What do you think?
Rate this book
The Tacksman's Daughter
Scotland, 1692. To escape a brutal winter storm, King William’s regiments descend on the small village of Glencoe. Caitriona Cameron, the tacksman’s daughter, cannot forget her unpleasant encounter the last time English troops appeared. She senses the army’s arrival might not be as innocent as it seems, but her warnings go unheeded. Not even MacIain, the MacDonald clan chief, listens. After twelve days of billeting in the villagers’ homes, the soldiers attack, committing one of the greatest atrocities in Highland history.
Cait escapes the assault with the help of Sergeant Edward Gage who is accused of being a traitor for not taking up arms against the MacDonalds. Edward is hunted by his debauched half-brother, Alexander, who stands to lose everything if King William attaints their father for his treasonous past deeds. With bad blood between them, Alexander sets out to capture Edward to prove his loyalty and save himself from ruin.
Cait and Edward travel to Edinburgh to confront the men they suspect are behind the attack, unaware that Alexander is headed there as well. Although Cait is convinced the chief of Clan Campbell is responsible, Edward suspects something much more sinister—that the orders came from higher up, possibly even from the king himself.
As accusations of betrayal, deceit, and treason abound, they are all trapped in a web of intrigue and danger, but not everyone will escape.
Cait escapes the assault with the help of Sergeant Edward Gage who is accused of being a traitor for not taking up arms against the MacDonalds. Edward is hunted by his debauched half-brother, Alexander, who stands to lose everything if King William attaints their father for his treasonous past deeds. With bad blood between them, Alexander sets out to capture Edward to prove his loyalty and save himself from ruin.
Cait and Edward travel to Edinburgh to confront the men they suspect are behind the attack, unaware that Alexander is headed there as well. Although Cait is convinced the chief of Clan Campbell is responsible, Edward suspects something much more sinister—that the orders came from higher up, possibly even from the king himself.
As accusations of betrayal, deceit, and treason abound, they are all trapped in a web of intrigue and danger, but not everyone will escape.
366 pages, Paperback
Published January 10, 2022
19 people are currently reading
498 people want to read
About the author
Donna Scott
3 books55 followersDonna Scott is an award-winning author of 17th and 18th century historical fiction. Before embarking on a writing career, she spent her time in the world of academia. She earned her BA in English from the University of Miami and her MS and EdD (ABD) from Florida International University. She has two sons and lives in sunny South Florida with her husband.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
March 21, 2022
You know when you love an author and their writing so much that you don't even have to read the description of their novel to know that you are going to buy it immediately and love it? That's Donna Scott for me. I've read all 3 of her books and with each new release, she just gets better and better!
Her latest, The Tacksman's Daughter, is just as amazing as her previous two releases. I seriously could not choose a favorite - that's like someone asking you to choose your favorite kid :) Though the answer is always the one that's annoying you the least at the moment..ha!
The Tacksman's Daughter is set in Glencoe, Scotland in the late 1600s. Caitriona Cameron is the daughter of the clan's Chief's Tacksman, which is an esteemed role at the time. When English soldiers arrive and ask for shelter and food they agree and welcome them. However, Cait is not convinced that they are safe and senses danger. When her sixth sense proves correct the entire clan is wiped out by the Englishmen based on orders sent from higher up.
Dear readers, be sure to have kleenex at the ready for this scene. The way the author writes never fails to bring the emotions out!
One of the English soldiers, Edward, is appalled by the orders and refuses to slaughter the very people who housed and fed them for weeks. He has fallen for Cait as well and doesn't want anything to happen to her. His refusal to fight makes him an enemy of his men, most especially his awful brother, Alexander, who is now trying to find him and bring him to the King for betrayal and to be hanged.
Edward, Cait, and others set out to find a new home and to exact revenge upon the people who ordered and perpetrated the massacre. There is adventure, romance, betrayal, danger, friendship, and family. It's a captivating story and one that I will think about for some time to come.
If you haven't read a Donna Scott novel please do yourself a favor and pick one up. I absolutely adore her writing and once I start a new book of hers it's hard to stop. You just want to devour it in one setting! I highly recommend The Tacksman's Daughter and cannot wait for the next release!
Her latest, The Tacksman's Daughter, is just as amazing as her previous two releases. I seriously could not choose a favorite - that's like someone asking you to choose your favorite kid :) Though the answer is always the one that's annoying you the least at the moment..ha!
The Tacksman's Daughter is set in Glencoe, Scotland in the late 1600s. Caitriona Cameron is the daughter of the clan's Chief's Tacksman, which is an esteemed role at the time. When English soldiers arrive and ask for shelter and food they agree and welcome them. However, Cait is not convinced that they are safe and senses danger. When her sixth sense proves correct the entire clan is wiped out by the Englishmen based on orders sent from higher up.
Dear readers, be sure to have kleenex at the ready for this scene. The way the author writes never fails to bring the emotions out!
One of the English soldiers, Edward, is appalled by the orders and refuses to slaughter the very people who housed and fed them for weeks. He has fallen for Cait as well and doesn't want anything to happen to her. His refusal to fight makes him an enemy of his men, most especially his awful brother, Alexander, who is now trying to find him and bring him to the King for betrayal and to be hanged.
Edward, Cait, and others set out to find a new home and to exact revenge upon the people who ordered and perpetrated the massacre. There is adventure, romance, betrayal, danger, friendship, and family. It's a captivating story and one that I will think about for some time to come.
If you haven't read a Donna Scott novel please do yourself a favor and pick one up. I absolutely adore her writing and once I start a new book of hers it's hard to stop. You just want to devour it in one setting! I highly recommend The Tacksman's Daughter and cannot wait for the next release!
December 28, 2021
Really enjoyed this one - I've not read any of Donna Scott's other works but I'll certainly be looking them up now.
I sped through this in one sitting, thoroughly lost in the world of Cait, Edward and Taran.
