What do you think?
Rate this book
Sebastian St. Cyr #17
When Blood Lies
March, 1815. The Bourbon King Louis XVIII has been restored to the throne of France, Napoleon is in exile on the isle of Elba, and Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, and his wife, Hero, have traveled to Paris in hopes of tracing his long-lost mother, Sophie, the errant Countess of Hendon. But his search ends in tragedy when he comes upon the dying Countess in the wasteland at the tip of the �Žle de la Cit�(c). Stabbed -- apparently with a stiletto -- and thrown from the bastions of the island's ancient stone bridge, Sophie dies without naming her murderer.
488 pages, Library Binding
First published April 5, 2022
273 people are currently reading
4582 people want to read
About the author
C.S. Harris
23 books3,016 followersCandice Proctor, aka C.S. Harris and C.S. Graham, is the bestselling, award-winning author of more than a dozen novels including the Sebastian St. Cyr Regency mystery series written under the name C.S. Harris, the new C.S. Graham thriller series co-written with Steven Harris, and seven historical romances. She is also the author of a nonfiction historical study of the French Revolution. Her books are available worldwide and have been translated into over twenty different languages.
Candice graduated Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude with a degree in Classics before going on to earn an MA and Ph.D. in history. A former academic, she has taught at the University of Idaho and Midwestern State University in Texas. She also worked as an archaeologist on a variety of sites including a Hudson's Bay Company Fort in San Juan Island, a Cherokee village in Tennessee, a prehistoric kill site in Victoria, Australia, and a Roman cemetery and medieval manor house in Winchester, England. Most recently, she spent many years as a partner in an international business consulting firm.
The daughter of a career Air Force officer and university professor, Proctor loves to travel and has spent much of her life abroad. She has lived in Spain, Greece, England, France, Jordan, and Australia. She now makes her home in New Orleans, Louisiana, with her husband, retired Army officer Steve Harris, her two daughters, and an ever-expanding number of cats.
Candice graduated Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude with a degree in Classics before going on to earn an MA and Ph.D. in history. A former academic, she has taught at the University of Idaho and Midwestern State University in Texas. She also worked as an archaeologist on a variety of sites including a Hudson's Bay Company Fort in San Juan Island, a Cherokee village in Tennessee, a prehistoric kill site in Victoria, Australia, and a Roman cemetery and medieval manor house in Winchester, England. Most recently, she spent many years as a partner in an international business consulting firm.
The daughter of a career Air Force officer and university professor, Proctor loves to travel and has spent much of her life abroad. She has lived in Spain, Greece, England, France, Jordan, and Australia. She now makes her home in New Orleans, Louisiana, with her husband, retired Army officer Steve Harris, her two daughters, and an ever-expanding number of cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 460 reviews
July 26, 2023
Love this series, loved this book, and love this author – no lies!!!
The historical context is captivating, the atmosphere is tangible to the point you feel part of the story not just the observer. The writing style is brilliant. The plot interwoven with such important historical events was superbly done, and the characters are fascinating.
The Plot
Sebastian has been on the look out for his mother after learning after twenty years that she was still alive. A woman who was difficult to forgive and difficult to forget, but he came to an understanding that something desperate must have driven his mother to have shrugged her shoulders at the rules and restrictions of her world, for braving the unknown and for flouting the social conventions and moralistic censure of the zealots to live a life far away from her two children.
Tragically when he finally came to meet this beautiful, enigmatic, and intrepid woman, it was at the end of her life as he looked down at the body of the woman, he knew instantly to be his mother. Dying at the foot of the bridge. Murder or suicide?
No spoilers here, we know from the opening pages that Sophia Hendon has been murdered but why, by whom and for what reasons is the mystery to be unravelled, in one of Sebastian’s most difficult cases because it is so personal. As he stumbles across a woman lying on the grass…
“Recognition slammed into him. He fell to his knees beside her, his hands trembling as he reached out to her, his aching gaze drifting over the familiar planes of her face-the straight patrician nose, the high cheekbones, the strong jaw. Features subtly changed by the passage of years but still recognizable, still so beloved.” It was his mother, her eyes opening to say his name and then closed forever.
The atmosphere and drama is further heighten because it is no longer safe to remain in Paris with the looming invasion of Russia, Austria and Prussia who have already stormed the outlaying villages of Montmartre and Belleville. While the warring nations’ leaders hammered out their peace agreement, the invading soldiers, as was too often the case with Russia’s invasion, they amused themselves in time-honoured tradition by not just “..conquering armies, but ransacking and looting houses, raping women, and bayoneting young children and animals.”
The case is fascinating, the times dangerous and the story wonderful.
Review and Comments
The historical backdrop of Napolean, Russia’s invasion of France and the Battle of Paris (1814) is by far the most intriguing aspect to the story and the way it is woven into the fictional storyline of a prominent woman who is murdered to protect something!!!
This is probably my favourite from the series and very timely because I have been reading and watching documentaries and films on Napoleon and the early 19th Century in Russia and France.
Harris is superb at historical fiction and possibly my favourite go-to author of HF with the way she weaves the real with the fiction, but her writing style encapsulates the period and atmosphere so well. Viva la C.J. Harris.
The Vivid surroundings - “You could hear the piling of a rain swollen stream mingling with a chorus of Birdsong. Ancient gnarled grapevines and peach and cherry orchards just coming into bloom. Sweet smelling drifts of roses” I was there !!!
The people - “How does one reduce a man to a few words? He is brilliant but good-humored… noble but quick-tempered and hardheaded…cynical and yet somehow also idealistic. And deadly when he needs to be.” – I was invested.
A wonderful addition to the series. Vibrant, tragic, heart-wrenching, fascinating and vividly depicted in history and the surroundings. Highly recommended.
The historical context is captivating, the atmosphere is tangible to the point you feel part of the story not just the observer. The writing style is brilliant. The plot interwoven with such important historical events was superbly done, and the characters are fascinating.
The Plot
Sebastian has been on the look out for his mother after learning after twenty years that she was still alive. A woman who was difficult to forgive and difficult to forget, but he came to an understanding that something desperate must have driven his mother to have shrugged her shoulders at the rules and restrictions of her world, for braving the unknown and for flouting the social conventions and moralistic censure of the zealots to live a life far away from her two children.
Tragically when he finally came to meet this beautiful, enigmatic, and intrepid woman, it was at the end of her life as he looked down at the body of the woman, he knew instantly to be his mother. Dying at the foot of the bridge. Murder or suicide?
No spoilers here, we know from the opening pages that Sophia Hendon has been murdered but why, by whom and for what reasons is the mystery to be unravelled, in one of Sebastian’s most difficult cases because it is so personal. As he stumbles across a woman lying on the grass…
“Recognition slammed into him. He fell to his knees beside her, his hands trembling as he reached out to her, his aching gaze drifting over the familiar planes of her face-the straight patrician nose, the high cheekbones, the strong jaw. Features subtly changed by the passage of years but still recognizable, still so beloved.” It was his mother, her eyes opening to say his name and then closed forever.
The atmosphere and drama is further heighten because it is no longer safe to remain in Paris with the looming invasion of Russia, Austria and Prussia who have already stormed the outlaying villages of Montmartre and Belleville. While the warring nations’ leaders hammered out their peace agreement, the invading soldiers, as was too often the case with Russia’s invasion, they amused themselves in time-honoured tradition by not just “..conquering armies, but ransacking and looting houses, raping women, and bayoneting young children and animals.”
The case is fascinating, the times dangerous and the story wonderful.
Review and Comments
The historical backdrop of Napolean, Russia’s invasion of France and the Battle of Paris (1814) is by far the most intriguing aspect to the story and the way it is woven into the fictional storyline of a prominent woman who is murdered to protect something!!!
This is probably my favourite from the series and very timely because I have been reading and watching documentaries and films on Napoleon and the early 19th Century in Russia and France.
Harris is superb at historical fiction and possibly my favourite go-to author of HF with the way she weaves the real with the fiction, but her writing style encapsulates the period and atmosphere so well. Viva la C.J. Harris.
The Vivid surroundings - “You could hear the piling of a rain swollen stream mingling with a chorus of Birdsong. Ancient gnarled grapevines and peach and cherry orchards just coming into bloom. Sweet smelling drifts of roses” I was there !!!
The people - “How does one reduce a man to a few words? He is brilliant but good-humored… noble but quick-tempered and hardheaded…cynical and yet somehow also idealistic. And deadly when he needs to be.” – I was invested.
A wonderful addition to the series. Vibrant, tragic, heart-wrenching, fascinating and vividly depicted in history and the surroundings. Highly recommended.
April 11, 2022
When Blood Lies by C.S. Harris is a 2022 Berkley publication.
Sebastian and Hero are in Paris following a possible lead to the whereabouts of Sebastian’s mother. A shocking event changes the trajectory of their mission sending them headlong into an intensely emotional and dangerous search for a killer.
I was very surprised by this turn of events. I never would have guessed things would turn out like this for Sebastian. That said, it made for a very absorbing murder mystery. This series is, at its core, is a procedural, but it is the historical details and the atmosphere, along with the amazing characters makes it stand out.
