What do you think?
Rate this book
Much Ado About Persuasion
Some duel with swords, others with ships. In love, however, they duel with hearts.
When Sir Walter Elliot, secret admirer of the Navy, invites officers to visit his estate, what could be more natural than for his two daughters to find themselves in love?
Elizabeth Elliot’s legendary, bitter pride clashes with Admiral Baldwin’s stubborn conceit until any hope of a match seems impossible. They say love conquers all, but does it?
All looks hopeful for Anne Elliot and the dashing Captain Wentworth, but when a cousin steps in and sets evil plans into motion, is their love enough to withstand the storm, or is it best to let the captain sail that ship… alone?
Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing meets Jane Austen’s Persuasion in this story about trust, disappointment, and disguises.
When Sir Walter Elliot, secret admirer of the Navy, invites officers to visit his estate, what could be more natural than for his two daughters to find themselves in love?
Elizabeth Elliot’s legendary, bitter pride clashes with Admiral Baldwin’s stubborn conceit until any hope of a match seems impossible. They say love conquers all, but does it?
All looks hopeful for Anne Elliot and the dashing Captain Wentworth, but when a cousin steps in and sets evil plans into motion, is their love enough to withstand the storm, or is it best to let the captain sail that ship… alone?
Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing meets Jane Austen’s Persuasion in this story about trust, disappointment, and disguises.
215 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 1, 2022
16 people are currently reading
87 people want to read
About the author
Barbara Cornthwaite
14 books177 followersBarbara Cornthwaite lives in the middle of Ireland with her husband and children. She taught college English before "retiring" to do something she loves far more; her days are now filled with homeschooling, trying to keep the house tidy (a losing battle), and trying to stay warm in the damp Irish climate (also a losing battle). She is surrounded by medieval castles, picturesque flocks of sheep, and ancient stone monuments. These things are unappreciated by her six
children, who are more impressed by traffic jams, skyscrapers, and hot weather.
children, who are more impressed by traffic jams, skyscrapers, and hot weather.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
June 22, 2022
Stars: 4.5
Synopsis: Shakespeare meets Austen when the Elliots of Kellynch are embroiled in a scheme of deception and revenge. The meek and gentle daughter Anne falls for the dashing Captain Wentworth, sharp-tongued Elizabeth clashes wits with Admiral Baldwin, and Mrs. Clay becomes a pawn in William Elliot’s dastardly plans when the beloved characters of Persuasion are matched with the intense plot of Much Ado About Nothing.
What I Loved: I must confess, I’ve never read/watched Much Ado About Nothing, so the entire plot of this novel was a mysterious adventure for me—and I quite enjoyed that. I was reunited with the characters of Persuasion (the first Austen novel I ever read, which I for the life of me cannot quite remember as well as I wish I could…), but their story was so much more different! In a good way, of course. I believe Austen and Shakespeare both would be pleased with how well Cornthwaite handled the elements of their stories!
On that note, Cornthwaite did make Austen’s characters a little more vivid and black-and-white (which sounds like an oxymoron, but I simply mean that everyone’s motives and personalities were clearer than in Persuasion). I appreciated it, but naturally it meant that Austen’s intentions and themes were gone from the story. (So was Wentworth’s letter at the end...which was a HUGE heartbreak.)
I absolutely loved seeing more of characters like Elizabeth, Mrs. Clay, Admiral Baldwin, etc.! Elizabeth and Baldwin quickly became my favorites, and their love story was so fun and sweet! (A little unrealistic and morally grey, but precious all the same.) Cornthwaite wrote their arcs perfectly and combined them with Much Ado’s plotline seamlessly! Not to mention the addition of the redemption themes, which was my favorite part.
And the ending? Even without the letter, it was still fabulous—happy endings galore, y’all! And that last line? OMGOSH I SQUEALED YOU GUYS. Seriously. Cornthwaite needs to write a sequel, because she left this open for the PERFECT Austen mashup. I can’t even, you guys.
Finally, we come to the writing. I was absolutely astounded by how Austen-esque the writing was in the first few chapters. Granted, it read more like Pride and Prejudice than it did Persuasion (Austen’s prose was significantly changed between the two), but I know Austen would’ve been proud. That said, it did start to take on a voice of its own as the story went on and it lost that Austen edge…but I still loved the writing and thought it fit the era perfectly! Since the story is written from the omniscient point-of-view, there was a lot of head-hopping—but it was written as it should be and was completely smooth; both immersive and narrative at the same time without being jarring!
What I Didn’t Love: I really only have one qualm: the pacing. I felt like, in some ways, the story moved too fast and characters such as Anne were passed over. Now, it didn’t stick out until the ending—which was certainly rushed—and I didn’t mind getting deep into the characters of Elizabeth, Baldwin, Borlock, and Penelope, but after finishing the story, it was noticeable that the ending was rather abrupt (I needed an epilogue) and a few things were rushed up.
Apart from that, I would’ve liked clearer faith content, but I do appreciate how the Christian elements in the story were authentic, subtle, and consistent to the original stories, in that neither Shakespeare’s nor Austen’s works were explicitly Christian.
Long Story Short: This Shakespearean twist on a beloved Austen classic will leave readers hungry for more! Cornthwaite admirably meshed Persuasion’s characters with Much Ado About Nothing’s plot and crafted a well-written, well-developed, engaging story that did its inspirations justice! I would certainly recommend to lovers of Shakespeare and Austen alike, romance connoisseurs, Regency buffs, and his-fic fans; and I would love to read more in the future!
Disclaimer: I received a review copy from the author through Celebrate Lit Publicity. All opinions expressed are my own.
Synopsis: Shakespeare meets Austen when the Elliots of Kellynch are embroiled in a scheme of deception and revenge. The meek and gentle daughter Anne falls for the dashing Captain Wentworth, sharp-tongued Elizabeth clashes wits with Admiral Baldwin, and Mrs. Clay becomes a pawn in William Elliot’s dastardly plans when the beloved characters of Persuasion are matched with the intense plot of Much Ado About Nothing.
What I Loved: I must confess, I’ve never read/watched Much Ado About Nothing, so the entire plot of this novel was a mysterious adventure for me—and I quite enjoyed that. I was reunited with the characters of Persuasion (the first Austen novel I ever read, which I for the life of me cannot quite remember as well as I wish I could…), but their story was so much more different! In a good way, of course. I believe Austen and Shakespeare both would be pleased with how well Cornthwaite handled the elements of their stories!
On that note, Cornthwaite did make Austen’s characters a little more vivid and black-and-white (which sounds like an oxymoron, but I simply mean that everyone’s motives and personalities were clearer than in Persuasion). I appreciated it, but naturally it meant that Austen’s intentions and themes were gone from the story. (So was Wentworth’s letter at the end...which was a HUGE heartbreak.)