Cait is from remote Glencoe, and the clan chief agrees to host English soldiers of King William. A massacre occurs, and Cait manages to escape. She then embarks on a journey to try to avenge the deaths of those she loves.
Edward is an English soldier, but with Scottish blood and a knowledge of Gaelic. He's shocked by the massacre, refusing to partake and branded a traitor. He goes on the run, reuniting with Cait.
His half brother, Alexander is hunting him, leaving a trail of broken hearts (and probably STDs) in his wake.
I recommend to any historical fiction lovers, I particularly enjoyed the use of Scots in the dialect and the Gaelic too, made it feel all the more authentic.
I sped through this in one sitting, thoroughly lost in the world of Cait, Edward and Taran.
Cait is from remote Glencoe, and the clan chief agrees to host English soldiers of King William. A massacre occurs, and Cait manages to escape. She then embarks on a journey to try to avenge the deaths of those she loves.
Edward is an English soldier, but with Scottish blood and a knowledge of Gaelic. He's shocked by the massacre, refusing to partake and branded a traitor. He goes on the run, reuniting with Cait.
His half brother, Alexander is hunting him, leaving a trail of broken hearts (and probably STDs) in his wake.
I recommend to any historical fiction lovers, I particularly enjoyed the use of Scots in the dialect and the Gaelic too, made it feel all the more authentic.
January 11, 2022
This is my first book by Donna Scott and I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed this historical fiction novel. It is based on true events on the true events of the Glencoe Massacre of 1692.This book was well written and the use of Scottish and Gaelic dialect contributed to the overall feel of 17th century Edinburgh.
There was non-stop action from the first page and I was fully immersed in the world. I loved the well-developed characters and Cait was by far my favorite character. It’s clear that an immense amount of research has gone into this book and I love that I’ve been able to learn more about Scottish history, which I find fascinating.
Rating: 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
There was non-stop action from the first page and I was fully immersed in the world. I loved the well-developed characters and Cait was by far my favorite character. It’s clear that an immense amount of research has gone into this book and I love that I’ve been able to learn more about Scottish history, which I find fascinating.
Rating: 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
March 15, 2022
The Tacksman’s Daughter is Donna Scott
Atlantic Publishing
Publication date January 3, 2022
Eighteen year old Caitriona { Cait} Cameron, has succeeded in staying unmarried and her father has made sure she and her sister can protect themselves against any unwanted male advances. She well know for her exceptional knife skills. Her and her family live within the protection of Alasdair MaClain the Chief of the McDonald’s of Glencoe. When English Redcoat’s, along with several men from the Campbell’s Clan arrive on a wintry day, nothing is ever the same again.
The Tacksman’s Daughter is Donna Scott is a superbly written historical fiction about the vicious massacre of Glencoe. It took place in the Scottish Highlands on 13 February 1692. In seamless narration, Donna Scott catapult’s the reader into this Dark and turbulent time when Scottish clansmen were forced to pledge their allegiance to the newly jointly crowned William III and Mary II.
As a reader, you can’t help but fall in love with the main characters, and feel so much remorse as the endure one of the most legendary atrocities in Scottish history. A complete violation of Highland hospitality that had political, and personal motivations. The villains in this story are well developed and splendidly hate-able.
This is the second book I have read from this very talented author. If you enjoy historical fiction set within the Scottish highlands, this book is for you.
Richly detailed with expertly developed three dimensional characters.
Atlantic Publishing
Publication date January 3, 2022
Eighteen year old Caitriona { Cait} Cameron, has succeeded in staying unmarried and her father has made sure she and her sister can protect themselves against any unwanted male advances. She well know for her exceptional knife skills. Her and her family live within the protection of Alasdair MaClain the Chief of the McDonald’s of Glencoe. When English Redcoat’s, along with several men from the Campbell’s Clan arrive on a wintry day, nothing is ever the same again.
The Tacksman’s Daughter is Donna Scott is a superbly written historical fiction about the vicious massacre of Glencoe. It took place in the Scottish Highlands on 13 February 1692. In seamless narration, Donna Scott catapult’s the reader into this Dark and turbulent time when Scottish clansmen were forced to pledge their allegiance to the newly jointly crowned William III and Mary II.
As a reader, you can’t help but fall in love with the main characters, and feel so much remorse as the endure one of the most legendary atrocities in Scottish history. A complete violation of Highland hospitality that had political, and personal motivations. The villains in this story are well developed and splendidly hate-able.
This is the second book I have read from this very talented author. If you enjoy historical fiction set within the Scottish highlands, this book is for you.
Richly detailed with expertly developed three dimensional characters.
March 21, 2022
Donna Scott is back and this time she is whisking us away to 17th century Scotland – and what an exhilarating and riveting ride it is!!
Before I start waffling, let us stop for a moment to fully appreciate how glorious this cover is, it’s stunning and fits the story perfectly!!
I was incredibly excited about this book from the moment I set eyes upon it, after reading Donna Scott’s previous book; The London Monster last year and I was hooked with her incredibly immersive writing so I knew that this was going to be another book that would keep me up until the wee hours and I was not disappointed, I was glued to the thrilling and tantalising story.
From the moment I picked this book up I was completely hooked, I am a huge fan of Scottish history especially when they are centred around true events from history and you can’t get any truer or more horrific than the Glencoe massacre and you can easily see who much research the author has done, she easily transports the reader to the brutal and danger 17th century with her richly descriptive and historical accurate writing. The characters are incredibly well developed, each one is beautifully fleshed out making them very real, the villains are remarkably well written and you can’t help but hate them. Cait is y personal favourite she is a brave and strong woman who has been plunged into one of the most horrific atrocities which Scotland ever saw, I liked her instantly and I loved following her journey and I especially loved the lighter tone of the book in the form of romance (always a win, win for a romance-loving bookworm).
