Short, no-sex, Regency romance, with an instalove MMC
The situation of Addie, the 19-year-old FMC in this novel, is extremely dark. Her father was a prosperous Baron. After 17 years as an only child, Addie's mother bore a baby son, Reggie, and died soon after due to complications of the birth. A few months ago, Addie's father unexpectedly died as well, and Addie and Reggie, who is the heir apparent to the barony, are in danger of being murdered by their guardian, a middle-aged cousin who is the heir presumptive, and will inherit the title if she and Reggie conveniently die.
Addie is afraid to go to any of her older male relatives who might be of any real help to her and Reggie. Apparently the Snidely Whiplash guardian has a split personality and has convinced all of the ton that he's one heck of a great guy, merely because he's the life of every party. Addie ends up applying for assistance from an elderly female cousin. However, the only help she is capable of providing to save Addie and Reggie is a fake letter of reference so Addie can get a job.
Addie manages to get hired as a maid at the London mansion of the MMC, the extremely rich and highly eligible Earl of Tolston. His age is never stated, but the implication is that he is, at most, in his early thirties, and he is, of course, well built and handsome. He is instantly smitten and massively protective of small, slender, beautiful Addie, when she falls at his feet in a dead faint. The delicate whiteness of her hands and the refinement of her speech lets him know immediately that she is not of the lower classes and should not be working as a maid, because she is probably a runaway debutante. (Unbelievably, his housekeeper did not care about any of that.)
This author does not typically write romantic suspense, and that type of story is not well suited to a short novel. If this were a plot in an Amanda Quick (Jayne Ann Krentz) Regency, it would lead to a much longer novel, and the villain would not experience the type of anticlimactic comeuppance that Snidely gets in this novel.
The romance itself is somewhat satisfying from the side of the earl, who is given his own POV. Unfortunately, I found Addie far less sympathetic because, frustratingly, she is always mindlessly on the run, which makes her an extremely unqualified and incompetent protector for her baby brother. Though Addie claims to herself throughout the novel that the survival of baby Reggie is her primary goal in life, her pride is actually her true motivation, because she puts her brother needlessly at risk due to refusing to confide in the earl, even after it's become quite apparent he can be trusted. Of course, if she did tell him the whole story of her dilemma, this novel would be finished in a few dozen pages, and he would serve as an unsatisfying deus ex machina, swooping in to solve her problem. But, for me personally, dragging out a story because of a failure to communicate vital information is a romantic conflict that I dislike.
I really enjoy this author's YA novellas, but this is only the second of her short Regency novels that I have read. I obtained this novel and the fifth one in this series for free, and I decided to check them out. I really enjoyed the fifth one. It is straight-up romance, with no dark villains and, as such, it worked out much better for my personal taste than this book did.
I rate this book 2.5 stars, which I have rounded up to 3 stars.