I absolutely loved seeing more of characters like Elizabeth, Mrs. Clay, Admiral Baldwin, etc.! Elizabeth and Baldwin quickly became my favorites, and their love story was so fun and sweet! (A little unrealistic and morally grey, but precious all the same.) Cornthwaite wrote their arcs perfectly and combined them with Much Ado’s plotline seamlessly! Not to mention the addition of the redemption themes, which was my favorite part.
And the ending? Even without the letter, it was still fabulous—happy endings galore, y’all! And that last line? OMGOSH I SQUEALED YOU GUYS. Seriously. Cornthwaite needs to write a sequel, because she left this open for the PERFECT Austen mashup. I can’t even, you guys.
Finally, we come to the writing. I was absolutely astounded by how Austen-esque the writing was in the first few chapters. Granted, it read more like Pride and Prejudice than it did Persuasion (Austen’s prose was significantly changed between the two), but I know Austen would’ve been proud. That said, it did start to take on a voice of its own as the story went on and it lost that Austen edge…but I still loved the writing and thought it fit the era perfectly! Since the story is written from the omniscient point-of-view, there was a lot of head-hopping—but it was written as it should be and was completely smooth; both immersive and narrative at the same time without being jarring!
What I Didn’t Love: I really only have one qualm: the pacing. I felt like, in some ways, the story moved too fast and characters such as Anne were passed over. Now, it didn’t stick out until the ending—which was certainly rushed—and I didn’t mind getting deep into the characters of Elizabeth, Baldwin, Borlock, and Penelope, but after finishing the story, it was noticeable that the ending was rather abrupt (I needed an epilogue) and a few things were rushed up.
Apart from that, I would’ve liked clearer faith content, but I do appreciate how the Christian elements in the story were authentic, subtle, and consistent to the original stories, in that neither Shakespeare’s nor Austen’s works were explicitly Christian.
Long Story Short: This Shakespearean twist on a beloved Austen classic will leave readers hungry for more! Cornthwaite admirably meshed Persuasion’s characters with Much Ado About Nothing’s plot and crafted a well-written, well-developed, engaging story that did its inspirations justice! I would certainly recommend to lovers of Shakespeare and Austen alike, romance connoisseurs, Regency buffs, and his-fic fans; and I would love to read more in the future!
Disclaimer: I received a review copy from the author through Celebrate Lit Publicity. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 30, 2022
This is a very clever, very well written mash-up of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing and Jane Austen's Persuasion.
Anne Elliot and Frederick Wentworth fit well as Hero and Claudio. The author takes some artistic license in softening Elizabeth Elliot's character to match Beatrice and adds a new one, Admiral Baldwin, to fill Benedick's role. It's this pairing that dominates the book, though Anne and Wentworth's story necessarily receives lots of page space as well. Appropriately, the title's "persuasion" refers to the tactic Mr. William Elliot and his valet, Borlock, use to get revenge on Wentworth. It's a different path to a broken engagement that more closely resembles Shakespeare than Austen.
In this reimagining, Sir Walter is an unabashed admirer of the Royal Navy and its officers, believing his absence from their ranks is a great loss to the country. This does not change his usual obsession with his appearance and his inflated pride over his position in the aristocracy. As the book's Don Pedro, he hosts a group of officers at Kellynch (despite his worsening financial problems), which is where most of the book is set. Many in the group do visit Lyme, but only briefly, and the story quickly returns to Sir Walter's estate.
The way Ms. Cornthwaite meshes elements of both stories is truly impressive. Mrs. Clay still sets her sights on Sir Walter, Lady Russell is still an influential friend to the family, Benwick still mopes over the death of his fiancee, Admiral Croft is still a sensible, happily married man (though Mrs. Croft stays off-page in this book), and Louisa Musgrove still acts foolishly. Wentworth's tendency to jump into action gets exploited here.
The war of words between Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin nicely rephrases Shakespeare's droll witticisms so they fit a Regency conversation. You do not have to be knowledgeable about either Shakespeare's play or Jane Austen's novel to enjoy this excellent book, though I would advise reading them first anyway. Foreknowledge of both storylines makes it rather fun to speculate where this book's plot might be headed!
Content is clean.
Anne Elliot and Frederick Wentworth fit well as Hero and Claudio. The author takes some artistic license in softening Elizabeth Elliot's character to match Beatrice and adds a new one, Admiral Baldwin, to fill Benedick's role. It's this pairing that dominates the book, though Anne and Wentworth's story necessarily receives lots of page space as well. Appropriately, the title's "persuasion" refers to the tactic Mr. William Elliot and his valet, Borlock, use to get revenge on Wentworth. It's a different path to a broken engagement that more closely resembles Shakespeare than Austen.
In this reimagining, Sir Walter is an unabashed admirer of the Royal Navy and its officers, believing his absence from their ranks is a great loss to the country. This does not change his usual obsession with his appearance and his inflated pride over his position in the aristocracy. As the book's Don Pedro, he hosts a group of officers at Kellynch (despite his worsening financial problems), which is where most of the book is set. Many in the group do visit Lyme, but only briefly, and the story quickly returns to Sir Walter's estate.
The way Ms. Cornthwaite meshes elements of both stories is truly impressive. Mrs. Clay still sets her sights on Sir Walter, Lady Russell is still an influential friend to the family, Benwick still mopes over the death of his fiancee, Admiral Croft is still a sensible, happily married man (though Mrs. Croft stays off-page in this book), and Louisa Musgrove still acts foolishly. Wentworth's tendency to jump into action gets exploited here.
The war of words between Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin nicely rephrases Shakespeare's droll witticisms so they fit a Regency conversation. You do not have to be knowledgeable about either Shakespeare's play or Jane Austen's novel to enjoy this excellent book, though I would advise reading them first anyway. Foreknowledge of both storylines makes it rather fun to speculate where this book's plot might be headed!
Content is clean.
May 27, 2022
Great rendition of Persuasion characters with Much Ado About Nothing.
Very well done.
I only had a a problem with Wentworth's horrible scene at the dinner in regards to Anne. That was hard to see her forgive him so easily for the horrible accusation and potential ruination of her reputation.
Very well done.
I only had a a problem with Wentworth's horrible scene at the dinner in regards to Anne. That was hard to see her forgive him so easily for the horrible accusation and potential ruination of her reputation.
July 31, 2023
“One Foot in Sea and One on Shore…”
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Persuasion and Much Ado About Nothing Mash Up
NOTE: This review came from the perspective of someone who has read and enjoyed both Persuasion and Much Ado About Nothing numerous times. However, while knowing both stories may enhance your enjoyment and understanding of this blended story, it isn’t imperative that you know both before reading this tale.
