What do you think?
Rate this book
Count the Nights by Stars
A 2023 Christianity Today Book of the Year Award-winner!Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears. 1961. After a longtime resident at Nashville’s historic Maxwell House Hotel suffers a debilitating stroke, Audrey Whitfield is tasked with cleaning out the reclusive woman’s room. There, she discovers an elaborate scrapbook filled with memorabilia from the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Love notes on the backs of unmailed postcards inside capture Audrey’s imagination with hints of a forbidden romance . . . and troubling revelations about the disappearance of young women at the exposition. Audrey enlists the help of a handsome hotel guest as she tracks down clues and information about the mysterious “Peaches” and her regrets over one fateful day, nearly sixty-five years earlier. 1897. Outspoken and forward-thinking Priscilla Nichols isn’t willing to settle for just any man. She’s still holding out hope for love when she meets Luca Moretti on the eve of the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Charmed by the Italian immigrant’s boldness, Priscilla spends time exploring the wonderous sights of the expo with Luca—until a darkness overshadows the monthslong event. Haunted by a terrible truth, Priscilla and Luca are sent down separate paths as the night’s stars fade into dawn.
414 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2022
461 people are currently reading
3538 people want to read
About the author
Michelle Shocklee
11 books1,311 followersMichelle Shocklee is the author of several historical novels, including ALL WE THOUGHT WE KNEW, the 2025 Christy Award Book of the Year; APPALACHIAN SONG, a 2024 Christy Award Finalist; COUNT THE NIGHTS BY STARS, winner of the 2023 Christianity Today Book Award in Fiction; and UNDER THE TULIP TREE, a Christy Award & Selah Award finalist.
As a woman of mixed heritage--her father's family is Hispanic and her mother's roots go back to Germany--she has always celebrated diversity and feels it's important to see the world through the eyes of one another. Learning from the past and changing the future is why she writes historical fiction.
With both her sons grown and happily married, Michelle and her husband make their home in Tennessee.
Click the "Influences" link in Michelle's profile to read more about why the theme of forgiveness is important, even in fiction.
As a woman of mixed heritage--her father's family is Hispanic and her mother's roots go back to Germany--she has always celebrated diversity and feels it's important to see the world through the eyes of one another. Learning from the past and changing the future is why she writes historical fiction.
With both her sons grown and happily married, Michelle and her husband make their home in Tennessee.
Click the "Influences" link in Michelle's profile to read more about why the theme of forgiveness is important, even in fiction.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 444 reviews
April 13, 2022
1961 & 1897 Nashville
Lovely time slip novel!
The story line is interwoven with historical details about the historic Maxwell House Hotel (had no idea this was the namesake for the coffee), the Tennessee Centennial Exposition and human trafficking.
Both story lines were engaging and I loved how the font type changed to differentiate between the two time periods. The meaning of the title is revealed in the pages. "Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears."
A portion of the proceeds from purchasing this novel go to a Christian organization that helps rescue and restore victims of human trafficking.
Bravo to the author on an engaging and well written novel steeped in historical detail.
Lovely time slip novel!
The story line is interwoven with historical details about the historic Maxwell House Hotel (had no idea this was the namesake for the coffee), the Tennessee Centennial Exposition and human trafficking.
Both story lines were engaging and I loved how the font type changed to differentiate between the two time periods. The meaning of the title is revealed in the pages. "Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears."
A portion of the proceeds from purchasing this novel go to a Christian organization that helps rescue and restore victims of human trafficking.
Bravo to the author on an engaging and well written novel steeped in historical detail.
April 12, 2022
I think this is a first for me -- a dual timeline novel with two historical periods and I am amazed at how the author brought both so vibrantly to life. So many subtle details that enhanced both stories for me.
Now, here's where I struggle with what to say in a review because I can't figure out how to write it without posting spoilers so this is going to be the most general of reviews ever!