In a way this makes me think of Outlander (minus the time travel) you have our main characters Cait and Edward – plus his deranged brother Alexander all connected and their stories and lives entwined; English and Scottish against one other, blood against blood clans betraying clans all set on a journey which history has already set out for them. It’s thrilling and I thought at times very emotional and haunting as all I could think was that parts of this really happened, it creeps into your heart and you feel everything beat and every betrayal.
Anyone who has read Donna Scott’s books will know what an incredible author she is, her writing is impeccable and atmospheric, she has this magical way with words that beautifully entwines fact with fiction so seamlessly, the story is a compelling and immersive tale of love, betrayal, loyalty, patriotic duty, secrets and heart-ache.
I must mention how much I really loved the use of the old Gaelic Scottish language strewn throughout, which gives the overall story a realism that keeps you turning the pages (plus every time any of the men spoke in Gaelic all I could hear in my head was the cast of Outlander).
The Taskman’s Daughter is an exhilarating, breathtaking, dramatic, intriguing and seductive story full of danger with a hint of romance.
Before I start waffling, let us stop for a moment to fully appreciate how glorious this cover is, it’s stunning and fits the story perfectly!!
I was incredibly excited about this book from the moment I set eyes upon it, after reading Donna Scott’s previous book; The London Monster last year and I was hooked with her incredibly immersive writing so I knew that this was going to be another book that would keep me up until the wee hours and I was not disappointed, I was glued to the thrilling and tantalising story.
From the moment I picked this book up I was completely hooked, I am a huge fan of Scottish history especially when they are centred around true events from history and you can’t get any truer or more horrific than the Glencoe massacre and you can easily see who much research the author has done, she easily transports the reader to the brutal and danger 17th century with her richly descriptive and historical accurate writing. The characters are incredibly well developed, each one is beautifully fleshed out making them very real, the villains are remarkably well written and you can’t help but hate them. Cait is y personal favourite she is a brave and strong woman who has been plunged into one of the most horrific atrocities which Scotland ever saw, I liked her instantly and I loved following her journey and I especially loved the lighter tone of the book in the form of romance (always a win, win for a romance-loving bookworm).
In a way this makes me think of Outlander (minus the time travel) you have our main characters Cait and Edward – plus his deranged brother Alexander all connected and their stories and lives entwined; English and Scottish against one other, blood against blood clans betraying clans all set on a journey which history has already set out for them. It’s thrilling and I thought at times very emotional and haunting as all I could think was that parts of this really happened, it creeps into your heart and you feel everything beat and every betrayal.
Anyone who has read Donna Scott’s books will know what an incredible author she is, her writing is impeccable and atmospheric, she has this magical way with words that beautifully entwines fact with fiction so seamlessly, the story is a compelling and immersive tale of love, betrayal, loyalty, patriotic duty, secrets and heart-ache.
I must mention how much I really loved the use of the old Gaelic Scottish language strewn throughout, which gives the overall story a realism that keeps you turning the pages (plus every time any of the men spoke in Gaelic all I could hear in my head was the cast of Outlander).
The Taskman’s Daughter is an exhilarating, breathtaking, dramatic, intriguing and seductive story full of danger with a hint of romance.
January 18, 2022
As a Scottish girl, I was SO excited to read a historical fiction novel based on the Glencoe massacre - a moment of huge significance in the history of Scotland and events stemming from the first Jacobite rising. Even though it was hundreds of years ago- there are reminders everywhere of this massacre, whether it is in museums or local establishments close to Glencoe or in folklore and phraseology, with the term "never trust a Campbell" still commonplace across Scotland.
The character we spend most of our time following, Cait, is wilful and wily - a bold female representative of Scotland if ever I saw one. While the inner feminist in me wanted her to storm off for justice without any input from a man, my cold heart can confirm this story contains a bit of romance - and it is wholesome in the best way.
Scott manages to explore found family really beautifully in the form of my favourite character- Taran. Such a sweet soul exists to detract from some of the more visceral moments of this novel and he is a true blessing.
There is a huge amount of research and historical accuracy in the story - something which I certainly appreciated. I feel like a bit of a map or family tree is definitely necessary to make the most of the story - perhaps this will be included in a paper copy. I really enjoyed the use of gaelic in the novel but I was left longing for a bit more Scots. Changing you to "ye" does not make a sentence Scots and with such a huge uprising in Scots leid written books at the moment I feel that the time was right for this and it would have added a bit more authenticity. I understand however that this may be unaccessible for a wider audience and that is why dialogue written in English over Scots - but a girl has to stick to her roots!
I loved my journey with Cait and her companions despite the grim concept of the story and I was truly sad when it was over. I really recommend this to anyone interested in the Glencoe massacre or any historical fiction fans. Was a brilliant read.
The character we spend most of our time following, Cait, is wilful and wily - a bold female representative of Scotland if ever I saw one. While the inner feminist in me wanted her to storm off for justice without any input from a man, my cold heart can confirm this story contains a bit of romance - and it is wholesome in the best way.
Scott manages to explore found family really beautifully in the form of my favourite character- Taran. Such a sweet soul exists to detract from some of the more visceral moments of this novel and he is a true blessing.
There is a huge amount of research and historical accuracy in the story - something which I certainly appreciated. I feel like a bit of a map or family tree is definitely necessary to make the most of the story - perhaps this will be included in a paper copy. I really enjoyed the use of gaelic in the novel but I was left longing for a bit more Scots. Changing you to "ye" does not make a sentence Scots and with such a huge uprising in Scots leid written books at the moment I feel that the time was right for this and it would have added a bit more authenticity. I understand however that this may be unaccessible for a wider audience and that is why dialogue written in English over Scots - but a girl has to stick to her roots!
I loved my journey with Cait and her companions despite the grim concept of the story and I was truly sad when it was over. I really recommend this to anyone interested in the Glencoe massacre or any historical fiction fans. Was a brilliant read.