THE PREMISE: Sir Walter Elliot invites some naval officers to Kellynch for a house party, where his daughters reconnect with some previous acquaintances including: Captain Wentworth – a valiant hero who is captivated by Miss Anne Elliot, and Admiral Baldwin – a prideful confirmed bachelor who constantly tries to best Elizabeth Elliot in their sparring matches. Love finds many couples in this merry gathering by way of determination, deception, and disguise…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Double the Genius: Crossing Shakespeare with Jane Austen?! Sounds like a brilliant idea to me! Much Ado About Nothing is my favorite Shakespeare comedy! It has such a fun plot, full of comedic mix-ups, sharp banter, and playful spirit. And while the enemies-to-lover story line could be easily translated to Jane Austen’s most famous couple, I like how Barbara Cornthwaite decided another combative pair should become her Beatrice and Benedick. Stories about Persuasion are always in short supply, and Elizabeth Elliot was born for this role!
- “I Cannot Endure My Lady Tongue”: My favorite storyline was the relationship between Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin. I loved their powerful emotions, their competitive dynamic, and how their hearts softened towards each other. I enjoyed seeing Elizabeth turn her sharpness to others outside of family for a change, and it made me laugh to see Admiral Baldwin constantly trying to put her in her place. I loved seeing so many of the well-known barbs and pithy rejoinders come out of these characters’ mouths.
- A Plain-Dealing Villain: Don John’s Regency counterpart – Mr. William Elliot – and his motivation in this story was so very cleverly done! Our “plain-dealing” villain has a black heart and a particular reason for wanting to exact some revenge. I thought this storyline fit so perfectly. I enjoyed the other characters Mr. Elliot inveigled into his schemes (even if it did take me a bit to become endeared to them), and the conflicts and changes this all brought about. Mr. Elliot serves as not only a villain, but as a major catalysts.
Bonus Story: There is an absolutely charming (and unrelated) 20 page short story about Charlotte Collins included in the back of this book. It was so sweet.
WHAT I HAVE MIXED FEELINGS ABOUT:
- Half Assured, Half Despairing: The relationship between Anne and Wentworth goes in a whole new direction in this tale – their romance is secured and settled quickly. But it doesn’t stay that way for long… While I did enjoy the freshness and uniqueness for this course for Wentworth and Anne, it did feel like we lost some of the essence that is Wentworth and Anne. They definitely resembled their Shakespearean counterparts, Claudio and Hero, a bit more.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Some Odd Quirks: With storylines for three couples to flesh out and two major works to blend, constructing this tale and putting it all together must’ve been a tall task! For the most part it all worked really well. But there were maybe some moments where I wished for a little less (earlier chapters) or a little more (the conclusion). I can imagine it being challenging to strike the right balance with everything, and I might have a biased preference for wanting to spend more time with one couple than others.
CONCLUSION: Courtship and comedy are united so cleverly in Much Ado About Persuasion! Barbara Cornthwaite issues forth a most diverting homage to these two great works of literature in her entertaining tale about abandoning pride and earning trust. An excellent choice for readers who adore Jane Austen and Shakespeare or who like the idea of our beloved Persuasion characters getting mixed up in a comedy of errors!
Austenesque Reviews
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
Source: Review Copy from Author
TYPE OF NOVEL: Persuasion and Much Ado About Nothing Mash Up
NOTE: This review came from the perspective of someone who has read and enjoyed both Persuasion and Much Ado About Nothing numerous times. However, while knowing both stories may enhance your enjoyment and understanding of this blended story, it isn’t imperative that you know both before reading this tale.
THE PREMISE: Sir Walter Elliot invites some naval officers to Kellynch for a house party, where his daughters reconnect with some previous acquaintances including: Captain Wentworth – a valiant hero who is captivated by Miss Anne Elliot, and Admiral Baldwin – a prideful confirmed bachelor who constantly tries to best Elizabeth Elliot in their sparring matches. Love finds many couples in this merry gathering by way of determination, deception, and disguise…
WHAT I LOVED:
- Double the Genius: Crossing Shakespeare with Jane Austen?! Sounds like a brilliant idea to me! Much Ado About Nothing is my favorite Shakespeare comedy! It has such a fun plot, full of comedic mix-ups, sharp banter, and playful spirit. And while the enemies-to-lover story line could be easily translated to Jane Austen’s most famous couple, I like how Barbara Cornthwaite decided another combative pair should become her Beatrice and Benedick. Stories about Persuasion are always in short supply, and Elizabeth Elliot was born for this role!
- “I Cannot Endure My Lady Tongue”: My favorite storyline was the relationship between Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin. I loved their powerful emotions, their competitive dynamic, and how their hearts softened towards each other. I enjoyed seeing Elizabeth turn her sharpness to others outside of family for a change, and it made me laugh to see Admiral Baldwin constantly trying to put her in her place. I loved seeing so many of the well-known barbs and pithy rejoinders come out of these characters’ mouths.
- A Plain-Dealing Villain: Don John’s Regency counterpart – Mr. William Elliot – and his motivation in this story was so very cleverly done! Our “plain-dealing” villain has a black heart and a particular reason for wanting to exact some revenge. I thought this storyline fit so perfectly. I enjoyed the other characters Mr. Elliot inveigled into his schemes (even if it did take me a bit to become endeared to them), and the conflicts and changes this all brought about. Mr. Elliot serves as not only a villain, but as a major catalysts.
Bonus Story: There is an absolutely charming (and unrelated) 20 page short story about Charlotte Collins included in the back of this book. It was so sweet.
WHAT I HAVE MIXED FEELINGS ABOUT:
- Half Assured, Half Despairing: The relationship between Anne and Wentworth goes in a whole new direction in this tale – their romance is secured and settled quickly. But it doesn’t stay that way for long… While I did enjoy the freshness and uniqueness for this course for Wentworth and Anne, it did feel like we lost some of the essence that is Wentworth and Anne. They definitely resembled their Shakespearean counterparts, Claudio and Hero, a bit more.
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
- Some Odd Quirks: With storylines for three couples to flesh out and two major works to blend, constructing this tale and putting it all together must’ve been a tall task! For the most part it all worked really well. But there were maybe some moments where I wished for a little less (earlier chapters) or a little more (the conclusion). I can imagine it being challenging to strike the right balance with everything, and I might have a biased preference for wanting to spend more time with one couple than others.
CONCLUSION: Courtship and comedy are united so cleverly in Much Ado About Persuasion! Barbara Cornthwaite issues forth a most diverting homage to these two great works of literature in her entertaining tale about abandoning pride and earning trust. An excellent choice for readers who adore Jane Austen and Shakespeare or who like the idea of our beloved Persuasion characters getting mixed up in a comedy of errors!
Austenesque Reviews
July 12, 2022
When two powerhouse classics meet, a most interesting tale unfolds. I was all kinds of curious when I took a gander at the blurb for this latest release from an author who has captivated me with her writing in the past. Barbara Cornthwaite took my favorite stories from both authors and mashed them into an entertaining, clever bit of storytelling.
