What do you think?
Rate this book
The Legend of Black Jack
They say he was an outsider. A man with no home, no family, no friend to call his own. The man with nothing left to love. The empty man.
They say he talked to animals. They say he traveled between worlds. They say he killed a god, and they may be right. He prowled the border between light and dark. He beat the devil himself with a walking stick. He healed a thousand people in a single day and killed a dragon the same midnight.
They say there was a woman. They say he died for her. No one knows the truth.
Those are the legends about him.
If you want to know the truth I will tell you.
The Legend of Black Jack is a coming-of-age fantasy adventure complete with full-page illustrations, written by Emmy-winning writer A. R. Witham. It begins on a stormy night in Chicago but Jack Swift’s true destination lies far, far away. The skillful magic of A.R. Witham’s story whisks you away from your everyday world to an unbelievable journey with unexpected action and unforgettable characters.
They say he talked to animals. They say he traveled between worlds. They say he killed a god, and they may be right. He prowled the border between light and dark. He beat the devil himself with a walking stick. He healed a thousand people in a single day and killed a dragon the same midnight.
They say there was a woman. They say he died for her. No one knows the truth.
Those are the legends about him.
If you want to know the truth I will tell you.
The Legend of Black Jack is a coming-of-age fantasy adventure complete with full-page illustrations, written by Emmy-winning writer A. R. Witham. It begins on a stormy night in Chicago but Jack Swift’s true destination lies far, far away. The skillful magic of A.R. Witham’s story whisks you away from your everyday world to an unbelievable journey with unexpected action and unforgettable characters.
495 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 20, 2022
115 people are currently reading
1287 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 184 reviews
July 3, 2024
Check out my review on my Booktube Channel for The Legend Of Black Jack HERE
Such a fun entertaining Adventure!!! The perfect palette cleanser read. Full of magic, pirates, knights, and battles. From the moment we meet Jack, you can’t help but love him!
Jack is an exceptional young man whose world is torn apart. Then he gets captured by talking Rhino Wizard….
This story filled me with nostalgia and reminded me of classic tales of adventure and fun. I would classify this with stories such as Jumanji, the never-ending story, The Pagemaster, and The Chronicles of Narnia. I was enraptured by Jack's band of characters and the many adversaries and adversities that he overcame.
I cannot wait for more from this author! The Legend of Black Jack is a perfect story of found family and coming of age with a wonderful adventure thrown in for good measure. It is a delightful read and a contender for one of my best books read this year.
Such a fun entertaining Adventure!!! The perfect palette cleanser read. Full of magic, pirates, knights, and battles. From the moment we meet Jack, you can’t help but love him!
Jack is an exceptional young man whose world is torn apart. Then he gets captured by talking Rhino Wizard….
This story filled me with nostalgia and reminded me of classic tales of adventure and fun. I would classify this with stories such as Jumanji, the never-ending story, The Pagemaster, and The Chronicles of Narnia. I was enraptured by Jack's band of characters and the many adversaries and adversities that he overcame.
I cannot wait for more from this author! The Legend of Black Jack is a perfect story of found family and coming of age with a wonderful adventure thrown in for good measure. It is a delightful read and a contender for one of my best books read this year.
July 6, 2022
I've tried starting this review with a dozen different sentences and none have been good enough to encompass how spectacular this story is.
Like myself, you might not read much YA, but letting that deter you from picking this up is doing yourself a disservice. It's YA told with a voice that is mature, yet accessible, it tells a beautiful, compelling, magical story that is steeped in deeper themes, meaningful relationships and beautiful flowing prose.
The prose and some aspects of the plot are reminiscent of Patrick Rothfuss's work. It is the first book I've read that has that same warm feel to the words, the one that embraces you and pulls you along, telling you a story that you just don't want to put down.
The plot is engaging, steering you through the magical world of Keymark as Jack meets incredibly crafted characters that ooze personality and are very distinct.
The father-son bond this story brings up is special. It got to me in the best way more than once, and I'm not ashamed to say I read the final words with tears in my eyes.
I'll be hard pressed to find a better read this year, or in years to come, for that matter.
Like myself, you might not read much YA, but letting that deter you from picking this up is doing yourself a disservice. It's YA told with a voice that is mature, yet accessible, it tells a beautiful, compelling, magical story that is steeped in deeper themes, meaningful relationships and beautiful flowing prose.
The prose and some aspects of the plot are reminiscent of Patrick Rothfuss's work. It is the first book I've read that has that same warm feel to the words, the one that embraces you and pulls you along, telling you a story that you just don't want to put down.
The plot is engaging, steering you through the magical world of Keymark as Jack meets incredibly crafted characters that ooze personality and are very distinct.
The father-son bond this story brings up is special. It got to me in the best way more than once, and I'm not ashamed to say I read the final words with tears in my eyes.
I'll be hard pressed to find a better read this year, or in years to come, for that matter.
September 30, 2022
This is the kind of story that will live on in the heart of its readers, forever.
An example of this kind of story for me is THE NEVERENDING STORY. I have watched that movie more times than I can count, anytime a theater near me brings it back for a limited time, I AM THERE. I've read the book and funnily enough, I like the movie better. It's a story that plants itself within your heart with a love that is so pure and so great, nothing could ever diminish it. THAT is what kind of story THE LEGEND OF BLACK JACK is.
Another reason this book will forever be special to me is because it got me through a terrifying time. The second day I spent within its pages, Hurricane Ian made landfall in Florida and started working its way across the state...right towards me. I was up for almost 2 full days with little to no sleep and A.R. Witham's OUTSTANDING narration (I was so graciously gifted the audiobook from the author) caught me up and transplanted my consciousness from reality and into Keymark. I was scared and exhausted, so there was no way I was able to concentrate on reading my Kindle copy, so the audiobook was a godsend. A.R. Witham is not just an author, he's a storyteller. There is a distinction - the narration was nothing short of magical - Witham masterfully adjusted the cadence and emotion in his voice to match all of the action and adventure taking place in this fantastic coming of age story about Jack Swift.
Jack Swift has just had the most miserable 14th birthday ever. Abused by his foster mother, plagued by nightmares of his father's death which keeps the survivor's guilt fresh and painful, Jack gets quite the surprise...not of the birthday variety either. A large rhino, who talks AND does magic appears in Jack's bedroom! Jack is certain he's dreaming as he's thrown into a watery portal and lands in another world. A world where legendary Border Knights protect the people and the Elves, most everyone can perform magic to an extent, there are PIRATES, a samurai, demons, more bugs than I was comfortable with, a Fell Prince - my heart rate is spiking just making this list because of all the exciting adventures that await readers in these pages.
The characters and their various interactions and relationships were brilliantly written. Every time you meet a new one, you tell yourself, "Yep, this one is my favorite character!" You meet another one and change your mind. The dark and evil foes are written so that I swear you actually *feel* a shadow pass over you when you're reading about them. The world building was excellent and readers really get a great tour as they travel with Jack as he tries to find his way home.
....Why are you still here? Grab a copy of this book and portal your way into one of the most amazing stories of our time.
An example of this kind of story for me is THE NEVERENDING STORY. I have watched that movie more times than I can count, anytime a theater near me brings it back for a limited time, I AM THERE. I've read the book and funnily enough, I like the movie better. It's a story that plants itself within your heart with a love that is so pure and so great, nothing could ever diminish it. THAT is what kind of story THE LEGEND OF BLACK JACK is.
Another reason this book will forever be special to me is because it got me through a terrifying time. The second day I spent within its pages, Hurricane Ian made landfall in Florida and started working its way across the state...right towards me. I was up for almost 2 full days with little to no sleep and A.R. Witham's OUTSTANDING narration (I was so graciously gifted the audiobook from the author) caught me up and transplanted my consciousness from reality and into Keymark. I was scared and exhausted, so there was no way I was able to concentrate on reading my Kindle copy, so the audiobook was a godsend. A.R. Witham is not just an author, he's a storyteller. There is a distinction - the narration was nothing short of magical - Witham masterfully adjusted the cadence and emotion in his voice to match all of the action and adventure taking place in this fantastic coming of age story about Jack Swift.
