*** EDIT: 15th April 2026 ***
What a difference novelty can make to your experience of reading a book. When I first read this book, I had only just discovered the LitRPG genre and hadn't experienced the plethora of considerably superior books out there. Back then, I was just pleased to be reading a LitRPG that didn't take place in a digital reality. However, now years later, that isn't nearly enough to keep me interested in a book.
This book has multiple flaws, the biggest of which are:
1. Not character-focused - The book is far more interesting in the plot unfolding than in setting up interesting characters.
2. Weirdly compressed timescale - The vast majority of the events in this book take place over the course of a small handful of days. There is far too much story advancement for that little time. The best example is that Jamie only enters Overwrold a week and a half after the opportunity to do so first appears, and yet when he arrives there are already people who behave like veterans of a long running war, who have had time to set up an encampment, build a structured command structure that feels like it was made from trial and error, and do a considerable amount of exploring of the new world and systems. It's the kind of thing that you might expect to find after a year, not just a few days. The rest of the book works out on this same sort of compressed timeline, and it's jarring to say the least.
3. Bog standard LitRPG - This might feel like a strange thing to say, considering my praise for it in the original review, but upon reading it again, there is nothing new here to sink your teeth into. If you have read something in this genre before, you will likely be familiar with everything set up here.
Overall, this book isn't bad, but it's not nearly as good as I originally thought. Therefore, I'm lowering the review score from 5 stars to 4.
*** ORIGINAL REVIEW ***
This is what LitRPG books should be. Take the gamer mechanics that make this sub-genre interesting, then find a way of integrating that into a story that has actual real-world (relative to the story) stakes. Books about people playing games just aren’t interesting, this on the other hand...
I really enjoyed the premise of this book. It is similar to the Shadow Sun series by Dave Wilmarth (an excellent series in the same genre if you’re looking for something else to read). Both series are about aliens incorporating the people of earth into a larger universe that functions using gamer mechanics. However, where the Shadow Sun series stays on Earth, this series forces the residents of Earth into Overworld.
This story is told solely from the viewpoint of Jamie Sinclair, and that’s always a plus for this reader. I really like stories that focus on one character, especially in the first novel of a series, as to me this is the most efficient way to get us invested in a new world without having to get bogged down in lots of different characters. That being said, there were plenty of secondary characters in this book that were well written. They were all well rounded, made good decisions based on how their character was written, and were very believable.
Finally, this book has some great and believable stakes to draw you into the story. So overall, this book was everything I was hoping for. Add in an easy-reading writing style and this quickly became one of my favourite books in this genre.
If I had one complaint, it would be that the author does an excellent job at building side characters only to abandon them (at least for now). It’s a little frustrating because I want to see those characters again and not have to get to know a load of new ones so soon after learning about the last ones and getting invested in their struggle. However, the decision to do this all made sense in the story, so I can’t really complain about it. This is just a personal taste thing.
Overall, this was a really well-written story and I can’t wait to see what happens next.