Sir Walter Elliot has a private penchant for the Navy and those brave men who command the ships of the Royal Navy. The baronet hosts a house party to enjoy the company of his friend, Admiral Croft, and some other officers. The house party also includes his heir, Mr. Elliot, and his steward’s daughter, Mrs. Clay along with his old neighbor, Lady Russell. Lady Russell is pleased for another reason. Sir Walter has three daughters and the oldest two are unmarried. Elizabeth, the eldest, is proud and fiery in nature while, Anne, the second daughter is a serious, calm woman. They attract the attention of two very different naval men. However, someone at the party is bent on a quiet, insidious revenge against Captain Wentworth through his love for Anne Elliot and another has the chance to prevent the success of the vengeful plot if he is willing to leave his unsavory past behind and turn over a new leaf.
As I mentioned, these two stories are my favorites from both authors so I was curious to see how the author would entwine the tales. Using the character names from Austen’s Persuasion, but some of the character traits and plot of Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, I was enchanted to see the stories melded together. Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin have a hostile enemies to lovers romance, Anne and Captain Wentworth have a tender, gentler romance, but I was tickled by the third romance for a surprising couple that is the key to the whole story and are variations on Shakespeare’s characters Borachio and Margaret. The span of the story is during the house party so it followed the Shakespearean plot with the Persuasion setting.
I found this light and fun tale to be highly entertaining. It has the tone of Shakespeare, but also facets of Austen, too. There was a balance, but never a complete mashing together into something completely new. In fact, I think it leaned heavier on Much Ado than Persuasion as to plot and much about the characters and even some direct quotes. I felt it worked for what the author was trying to do here. There are inspirational themes of guilt, wrongs, and finding redemption. I don’t think a reader has to be overly familiar with either or both the classics that make up this book, but I do think readers will have fun spotting familiar characters, situations, and writing style if they do. All in all, it was flirty and sweet with a respectful nod to two classics. Those who enjoy sweet, but light historical romance should be a good fit.
I rec'd an eARC from the author to read in exchange for an honest review.
Sir Walter Elliot has a private penchant for the Navy and those brave men who command the ships of the Royal Navy. The baronet hosts a house party to enjoy the company of his friend, Admiral Croft, and some other officers. The house party also includes his heir, Mr. Elliot, and his steward’s daughter, Mrs. Clay along with his old neighbor, Lady Russell. Lady Russell is pleased for another reason. Sir Walter has three daughters and the oldest two are unmarried. Elizabeth, the eldest, is proud and fiery in nature while, Anne, the second daughter is a serious, calm woman. They attract the attention of two very different naval men. However, someone at the party is bent on a quiet, insidious revenge against Captain Wentworth through his love for Anne Elliot and another has the chance to prevent the success of the vengeful plot if he is willing to leave his unsavory past behind and turn over a new leaf.
As I mentioned, these two stories are my favorites from both authors so I was curious to see how the author would entwine the tales. Using the character names from Austen’s Persuasion, but some of the character traits and plot of Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing, I was enchanted to see the stories melded together. Elizabeth and Admiral Baldwin have a hostile enemies to lovers romance, Anne and Captain Wentworth have a tender, gentler romance, but I was tickled by the third romance for a surprising couple that is the key to the whole story and are variations on Shakespeare’s characters Borachio and Margaret. The span of the story is during the house party so it followed the Shakespearean plot with the Persuasion setting.
I found this light and fun tale to be highly entertaining. It has the tone of Shakespeare, but also facets of Austen, too. There was a balance, but never a complete mashing together into something completely new. In fact, I think it leaned heavier on Much Ado than Persuasion as to plot and much about the characters and even some direct quotes. I felt it worked for what the author was trying to do here. There are inspirational themes of guilt, wrongs, and finding redemption. I don’t think a reader has to be overly familiar with either or both the classics that make up this book, but I do think readers will have fun spotting familiar characters, situations, and writing style if they do. All in all, it was flirty and sweet with a respectful nod to two classics. Those who enjoy sweet, but light historical romance should be a good fit.
I rec'd an eARC from the author to read in exchange for an honest review.
December 24, 2022
It was a clever idea to mash up Shakespeare and Austen, and of all Shakespeare’s plays, perhaps only The Taming of the Shrew would have been a better choice than Much Ado about Nothing. considerable violence needed to be done to the melancholic mood and the characters of Persuasion, however, to pull this off.
Barbara Cornthwaite begins briskly by taking an axe to Sir Walter Elliot’s disdain for the complexions of naval men; she invents a fairly preposterous envy-cum-adulation on his part for the profession, and further signals our descent into farce by grossly exaggerating Sir Walter’s financial crisis. Fair enough; I can enjoy a good farce. And for the most part this is a good farce, saved by Shakespeare’s twin gifts for pithy insults and preposterous plot schemes. Austen’s language, her fine social distinctions, her shrewdly drawn characters all suffer severe damage, though, and this is most clearly seen in the depiction of her heroine, Anne Elliot, who fades in this story into a rather tedious “straight man” in support of her sister Elizabeth’s comedian. And yet Elizabeth can’t quite emerge as the heroine because of Shakespeare’s twin-couple structure, taking us even further out of Austen territory.
In the early going, before I realized how thoroughly Shakespeare was inspiring the story, I was put off by the narrative style, which is heavy on the telling and jumps from one point of view to another, and another, and another. But as it went along I settled in and enjoyed the novel ways the story was going, especially the unexpected evolutions of certain characters who are little more than caricatures in Austen. I liked the emphasis on conscience and learning from past mistakes, even though that somewhat marred the Shakespearean tidiness of the storyline. In the end this was more of a pun on both authors than a pastiche, and once I accepted the rules of the game I had fun with it.
Barbara Cornthwaite begins briskly by taking an axe to Sir Walter Elliot’s disdain for the complexions of naval men; she invents a fairly preposterous envy-cum-adulation on his part for the profession, and further signals our descent into farce by grossly exaggerating Sir Walter’s financial crisis. Fair enough; I can enjoy a good farce. And for the most part this is a good farce, saved by Shakespeare’s twin gifts for pithy insults and preposterous plot schemes. Austen’s language, her fine social distinctions, her shrewdly drawn characters all suffer severe damage, though, and this is most clearly seen in the depiction of her heroine, Anne Elliot, who fades in this story into a rather tedious “straight man” in support of her sister Elizabeth’s comedian. And yet Elizabeth can’t quite emerge as the heroine because of Shakespeare’s twin-couple structure, taking us even further out of Austen territory.