Jack Swift has just had the most miserable 14th birthday ever. Abused by his foster mother, plagued by nightmares of his father's death which keeps the survivor's guilt fresh and painful, Jack gets quite the surprise...not of the birthday variety either. A large rhino, who talks AND does magic appears in Jack's bedroom! Jack is certain he's dreaming as he's thrown into a watery portal and lands in another world. A world where legendary Border Knights protect the people and the Elves, most everyone can perform magic to an extent, there are PIRATES, a samurai, demons, more bugs than I was comfortable with, a Fell Prince - my heart rate is spiking just making this list because of all the exciting adventures that await readers in these pages.
The characters and their various interactions and relationships were brilliantly written. Every time you meet a new one, you tell yourself, "Yep, this one is my favorite character!" You meet another one and change your mind. The dark and evil foes are written so that I swear you actually *feel* a shadow pass over you when you're reading about them. The world building was excellent and readers really get a great tour as they travel with Jack as he tries to find his way home.
....Why are you still here? Grab a copy of this book and portal your way into one of the most amazing stories of our time.
July 4, 2022
This was a Fantastic Adventure with Heart
Seven year after a tragic accident, Jack Swift has been shipped for foster home to foster home. Each worse than the last. On the night of his 14th birthday, a massive rhino man appears in Jack's room and whisks him away to another realm hidden beneath the Chicago river. Danger is at every turn and people are looking at Jack to preform miracles! Jack may be a genius but they want magic and miracles where Jack only knows science. How can he possibly help these people and save the realm from evil.
Wow! I am so happy this was recommended to me!! I absolutely adored this book!
It has so much heart and instantly hooked me and then destroyed me (but in a good way..kinda) It is action packed and danger is around every corner, Jack really can't catch a break.
I read the ebook along with the audiobook which is narrated by the author himself! He did an amazing job and the characterisations were spot on.
Speaking of characters, I now need this book in physical form. The 20 odd pieces of digital art are amazing and really help with the world building and immersion into the world of Keymark.
I know, not my best review but I just needed to gush and recommend EVERYONE who loves fantasy with magic portals and epic warriors and battle scenes PICK THIS UP NOW. Perfect for why and adult alike.
Seven year after a tragic accident, Jack Swift has been shipped for foster home to foster home. Each worse than the last. On the night of his 14th birthday, a massive rhino man appears in Jack's room and whisks him away to another realm hidden beneath the Chicago river. Danger is at every turn and people are looking at Jack to preform miracles! Jack may be a genius but they want magic and miracles where Jack only knows science. How can he possibly help these people and save the realm from evil.
Wow! I am so happy this was recommended to me!! I absolutely adored this book!
It has so much heart and instantly hooked me and then destroyed me (but in a good way..kinda) It is action packed and danger is around every corner, Jack really can't catch a break.
I read the ebook along with the audiobook which is narrated by the author himself! He did an amazing job and the characterisations were spot on.
Speaking of characters, I now need this book in physical form. The 20 odd pieces of digital art are amazing and really help with the world building and immersion into the world of Keymark.
I know, not my best review but I just needed to gush and recommend EVERYONE who loves fantasy with magic portals and epic warriors and battle scenes PICK THIS UP NOW. Perfect for why and adult alike.
August 5, 2022
Well, this was just delightful! First and foremost, a special thank you to the author A.R.Witham, (or Andy, as he asks to be called in his Note From the Author,) both for creating this wonderful tale and fore sharing it with me via audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
Jack Swift is exactly the kind of character I love to root for. He has an absolutely amazing mind along with an eidetic memory, but we see this strength at times being a weakness as he struggles to come to grips with an entirely different world with it's own rules, legends and language. In particular his relationship with his father is among the most wholesome things I've read in recent memory.
I strongly encourage any and all readers (not just fantasy readers,) to take a journey with Jack and experience the magic and majesty of the lands of Keymark, Rimmy's Cull, Glyn Aker, Highyon Garde, the Paladine Arch and Werrun Fell. I haven't read a portal fantasy I got this lost in since Narnia - one of the foundational fiction series of my youth.
It is my sincere hope that Witham continues writing in this world - the standalone nature of a fantasy story is unique in today's landscape and something to be appreciated ... but let's face it - I read fantasy because I love series.
READ THIS
Jack Swift is exactly the kind of character I love to root for. He has an absolutely amazing mind along with an eidetic memory, but we see this strength at times being a weakness as he struggles to come to grips with an entirely different world with it's own rules, legends and language. In particular his relationship with his father is among the most wholesome things I've read in recent memory.
I strongly encourage any and all readers (not just fantasy readers,) to take a journey with Jack and experience the magic and majesty of the lands of Keymark, Rimmy's Cull, Glyn Aker, Highyon Garde, the Paladine Arch and Werrun Fell. I haven't read a portal fantasy I got this lost in since Narnia - one of the foundational fiction series of my youth.
It is my sincere hope that Witham continues writing in this world - the standalone nature of a fantasy story is unique in today's landscape and something to be appreciated ... but let's face it - I read fantasy because I love series.
READ THIS
March 3, 2023
Boy do I regret not finishing this sooner.
Legend of Black Jack captures the adventures of childhood, reminiscent of stories like the Neverending Story, Wonderland, Neverland, and others, yet it is uniquely its own. Never once did I think it stole from any one of those. Instead it has a wikk of its own—A magic that can only be explained by reading this for yourself.
As a writer, AR Witham, never once talks down to you, but instead takes you by the hand and drags you into a wonderful adventure. This is a story for all ages, and will go down among those greats I mentioned, as a Legend in and of itself.
Thank you for writing and sharing this, AR. I look forward to the next jaunt.
Legend of Black Jack captures the adventures of childhood, reminiscent of stories like the Neverending Story, Wonderland, Neverland, and others, yet it is uniquely its own. Never once did I think it stole from any one of those. Instead it has a wikk of its own—A magic that can only be explained by reading this for yourself.
As a writer, AR Witham, never once talks down to you, but instead takes you by the hand and drags you into a wonderful adventure. This is a story for all ages, and will go down among those greats I mentioned, as a Legend in and of itself.
Thank you for writing and sharing this, AR. I look forward to the next jaunt.
June 18, 2023
What a truly wonderful story.
The story is encapsulating, magical, memorable and told with a voice that connects straight to your heart.
I don't need to write a long review here, I just need to tell you, to pick this up and read it
The story is encapsulating, magical, memorable and told with a voice that connects straight to your heart.
I don't need to write a long review here, I just need to tell you, to pick this up and read it
October 14, 2022
5/5 stars
A magical world, masterful storytelling, with every moment better than the last.
The Legend of Black Jack, is a self published YA Portal fantasy by A. R. Witham, and a great debut. A book that reminded me of so many of the stories I loved growing up as a kid. Including the NeverEnding Story, Jumanji and Little Nemo: Adventures in Slumberland. A great mix of childlike wonder and impactful moments that hit as an adult.
There is a variety of relationships explored in this. Primarily, the relationship between father and son. While I’m not a father, I am a mother, and I found the parent/child relationship really well done. The father/son relationship reached out and grabbed my heart right from the start.
This coming-of-age fantasy, shows the meaning of friendship, the making of legends, and a struggle between good and evil.
We get a beautifully crafted world with pirates, knights, magical creatures (talking rhino included) and memorable characters. I can’t forget to mention that there is great action scenes, quests, a high stakes story and episodic adventures.
This is a story I would love to read with my own child, when they’re old enough.
The Legend of Black Jack was a fun adventure to read. I listened to the audiobook, narrated by the author and he did a fantastic job. I felt as though I were listening to a storyteller artfully crafting a story. I also read the ebook (with audiobook) and was pleasantly surprised to find several illustrations throughout depicting the world and story.
A. R. Witham has made something special here and I can’t wait for more.
A magical world, masterful storytelling, with every moment better than the last.
The Legend of Black Jack, is a self published YA Portal fantasy by A. R. Witham, and a great debut. A book that reminded me of so many of the stories I loved growing up as a kid. Including the NeverEnding Story, Jumanji and Little Nemo: Adventures in Slumberland. A great mix of childlike wonder and impactful moments that hit as an adult.
