Sensual Secrets was a random buy from the library book sale. I thought that the premise, that of a painfully shy, repressed young woman who kept a journal of her most secret sexual fantasies online that is then found and read by the man of her dreams, to have potential as a hot, steamy and interesting read. Ultimately though, I thought that the story fell rather flat. It seemed that every time Jay tried to set up a scenario from Amelia's diary it never quite worked out, and I started loosing count of all the times she ended up leaving him frustrated. Unfortunately this was making me frustrated too. While I'm not a reader who wants to see the protagonists jump into bed with one another at the first available opportunity, all the aborted attempts just became rather tiresome, and the "main event" didn't end up happening until very near the end of the book. There was some other steamy content in the form of Amelia's diary entries, both of them getting friendly with their own hands, and a couple of other things, but what I really wanted to see was the characters interacting with each other more. I think that if Jay had earned Amelia's trust, she had communicated her fantasies to him, and then they had played them out, instead of him sneaking peeks at her diary, it would have been a much better story with a lot more depth.
Amelia and Jay were both generally likable characters, but I thought they could have been better too. As a shy person myself, I understood Amelia's timidity, but her constant self-reproach in the early chapters became a little too repetitive. Then over the course of just a few weeks, she magically came out of her shell, which I thought stretched the bounds of credibility. Jay was a decent guy with some good traits that I usually like in a hero, but what bothered me about him was that he seemed rather contradictory. On the one hand he supposedly saw Amelia for who she was and found her desirable in spite of her plain appearance, while on the other hand, it all seemed like a game to him, with the ultimate goal being sex. When he started thinking about dumping Amelia after they had sex for the first time and she declared her love, I started loosing respect for him, and in my opinion, he only partially redeemed himself by the end of the story. There was also a sub-plot about Jay being an incredibly intelligent guy who had turned his back on academics and a promising writing career in favor of running a Harley shop, but then he did an abrupt about-face at the end which didn't really make much sense. I think the problem was that the author tried to cram too many cliched romance hero characteristics into Jay, which ultimately diluted the character.
Overall though, Sensual Secrets was a pretty readable book (I've certainly read worse;)), and a reasonably pleasant way to spend a few hours. However, it might be the type of book better left to a boring, rainy afternoon when there's nothing better to do. I'm sure that I have tons of books on my TBR list that would have given me a more satisfaction. This was my first book by Jo Leigh though, and since I have several of her other books on my TBR list that were recommended by a friend, I will try to keep an open mind.