What do you think?
Rate this book
Lucy Anne Trotter #1
Asesinato en Rudhall Manor
A murder and a theft have been committed at Rudhall Manor. A box of jewels has vanished and Lord Sedley, a lusty old aristocrat, has been stabbed six times in the chest.
It is all very mysterious, and the Sedley family and the servants have decided that Miss Lucy Anne Trotter, a recently employed governess, is to blame for the unfortunate events.
The legendary and wickedly handsome Marquis, Lord William Adair, learns of the matter and decides to uncover the truth.
Lucy, however, has little faith in blue blooded creatures—even if they possess dashing good looks— and, accompanied by two naughty pugs and a moody raven, decides to investigate and unmask the killer herself.
But the hunt for the killer turns out to be far more complicated than she anticipates—what with snooty servants, warts in odd places, mixed up love affairs, agitated chickens and dreadful disguises ruining her plans.
Soon she begins to wonder if, for once, she is in over her head….
It is all very mysterious, and the Sedley family and the servants have decided that Miss Lucy Anne Trotter, a recently employed governess, is to blame for the unfortunate events.
The legendary and wickedly handsome Marquis, Lord William Adair, learns of the matter and decides to uncover the truth.
Lucy, however, has little faith in blue blooded creatures—even if they possess dashing good looks— and, accompanied by two naughty pugs and a moody raven, decides to investigate and unmask the killer herself.
But the hunt for the killer turns out to be far more complicated than she anticipates—what with snooty servants, warts in odd places, mixed up love affairs, agitated chickens and dreadful disguises ruining her plans.
Soon she begins to wonder if, for once, she is in over her head….
261 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 15, 2014
173 people are currently reading
288 people want to read
About the author
Anya Wylde
68 books304 followersAnya Wylde lives in Ireland along with her husband and a fat French poodle (now on a diet). She can cook a mean curry, and her idea of exercise is occasionally stretching her toes. She holds a degree in English literature and adores reading and writing.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 112 reviews
April 24, 2017
2.5★s
Miss Lucy Anne Trotter was finally leaving the orphanage and she was ecstatic to be going into the employ of Lord Sedley of Rudhall Manor to be the governess for the two young children there. The day Lucy was among the crowd of onlookers to spy a hot air balloon descending with Lord William Adair on board was the day her life changed once again.
Returning to the Manor she was struck by the fuss and chaos of the inhabitants – and when she spied Lord Adair in the parlour as well, she was almost struck dumb. With the jewellery having been stolen and Lord Sedley murdered, the household immediately decided Lucy was the person who had both murdered and stolen – never mind why she would return after a day out…
Though Lord Adair had said he would uncover the truth, Lucy decided she would clear her name by herself. But the mixture of a resident ghost, some pugs as well as various other animals and the animosity of the household; both staff and residents – Lucy was sure she was in over her head. What was she to do?
Murder at Rudhall Manor by Anya Wylde is both absurd and humorous. Light hearted and at times quite ridiculous, the characters that surrounded Lucy had little to no sense whatsoever. Peter seemed quite apart from the rest of his family; gentle and kind, but looked down on by everyone around him. I had thought Murder at Rudhall Manor would be similar to the author’s previous work I’ve read and enjoyed – The Fairweather Sisters series (starting with Penelope); The Wicked Wager – but it’s completely different. A light, cosy mystery which will be enjoyed by lovers of that particular genre.
With thanks to the author for my digital copy to read and review.
Miss Lucy Anne Trotter was finally leaving the orphanage and she was ecstatic to be going into the employ of Lord Sedley of Rudhall Manor to be the governess for the two young children there. The day Lucy was among the crowd of onlookers to spy a hot air balloon descending with Lord William Adair on board was the day her life changed once again.
Returning to the Manor she was struck by the fuss and chaos of the inhabitants – and when she spied Lord Adair in the parlour as well, she was almost struck dumb. With the jewellery having been stolen and Lord Sedley murdered, the household immediately decided Lucy was the person who had both murdered and stolen – never mind why she would return after a day out…
Though Lord Adair had said he would uncover the truth, Lucy decided she would clear her name by herself. But the mixture of a resident ghost, some pugs as well as various other animals and the animosity of the household; both staff and residents – Lucy was sure she was in over her head. What was she to do?
Murder at Rudhall Manor by Anya Wylde is both absurd and humorous. Light hearted and at times quite ridiculous, the characters that surrounded Lucy had little to no sense whatsoever. Peter seemed quite apart from the rest of his family; gentle and kind, but looked down on by everyone around him. I had thought Murder at Rudhall Manor would be similar to the author’s previous work I’ve read and enjoyed – The Fairweather Sisters series (starting with Penelope); The Wicked Wager – but it’s completely different. A light, cosy mystery which will be enjoyed by lovers of that particular genre.
With thanks to the author for my digital copy to read and review.
February 27, 2015
3.5
A wonderfully ridiculous murder mystery. If Monty Python's Flying Circus had decided to write one, you would have ended up with something close to this. Every single character is exaggerated, their most prominent traits and faults put on display for all to see. Not one character is left alone. Don't approach this expecting it to be a usual historical murder mystery.
I might need a new shelf for this book. It isn't exactly historical fiction since there are precious few things that mark this as belonging to a certain period. There is no romance so it can't be a historical romance. It definitely is a whodunnit mystery.
The first chapter introduces you to Miss Lucy Anne Trotter just leaving an orphanage to work as a governess at Lord Sedley's manor. From her former teacher's comments one can see that Lucy is no ordinary girl.
The story then skips to three months later with Lucy being accused of theft of family jewels (*snicker*) and it takes two chapters for you to find out that Lord Sedley was murdered too. The Sedleys have issues with priorities.
Fortunately, a handsome and perfect Lord Adair agreed to investigate or simply agree that Lucy is guilty. Since she isn't someone who would just stand there and wait for the noose to tighten around her neck, Lucy decides to help herself and starts her own investigation, but unlike any other mystery so far, she messes everything up. Spectacularly, I might say.
The problem Lord Adair and Lucy have is that everyone hated the lusty old man. He hardly left his wife, daughter and two sons, even servants in sad tears.
There is also a ghost in the manor ('Oh, smooth your hair. I don't like seeing it wave at the roof. It makes you look eerie.'), but if you think it would make much difference, you'd be mistaken. Apart from the two times the ghost helps her, Lucy has to help herself.
There are a couple of editing errors in the book, but not many ('Aunt Sedley shoved a finger in each year and whizzed out of the room,'), but not as many to take you out of the story.
I started suspecting who the killer is early because it was already used in another very famous short story, but it suited this mystery's exaggerations well.
This can't be the end of Miss Lucy Anne Trotter's adventures. I hope this won't be the only book about her.
A wonderfully ridiculous murder mystery. If Monty Python's Flying Circus had decided to write one, you would have ended up with something close to this. Every single character is exaggerated, their most prominent traits and faults put on display for all to see. Not one character is left alone. Don't approach this expecting it to be a usual historical murder mystery.
I might need a new shelf for this book. It isn't exactly historical fiction since there are precious few things that mark this as belonging to a certain period. There is no romance so it can't be a historical romance. It definitely is a whodunnit mystery.
The first chapter introduces you to Miss Lucy Anne Trotter just leaving an orphanage to work as a governess at Lord Sedley's manor. From her former teacher's comments one can see that Lucy is no ordinary girl.
'What else? Ah yes, do not rearrange Lord Sedley's library as you did for us when you were fifteen. It is not amusing. And don't even think of wriggling down a creeper.'Lucy reminds me of another hard to follow the rules character, Penelope. Two characters from Fairweather Sisters series are mentioned too (Falcon and Philbert Woodbead).
The story then skips to three months later with Lucy being accused of theft of family jewels (*snicker*) and it takes two chapters for you to find out that Lord Sedley was murdered too. The Sedleys have issues with priorities.
Fortunately, a handsome and perfect Lord Adair agreed to investigate or simply agree that Lucy is guilty. Since she isn't someone who would just stand there and wait for the noose to tighten around her neck, Lucy decides to help herself and starts her own investigation, but unlike any other mystery so far, she messes everything up. Spectacularly, I might say.