Emotionally gripping -- especially the 1897 timeline. It just gutted me in places. I kept thinking, no, this couldn't be happening even though I saw the foreshadowing. And Audrey's complicated life in 1961 -- going from a somewhat naive and sheltered college student to awakening to the injustice in the world, both past and present The growth in both heroines is phenomenal and I felt every growing pain right along with them.
Love the way the scrapbook binds these two timelines together and the expert way Shocklee weaves in and out of each era, always leaving me wanting more even as I was eager to jump back into the other timeline. Made for a seamless read that held me enthralled.
Now, here's where I struggle with what to say in a review because I can't figure out how to write it without posting spoilers so this is going to be the most general of reviews ever!
Emotionally gripping -- especially the 1897 timeline. It just gutted me in places. I kept thinking, no, this couldn't be happening even though I saw the foreshadowing. And Audrey's complicated life in 1961 -- going from a somewhat naive and sheltered college student to awakening to the injustice in the world, both past and present The growth in both heroines is phenomenal and I felt every growing pain right along with them.
Love the way the scrapbook binds these two timelines together and the expert way Shocklee weaves in and out of each era, always leaving me wanting more even as I was eager to jump back into the other timeline. Made for a seamless read that held me enthralled.
January 14, 2022
A gripping Christian dual timeline novel that moves seamlessly between 1961, when Audrey Whitfield cleans out the hotel room of a reclusive woman who's just had a stroke, and 1897, when Priscilla Nichols meets charming Italian immigrant Luca Moretti on the eve of the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. A woman goes missing that night and the event changes Priscilla's life forever. Tennessee in both eras comes fully alive in Shocklee's vivid narrative, as does the heartbreaking issue of human trafficking. A poignant and highly recommended read. Out March 8.
Thanks to the author, Tyndale, and Edelweiss for the ARC; opinions are mine.
Thanks to the author, Tyndale, and Edelweiss for the ARC; opinions are mine.
September 18, 2021
Hi Readers!
I'm getting excited about sharing this historical time-slip novel with you all. Lots of cool Nashville history is included--the 1897 Tennessee Centennial Exposition, the Maxwell House Hotel, 1960s Nashville, etc. There are also some really important truths running through these pages, with the heart of the story being "I see you."
I'll share more in the coming months as we get closer to the March 8, 2022 release date. I'd love it if you'd sign up for my newsletter -- click Contact Me on my website. It's a great way to stay up on all the news, contests, and giveaways!
See you in March!
I'm getting excited about sharing this historical time-slip novel with you all. Lots of cool Nashville history is included--the 1897 Tennessee Centennial Exposition, the Maxwell House Hotel, 1960s Nashville, etc. There are also some really important truths running through these pages, with the heart of the story being "I see you."
I'll share more in the coming months as we get closer to the March 8, 2022 release date. I'd love it if you'd sign up for my newsletter -- click Contact Me on my website. It's a great way to stay up on all the news, contests, and giveaways!
See you in March!
February 2, 2022
This dual-timeline novel takes us to Nashville, Tennessee in both 1897 and 1961. In 1961, Audrey Whitfield is home from college after the death of her mother. She is helping out her grief-stricken father at the historic Maxwell House Hotel. While cleaning out the room of an elderly guest who has had a stroke, she finds a scrapbook of mementos from the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Hints of a long-ago romance, and possible evidence of the disappearance of young women at the exposition, start Audrey on an investigation into Nashville’s past. In 1897, Priscilla Nichols is staying at the Maxwell House Hotel and exploring the Tennessee Centennial Exposition with her driver, Luca Moretti, until a disappearance changes everything.
