3.75 stars. There is not a lot of wlw fantasy out there so I’m always happy to see a new book appear. In this case it was a debut book meaning a new author of fantasy, which makes me double happy. This book was not without some (debut) bumps, but I enjoyed reading it and will keep my eye on this author for future books.
The protagonists Barra and Silvi are part of two rivaling groups of people. Both have their own language and customs, which are vastly different. Barra is a Neamairtese, which are very free-spirited nomadic people that possess magic. Silvi on the other hand is a Svekard, they are loud, proud and strong (they reminded me of Vikings), they are afraid of magic and their biggest enemies are the Neamairtese. Need I say this is an enemies to lovers storyline? Karter put a lot of effort in getting us acquainted with Silvi and Barra, to understand them individually as well as their cultures and their personal growth throughout the book was very well done. I thought it was amazing how they actually communicated as they don’t speak each other’s language. In terms of romance I didn’t immediately see the match because they are so very different, but I was intrigued anyway. The switch from hate to intense love was a bit too fast for my liking, even with the fated love/mate trope, but I did like them as a couple in the end.
The big issue I had, however, was the pacing. It was slow at moments and I got an info dump feeling at times. The cultures are explained in great detail and especially their gods and history, and while interesting, it was a bit much at times. I’m also not a fan of stories within stories of which there were a lot.
And now I’m going to contradict myself, because in the current format I thought it was too slow at times and could be shortened, but I also kept thinking: “this is too short”, it might have been better as a duology or even a trilogy. The format of a romance was chosen and all focus is placed on the two MCs and their thoughts and feelings. In fact, for a fantasy book there was not a whole lot of action, while there is a lot happening, especially in the second half of the book. Many of these events were sort of fast forwarded and described without much detail and because of that I didn’t connect with these parts of the story, but if I could have seen the impact of these events with more details and especially 1 or more POVs from the people affected, I think I would be hooked to these parts of the story as well. That would have meant that the romance format would be traded for an epic fantasy with a romance storyline, which was probably not the intention of the author, but I’m throwing it out there anyway.
Despite some bumps I enjoyed reading this very much (I mean, look at my rambling, this book made me think, that’s telling) and I’m curious to see what Karter will write in the future. If you like fantasy, and don’t mind slightly heavy-handed cultural descriptions, especially of their many gods and deities, this is a book to read.
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.