The climate in France at this critical juncture is handled incredibly well and is very interesting all by itself. But the situation is heart wrenching for Sebastian. And as always, he melts my heart. My immense respect for Hero climbs up another notch in this installment. The mystery this time around is an emotional one, but the intrigue kept me on the edge of my seat.
This is one of those series, I wait impatiently for each installment and then must force myself to slow down and relish every dark, splendid detail.
This series is, at its core, is a procedural, but it is the incredible historical details and the atmosphere, along with the amazing characters makes it stand out. The story ends on an intriguing note and is yet another stellar installment in one of my all-time favorite series!
Sebastian and Hero are in Paris following a possible lead to the whereabouts of Sebastian’s mother. A shocking event changes the trajectory of their mission sending them headlong into an intensely emotional and dangerous search for a killer.
I was very surprised by this turn of events. I never would have guessed things would turn out like this for Sebastian. That said, it made for a very absorbing murder mystery. This series is, at its core, is a procedural, but it is the historical details and the atmosphere, along with the amazing characters makes it stand out.
The climate in France at this critical juncture is handled incredibly well and is very interesting all by itself. But the situation is heart wrenching for Sebastian. And as always, he melts my heart. My immense respect for Hero climbs up another notch in this installment. The mystery this time around is an emotional one, but the intrigue kept me on the edge of my seat.
This is one of those series, I wait impatiently for each installment and then must force myself to slow down and relish every dark, splendid detail.
This series is, at its core, is a procedural, but it is the incredible historical details and the atmosphere, along with the amazing characters makes it stand out. The story ends on an intriguing note and is yet another stellar installment in one of my all-time favorite series!
May 4, 2022
The seventeenth book in this wonderful series and the setting moves from London to Paris which provides the author with a whole new situation to describe.
The year is 1815 and Sebastian and Hero are in Paris to meet Sebastian's long lost mother. Their timing is bad as Napoleon chooses this moment to escape from Elba and head back to the capital city, raising volunteers to fight for him as he goes. Sebastian is fully occupied in solving a murder which is very personal and important to him and makes leaving France impossible for him. It all gets very exciting.
The author knows Paris as well as she does London and her descriptions are excellent. She also knows her history and I know a lot more now as a result of reading the book. As usual I enjoyed watching Sebastian performing detective work the way it was done in 1815, and he was very lucky he even survived working on this particular case.
The characters of course make this series really special. Sebastian and Hero are both capable and strong, and together they make a splendid team. Their relationship is also a joy to read about, both between the two of them and as a family unit with the two little boys.
The ending of the book is melancholy and leaves the family in an unfortunate situation. I am already looking forward to discovering the author's future plans for them.
The year is 1815 and Sebastian and Hero are in Paris to meet Sebastian's long lost mother. Their timing is bad as Napoleon chooses this moment to escape from Elba and head back to the capital city, raising volunteers to fight for him as he goes. Sebastian is fully occupied in solving a murder which is very personal and important to him and makes leaving France impossible for him. It all gets very exciting.
The author knows Paris as well as she does London and her descriptions are excellent. She also knows her history and I know a lot more now as a result of reading the book. As usual I enjoyed watching Sebastian performing detective work the way it was done in 1815, and he was very lucky he even survived working on this particular case.
The characters of course make this series really special. Sebastian and Hero are both capable and strong, and together they make a splendid team. Their relationship is also a joy to read about, both between the two of them and as a family unit with the two little boys.
The ending of the book is melancholy and leaves the family in an unfortunate situation. I am already looking forward to discovering the author's future plans for them.
July 6, 2022
4.5
Nearly a perfect book for this history- and mystery-loving reader.
I’ve adored this series since it began and eagerly await each new edition, but without a doubt, this installment is the best of the bunch.
Sebastian and Hero are in Paris, determined to wait for the return of Sebastian’s mother who fled to Paris 20 years earlier.
From the first chapter, Viscount Devlin’s wait to confront his mother finally ends. From then until the end of this surprising book, much happens. Some threads are impossible to surmise— yet all the action occurs with the planned return of Napoleon to Paris.
From architecture, royal life, rose gardens, British diplomacy and hidden relics, the real historic backdrop to the mystery plaguing the Devlin family enhances this book. And totally had me avoiding Google so I didn’t spoil the book for myself.
As I read this I realized I really don’t know much about Napoleon’s wars and rule. Definitely need to read more— the Arch de Triumph, modern morgues and Paris’ catacombs all have the emperor in common.
Nearly a perfect book for this history- and mystery-loving reader.
I’ve adored this series since it began and eagerly await each new edition, but without a doubt, this installment is the best of the bunch.
Sebastian and Hero are in Paris, determined to wait for the return of Sebastian’s mother who fled to Paris 20 years earlier.
From the first chapter, Viscount Devlin’s wait to confront his mother finally ends. From then until the end of this surprising book, much happens. Some threads are impossible to surmise— yet all the action occurs with the planned return of Napoleon to Paris.
From architecture, royal life, rose gardens, British diplomacy and hidden relics, the real historic backdrop to the mystery plaguing the Devlin family enhances this book. And totally had me avoiding Google so I didn’t spoil the book for myself.
As I read this I realized I really don’t know much about Napoleon’s wars and rule. Definitely need to read more— the Arch de Triumph, modern morgues and Paris’ catacombs all have the emperor in common.
June 2, 2022
Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, has brought his family to Paris to finally locate his mother Sophie. He’s confirmed that she has taken the name Sophia Cappella and lives in the city. It’s March 1815, a turbulent time in France where Napoleon is in exile and the Bourbon King Louis VIII has been restored to the throne but rumors abound that the emperor plans to return. Tragically, Sebastian’s reunion with his mother is short lived when he comes upon her as she lay dying not far from where he was staying. Someone had stabbed and thrown her off of a footbridge, leaving her to die. When it becomes clear that French authorities have no interest in finding her killer, Sebastian begins investigating the most important case he’s ever undertaken. That pursuit will reveal much of Sophie’s secrets, placing him at the center of France’s political turmoil.
My knowledge of France’s history during this time is embarrassingly limited, as I’ve never understood the post revolution monarchy shifts, finding the whole era confusing. I began this story solely focused on Sebastian finding his mother and perhaps finally learning the identity of his biological father. What I hadn’t anticipated was being fascinated with the history of this period. The author cleverly used Sophie as a critical figure in the political machinations involving Napoleon’s emergence from exile. Her long term relationship with one of his marshals, Alexandre McClellan (fictional), has deeper implications, too. Who knew I’d finally understand those leadership shifts in the aristocracy and what inspired the people to re-embrace the exiled emperor and why he was destined to ultimately fail.
Though the historical elements once again captured my imagination, it was Sebastian and wife Hero who took hold of my heart. His grief was palpable and her commitment to his dogged determination to find Sophie’s killer reminded me how much I loved their union. Hero is a formidable partner and if Sebastian ever needed one, it was during this investigation. The journey to the truth led them to many curious people who were connected to Sophie, also giving them insight into who she was for the past twenty years. It wasn’t ever clear who they could trust and all seem to have their own agendas. It was a dangerous time for those connected to the aristocracy as they had to balance allegiances as they were subject to change overnight and back again. All of this was presented against the backdrop of historic Paris, told in such vivid detail I felt I could see, smell and hear the city. This was a brilliantly written story that didn’t provide all the answers I was hoping to find but brought me (and Sebastian) closer to finding the truth. I’m just happy I also got an incredible history lesson in the meantime. Prepare to Google as you work through the story!
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to Berkley and NetGalley for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
My knowledge of France’s history during this time is embarrassingly limited, as I’ve never understood the post revolution monarchy shifts, finding the whole era confusing. I began this story solely focused on Sebastian finding his mother and perhaps finally learning the identity of his biological father. What I hadn’t anticipated was being fascinated with the history of this period. The author cleverly used Sophie as a critical figure in the political machinations involving Napoleon’s emergence from exile. Her long term relationship with one of his marshals, Alexandre McClellan (fictional), has deeper implications, too. Who knew I’d finally understand those leadership shifts in the aristocracy and what inspired the people to re-embrace the exiled emperor and why he was destined to ultimately fail.
Though the historical elements once again captured my imagination, it was Sebastian and wife Hero who took hold of my heart. His grief was palpable and her commitment to his dogged determination to find Sophie’s killer reminded me how much I loved their union. Hero is a formidable partner and if Sebastian ever needed one, it was during this investigation. The journey to the truth led them to many curious people who were connected to Sophie, also giving them insight into who she was for the past twenty years. It wasn’t ever clear who they could trust and all seem to have their own agendas. It was a dangerous time for those connected to the aristocracy as they had to balance allegiances as they were subject to change overnight and back again. All of this was presented against the backdrop of historic Paris, told in such vivid detail I felt I could see, smell and hear the city. This was a brilliantly written story that didn’t provide all the answers I was hoping to find but brought me (and Sebastian) closer to finding the truth. I’m just happy I also got an incredible history lesson in the meantime. Prepare to Google as you work through the story!