The problem Lord Adair and Lucy have is that everyone hated the lusty old man. He hardly left his wife, daughter and two sons, even servants in sad tears.
'Along with his commanding voice he had also possessed a lusty temperament, a lineage that could be traced back a hundred years, and blood so blue that one was amazed to see his red cheeks. He also happened to have been four feet, eleven inches tall.'One of Lucy's greatest problems is that she doesn't belong to either of the groups living in the manor.
There is also a ghost in the manor ('Oh, smooth your hair. I don't like seeing it wave at the roof. It makes you look eerie.'), but if you think it would make much difference, you'd be mistaken. Apart from the two times the ghost helps her, Lucy has to help herself.
There are a couple of editing errors in the book, but not many ('Aunt Sedley shoved a finger in each year and whizzed out of the room,'), but not as many to take you out of the story.
I started suspecting who the killer is early because it was already used in another very famous short story, but it suited this mystery's exaggerations well.
This can't be the end of Miss Lucy Anne Trotter's adventures. I hope this won't be the only book about her.
September 25, 2014
Synopsis
Two years after Lucy Trotter leaves the loveless but familiar confines of Brooding Cranesbill (the orphanage and school for underprivileged girls where she was raised), and takes employment as the nanny to the aristocratic Sedley family, Lucy is accused of murdering Lord Sedley, mainly because she is poor and without family. Lady Sedley calls upon the national hero, Lord Adair to solve the crime and prove that Lucy is the murderess, along with finding a set of family jewels that disappeared around the same time. Lucy is mesmerized by the unearthly beauty of Lord Adair, however, she knows that if she doesn't give him a helping hand solving the murder, there's a real chance she will end up hanging for a crime she didn't commit, while the real culprit walks away a free person. Lord Adair has his hands full solving a crime in a house full of strange characters, including a ghost, an animal obsessed male heir, and an amorous valet having an affair with the lady of the house.
Review
Anya Wylde has written another novel chock full of puns and slapstick humor that will make even the most hardened reader chuckle. Her heroine, Lucy is very lovable, because of her indomitable spirit and her atypical view of the world. Every character in this book is weird, which makes the distinguished recurring character of Lord Adair feel almost normal. The mystery was well done, and actually was a complete surprise to me.
While I enjoyed this book, I didn't find it as hilariously funny as her previous books. Sometimes, it even felt like Wylde was trying too hard to get laughs. There were a few odd moments that seemed so random; it was hard to be convinced they were being played for laughs. For some reason, the writing feels less cohesive. The story, while a shorter length novel, tends to meander a bit, prompting me to wonder when it would get to the climax.
It was a very pleasant surprise to see the character of Lord Adair again. His presence in previous books has endeared this reader and no doubt all of Wylde's other readers. I would have liked to see more chemistry between him and Lucy, although I am not sure this novel is meant to be a romance. It seems as though Lucy's attraction to him was one-sided, despite Lucy being highly endearing. This seemed like a missed romantic opportunity for Lord Adair's lonely character.
Lucy will appeal to readers who love characters like Bronte's Jane Eyre. She is a strong-minded, vibrant, unique and indefatigable young woman who deserves a happy ending, and no doubt readers will root for her. Her poor treatment by the family and servants alike inspired pathos in me as I read, and her antics made me laugh.
Overall, Murder at Rudhall Manor is a good book. The humor is quirky and entertaining, and the touch of the supernatural, teamed with a mystery that the readers have to work to solve, makes for a diverting read overall. A more cohesive storyline and a plot with greater momentum would have made this a close to flawless book. But even with its flaws, this was a fun read.
Overall rating: 3.5/5.0 stars
Reviewed for The Hope Chest Reviews: http://www.thcreviews.com/cgi-bin/vts...
Two years after Lucy Trotter leaves the loveless but familiar confines of Brooding Cranesbill (the orphanage and school for underprivileged girls where she was raised), and takes employment as the nanny to the aristocratic Sedley family, Lucy is accused of murdering Lord Sedley, mainly because she is poor and without family. Lady Sedley calls upon the national hero, Lord Adair to solve the crime and prove that Lucy is the murderess, along with finding a set of family jewels that disappeared around the same time. Lucy is mesmerized by the unearthly beauty of Lord Adair, however, she knows that if she doesn't give him a helping hand solving the murder, there's a real chance she will end up hanging for a crime she didn't commit, while the real culprit walks away a free person. Lord Adair has his hands full solving a crime in a house full of strange characters, including a ghost, an animal obsessed male heir, and an amorous valet having an affair with the lady of the house.
Review
Anya Wylde has written another novel chock full of puns and slapstick humor that will make even the most hardened reader chuckle. Her heroine, Lucy is very lovable, because of her indomitable spirit and her atypical view of the world. Every character in this book is weird, which makes the distinguished recurring character of Lord Adair feel almost normal. The mystery was well done, and actually was a complete surprise to me.
While I enjoyed this book, I didn't find it as hilariously funny as her previous books. Sometimes, it even felt like Wylde was trying too hard to get laughs. There were a few odd moments that seemed so random; it was hard to be convinced they were being played for laughs. For some reason, the writing feels less cohesive. The story, while a shorter length novel, tends to meander a bit, prompting me to wonder when it would get to the climax.
It was a very pleasant surprise to see the character of Lord Adair again. His presence in previous books has endeared this reader and no doubt all of Wylde's other readers. I would have liked to see more chemistry between him and Lucy, although I am not sure this novel is meant to be a romance. It seems as though Lucy's attraction to him was one-sided, despite Lucy being highly endearing. This seemed like a missed romantic opportunity for Lord Adair's lonely character.
Lucy will appeal to readers who love characters like Bronte's Jane Eyre. She is a strong-minded, vibrant, unique and indefatigable young woman who deserves a happy ending, and no doubt readers will root for her. Her poor treatment by the family and servants alike inspired pathos in me as I read, and her antics made me laugh.
Overall, Murder at Rudhall Manor is a good book. The humor is quirky and entertaining, and the touch of the supernatural, teamed with a mystery that the readers have to work to solve, makes for a diverting read overall. A more cohesive storyline and a plot with greater momentum would have made this a close to flawless book. But even with its flaws, this was a fun read.
Overall rating: 3.5/5.0 stars
Reviewed for The Hope Chest Reviews: http://www.thcreviews.com/cgi-bin/vts...
June 4, 2020
This novel was provided free of charge by the author in exchange for an honest review.
The characters in this book were interesting, all were unique and had certain qualities that made you confused. Lucy has had a rough life and is a brave soul. She knows that there is no way out, except to solve the murder. Lord Adair is a charming and frustrating hero, with flaws enough to match our heroine.
This book was fun and had me guessing to the end. A lovely light read that has an impressive deal of excitement packed within.
The characters in this book were interesting, all were unique and had certain qualities that made you confused. Lucy has had a rough life and is a brave soul. She knows that there is no way out, except to solve the murder. Lord Adair is a charming and frustrating hero, with flaws enough to match our heroine.
This book was fun and had me guessing to the end. A lovely light read that has an impressive deal of excitement packed within.
April 22, 2020
'A murder and a theft have been committed at Rudhall Manor. A box of jewels has vanished and Lord Sedley, a lusty old aristocrat, has been stabbed six times in the chest.
It is all very mysterious, and the Sedley family and the servants have decided that Miss Lucy Anne Trotter, a recently employed governess, is to blame for the unfortunate events.
The legendary and wickedly handsome Marquis, Lord William Adair, learns of the matter and decides to uncover the truth.
Lucy, however, has little faith in blue blooded creatures—even if they possess dashing good looks— and, accompanied by two naughty pugs and a moody raven, decides to investigate and unmask the killer herself.
But the hunt for the killer turns out to be far more complicated than she anticipates—what with snooty servants, warts in odd places, mixed up love affairs, agitated chickens and dreadful disguises ruining her plans.
Soon she begins to wonder if, for once, she is in over her head….'
__________________________________
1.5 stars, rounded down to 1 star.