In the early going, before I realized how thoroughly Shakespeare was inspiring the story, I was put off by the narrative style, which is heavy on the telling and jumps from one point of view to another, and another, and another. But as it went along I settled in and enjoyed the novel ways the story was going, especially the unexpected evolutions of certain characters who are little more than caricatures in Austen. I liked the emphasis on conscience and learning from past mistakes, even though that somewhat marred the Shakespearean tidiness of the storyline. In the end this was more of a pun on both authors than a pastiche, and once I accepted the rules of the game I had fun with it.
June 25, 2022
A fresh mash-up of classic British literature featuring Much Ado About Nothing and Persuasion.
Perfect for anglophiles everywhere, this book does a great job of handling and blending two well-known classics. I liked how the author was able to pay homage to the styles of both of these great authors, while also taking unique twists of her own.
I think that it does help to be somewhat familiar with the original plots of the stories, I had to ask my daughter and consult the internet a few times to refresh my memory. I liked that it gave us more characters to follow, and more subplots, as well as surprises.
Overall, a fun twist on literary classics, well written and engaging. Anne and Wentworth are just a few of the characters that are explored in this fresh re-mix.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Perfect for anglophiles everywhere, this book does a great job of handling and blending two well-known classics. I liked how the author was able to pay homage to the styles of both of these great authors, while also taking unique twists of her own.
I think that it does help to be somewhat familiar with the original plots of the stories, I had to ask my daughter and consult the internet a few times to refresh my memory. I liked that it gave us more characters to follow, and more subplots, as well as surprises.
Overall, a fun twist on literary classics, well written and engaging. Anne and Wentworth are just a few of the characters that are explored in this fresh re-mix.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
June 26, 2022
Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing and Jane Austen’s Persuasion brought together in one clever mashup. I love classic retellings! In this one, the author combines the plot from Much Ado About Nothing with the characters of Persuasion. While I definitely remember Persuasion, it’s been a while since I’ve read Shakespeare’s famous comedy or seen the movie, so I went into the story not knowing what to expect. It’s definitely a creative spin on these classics with more emphasis on secondary characters like Elizabeth, Admiral Baldwin, Mrs. Cray, and Mr. Elliot. Anne and Captain Wentworth are definitely present, but not solely the focus.
In this story, Sir Walter Elliot is enamored with the navy and invites several officers to stay at his estate. With two marriageable daughters, what’s more natural than to have them fall in love? Unfortunately, Elizabeth remembers Admiral Baldwin from London where he dashed her hopes. She’s developed a prideful personality as well as an acerbic tongue which she uses frequently on Admiral Baldwin. He’s stubborn and conceited, so they’re well matched. Could these two be tricked into love? Anne and Captain Wentworth immediately develop a rapport, but what happens when a conniving cousin threatens to tear them apart?
The characters of Persuasion fit nicely into this Shakespearean comedy. The author was able to stay true to Jane Austen’s vision while incorporating a different plot. The misunderstandings, plotting, and mischief as well as the romance drew me into the story. While I missed Anne’s pining for Wentworth and his heartfelt letter in the original Persuasion, there was still plenty to endear me to this altered version. Elizabeth and Mrs. Cray really become more sympathetic and well rounded and I was invested in them finding happiness. The author also subtly includes an enjoyable redemption theme in the story.
This is the second book I’ve read by this author and am excited to read more. There’s a teaser at the end involving another Jane Austen character and I can’t wait to see what she comes up with for her. Recommend to fans of classic retellings, historical romance, and historical Christian romance/fiction. Thanks to CelebrateLit for the complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
In this story, Sir Walter Elliot is enamored with the navy and invites several officers to stay at his estate. With two marriageable daughters, what’s more natural than to have them fall in love? Unfortunately, Elizabeth remembers Admiral Baldwin from London where he dashed her hopes. She’s developed a prideful personality as well as an acerbic tongue which she uses frequently on Admiral Baldwin. He’s stubborn and conceited, so they’re well matched. Could these two be tricked into love? Anne and Captain Wentworth immediately develop a rapport, but what happens when a conniving cousin threatens to tear them apart?
The characters of Persuasion fit nicely into this Shakespearean comedy. The author was able to stay true to Jane Austen’s vision while incorporating a different plot. The misunderstandings, plotting, and mischief as well as the romance drew me into the story. While I missed Anne’s pining for Wentworth and his heartfelt letter in the original Persuasion, there was still plenty to endear me to this altered version. Elizabeth and Mrs. Cray really become more sympathetic and well rounded and I was invested in them finding happiness. The author also subtly includes an enjoyable redemption theme in the story.
This is the second book I’ve read by this author and am excited to read more. There’s a teaser at the end involving another Jane Austen character and I can’t wait to see what she comes up with for her. Recommend to fans of classic retellings, historical romance, and historical Christian romance/fiction. Thanks to CelebrateLit for the complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
June 25, 2022
“Regret is a loathsome burden to carry.”
“Happy are the men that hear their detractions and can put them to mending.”
Because I had not read Austin’s Persuasion and Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing, I chose to find summaries of the plays to better understand what to expect from the novel Cornthwaite’s Much Ado about Persusaion. Once I had done that, I could better appreciate how Barbara Cornthwaite marries Much Ado about Nothing and Persuasion.
I did not connect with the characters immediately. Slowly, as I became more acclimated to the antiquated language, I really began to enjoy the multiple storylines presented. A robust tale, with several relationships threatened, forming, or desired, it was at first difficult to keep all the characters straight. Happily, I found that continued reading rectified this problem. There were actually several times I laughed out loud. While the original tales are older and the language mimics that of earlier centuries, there were so many nuggets of truth that are applicable today! How I loved that! I underlined a great many quotes.
Faith is included with appropriate Scripture quotes or even sermon snippets that fit right in to the fabric of the story. Nothing contrived there, which can be a tricky maneuver for an author.
I recommend this novel for fans of Jane Austen and William Shakespeare. Other historical fiction lovers might also be enthralled with the story.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“good people collect other good people around them.”
Good birth is no guarantee of good character.”
“Pride is a very empty comfort when you are alone.”
“…the best thing would be to start off by praising her. Not something about her beauty, which might seem like mere flattery, but something about her character.”
“Happy are the men that hear their detractions and can put them to mending.”
Because I had not read Austin’s Persuasion and Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing, I chose to find summaries of the plays to better understand what to expect from the novel Cornthwaite’s Much Ado about Persusaion. Once I had done that, I could better appreciate how Barbara Cornthwaite marries Much Ado about Nothing and Persuasion.
I did not connect with the characters immediately. Slowly, as I became more acclimated to the antiquated language, I really began to enjoy the multiple storylines presented. A robust tale, with several relationships threatened, forming, or desired, it was at first difficult to keep all the characters straight. Happily, I found that continued reading rectified this problem. There were actually several times I laughed out loud. While the original tales are older and the language mimics that of earlier centuries, there were so many nuggets of truth that are applicable today! How I loved that! I underlined a great many quotes.