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to Berkley and NetGalley for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
May 22, 2022
After all his years searching for his mother, Sebastian and his wife Hero are finally able to follow go to Paris to follow up leads that she is living there under an assumed name. Napoleon is on exile on Elba and the Bourbon King Louis XVIII is back on the throne, making it once again safe for the English to travel to France. Sadly for Sebastian, he does find his mother, but only as she is lying dying after being stabbed and thrown off a bridge. Sebastian is determined not to return to London before he finds her killer, despite Napoleon’s escape from Elba and imminent return to Paris.
This is an excellent addition to the series, although questions still remain to be answered about the identity of Sebastian’s father and why his mother had to fake her death and disappear. In addition to the well written plots, it’s the accurate historical details and the strength of the characters that make this such a good series. Hero and Sebastian are both such strong and compassionate characters and I love the way they support each other during Sebastian’s investigations. The historic details and the evocative descriptions of early nineteenth century Paris combine to create a very atmospheric mystery. The end of the novel leaves Sebastian and Hero in a politically dangerous position so it will be an anxious wait for the next episode to see what happens to them next.
This is an excellent addition to the series, although questions still remain to be answered about the identity of Sebastian’s father and why his mother had to fake her death and disappear. In addition to the well written plots, it’s the accurate historical details and the strength of the characters that make this such a good series. Hero and Sebastian are both such strong and compassionate characters and I love the way they support each other during Sebastian’s investigations. The historic details and the evocative descriptions of early nineteenth century Paris combine to create a very atmospheric mystery. The end of the novel leaves Sebastian and Hero in a politically dangerous position so it will be an anxious wait for the next episode to see what happens to them next.
May 10, 2024
Ugh— that feeling you get after you’ve read two chapters and you realize you’ve already read the book you’ve been looking forward to reading!
Napoleon and Paris are no match for Devlin, Hero and compatriots. This was a really good mystery but it was tinged with sadness as well.
One long standing storyline has been Devlin’s troubled history with his mother who abandoned he and his family when he was a child. Finally Devlin and longtime readers can close the book on that plot point.
Still, there’s a lot of mystery surrounding his real father’s identity and Devlin always finds himself solving one mystery or another for other privileged people. My hope is the next book will bring him and his young family back to London
(Reviewed 6/2922)
Napoleon and Paris are no match for Devlin, Hero and compatriots. This was a really good mystery but it was tinged with sadness as well.
One long standing storyline has been Devlin’s troubled history with his mother who abandoned he and his family when he was a child. Finally Devlin and longtime readers can close the book on that plot point.
Still, there’s a lot of mystery surrounding his real father’s identity and Devlin always finds himself solving one mystery or another for other privileged people. My hope is the next book will bring him and his young family back to London
(Reviewed 6/2922)
April 26, 2022
Very intense latest book in the series.
After all those years of searching, I was totally heartbroken for Sebastian 🥺.
All ended with a tragedy. It really wasn’t fair for him but at least he got some answers about his parentage, Nothing conclusive yet. Except, if Ms. Harris wants to write another plot twist story, and Sebastian will meet ‘the guy’ sometimes in the future. Which I think, he probably should, after seeing how’s his mum ended and to understand what went on with his past.
I don’t really believe with coincidence, those letter, painting and Welsh grand-mère said it all.
Anyway, you should read this series if you have not started yet.
Start with book #1 and just put up with a different heroine for the first three books and you will meet the absolutely wonderful heroine after that 😘.
You know what? I spent hours after finishing this book reading about Napoleon, The Hundreds Days, Marie-Thérèse and Wellington! Very interesting history and The Sickman Putin is just one guy from a long list. Us human, really do have a short memory, don’t we? 😐.
Well, I can’t wait for more stories from my favourite couple 😘.
❤️❤️❤️
After all those years of searching, I was totally heartbroken for Sebastian 🥺.
All ended with a tragedy. It really wasn’t fair for him but at least he got some answers about his parentage, Nothing conclusive yet. Except, if Ms. Harris wants to write another plot twist story, and Sebastian will meet ‘the guy’ sometimes in the future. Which I think, he probably should, after seeing how’s his mum ended and to understand what went on with his past.
I don’t really believe with coincidence, those letter, painting and Welsh grand-mère said it all.
Anyway, you should read this series if you have not started yet.
Start with book #1 and just put up with a different heroine for the first three books and you will meet the absolutely wonderful heroine after that 😘.
You know what? I spent hours after finishing this book reading about Napoleon, The Hundreds Days, Marie-Thérèse and Wellington! Very interesting history and The Sickman Putin is just one guy from a long list. Us human, really do have a short memory, don’t we? 😐.
Well, I can’t wait for more stories from my favourite couple 😘.
❤️❤️❤️
April 10, 2022
A disappointing book, especially since there has already been a mistery regarding a piece of jewelery involved in a murder in Harris's earlier books in the series.
Considering the victim in this book is Sebastian's long lost mother, I miss a bigger emotional impact on him. The book felt just like a series of events following one another, and the whole explanation for the murder is flat and uninspiring.
Considering the victim in this book is Sebastian's long lost mother, I miss a bigger emotional impact on him. The book felt just like a series of events following one another, and the whole explanation for the murder is flat and uninspiring.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 17, 2022
The mystery of who killed Sebastian's mothers leads in many different directions. His family knew more about her than they had told Sebastian. I am enjoying the book as I am easily learning European history as I have always had an interest in the Napoleonic Wars. The author has a PhD in European history. Hero is a well written woman that is strong and also in keeping with the times. I enjoyed the reader and thought she did a fine job, and it is always hard to change after many years. I also agree Sebastain's voice needs to sound younger. The last few books have done little to advance the personal story and was glad this one did move it along a bit...not as much as I would like.
May 15, 2022
I've given this an A- at AAR, 4.5 stars rounded up.
I eagerly await the release of a new Sebastian St. Cyr book every year; we’re up to book seventeen with When Blood Lies and it’s one of the best of the recent instalments, a fabulous blend of whodunit and history set in Paris in March of 1815, in the days leading up to Napoleon’s escape from Elba. As the author has picked up the long-running storyline relating to Sebastian’s search for the truth about his parentage, it’s impossible to write a review of When Blood Lies without reference to earlier books in the series, so please be aware there are spoilers ahead.
For the last twenty-odd years, Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin and heir to the Earl of Hendon, believed his mother Sophia – who left her marriage and England when he was a boy – was dead. But he has recently discovered that is not the case, and in the previous book ( What the Devil Knows ) learned she was living in Paris, and was presently in Vienna, where negotiations between the various countries and states of Europe have been in progress for some time, as they work to rebuild following Napoleon’s defeat in 1814.
When this story begins, Sebastian, his wife Hero and their children are in Paris where he hopes, at long last, to meet with his errant mother on her return to the city and to finally get some answers to questions long unasked – even though he isn’t sure he’s ready to hear them. Walking the misty banks of the Seine one evening, he’s reached the Pont Neuf when his attention is caught by a glimpse of what looks like an out-flung arm down on the river bank; he hurries down the stone steps to discover the body of a tall, slim, well-dressed woman lying motionless at the water’s edge, her pale cheek smeared with blood. Bolts of recognition and devastation hit Sebastian when the woman looks into his eyes before uttering a single word – his name.
Sebastian has his mother taken to his house in the Place Dauphine, where he and Hero tend her as best they can while they wait for the doctor to arrive – but her injuries are too severe, and all the doctor can do when he arrives is accede to Sebastian’s request that he examine the body to see if he can give him some idea as to cause of her death. Sebastian suspects, given where she was found, that his mother may have fallen or been pushed from the bridge; the physician agrees that her injuries indicate a fall, but also tells Sebastian that she was stabbed in the back before being lifted and thrown over the parapet. Clearly, whatever happened was no accident – but Sebastian knows so little about his mother’s life over the past two decades that he has no inkling as to why she would be murdered. But that isn’t going to stop him from doing everything he possibly can to find out – no matter that his investigation will bring him into conflict with the most powerful families and factions in France.
There are a lot of moving parts to this story, all of them absolutely gripping, all of them very cleverly slotted together. The pacing is swift but not rushed; there’s time to absorb every new development before moving on to the next, each new piece of information often raising more questions than it answers. Sebastian learns that Sophia had been the mistress of one of Napoleon’s most trusted generals – a Scotsman to whom Sebastian bears more than a passing resemblance – who is now in Vienna negotiating on behalf of the newly reinstated Bourbons, and that after leaving Vienna, Sophia visited Napoleon on Elba before returning to Paris. But why? What’s the significance of the – now empty – jewellery case she was carrying on the night of her death? And what was she doing on the Pont Neuf that night? Sebastian and Hero have their work cut out as they search for the truth while the political situation in France hangs in the balance; the growing dissatisfaction of the populace with their Bourbon king has rumours that L’Empereur is about to return spreading like wildfire – and when the news reaches Paris that Napoleon has escaped his prison on Elba, Sebastian realises he’s running out of time… as, perhaps, is everyone around him.