A Murder at Rudhall Manor is a cozy mystery and the first book in Anya Wylde's A Lucy Anne Trotter Mystery series.
This book is absolutely absurd. It tries too hard to be fun and amusing, but instead completely overshoots into annoying and childish. The characters read more as charicatures than people. I really wish the author had done away with trying to make everything so ridiculous in her attempt to make it whimsical and funny. Had she just told the story, minus the absurdities, I would have enjoyed it much more and the mystery would have been much more engaging that way. If you are a fan of regency or historical cozy mysteries, give this one a pass. It takes place in the past and that's all that can be said for it. The voice, the customs, and the tone of the book are not inkeeping with the setting at all.
If this book wasn't so short, I never would have continued to read it through to the end. I regret and am a little mad that I read this book and I do not recommend it to anyone. Save your time and give this one a pass. I will not continue with this series, but I would probably consider reading another book by this author if she would only give up on going out of her way to make everything so unbelievably ridiculous.
_____
I read this book with my Kindle Unlimited membership. I chose to read this book after the author reached out to me. I voluntarily read and reviewed A Murder at Rudhall Manor by Anya Wylde, this is my honest review.
It is all very mysterious, and the Sedley family and the servants have decided that Miss Lucy Anne Trotter, a recently employed governess, is to blame for the unfortunate events.
The legendary and wickedly handsome Marquis, Lord William Adair, learns of the matter and decides to uncover the truth.
Lucy, however, has little faith in blue blooded creatures—even if they possess dashing good looks— and, accompanied by two naughty pugs and a moody raven, decides to investigate and unmask the killer herself.
But the hunt for the killer turns out to be far more complicated than she anticipates—what with snooty servants, warts in odd places, mixed up love affairs, agitated chickens and dreadful disguises ruining her plans.
Soon she begins to wonder if, for once, she is in over her head….'
__________________________________
1.5 stars, rounded down to 1 star.
A Murder at Rudhall Manor is a cozy mystery and the first book in Anya Wylde's A Lucy Anne Trotter Mystery series.
This book is absolutely absurd. It tries too hard to be fun and amusing, but instead completely overshoots into annoying and childish. The characters read more as charicatures than people. I really wish the author had done away with trying to make everything so ridiculous in her attempt to make it whimsical and funny. Had she just told the story, minus the absurdities, I would have enjoyed it much more and the mystery would have been much more engaging that way. If you are a fan of regency or historical cozy mysteries, give this one a pass. It takes place in the past and that's all that can be said for it. The voice, the customs, and the tone of the book are not inkeeping with the setting at all.
If this book wasn't so short, I never would have continued to read it through to the end. I regret and am a little mad that I read this book and I do not recommend it to anyone. Save your time and give this one a pass. I will not continue with this series, but I would probably consider reading another book by this author if she would only give up on going out of her way to make everything so unbelievably ridiculous.
_____
I read this book with my Kindle Unlimited membership. I chose to read this book after the author reached out to me. I voluntarily read and reviewed A Murder at Rudhall Manor by Anya Wylde, this is my honest review.
February 19, 2020
A murder and a theft have been committed at Rudhall Manor. A box of jewels has vanished and Lord Sedley has been stabbed six times in the chest. Miss Lucy Anne Trotter, a recently employed governess, is to blame for the unfortunate events. The legendary and wickedly handsome Marquis, Lord William Adair, learns of the matter and decides to uncover the truth.
Ms. Anya Wylde’s new novel is a historical mystery. (No romance - sadly, only something in prospect between Lucy and Lord Adair at the end.)
Lucy is meddlesome, tend to embarrass herself, and easily gets into uncomfortable situations. The story is told from her viewpoint, and I often was lost in her rhapsodic, fragmented thoughts and observations.
Lord Adair is a key figure in Penelope too. He is my favorite character from Ms. Wylde books, and he doesn’t disappoint here either. I would love to see him falling in love.
The story is great, though the plot has to fight a serious battle with the narration.
The situations are over-the-top comical, sometimes too exaggerated to enjoy them without raising an eyebrow.
My favorite book by the author is still Penelope, but Murder At Rudhall Manor could be very enjoyable too, if you are in the mood of a historical comedy with a pretty good mystery.
*I received a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
Ms. Anya Wylde’s new novel is a historical mystery. (No romance - sadly, only something in prospect between Lucy and Lord Adair at the end.)
Lucy is meddlesome, tend to embarrass herself, and easily gets into uncomfortable situations. The story is told from her viewpoint, and I often was lost in her rhapsodic, fragmented thoughts and observations.
Lord Adair is a key figure in Penelope too. He is my favorite character from Ms. Wylde books, and he doesn’t disappoint here either. I would love to see him falling in love.
The story is great, though the plot has to fight a serious battle with the narration.
The situations are over-the-top comical, sometimes too exaggerated to enjoy them without raising an eyebrow.
My favorite book by the author is still Penelope, but Murder At Rudhall Manor could be very enjoyable too, if you are in the mood of a historical comedy with a pretty good mystery.
*I received a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
July 8, 2014
Got the ebook from the writer herself. Yeay! Thanks Anya. I fell in love with her writing since Penelope and of course I jumped with excitement when she offered me the chance to read her newest book.
When I first saw the name Lord Adair as the main character, I was so excited... haha. Well, he has played quite a prominent role since Penelope, so no wonder if we want to know who will end up with the most dashing Lord Adair.
But, as it turned out, this story was purely about the murder mystery and not a love story with some mysteries. Lord Adair was invited by the younger son of the family to search for the murderer of his father Lord Sedley who was stabbed while taking his afternoon nap and the missing jewels.
Miss Lucy Trotter, the new governess was accused as the thief and also the murderer since she was the outsider and had only been at Rudhall Manor for three months. And everyone seemed to witness something or other which point out she as the most logical person to be the murderer.
Surprisingly, Lord Adair believed in her and asked her to believe in him to solve the mystery. Lucy wanted to believe in him, but seeing that no obvious action was taken by the lord, she decided to investigate the matters by herself. It was her very own life at the stake, after all.
Thus began the hilarious part when Lucy's trying to search for the murderer and the missing jewels. Disguising as a tree (complete with the branches and leaves!), hiding under the bed of Lady Sedley with the hope that she would reveal something to her lover and many others which usually ends up wrongly and she get caught spying, which deepened the household animosity towards her.
The (mis)adventures of Lucy were a little outrageous and over the top, but you couldn't help but to laugh out loud. The story was told totally from Lucy's perspective, so we really have no idea what form of investigation Lord Adair was using. The revealation of the real murderer was a bit dramatic and quite unexpected (well...at least by me).
All in all, still a good read and could cheer me up (coincidently, Ms Wylde's books came to me during a gloomy time, both times!). But I was a little distracted by Lucy's thoughts (which can go very far) and they did make the story go out of line. Maybe because Lucy was all alone, so she only have her own self (Aunt Sedley was not much help!) to rely on.
Hope that this series will continue with many other adventures. I am really looking forward to the odd pair's continuous mystery-solving adventures!
When I first saw the name Lord Adair as the main character, I was so excited... haha. Well, he has played quite a prominent role since Penelope, so no wonder if we want to know who will end up with the most dashing Lord Adair.
But, as it turned out, this story was purely about the murder mystery and not a love story with some mysteries. Lord Adair was invited by the younger son of the family to search for the murderer of his father Lord Sedley who was stabbed while taking his afternoon nap and the missing jewels.
Miss Lucy Trotter, the new governess was accused as the thief and also the murderer since she was the outsider and had only been at Rudhall Manor for three months. And everyone seemed to witness something or other which point out she as the most logical person to be the murderer.
Surprisingly, Lord Adair believed in her and asked her to believe in him to solve the mystery. Lucy wanted to believe in him, but seeing that no obvious action was taken by the lord, she decided to investigate the matters by herself. It was her very own life at the stake, after all.
Thus began the hilarious part when Lucy's trying to search for the murderer and the missing jewels. Disguising as a tree (complete with the branches and leaves!), hiding under the bed of Lady Sedley with the hope that she would reveal something to her lover and many others which usually ends up wrongly and she get caught spying, which deepened the household animosity towards her.