This captivating story takes us to the exposition as it begins in 1897. The descriptions of the shining exhibits at Exposition Park make you feel as if you are there. Through the wealthy Priscilla and the working-class immigrant Gia, we see the oppression of women of the time in different ways. The haughty privilege and power seized and abused by the rich is also portrayed, and is shocking to behold. In 1961, Audrey learns more about the American civil rights movement through Jason, who wants to be a civil rights attorney. The reader learns the history of the movement and is told of lunch counter sit-ins and the Freedom Riders, fighting for equality against the evil Jim Crow laws. In 1897, when the disappearance occurs and the mystery begins, it is shocking and compelling. Audrey and Priscilla unravel elements of this secret in two timelines. At the same time, shadowy figures from the upper class try to interfere. Rich in history and mystery, Count the Nights by Stars is a novel that will teach and inspire.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers via Historical Novels Review Magazine. My review is voluntary and my opinions are my own.
This captivating story takes us to the exposition as it begins in 1897. The descriptions of the shining exhibits at Exposition Park make you feel as if you are there. Through the wealthy Priscilla and the working-class immigrant Gia, we see the oppression of women of the time in different ways. The haughty privilege and power seized and abused by the rich is also portrayed, and is shocking to behold. In 1961, Audrey learns more about the American civil rights movement through Jason, who wants to be a civil rights attorney. The reader learns the history of the movement and is told of lunch counter sit-ins and the Freedom Riders, fighting for equality against the evil Jim Crow laws. In 1897, when the disappearance occurs and the mystery begins, it is shocking and compelling. Audrey and Priscilla unravel elements of this secret in two timelines. At the same time, shadowy figures from the upper class try to interfere. Rich in history and mystery, Count the Nights by Stars is a novel that will teach and inspire.
I received a free copy of this book from the publishers via Historical Novels Review Magazine. My review is voluntary and my opinions are my own.
May 28, 2022
This book was so moving.... it explores darkness as well as beauty that can emerge from it when the right person takes on the purpose of seeing others for who they are beneath all the pain. I highly recommend this book!
September 7, 2022
My big beef with this book was that there was zero warning that it dealt with prostitution. I don’t mind reading about it in certain cases, but I love having warning about it right in the back-cover blurb so that I can decide whether or not I feel like investing my mental and emotional energies into such a tale. Some days I do; some days I don’t.
For some strange reason, I seem to be drawn to those books that feature a love triangle where one of the guys is completely abhorrent. I have no idea why this is, and it drives me nuts every time, but I stumble across this trope time after time after time…
I’m getting worn out on racial-issues-fueled books. I’ve simply grown beyond them and prefer not to read books in this trope very often anymore.
The first memorable moment of faith came at the 40% mark. That felt way too late in the game. Even after that mark, the faith thread felt practically non-existent for most of the story. It was much too light for my taste.
In the audio version, the transition between time periods was abrupt at times. Context helped to sort out which era each scene was in, but I did wonder a few times if there was a smoother way of transitioning from one era to the other.
I loved Audrey’s brother! He was so charming and delightful.
Luca was amazing. He was the type of hero I could root for: chivalrous and gallant to the core. My heart broke for his sister and how his story ended.
The Tennessee Centennial Exposition setting was so enjoyable! I love settings like that when the authors are able to bring them to life, which Mrs. Shocklee was able to do here. This aspect of the book was my favorite.
The scrapbook was phenomenal! I love how this was incorporated into the story and brought the leads of the 1960s’ era together.
Content: derogatory term, brothels, drugs, alcohol, prostitutes
For some strange reason, I seem to be drawn to those books that feature a love triangle where one of the guys is completely abhorrent. I have no idea why this is, and it drives me nuts every time, but I stumble across this trope time after time after time…
I’m getting worn out on racial-issues-fueled books. I’ve simply grown beyond them and prefer not to read books in this trope very often anymore.
The first memorable moment of faith came at the 40% mark. That felt way too late in the game. Even after that mark, the faith thread felt practically non-existent for most of the story. It was much too light for my taste.
In the audio version, the transition between time periods was abrupt at times. Context helped to sort out which era each scene was in, but I did wonder a few times if there was a smoother way of transitioning from one era to the other.
I loved Audrey’s brother! He was so charming and delightful.
Luca was amazing. He was the type of hero I could root for: chivalrous and gallant to the core. My heart broke for his sister and how his story ended.