When Blood Lies is an engrossing page-turner, a book I found difficult to set aside and was eager to get back to. The seamless way the author weaves her original plot threads through the fabric of history is masterful, as is the way she incorporates the various historical figures who appear throughout the tale. We see a little less of Hendon and Jarvis here – although the latter makes his presence felt in his usual inimitable fashion – but having Hero taking such a major role in the story is a big plus. She and Sebastian are so finely attuned that they appear almost able to read each other’s minds; I love the level of trust and understanding between them, and the way they bounce ideas off each other and help and support one another is wonderful to see. Sebastian goes through a lot in this book; grief for his mother, regret for their lost years together, frustration at the fact he may never now find out the identity of his biological father – which he tries to set aside while he tries to find the murderer, but his conflicted emotions are never far away and Hero is his rock.
Full of intrigue and suspense with a superbly-drawn cast of characters, a compelling leading man and packed to the gills with fascinating historical detail, When Blood Lies is another wonderful instalment in this excellent long-running mystery series. Now the waiting starts for book eighteen next year!
I eagerly await the release of a new Sebastian St. Cyr book every year; we’re up to book seventeen with When Blood Lies and it’s one of the best of the recent instalments, a fabulous blend of whodunit and history set in Paris in March of 1815, in the days leading up to Napoleon’s escape from Elba. As the author has picked up the long-running storyline relating to Sebastian’s search for the truth about his parentage, it’s impossible to write a review of When Blood Lies without reference to earlier books in the series, so please be aware there are spoilers ahead.
For the last twenty-odd years, Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin and heir to the Earl of Hendon, believed his mother Sophia – who left her marriage and England when he was a boy – was dead. But he has recently discovered that is not the case, and in the previous book ( What the Devil Knows ) learned she was living in Paris, and was presently in Vienna, where negotiations between the various countries and states of Europe have been in progress for some time, as they work to rebuild following Napoleon’s defeat in 1814.
When this story begins, Sebastian, his wife Hero and their children are in Paris where he hopes, at long last, to meet with his errant mother on her return to the city and to finally get some answers to questions long unasked – even though he isn’t sure he’s ready to hear them. Walking the misty banks of the Seine one evening, he’s reached the Pont Neuf when his attention is caught by a glimpse of what looks like an out-flung arm down on the river bank; he hurries down the stone steps to discover the body of a tall, slim, well-dressed woman lying motionless at the water’s edge, her pale cheek smeared with blood. Bolts of recognition and devastation hit Sebastian when the woman looks into his eyes before uttering a single word – his name.
Sebastian has his mother taken to his house in the Place Dauphine, where he and Hero tend her as best they can while they wait for the doctor to arrive – but her injuries are too severe, and all the doctor can do when he arrives is accede to Sebastian’s request that he examine the body to see if he can give him some idea as to cause of her death. Sebastian suspects, given where she was found, that his mother may have fallen or been pushed from the bridge; the physician agrees that her injuries indicate a fall, but also tells Sebastian that she was stabbed in the back before being lifted and thrown over the parapet. Clearly, whatever happened was no accident – but Sebastian knows so little about his mother’s life over the past two decades that he has no inkling as to why she would be murdered. But that isn’t going to stop him from doing everything he possibly can to find out – no matter that his investigation will bring him into conflict with the most powerful families and factions in France.
There are a lot of moving parts to this story, all of them absolutely gripping, all of them very cleverly slotted together. The pacing is swift but not rushed; there’s time to absorb every new development before moving on to the next, each new piece of information often raising more questions than it answers. Sebastian learns that Sophia had been the mistress of one of Napoleon’s most trusted generals – a Scotsman to whom Sebastian bears more than a passing resemblance – who is now in Vienna negotiating on behalf of the newly reinstated Bourbons, and that after leaving Vienna, Sophia visited Napoleon on Elba before returning to Paris. But why? What’s the significance of the – now empty – jewellery case she was carrying on the night of her death? And what was she doing on the Pont Neuf that night? Sebastian and Hero have their work cut out as they search for the truth while the political situation in France hangs in the balance; the growing dissatisfaction of the populace with their Bourbon king has rumours that L’Empereur is about to return spreading like wildfire – and when the news reaches Paris that Napoleon has escaped his prison on Elba, Sebastian realises he’s running out of time… as, perhaps, is everyone around him.
When Blood Lies is an engrossing page-turner, a book I found difficult to set aside and was eager to get back to. The seamless way the author weaves her original plot threads through the fabric of history is masterful, as is the way she incorporates the various historical figures who appear throughout the tale. We see a little less of Hendon and Jarvis here – although the latter makes his presence felt in his usual inimitable fashion – but having Hero taking such a major role in the story is a big plus. She and Sebastian are so finely attuned that they appear almost able to read each other’s minds; I love the level of trust and understanding between them, and the way they bounce ideas off each other and help and support one another is wonderful to see. Sebastian goes through a lot in this book; grief for his mother, regret for their lost years together, frustration at the fact he may never now find out the identity of his biological father – which he tries to set aside while he tries to find the murderer, but his conflicted emotions are never far away and Hero is his rock.
Full of intrigue and suspense with a superbly-drawn cast of characters, a compelling leading man and packed to the gills with fascinating historical detail, When Blood Lies is another wonderful instalment in this excellent long-running mystery series. Now the waiting starts for book eighteen next year!
January 31, 2024
C.S. Harris writes this series within the historical context of the time, and it is utterly captivating. The atmosphere is tangible that you feel part of the story not just the observer. Her writing style is brilliant and draws you right into the story and the mystery. The plot interwoven with important historical events was wonderfully done. All the characters are fascinating. Hero is my girl, for sure. She is one kick-a** woman.
Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, has been looking for his mother, Sophie, ever since he found out she didn't die in a boating accident. March, 1815, and peace between England and France is a reality. The Bourbon King is back on the throne and Napoleon has been exiled to the Isle of Elba off the coast of Italy. He and Hero are in Paris to find her. But Sebastian is too late, someone has murdered her. Sebastian is angry that she is dead, and he will never have the answers to his questions.
Her time in Paris is not without controversy and she lived openly as the mistress of a Napoleon general Maréchal Alexandre McClellan, the scion of a noble Scottish Jacobite family. Sebastian soon learns that the French authorities have no interest in finding her killer. Tracing her travels and interactions with the Bourbons and others is all Sebastian can do to find her killer. There are some who want him to fail and will do anything to make sure he does not succeed.
Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, has been looking for his mother, Sophie, ever since he found out she didn't die in a boating accident. March, 1815, and peace between England and France is a reality. The Bourbon King is back on the throne and Napoleon has been exiled to the Isle of Elba off the coast of Italy. He and Hero are in Paris to find her. But Sebastian is too late, someone has murdered her. Sebastian is angry that she is dead, and he will never have the answers to his questions.
Her time in Paris is not without controversy and she lived openly as the mistress of a Napoleon general Maréchal Alexandre McClellan, the scion of a noble Scottish Jacobite family. Sebastian soon learns that the French authorities have no interest in finding her killer. Tracing her travels and interactions with the Bourbons and others is all Sebastian can do to find her killer. There are some who want him to fail and will do anything to make sure he does not succeed.
April 18, 2022
I truly try to consider a book and my review for the sake of the book alone. Easier said than done sometimes. Take this one as an example. It isn't a bad book. I like the historical elements concerning the French Revolution and Napoleon. The mystery is OK; what I've come to expect from this series. Yet, I feel so let down by this book. For multiple books of this series, Harris has been building the reader toward a particular plot point (keeping this spoiler free is hard). This is the book in which that plot point would finally be realized. I was so excited! And then.....have you ever had a firework that is supposed to be a huge bang with all kinds of lights and colors but it instead just fizzles a little with barely a pop? A dud. I'll still read this series, and I'm interested in where it will go from here.
March 9, 2023
Reread/listened to the audiobook March'2023:
5 stars - Historical Mystery
I enjoyed this installment even more this time around. Davina Porter has been the audiobook narrator for all of the previous books in the series, and she's phenomenal. There's a different narrator for this book, Jenny Sterlin, and she did a good job. But I really missed Davina Porter's voice, especially her vocal characterization of Sebastian.
Original rating/review April'2022:
4-4.5 stars - Historical Mystery
This is one of my all-time favorite series. I love the characters and the way the author weaves real historical events, people, and places into the storyline and mystery. This time around, Sebastian and Hero are in Paris, and they end up trying to solve his mother's murder that seems connected to the political intrigue and machinations of the Bourbon court and Napoleon's potential return to Paris from his exile in Elba.
I've been so eager to read this book. I really liked it, but it's not one of my favorites of the series. The story dragged a bit at times, especially since some of the historical context, information, and details were extensive and seemed more like a French history lesson rather than being necessary for the story. I also missed the rest of the characters back in England.
My biggest issue/frustration is with the cliffhanger ending. The murder was solved, but I also think the author is dragging out the
Even though it wasn't one of my favorites of the series, When Blood Lies is still an intriguing mystery with characters I love, and C.S. Harris is a brilliant writer. I just wish the next book was coming out much sooner because it's going to be really hard waiting a year to find out what happens next.
When I read this series, I'm always amazed at how relevant and reminiscent the history is to current day. It's as if we've truly learned nothing.
"Who was it said that the periods of greatest happiness are the missing pages in our history books?"