January 17, 2022
I said it last year and I’ll say it this year this is something about books set in Scotland that for me stand out from the down. This historical book gave me everything I love with reading. Full of characters you root for every step of the way and others you detest. On top of every emotion roller coaster emotion possible, the ups on love and the downs of deception. I was shocked at the level of detail built up in the pages of high end research that makes this the most perfect historical fiction.
The author does a wonderful job at providing you with knowledge of the Scottish dialect. For the first book I’ve read by this author I completely appreciated the flow of the writing and the pace of the events that occur throughout. It never fails to shock me when I do find out about the brutality of some historical events but the depth of emotion used is extremely humbling.
Cait was a strong female lead as much as Alexander was a strong bad guy lead. These two characters had a way of coming together to highlight every low and high through the book. Sometimes with historical reads you can sometimes get caught up in the era and lose interest along the way. I was so shocked that like many brilliant authors out there Donna managed to keep me hooked at every given opportunity. I found the read to be extremely adventurous, enjoyable, knowledgable and just absolutely epic.
This book has made me want to go back and visit Scotland this year. This won’t be the last book I read by this author that’s for sure. So thankful for the opportunity to read this wonderful book.
The author does a wonderful job at providing you with knowledge of the Scottish dialect. For the first book I’ve read by this author I completely appreciated the flow of the writing and the pace of the events that occur throughout. It never fails to shock me when I do find out about the brutality of some historical events but the depth of emotion used is extremely humbling.
Cait was a strong female lead as much as Alexander was a strong bad guy lead. These two characters had a way of coming together to highlight every low and high through the book. Sometimes with historical reads you can sometimes get caught up in the era and lose interest along the way. I was so shocked that like many brilliant authors out there Donna managed to keep me hooked at every given opportunity. I found the read to be extremely adventurous, enjoyable, knowledgable and just absolutely epic.
This book has made me want to go back and visit Scotland this year. This won’t be the last book I read by this author that’s for sure. So thankful for the opportunity to read this wonderful book.
June 30, 2022
4.5 stars.
I want to thank the author for my review copy in exchange for an honest review.
Cait lived a quiet life in Glencoe with her parents, siblings and friends. She lobes her little town until soldiers come in one day asking her father for shelter. Cait is sure they don't have good intentions but every seems to think she is being silly so she does her best to ignore her gut and join in the revelry which is made easier with one solider, Edward.
Edward serves his duty because he has to as does his half brother Alexander. That is the only thing they do alike though. Edward is sweet on Cait from the moment they arrive at her fathers home. He tries to ease her concern about his regimen.. He makes her feel safe.. Then the worst is happening. Orders have come down from the Master Stair to destroy Glencoe and all people in it. Well, Edward refuses and does his best to warn Cait and her parents..The town and people that gave the soldiers refuge is soon destroyed. People murdered. Edward is an outlaw and is searching for Cait. Cait is a mess because of more tragedy that be falls her.
This story was very emotional and character driven. There are a few points of view and we really get a since of what the characters are going through at each moment. The author does an incredible job of keeping the reader Engaged in the story. I've read the authors other books and this one by far is the best.
I want to thank the author for my review copy in exchange for an honest review.
Cait lived a quiet life in Glencoe with her parents, siblings and friends. She lobes her little town until soldiers come in one day asking her father for shelter. Cait is sure they don't have good intentions but every seems to think she is being silly so she does her best to ignore her gut and join in the revelry which is made easier with one solider, Edward.
Edward serves his duty because he has to as does his half brother Alexander. That is the only thing they do alike though. Edward is sweet on Cait from the moment they arrive at her fathers home. He tries to ease her concern about his regimen.. He makes her feel safe.. Then the worst is happening. Orders have come down from the Master Stair to destroy Glencoe and all people in it. Well, Edward refuses and does his best to warn Cait and her parents..The town and people that gave the soldiers refuge is soon destroyed. People murdered. Edward is an outlaw and is searching for Cait. Cait is a mess because of more tragedy that be falls her.
This story was very emotional and character driven. There are a few points of view and we really get a since of what the characters are going through at each moment. The author does an incredible job of keeping the reader Engaged in the story. I've read the authors other books and this one by far is the best.
January 9, 2022
This is my first book by Donna Scott and what a fast-paced historic fiction with lots of twists and turns that will keep you up late at night. The author has definitely done her research on this book. The story is set in Scotland in 1692. A horrible massacre occurs in the village of Glencoe by English troops. Only a few of the villagers survive. Cait, her sister, and her friend are rescued by Sergeant Edward Gage who is against the massacre. The story follows them as they attempt to make their way to Edinburgh to confront the men who they believe are behind the attack on Glencoe. At times throughout the story, they are separated and each has their own experiences that add to the story. If you are a fan of historic fiction you may also enjoy this book.
Thank you @instabooktours and @donnascott for this eARC.
Thank you @instabooktours and @donnascott for this eARC.
January 8, 2022
Donna Scott has a wonderful way of writing and the use of Scottish vernacular and Gaelic dialect is incredible in this novel! The characterisation is awesome, Cait was a character you just have to root for such a strong willed young woman! I also loved (no hate please) Alexander because of his complicated character make up.
Telling the story of the Glencoe massacre, this piece of historical fiction is a must read and I stormed through it wanting to follow Cait, Alexander and Edward on their journeys through Scotland .
I would reccomend to my historical fiction lovers out there.
Telling the story of the Glencoe massacre, this piece of historical fiction is a must read and I stormed through it wanting to follow Cait, Alexander and Edward on their journeys through Scotland .
I would reccomend to my historical fiction lovers out there.
December 30, 2021
Donna Scott has done it again, bringing to life a dastardly villain in the form of Alexander. There were a few moments when I caught myself mumbling under my breath, 'He's SUCH an a..hole.' He's the type of villain you love to hate, which makes you vie for the other characters all the more. My favourite scene in the book was from Taran's point-of-view in the alehouse—exquisitely visceral!