The Tennessee Centennial Exposition setting was so enjoyable! I love settings like that when the authors are able to bring them to life, which Mrs. Shocklee was able to do here. This aspect of the book was my favorite.
The scrapbook was phenomenal! I love how this was incorporated into the story and brought the leads of the 1960s’ era together.
Content: derogatory term, brothels, drugs, alcohol, prostitutes
January 1, 2023
4.5⭐️
Two timelines, both in Nashville Tennessee, both regarding the Maxwell House Hotel:
May 1897 and December 1961. Priscilla Nichols is in both timelines.
Main characters in 1897:
Priscilla Nichols: A 25-year-old daughter of a wealthy railroad investor
Luca Moretti: Carriage driver for Maxwell House
Gia Moretti: Luca's 14-year-old sister, and Priscilla‘s lady’s maid
Kenton Thornley: Son of another wealthy investor staying at the Maxwell House, expected to marry Priscilla
Main characters in 1961
Audrey Whitfield: Helping her father out at the front desk of the Maxwell House Hotel
Jason Sumner: Staying at the Maxwell House for a couple of weeks on business
Priscilla Nichols: Elderly lady living in the Maxwell House Hotel
Emmet Whitfield: Audrey’s younger mentally challenged brother
This is one of those books you don’t want to put down. The main character (Priscilla) was 25 in 1897, unmarried, visiting Nashville with her parents to attend Tennessee’s Centennial Exposition. There she meets and befriends Luca, a carriage driver who is tasked with driving and escorting her to the Exposition daily.
In 1961 Priscilla's about 89 and has been living in the Maxwell House Hotel for the last 20 years, no visitors and no family that the staff knew of (which late in the book you’ll realize is odd).
The story reveals Priscilla's life between those years. The many things she experienced and learned beyond her sheltered, privileged life went into a scrapbook, which in 1961 becomes a mystery for Audrey and Jason to unravel, enriching their lives in the end.
My only issue was the Italian accents both Luca and Gia had. Luca was two when he came to America, and Gia was born here. Why do they have accents? Why do they call people Sigñora and Sigñorina? All they’ve ever known is America. This was off-putting to me being raised in an Italian household with aunts who were born in Italy, came here young, and only spoke Italian until they went to school. They had no trace of an accent in their adult years. If the author had placed Luca and Gia's immigration, like, 5 years before, this would have made more sense. But then their history in New York would have been skewed.
Ah well, it was clean and entertaining, with an intrinsic faith element. This is one really good story I’d recommend.
Two timelines, both in Nashville Tennessee, both regarding the Maxwell House Hotel:
May 1897 and December 1961. Priscilla Nichols is in both timelines.
Main characters in 1897:
Priscilla Nichols: A 25-year-old daughter of a wealthy railroad investor
Luca Moretti: Carriage driver for Maxwell House
Gia Moretti: Luca's 14-year-old sister, and Priscilla‘s lady’s maid
Kenton Thornley: Son of another wealthy investor staying at the Maxwell House, expected to marry Priscilla
Main characters in 1961
Audrey Whitfield: Helping her father out at the front desk of the Maxwell House Hotel
Jason Sumner: Staying at the Maxwell House for a couple of weeks on business
Priscilla Nichols: Elderly lady living in the Maxwell House Hotel
Emmet Whitfield: Audrey’s younger mentally challenged brother
This is one of those books you don’t want to put down. The main character (Priscilla) was 25 in 1897, unmarried, visiting Nashville with her parents to attend Tennessee’s Centennial Exposition. There she meets and befriends Luca, a carriage driver who is tasked with driving and escorting her to the Exposition daily.
In 1961 Priscilla's about 89 and has been living in the Maxwell House Hotel for the last 20 years, no visitors and no family that the staff knew of (which late in the book you’ll realize is odd).
The story reveals Priscilla's life between those years. The many things she experienced and learned beyond her sheltered, privileged life went into a scrapbook, which in 1961 becomes a mystery for Audrey and Jason to unravel, enriching their lives in the end.