"But in the end, the differences between a king and an emperor are not so great, hmm? Not great enough to die for. Both take money from the poor to buy fine gowns and jewels for their women and to accumulate more horses, carriages, and grand chateaus than anyone has need of. And both send the sons of the poor off to fight and die in their wars."
"But then I remember what France was like before the Revolution, the way they used to dash through the streets in their gilded carriages without a thought to the poor people they so often killed or maimed with impunity. The way they dressed in silks and velvets and wore diamond buckles on their shoes while tens of thousands of women and children starved to death. And I think, They could have done something to avert it all. They could have, except they were too selfish to share any of their massive wealth and power, and too arrogant to believe the people could ever rise up and take it from them. And because of their hubris and their greed, millions died. Millions."
5 stars - Historical Mystery
I enjoyed this installment even more this time around. Davina Porter has been the audiobook narrator for all of the previous books in the series, and she's phenomenal. There's a different narrator for this book, Jenny Sterlin, and she did a good job. But I really missed Davina Porter's voice, especially her vocal characterization of Sebastian.
Original rating/review April'2022:
4-4.5 stars - Historical Mystery
This is one of my all-time favorite series. I love the characters and the way the author weaves real historical events, people, and places into the storyline and mystery. This time around, Sebastian and Hero are in Paris, and they end up trying to solve his mother's murder that seems connected to the political intrigue and machinations of the Bourbon court and Napoleon's potential return to Paris from his exile in Elba.
I've been so eager to read this book. I really liked it, but it's not one of my favorites of the series. The story dragged a bit at times, especially since some of the historical context, information, and details were extensive and seemed more like a French history lesson rather than being necessary for the story. I also missed the rest of the characters back in England.
My biggest issue/frustration is with the cliffhanger ending. The murder was solved, but I also think the author is dragging out the
Even though it wasn't one of my favorites of the series, When Blood Lies is still an intriguing mystery with characters I love, and C.S. Harris is a brilliant writer. I just wish the next book was coming out much sooner because it's going to be really hard waiting a year to find out what happens next.
When I read this series, I'm always amazed at how relevant and reminiscent the history is to current day. It's as if we've truly learned nothing.
"Who was it said that the periods of greatest happiness are the missing pages in our history books?"
"But in the end, the differences between a king and an emperor are not so great, hmm? Not great enough to die for. Both take money from the poor to buy fine gowns and jewels for their women and to accumulate more horses, carriages, and grand chateaus than anyone has need of. And both send the sons of the poor off to fight and die in their wars."
"But then I remember what France was like before the Revolution, the way they used to dash through the streets in their gilded carriages without a thought to the poor people they so often killed or maimed with impunity. The way they dressed in silks and velvets and wore diamond buckles on their shoes while tens of thousands of women and children starved to death. And I think, They could have done something to avert it all. They could have, except they were too selfish to share any of their massive wealth and power, and too arrogant to believe the people could ever rise up and take it from them. And because of their hubris and their greed, millions died. Millions."
January 8, 2025
Beyond captivating installment❣️Five Stars wouldn't be enough for how fantastic this book was. Seriously. Please check out this book and experience it all in person if you have any doubts.
I've taken my time rearranging my thoughts and restraining myself to remain cool ~ calm and compassionate in my review. First off, the entire mystery was devoted to solving Dama Bianca Cappella/Sophie's vicious murder. I had an extremely negative view on the type of (fictional) person she was. Fortunately, how she died had already done justice to all the wrong she dumped on Sebastian. So! On my mind, it was already Case closed. No need to get into why/how she turned me cold.
I was so blown away by the chosen time period of March 1815 in Paris, in France to be exact, for this entire mystery. It was supposed to be a peaceful time since Napoléon was safely exiled in Elba, under the British guard. But the reality was just the opposite! Paris was boiling ~ already on the brink of massive destructive explosion again!
Sebastian and Hero as well as their entire small family were willingly living in the heart of the explosion itself. It was the only chance Sebastian had ~ after years of not knowing ~ of heartbreaking search for answers ~ to finally get to meet Sophie again after twenty long years~ to ask her questions face to face.
What a masterpiece of creating a perfect crime scene! Such a time of blatant anarchy! Sophie's murder didn't serve any high purpose! Sebastian was just there to witness her final moments! No last meaningful words! Her passing was like a piece of garbage got thrown away. But OMG ~ how Sebastian mourned her:
Gripping historical moments ~ heart pounding do or die actions ~ satisfactory moment when justice was served ~ and more ~ placed this historical mystery BEST of 2022 on my list! But the epic scene that clinched my #1 spot was the scene when Hero displayed a heroic love of a mother to save her child's life:
It was just and right. But there was no happy ending to be found here. Napoléon would enjoy his glorious 100 more days and spread more dead (bodies) and suffering far and wide! Again!
I've taken my time rearranging my thoughts and restraining myself to remain cool ~ calm and compassionate in my review. First off, the entire mystery was devoted to solving Dama Bianca Cappella/Sophie's vicious murder. I had an extremely negative view on the type of (fictional) person she was. Fortunately, how she died had already done justice to all the wrong she dumped on Sebastian. So! On my mind, it was already Case closed. No need to get into why/how she turned me cold.
I was so blown away by the chosen time period of March 1815 in Paris, in France to be exact, for this entire mystery. It was supposed to be a peaceful time since Napoléon was safely exiled in Elba, under the British guard. But the reality was just the opposite! Paris was boiling ~ already on the brink of massive destructive explosion again!
Sebastian and Hero as well as their entire small family were willingly living in the heart of the explosion itself. It was the only chance Sebastian had ~ after years of not knowing ~ of heartbreaking search for answers ~ to finally get to meet Sophie again after twenty long years~ to ask her questions face to face.
What a masterpiece of creating a perfect crime scene! Such a time of blatant anarchy! Sophie's murder didn't serve any high purpose! Sebastian was just there to witness her final moments! No last meaningful words! Her passing was like a piece of garbage got thrown away. But OMG ~ how Sebastian mourned her:
. . . and he felt his chest heave with a piercing sorrow and soul-wrenching sense of loss and sobs that went on and on until he thought they would never stop. . .
Gripping historical moments ~ heart pounding do or die actions ~ satisfactory moment when justice was served ~ and more ~ placed this historical mystery BEST of 2022 on my list! But the epic scene that clinched my #1 spot was the scene when Hero displayed a heroic love of a mother to save her child's life:
It was just and right. But there was no happy ending to be found here. Napoléon would enjoy his glorious 100 more days and spread more dead (bodies) and suffering far and wide! Again!
April 26, 2022
Amazing continuation of Devil’s search for the truth about his mother. Hero and the children are with him. But these are dangerous times. The Bourbon Royal family have regained the throne, but not the populace’s regard, Napoleon is cutting loose from Elba and violent murder is evident. We meet some of the more infamous characters of the time as Hero & Devlin take on a quest close to Devlin’s heart. So near and yet so far away!
I was trapped!
I was trapped!
April 8, 2022
There are important milestones I shall not reveal and therefore spoil this book for other fans of this series. Sebastian and Hero are in Paris, so we get the wonders of that city and the unrest of Napoleon on Elba. I find I cannot describe the action without spoilers, so I will just say this book will satisfy those interested in the history of France and Napoleon's life.
As is common, there are many dangerous situations for Sebastian and his family.
I think this is the best book of the series.
As is common, there are many dangerous situations for Sebastian and his family.
I think this is the best book of the series.
June 13, 2022
Another great entry in this series
Devlin and Hero find themselves in France at a particularly eventful time to solve a murder of someone close to them. History and fiction combine for a great read.
Devlin and Hero find themselves in France at a particularly eventful time to solve a murder of someone close to them. History and fiction combine for a great read.
July 31, 2024
After reading 17 books in this series, I think it's time for me to say goodbye to Sebastian St. Cyr. It's just the same stuff over and over again. This one was fine, didn't love it, didn't hate it.
April 24, 2023
4.5 stars, rounded up to 5 because I love this series with a love so true.
Wow! The author ups her game in this one, delivering a mystery that hits our hero (Sebastian St Cyr, Viscount Devlin) right in the heart. The book opens in early March, 1815. Devlin, his wife Hero, and their two small children are in Paris so that Devlin can continue his search for his mother, whom he last saw when he was a boy and whom he long believed to be dead. His search ends as he finds her late one evening, near death; she dies before she can name her killer.
Grief-striken, Devlin is determined to find out who killed his mother (who was going by the name Sophia Cappello) and for what reason. This leads him (and the reader) into the labyrinth of French politics. The Bourbons may have been restored to the throne when Napoleon abdicated in 1814 but they are not loved. Indeed they appear to be doing their best to make their subjects wish for Napoleon's return. Of course there are those who are actively working to free Napoleon from his exile on Elba.
As the story progresses it becomes apparent that Sophie was involved, somehow, in these machinations. Devlin finds himself (and his family) being threatened by Royalist supporters while others (probable Napoleon supporters) are less than forthcoming in answering his questions.
The author does a great job of balancing Devlin's quest against the backdrop of Napoleon's escape from Elba and his subsequent march on Paris. Ms Harris deftly weaves real people into her cast of characters--her author's afterword let's us know who was fictional and who wasn't.
Lord Jarvis and the Earl of Hendon make cameo appearances, as does Devlin's nasty sister Amanda.