There is a variety of relationships explored in this. Primarily, the relationship between father and son. While I’m not a father, I am a mother, and I found the parent/child relationship really well done. The father/son relationship reached out and grabbed my heart right from the start.
This coming-of-age fantasy, shows the meaning of friendship, the making of legends, and a struggle between good and evil.
We get a beautifully crafted world with pirates, knights, magical creatures (talking rhino included) and memorable characters. I can’t forget to mention that there is great action scenes, quests, a high stakes story and episodic adventures.
This is a story I would love to read with my own child, when they’re old enough.
The Legend of Black Jack was a fun adventure to read. I listened to the audiobook, narrated by the author and he did a fantastic job. I felt as though I were listening to a storyteller artfully crafting a story. I also read the ebook (with audiobook) and was pleasantly surprised to find several illustrations throughout depicting the world and story.
A. R. Witham has made something special here and I can’t wait for more.
May 20, 2022
Kindly received an ARC for an honest review...
Jack Swift never catches a break ... he was plunged into an adventure he never saw coming.
Few YA books keep my interest going but A.R. managed to hold my attention and my breath. Characters are well established, the World fantastic and great battle scenes .
Heartwarming, frightning, breathless, and sometimes grim - a really fine debut by the author.
Really loved the story. If you love adventure, action, battle and strong bonds of friends and family and a lovable MC as well as great side characters, you gonna love this story.
4.5* and the Illustrations brought it up to 5*
Amazing illustrations throughout the whole book!
Jack Swift never catches a break ... he was plunged into an adventure he never saw coming.
Few YA books keep my interest going but A.R. managed to hold my attention and my breath. Characters are well established, the World fantastic and great battle scenes .
Heartwarming, frightning, breathless, and sometimes grim - a really fine debut by the author.
Really loved the story. If you love adventure, action, battle and strong bonds of friends and family and a lovable MC as well as great side characters, you gonna love this story.
4.5* and the Illustrations brought it up to 5*
Amazing illustrations throughout the whole book!
August 17, 2023
This book is blatantly sexist. I'm confused why it has so many positive reviews.
We have handfuls of male characters and *checks notes* two women. One is an obese abusive alcoholic. The other is our "little firecracker" (she's older than the protagonist) who shows up to take off her shirt, tease our protagonist, and give worldbuilding dumps.
Additionally, this book is constantly using default-male language. To describe groups of men and women, it usually just refers to the everyone as "men." Like, in the end of the book, all the men celebrate their victory. Also some women are there to give out random lusty kisses.
We have handfuls of male characters and *checks notes* two women. One is an obese abusive alcoholic. The other is our "little firecracker" (she's older than the protagonist) who shows up to take off her shirt, tease our protagonist, and give worldbuilding dumps.
Additionally, this book is constantly using default-male language. To describe groups of men and women, it usually just refers to the everyone as "men." Like, in the end of the book, all the men celebrate their victory. Also some women are there to give out random lusty kisses.
April 11, 2023
A fast paced YA portal fantasy with strong characters that draw from very clear inspirations. The audiobook was wonderfully narrated by the author which at first I was worried about going in. This reads almost episodically which didn't quite work for me, and the style itself is not to my specific taste, but for those seeking a fun, fast YA read, and want to support indie, I would recommend.
Thank you A.R. Witham for providing an audiobook copy for review.
Thank you A.R. Witham for providing an audiobook copy for review.
April 23, 2022
I received an arc of this book from the author via NetGalley - thank you very much!!
The Legend of Black Jack is the debut novel by Emmy winning A.R. Witham and bearing that in mind, the quality of the writing is remarkable, expertly bringing this fantasy to life. I absolutely loved this book - it sucked me in from the start and I found it really difficult to put down.
There is an amazingly varied cast of fully fleshed-out characters, imaginative storytelling combined with the inclusion of songs, literary quotes at the beginning of chapters and wonderful illustrations, which all serve to turn this book into something truly magical. I was hooked from the moment the ‘monster’ appeared in fourteen year old Jack’s bedroom and kidnapped him away from his tragic beginnings as an orphaned foster kid living with a real monster of an alcoholic foster mother:
“He had entered a state of fixed fascination with his kidnapper. The thing had come out of a nightmare, chucked him out the window like a bag of garbage, changed into a lizard (and back again before his very eyes), protected him from a fall that should have killed him, and come out of it all without a scratch. The monster, Jack thought, was miraculous.”
The amazing level of descriptive detail transports the reader into their own imagination with ease and every scene is so easy to visualize. The magical world of Keymark, which Jack is taken to via a portal, is full of everything a young reader of fantasy could ask for: pirates; a dragon; pixies; a traitorous villain with an army of venomous creatures; a beautiful heroine and oodles of swashbuckling bravery and derring-do. Aimed at a middle grade/young adult audience, there is also wholesome advice given from time to time, such as from Jack’s father:
“Do it with your whole heart, his calm voice said. Sometimes you’ll succeed and sometimes you’ll fail. But never let anyone say you didn’t give it your best.”
There is also heroic advice from one of the Border Knights, Abraham Qin:
“If you die today, then die well.”
What I found really ingenious was that the main character started off in Chicago, in our own world having voraciously devoured a whole host of encyclopedias and watched a surgeon perform a large number of surgeries. Thanks to his amazing eidetic memory, this fourteen year old boy is an expert on many scientific principles and even able to perform surgery from memory. When he enters the fabulous world of Keymark he has the power of science at his fingertips which is able to cause awe amongst the people he meets who are only accustomed to ‘majik’. Jack is able to draw upon his encyclopedic knowledge to teach a blue gecko American Sign Language in order to communicate with him, to use Galileo’s theories about gravity and the French invention of the parachute made from silk in order to aid his escape from a relentless demon that is hunting him.
His ability to remember the chemical formula for gunpowder allows him to help fight off a whole army of monstrous creatures.
My favourite character among the unlikely companions drawn to Jack’s side during his adventure was the roguish pirate, Rooker Flynn, who begins to respect Jack the more he gets to know him, rather than dismissing him as a young ‘boychick’. Rooker is very down to Earth and quite deliciously disgusting at times:
“Rooker put up a pot of coffee, took off his boots, and went to work on his calloused feet, shredding the dead skin off with a cheese grater. “Ahh,” he sighed happily. “Ya want this when I’m done?” “No. Disgusting. Thanks.” “
We see the power of teamwork come into play as the adventure continues. The main premise of the novel is one of good versus evil with the noble Paladine Knight, Valerian Tsai out to defeat the evil Necrórceror. Jack and his companions each has a skill necessary to make their plan work - alone none of them would have succeeded. This is a great positive message for the younger readers of this book.
I really liked the idea of the dog, Shadow, the embodiment of Jack’s Fear who begins as a puppy and gradually grows larger until almost a wolf as Jack becomes more and more fearful. Despite his fear accompanying him everywhere, Jack never gives up. His courage and determination are relentless and he also continues to have Hope:
“Hope is a dangerous thing. It can keep a man going when all seems lost, can keep him standing, keep him fighting. But when nothing is left but despair, nothing but blackness and panic and the promise of death, the tiniest sliver of hope—the narrowest thread—can seem as solid as a steel cable. That thread bears the illusion of stability, of substance, of strength, but it is only a fool’s fantasy. Hope is delicate. Hope is fragile. And a man can grip it too tightly.“
This action-packed novel is a relentless, rollicking and rambunctious romp and a roller-coaster thrill ride. It is very cinematic and I can easily imagine it becoming a blockbuster summer vacation movie one day. I cannot recommend it more highly!
The Legend of Black Jack is the debut novel by Emmy winning A.R. Witham and bearing that in mind, the quality of the writing is remarkable, expertly bringing this fantasy to life. I absolutely loved this book - it sucked me in from the start and I found it really difficult to put down.
There is an amazingly varied cast of fully fleshed-out characters, imaginative storytelling combined with the inclusion of songs, literary quotes at the beginning of chapters and wonderful illustrations, which all serve to turn this book into something truly magical. I was hooked from the moment the ‘monster’ appeared in fourteen year old Jack’s bedroom and kidnapped him away from his tragic beginnings as an orphaned foster kid living with a real monster of an alcoholic foster mother:
“He had entered a state of fixed fascination with his kidnapper. The thing had come out of a nightmare, chucked him out the window like a bag of garbage, changed into a lizard (and back again before his very eyes), protected him from a fall that should have killed him, and come out of it all without a scratch. The monster, Jack thought, was miraculous.”
