TW: eating disorders
I was excited about this book, and I really wanted to enjoy it, but there were too many things that made it not a great read.
First, the book reads like it hasn’t been edited: the author jumps around, doesn’t have a clear vision, makes very simple grammar and spelling mistakes - which all led the book to fall flat for me. My biggest gripe is that the author referred to chewing and spitting as a diet and not as an eating disorder - any good editor should have fixed this, especially for a book written in the 2020s.
Second, the author cites studies that have been wholly debunked to prove her points (I’m mainly thinking about the two she cited regarding ultra processed foods). It made me question the rest of her research and positions- what other studies were junk science that she referenced? I fully believe it is the duty of the author to do deep research into everything they quote, and it appears this author didn’t. (Thanks, Maintenance Phase for making me look closely at this type of stuff.)
Third, the author has a section where she’s like, “I don’t want to talk about weight but we have to!” And then proceeds to talk about how being “overweight” makes people unhealthy, but ends this section saying something like “everyone, no matter their size, deserves our love.” Like girl which is it? Just don’t bring up weight if you’re going to skirt around it like that. We know how you really feel.
Fourth, I couldn’t stand the writing style. the author tried to be “cutesy” and break the fourth wall to talk to the reader, saying shit like “I know you don’t want to eat your leafy greens, butttt” blah blah blah. So juvenile for a research book.
Fifth, and I know I mentioned this above, the book was jumpy and there was no clear direction. Even within each sub-section of a chapter, I kept being like, “where is she going with this?” I couldn’t tell if she wanted this to be a respectable research book, a memoir about her own personal journey with food, a cookbook, or a cutesy food guide for girlies. Seriously, editor needed.
Coming back with a sixth thing after posting my initial review - the author is a relatively privileged woman and there wasn’t much talk (I can’t remember any) around the privilege surrounding food. the author talks about how eating a whole foods diet (lots of veggies, whole grains, fermented foods, etc) is best for our bodies and minds, without mentioning the socioeconomic factors that put some communities at a disadvantage to do this. I was skeptical of the book the first few pages in, but continued to read, when the author mentioned that a study showed that people who ate many fresh fruits and veggies were less depressed than those who didn’t - OK, well let’s think about that: people who can’t afford to eat fresh veggies and fruits may be facing economic insecurity, making them more at risk of depression. I was a bit upset the book didn’t delve into the social issues around food access- the whole point of the book is about the relationship between food and mental health; surely, societal issues around food inequality play into this as well.
All in all, I did learn a few things that were helpful to me in my chronic illness journey. But now I’m questioning all of her research… unfortunately wouldn’t recommend.