For long-time readers who wonder if Devlin finally learns the identity of his father--well, you'll have to read the book. I am NOT going to spoil that part of the story. The mystery is cleared up and resolved in a very dramatic fashion
For those readers who, like me, having trouble remembering what exactly happened in earlier books--Devlin first tangled with Bourbon's Marie-Therese in Why Kings Confess, which also introduced Dr. Pelletan's fictitious daughter, Alexandrie Sauvage. It's been a while since I've read that book, so I've picked it up for a re-read.
The author drops a few hints at the end of the book to let us know there is more to come. Hurray! Now, we just have to wait...
ETA: re-read 4/24/2023. Still marvelous.
Wow! The author ups her game in this one, delivering a mystery that hits our hero (Sebastian St Cyr, Viscount Devlin) right in the heart. The book opens in early March, 1815. Devlin, his wife Hero, and their two small children are in Paris so that Devlin can continue his search for his mother, whom he last saw when he was a boy and whom he long believed to be dead. His search ends as he finds her late one evening, near death; she dies before she can name her killer.
Grief-striken, Devlin is determined to find out who killed his mother (who was going by the name Sophia Cappello) and for what reason. This leads him (and the reader) into the labyrinth of French politics. The Bourbons may have been restored to the throne when Napoleon abdicated in 1814 but they are not loved. Indeed they appear to be doing their best to make their subjects wish for Napoleon's return. Of course there are those who are actively working to free Napoleon from his exile on Elba.
As the story progresses it becomes apparent that Sophie was involved, somehow, in these machinations. Devlin finds himself (and his family) being threatened by Royalist supporters while others (probable Napoleon supporters) are less than forthcoming in answering his questions.
The author does a great job of balancing Devlin's quest against the backdrop of Napoleon's escape from Elba and his subsequent march on Paris. Ms Harris deftly weaves real people into her cast of characters--her author's afterword let's us know who was fictional and who wasn't.
Lord Jarvis and the Earl of Hendon make cameo appearances, as does Devlin's nasty sister Amanda.
For long-time readers who wonder if Devlin finally learns the identity of his father--well, you'll have to read the book. I am NOT going to spoil that part of the story. The mystery is cleared up and resolved in a very dramatic fashion
For those readers who, like me, having trouble remembering what exactly happened in earlier books--Devlin first tangled with Bourbon's Marie-Therese in Why Kings Confess, which also introduced Dr. Pelletan's fictitious daughter, Alexandrie Sauvage. It's been a while since I've read that book, so I've picked it up for a re-read.
The author drops a few hints at the end of the book to let us know there is more to come. Hurray! Now, we just have to wait...
ETA: re-read 4/24/2023. Still marvelous.
September 5, 2022
I will start off with a confession. I love this series by C.S. Harris. I've listened to the audio of each of the previous 16 and fell in love with the narration by Davina Porter. She became the voice of the storyteller for me so when Jenny Sterlin took over the audio for this volume of the series I hesitated. As much as I love listening to the latest adventures of Sebastian St. Cyr and Hero, a new narrator put me off.
I am glad I finally overcame my reservation and got to this great addition to the series. This is the most ambitious and complex of Harris's stories thus far. Or perhaps it was for me who had only sketchy background on French history during the early 1800's, just after the fall of Louie XVI, the Reign of Terror and the abdication of Napoleon. This book sent me back to Wikipedia more than once. There is so much here both in the story of Sebastian and the story of France. In the early pages Sebastian's mother is found but is dying. But at who's hands? This is the trail Sebastian much follow and in the usual fashion many more bodies will accumulate before it reaches a tentative end.
There are many, many characters introduced early, so I found I needed a print copy to refer to. As the story is set in Paris many of the usual persons who assist Sebastian are replaced by French counterparts. As usual it is impossible to tell who is telling the truth, who can be trusted and who the attackers are. Safe to say there will be several attempts on Sebastian and Hero's lives before it is over. I am not going to try to detail all the plot here. It revolves mainly around Sebastian's mothers connection to Napoleon through her lover, a highly successful general. The story circles through the days of the return of the Bourbons, and Napoleon's escape from Elba and march toward Paris, along with a scared amulet, the Talisman of Charlemagne.
It's a great, fun story but is not the best place to start in the series if you are not familiar with the backstory of these characters. I loved it and loved learning so much French history along the way. The author does leave me with enough questions that I am anxious for her next regardless of who narrates it.
P.S. Sterlin does a more an adequate job though I found her a little slow and sped the audio up to 1.1 which made it flow better. Also the Recorded Books version did not contain the historical note at the end by the author that gives such great factual context to events and characters and should not be missed.
4.5 stars rounded up
I am glad I finally overcame my reservation and got to this great addition to the series. This is the most ambitious and complex of Harris's stories thus far. Or perhaps it was for me who had only sketchy background on French history during the early 1800's, just after the fall of Louie XVI, the Reign of Terror and the abdication of Napoleon. This book sent me back to Wikipedia more than once. There is so much here both in the story of Sebastian and the story of France. In the early pages Sebastian's mother is found but is dying. But at who's hands? This is the trail Sebastian much follow and in the usual fashion many more bodies will accumulate before it reaches a tentative end.
There are many, many characters introduced early, so I found I needed a print copy to refer to. As the story is set in Paris many of the usual persons who assist Sebastian are replaced by French counterparts. As usual it is impossible to tell who is telling the truth, who can be trusted and who the attackers are. Safe to say there will be several attempts on Sebastian and Hero's lives before it is over. I am not going to try to detail all the plot here. It revolves mainly around Sebastian's mothers connection to Napoleon through her lover, a highly successful general. The story circles through the days of the return of the Bourbons, and Napoleon's escape from Elba and march toward Paris, along with a scared amulet, the Talisman of Charlemagne.
It's a great, fun story but is not the best place to start in the series if you are not familiar with the backstory of these characters. I loved it and loved learning so much French history along the way. The author does leave me with enough questions that I am anxious for her next regardless of who narrates it.
P.S. Sterlin does a more an adequate job though I found her a little slow and sped the audio up to 1.1 which made it flow better. Also the Recorded Books version did not contain the historical note at the end by the author that gives such great factual context to events and characters and should not be missed.
4.5 stars rounded up
July 3, 2022
I really enjoyed this instalment being set amongst these particular historical events and found them more interesting than most of the fictional plot. While I thought Devlin finally tracking down his mother was interesting, especially with the way it plays out, I'll admit there was only one family-oriented scene that really got me in my feels -- and it didn't even feature the main character.
I still sorta rolled my eyes and seeing the usual scenes play out but thankfully there were a few less than usual. Why Jarvis was included at all is kinda beyond me as he was useless and played into those usual scenes thing.
But mostly I'm just excited I picked up a book after.. weeks of not reading.
I still sorta rolled my eyes and seeing the usual scenes play out but thankfully there were a few less than usual. Why Jarvis was included at all is kinda beyond me as he was useless and played into those usual scenes thing.
But mostly I'm just excited I picked up a book after.. weeks of not reading.
November 24, 2022
This is one of my favorite historical mystery series - I have read every book, and admit I prefer the last several, since Hero has come on the scene. She is one of my favorite characters, and never disappoints.
This entry was everything I love about the series, and more - intricate puzzle, meticulous research, intriguing characters - but the first chapter was a gobsmacking opening! From there on, I knew I was in for a treat. The author didn’t disappoint, immersing the reader in Paris, tense from years of conflict and so much death - revolution, Reign of Terror, Napoleon’s rule, the restoration of the Bourbons - and finally, Napoleon’s escape from Elba.
The author has a PhD in nineteenth-century European history, and has written a nonfiction history of the French Revolution, so I knew the research was sound. I always learn a great deal when I read these mysteries; most take place in England, and it is the Regency era of Jane Austen, the ton, and countless romance novels, both good and bad. But St. Cyr and his wife Hero don’t spend much time at routs and balls! He investigates murders, and she researches and writes about social ills like child labor and the living conditions of the poor. St. Cyr believed for years that his beautiful, brilliant, headstrong mother died while fleeing from her husband, the Earl of Hendon (and their children). Over the course of the series, many painful personal truths have been revealed, as Sebastian brought this or that killer to justice, including
I don’t want to give any spoilers away, but as always, I am left looking forward to the next book - and as the author left us dangling with Sebastian and Hero still in Paris as Napoleon triumphantly returns from Elba, I can’t wait to read about how and when they get home to England. I also want to read more about French history - this book, along with an exciting, complex mystery, drives home the intrigues and factions and suffering of the period. Fascinating, gripping, engrossing historical mystery at its finest!
This entry was everything I love about the series, and more - intricate puzzle, meticulous research, intriguing characters - but the first chapter was a gobsmacking opening! From there on, I knew I was in for a treat. The author didn’t disappoint, immersing the reader in Paris, tense from years of conflict and so much death - revolution, Reign of Terror, Napoleon’s rule, the restoration of the Bourbons - and finally, Napoleon’s escape from Elba.