The amazing level of descriptive detail transports the reader into their own imagination with ease and every scene is so easy to visualize. The magical world of Keymark, which Jack is taken to via a portal, is full of everything a young reader of fantasy could ask for: pirates; a dragon; pixies; a traitorous villain with an army of venomous creatures; a beautiful heroine and oodles of swashbuckling bravery and derring-do. Aimed at a middle grade/young adult audience, there is also wholesome advice given from time to time, such as from Jack’s father:
“Do it with your whole heart, his calm voice said. Sometimes you’ll succeed and sometimes you’ll fail. But never let anyone say you didn’t give it your best.”
There is also heroic advice from one of the Border Knights, Abraham Qin:
“If you die today, then die well.”
What I found really ingenious was that the main character started off in Chicago, in our own world having voraciously devoured a whole host of encyclopedias and watched a surgeon perform a large number of surgeries. Thanks to his amazing eidetic memory, this fourteen year old boy is an expert on many scientific principles and even able to perform surgery from memory. When he enters the fabulous world of Keymark he has the power of science at his fingertips which is able to cause awe amongst the people he meets who are only accustomed to ‘majik’. Jack is able to draw upon his encyclopedic knowledge to teach a blue gecko American Sign Language in order to communicate with him, to use Galileo’s theories about gravity and the French invention of the parachute made from silk in order to aid his escape from a relentless demon that is hunting him.
His ability to remember the chemical formula for gunpowder allows him to help fight off a whole army of monstrous creatures.
My favourite character among the unlikely companions drawn to Jack’s side during his adventure was the roguish pirate, Rooker Flynn, who begins to respect Jack the more he gets to know him, rather than dismissing him as a young ‘boychick’. Rooker is very down to Earth and quite deliciously disgusting at times:
“Rooker put up a pot of coffee, took off his boots, and went to work on his calloused feet, shredding the dead skin off with a cheese grater. “Ahh,” he sighed happily. “Ya want this when I’m done?” “No. Disgusting. Thanks.” “
We see the power of teamwork come into play as the adventure continues. The main premise of the novel is one of good versus evil with the noble Paladine Knight, Valerian Tsai out to defeat the evil Necrórceror. Jack and his companions each has a skill necessary to make their plan work - alone none of them would have succeeded. This is a great positive message for the younger readers of this book.
I really liked the idea of the dog, Shadow, the embodiment of Jack’s Fear who begins as a puppy and gradually grows larger until almost a wolf as Jack becomes more and more fearful. Despite his fear accompanying him everywhere, Jack never gives up. His courage and determination are relentless and he also continues to have Hope:
“Hope is a dangerous thing. It can keep a man going when all seems lost, can keep him standing, keep him fighting. But when nothing is left but despair, nothing but blackness and panic and the promise of death, the tiniest sliver of hope—the narrowest thread—can seem as solid as a steel cable. That thread bears the illusion of stability, of substance, of strength, but it is only a fool’s fantasy. Hope is delicate. Hope is fragile. And a man can grip it too tightly.“
This action-packed novel is a relentless, rollicking and rambunctious romp and a roller-coaster thrill ride. It is very cinematic and I can easily imagine it becoming a blockbuster summer vacation movie one day. I cannot recommend it more highly!
July 30, 2022
3.5 stars (rounded down)
The Legend of Black Jack is a book that constantly kept popping up on my radar and despite the fact that a YA portal fantasy is not my usual choice of book, everyone’s praise and love for this story completely won me over.
Now, I can definitely see why so many people gush about this book, because it is a very heartfelt, endearing and entertaining story that will undoubtedly resonate with many readers. That said, I personally appreciate and enjoy this story more in hindsight than I did while reading it, because there was just something holding me back from getting invested.
The story starts in our world and we meet Jack and his dad. The author did an amazing job of showing the wonderful father/son relationship between these two in just a couple of pages, I immediately cared for them!
However, it doesn’t take long for tragedy to hit and then Jack’s life is turned completely on its head. His childhood is far from ideal, but on his fourteenth birthday, he is whisked away to a fantasy world and what follows is an action-packed adventure unlike anything you could have ever imagined.
Now, I mainly read adult fantasy these days, but I do enjoy middle-grade and YA from time to time. This book, however, straddles the line between all these age-ranges and for me it ended up feeling a bit jarring. The characters, their behaviour and their interactions often lean toward the younger side, while the writing and the tone of the book sometimes veer into much more adult territory. I don’t know why it bothered me so much, but it just really kept me from getting immersed.
And then there’s the pacing. Look, I love me a good action-packed and engaging story, but this one just started with a bang and it doesn't stop the entire way through. The story almost felt a bit episodic to me, in that each chapter features a new threat for our characters to defeat and it started to get on my nerves a bit. These characters deserved to catch a breath!
I do have to say that I was pleasantly surprised by the world that Jack is thrust into, it truly felt like an amalgamation of everything that is so great about fantasy and gave me all the nostalgic feels. The pacing was just so relentlessly fast that I barely had time to sit back and enjoy the world that A.R. Witham has created, so that was a bit of a bummer.
Also, I tend to be a very character driven reader and I think that the fact this story was so action-packed kept me from getting invested in the characters and their relationships. There’s no denying that there are some wonderful characters in this book and I actually loved the strong focus on (found) family and friendship here. However, I personally just prefer to spend a bit more down-time with my characters and see their interaction while they aren’t fighting for their lives, because that often helps me connect more to them.
Lastly, I do have to give props to the author for writing a very engaging story. I read this book in a little over 24 hours, because it was just so easily readable, so I guess the faster pace did have a positive aspect to it after all. The stakes were also a lot higher than I was anticipating and I really enjoyed that. I would definitely describe this as a heartwarming and feel-good story, but the author isn’t afraid to include some more difficult themes as well. And there are also some very touching and emotional moments that will undoubtedly stick with you even after closing this book.
Also, the full-page illustrations were a wonderful addition to the story. They definitely helped me get more immersed in this world, so that was just lovely.
So, while this wasn’t entirely the book for me, I think there is a lot to enjoy and the writing was so good that I would love to read more from A.R. Witham in the future.
I seriously hope this book finds its right audience, so don’t hesitate to give this one a shot if anything about the premise intrigues you, because I know that it has been a huge hit for many people.
It was an enjoyable adventure that I definitely don’t regret reading.
The Legend of Black Jack is a book that constantly kept popping up on my radar and despite the fact that a YA portal fantasy is not my usual choice of book, everyone’s praise and love for this story completely won me over.
Now, I can definitely see why so many people gush about this book, because it is a very heartfelt, endearing and entertaining story that will undoubtedly resonate with many readers. That said, I personally appreciate and enjoy this story more in hindsight than I did while reading it, because there was just something holding me back from getting invested.
The story starts in our world and we meet Jack and his dad. The author did an amazing job of showing the wonderful father/son relationship between these two in just a couple of pages, I immediately cared for them!
However, it doesn’t take long for tragedy to hit and then Jack’s life is turned completely on its head. His childhood is far from ideal, but on his fourteenth birthday, he is whisked away to a fantasy world and what follows is an action-packed adventure unlike anything you could have ever imagined.
Now, I mainly read adult fantasy these days, but I do enjoy middle-grade and YA from time to time. This book, however, straddles the line between all these age-ranges and for me it ended up feeling a bit jarring. The characters, their behaviour and their interactions often lean toward the younger side, while the writing and the tone of the book sometimes veer into much more adult territory. I don’t know why it bothered me so much, but it just really kept me from getting immersed.
And then there’s the pacing. Look, I love me a good action-packed and engaging story, but this one just started with a bang and it doesn't stop the entire way through. The story almost felt a bit episodic to me, in that each chapter features a new threat for our characters to defeat and it started to get on my nerves a bit. These characters deserved to catch a breath!
I do have to say that I was pleasantly surprised by the world that Jack is thrust into, it truly felt like an amalgamation of everything that is so great about fantasy and gave me all the nostalgic feels. The pacing was just so relentlessly fast that I barely had time to sit back and enjoy the world that A.R. Witham has created, so that was a bit of a bummer.