This loss in this story (sensitively handled) made me well up, Cait's wit made me laugh aloud, and Alexander's douchbaggery made me growl—all the feels you expect from a brilliant book.
This loss in this story (sensitively handled) made me well up, Cait's wit made me laugh aloud, and Alexander's douchbaggery made me growl—all the feels you expect from a brilliant book.
February 9, 2022
I sat down with this book and the sensory details evoked a desire to savor the words as I would a strong single malt scotch for the first time, enjoying the subtlety of the nuanced flavors. The Tacksman’s Daughter weaves together stories of survival in the midst of transitioning loyalties and shifting truths. The slow reveal of the historical setting and character details unfold as they do in a Shakespearean play. Captivating and frustrating the reader’s desire to reconcile the foil characters, the author challenges stereotypes while unveiling strengths in surprising critical moments. The reader is encouraged to take sides and question alliances as the characters journey through their strengths and weaknesses. The pacing is fast and suspenseful while the mystery enthusiasts will appreciate the subtle details throughout. My only regret is that this book ends leaving me with a desire for more. As this is the author’s newly released masterpiece so I am left in suspense for Donna Scott’s next novel.
February 12, 2025
Really loved this and couldn't put it down! Such an amazing FMC! Bravo!
July 27, 2022
REVIEWER'S CHOICE
Purely as a matter of personal preference, occasionally a book has it all for me. To this happy list I add Donna Scott's marvelously crafted The Tacksman's Daughter. It ticks all the boxes. Set in Scotland? Check. Deals with a heretofore under-fictionalized historic event? Check. A cast of full-bodied, three-dimensional characters, both endearing and despicable? Check.
The author had me with at the first line: "February 2, 1692, Alt Na Munde, Glencoe, Scotland." Anyone passingly familiar with Scottish history immediately knows we're in for a tale of the tragic duplicity and murder wreaked by soldiers of Clan Campbell upon their unsuspecting and gracious hosts, the MacDonalds of Glencoe. This horrible abuse of the near-sacred Highland obligation of hospitality resonates to this day in the Scottish collective consciousness.
Ms Scott spins her engaging and heartbreaking tale through the eyes of an irresistible main character, Caitriona Cameron, daughter of one of the tacksmen—major landholders—under MacIain, chieftain of the MacDonalds. This places Cait in the stunning beautiful glen when red-coated soldiers arrive. These are mostly Scottish troops mustered from the Campbell lands and under the command of Captain Robert Campbell of Glenlyon, a name reviled down the ensuing 300 years.
The MacDonalds offer shelter and hospitality to the troops who are transiting Glencoe when a winter storm hits, snowing them in for several days. Unbeknownst to their hosts, Captain Campbell has received orders to kill all persons under age of 70, women and children included. Cait narrowly escapes the massacre with the aid of advance warning from an English sergeant, with the remainder of the book taken up with her determined quest for vengeance and accompanying journey through her grief to a place of forgiveness, finding love along the way. Her quest meanders through Stirling and several villages before reaching its culmination in the crowded wynds and teeming streets of Edinburgh.
The author avoids most of the simplistic stereotypes and quasi-historical tropes into which she could easily have fallen; much myth-making has been spawned by the Massacre at Glencoe, after all. Instead, she creates very nuanced characters who, while deeply traumatized by the horror that occurred in the snows of Glencoe, show an uncanny ability to heal and evolve. The much-reviled Glenlyon, for example, becomes a more complicated, even pitiful, character in Ms Scott's supple handling.
This volume is professionally edited and formatted, with a lovely and engaging cover. Any weaknesses are small and detract very little from the craftsmanship of this accomplished storyteller. The Tacksman's Daughter should be a satisfying read for fans of Outlander, lovers of all things Scottish, and the general devotee of historical fiction. I highly recommend this engrossing novel.
Originally Reviewed for Discovering Diamonds
Purely as a matter of personal preference, occasionally a book has it all for me. To this happy list I add Donna Scott's marvelously crafted The Tacksman's Daughter. It ticks all the boxes. Set in Scotland? Check. Deals with a heretofore under-fictionalized historic event? Check. A cast of full-bodied, three-dimensional characters, both endearing and despicable? Check.
The author had me with at the first line: "February 2, 1692, Alt Na Munde, Glencoe, Scotland." Anyone passingly familiar with Scottish history immediately knows we're in for a tale of the tragic duplicity and murder wreaked by soldiers of Clan Campbell upon their unsuspecting and gracious hosts, the MacDonalds of Glencoe. This horrible abuse of the near-sacred Highland obligation of hospitality resonates to this day in the Scottish collective consciousness.
Ms Scott spins her engaging and heartbreaking tale through the eyes of an irresistible main character, Caitriona Cameron, daughter of one of the tacksmen—major landholders—under MacIain, chieftain of the MacDonalds. This places Cait in the stunning beautiful glen when red-coated soldiers arrive. These are mostly Scottish troops mustered from the Campbell lands and under the command of Captain Robert Campbell of Glenlyon, a name reviled down the ensuing 300 years.
The MacDonalds offer shelter and hospitality to the troops who are transiting Glencoe when a winter storm hits, snowing them in for several days. Unbeknownst to their hosts, Captain Campbell has received orders to kill all persons under age of 70, women and children included. Cait narrowly escapes the massacre with the aid of advance warning from an English sergeant, with the remainder of the book taken up with her determined quest for vengeance and accompanying journey through her grief to a place of forgiveness, finding love along the way. Her quest meanders through Stirling and several villages before reaching its culmination in the crowded wynds and teeming streets of Edinburgh.
The author avoids most of the simplistic stereotypes and quasi-historical tropes into which she could easily have fallen; much myth-making has been spawned by the Massacre at Glencoe, after all. Instead, she creates very nuanced characters who, while deeply traumatized by the horror that occurred in the snows of Glencoe, show an uncanny ability to heal and evolve. The much-reviled Glenlyon, for example, becomes a more complicated, even pitiful, character in Ms Scott's supple handling.