My only issue was the Italian accents both Luca and Gia had. Luca was two when he came to America, and Gia was born here. Why do they have accents? Why do they call people Sigñora and Sigñorina? All they’ve ever known is America. This was off-putting to me being raised in an Italian household with aunts who were born in Italy, came here young, and only spoke Italian until they went to school. They had no trace of an accent in their adult years. If the author had placed Luca and Gia's immigration, like, 5 years before, this would have made more sense. But then their history in New York would have been skewed.
Ah well, it was clean and entertaining, with an intrinsic faith element. This is one really good story I’d recommend.
September 1, 2025
“Count your nights by stars, not shadows; count your life with smiles, not tears.”
― Michelle Shocklee, Count the Nights by Stars
Story: 4
Audio: 5
Narrator: Sarah Zimmerman
Available: Hoopla
Listen at 1.4 speed
I enjoyed this. The transitions between timelines was smoothly done and I thought the story moved at a good pace. As a history buff I was intrigued by this historical time period. Wish there had been an authors note explaining what parts, if any, were historically accurate and her motivation in writing about this particular time period/location. Natives of the Nashville area will really enjoy this.
Audio was well performed.
― Michelle Shocklee, Count the Nights by Stars
Story: 4
Audio: 5
Narrator: Sarah Zimmerman
Available: Hoopla
Listen at 1.4 speed
I enjoyed this. The transitions between timelines was smoothly done and I thought the story moved at a good pace. As a history buff I was intrigued by this historical time period. Wish there had been an authors note explaining what parts, if any, were historically accurate and her motivation in writing about this particular time period/location. Natives of the Nashville area will really enjoy this.
Audio was well performed.
September 30, 2022
A lovely dual timeline book! The individual stories were woven together seamlessly and I very much appreciated the topics tackled by the author--immigration, human trafficking, and treating all people with love and respect. Learning about the Tennessee Centennial Exposition was also fascinating, as I'd never heard of it. The romantic thread was unpredictable and satisfying. A touching story.
July 11, 2022
Wow. Literally wow. Going into this, I wasn't 100% sure what I was hoping for or expecting but by the end, I was blown away by...everything. There are a couple cons still which I'll get into but overall, this was such a heartfelt and captivating read. I literally gave up an entire night of sleep because I had to know how it ended. And the cover is great- every time I look at it, I think of Utah. My family went there last year and I dunno. Just something about the stars and the colors... I'm rambling.
Pros/Likes:
1) The past and present intertwined so satisfyingly. I marked this under my time-traveler shelf. It's not exactly time travel but the past (1897) and present (1961) definitely blend together to create an amazing story. And while I'm on the topic of history- this was the first time I'd ever heard of the Tennesse Centennial Exposition. It was neat learning something new.
2) I loved the frequent POV switches. They flowed so well, and I never had trouble keeping up.
3) The unexpected Christmas setting. I was definitely not expecting this to take place during Christmas (it seems more summer-y to me) but it was a fun surprise.
4) And, of course, we have to hit on the characters. At first, I was not a fan of Priscilla. She's the very definition of a strong female lead. Not that this is a bad thing, but she started out kind of annoying and snotty. As the story progressed, I had a better idea of why she craved her independence so badly. With her overbearing mom, absent dad, and Kenton (Blah!)- it's either cave to their every whim and be miserable or step out and be her own person. So, I can understand her motives and attitude for that reason. Her situation reminded me of Rose in the Titanic movie.
Luca was the best and I love his relationship with his sister, Gia. Audrey's character was very down-to-earth and relatable. Her relationship with her brother, Emmet, came off very real to life. I appreciated that all the characters were flawed and had regrets. They all had to overcome some sort of obstacle.
Cons/Dislikes:
1) Kenton. Need I even say more? Like he was the perfect villain to hate, and he was so well-written that I utterly despised seeing his very name in print.