Also, I tend to be a very character driven reader and I think that the fact this story was so action-packed kept me from getting invested in the characters and their relationships. There’s no denying that there are some wonderful characters in this book and I actually loved the strong focus on (found) family and friendship here. However, I personally just prefer to spend a bit more down-time with my characters and see their interaction while they aren’t fighting for their lives, because that often helps me connect more to them.
Lastly, I do have to give props to the author for writing a very engaging story. I read this book in a little over 24 hours, because it was just so easily readable, so I guess the faster pace did have a positive aspect to it after all. The stakes were also a lot higher than I was anticipating and I really enjoyed that. I would definitely describe this as a heartwarming and feel-good story, but the author isn’t afraid to include some more difficult themes as well. And there are also some very touching and emotional moments that will undoubtedly stick with you even after closing this book.
Also, the full-page illustrations were a wonderful addition to the story. They definitely helped me get more immersed in this world, so that was just lovely.
So, while this wasn’t entirely the book for me, I think there is a lot to enjoy and the writing was so good that I would love to read more from A.R. Witham in the future.
I seriously hope this book finds its right audience, so don’t hesitate to give this one a shot if anything about the premise intrigues you, because I know that it has been a huge hit for many people.
It was an enjoyable adventure that I definitely don’t regret reading.
November 2, 2023
The author very kindly sent me a review copy of the audiobook version, which is performed by him expertly. I really enjoyed the narration.
This book opens up very grounded within our natural world. It bears the nostalgia of the boy who lived, or the land behind the wardrobe, in a sense that felt very cozy like an old middle grade friend. The story follows a young teenage boy named Jack, who has an eidetic memory with a hankering for knowledge. That doesn’t stop him from having a long way to grow up, nor does it stop him from having a lot more to learn. And it certainly doesn’t stop him from being sucked into a wholly fantasy world with dangers and bloodshed.
The author does a phenomenal job of having the reader learn and grow with the character. It’s one of the things that resonated with me the most in the feel-good, middle grade way, even though the writing and content is most definitely young adult. To really understand and progress the way the author intends, you truly have to feel and grow as Jack does, to come of age, and the author hands it all right to you.
The fantasy world is beautifully fleshed out, and I absolutely loved the diverse cast of characters and creatures this book features. Some felt wonderfully Narnian, while there’s even some you’d never think of! The writing is great, the description is wonderful, the action is top notch, and the heart and emotion hit precisely the way it’s meant to. I would gladly read many more.
Personally a 5/5* for me, an absolutely banger of a fantasy novel. Have you gotten your hands on this one yet??
This book opens up very grounded within our natural world. It bears the nostalgia of the boy who lived, or the land behind the wardrobe, in a sense that felt very cozy like an old middle grade friend. The story follows a young teenage boy named Jack, who has an eidetic memory with a hankering for knowledge. That doesn’t stop him from having a long way to grow up, nor does it stop him from having a lot more to learn. And it certainly doesn’t stop him from being sucked into a wholly fantasy world with dangers and bloodshed.
The author does a phenomenal job of having the reader learn and grow with the character. It’s one of the things that resonated with me the most in the feel-good, middle grade way, even though the writing and content is most definitely young adult. To really understand and progress the way the author intends, you truly have to feel and grow as Jack does, to come of age, and the author hands it all right to you.
The fantasy world is beautifully fleshed out, and I absolutely loved the diverse cast of characters and creatures this book features. Some felt wonderfully Narnian, while there’s even some you’d never think of! The writing is great, the description is wonderful, the action is top notch, and the heart and emotion hit precisely the way it’s meant to. I would gladly read many more.
Personally a 5/5* for me, an absolutely banger of a fantasy novel. Have you gotten your hands on this one yet??
August 23, 2022
This book was an absolute delight to read. Precocious Jack's journey is filled with wonder and heart, and I was surprised to have teared up a little at the end. Whereas I sometimes feel that modern fantasy authors spend so much time worrying about world building, magic systems and trope subversions to the point that the story sometimes feels secondary, A.R. Witham hasn't forgotten that a story should be first and foremost a compelling story. That's not to say that there isn't great world-building or any of those things in this novel, but I feel that Witham's focus was to tell Jack's story first and weave all the other fantastical elements around it.
The pacing and plotting was superb, and this 440-page book flew by because it was so compelling. The cast of characters was enjoyable, especially Jack's companions as the novel got further along. This is a fantasy coming of age tale that deserves all the accolades I've seen in so many places. Jack's journey is likely to stick with me for a long time.
-----
If there is one complaint with the book, there were several typographical and formatting errors in the book that distracted me and took me out of the story. But as this is a self-published work, they were forgiven quickly, but I did want to mention it.
The pacing and plotting was superb, and this 440-page book flew by because it was so compelling. The cast of characters was enjoyable, especially Jack's companions as the novel got further along. This is a fantasy coming of age tale that deserves all the accolades I've seen in so many places. Jack's journey is likely to stick with me for a long time.
-----
If there is one complaint with the book, there were several typographical and formatting errors in the book that distracted me and took me out of the story. But as this is a self-published work, they were forgiven quickly, but I did want to mention it.
August 25, 2022
TLDR: I may have broken my keyboard by how hard I just smashed the 5 star button. This novel is ADVENTURE and HEART! I can totally see why it's compared to the likes of The Pagemaster, The Chronicles of Narnia, and (for me) The Neverending Story. A fantastic cast of characters and locations swirl around a truly touching tale centering around the concepts of growing up and paternal bonds/love. This wasn't just a home run for me; it was a grand slam!
First, let's talk about the plot. Jack's story is carefully laid out and paced with an amazing mix of colorful settings, each introduced and built upon through our close tie with our protagonist, who is experiencing all of these magical locations for the first time alongside us. The buildup, action, and decompression of tension is (in my opinion) handled beautifully, with heart-pounding action and sweet, slice-of-life moments to break up the more serious sections. This is a roller coaster journey that seamlessly glides through each section with grace while remaining thrilling throughout.
As far as the characters, calling them a colorful cast would be doing them an injustice. Here we have Rhino wizards, powerful knights in gleaming armor, crocodile samurai, swashbuckling pirates, mysterious elves, agile cat-people, and cute, clever lizards (I loved the tams). The characters, and their interactions, would prove one of the aspects of the story I enjoyed the most.
Let's talk about Keymark. This setting feels like adventure. I know, on its face, that seems like an odd statement, but if you read this book, you'll understand what I mean. Keymark is like a buffet of fantastical landscapes, weather, and hazards; the perfect sandbox for a whirlwind adventure. If an imaginative, adventure-seeking youth could wield god-like power and construct a paradise, it may look a lot like Keymark. 10/10 love for this place!
Lastly, let's talk about the core of this story, which is the coming-of-age growth Jack Swift experiences along his journey, as well as the parental bond that drives his character forward. Andy, you really hit this out of the park. I'm not a father, but, as a son, and as someone who recently lost their father, I can say unabashedly that parts of this story had me nearly in tears. From the bottom of my heart, I just wanna say thanks for writing this; it was an absolute treat to read.
First, let's talk about the plot. Jack's story is carefully laid out and paced with an amazing mix of colorful settings, each introduced and built upon through our close tie with our protagonist, who is experiencing all of these magical locations for the first time alongside us. The buildup, action, and decompression of tension is (in my opinion) handled beautifully, with heart-pounding action and sweet, slice-of-life moments to break up the more serious sections. This is a roller coaster journey that seamlessly glides through each section with grace while remaining thrilling throughout.
As far as the characters, calling them a colorful cast would be doing them an injustice. Here we have Rhino wizards, powerful knights in gleaming armor, crocodile samurai, swashbuckling pirates, mysterious elves, agile cat-people, and cute, clever lizards (I loved the tams). The characters, and their interactions, would prove one of the aspects of the story I enjoyed the most.
Let's talk about Keymark. This setting feels like adventure. I know, on its face, that seems like an odd statement, but if you read this book, you'll understand what I mean. Keymark is like a buffet of fantastical landscapes, weather, and hazards; the perfect sandbox for a whirlwind adventure. If an imaginative, adventure-seeking youth could wield god-like power and construct a paradise, it may look a lot like Keymark. 10/10 love for this place!
