3.25
I had braced myself for what I thought would be the perfect storm of yelling, screaming, and tears. I imagined us arguing about whether or not it was a choice. I imagined them crying hysterically and blaming themselves, as if my faults were caused by something they had done. I imagined them scolding me for entertaining the idea of homosexuality. But no. None of that came. Instead, what I got was far worse: They left me alone.
In drown, we follow two boys through their sexual awakening. Erik is just trying to work on a biology project when his classmate, hotshot athlete Andrew, gropes him and startles Erik into the realization that, despite his strict Catholic upbringing, he may actually have a thing for guys. Meanwhile, half a state away, Nick is supposed to lose his v-card to his girlfriend, but is unable to ... rise to the occasion. When Nick's parents separate and he chooses his mom, the boys are introduced and quickly form a fast friendship ... which quickly escalates into more. But with Nick in denial as to his sexuality and Erik's unsupportive parents, what choice does one have but to drown?
Leonardo did a great job of building the relationships and portraying the giddiness of the beginning of texting and hanging out with your crush. His portrayal of emotions and identity were genuinely excellent. I love that he addressed Erik's feeling of dysphoria without diving too deeply into it, leaving the reader to wonder if it was genuine dissatisfaction with his gender or brought about by Catholic shame. Their parental relationships were well fleshed out and seemed to genuinely portray parents who cared very much and very differently in regards to one another. The helpless misery of feeling powerless in a relationship where you care more than the other person does was so accurate that I physically felt it in my chest.
And maybe that's why I didn't love it: The powerlessness and the loneliness of it all. The way Erik, essentially, loses everything over it. Because, quite frankly, Nick is toxic. He drives a wedge between Erik and Mackenzie, then says he can't decide how he feels about Erik himself, leaving Erik feeling utterly isolated. Mackenzie isn't speaking to him. He can't open up to his parents. Nick is telling him they're just friends. The bullies have gotten hold of the fact that Erik is gay. And, in his moment of need, after all he's done to make Nick feel good and cared for, he is told that it was all a mistake. He isn't comforted. He isn't fought for. He isn't told sweet nothings. He is, essentially, abandoned when he needs Nick the most. But then Nick makes his decision and everything is suddenly okay.
I felt like this was Erik's story, or maybe both Erik and Nick's, but in the end, it was really only Nick's story. And, boy, was that a letdown.