The (mis)adventures of Lucy were a little outrageous and over the top, but you couldn't help but to laugh out loud. The story was told totally from Lucy's perspective, so we really have no idea what form of investigation Lord Adair was using. The revealation of the real murderer was a bit dramatic and quite unexpected (well...at least by me).
All in all, still a good read and could cheer me up (coincidently, Ms Wylde's books came to me during a gloomy time, both times!). But I was a little distracted by Lucy's thoughts (which can go very far) and they did make the story go out of line. Maybe because Lucy was all alone, so she only have her own self (Aunt Sedley was not much help!) to rely on.
Hope that this series will continue with many other adventures. I am really looking forward to the odd pair's continuous mystery-solving adventures!
October 11, 2020
A bit too light and fluffy to be truly enjoyable but Lucy is a plucky heroine which makes for a breezy read. It's a snackish kind of book that you skim the entirety of it rather than get engrossed trying to catch all the clues and hidden details - the mystery is about as complex as an amoeba.
FYI there's no central romance either (though inklings of a partiality) so it's a mystery romp rather than a romantic mystery.
Rating: 3 green silk robes
Rereadablity: This series has two books so far – I probably won't re-read this one or read the next.
FYI there's no central romance either (though inklings of a partiality) so it's a mystery romp rather than a romantic mystery.
Rating: 3 green silk robes
Rereadablity: This series has two books so far – I probably won't re-read this one or read the next.
July 8, 2020
I previously read Penelope and found it odd but my favorite character from that book stars as the romantic lead in this series so I figured I'd give Murder at Rudhall Manor a try.
I guess it was worth the 99 cents. But it sure was bizarre.
On the positive side, I could definitely see improvements in the author's writing style. Scenes feel a little more polished. And having the book take place almost exclusively at Rudhall Manor meant I flinched less often at historical inaccuracies. Or, to be more precise, I was able to ignore the era the book was supposed to take place in with more ease.
But those two thing aside, I can't say I particularly enjoyed the novel. It tries too hard to be funny. The absurdities just keep coming until I was left wondering if this was supposed to be the fevered dreams of an insane asylum patient. Some scenes felt like they took forever--like the balloon landing --whereas others prove so sparse on details I was left flipping backwards trying to figure out how the heroine got herself into the predicament.
Characters that play semi-important parts at the beginning disappear as the book continues (mostly I'm thinking of the children.) And for a cozy mystery, it all but shoves the solution in your face by repeating everyone's alibis so often you finally go 'oh, duh' and then have to sit through another 30% of the book wanting to scream "IT IS ObViOuSlY so n so!" (And it was.)
I'm still stuck on the romance and I won't lie, if I had access to the next book in the series for free I would totally snatch it up, if only because train wrecks are morbidly fascinating. But I won't be paying money for the rest of the series.
I guess it was worth the 99 cents. But it sure was bizarre.
On the positive side, I could definitely see improvements in the author's writing style. Scenes feel a little more polished. And having the book take place almost exclusively at Rudhall Manor meant I flinched less often at historical inaccuracies. Or, to be more precise, I was able to ignore the era the book was supposed to take place in with more ease.
But those two thing aside, I can't say I particularly enjoyed the novel. It tries too hard to be funny. The absurdities just keep coming until I was left wondering if this was supposed to be the fevered dreams of an insane asylum patient. Some scenes felt like they took forever--like the balloon landing --whereas others prove so sparse on details I was left flipping backwards trying to figure out how the heroine got herself into the predicament.
Characters that play semi-important parts at the beginning disappear as the book continues (mostly I'm thinking of the children.) And for a cozy mystery, it all but shoves the solution in your face by repeating everyone's alibis so often you finally go 'oh, duh' and then have to sit through another 30% of the book wanting to scream "IT IS ObViOuSlY so n so!" (And it was.)
I'm still stuck on the romance and I won't lie, if I had access to the next book in the series for free I would totally snatch it up, if only because train wrecks are morbidly fascinating. But I won't be paying money for the rest of the series.
April 9, 2020
A great cozy mystery... first in a short series. Looking forward to the next!
August 4, 2016
Protagonist: 5/5
Secondary Characters: 5/5
Mystery: 5/5
Humor/Fun: 5/5
Pace: 5/5
*Ebook provided to me in exchange for my honest review*
I just love Ms Wylde's stories! And Murder At Rudhall Manor is no exception. It was a little outrageous, a little absurd and a little over-the-top, but a whole lot of fun. The dialog, the characters, the comical situations that Lucy found herself in, flow of the story, and the excellent mystery… I enjoyed it all completely. Another book for my Favorites Shelf! I highly, highly recommend this book, and any of Anya Wylde's earlier books. They never fail to renew my love of reading and bring me so much joy and happiness.
Secondary Characters: 5/5
Mystery: 5/5
Humor/Fun: 5/5
Pace: 5/5
*Ebook provided to me in exchange for my honest review*
I just love Ms Wylde's stories! And Murder At Rudhall Manor is no exception. It was a little outrageous, a little absurd and a little over-the-top, but a whole lot of fun. The dialog, the characters, the comical situations that Lucy found herself in, flow of the story, and the excellent mystery… I enjoyed it all completely. Another book for my Favorites Shelf! I highly, highly recommend this book, and any of Anya Wylde's earlier books. They never fail to renew my love of reading and bring me so much joy and happiness.
June 21, 2014
I've been lucky enough to read all of Anya Wylde's books. They have never disappointed me. When Anya offered me a copy of her newest book to read and review I jumped at the chance. I truly enjoyed this funny Regency murder mystery. Lucy was very entertaining, and slightly crazy. All the secondary characters were fun in a great over the top way. I would love to read more about Lord Adair. The mystery kept me guessing and managed to surprise me in the end. My only complaint is the end. What will Lucy's life be like in the future? I want more of Lucy's adventures.
I highly recommend this quick fun book. It is an excellent addition to Ms. Wylde's novels.
I highly recommend this quick fun book. It is an excellent addition to Ms. Wylde's novels.
August 18, 2017
.
This book definitely was not my cup of tea, even though I thoroughly enjoyed the book entitled 'Penelope' by the same author.
Author's imagination went waaaay below my tolerance level. The attempt at quirkiness delved into the ridiculous over and over and over again. I was so tempted not to complete my reading of it. However, I trudged my way through and was left wondering why I even bothered.
Would not recommend.
This book definitely was not my cup of tea, even though I thoroughly enjoyed the book entitled 'Penelope' by the same author.
Author's imagination went waaaay below my tolerance level. The attempt at quirkiness delved into the ridiculous over and over and over again. I was so tempted not to complete my reading of it. However, I trudged my way through and was left wondering why I even bothered.
Would not recommend.
April 28, 2020
Let’s turn the clock back to the early 19th
century Regency period. Here we will meet
Miss Lucy Anne Trotter as she leaves the
Brooding Cranesbill orphanage and school
for underprivileged girls.
This is where Lucy was raised. Now she is
going to Blackwell to become the governess
for Lord Robert Archibald Cuthbert Sedley’s
family. They reside in the Rudhall Manor,
a dark old mansion.
Lucy goes down into the village one afternoon.
She is in the village when an object comes
down from the sky. It is an air balloon
containing the Lord William Ellsworth Hartell
Adair, the Marquis of Lockwood.
After watching the balloon set down and
Lord Adair get out of the balloon, Lucy scurries
back to Rudhall Manor. Never expecting to
discover she has been accused of jewel theft
plus the murder of Lord Sedley.
What’s Lucy to do now?? She finds herself
alone as the family and servants all believe her
guilty. Lucy is the outsider to them and very
disposable as she came to them from an
orphanage.
Lucy also discovers that Lord Adair has been
asked to search for the murderer and to find
the missing jewels. He requests her trust that
he will uncover the culprit and clear her name.
But can she trust a blue blood?
Lucy decides to investigate which leads to all
sorts of humorous and disastrous shenanigans.
Having been alone, scared and lonely all her
years, Lucy has developed an very active
imagination which is vividly described
throughout the story.