Lastly, let's talk about the core of this story, which is the coming-of-age growth Jack Swift experiences along his journey, as well as the parental bond that drives his character forward. Andy, you really hit this out of the park. I'm not a father, but, as a son, and as someone who recently lost their father, I can say unabashedly that parts of this story had me nearly in tears. From the bottom of my heart, I just wanna say thanks for writing this; it was an absolute treat to read.
November 17, 2022
A lot of fun!
So many stories & tales speak of him. Of times when the land desperately cried out for a hero. The times of the legendary Black Jack. Fantastic portal fantasy! A wild ride full of fascinating characters!
So many stories & tales speak of him. Of times when the land desperately cried out for a hero. The times of the legendary Black Jack. Fantastic portal fantasy! A wild ride full of fascinating characters!
August 19, 2024
3.5/5 (rounded up) This was an entertaining high fantasy portal adventure standalone that straddles YA and adult tones expertly. Keymark is an enchanting and captivating world with unique characters and the author’s descriptions and use of imagery was masterful. The story draws from classic inspirations but carves its own path with a lightning fast pace and a plot full of adventure, with some twists that were satisfying. I listened to part of it on audio, and the author does an incredible job with the narration, giving the story, and its characters, life.
On the whole though, the book didn’t completely land for me - perhaps mostly stylistically. And while I enjoy fast paced books, this one moved quite quickly, I felt, at the expense of more impactful moments or more compelling characters or relationships. I think the choices made throughout the book allow it to lean heavier into the YA group, which isn’t where I spend most of my time. All in all, a fun time, and a well-done adventure story from a respected Indie author. I’d recommend reading a few reviews (they’re mostly glowing!) and picking this up if it ticks some boxes for you!
On the whole though, the book didn’t completely land for me - perhaps mostly stylistically. And while I enjoy fast paced books, this one moved quite quickly, I felt, at the expense of more impactful moments or more compelling characters or relationships. I think the choices made throughout the book allow it to lean heavier into the YA group, which isn’t where I spend most of my time. All in all, a fun time, and a well-done adventure story from a respected Indie author. I’d recommend reading a few reviews (they’re mostly glowing!) and picking this up if it ticks some boxes for you!
April 21, 2023
What a fun adventure!
Let me start by saying that when I began reading the first few chapters this was not at all what I expected. I knew it was a YA fantasy, but was not expecting a portal fantasy with as many medical references. I struggle with medical-related topics but eventually fell into a rhythm and I was beginning to enjoy it. I loved so many characters. Rooker, Valerian, Memphis, Fuji, the trio.
The middle was tough for me. I lost the motivation to push forward from about 40-70%. However... once it hit that 70% mark... things FLEW. The final battle was absolutely fantastic and moved around just enough to keep things interesting while adding different layers to the battle.
Let me start by saying that when I began reading the first few chapters this was not at all what I expected. I knew it was a YA fantasy, but was not expecting a portal fantasy with as many medical references. I struggle with medical-related topics but eventually fell into a rhythm and I was beginning to enjoy it. I loved so many characters. Rooker, Valerian, Memphis, Fuji, the trio.
The middle was tough for me. I lost the motivation to push forward from about 40-70%. However... once it hit that 70% mark... things FLEW. The final battle was absolutely fantastic and moved around just enough to keep things interesting while adding different layers to the battle.
August 9, 2022
4.5 Stars rounded to 5.
The Legend of Black Jack is a step back in time. Back to the days of reading Treasure Ireland, the Sword and the Stone and Harry Pay the Pirate.
Jack Swift is a young man who is having a hard time as a teenager. No stability and lack of solid footing mask the genius bubbling under the surface.
The plot revolves around Jack being stolen away to another world and finding himself at the centre of a world which is much more fantastical than his native Chicago. A world that is reliant on magic (majik) and anthropomorphised characters aplenty, with recognisable and mythical beings in equal measure.
The book tells a story reminiscent of the type of sprawling adventures that are found in the books named above, while combining a little NeverEnding Story. The plot and action doesn't stand still for anyone as the adventure is constantly varied with a strong sense of stakes and threat always at the fore.
There is a diverse and numerous array of colourful characters spread throughout the book, with the best characters being those with expanded arcs which show strong development. My favourites from this point of view were Rooker and Fuji but each character has their place. Some of the characters do not feature much progression but I am hopeful that any further stories in this universe have had strong foundations laid for development, especially in the female characters (of which there are only a few).
However, the cast are so wide and varied that to develop more would have laid the book to be much longer and not achieve its aim of being a thrill ride akin to a Disney attraction. While the book appears to be a middle grade book (and certainly fits the demographic for this), there is a serious and dark side to the story that punctuates the story that give it such excellent depth throughout.
A thoroughly enjoyable rollercoaster of a book that deserves a place on most people's bookshelves.
The Legend of Black Jack is a step back in time. Back to the days of reading Treasure Ireland, the Sword and the Stone and Harry Pay the Pirate.
Jack Swift is a young man who is having a hard time as a teenager. No stability and lack of solid footing mask the genius bubbling under the surface.
The plot revolves around Jack being stolen away to another world and finding himself at the centre of a world which is much more fantastical than his native Chicago. A world that is reliant on magic (majik) and anthropomorphised characters aplenty, with recognisable and mythical beings in equal measure.
The book tells a story reminiscent of the type of sprawling adventures that are found in the books named above, while combining a little NeverEnding Story. The plot and action doesn't stand still for anyone as the adventure is constantly varied with a strong sense of stakes and threat always at the fore.
There is a diverse and numerous array of colourful characters spread throughout the book, with the best characters being those with expanded arcs which show strong development. My favourites from this point of view were Rooker and Fuji but each character has their place. Some of the characters do not feature much progression but I am hopeful that any further stories in this universe have had strong foundations laid for development, especially in the female characters (of which there are only a few).
However, the cast are so wide and varied that to develop more would have laid the book to be much longer and not achieve its aim of being a thrill ride akin to a Disney attraction. While the book appears to be a middle grade book (and certainly fits the demographic for this), there is a serious and dark side to the story that punctuates the story that give it such excellent depth throughout.
A thoroughly enjoyable rollercoaster of a book that deserves a place on most people's bookshelves.
December 1, 2022
I don't have too much to add from my original review. It's still a great story! But I loved the narration by Andy personally. It's hard to beat the ability of an author that has the skill set to handle their narration who is intimate with the book. As I mentioned on social media I had strong narration style vibes from Andy comparing him to the late great Jean Shepherd. Very similar styles and it just fit this story perfect for my immersion. It felt like someone was sitting in the room with me just telling me of this epic story! I bumped this up to a solid 5.0/5.0 with the audiobook.
Original Review 4.5/5.0 officially
I had heard about this one from the community both in Discord and on Twitter this Summer so I had added it to my short list and found some time here in early September to dive into this one. I honestly didn't know much going in other than most readers I had seen enjoyed it to some extent or another.
I will say as interesting as the prologue was to start this book, by the second chapter I was scratching my head as our world was being turned upside down. The prologue had me expecting a bit of an Indiana Jones type of story which I wouldn't have been mad about at all. However, the way this book progressed I ended up with very strong nostalgia vibes reminding me of fantasy movies from the 80s that I grew up watching. It felt like I was being throw back into fantastical worlds such as The Never Ending Story, Time Bandits, Dark Crystal or Labyrinth once again.
The pacing seemed very consistent for me. There was a lot of action or anxiety as we learn about the world and characters around our protagonist and his story. This was one of those books that I found time whenever I could to keep moving along with this story.
The character development was strong as well. We certainly learn a lot about Jack but as the story is told we learn more and more about many of the supporting characters as well. I'm not sure I'll forget the introduction of Memphis to Jack for quite some time. That was the moment I shoock my head wondering just what I had gotten into! There are also several touching moments near the end of the story and one specifically that actually got me a little choked up. It wasn't a sad moment, just a very powerful and emotional moment!
