I don’t want to hold my breath and be disappointed 😔
Profile Image for Elle.
110 reviews
November 11, 2024
You know a love triangle is good when even you can't even decide who you really want the main character to end up with. I mean I was pretty sure I wanted her with Ezekiel but damn, Lucas puts up a fight.

The amnesia plot stresses me out but her moments with Claude really shines through. I kinda miss how cozy and light the story was because now I'm just thrown into this hurricane of plots and schemes and sometimes I just really want to go back to cozy tea time with Claude and deciding between two guys who are obviously head over heels for her.
Profile Image for Hstwdthllczy.
234 reviews9 followers
May 20, 2022
4.25 𝑺𝒕𝒂𝒓𝒔

Apologies for finishing this so late but, I was waiting for more chapters to come. I stopped reading this about a month ago to wait for more chapters to arrive and I clicked on this today because I couldn't wait any longer, just to find out that there was only one chapter left???
I-😭🤚

Anyways, I'm kinda disappointed due to the lack of romance but I think this ending is also fine

Thank you Spoon-nim💕~
20 reviews
January 6, 2024
It was a surprising start. I missed Lucas so much, it's good that he came back from the beginning and I loved that they showed a little bit about his past. I died of emotion with the kiss Arthie gave Lucas. Lucas's jealousy is the best thing ever my favorite in chapter 75 (my favorite).
In ch 79 Claude's memories came out and he smiled at his baby.
I don't understand what's going on I need to read the next volume now.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Kate.
1,181 reviews86 followers
May 23, 2025
Who Made Me a Princess is probably one of the better series I'm reading currently (I'm not reading a lot of manga/manhwa these days, though...too busy). It's just so adorably funny, though the last couple of volumes have been more serious and have taken the story down a dark path. I'm curious to see how things will resolve.
Profile Image for Alejandra Zavala.
127 reviews3 followers
May 6, 2023
Lo que tengo contra el hermano de Claude es personal 🙃 y lo que más me frustra es que use a Janette (Zenit) que frustrante. Sin embargo, necesito respuestas por lo que dejar de leerlo no es una opción.
Profile Image for marmarmar.
176 reviews27 followers
webcomic
July 13, 2023
( 69-83)
Aquí está en final de la segunda temporada y AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA.
¿Por qué el villano tiene que ser tan guapo? Un poco de respeto, por favor. Igual se le está descongelando el corazoncito.
ALSO MI PAPÁ CLAUDE DEBE SER SALVAGUARDADO Y CURADO.
Profile Image for Montana.
66 reviews1 follower
June 13, 2024
I love this series but this was probably the most boring of the novels so far. Just a lot of fretting over “daddy” and very little progress made in the story overall. But as always, gorgeous artwork and design.
Profile Image for Yan.
456 reviews
February 20, 2025
This is such a cute story. There is a romance but I like that the story line is focused on the relationship between Athy and Claude. I love how cute the relationship is between the father and child. Athy is also smart, especially on how she use her knowledge about the story to her advantage.
Profile Image for 。⋆☂ Polaris {Gone for exams} ☽˚。.
146 reviews17 followers
March 7, 2025
it's dragging on too long and it's getting repetitive. Overall super disappointed idk if I will continue this
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.