The mystery is very well plotted and the characters
are artfully created while quirky, vain with attitudes.
Even the servants have snobbish attitudes. There
are mixed up supposed love affairs and plenty of
secrets within the walls.
The reader will also meet two feisty small pugs, a
moody raven named Spinoza, a red tailed baboon,
an crazy, cranky Egyptian crane plus chickens.
Aunt Sedley, the ghost communicates with Lucy
throughout the story.
An enjoyable read.
I volunteered to read Murder at Rudhall Manor.
Thanks to the author for the opportunity. My
opinion is voluntary and my own.
century Regency period. Here we will meet
Miss Lucy Anne Trotter as she leaves the
Brooding Cranesbill orphanage and school
for underprivileged girls.
This is where Lucy was raised. Now she is
going to Blackwell to become the governess
for Lord Robert Archibald Cuthbert Sedley’s
family. They reside in the Rudhall Manor,
a dark old mansion.
Lucy goes down into the village one afternoon.
She is in the village when an object comes
down from the sky. It is an air balloon
containing the Lord William Ellsworth Hartell
Adair, the Marquis of Lockwood.
After watching the balloon set down and
Lord Adair get out of the balloon, Lucy scurries
back to Rudhall Manor. Never expecting to
discover she has been accused of jewel theft
plus the murder of Lord Sedley.
What’s Lucy to do now?? She finds herself
alone as the family and servants all believe her
guilty. Lucy is the outsider to them and very
disposable as she came to them from an
orphanage.
Lucy also discovers that Lord Adair has been
asked to search for the murderer and to find
the missing jewels. He requests her trust that
he will uncover the culprit and clear her name.
But can she trust a blue blood?
Lucy decides to investigate which leads to all
sorts of humorous and disastrous shenanigans.
Having been alone, scared and lonely all her
years, Lucy has developed an very active
imagination which is vividly described
throughout the story.
The mystery is very well plotted and the characters
are artfully created while quirky, vain with attitudes.
Even the servants have snobbish attitudes. There
are mixed up supposed love affairs and plenty of
secrets within the walls.
The reader will also meet two feisty small pugs, a
moody raven named Spinoza, a red tailed baboon,
an crazy, cranky Egyptian crane plus chickens.
Aunt Sedley, the ghost communicates with Lucy
throughout the story.
An enjoyable read.
I volunteered to read Murder at Rudhall Manor.
Thanks to the author for the opportunity. My
opinion is voluntary and my own.
April 28, 2020
I was sent a copy of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review so here we go. After leaving the orphanage which she has called home for her whole life, Lucy Trotter transitions into the life of a governess. Three months after starting, she is accused of not only robbing the family, but murdering the lord of the manor. Only the combined investigative skills of herself and Lord Adair, a visiting investigator, can absolve her of the crime.
I liked the general plot of it, I think it had a fun twist that I didn't see coming. I did have a difficult time following the progression of events, it felt clunky and not as fluent as I prefer my mysteries to be. The exposition was too given, it should have been interpreted through actions. The character development was kind of awkward in the same way- too direct.
I did like the mystery though and I think that it has a lot of potential for the future. I don't know if a romance is on the horizon but I did like the chemistry between Lord Adair and Lucy, there was some potential there. I thought the "love" she had with Peter was weird and under-developed, but if there's romance later on, I won't be complaining. Thank you Anya for the chance to read this one!
This review and all my others can be found at: https://aworldshapedbybooks.blogspot....
June 9, 2020
This is a historical, cozy mystery, and comedy story. It takes place in England in the late 1800's. The story involves a balloon, animals, a wealthy family, theft, murder, and a ghost. The main character is an orphan named Lucy. She and a unusual detective, Lord Adair, try to solve the crimes. I liked Lord Adair more than her. The story is quite silly, at times ridiculous. Sometimes it is funny, but at other times it is annoying.
May 30, 2019
I really enjoyed it! Yes, it does have some ridiculous details (the animals especially), but those just make for a very entertaining read!
I had a hoot reading it, and I suspect we haven't seen the last of Lucy either!
I had a hoot reading it, and I suspect we haven't seen the last of Lucy either!
September 4, 2014
Hijinks for a young lady just out of the orphanage school room off to see the world and make her place in it. Who knew murder could make me snicker, laugh and snort like that? I swear if Alice's Wonderland got loose in an English country manor house then this story is what it would look like- insanely fun characters, situations, and exotic animals thrown in for bonus thrills. I thought this author's Madcap series was high amusement, but this latest release rivaled them. In fact, there was a cameo appearance of Philbert's poetry present.
The story opens with Miss Lucy Anne Trotter accepting the position as governess to the niece and nephew of Lord and Lady Sedley of Rudhall Manor. Just a few months in, Lucy is bored and wishes for something- anything- to happen, but what transpired next was not exactly her idea of pleasant excitement. After she watches the landing of a hot air balloon onto the village green operated by the famous Lord Adair in a shocking robe and slippers, she makes her way slowly back to the manor just knowing she would be scolded by Lady Sedley for being late. To her surprise, she is accused of stealing the Sedley jewels and if that were not enough she becomes the prime suspect in the murder of Lord Sedley. Lord Adair is asked to investigate with the priority being to find the jewels, but Lucy doesn't trust him so determines to do her own detecting since it is her neck in the noose.
So detect she does. Spying at keyholes, running about in disguise to stalk the family, ransacking rooms, avoiding Lord Peter's menagerie of pets, taking the accusing looks from the other servants and running across the suave, handsome Lord Adair at every turn when her detecting efforts get her in worse trouble reminding her that she can trust him. Maybe, but maybe not. There is still a murdering thief on the loose after all.
I found Lucy a splendid comic heroine and enjoyed getting the story narrated by her. She had this trick of blurting something off the wall out of her mouth when she wished for a subject change and she let her imagination run wild when she didn't want to hear someone prosing on in a boring fashion including the dashing yet enigmatic Lord Adair. For all the craziness going on, there was still a strong plot thread that kept moving through it all. It's not a terribly difficult murder mystery, but it offers a bit of a challenge with Lucy's own antics causing the distractions and the fact that pretty much everyone had motive and somewhat the opportunity. The other characters were so colorful and engaging too even the ones that weren't likeable. Lucy's detecting methods were off the hook. The only niggle I really had was that the story ended abruptly. It was finished in the sense that the case was over, but I guess I was waiting for a bit something more than what did finish the last page. Maybe there will be more installments as Lucy hones her detecting talents and I would love more from the capable and charismatic Lord Adair.
All in all, it was a delight through and through. Those who enjoy their mysteries laced with humor and don't mind a historic backdrop should grab this one up for a light fun cozy mystery that will have you laughing in no time.
My thanks to the author for the opportunity to read this story in exchange for an honest review.
The story opens with Miss Lucy Anne Trotter accepting the position as governess to the niece and nephew of Lord and Lady Sedley of Rudhall Manor. Just a few months in, Lucy is bored and wishes for something- anything- to happen, but what transpired next was not exactly her idea of pleasant excitement. After she watches the landing of a hot air balloon onto the village green operated by the famous Lord Adair in a shocking robe and slippers, she makes her way slowly back to the manor just knowing she would be scolded by Lady Sedley for being late. To her surprise, she is accused of stealing the Sedley jewels and if that were not enough she becomes the prime suspect in the murder of Lord Sedley. Lord Adair is asked to investigate with the priority being to find the jewels, but Lucy doesn't trust him so determines to do her own detecting since it is her neck in the noose.
So detect she does. Spying at keyholes, running about in disguise to stalk the family, ransacking rooms, avoiding Lord Peter's menagerie of pets, taking the accusing looks from the other servants and running across the suave, handsome Lord Adair at every turn when her detecting efforts get her in worse trouble reminding her that she can trust him. Maybe, but maybe not. There is still a murdering thief on the loose after all.