Faith is included with appropriate Scripture quotes or even sermon snippets that fit right in to the fabric of the story. Nothing contrived there, which can be a tricky maneuver for an author.
I recommend this novel for fans of Jane Austen and William Shakespeare. Other historical fiction lovers might also be enthralled with the story.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“good people collect other good people around them.”
Good birth is no guarantee of good character.”
“Pride is a very empty comfort when you are alone.”
“…the best thing would be to start off by praising her. Not something about her beauty, which might seem like mere flattery, but something about her character.”
June 20, 2022
This novel is a very clever retelling of the combined stories of Persuasion by Jane Austen and Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare. I have read Persuasion many times, but it has been years since I read Much Ado About Nothing. I though that the particular ways the author overlapped these stories made for a new story that made sense.
The way the novel is written is very similar to the style of Jane Austen. The reader is told what is going on in the scene and what the thoughts are for the characters. Points of view switch around mid chapter, which can sometimes get a bit confusing, but is also similar to the Austen novels I have read. This style does make it a bit harder for me to feel as if I am living the story, rather than just being an observer. That is how I felt with this novel. I enjoyed it, yet felt as if I was on the outside looking in. But, it was a clever tale and I am impressed with the way two famous stories were combined into something similar, yet new.
(3.5 stars)
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but read a copy through Kindle Unlimited instead. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
The way the novel is written is very similar to the style of Jane Austen. The reader is told what is going on in the scene and what the thoughts are for the characters. Points of view switch around mid chapter, which can sometimes get a bit confusing, but is also similar to the Austen novels I have read. This style does make it a bit harder for me to feel as if I am living the story, rather than just being an observer. That is how I felt with this novel. I enjoyed it, yet felt as if I was on the outside looking in. But, it was a clever tale and I am impressed with the way two famous stories were combined into something similar, yet new.
(3.5 stars)
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but read a copy through Kindle Unlimited instead. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
June 24, 2022
A much-needed venture into a Jane Austen-like plot with captains and admirals, fair maidens, and romance. Take a long walk or enjoy a good meal though strangled finances lurk ahead.
In the fashion of the times, romance and clothing fade in and out. With two unwed daughters in the house, plotting and mischief hang about on everyone’s mind. Could the long house sojourn amount to changed lives—whether new love, healing heart, friendship, or adventure.
The details in long paragraphs plop the reader in the era. Welcome to an entertaining foray into a simpler, yet surprisingly complicated, period. Bravo, Barbara Cornthwaite.
In the fashion of the times, romance and clothing fade in and out. With two unwed daughters in the house, plotting and mischief hang about on everyone’s mind. Could the long house sojourn amount to changed lives—whether new love, healing heart, friendship, or adventure.
The details in long paragraphs plop the reader in the era. Welcome to an entertaining foray into a simpler, yet surprisingly complicated, period. Bravo, Barbara Cornthwaite.
June 8, 2022
Cornthwaite's mash-up of Shakespeare and Austin works! What a great idea!!
June 25, 2022
This is an author that I enjoy reading. She has great wit and makes her characters come to life before my eyes. I loved her mystery college professor series and knew that I would love this book too. Not just because I enjoy her writing but because I enjoy the classics as well and she’s rewriting and meshing two classics together in this book.
I was not disappointed! You won’t be either. Let me know which is your favorite, Anne or Elizabeth. I think Elizabeth was mine though I loved the storyline that Anne had as well.
Both works get put together in this novel but it’s done in such a way that you really can’t tell unless you’re a fan of the two works used. It comes off with all the style and flair I have come to expect from this author but also reading as a regency novel.
I highly recommend you read this novel. But also I find myself mildly jealous of the author as she lives in Ireland and it’s on the top of my to-visit places!
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
I was not disappointed! You won’t be either. Let me know which is your favorite, Anne or Elizabeth. I think Elizabeth was mine though I loved the storyline that Anne had as well.
Both works get put together in this novel but it’s done in such a way that you really can’t tell unless you’re a fan of the two works used. It comes off with all the style and flair I have come to expect from this author but also reading as a regency novel.
I highly recommend you read this novel. But also I find myself mildly jealous of the author as she lives in Ireland and it’s on the top of my to-visit places!
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
July 2, 2022
I would never have imagined taking the characters from Jane Austen’s beloved novel “Persuasion” and matching them with Shakespeare’s “Much Ado About Nothing”. When I first saw the publisher’s description for this book, I could not imagine how the two could successfully work together; but the selling point for me was that this book is written by Barbara Cornthwaite. I’ve been impressed with this author’s books in the past, and I’m glad I took a chance on this one. She has very skillfully woven the two storylines together. You don’t have to be familiar with either “Persuasion” or “Much Ado” to enjoy reading this new retake on those stories.
One of my main complaints about authors who attempt to take Jane Austen’s characters and place them in a different setting is that they don’t get the correct time period details or they change the characters’ personalities. I thought the author did a great job in both respects with this book. The dialogue fit the time period very well and flowed smoothly, and all the characters retained elements of their original personalities. There were a couple of scenes that I might have changed, but they still fit within the story.
If you like Jane Austen’s books, I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised with this retake on her classic story. Having read quite a few books that fall under the category of “Austen fan fiction”, I thought this was one of the best I’ve read of those books. I’m looking forward to reading it again and seeing what little details I might have missed the first time through.
I voluntarily received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
One of my main complaints about authors who attempt to take Jane Austen’s characters and place them in a different setting is that they don’t get the correct time period details or they change the characters’ personalities. I thought the author did a great job in both respects with this book. The dialogue fit the time period very well and flowed smoothly, and all the characters retained elements of their original personalities. There were a couple of scenes that I might have changed, but they still fit within the story.
If you like Jane Austen’s books, I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised with this retake on her classic story. Having read quite a few books that fall under the category of “Austen fan fiction”, I thought this was one of the best I’ve read of those books. I’m looking forward to reading it again and seeing what little details I might have missed the first time through.
I voluntarily received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
July 2, 2022
Much Ado About Persuasion is an intriguing mash up of William Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing and Jane Austen’s Persuasion. With a list of characters that all have their own purpose for gathering at Kellynch Hall, you are sure to be entertained.
I think I counted five different sub-plots within the overall story. Each one bringing their own sense of drama and romance to the festivities. Barbara Cornthwaite did a marvelous job in keeping everyone together and their stories engaging. Her particular style of writing was interesting as well. It reminded me of a classic Jane Austen novel with a few twists which I am suspecting she pulled from Shakespeare. Thank goodness she didn’t dive into the old English of Shakespeare though.
Each individual character had their own problems and longings that they willingly shared throughout the book in order to tie everything together at the end. Though I must say, keeping all the characters together was difficult for me even though the author did a wonderful job, as I stated above. I think I was more than halfway through the book before I could remember who each character and sub-plot. Even though I spent a bunch of my time trying to pair up everything, it was also well with written and enjoyable that I wanted to keep pushing through despite my difficulties. To me, that’s the marks for a good writer.
