I am very puzzled by the readers who have rated this book with 5 stars. Now, it certainly has well-written descriptions of rural Virginia and good character development (though I can't quite determine how much of this is the book and how much should actually be credited to the TV series), but it is truly not 5-star 'amazing'. I had to stretch a little just to give it 3 stars. To each his own, I suppose.
That being said, there are several aspects of this book I really enjoyed. I liked seeing a more accurate description of rural living during the Depression era. (Let's face it, the TV show depicts the family as being way better off than reality would ever allow!) I liked getting to know this close-knit family who worked so hard for every inch, yet never resented that hard work and never expected to get anything without paying for it themselves. These are such good qualities (...and getting in shorter supply). I also liked, as I mentioned earlier, the descriptions of the countryside. I've spent some time in central Virginia; it is indeed beautiful.
As with many reviewers, I did not care for Claris. Many aspects of this character made me pull away and think, "Ugh. Not her again." Would a boy like Clay-Boy really have been pulled into the web of such a girl as this? Irritating, to say the least. And their little tryst on the mountain? Again, ugh. The book lost a whole star right there.
However, more than that, what I found most objectionable in this book was the way the parents and grandparents addressed each other most of the time. Yes, the daddy woke the mama every morning with a gentle, "Sweetheart." That was endearing. But what we see most times are terms such as, "Old Woman", "Old Fool", "Crazy Man", and so on. Now, I feel like I have just as much appreciation for sarcasm and tongue-in-cheek as the next person, but I also appreciate that you "draw more flies with honey than with vinegar". And it just seems to me that a loving family at this time in history, trying to raise their children right, with proper respect for their elders and for each other, would consider their words... or rather that the writer should consider his words. Then again, with all due respect, Mr. Hamner seems to have a much more colorful (ahem) vocabulary than I would tolerate in my house.
All in all, I am very pleased to have read this book, not so pleased to have paid for this book.