I found Lucy a splendid comic heroine and enjoyed getting the story narrated by her. She had this trick of blurting something off the wall out of her mouth when she wished for a subject change and she let her imagination run wild when she didn't want to hear someone prosing on in a boring fashion including the dashing yet enigmatic Lord Adair. For all the craziness going on, there was still a strong plot thread that kept moving through it all. It's not a terribly difficult murder mystery, but it offers a bit of a challenge with Lucy's own antics causing the distractions and the fact that pretty much everyone had motive and somewhat the opportunity. The other characters were so colorful and engaging too even the ones that weren't likeable. Lucy's detecting methods were off the hook. The only niggle I really had was that the story ended abruptly. It was finished in the sense that the case was over, but I guess I was waiting for a bit something more than what did finish the last page. Maybe there will be more installments as Lucy hones her detecting talents and I would love more from the capable and charismatic Lord Adair.
All in all, it was a delight through and through. Those who enjoy their mysteries laced with humor and don't mind a historic backdrop should grab this one up for a light fun cozy mystery that will have you laughing in no time.
My thanks to the author for the opportunity to read this story in exchange for an honest review.
May 13, 2015
Though quite silly, I found Murder At Rudhall Manor to be a good and entertaining story. There’s a murderer on the loose at Rudhall Manor but it’s nearly impossible to take any of it seriously with the over the top goings on. Naturally, the dysfunctional Sedley family is quick to blame our charming governess, Miss Lucy Trotter, though they have not one shred of proof, other than their obvious dislike and prejudice against the hired help, though she has yet to be paid for her work. Unfortunately for Miss Trotter, the rest of the household staff soon begins to believe she is the culprit and go out of their way to make her feel alone and without any allies. The arrival of Lord Adair does not seem to be of any help either as his investigation does not expose the killer either. Lucy starts to seriously fear that her neck will soon be in a noose. The arrival of Aunt Sedley provides a welcome distraction and Lucy agrees to look into the murder to find the real killer, but Aunt Sedley is not much help, being dead herself and a ghost. Lucy embarks on a madcap chase through the house and grounds looking for clues that will reveal the true identity of the killer before she runs out of time.
I enjoyed meeting Lucy and found her to be very brave and full of spunk, which is a rarity for women in this time period. Growing up in an orphanage has taught Lucy to rely on her own wits and intelligence to get through life. When she takes up the post of governess at Rudhall Manor, she has no idea that her wits and intelligence is what she has most going for her to keep her out of the hangman’s noose. I admired her tenacity to investigate the murder while facing animosity and opposition from everyone else around her. I found Lord Adair to be a very strange character, starting with his bizarre entrance by hot air balloon into the story. He’s quite eccentric and I suspect a little bit insane, but he and Lucy make a great, though odd, couple. What I found interesting was though Lucy found him to be very attractive, there was absolutely no hint of romance between them. This will make sense if you have read Penelope, though I am curious to see what they get up to next. I did not care for the living members of the Sedley family. Though she wasn’t much help to Lucy in her investigations, I thought Aunt Sedley was very entertaining. It’s too bad the rest of the family wasn’t as likable.
The story moves at a very good pace, keeping me engaged and interested in the story enough to want to know what happens next. A major twist at the end of the book with the reveal of the villain, which took me completely by surprise, which shouldn’t have come as a surprise since this story doesn’t follow the expected direction at any time.
My Final Verdict: Murder At Rudhall Manor will appeal to fans of light mysteries or quirky storylines and characters. Overall, this is an enjoyable story that will keep the reader entertained for several hours.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of Murder At Rudhall Manor from the author in exchange for an honest review.
I enjoyed meeting Lucy and found her to be very brave and full of spunk, which is a rarity for women in this time period. Growing up in an orphanage has taught Lucy to rely on her own wits and intelligence to get through life. When she takes up the post of governess at Rudhall Manor, she has no idea that her wits and intelligence is what she has most going for her to keep her out of the hangman’s noose. I admired her tenacity to investigate the murder while facing animosity and opposition from everyone else around her. I found Lord Adair to be a very strange character, starting with his bizarre entrance by hot air balloon into the story. He’s quite eccentric and I suspect a little bit insane, but he and Lucy make a great, though odd, couple. What I found interesting was though Lucy found him to be very attractive, there was absolutely no hint of romance between them. This will make sense if you have read Penelope, though I am curious to see what they get up to next. I did not care for the living members of the Sedley family. Though she wasn’t much help to Lucy in her investigations, I thought Aunt Sedley was very entertaining. It’s too bad the rest of the family wasn’t as likable.
The story moves at a very good pace, keeping me engaged and interested in the story enough to want to know what happens next. A major twist at the end of the book with the reveal of the villain, which took me completely by surprise, which shouldn’t have come as a surprise since this story doesn’t follow the expected direction at any time.
My Final Verdict: Murder At Rudhall Manor will appeal to fans of light mysteries or quirky storylines and characters. Overall, this is an enjoyable story that will keep the reader entertained for several hours.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of Murder At Rudhall Manor from the author in exchange for an honest review.
August 20, 2017
Lucy Trotter has just left the orphanage to become a governess when a bunch of random stuff happens. Everything is described in such convoluted ways that I was never sure what exactly was happening (a balloon lands? maybe?) and Lucy was such an unlikely character that I didn't care what she discovered or did.
May 24, 2016
I recently read /reread two other book by this author and based on the sample decided to read this one. But it didn't do it for me. I didn't embrace any of the characters, even the supposed heroine was pretty much unlikable. It is a who done it where I didn't care who did it.
February 1, 2017
Funny mystery, though I had it figured out pretty early. The main character was a bit unbelievable, and annoying, but her antics were comedic, even if a bit useless. I prefer a bit more mystery in my mystery, but as a comedy, it was just fine.
July 1, 2017
A complete waste of time! This deserves a -1 rating.
April 17, 2020
Historical Murder Mystery, Cozy Mystery
“It won’t be easy,” Miss Summer repeated firmly, “for the world to adjust to your presence. England will have to shift around, make space, adapt a little, stand on its toenails and stay alert to be able to absorb someone like you... It may happen... Miracles are not unheard of.”
Lucy Anne Trotter has turned 18 and now she must vacate the orphanage that she has grown up in. She has been procured a job as a governess at Rudhall Manor. Three months into her position and the Lord Sedley is found stabbed to death in his bed chamber and a jewel necklace is stolen.
“Lord Robert Archibald Sedley, Lucy recalled, had been a belligerent fellow. A rotten creature who had been bottle headed substantially cracked and had possessed a voice that seemed to emerge from deep within his intestines to break through his cruel lips in a bellowing, reverberating sound.
A sound that had shaken the very air surrounding him and had held enough power to send a weak-willed creature shooting a few feet into the air in absolute terror.
Along with his commanding voice, he had also possessed a lusty temperament, a lineage that could be traced back a hundred years, and blood so blue that one was amazed to see his red cheeks.
He also happened to have been four feet, eleven inches tall.”
Everyone is pointing the finger at Lucy as the culprit. The family of course is sticking together and so are the servants, since Lucy is the newest addition to the household, she is the odd man out. A visiting Lord Adair, who has a reputation for solving crimes such as these has appointed himself investigator and advises no one shall leave the house until the crime is solved and the murderer discovered. Lucy however trusts no one and begins investigating herself, otherwise it is the gallows for her for sure.
With so many suspects, all having a motive to murder the horrible man, who could have actually done it?
This book was not my cup tea. The story line was good, your average murder mystery, xx number of people in house, only one way into to the room, who committed the crime? Meant to be humorous, however to me it came across more ridiculous. Parts of the book went off on random tangents by the main character and I found myself getting lost and having to re-read in order to try and understand what just happened and why that was important. I feel like the author was trying to add body to the character but I just didn’t care for it. Speaking of the the main character, she becomes some what of a detective to find out who committed the crime, however she is more childish than anything. She is suppose to be an 18 year old young woman but acts more like a 12 year old girl.
“She kicked the table.
“Stop it. I told you it is a hundred years old. It is fragile. Besides, young ladies shouldn’t go around kicking things. It is not done.”
“Not done? Now you sound like an antique piece.” She peeked at him from underneath her lashes and once again kicked the table.
His lips pursed in disapproval.