** this was the first story I’ve read by this author. I obtained the book through the publisher so that I might share my true view of the story.
I think I counted five different sub-plots within the overall story. Each one bringing their own sense of drama and romance to the festivities. Barbara Cornthwaite did a marvelous job in keeping everyone together and their stories engaging. Her particular style of writing was interesting as well. It reminded me of a classic Jane Austen novel with a few twists which I am suspecting she pulled from Shakespeare. Thank goodness she didn’t dive into the old English of Shakespeare though.
Each individual character had their own problems and longings that they willingly shared throughout the book in order to tie everything together at the end. Though I must say, keeping all the characters together was difficult for me even though the author did a wonderful job, as I stated above. I think I was more than halfway through the book before I could remember who each character and sub-plot. Even though I spent a bunch of my time trying to pair up everything, it was also well with written and enjoyable that I wanted to keep pushing through despite my difficulties. To me, that’s the marks for a good writer.
** this was the first story I’ve read by this author. I obtained the book through the publisher so that I might share my true view of the story.
June 23, 2022
Much Ado About Persuasion is a Christian historical, retelling of a mixture of two books. Author Barbara Cornthwaite has taken books by authors Jane Austen and William Shakespeare and blended them into one delightful story. The title might have given this away.
This novel is a very imaginative retelling of the combined stories of Persuasion by Jane Austen and Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare. For me, the way the author overlapped these two stories made an interesting new tale. Both stories were twisted and shaped to become a new combined one.
I enjoyed the writing style of the author. The language was period correct. Her characters were researched and loosely based on the originals. The way the novel is written reminds me of the style of Jane Austen.
It took me a while to become invested in the story and characters. There are many different characters as well as storylines. It is not a book to read lightly. I needed to pay attention to get everything straight at first.
Scripture and faith are included along with multiple timeless life lessons. I found clever humor in places and some emotional bits. All in all it is a nice book. Shakespeare and Austen fans will enjoy it. Readers that like the combination of two books made into one will, also. For me, I prefer my stories separate, but I do recommend this one. It gets a 4 out of 5 star rating. A copy was provided by Celebrate Lit, but these are my honest words.
This novel is a very imaginative retelling of the combined stories of Persuasion by Jane Austen and Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare. For me, the way the author overlapped these two stories made an interesting new tale. Both stories were twisted and shaped to become a new combined one.
I enjoyed the writing style of the author. The language was period correct. Her characters were researched and loosely based on the originals. The way the novel is written reminds me of the style of Jane Austen.
It took me a while to become invested in the story and characters. There are many different characters as well as storylines. It is not a book to read lightly. I needed to pay attention to get everything straight at first.
Scripture and faith are included along with multiple timeless life lessons. I found clever humor in places and some emotional bits. All in all it is a nice book. Shakespeare and Austen fans will enjoy it. Readers that like the combination of two books made into one will, also. For me, I prefer my stories separate, but I do recommend this one. It gets a 4 out of 5 star rating. A copy was provided by Celebrate Lit, but these are my honest words.
June 26, 2022
I have been able to read Barbara Cornthwaite's work before so I was excited to see a historical fiction book pop into my TBR list. Much Ado About Persuasion is a Historical Fiction/Jane Austen Retelling story. I have not really read a ton of Jane Austen stories, but what I have read I have always enjoyed. One of the best things about this book is how the author blended Shakespeare and Austen together and created her own story. While I have not read the books these are based on, I don't feel like I missed out on anything.
Sir Walter Elliot invites other officers to his home, and his daughters fall in love. I mean, wasn't that the point? Elizabeth Elliot and Admiral Baldwin’s story made me laugh several times. She has some pride, he can be conceited. It reminds me how opposites can attract. I liked their character and found myself chuckling several times. Her sister Anne is hopeful about her growing relationship with Captain Wentworth. But there is family meddling. I enjoyed seeing their stories unfold.
I felt the author wrote her time period well. She always sprinkles in wit and humor in her books and that is one of the reasons that I like to read her work. The characters were engaging, and well developed. It did take me a few chapters to get fully invested in the story, but once I was I did not want to put the book down.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book, all thoughts are my own.
Sir Walter Elliot invites other officers to his home, and his daughters fall in love. I mean, wasn't that the point? Elizabeth Elliot and Admiral Baldwin’s story made me laugh several times. She has some pride, he can be conceited. It reminds me how opposites can attract. I liked their character and found myself chuckling several times. Her sister Anne is hopeful about her growing relationship with Captain Wentworth. But there is family meddling. I enjoyed seeing their stories unfold.
I felt the author wrote her time period well. She always sprinkles in wit and humor in her books and that is one of the reasons that I like to read her work. The characters were engaging, and well developed. It did take me a few chapters to get fully invested in the story, but once I was I did not want to put the book down.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this book, all thoughts are my own.
June 18, 2022
I may be one of the few readers who are not familiar with Jane Austen and her books. Oh I have heard of them but never taken the time to actually give one a try. I felt like I would be at a disadvantage reading this story but the author welcomes readers with an ease into the world where many are fascinated by everything related to this part of well known stories.
It was entertaining to see how an author meshed two stories together and accomplish a journey with characters that I came to like. I kept thinking how prim and proper everyone seemed yet they each shared struggles along the way. I laughed when one of the women declared she would never marry. She did enjoy bantering with one particular man who for me made the story a bit more enticing.
I loved the historical feel of the story with undertones of guilt, redemption and happiness all put together in a delightful story. After reading this book, I have given myself a challenge. I will be reading books that are based on this story and know that I will find an admiration for this time period and the characters which I want to follow.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
It was entertaining to see how an author meshed two stories together and accomplish a journey with characters that I came to like. I kept thinking how prim and proper everyone seemed yet they each shared struggles along the way. I laughed when one of the women declared she would never marry. She did enjoy bantering with one particular man who for me made the story a bit more enticing.
I loved the historical feel of the story with undertones of guilt, redemption and happiness all put together in a delightful story. After reading this book, I have given myself a challenge. I will be reading books that are based on this story and know that I will find an admiration for this time period and the characters which I want to follow.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
June 28, 2022
As I began reading Much Ado About Persuasion I found the story difficult to stay interested in at times. With a member of the gentry determined to live above his means, a house party, and a lot of deception, and a fixation on revenge, this book seemed to move very slowly at times. At other times, I found myself caught up in the story.
I loved Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth. I also appreciated the valet of the villain in this story. A former member of the gentry, he winds up committing acts of evil under the threat of being revealed as a criminal. A young widow provides the perfect match for the valet.
