I thought this story to be a big disappointment. I was excited by the ‘who dunnit?’ premise and thought the remote setting would cleverly build anticipation. However, this story felt erratic, with underdeveloped characters and too many coincidences.
I struggled to keep track of the three women narrating the story. Sometimes the voice switched mid-chapter and I became grateful for the character list at the beginning of the story. That being said, even when I was well into the book, I still had to keep reminding myself of the character positions. I think this is because they felt so one-dimensional and lacking development. Furthermore, I didn’t grow to particularly like any of the characters and found myself irritated by their attitudes. I was confused by the male lead, Robert, who seemed to go from being extremely frail and elderly, to acting like a patriarch that the family fears. Furthermore, I found his relationships with several women to be a bit toe-curling and I disliked how he spoke to the women around him.
Reading this book, I felt like some parts were rushed too much. For example, in the opening chapters, I thought I had missed some significant element of the plot because the story was simply rushing through to get the characters on the remote, holiday island. This set the tone for the rest of the book and I felt like I was constantly playing ‘catch up’ to the narrative as parts didn’t feel truly explained properly. Too many over-used cliches appeared in this book and this definitely lessened the intensity of the story. Frequent convenient plot devices were used to make this a ‘tidy’ narrative and it didn’t feel like it ever got going, even with the mystery element of the story.
Whilst this had the enticing cover and the idea of the wealthy behaving badly, this book did not meet expectations. The setting was never truly explored and I thought this was a missed opportunity. I persevered with the novel because I wanted to find out the answers but, honestly, did not really care by the end of it who was alive and who was dead. I love a good ‘who dunnit?’ mystery but I think Armstrong was off the mark here. It had such promise but it made me want to get away from the book itself.
With thanks to HQ Digital and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.