“I am sorry,” she said, feeling guilty. “I am not sure why I did that. It was almost as if an invisible imp grasped my foot and threw it at the table.”
“I see.”
“You do?” She asked in wonder. “I don’t see how you could, though, because I said it and I don’t see what I said. Then how could you see it? Let me explain more clearly-“
“Leave the investigations to me, “ he interrupted.
“You already said that,” she told her feet.
“Look at me,” he ordered.
She slowly lifted her chin, crossed her eyes and stuck her tongue out.”
A mix between cozy mystery and a historical mystery like Agatha Christie but falling short on both. It reminded me more of the old Scooby-do cartoons. I liked them as a child but not so funny now as an adult.
This was not a bad book just not for me. If you like silly mysteries, then this is for you.
“It won’t be easy,” Miss Summer repeated firmly, “for the world to adjust to your presence. England will have to shift around, make space, adapt a little, stand on its toenails and stay alert to be able to absorb someone like you... It may happen... Miracles are not unheard of.”
Lucy Anne Trotter has turned 18 and now she must vacate the orphanage that she has grown up in. She has been procured a job as a governess at Rudhall Manor. Three months into her position and the Lord Sedley is found stabbed to death in his bed chamber and a jewel necklace is stolen.
“Lord Robert Archibald Sedley, Lucy recalled, had been a belligerent fellow. A rotten creature who had been bottle headed substantially cracked and had possessed a voice that seemed to emerge from deep within his intestines to break through his cruel lips in a bellowing, reverberating sound.
A sound that had shaken the very air surrounding him and had held enough power to send a weak-willed creature shooting a few feet into the air in absolute terror.
Along with his commanding voice, he had also possessed a lusty temperament, a lineage that could be traced back a hundred years, and blood so blue that one was amazed to see his red cheeks.
He also happened to have been four feet, eleven inches tall.”
Everyone is pointing the finger at Lucy as the culprit. The family of course is sticking together and so are the servants, since Lucy is the newest addition to the household, she is the odd man out. A visiting Lord Adair, who has a reputation for solving crimes such as these has appointed himself investigator and advises no one shall leave the house until the crime is solved and the murderer discovered. Lucy however trusts no one and begins investigating herself, otherwise it is the gallows for her for sure.
With so many suspects, all having a motive to murder the horrible man, who could have actually done it?
This book was not my cup tea. The story line was good, your average murder mystery, xx number of people in house, only one way into to the room, who committed the crime? Meant to be humorous, however to me it came across more ridiculous. Parts of the book went off on random tangents by the main character and I found myself getting lost and having to re-read in order to try and understand what just happened and why that was important. I feel like the author was trying to add body to the character but I just didn’t care for it. Speaking of the the main character, she becomes some what of a detective to find out who committed the crime, however she is more childish than anything. She is suppose to be an 18 year old young woman but acts more like a 12 year old girl.
“She kicked the table.
“Stop it. I told you it is a hundred years old. It is fragile. Besides, young ladies shouldn’t go around kicking things. It is not done.”
“Not done? Now you sound like an antique piece.” She peeked at him from underneath her lashes and once again kicked the table.
His lips pursed in disapproval.
“I am sorry,” she said, feeling guilty. “I am not sure why I did that. It was almost as if an invisible imp grasped my foot and threw it at the table.”
“I see.”
“You do?” She asked in wonder. “I don’t see how you could, though, because I said it and I don’t see what I said. Then how could you see it? Let me explain more clearly-“
“Leave the investigations to me, “ he interrupted.
“You already said that,” she told her feet.
“Look at me,” he ordered.
She slowly lifted her chin, crossed her eyes and stuck her tongue out.”
A mix between cozy mystery and a historical mystery like Agatha Christie but falling short on both. It reminded me more of the old Scooby-do cartoons. I liked them as a child but not so funny now as an adult.
This was not a bad book just not for me. If you like silly mysteries, then this is for you.
May 9, 2020
Miss Lucy Ann Trotter was orphaned as a young child and raised and educated in an orphanage. Now grown, she has taken her first position as a governess at the home of Lord Sedley. Lucy is optimistic and imaginative and has a wonderful gift for description. However, she is also the perfect suspect when some jewels are stolen and Lord Sedley is found murdered.
The family has banded together and so have the servants leaving Lucy with no one to take her side except the handsome and desirable Lord William Adair who is famous for his investigative abilities . He enters the scene via hot air balloon and clad in his dressing gown after an unexpected flight.
Lucy decides that Lord Adair will likely side with the aristocratic family and thus has to investigate herself if she wants to avoid the hangman's noose. She enters into a contest with Lord Adair as to who will discover the murderer first.
Lucy's investigations take her to all of the family's rooms to search for the missing jewels and lead her to discover that the widow is having an affair with a valet and the eldest daughter is also romancing the valet. The eldest son seems too involved with collecting animals including a baboon, a crane, a raven, and a couple of pugs to have had anything to do with his father's death. While the youngest son seems to involved in drinking and gambling and chasing women to have any role in his father's death.
Lucy's investigations include disguising herself as a tree to follow after the widow and her eldest to try to overhear them conspiring and impersonating a chicken in the hopes that the chickens will get off their nests to reveal stolen jewels. Assisting Lucy in her investigations is the family ghost who is a bit distracted by her romance with another local ghost.
The story was engaging and silly. The descriptions were humorous and Lucy's actions comical. Readers looking for slapstick humor in their mysteries will enjoy Lucy's first case.
The family has banded together and so have the servants leaving Lucy with no one to take her side except the handsome and desirable Lord William Adair who is famous for his investigative abilities . He enters the scene via hot air balloon and clad in his dressing gown after an unexpected flight.
Lucy decides that Lord Adair will likely side with the aristocratic family and thus has to investigate herself if she wants to avoid the hangman's noose. She enters into a contest with Lord Adair as to who will discover the murderer first.
Lucy's investigations take her to all of the family's rooms to search for the missing jewels and lead her to discover that the widow is having an affair with a valet and the eldest daughter is also romancing the valet. The eldest son seems too involved with collecting animals including a baboon, a crane, a raven, and a couple of pugs to have had anything to do with his father's death. While the youngest son seems to involved in drinking and gambling and chasing women to have any role in his father's death.
Lucy's investigations include disguising herself as a tree to follow after the widow and her eldest to try to overhear them conspiring and impersonating a chicken in the hopes that the chickens will get off their nests to reveal stolen jewels. Assisting Lucy in her investigations is the family ghost who is a bit distracted by her romance with another local ghost.
The story was engaging and silly. The descriptions were humorous and Lucy's actions comical. Readers looking for slapstick humor in their mysteries will enjoy Lucy's first case.
May 3, 2020
Lucy Anne Trotter was raised and educated at Brooding Cranesbill Orphanage and is now at ther first job as a governess for the Sedley family at Rudhall estate.
When a box of family jewels turns up missing and Lord Sedley is found dead of six stab wounds, the family decides Lucy is the guilty party. She is poor and has no family so she is a convenient choice.
Lord William Ellsworth Hartell Adair, the Marquis of Lockwood, international spy, renown national hero, the savior of the King and Regent, and the most handsome man in England has recently dropped in to the village of Blackwell…literally by hot air balloon.
When Lord Adair hears of Sir Sedley’s murder from the village doctor, who was given a silver tea set to keep his mouth shut, he immediately shows up at Rudhall to solve the crime. The thing that really interests him is the family’s attitude about the murder and theft. They only told Adair of the theft. When Lucy is accused of murder, Lord Adair becomes more intrigued.
This is a madcap adventure set in the Regency era. It has the ladies lusting after Lord Adair. Adair being mysteriously alluring, gentlemanly and dashing. The staff being loyal to the family, but still having secrets and schemes of their own. Clandestine meetings behind close doors. Bravery and determindness in finding what actually happened and who committed the murder by Lucy’s investigating and spying. There are healthy doses of clumsiness, possible solutions that are nowhere possible to be true.
Adair may be dashing and brilliant, but Lucy is brave, upbeat and determined. The combination works well and at a good pace. Pure entertainment!
I was given the opportunity to read this book by Anya Wylde, the author, and I thank her for it.
When a box of family jewels turns up missing and Lord Sedley is found dead of six stab wounds, the family decides Lucy is the guilty party. She is poor and has no family so she is a convenient choice.
Lord William Ellsworth Hartell Adair, the Marquis of Lockwood, international spy, renown national hero, the savior of the King and Regent, and the most handsome man in England has recently dropped in to the village of Blackwell…literally by hot air balloon.
When Lord Adair hears of Sir Sedley’s murder from the village doctor, who was given a silver tea set to keep his mouth shut, he immediately shows up at Rudhall to solve the crime. The thing that really interests him is the family’s attitude about the murder and theft. They only told Adair of the theft. When Lucy is accused of murder, Lord Adair becomes more intrigued.
This is a madcap adventure set in the Regency era. It has the ladies lusting after Lord Adair. Adair being mysteriously alluring, gentlemanly and dashing. The staff being loyal to the family, but still having secrets and schemes of their own. Clandestine meetings behind close doors. Bravery and determindness in finding what actually happened and who committed the murder by Lucy’s investigating and spying. There are healthy doses of clumsiness, possible solutions that are nowhere possible to be true.
Adair may be dashing and brilliant, but Lucy is brave, upbeat and determined. The combination works well and at a good pace. Pure entertainment!
I was given the opportunity to read this book by Anya Wylde, the author, and I thank her for it.
July 14, 2020
This book is listed in Goodreads as a Regency murder mystery. I felt it had all the elements of a cozy mystery so sent a question to the author and she agreed that it is a cozy mystery.
The mystery occurs in early 19th century Great Britain. Lucy Anne Trotter was sent to Lord Robert Archibald Sedley's family home to be the governess. The home is called Rudhall Manor and is an old dark mansion. When Lord Sedley is found stabbed to death the family blames Lucy without any proof. They also believe she has stolen some items. Lucy is in the village when a hot air balloon descends with Lord William Adair aboard. Lord Adair is the Marquis of Lockwood, an international spy, a hero, and solves crimes. He is there to find the killer and Lucy is totally charmed by him. She feels she has to find the murderer and clear her name. The members of the family ae well described. The younger son has many animals that he cares for. The Lady of the house has been having an affair with the butler. There are many other various servents and an older brother and sister. Lucy even makes herself to look like a tree to investigate. Her misadventures and her searching for clues can be funny at times. She even makes a bet with Lord Adair as to who will solve the mystery first.
I loved the story and have started to read the next book in the series.
The mystery occurs in early 19th century Great Britain. Lucy Anne Trotter was sent to Lord Robert Archibald Sedley's family home to be the governess. The home is called Rudhall Manor and is an old dark mansion. When Lord Sedley is found stabbed to death the family blames Lucy without any proof. They also believe she has stolen some items. Lucy is in the village when a hot air balloon descends with Lord William Adair aboard. Lord Adair is the Marquis of Lockwood, an international spy, a hero, and solves crimes. He is there to find the killer and Lucy is totally charmed by him. She feels she has to find the murderer and clear her name. The members of the family ae well described. The younger son has many animals that he cares for. The Lady of the house has been having an affair with the butler. There are many other various servents and an older brother and sister. Lucy even makes herself to look like a tree to investigate. Her misadventures and her searching for clues can be funny at times. She even makes a bet with Lord Adair as to who will solve the mystery first.
I loved the story and have started to read the next book in the series.
April 20, 2020
This was a cute historical (old England) cozy mystery with a satisfying ending. There’s the actual murder, theft of jewels, and a flippant ghost who only Lucy can see and hear. But…the writing was almost slapstick at times—too over the top. The character of Lucy actually reminded me of another Lucy—as in “I Love Lucy” and the antics that Lucy would often get into. The imagery was good if also a little over the top. The story is light-hearted though often devolves into the ridiculous (Hey Lucy!).
What I liked: the writing is light and funny though slapstick. Lucy is lovable if a bit impulsive and daft. Though I’m not a huge fan of slapstick comedy, the writing had me smiling and even laughing at times – always a good thing. And the mystery part of the story was not bad with a surprising ending (sort of). And I loved Aunt Sedley (the ghost). She was quite the character as well.
What I didn’t like: Lucy kept telling the good Lord Adair how accomplished she was at a variety of things, but we never see that side of her. All we see are the antics.
Recommendation: If you like over-the-top slapstick humor with your mystery, definitely pick this one up. It’s absurdly fun.
I received a copy of this book from the author.
What I liked: the writing is light and funny though slapstick. Lucy is lovable if a bit impulsive and daft. Though I’m not a huge fan of slapstick comedy, the writing had me smiling and even laughing at times – always a good thing. And the mystery part of the story was not bad with a surprising ending (sort of). And I loved Aunt Sedley (the ghost). She was quite the character as well.
What I didn’t like: Lucy kept telling the good Lord Adair how accomplished she was at a variety of things, but we never see that side of her. All we see are the antics.
Recommendation: If you like over-the-top slapstick humor with your mystery, definitely pick this one up. It’s absurdly fun.
I received a copy of this book from the author.
April 22, 2023
Novela totalmente prescindible, de hecho, hasta me ha aburrido bastante en algunos momentos.
La protagonista es Lucy Anne Trotter, una institutriz recién salida de un internado que no cuaja en la familia aristocrática venida a menos en la que trabaja debido a su actitud irreverente e infantil. Cuando el señor de la casa muere apuñalado y las joyas de la familia desaparecen, todas las sospechas de familiares y sirvientes recaerán sobre ella. Lord Adair, un aristócrata bien relacionado y considerado un héroe nacional, asumirá la investigación, pero Lucy también comenzará sus propias pesquisas para demostrar su inocencia.
Elegí la novela porque me pareció simpática la portada y me gustó el gancho del humor. Sin embargo, el humor es insulso e infantil, nada ingenioso; la investigación de Lucy es superficial y absurda; la trama es sí no tiene mucho recorrido y el desenlace no está mal hilado pero tampoco es para tirar cohetes. He terminado la novela porque es corta, pero aunque es el inicio de una serie, no creo que caiga con la segunda.
La protagonista es Lucy Anne Trotter, una institutriz recién salida de un internado que no cuaja en la familia aristocrática venida a menos en la que trabaja debido a su actitud irreverente e infantil. Cuando el señor de la casa muere apuñalado y las joyas de la familia desaparecen, todas las sospechas de familiares y sirvientes recaerán sobre ella. Lord Adair, un aristócrata bien relacionado y considerado un héroe nacional, asumirá la investigación, pero Lucy también comenzará sus propias pesquisas para demostrar su inocencia.
Elegí la novela porque me pareció simpática la portada y me gustó el gancho del humor. Sin embargo, el humor es insulso e infantil, nada ingenioso; la investigación de Lucy es superficial y absurda; la trama es sí no tiene mucho recorrido y el desenlace no está mal hilado pero tampoco es para tirar cohetes. He terminado la novela porque es corta, pero aunque es el inicio de una serie, no creo que caiga con la segunda.
February 14, 2020
I had a blast with this one!
Anya Wylde's writing style really captured my attention and sustained it. It's rare for me to read a historical centered on humor. Sure, there are romances that have a bit of humor but this one is about 80% funny.
What I liked most is I wasn't able to guess the culprit. Ms. Wylde really thought on this and presented a lot of suspects. I also liked how weird and funny our heroine is but she got things done.
The breath of fresh air is Lord Adair and he has this sense of being a protector when he's around that made the reader (myself) feel at ease. There are a lot of twists and turns here that would definitely keep you turning page after page.
Anya Wylde's writing style really captured my attention and sustained it. It's rare for me to read a historical centered on humor. Sure, there are romances that have a bit of humor but this one is about 80% funny.
What I liked most is I wasn't able to guess the culprit. Ms. Wylde really thought on this and presented a lot of suspects. I also liked how weird and funny our heroine is but she got things done.
The breath of fresh air is Lord Adair and he has this sense of being a protector when he's around that made the reader (myself) feel at ease. There are a lot of twists and turns here that would definitely keep you turning page after page.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 112 reviews