This volume is professionally edited and formatted, with a lovely and engaging cover. Any weaknesses are small and detract very little from the craftsmanship of this accomplished storyteller. The Tacksman's Daughter should be a satisfying read for fans of Outlander, lovers of all things Scottish, and the general devotee of historical fiction. I highly recommend this engrossing novel.
Originally Reviewed for Discovering Diamonds
January 12, 2022
We often visited Scotland on holiday when I was a child. My Dad was an historian so we visited castles, battlegrounds, museums and Glencoe. I will never forget visiting the museum and hearing about the terrible massacre. I went home armed with history books by John Prebble and I was immediately attracted to this book set in Glencoe.
1692 and English soldiers arrive in the village of Glencoe asking for food and lodging because of the terrible weather. Although Cait raises her suspicions, she is ignored. The villagers are generous hosts for 12 days before, under cover of darkness, the soldiers launch a brutal attack on their hosts. Cait is the daughter of the Tacksman, (a landholder) who survives the attack with her friend and her child, but her family are slaughtered. She is helped by Edward Gage, an English soldier and together they journey to Edinburgh to confront those they believe are responsible for the attack. Their journey is full of danger including the threat of Edward’s half brother, Alexander who has plans to frame his brother for the attack.
The Tacksman’s Daughter is a retelling of the Glencoe massacre with literary characters woven among historical figures. There is a fascinating afterword written by Donna Scott about the writing of the story. In some ways I wish I had read this first. She details the sources she used - some of the dialogue was taken ‘verbatim from eyewitness accounts’ and explains which characters are fact and which fiction.
This is a lovely blend of history and adventure - Cait is a feisty heroine, skilled with a knife, Alexander is the most evil of enemies; violent, a sexual predator, with no redeeming qualities. Like any great adventure you spend the whole story sat on the edge of your seat desperate for the good guys to win out. This is a brutal and physical world and extremely volatile politically with Jacobite plots, and an uneasy peace between Scotland and England. The story is full of historical observation, social mores, dialogue and some beautiful Gaelic language (wouldn’t this be wonderful on audiobook!)
’.
I really enjoyed this, loved the characters and revising a period in history which fascinates me. Since reading this I have been reading about the Jacobites and hunting among my bookshelves for those Prebble books!
Thanks you to Donna Scott and instabook tours for allowing me to take part on this tour.
AD-PR Product
March 23, 2022
My Thoughts:
One of my favorite settings in a story is Scotland. I’m also fond of Ireland, Wales, and England. The time period is another favorite because of the history of this time: the Jacobite group and the current ruling monarch in England. These are strong reasons for me to become swept up in the story.
Another reason I fell in love with the story is the character, Caitriona or Cait. She is both beautiful and wise. She has a hidden talent rare for a female and this gives her an interesting and enticing bonus.
The two brothers are Alexander and Edward. They are polar opposites which also create elements for the story. Plus, when there are characters who are so opposite in nature it causes each to become larger in the eyes of the reader. What I am saying is if the very bad and mean character were not so very bad and mean he would not make the very good character look so good. I hope that makes sense. It is like placing a diamond beside a piece of coal. The diamond seems to be more brilliant and beautiful beside that piece of coal rather than placed alone. It is the same with the two female characters. One of them is feisty and wise. The other is innocent and naive.
What did I learn or take away from the story?
A. That people see sometimes what they want to see in another person. Love often obscures vision.
B. Freedom and truth is worth fighting for.
C. When a person is deceptive, their behavior will eventually show who they really are as a person.
How do I wish the story had ended?
A. I wish the brother with the terrible qualities had changed his character to positive attributes.
B. I wish the lovemaking scenes held tenderness, gentleness, and patience. In this story there are two brothers with two very different ways of engaging in sex. I had hoped to find a more gentle and patient nature in one of the brothers. I’m not saying he is a brute, but I am tired of lovemaking scenes in stories being all about quick fiery passion. One of the best love scenes in a story I’ve read is in the book, For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway. Hemingway understands that women don’t always want a quick fiery pop of sex.
Themes in the story: family honor, courage, deception, revenge, romance, survival, war, rebellion, beauty, greed, loyalty, jealousy, redemption, obsession, bravery, and betrayal.
Format: E-book.
Source: I received a complimentary e-book copy from Historical Fiction Virtual Book Tours. I am not required to write a positive review.
Audience: Historical fiction readers. Readers who have an interest in Scottish history.
Rating: Very good to excellent.
One of my favorite settings in a story is Scotland. I’m also fond of Ireland, Wales, and England. The time period is another favorite because of the history of this time: the Jacobite group and the current ruling monarch in England. These are strong reasons for me to become swept up in the story.
Another reason I fell in love with the story is the character, Caitriona or Cait. She is both beautiful and wise. She has a hidden talent rare for a female and this gives her an interesting and enticing bonus.
The two brothers are Alexander and Edward. They are polar opposites which also create elements for the story. Plus, when there are characters who are so opposite in nature it causes each to become larger in the eyes of the reader. What I am saying is if the very bad and mean character were not so very bad and mean he would not make the very good character look so good. I hope that makes sense. It is like placing a diamond beside a piece of coal. The diamond seems to be more brilliant and beautiful beside that piece of coal rather than placed alone. It is the same with the two female characters. One of them is feisty and wise. The other is innocent and naive.
What did I learn or take away from the story?
A. That people see sometimes what they want to see in another person. Love often obscures vision.
B. Freedom and truth is worth fighting for.
C. When a person is deceptive, their behavior will eventually show who they really are as a person.
How do I wish the story had ended?