The world building was another strong aspect of this read. We start our early learning about a few areas within Jack's world in detail before we are transported to another fantastic world which spends most of the book learning about this new world. There were so many regions, environments, races and cultures introduced and explained to us by the author. There were so many different traditional fantasy aspects pulled into this grand story! We have pirates, mages, knights/samurai and deamons to make one hell of an adventure!
I thoroughly enjoyed this read and I hope that Andy (now that I've finished his book, I hope I can call him that) can continue to give us more wonderful stories and worlds to explore in the future!
I think this book could appeal to many different readers since it touches on a lot of different sub-genres to fantasy. I've since seen this book categorized as a Young Adult Portal Science Fiction Fantasy. And though it does have aspects that fit that, I hope that doesn't turn readers off from giving this one a chance. It's not a very long read and the style is a very easy read as well. Definitely worth the time!
Original Review 4.5/5.0 officially
I had heard about this one from the community both in Discord and on Twitter this Summer so I had added it to my short list and found some time here in early September to dive into this one. I honestly didn't know much going in other than most readers I had seen enjoyed it to some extent or another.
I will say as interesting as the prologue was to start this book, by the second chapter I was scratching my head as our world was being turned upside down. The prologue had me expecting a bit of an Indiana Jones type of story which I wouldn't have been mad about at all. However, the way this book progressed I ended up with very strong nostalgia vibes reminding me of fantasy movies from the 80s that I grew up watching. It felt like I was being throw back into fantastical worlds such as The Never Ending Story, Time Bandits, Dark Crystal or Labyrinth once again.
The pacing seemed very consistent for me. There was a lot of action or anxiety as we learn about the world and characters around our protagonist and his story. This was one of those books that I found time whenever I could to keep moving along with this story.
The character development was strong as well. We certainly learn a lot about Jack but as the story is told we learn more and more about many of the supporting characters as well. I'm not sure I'll forget the introduction of Memphis to Jack for quite some time. That was the moment I shoock my head wondering just what I had gotten into! There are also several touching moments near the end of the story and one specifically that actually got me a little choked up. It wasn't a sad moment, just a very powerful and emotional moment!
The world building was another strong aspect of this read. We start our early learning about a few areas within Jack's world in detail before we are transported to another fantastic world which spends most of the book learning about this new world. There were so many regions, environments, races and cultures introduced and explained to us by the author. There were so many different traditional fantasy aspects pulled into this grand story! We have pirates, mages, knights/samurai and deamons to make one hell of an adventure!
I thoroughly enjoyed this read and I hope that Andy (now that I've finished his book, I hope I can call him that) can continue to give us more wonderful stories and worlds to explore in the future!
I think this book could appeal to many different readers since it touches on a lot of different sub-genres to fantasy. I've since seen this book categorized as a Young Adult Portal Science Fiction Fantasy. And though it does have aspects that fit that, I hope that doesn't turn readers off from giving this one a chance. It's not a very long read and the style is a very easy read as well. Definitely worth the time!
July 6, 2022
YA Portal Fantasy as it ought to be written!
Jack, a brilliant 14 year old that remembers everything and has an insatiable hunger for knowledge... gets pulled into a world of magic. When the magic of the world comes up short, Jack must use his knowledge of science to solve the problems and defeat the enemies that threaten all life.
I was hesitant to give this book a chance since I don't usually like YA, but this book came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. It was fantastic! I loved every minute of reading this book. It's such a fun story with terrific action, heartwarming moments, and excellent pacing. I couldn't put it down!
The author also narrates the audiobook and I was blown away with how great of a job he did! If you're going on a family road trip... this is the book to listen to. It is kid friendly and the whole family will enjoy the story!
Overall rating of 93/100
Jack, a brilliant 14 year old that remembers everything and has an insatiable hunger for knowledge... gets pulled into a world of magic. When the magic of the world comes up short, Jack must use his knowledge of science to solve the problems and defeat the enemies that threaten all life.
I was hesitant to give this book a chance since I don't usually like YA, but this book came highly recommended and it did not disappoint. It was fantastic! I loved every minute of reading this book. It's such a fun story with terrific action, heartwarming moments, and excellent pacing. I couldn't put it down!
The author also narrates the audiobook and I was blown away with how great of a job he did! If you're going on a family road trip... this is the book to listen to. It is kid friendly and the whole family will enjoy the story!
Overall rating of 93/100
August 22, 2025
First of all I have to thank Netgalley and A. R. Witham for giving me an arc in exchange for my review.
Oh man this book is a giant hodgepodge of characters/creatures in the best way possible. I jokingly shared this with the author already but the only thing missing from this epic fantasy story is a clan of Ninjas. Seriously Andy where the heck are they :)
Okay jokes aside this was an awesome adventure that had me hooked from the start, although I may be a little biased since the opening takes place in my home state. Honestly I had never heard of this book or the author until I attended an online event where he offered up the arc for all who were interested. I was looking for something new to read and decided to give it a try and I'm so glad I did.
The story centers around Jack Swift who has a knack for learning that is unmatched. While the opening to the book would lead you to believe he is destined to become the greatest archaeologist to ever live, fate has other plans for him. As a result Jack discovers his true passion which becomes both a blessing and a curse as his adventure unfolds. Jack starts off the story as a young boy and ends with him in his teenage years. Throughout his adventure we get to see him struggle with doubts and fears which not only makes him very relatable but also makes you cheer him on more and more. I definitely got some Robin Hood and his merry men vibes from this book in the sense that Jack is surrounded by an amazing cast of characters that are extremely loyal to him. I also found myself becoming extremely attached to a few of them which at times hit me in the feels as the story unfolded.
The Legend of Black Jack is one wild ride that feels like if it was a video game it would be an instant classic. A. R. Witham did a fantastic job of showing us this vast and wonderful world with each stop on the journey containing its own unique elements all through Jack's eyes and I loved every minute of it.
"Live or die, they're gonna remember us. Good stories are the only way men can hope to live forever. And I aim to make sure I get my own verse" - Rooker Flynn
3.5/5
Oh man this book is a giant hodgepodge of characters/creatures in the best way possible. I jokingly shared this with the author already but the only thing missing from this epic fantasy story is a clan of Ninjas. Seriously Andy where the heck are they :)
Okay jokes aside this was an awesome adventure that had me hooked from the start, although I may be a little biased since the opening takes place in my home state. Honestly I had never heard of this book or the author until I attended an online event where he offered up the arc for all who were interested. I was looking for something new to read and decided to give it a try and I'm so glad I did.
The story centers around Jack Swift who has a knack for learning that is unmatched. While the opening to the book would lead you to believe he is destined to become the greatest archaeologist to ever live, fate has other plans for him. As a result Jack discovers his true passion which becomes both a blessing and a curse as his adventure unfolds. Jack starts off the story as a young boy and ends with him in his teenage years. Throughout his adventure we get to see him struggle with doubts and fears which not only makes him very relatable but also makes you cheer him on more and more. I definitely got some Robin Hood and his merry men vibes from this book in the sense that Jack is surrounded by an amazing cast of characters that are extremely loyal to him. I also found myself becoming extremely attached to a few of them which at times hit me in the feels as the story unfolded.
The Legend of Black Jack is one wild ride that feels like if it was a video game it would be an instant classic. A. R. Witham did a fantastic job of showing us this vast and wonderful world with each stop on the journey containing its own unique elements all through Jack's eyes and I loved every minute of it.
"Live or die, they're gonna remember us. Good stories are the only way men can hope to live forever. And I aim to make sure I get my own verse" - Rooker Flynn
3.5/5
Want to read
June 20, 2024🏴☠️🦜 On Sale .99 June 20, 2024 🦜🏴☠️
December 6, 2022
I Read and listened 🎧this for a mini Buddy Read 👀📕 with my friends,
Anthony and Grant!
And if you’re the type of person and you were young and you played hard, and had fun and read books, this is definitely the story for you.
Bottom line you can’t go wrong with the story !!
It’ll touch everyone’s a different way.
It’ll make people laugh.
Even times it could make you a little sad,
But in its own quirkiness It’ll bring a smile back to your face.
This is definitely a portal fantasy. You wake up with a walking talking rhino in your room.
If you bonded well with your dad, when you were young, this book is for you.
If you like pirates and read, treasure Island, when you were young, this book is for you!
