Even Dogs Go to Other Worlds Vol 1 had its moments, but overall, it fell short of my expectations. The premise of a man and his dog being isekaied into another world intrigued me, but the execution left much to be desired. The story lacked significant progression, and it primarily revolved around a slice-of-life power fantasy that seemed to verge on harem territory , which isn't my preferred genre.
One major issue I had was with the inconsistent portrayal of the aristocratic society. The setting is meant to be formal and hierarchical, but the behavior of certain characters, like the duke's daughter freely wandering into the forest or entering men's rooms while they sleep, seemed out of place and contradictory.
The choices made by background characters were also questionable. For example, the attempted robbery from thugs felt forced and poorly thought-out. It's hard to believe that city thugs would target a noblewoman, her knights, and a giant wolf.
The relationships between the characters lacked depth and development. In a slice-of-life story, the characters should shine, but throughout most of the book, the main character had little meaningful knowledge about others, making it challenging to feel invested in their connections.
On the positive side, the bath scene with the dog turned wolf had genuine emotion and believability, which was a standout moment in an otherwise lackluster narrative. The author demonstrated the ability to write engaging scenes, but the book suffered from an info dumps for world building and too many characters, making it difficult to maintain interest.