A. I wish the brother with the terrible qualities had changed his character to positive attributes.
B. I wish the lovemaking scenes held tenderness, gentleness, and patience. In this story there are two brothers with two very different ways of engaging in sex. I had hoped to find a more gentle and patient nature in one of the brothers. I’m not saying he is a brute, but I am tired of lovemaking scenes in stories being all about quick fiery passion. One of the best love scenes in a story I’ve read is in the book, For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway. Hemingway understands that women don’t always want a quick fiery pop of sex.
Themes in the story: family honor, courage, deception, revenge, romance, survival, war, rebellion, beauty, greed, loyalty, jealousy, redemption, obsession, bravery, and betrayal.
Format: E-book.
Source: I received a complimentary e-book copy from Historical Fiction Virtual Book Tours. I am not required to write a positive review.
Audience: Historical fiction readers. Readers who have an interest in Scottish history.
Rating: Very good to excellent.
March 23, 2022
Historical fiction that completely transports you to the Scottish Highlands.
Scott not only gives us an intriguing and engaging story but she fills it with characters that felt so authentic to the period. **disclaimer: I was not alive when this takes place in 1692** Cait's character makes my heart bleed. I adored her and wanted to hug her so hard. Edward is her perfect complement while his brother really is the complete opposite. He was quite easy to dislike 😂. Davina makes you want to shake her and love her at the same time. Mix treason, sibling rivalry, Jacobites, and the English Army all together and you have found a great read!
.
The Tacksmans Daughter is not purely fiction, the main story around the destruction and devastation of Glencoe is based on a true historical massacre.
.
I always appreciate when authors bring to light events that history tends to leave out.
.
Recommend to lovers of Scottish Historical fiction; this one had Outlander vibes (minus time travel). Go check it out!!!
Scott not only gives us an intriguing and engaging story but she fills it with characters that felt so authentic to the period. **disclaimer: I was not alive when this takes place in 1692** Cait's character makes my heart bleed. I adored her and wanted to hug her so hard. Edward is her perfect complement while his brother really is the complete opposite. He was quite easy to dislike 😂. Davina makes you want to shake her and love her at the same time. Mix treason, sibling rivalry, Jacobites, and the English Army all together and you have found a great read!
.
The Tacksmans Daughter is not purely fiction, the main story around the destruction and devastation of Glencoe is based on a true historical massacre.
.
I always appreciate when authors bring to light events that history tends to leave out.
.
Recommend to lovers of Scottish Historical fiction; this one had Outlander vibes (minus time travel). Go check it out!!!
January 4, 2022
What a way to start the year with a trip round Scotland. Books like The Tacksman's Daughter are the reason I love reading historical fiction, they transport you, not just to places but back in time. Donna has clearly put so much research in to creating this novel, but doesn't shove it in your face & make parts overly long or descriptive. She weaves the details into the dialogue & prose so that the reader has all the information they need to create an image of the time, but it's effortlessly done.
Her characters are well written, with villians to hate, although there are grey areas to some, & heroes in many shapes not just our strapping lead man & wilful heroine. I particularly loved how many of the characters were real people caught up in this infamous event.
If you ever visit Edinburgh a trip to the castle or Mary Kings close are a must for any historical fictions fans, Donna captures 17th century Edinburgh brilliantly in this book.
Her characters are well written, with villians to hate, although there are grey areas to some, & heroes in many shapes not just our strapping lead man & wilful heroine. I particularly loved how many of the characters were real people caught up in this infamous event.
If you ever visit Edinburgh a trip to the castle or Mary Kings close are a must for any historical fictions fans, Donna captures 17th century Edinburgh brilliantly in this book.
January 7, 2022
This is my first book from this author and not my usual genre. However, due to my love of history, I thought it may be something that I would enjoy. This was my first read of the year- and a great choice!
Betrayal, death, heartbreak, love- this book has it all! The author portrays a clear passion for history through the telling of the story and the plot shows that a lot of research has gone into the writing. The characters are well written and it is easy to like the main protagonists, Cait and Edward. Despite all of the barriers that the plot throws at them, we find ourselves rooting for their happy ever after! The plot was easy to follow and I found it to be a really interesting read. I particularly liked the inclusion of Gaelic and Scottish dialect to make the plot and characters feel more authentic. If you are interested in history or like a good historical novel, then this is one to add to add to your reading list.
Betrayal, death, heartbreak, love- this book has it all! The author portrays a clear passion for history through the telling of the story and the plot shows that a lot of research has gone into the writing. The characters are well written and it is easy to like the main protagonists, Cait and Edward. Despite all of the barriers that the plot throws at them, we find ourselves rooting for their happy ever after! The plot was easy to follow and I found it to be a really interesting read. I particularly liked the inclusion of Gaelic and Scottish dialect to make the plot and characters feel more authentic. If you are interested in history or like a good historical novel, then this is one to add to add to your reading list.
March 31, 2022
This was my first book tour read of the year and wow what a book to start with.
I love historical fiction and this has everything that I look for in a historical fiction novel. The book was so well written by author @donnascottwriter and the content had obviously been so well researched as she was able to give such engaging descriptions and such vivid imagery that I felt I was right there in the pages of the book.
It was a gripping read that I couldnt put down made even better by the development of the characters who were either loveable or hateful but either way they were perfect on the page.
If you love historical fiction or you love scotland I would definitely recommend reading this book, you will not regret it.
A massive thank you to @donnascottwriter and @instabooktours for having me on the tour. I loved every second of reading the book ♥️♥️
#booktour #bookstagram #donnascott #instabooktours #thetacksmansdaughter #historicalfiction #scotland #booksarelife
I love historical fiction and this has everything that I look for in a historical fiction novel. The book was so well written by author @donnascottwriter and the content had obviously been so well researched as she was able to give such engaging descriptions and such vivid imagery that I felt I was right there in the pages of the book.
It was a gripping read that I couldnt put down made even better by the development of the characters who were either loveable or hateful but either way they were perfect on the page.
If you love historical fiction or you love scotland I would definitely recommend reading this book, you will not regret it.
