This is an extremely difficult review to write as I thought about DNFing several times, but that wouldn’t be true to my agreement to provide an honest review in exchange for a copy. It wasn't that I was caught off guard, for I expected dark prose and gloomy poetry given the book's title and opening blurb.
The book’s beginning pages came with content warnings (and also kind advice). Kudo’s to the author for providing those advance warnings. The warnings included the following:
• Mental Health Conditions
• Suicide/Suicidal Ideation
• Self-Harm
• Sexual Assault
• Gun Violence
• Violence against poc
• Brief mentions of body dysmorphia
• Brief mentions of drug/alcohol use*
• + other tough topics
Ok - Holy smokes! That’s a LOT of heavy stuff in a book of 176 pgs (NetGalley ARC copy version...with some pages blank at the end). *I would disagree with the word “brief” when applied to drug use.
What I liked about this book:
• The cover design
• The title of the book
• The drawn illustrations
• What I believe (hope) was the author's intent in writing this creative work.**
What I didn't like about this book:
• MORE than half of the book is focused on the deeply dark. It had the feel of a journal one might keep in therapy. However, the opening of the book (in part) mentions “This is a work of FICTION”, the “product of the author's Imagination” - Italics mine). Knowing that up front, gave me a feeling that what was written, was LESS THAN TRUE heartfelt realism (as is often expressed in poetry), even though the author states that SOME of the pieces are based on true stories.
• The road to recovery receives a lot less time and attention. When the road to recovery begins to be expressed, it is way too simplistic, rushed.
• Peppered with frequent F*Bombs (even in recovery sections)
• Unflattering references to god/religion (the word “god” as written in book).
Summary: I'm extremely familiar, and most certainly, no stranger to depression. I have seen the effects of serious mental illness in countless others, and unfortunately have also experienced seeing ones give up on life.
The Content: I get the meaning of the book’s title, the meaning of “paper girl”, meaning of “knives”, but was completely disappointed in content here. It didn't uplift me, nor did I appreciate the style of writing. The “dark writing” was understandably angry, intense, hopeless. The “road to recovery-journey to heal” writing felt so shallow, hollow, ordinary, insincere.
I was hoping this read would be inspiring, illuminating, healing, AFTER the darkness was expressed, after all the effects of the proverbial knives.. For some reviewers, it was all that. For me - no, not even close. The negativity/darkness content FAR outweighed any positivity or healing implied. Then I remembered this is a work of FICTION, the product of the authors imagination. With a minimum of no less than 9 trigger warnings - obviously this publication is not for everyone.
Perhaps the reading of the author’s creative thoughts and poetry will provide a lesson for some to experience a mental darkness they have never experienced or seen before. Or perhaps it gives a voice to someone who stayed silent, who could never speak or felt misunderstood if they tried. My hope is that it will provide whatever enjoyment /benefit to the reader that the author intended.**
1.5 rounded up to 2 Stars
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion. ALL opinions are my own.