I am glad I continued reading this story so I found out how it ends. So if you enjoy Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing or Jane Austen’s Persuasion, check out this book for yourself.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
I loved Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth. I also appreciated the valet of the villain in this story. A former member of the gentry, he winds up committing acts of evil under the threat of being revealed as a criminal. A young widow provides the perfect match for the valet.
I am glad I continued reading this story so I found out how it ends. So if you enjoy Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing or Jane Austen’s Persuasion, check out this book for yourself.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
April 7, 2022
This book is very well written as Barbara Cornthwaite is a fabulous writer in any genre. I think it will be very much appreciated by those who know both Persuasion and Much Ado about Nothing inside and out, which I unfortunately do not. I only have a passing acquaintance with each. That said, I was fully able to follow the story and enjoyed it; I just felt like I might be missing some insider stuff that would make others appreciate it even more. I especially enjoyed one of the side stories about a valet and one of the Elliot sisters' friends. I am a Cornthwaite fan because of her fantastic Christian cozy mysteries (The Wilkester Mysteries), and while I didn't enjoy this book as much as those, it was still an enjoyable read, and I believe those who love Jane Austen will really love this book.
I received a complimentary early electronic copy of this book from the author.
I received a complimentary early electronic copy of this book from the author.
June 24, 2022
If you like Jane Austin's book, then I think you will enjoy "Much Ado About Persuasion" by Barbara Cornthwaite. I myself am not a fan of her books but I did like and followed this story easily enough. This is a good retelling of two books written by two classics writers which I haven't read much of, I have read a few of Jane's Austin's books but none of Shakespeare’s books. Yes I have heard of Romeo and Juliet but haven't read it. This is a love story for those that likes romance. There is humor, faith and quilt and all the emotions that readers like to read about in their books. I felt like I was just reading not actually watching the scenes unfold in the novel. But I still recommend it for readers who likes different styles of writting and retelling of classics.
I was given a complementary copy by the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.
I was given a complementary copy by the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.
June 25, 2022
To say I loved every bit of this classic literature remix would be the understatement of all time. Being a Jane Austen enthusiast, I was a little wary at first but our author took each character and developed them as beautifully as Austen herself. The mixture with Shakespeare’s classic tale flowed seamlessly together as if they were meant to be as one all along. The many layers to the plot keep you easily intrigued ready to see what happens next, and the redemption found with some of our even less likeable characters is very satisfying. The language and descriptions used transported me in time and place to be a part of the story. I can not recommend this fiction enough for those who enjoy classic fiction or are looking for an engaging historical fiction.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, and all opinions given are entirely my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, and all opinions given are entirely my own.
June 27, 2022
As much as I love Shakespear and Jane Austen, it was so exciting to learn that this book would be a mingling of both authors stories. That is to say that this author, Barbara Cornthwaite, wrote this book with two of their stories in mind--Much Ado about Nothing and Persuasion. Even before I knew this, I could recall certain events from these books throughout the pages of Much Ado About Persuasion, which was simply marvelous!
It is interesting to see how Cornthwaite is inspired by these two amazing classic authors as she takes note and inspiration from their work to pen her own words. This was such a fabulous idea for a modern day story--of course, even though Shakespeare and Austen are from generations ago, we can still learn so much about life and friendship from them today. If you enjoy classic literature, I recommend picking this book up! Happy reading friends!
It is interesting to see how Cornthwaite is inspired by these two amazing classic authors as she takes note and inspiration from their work to pen her own words. This was such a fabulous idea for a modern day story--of course, even though Shakespeare and Austen are from generations ago, we can still learn so much about life and friendship from them today. If you enjoy classic literature, I recommend picking this book up! Happy reading friends!
May 4, 2022
Barbara Cornthwaite has produced another thoroughly entertaining and enjoyable book, this time a mashup of Jane Austen's Persuasion and Much Ado About Nothing!
If you are familiar with those works, you will enjoy how she has woven the two stories together, and if you are not familiar with those works, you will still enjoy the intricate weaving of plot lines and characters as well as the humor, wit, and thought-provoking character development.
Cornthwaite's style is easy to read and engrossing. She effortlessly draws you into the time period, and gets her details right.
Reading this book was a truly delightful experience!
If you are familiar with those works, you will enjoy how she has woven the two stories together, and if you are not familiar with those works, you will still enjoy the intricate weaving of plot lines and characters as well as the humor, wit, and thought-provoking character development.
Cornthwaite's style is easy to read and engrossing. She effortlessly draws you into the time period, and gets her details right.
Reading this book was a truly delightful experience!
July 2, 2022
Ok, I wasn’t sure what to think when I read that this was a mix of Shakespeare and Jane Austen. I truly enjoyed it. The author did a good job with the story and the characters. The characters weren’t exactly like the other books but you could tell.
The story flowed well and I was happy to keep reading. There was an instance that I wasn’t thrilled with but overall the book was good. I liked the character interactions and it was fun to see her spin on things.
4/5
Thank you to the author/publisher for the review copy of this book via Celebrate Lit. I received this book in exchange for an honest review and the opinions stated above are 100% mine.
The story flowed well and I was happy to keep reading. There was an instance that I wasn’t thrilled with but overall the book was good. I liked the character interactions and it was fun to see her spin on things.
4/5
Thank you to the author/publisher for the review copy of this book via Celebrate Lit. I received this book in exchange for an honest review and the opinions stated above are 100% mine.
June 18, 2022
In this story about trust, disappointment, and disguises, Barbara Cornthwaite cleverly blends together Shakespeare’s “Much Ado about Nothing” and Jane Austen’s “Persuasion” into “Much Ado about Persuasion.” There are inspirational themes of guilt, wrongs, and finding redemption. It is a delightfully entertaining and most enjoyable book. Barbara has skillfully interwoven the two stories together with the intricate weaving of plot lines and characters. Humor and wit are lavishly interspersed in an easy to read and engrossing style. I highly recommend this delightful book.
May 23, 2022
I have had the pleasure of reading Barbara Cornthwaite’s mysteries and was excited to have the opportunity to read her newest historical fiction, Much Ado About Persuasion. I thought it was a pretty good read. It was fun traveling back in time and taking this adventure with the characters. There were a few humorous scenes that kept me wanting to keep reading. A good, sweet and entertaining story that puts a spin to the tales from Shakespeare (Much Ado About Nothing) and Jane Austen (Persuasion).
I am giving Much Ado About Persuasion four stars. I recommend it for readers who enjoy reading clean historical romance. I would be interested in reading more books by Barbara Cornthwaite in the future.
I received a digital copy of Much Ado About Persuasion from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
I am giving Much Ado About Persuasion four stars. I recommend it for readers who enjoy reading clean historical romance. I would be interested in reading more books by Barbara Cornthwaite in the future.
I received a digital copy of Much Ado About Persuasion from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
April 28, 2024
Best final sentence ever!
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews