3.5*
Carsen Taite is one of the best at writing stories with lawyers and judges and plots involving complex cases and the judicial system. And this story showcases that very well 👌🏻
So, this story is about Franco, a lawyer, and Nina, a judge. They both met during high school and college and were college sweethearts and the love of each other’s lives until, out of nowhere (but not really, because we learn more about what happened to Franco and her dad and why she did what she did), Franco broke up with Nina and then they went their separate ways.
Two decades later, as a favor to an old friend, Franco goes back to her hometown, Dallas, where Nina is a judge now. Circumstances make Nina the judge in charge of the case Franco’s there to see if she’ll take or not, but that day a shootout takes place in Nina’s courtroom and they both see their lives flash before their eyes and all the regrets they have and how their story is very much still unresolved. And after that, it’s just them trying to solve the case and dealing with their old and new feelings.
I was enjoying this book immensely until the end, to be honest. I was legit flipping the pages back and forth to try and see if I had missed a chapter somewhere… Because the book ended out of nowhere 😩 And I lowkey feel cheated, because I was super invested in their story and after all the hard times and all the “let’s just be friends” going on between Franco and Nina, that ending felt super rushed and it feels like another chapter is needed to conclude things. I legit need an epilogue or something so I can get closure and actually see them getting together and doing stuff together and not just an “ending” with them basically being “only friends” throughout the whole book and in the end, after a somewhat threatening event, they get all cuddly and one of them simply asks the other if they are a “thing” and the other says they are. Like, after being super invested, my romantic self needs more than this. An epilogue would’ve made a very big difference and it would’ve given the readers more closure, but that’s just my opinion.
Anyways… Overall, the story is super good and interesting and I loved reading about the ins and outs of all things law and being able to feel the tension between Nina and Franco. But that ending really dampened things for me and that’s why I’m only giving this 3.5*.
I received and Advanced Review Copy (ARC) from Bold Strokes Books through Netgalley in exchange for a voluntary and honest review.