3.5. I received an ARC from the author and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.
I had heard of the Softest Kinksters series, due to (presumably, I forget) having read the first story and in an anthology a while back and following the author on Twitter. I’ve long been interested in them, so I jumped at the chance to read the special print collection.
I really appreciate the general vibe of the collection of promoting a more emotional, multifaceted side to kink than is often seen in some mainstream media, mostly by non-practitioners. While I’m not in the BDSM community myself, I am interested in exploring more compassionate portrayals of it in fiction, and am glad that is what Williams provided here. And the addition of endorsements from fellow authors Eden Bradley and Stefanie Simpson, writing a foreword and concluding essay, respectively, present arguments that I can’t help but agree with upon finishing the collection.
I will say that the writing style and perspective choices take some getting used to. No one is referred to by a proper name (except in a kink context), and that makes things especially confusing during the f/f shorts, when both leads are referred to as “she.” I can’t say I connected with any characters, but I did like certain story concepts more than others.
Holding On perfectly escalates the tension between the couple while on a date, then finding themselves stuck together in his apartment during a storm. Hanging On is an incredibly sexy sapphic reunion story between spouses. Carrying On is a standout in its delightful awkwardness, and I love how the couple were still able to have their moment even amid myriad mishaps. Turning On was a wonderful exploration of a variety of kinks I was unfamiliar with, but am definitely into. Hitting On is another fun one for me, as I’m a sucker for anything that happens in a library…even when it gets a bit kinky. Catching On is friends to lovers perfection, with the yearning and the questions around what will happen if things get revealed. There are also two exclusive stories. Playing On continues the story starred in Hitting On, and given that is one of my personal standouts, I liked following them again. And Letting On has best friends faking a Domme/sub dynamic, which is a lot of fun.
While there are the drawbacks of a short story collection, along with the additional issues with some of the technical choices, Ali Williams’ style still brings a lot to the erotic/kinky romance subgenre that makes her stories stand out. Both Eden Bradley and Stefanie Simpson concur on this issue, with Bradley noting how Williams delves into the human psyche in her work, tapping into issues that resonate with readers, such as anxiety, pain, and loss, and Simpson praising the deeper meaning of kink to the individual couples and their relationships. While I didn’t feel fully connected on a character level, I can see how each of these stories can work on a personal, intimate level. And for that reason, I absolutely feel this collection is worth reading, even if you aren’t that into BDSM.