The author has a PhD in nineteenth-century European history, and has written a nonfiction history of the French Revolution, so I knew the research was sound. I always learn a great deal when I read these mysteries; most take place in England, and it is the Regency era of Jane Austen, the ton, and countless romance novels, both good and bad. But St. Cyr and his wife Hero don’t spend much time at routs and balls! He investigates murders, and she researches and writes about social ills like child labor and the living conditions of the poor. St. Cyr believed for years that his beautiful, brilliant, headstrong mother died while fleeing from her husband, the Earl of Hendon (and their children). Over the course of the series, many painful personal truths have been revealed, as Sebastian brought this or that killer to justice, including
I don’t want to give any spoilers away, but as always, I am left looking forward to the next book - and as the author left us dangling with Sebastian and Hero still in Paris as Napoleon triumphantly returns from Elba, I can’t wait to read about how and when they get home to England. I also want to read more about French history - this book, along with an exciting, complex mystery, drives home the intrigues and factions and suffering of the period. Fascinating, gripping, engrossing historical mystery at its finest!
April 5, 2022
One of the most vibrant, yet gritty historical mystery series on the market today captivates and meets readers intellectually and emotionally with a remarkable tale that is much more than a clever mystery set in the Regency period. This series is one of my most anticipated reads each year and makes my top favorites lists.
Opening Line
Thursday, 2 March 1815
One more day, he thought, one more day, perhaps two, and then… And then what?
Loc 86
Tragedy and Treason
With the peace after Napoleon is exiled to Elba, Sebastian and Hero come to Paris to meet the mother who abandoned her family when he was a child. He can perhaps come to know her again, but also get answers about his real father.
His long search leads to the heartbreaking moment he finds her not far from his house life nearly extinct. He is determined to discover the answers about the murder of the woman of mystery known as Sophia Cappello even when he is warned to leave it alone.
“In the past eleven months, we’ve torn down the tricolor and raised the white Bourbon flag, chipped the Emperor’s bees and eagles off our buildings, renamed squares and bridges, and replaced the prints of Napoleon in our shopwindows with those of Louis XVIII. Such external changes are easy. But beneath it all, resentments and hatreds linger. Fester… be careful, my lord. Be careful what questions you ask and be very careful whom you trust…”
Loc 281
Sebastian’s mother is not considered respectable after leaving her husband and children to be the mistress of one of Napoleon’s generals, but Sebastian learns she was more than an ornament on the man’s arm. Sophie had an eclectic group of friends and interests and made some powerful enemies because of her startling politics. Sophie’s recent journey took her to visit an island where a deposed Emperor sits in exile. Was his mother involved in a plot to restore Napoleon?
Not So Friendly Advice
Sophie’s secret activities are a powder keg to the new peace. In delving into those secrets, Sebastian discovers that a ruthless killer will stop at nothing to know something she knew and many simply want Sebastian to leave off his hunt for the truth.
In the past, Sebastian’s encounters with his wife’s father have been smoldering with mutual dislike and Lord Jarvis is in Paris to help the Bourbons transition back into power and their latest encounter is far from cordial.
“The last thing he wanted at that moment was a conversation with the British King’s powerful, Machiavellian cousin. But he leapt up to take the seat opposite his father-in-law anyway…Jarvis’ steely gray eyes narrowed. “There are things going on here about which you have no idea. Things that are far great importance than the death of one woman.” “Not to me”… “I will not tolerate your interference in an already volatile situation.” “I’m not dropping this investigation.”
Loc 1806
While conducting the investigation, Sebastian is helped by his intrepid wife who aches for Sebastian’s grief and need for answers. Hero will even plunge into the dank slums or face down armed thugs to discover the answers they need. And, a surprise source of aid comes from the sly one-time criminal Vidocq, the head of the newly formed Surete’. Most of those they question are holding back or outright lying and there is a menace toward Sebastian and those he holds dear.
“It was when Hero was studying the stall’s array of gaily painted wooden horses that she felt it again – that intense awareness of being watched. Of being watched by someone who did not wish her well.”
Loc 3524
Dynamic Detecting Duo
Sebastian and Hero are an incredible pair. Their story is told over several books and they have come into their own as a deeply loving, mutually respecting couple both in marriage and shared interests like detection.
Hero thinks of Sebastian: “How does one reduce a man to a few words? He is brilliant but good-humored… noble but quick-tempered and hardheaded…cynical and yet somehow also idealistic. And deadly when he needs to be.”
Loc 3343
And, Hero?
“…while Lady Devlin…” He paused as if searching for the right words. “She is a formidable woman.”
Loc 5070
Matters take their course and there are some breathtaking moments with a final blood-pumping scene before the book has a short denouement and an abrupt end that tantalizes the promise for the next installment.
Vive le Sebastian
The historical backdrop including real life characters and events, the twisting and often exciting mystery plot, and the complex relationships and situations all meld to deliver a fabulous and riveting book. The author even gives a playful nod toward beloved Jane Austen as Sebastian’s contemporary and old acquaintance from a previous case. While murder is the obvious element, the social injustices of the day as well as cultural history are brought to life so well that these are as much historical fiction as mystery which broadens the appeal to many more readers. My parting advice to newbies is prepare to binge.
I rec'd an eARC through NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
Opening Line
Thursday, 2 March 1815
One more day, he thought, one more day, perhaps two, and then… And then what?
Loc 86
Tragedy and Treason
With the peace after Napoleon is exiled to Elba, Sebastian and Hero come to Paris to meet the mother who abandoned her family when he was a child. He can perhaps come to know her again, but also get answers about his real father.
His long search leads to the heartbreaking moment he finds her not far from his house life nearly extinct. He is determined to discover the answers about the murder of the woman of mystery known as Sophia Cappello even when he is warned to leave it alone.
“In the past eleven months, we’ve torn down the tricolor and raised the white Bourbon flag, chipped the Emperor’s bees and eagles off our buildings, renamed squares and bridges, and replaced the prints of Napoleon in our shopwindows with those of Louis XVIII. Such external changes are easy. But beneath it all, resentments and hatreds linger. Fester… be careful, my lord. Be careful what questions you ask and be very careful whom you trust…”
Loc 281
Sebastian’s mother is not considered respectable after leaving her husband and children to be the mistress of one of Napoleon’s generals, but Sebastian learns she was more than an ornament on the man’s arm. Sophie had an eclectic group of friends and interests and made some powerful enemies because of her startling politics. Sophie’s recent journey took her to visit an island where a deposed Emperor sits in exile. Was his mother involved in a plot to restore Napoleon?
Not So Friendly Advice
Sophie’s secret activities are a powder keg to the new peace. In delving into those secrets, Sebastian discovers that a ruthless killer will stop at nothing to know something she knew and many simply want Sebastian to leave off his hunt for the truth.
In the past, Sebastian’s encounters with his wife’s father have been smoldering with mutual dislike and Lord Jarvis is in Paris to help the Bourbons transition back into power and their latest encounter is far from cordial.
“The last thing he wanted at that moment was a conversation with the British King’s powerful, Machiavellian cousin. But he leapt up to take the seat opposite his father-in-law anyway…Jarvis’ steely gray eyes narrowed. “There are things going on here about which you have no idea. Things that are far great importance than the death of one woman.” “Not to me”… “I will not tolerate your interference in an already volatile situation.” “I’m not dropping this investigation.”
Loc 1806
While conducting the investigation, Sebastian is helped by his intrepid wife who aches for Sebastian’s grief and need for answers. Hero will even plunge into the dank slums or face down armed thugs to discover the answers they need. And, a surprise source of aid comes from the sly one-time criminal Vidocq, the head of the newly formed Surete’. Most of those they question are holding back or outright lying and there is a menace toward Sebastian and those he holds dear.
“It was when Hero was studying the stall’s array of gaily painted wooden horses that she felt it again – that intense awareness of being watched. Of being watched by someone who did not wish her well.”
Loc 3524
Dynamic Detecting Duo
Sebastian and Hero are an incredible pair. Their story is told over several books and they have come into their own as a deeply loving, mutually respecting couple both in marriage and shared interests like detection.
Hero thinks of Sebastian: “How does one reduce a man to a few words? He is brilliant but good-humored… noble but quick-tempered and hardheaded…cynical and yet somehow also idealistic. And deadly when he needs to be.”
Loc 3343
And, Hero?
“…while Lady Devlin…” He paused as if searching for the right words. “She is a formidable woman.”
Loc 5070
Matters take their course and there are some breathtaking moments with a final blood-pumping scene before the book has a short denouement and an abrupt end that tantalizes the promise for the next installment.
Vive le Sebastian
The historical backdrop including real life characters and events, the twisting and often exciting mystery plot, and the complex relationships and situations all meld to deliver a fabulous and riveting book. The author even gives a playful nod toward beloved Jane Austen as Sebastian’s contemporary and old acquaintance from a previous case. While murder is the obvious element, the social injustices of the day as well as cultural history are brought to life so well that these are as much historical fiction as mystery which broadens the appeal to many more readers. My parting advice to newbies is prepare to binge.