A massive thank you to @donnascottwriter and @instabooktours for having me on the tour. I loved every second of reading the book ♥️♥️
#booktour #bookstagram #donnascott #instabooktours #thetacksmansdaughter #historicalfiction #scotland #booksarelife
January 10, 2022
I knew absolutely nothing about the Glencoe massacre before reading this book. I recently learned that my husband has Scottish heritage so I’ve taken an interest in all-things-Scottish. I even started watching the Outlander series, which is why I was drawn to this novel. In the back of the book, the author tells you how she used each one of the main characters to represent the types of people who were victims or perpetrators of the attack, and a lot of the characters were real people. I am a stickler for detail and love a well researched historical read, and The Tacksman’s Daughter had me turning the pages!!! If you love historical fiction and are a fan of Outlander, you will absolutely love this book!
May 11, 2022
This is the third book I've read by this author, and I think what I like most about her writing is her humor and her settings. This book takes place in Scotland after the Glencoe massacre. It almost felt like an adventure story, with Cait seeking revenge for her parents' murder and love interest Edward seeking to clear his name for crimes he didn't commit. As I've said in my other review for this author's debut novel Shame the Devil, she writes amazing villains. In this book, it's Edward's brother, Alexander, and he is pure evil I tell you! Now that I've devoured all three of this author's books, I'm afraid I'm going to have to wait a long time for her next one :(
December 29, 2021
There are so many moments in history that I’ve heard about but never studied. The Glencoe Massacre of 1692 is one of them, which is why I was thrilled to see that Donna Scott’s third book starts with this tragic event in Scottish history and sets her heroine on a path of vengeance! There are a lot of rich and complex relationships in The Tacksman's Daughter (and of course one that features Scott’s requisite villain readers love to hate!), but I especially appreciate the way she weaves history into her stories without a heavy hand. Be prepared to learn while being entertained!
December 29, 2021
There are so many moments in history that I’ve heard about but never studied. The Glencoe Massacre of 1692 is one of them, which is why I was thrilled to see that Donna Scott’s third book starts with this tragic event in Scottish history and sets her heroine on a path of vengeance! There are a lot of rich and complex relationships in The Tacksman's Daughter (and of course one that features Scott’s requisite villain readers love to hate!), but I especially appreciate the way she weaves history into her stories without a heavy hand. Be prepared to learn while being entertained!
February 11, 2022
A Gripping Tale Based on Real Events
The Tacksman’s Daughter is Donna Scott’s best book yet. Based on a real event that took place in 1692, it chronicles a Scottish Highland atrocity in which clan was turned against clan at the orders of the English King. Or maybe not? There is enough intrigue, history, romance, and betrayal here to please the most demanding reader of historical fiction. You will fall in love with the characters and the setting, all beautifully portrayed. I highly recommend this book.
The Tacksman’s Daughter is Donna Scott’s best book yet. Based on a real event that took place in 1692, it chronicles a Scottish Highland atrocity in which clan was turned against clan at the orders of the English King. Or maybe not? There is enough intrigue, history, romance, and betrayal here to please the most demanding reader of historical fiction. You will fall in love with the characters and the setting, all beautifully portrayed. I highly recommend this book.
June 15, 2022
This is my second book I’ve read by Donna Scott. The first one, Shame the Devil, hooked me into historical fiction and this one definitely did not disappoint. There is adventure, romance, danger, and friendship. Cait is quite the strong young woman and Alexander is quite the jealous scoundrel. Edward is his charming (almost twin) brother who is the exact opposite of Alexander.
I learned a lot about the tragic Glencoe massacre from this book, with which I was not familiar with. What a great history lesson that kept me interested throughout the entire book.
I learned a lot about the tragic Glencoe massacre from this book, with which I was not familiar with. What a great history lesson that kept me interested throughout the entire book.
January 13, 2022
I feel as though I continue to continue forward my fascination for Scotland and Scottish culture, there are so many more time periods I discover, that I before had no inclination of whatever, The Glencoe Massacre of 1692 being one of them. Taking down too many members of the Clan MacDonald in petty claim over royal allegiance, moreover right place wrong time, because of lack of staffing at Fort William?? With the English claiming their possession of such territories, they don't really have much patience with these inhabitants, and that's pretty sad to hear about, I mean just look at the Jacobite rebellion that accord almost 50 years later..
Overall, I really enjoyed the deep dive into this fictitious retelling of what occurred in the 1690s through the lens of the young and courageous Cait and the horrid villain that became of Alexander.
4/5 Stars
Overall, I really enjoyed the deep dive into this fictitious retelling of what occurred in the 1690s through the lens of the young and courageous Cait and the horrid villain that became of Alexander.
4/5 Stars
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 10, 2022
I absolutely loved this book! I sat down to read it and the next thing I knew I was done! The writing in this book is captivating and the descriptions are amazing! My favorite character was Cait! Her personality is one you can't help but enjoy! She had me laughing out loud a few times! I haven't read anything else by Donna Scott but that is definitely going to change!
Thank you Insta Book Tours and Donna Scott for my place on this tour and also for sharing this book with me!
Thank you Insta Book Tours and Donna Scott for my place on this tour and also for sharing this book with me!
February 15, 2022
The Tacksman's Daughter is a wonderful novel based on real events. The book is beautifully written and edited and the story flows so well that you don't want to stop reading. It's clear the author did her research because her details of the time period and events are accurate. The characters are real and their emotions were so well expressed that I thought I was right there with them! If you love historical fiction as I do then you must read The Tacksman's Daughter.
March 8, 2022
From the first paragraph I was hooked! The characters are so well developed that I was invested in their lives right from the start. I read the book in one sitting. I could not put it down! I highly recommend this to historical fiction fans and anyone who loves a good read. If you’re an Outlander fan, this book is for you! There is romance, suspense mystery and some twists and turns that will keep you on the edge of your seat!!
Read this book!
Read this book!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews