What do you think?
Rate this book
Dear Your Holiness
“During the week of his father's funeral, Sirius Black meets an unusual priest and offers to help write Orion Black's eulogy. At the same time, he's started texting a mysterious bass player from a pop-punk band that he accidentally swapped phones with. Eventually, the conversations between the two start to blur together and Sirius has trouble trying to decide which one he's falling for the hardest.”
782 pages, ebook
Published December 19, 2021
21 people are currently reading
489 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews
May 26, 2022
bless me father indeed
August 6, 2022
I’m an atheist but amen.
November 11, 2022
pretty enjoyable and fast-paced but ain’t no way ppl are this horny all the time
January 15, 2022
gay priest hubba hubba
December 14, 2022
Now I need to watch fleabag
February 20, 2023
priest remus? oh yeah, bless me father indeed
September 5, 2023
I might step foot into church again
September 25, 2023
I want to put this fanfic in a blender and drink it
November 9, 2025
5 ★
this was so cute!! the wolfstar was amazing and and it was so sweet especially when james and lily adopted harry. remus being a menace the whole time tho had me dead 😭😭
this was so cute!! the wolfstar was amazing and and it was so sweet especially when james and lily adopted harry. remus being a menace the whole time tho had me dead 😭😭
July 6, 2022
nobody talk to me for like a week i’m still recovering from this !!! priest remus?!? PRIEST REMUS?!!
November 6, 2022
He was indeed a total smokeshow.
July 13, 2023
5 stars… lol I just actually read this one and it was good. I felt the smut scenes and the singing scenes went a little longer than necessary and I found myself skipping some but I really love the conflict and angst in this and I was even questioning if Moony was Remus at times lol. Really well done.
4 stars… (actually read Save Me, Save Me, Save Me by the same author but I’m too lazy to make a new book for the fic)
4 stars… (actually read Save Me, Save Me, Save Me by the same author but I’m too lazy to make a new book for the fic)
April 17, 2024
Why did I take so long to read this??? THIS IS AMAZING.
My god this was so so so good. There’s no way this review is going to make sense, because I’m just mesmerized by this.
The romance was so cute, they had so much chemistry, the tension 🥵I’ll never be able to step foot into a church again after this.
The way the author handled heavy topics without making the story itself heavy and still being mindful of those subjects ✨perfection✨
I don’t even know what to say, I’m 100% incoherent because I’m so in love with this story, with them…
I just finished reading it and I already want to re read.
10/10 would recommend. Please read this fic. It’s one of the best I’ve ever read.
My god this was so so so good. There’s no way this review is going to make sense, because I’m just mesmerized by this.
The romance was so cute, they had so much chemistry, the tension 🥵I’ll never be able to step foot into a church again after this.
The way the author handled heavy topics without making the story itself heavy and still being mindful of those subjects ✨perfection✨
I don’t even know what to say, I’m 100% incoherent because I’m so in love with this story, with them…
I just finished reading it and I already want to re read.
10/10 would recommend. Please read this fic. It’s one of the best I’ve ever read.
August 6, 2022
jebe crkvu u mozak znači 5/5
April 23, 2023
mam dość poddaje się nie czytam tego już
October 7, 2024
Fleabag but make it Wolfstar
May 31, 2025
perfect ending 😇
September 1, 2022
“And he is more important to me than any meaningless religion.”
Nunca habrán palabras suficientes para describir esta historia y todo lo que me hizo sentir.
Una de mis favoritas, oficialmente está en el top del top del top de todos los tops. Te amo Dear Your Holiness, nadie te ama como yo.
“(Padfoot):
there is no one else
it’s been you since the beginning
it was always you
I just didn’t always know it.”
Nunca habrán palabras suficientes para describir esta historia y todo lo que me hizo sentir.
Una de mis favoritas, oficialmente está en el top del top del top de todos los tops. Te amo Dear Your Holiness, nadie te ama como yo.
“(Padfoot):
there is no one else
it’s been you since the beginning
it was always you
I just didn’t always know it.”
July 23, 2023
"i want this. i want you. i'm choosing you."
5/5
i might be an atheist but bless me father indeed.
THE TENSION??? THE CHEMISTRY????? THE ANGST???? I AM HERE FOR THAT.
5/5
i might be an atheist but bless me father indeed.
THE TENSION??? THE CHEMISTRY????? THE ANGST???? I AM HERE FOR THAT.
February 20, 2024
bless me father this was GOOD and LONG so idc that its a fucking fanfiction IM LOGGING IT
October 18, 2024
“I don't care about what the church will say. I want this. I want you. I'm choosing you."
it just didn't deliver what I wanted–not enough religious crisis. I wanted a priest who cried and begged for forgiveness but I guess maybe that's just me.
to be honest the start wasn't bad, I did at some point enjoyed it. but it got tedious and just bored me, the last 30%?? I fought with my life to not dnf it.
love the side scenes of jily–they are my beloveds.
also, this is just a personal opinion and I generally wouldn't comment it in fics BUT since I'm still enraged and annoying by this fic I'll say it: I fucking hate peter pettigrew there's not a fic on earth that would make me like him, not even if it's an au (stop trying to make peter a likeable character ITS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN FOR ME!)
anyway glad it's over, it took me two and a half months to read it, that should say how much I didn't enjoy it.
it just didn't deliver what I wanted–not enough religious crisis. I wanted a priest who cried and begged for forgiveness but I guess maybe that's just me.
to be honest the start wasn't bad, I did at some point enjoyed it. but it got tedious and just bored me, the last 30%?? I fought with my life to not dnf it.
love the side scenes of jily–they are my beloveds.
also, this is just a personal opinion and I generally wouldn't comment it in fics BUT since I'm still enraged and annoying by this fic I'll say it: I fucking hate peter pettigrew there's not a fic on earth that would make me like him, not even if it's an au (stop trying to make peter a likeable character ITS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN FOR ME!)
anyway glad it's over, it took me two and a half months to read it, that should say how much I didn't enjoy it.
dnf
August 2, 2025dnf at 20%
November 21, 2022
……oh my goodness, fleabag era
some scenes definitely could’ve been shortened like come on but the entire thing i’m just ajdkjdjdjksjxka
some scenes definitely could’ve been shortened like come on but the entire thing i’m just ajdkjdjdjksjxka
May 2, 2022
4.5/5
God please forgive me for this one lol
Favorite parts:
- Remus literally everytime he would kneel on the stage or jump off it towards sirius to kiss or touch him
- Remus cooking him breakfast HAHAH
- The sexual tension through the texts was alwayssss the best part
- Sirius accidentally calling Remus moony and when Re smiled was ADORABLE
- Sirius doing communion OMGGG ill never get over that
- Remus giving that speech saying “With exultant lips, my mouth shall praise you.” IN FRONT OF THE CHURCH
- WHEN REMUS TOOK HIS MASK OFF
_________________________________________________
Favorite Quotes:
“BLESS ME, FATHER” JAKSKSKSIWKD literally anytime this phrase was used i screamed
“But there was one thing he knew, the only faith in his life without the doubt beside, and that was the certainty in recognizing Remus Lupin’s touch” 😭
“He wanted Remus to see him as the one who could carry all his secrets for him, he wanted Remus to see him as separate from the rest of the world.”
“I know she’ll never say it, so I’ll say it in her place,” Remus whispered into the dark, limitless curls of Sirius’ hair. “I’m proud of you, Sirius.”
“It’s in everything he does. It’s in the way he speaks and in the way he listens and in the way he looks at you. He has more of a right to doubt than anyone, but he somehow maintains this unbreakable faith that makes me want to believe in shit I’ve hated for most of my life. Mostly myself.”
God please forgive me for this one lol
Favorite parts:
- Remus literally everytime he would kneel on the stage or jump off it towards sirius to kiss or touch him
- Remus cooking him breakfast HAHAH
- The sexual tension through the texts was alwayssss the best part
- Sirius accidentally calling Remus moony and when Re smiled was ADORABLE
- Sirius doing communion OMGGG ill never get over that
- Remus giving that speech saying “With exultant lips, my mouth shall praise you.” IN FRONT OF THE CHURCH
- WHEN REMUS TOOK HIS MASK OFF
_________________________________________________
Favorite Quotes:
“BLESS ME, FATHER” JAKSKSKSIWKD literally anytime this phrase was used i screamed
“But there was one thing he knew, the only faith in his life without the doubt beside, and that was the certainty in recognizing Remus Lupin’s touch” 😭
“He wanted Remus to see him as the one who could carry all his secrets for him, he wanted Remus to see him as separate from the rest of the world.”
“I know she’ll never say it, so I’ll say it in her place,” Remus whispered into the dark, limitless curls of Sirius’ hair. “I’m proud of you, Sirius.”
“It’s in everything he does. It’s in the way he speaks and in the way he listens and in the way he looks at you. He has more of a right to doubt than anyone, but he somehow maintains this unbreakable faith that makes me want to believe in shit I’ve hated for most of my life. Mostly myself.”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 30, 2022
My favorite wolfstar fic so far and I've read A LOT
April 13, 2022
i am a fundamentally different person now that i have read this
July 2, 2022
this is my new religion
July 31, 2022
i really LOVED the slowburn
November 6, 2023
at this point i’m solely using goodreads to track the fanfics i read, but this was good, i enjoyed it
Displaying 1 - 30 of 152 reviews