2) I felt there was no well-deserved justice. It was very disheartening and frustrating to see evil people get off scot-free.
This is not a pro or a con but more of a content warning. A big theme of this story included prostitution and human trafficking. HOWEVER...there were no inappropriate scenes. I want to say there wasn't any language either. Never once did the content become too uncomfortable. I strongly believe the author handled this delicate and sensitive topic with both class and tact. Not only that but she offered hope and light rather than dwelling on the doom and gloom.
All in all- I very much enjoyed this. I loved the history, the sweet romance between Priscilla & Luca, and the message of hope and redemption. 4.5 star rating!
Pros/Likes:
1) The past and present intertwined so satisfyingly. I marked this under my time-traveler shelf. It's not exactly time travel but the past (1897) and present (1961) definitely blend together to create an amazing story. And while I'm on the topic of history- this was the first time I'd ever heard of the Tennesse Centennial Exposition. It was neat learning something new.
2) I loved the frequent POV switches. They flowed so well, and I never had trouble keeping up.
3) The unexpected Christmas setting. I was definitely not expecting this to take place during Christmas (it seems more summer-y to me) but it was a fun surprise.
4) And, of course, we have to hit on the characters. At first, I was not a fan of Priscilla. She's the very definition of a strong female lead. Not that this is a bad thing, but she started out kind of annoying and snotty. As the story progressed, I had a better idea of why she craved her independence so badly. With her overbearing mom, absent dad, and Kenton (Blah!)- it's either cave to their every whim and be miserable or step out and be her own person. So, I can understand her motives and attitude for that reason. Her situation reminded me of Rose in the Titanic movie.
Luca was the best and I love his relationship with his sister, Gia. Audrey's character was very down-to-earth and relatable. Her relationship with her brother, Emmet, came off very real to life. I appreciated that all the characters were flawed and had regrets. They all had to overcome some sort of obstacle.
Cons/Dislikes:
1) Kenton. Need I even say more? Like he was the perfect villain to hate, and he was so well-written that I utterly despised seeing his very name in print.
2) I felt there was no well-deserved justice. It was very disheartening and frustrating to see evil people get off scot-free.
This is not a pro or a con but more of a content warning. A big theme of this story included prostitution and human trafficking. HOWEVER...there were no inappropriate scenes. I want to say there wasn't any language either. Never once did the content become too uncomfortable. I strongly believe the author handled this delicate and sensitive topic with both class and tact. Not only that but she offered hope and light rather than dwelling on the doom and gloom.
All in all- I very much enjoyed this. I loved the history, the sweet romance between Priscilla & Luca, and the message of hope and redemption. 4.5 star rating!
April 25, 2023
Loved this story! Highly recommended!
March 23, 2022
No Spoilers!
Michelle Shocklee has penned a beautifully written, but intense dual-timeline—one that shattered my emotions like a broken mirror—the shards of which I never could completely recover.
Beginning at the Maxwell House Hotel in 1960 Nashville and alternating between the exciting Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1897, we meet two heroines who become connected by a mysterious scrapbook. A scrapbook hinting at a forbidden, all consuming love, the disappearance of young women at the exposition, and an enigmatic character dubbed "Peaches."
I enjoyed learning about the wondrous expo...an exhilarating month long event full of fun and frolic, but obscured by a darkness too deep to fathom. You will meet the handsome and honorable, Luca, his beautiful sister, Gia—and the wealthy woman he dares to fall in love with—whilst another romance is brewing later at the Maxwell House Hotel (pardon my pun!)
The haunting realities in this novel were emotionally hard to read and many times my eyes were filled with unshed tears, but oh, the lessons learned as each character evolves by the grace of God. Count the Nights by Stars literally kept me up burning the midnight oil—it was just that good.
“Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears." Luca
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Tyndale House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. All opinions expressed are my own.*
Michelle Shocklee has penned a beautifully written, but intense dual-timeline—one that shattered my emotions like a broken mirror—the shards of which I never could completely recover.