I rec'd an eARC through NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
September 29, 2023
Davina Porter has narrated the past 16 books in this series and I was very disappointed when her voice did not greet me when starting book 17. After doing some online research I discovered that she has retired. Though I’m very happy for her, selfishly I am really going to miss her excellent narrating. I would listen to her narration at 1.5 speed and ended up speeding it up to 1.70 for Jenny Sterlin. What a tough job Sterlin has living up to her predecessor. She does a decent job except for her narration of the main character… Sebastian. She preforms his voice it too high pitched. I cringe every time she reads his parts. Definitely does not fit his character. Hope this changes in the coming books. At book 17 I’m too invested in these characters to set the series aside. so I’m really hoping Sterlin finds her groove and gets the narration back on track.
January 5, 2023
I did like this enough. I found the beginning slow and I read it slowly. I suppose I was disappointed after all of these novels that Sebastian never did get to see his mother alive.
April 7, 2022
Barbara’s rating: 5 of 5 Stars
Series: Sebastian St. Cyr #17
Publication Date: 4/5/22
Period: Regency - March 1815
Number of Pages: 326
One of the best things about the entire series is that it totally captivates you – both emotionally and intellectually. I always learn so much history right along with solving a complex, convoluted, and twisted mystery. I would say this is one of the best books in the series, but you wouldn’t believe me because I say that about each new book! It is truly a wonderful read and I devoured each and every word of it. It was so bittersweet with Sebastian finally finding his mother and then getting so little time with her. Sebastian and Hero have grown so close to each other and they are so loving and supportive – I just love that part of the story.
It is March of 1815; Napoleon has been exiled to Elba for a year; The Bourbons have been restored to the throne of France; Ex-Pats have returned to France; There is a conference being held to determine the future of France, Europe, and Napoleon. Unrest among the French citizens is also quietly present – they aren’t openly opposed to the Bourbons nor are they openly supportive of a return by Napoleon – but they are tired of the way they are being treated. Sebastian, Hero, and the two boys have traveled to Paris during these turbulent times so Sebastian can search for his mother, Sophie.
As a melancholy and frustrated Sebastian walks near the Seine, he finds a very badly injured woman – a woman he recognizes – his mother. She recognizes him immediately – but can only utter his name before he picks her up and rushes her to his leased home. When she dies from her wounds without saying anything else, Sebastian and Hero vow to solve the case – no matter where the evidence leads. And goodness does it take some strange twists and turns. Was his mother involved in espionage? Where had she been on her recent trip – and what was its purpose? Is she involved – directly or inadvertently – in Napoleon’s escape from Elba? Oh! What a tangled web of intrigue and deception for Sebastian and Hero to work through before they finally discover the truth.
I highly recommend this book and hope you will enjoy it as much as I did. The writing is superb, the characters are unique, interesting, and compelling, and the mystery will keep you guessing until the very end. Then, if you add in all of the very descriptive historical details, you’ll feel as if you are right there with the tensions rising as Napoleon escapes Elba and heads toward Paris. Truly an excellent read!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Series: Sebastian St. Cyr #17
Publication Date: 4/5/22
Period: Regency - March 1815
Number of Pages: 326
One of the best things about the entire series is that it totally captivates you – both emotionally and intellectually. I always learn so much history right along with solving a complex, convoluted, and twisted mystery. I would say this is one of the best books in the series, but you wouldn’t believe me because I say that about each new book! It is truly a wonderful read and I devoured each and every word of it. It was so bittersweet with Sebastian finally finding his mother and then getting so little time with her. Sebastian and Hero have grown so close to each other and they are so loving and supportive – I just love that part of the story.
It is March of 1815; Napoleon has been exiled to Elba for a year; The Bourbons have been restored to the throne of France; Ex-Pats have returned to France; There is a conference being held to determine the future of France, Europe, and Napoleon. Unrest among the French citizens is also quietly present – they aren’t openly opposed to the Bourbons nor are they openly supportive of a return by Napoleon – but they are tired of the way they are being treated. Sebastian, Hero, and the two boys have traveled to Paris during these turbulent times so Sebastian can search for his mother, Sophie.
As a melancholy and frustrated Sebastian walks near the Seine, he finds a very badly injured woman – a woman he recognizes – his mother. She recognizes him immediately – but can only utter his name before he picks her up and rushes her to his leased home. When she dies from her wounds without saying anything else, Sebastian and Hero vow to solve the case – no matter where the evidence leads. And goodness does it take some strange twists and turns. Was his mother involved in espionage? Where had she been on her recent trip – and what was its purpose? Is she involved – directly or inadvertently – in Napoleon’s escape from Elba? Oh! What a tangled web of intrigue and deception for Sebastian and Hero to work through before they finally discover the truth.
I highly recommend this book and hope you will enjoy it as much as I did. The writing is superb, the characters are unique, interesting, and compelling, and the mystery will keep you guessing until the very end. Then, if you add in all of the very descriptive historical details, you’ll feel as if you are right there with the tensions rising as Napoleon escapes Elba and heads toward Paris. Truly an excellent read!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
April 9, 2022
One of the fundamental arc of Sebastian's story finally comes to fruition, even in a rather disappointing way in my opinion, in this which is the 17th book in the series (better late than never). This time Devlin and Hero are on a trip to Paris in the period between Napoleon's exile in Elba and his return to power. The pace is always quite high and we get to know the more or less realistic but real-life character of Vidocq, who will later serve as the basis for the greatest literary detectives of the 1800s, from Sherlock Holmes to Javert.
Now the only mystery that remains is Sebastian's real father, but maybe another ten books will be needed for that too, although I really hope not.
Una delle arc fondamentali della storia di Sebastian arriva finalmente a compimento, anche in maniera piuttosto deludente secondo me, in questo che é il 17° libro della serie (meglio tardi che mai). Stavolta Devlin ed Hero sono in trasferta a Parigi nel periodo tra l'esilio di Napoleone all'Elba ed il suo ritorno al potere. Il ritmo é sempre piuttosto alto e noi facciamo la conoscenza con il personaggio piú o meno realistico, ma ai tempi reali, di Vidocq, che servirá poi come base per i piú grandi detective letterari del 1800, da Sherlock Holmes a Javert.
Adesso l'unica incognita resta il padre reale di Sebastian, ma magari anche per questo serviranno un'altra decina di libri, anche se io mi auguro proprio di no.
Now the only mystery that remains is Sebastian's real father, but maybe another ten books will be needed for that too, although I really hope not.
Una delle arc fondamentali della storia di Sebastian arriva finalmente a compimento, anche in maniera piuttosto deludente secondo me, in questo che é il 17° libro della serie (meglio tardi che mai). Stavolta Devlin ed Hero sono in trasferta a Parigi nel periodo tra l'esilio di Napoleone all'Elba ed il suo ritorno al potere. Il ritmo é sempre piuttosto alto e noi facciamo la conoscenza con il personaggio piú o meno realistico, ma ai tempi reali, di Vidocq, che servirá poi come base per i piú grandi detective letterari del 1800, da Sherlock Holmes a Javert.
Adesso l'unica incognita resta il padre reale di Sebastian, ma magari anche per questo serviranno un'altra decina di libri, anche se io mi auguro proprio di no.
May 29, 2022
Sebastian and Hero (and the entire extended family) have finally traveled abroad! While the fathers are in Paris on government business and some secondary characters are enjoying the return of Society during the Restoration, Sebastian and Hero have come to reunite Sebastian with his mother. We get to meet Sophia, but the meeting doesn’t go according to plan. Remember the heartache for Sebastian in the early books as his life was a complete mess? This is a throwback, except he has the support of Hero and that makes this less devastating to him (and us!).
At least seven murders occur as Sebastian and Hero try to find a killer and a valuable relic that Napoleon might want as he marches towards Paris, the Charlemagne Amulet. Along the way, they encounter a slew of real people, which makes this a very entertaining read for anyone who knows French history.
It’s lovely to see Hero being as fierce as ever, especially in a scene where their ward (the son of the man Sebastian thinks was his half-brother) is in danger and calls for his mother for the first time.
Jarvis is in the periphery for the first time, which is actually kind of nice. It opens the door for Sebastian to work with an interesting French official.
The question of who Sebastian’s biological father is comes up again as a portrait presents Sebastian with a likely candidate.
The last chapter is Hero’s alone and it is a great conclusion. How long do we have to wait for the next book?
At least seven murders occur as Sebastian and Hero try to find a killer and a valuable relic that Napoleon might want as he marches towards Paris, the Charlemagne Amulet. Along the way, they encounter a slew of real people, which makes this a very entertaining read for anyone who knows French history.
It’s lovely to see Hero being as fierce as ever, especially in a scene where their ward (the son of the man Sebastian thinks was his half-brother) is in danger and calls for his mother for the first time.
Jarvis is in the periphery for the first time, which is actually kind of nice. It opens the door for Sebastian to work with an interesting French official.
The question of who Sebastian’s biological father is comes up again as a portrait presents Sebastian with a likely candidate.
The last chapter is Hero’s alone and it is a great conclusion. How long do we have to wait for the next book?
June 11, 2022
I really enjoy this series and I always get excited when a new book comes out. This book did not disappoint. I found that the connection to Napoleon and the mystery regarding Sebastian's mother very intriguing. There are still more mysteries to be solved regarding Sebastian so I am waiting for the next book already.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 460 reviews