If you like the undead, when you were young, then this book is for you!!!
I gave it ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars!!!!!!!
Anthony and Grant!
And if you’re the type of person and you were young and you played hard, and had fun and read books, this is definitely the story for you.
Bottom line you can’t go wrong with the story !!
It’ll touch everyone’s a different way.
It’ll make people laugh.
Even times it could make you a little sad,
But in its own quirkiness It’ll bring a smile back to your face.
This is definitely a portal fantasy. You wake up with a walking talking rhino in your room.
If you bonded well with your dad, when you were young, this book is for you.
If you like pirates and read, treasure Island, when you were young, this book is for you!
If you like the undead, when you were young, then this book is for you!!!
I gave it ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars!!!!!!!
July 22, 2022
The young protagonist is 14 and has an eidetic memory. We get to know his background before the fantastical events begin. So even though he is so talented, he still acts like a teenager and has his moments of impatience or anger. He is so well developed that you think you know him.
As other characters are introduced, you are thrown into quite a labyrinth of fantasy creatures from elves and dwarves or talking animals and zombies. There are several different scenarios with otherworldly creatures to keep your mind engaged or to sort them out. There is a honorable and stalwart knight who is one of my favorite characters. I also like Nightingale, although he doesn’t have that much page time. Memphis the Rhino and the trio of Django, Li-Bao and Chance are terrific as well as the two animal companions (sort of) of Jack, which are Fuji the tam and Shadow the wolf/dog. As you can see, there’s so much going on here, that there could have been separate stories about some of these characters. I would definitely read their stories!
If you like lots of fantasy tropes merged into one story, this is for you! It was a rollicking good time!
As other characters are introduced, you are thrown into quite a labyrinth of fantasy creatures from elves and dwarves or talking animals and zombies. There are several different scenarios with otherworldly creatures to keep your mind engaged or to sort them out. There is a honorable and stalwart knight who is one of my favorite characters. I also like Nightingale, although he doesn’t have that much page time. Memphis the Rhino and the trio of Django, Li-Bao and Chance are terrific as well as the two animal companions (sort of) of Jack, which are Fuji the tam and Shadow the wolf/dog. As you can see, there’s so much going on here, that there could have been separate stories about some of these characters. I would definitely read their stories!
If you like lots of fantasy tropes merged into one story, this is for you! It was a rollicking good time!
June 23, 2023
YES!!
I knew full well that I’d love this book. Everyone said I would, and everything pointed to me enjoying it. One can only hope to find a book as great as this. And it doesn’t happen often. This will be, without a doubt, one of the books I reread the most in the coming years. The tale that Mr. Witham was able to spin is just so incredibly enjoyable. Even with my few minor nitpicks, my enjoyment couldn’t be diminished. Just absolutely fantastic.
And I know this is a ✨glowing✨ review, it deserves it. There’s so many books that I’ve read recently, and loved. But even with the ones that I think I like “more”, I don’t see myself rereading them like I will with this (looking at you Les Mis).
I’ll do a full review of this book in a few weeks on the channel, in which I’ll be a bit more objective in things, but for a “quick” Goodreads review, I think I can gush a little.
I knew full well that I’d love this book. Everyone said I would, and everything pointed to me enjoying it. One can only hope to find a book as great as this. And it doesn’t happen often. This will be, without a doubt, one of the books I reread the most in the coming years. The tale that Mr. Witham was able to spin is just so incredibly enjoyable. Even with my few minor nitpicks, my enjoyment couldn’t be diminished. Just absolutely fantastic.
And I know this is a ✨glowing✨ review, it deserves it. There’s so many books that I’ve read recently, and loved. But even with the ones that I think I like “more”, I don’t see myself rereading them like I will with this (looking at you Les Mis).
I’ll do a full review of this book in a few weeks on the channel, in which I’ll be a bit more objective in things, but for a “quick” Goodreads review, I think I can gush a little.
July 5, 2022
Jack Swift is brilliant & in foster care when on his 14th birthday he’s kidnapped by a monster & magically taken to another world.
It’s a swashbuckling action adventure that you won’t want to miss!! Chapter 18 WOO, hold on cuz it’s a thrill ride. All sorts of good & bad monsters.
An easy fun fantasy narrated by the author who must be a bard in real life.
It’s a swashbuckling action adventure that you won’t want to miss!! Chapter 18 WOO, hold on cuz it’s a thrill ride. All sorts of good & bad monsters.
An easy fun fantasy narrated by the author who must be a bard in real life.
February 17, 2022
I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Legend of Black Jack took me on an entertaining adventure. The title alone intrigued me and sort of gave me Pirates of the Caribbean vibes. If I'm being honest, that's probably why I wanted to read it. Then I actually dove into the book and let's just say that I wasn't disappointed one bit.
The adventure definitely takes off pretty early on. I never found myself bored or the pace lagging one bit either. The characters were pretty likable throughout it as well. Especially when it came to Jack. Now he didn't have things completely easy because of what went down in the very beginning. But like all tragic beginnings, he goes off to find himself and an adventure.
Long story short, each chapter kept me on my toes. I also really enjoyed the little illustrations because they definitely helped show what things would look like in this world. Especially when you could describe something one way and my mind goes down a different path. They just helped clear what the real image was so I couldn't be easily confused by... well... myself.
In the end, I honestly enjoyed everything about this book. I'll definitely be on lookout for the next one A.R. writes!
The Legend of Black Jack took me on an entertaining adventure. The title alone intrigued me and sort of gave me Pirates of the Caribbean vibes. If I'm being honest, that's probably why I wanted to read it. Then I actually dove into the book and let's just say that I wasn't disappointed one bit.
The adventure definitely takes off pretty early on. I never found myself bored or the pace lagging one bit either. The characters were pretty likable throughout it as well. Especially when it came to Jack. Now he didn't have things completely easy because of what went down in the very beginning. But like all tragic beginnings, he goes off to find himself and an adventure.
Long story short, each chapter kept me on my toes. I also really enjoyed the little illustrations because they definitely helped show what things would look like in this world. Especially when you could describe something one way and my mind goes down a different path. They just helped clear what the real image was so I couldn't be easily confused by... well... myself.
In the end, I honestly enjoyed everything about this book. I'll definitely be on lookout for the next one A.R. writes!
January 12, 2023
Five stars, easily.
The setup was unique and quick for a portal fantasy/coming of age tale. I also like the twist on the classic trope of “destined one”; it’s original and keeps the protagonist driven throughout the story.
Pacing for most of the book was breakneck and Mr. Witham knows how to keep his characters moving. Characters are introduced evenly throughout and there’s not a terrific info dump of names I need to remember, which was appreciated. Some of them playing into typical traits assigned with races (ie Elves are again the stoic archers), but diversity overall makes them easy to differentiate. They’re fun and I found myself rooting for them to overcome their challenges.
Resolution of obstacles seemed quick and I would have liked a few more chapters of what drove the antagonist side to their goals. It was tidy and I was sad to see it end after the book’s buildup.
Overall the story was wildly entertaining. The action was thought out and I hope that if this world continues we will see fleshed out characters because I want to read more and see this world go a great distance. Twist the knife on these intensely likable (sometimes dastardly) players. Thank you Andy. We most certainly are friends now.
The setup was unique and quick for a portal fantasy/coming of age tale. I also like the twist on the classic trope of “destined one”; it’s original and keeps the protagonist driven throughout the story.
Pacing for most of the book was breakneck and Mr. Witham knows how to keep his characters moving. Characters are introduced evenly throughout and there’s not a terrific info dump of names I need to remember, which was appreciated. Some of them playing into typical traits assigned with races (ie Elves are again the stoic archers), but diversity overall makes them easy to differentiate. They’re fun and I found myself rooting for them to overcome their challenges.
Resolution of obstacles seemed quick and I would have liked a few more chapters of what drove the antagonist side to their goals. It was tidy and I was sad to see it end after the book’s buildup.
Overall the story was wildly entertaining. The action was thought out and I hope that if this world continues we will see fleshed out characters because I want to read more and see this world go a great distance. Twist the knife on these intensely likable (sometimes dastardly) players. Thank you Andy. We most certainly are friends now.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 184 reviews