Beginning at the Maxwell House Hotel in 1960 Nashville and alternating between the exciting Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1897, we meet two heroines who become connected by a mysterious scrapbook. A scrapbook hinting at a forbidden, all consuming love, the disappearance of young women at the exposition, and an enigmatic character dubbed "Peaches."
I enjoyed learning about the wondrous expo...an exhilarating month long event full of fun and frolic, but obscured by a darkness too deep to fathom. You will meet the handsome and honorable, Luca, his beautiful sister, Gia—and the wealthy woman he dares to fall in love with—whilst another romance is brewing later at the Maxwell House Hotel (pardon my pun!)
The haunting realities in this novel were emotionally hard to read and many times my eyes were filled with unshed tears, but oh, the lessons learned as each character evolves by the grace of God. Count the Nights by Stars literally kept me up burning the midnight oil—it was just that good.
“Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears." Luca
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Tyndale House via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion. All opinions expressed are my own.*
November 1, 2023
Libby loan 10 hours Narrated by Sarah Zimmerman (A)
4.5 stars rounded up
This was not only an excellent work of historical fiction, it is also a story of Christian faith and the challenges that face those who seek to be obedient to serve God despite obstacles..
I had never heard of either the Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1987 or the Parthenon that still remains as an art museum in Nashville.. Nor had I heard of the Maxwell House Hotel. (Yes, the home of the famous coffee and a home of the KKK.) The book has a dual timeline that flows seamlessly between 1897 and 1961. So many books are now set in WWII. This is an interesting change of pace with a great mystery that involves a scrapbook made by a reclusive long-time resident of the Maxwell House.
Various subjects are dealt with with sensitivity, child trafficking, prostitution, gender inequality, class inequality, discrimination against immigrants, civil rights in the 1960s, women's rights, and the care of mentally challenged children. This is an exceptional book that would be a great change of pace for those who enjoy history but need a lighter read.
. Again, I used the internet to find photos of the Expedition and the original Maxwell House Hotel and more background about the hotel. The author does an exceptional job of bringing both vividly to the reader's imagination.
4.5 stars rounded up
This was not only an excellent work of historical fiction, it is also a story of Christian faith and the challenges that face those who seek to be obedient to serve God despite obstacles..
I had never heard of either the Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1987 or the Parthenon that still remains as an art museum in Nashville.. Nor had I heard of the Maxwell House Hotel. (Yes, the home of the famous coffee and a home of the KKK.) The book has a dual timeline that flows seamlessly between 1897 and 1961. So many books are now set in WWII. This is an interesting change of pace with a great mystery that involves a scrapbook made by a reclusive long-time resident of the Maxwell House.
Various subjects are dealt with with sensitivity, child trafficking, prostitution, gender inequality, class inequality, discrimination against immigrants, civil rights in the 1960s, women's rights, and the care of mentally challenged children. This is an exceptional book that would be a great change of pace for those who enjoy history but need a lighter read.
. Again, I used the internet to find photos of the Expedition and the original Maxwell House Hotel and more background about the hotel. The author does an exceptional job of bringing both vividly to the reader's imagination.
August 26, 2022
An enjoyable read. Always love learning new things through historical fiction. It was interesting to read about the history of the Maxwell House Hotel in Nashville and also about the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Thought it was also really neat how the phrase "count the nights by stars" is used in the story. It certainly made the perfect title for the book. Overall, it wasn't a super exciting read for me but was still an enjoyable one.
October 26, 2025
4.5 Her stories are always keep me invested.
April 6, 2024
This is my 3rd book that I’ve read by Michelle Shocklee in 2024, and she is quickly becoming one of my favorite authors! Loved this one! It is set in Nashville, which is where I live, so I enjoyed hearing of locations around the city that are familiar to me. The book vacillates between Nashville in 1897 during Tennessee’s 100th year Centennial Exposition and in the 1950s. One of Nashville’s most prominent landmarks today is the Parthenon, which if you tour it, you’ll learn was originally built for the 1897 Centennial Exposition. I have always been curious about that event, and I enjoyed the details of the 1897 Exposition in the book. I also enjoyed the storyline of Priscilla’s help in rescuing women who were being trafficked during that event and that time period. What an inspiration!
February 25, 2024
this was a very interesting, sweet, dual-timeline story about the Tennessee Centennial Exhibition. It felt very much like a fiction version of The Devil in the White City: Murder, Magic, and Madness at the Fair That Changed America. With that said, know that a main topic of this book is girls going missing, and ultimately being found working as prostitutes. A main character spends her life rescuing these girls and giving them a second chance.
I think my favorite part of the book was Emmet. It was so sweet to see a sister taking care of her special needs brother. There was one scene where I felt like crying (in the grocery store again).
For the christianity aspect I would give it a 2/5 rating. There were some good parts with Christian sentiments, but most of it was lacking Christianity.
Cleanliness: mentions of prostitutes and brothels, mentions of scantily clad women, a man gets beat up, sickness and death
I think my favorite part of the book was Emmet. It was so sweet to see a sister taking care of her special needs brother. There was one scene where I felt like crying (in the grocery store again).
For the christianity aspect I would give it a 2/5 rating. There were some good parts with Christian sentiments, but most of it was lacking Christianity.
Cleanliness: mentions of prostitutes and brothels, mentions of scantily clad women, a man gets beat up, sickness and death
March 30, 2022
A book rooted in history, love, and mystery, Count the Nights by Stars is a five-star read. In this book, the story is split between two timelines. One transports readers back to the last few years of the 19th century, where a young woman, Priscilla Nichols, meets two people who change the course of her life in ways she never imagines. I loved Priscilla’s story because it was beautiful, heartbreaking, and inspiring. The other timeline brings readers to the mid 20th century, where Audrey Whitfield, along with the help of her family, her friend Jason (and *hint* later on more than just a friend), and unexpected people help her unearth the mystery behind the scrapbook belonging to one of their hotel residents.
There are so many elements to this book I loved. One of them was how the author touched a lot on physical handicaps, as one of the character’s family members had Down syndrome. Learning what it must have been like for family members to care for someone who is handicapped and all that entails (personal sacrifice, struggle, and time) was so eye-opening to me. It made the story all the more beautiful as the characters discovered the beauty to be found in caring for those who cannot take care of themselves.
Also, the flow between past/present scenes was easy to track with and didn’t distract from the narrative of the story. Some books that include dual timelines often pull me out of one narrative before I’ve had enough time to submerge myself in the story and characters.
Finally, the storyline was so creative. I haven’t read any books that deal with the topics the author addressed in the same way, or even a similar way, as she did. Without spoiling anything, just know you’re in for a treat!
One thing I wish was done a little differently was maybe more of a clue or hint as to who the mysterious woman was who asked about the scrapbook and threatened several characters. Also, who or what was responsible for the hotel burning down. Unless I missed something, I don’t remember there being specific clarification on if it was the mystery woman or something else that started it. These two instances felt lacking a little in detail/clarity in my opinion (this may have just been me, though).
However, this is a small detail and does not take away from the beauty of this story!
One of my favorite quotes: “Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears.”
With intrigue, surprising twists, and tender scenes that leave you teary-eyed, this book is a must-read.
There are so many elements to this book I loved. One of them was how the author touched a lot on physical handicaps, as one of the character’s family members had Down syndrome. Learning what it must have been like for family members to care for someone who is handicapped and all that entails (personal sacrifice, struggle, and time) was so eye-opening to me. It made the story all the more beautiful as the characters discovered the beauty to be found in caring for those who cannot take care of themselves.
Also, the flow between past/present scenes was easy to track with and didn’t distract from the narrative of the story. Some books that include dual timelines often pull me out of one narrative before I’ve had enough time to submerge myself in the story and characters.
Finally, the storyline was so creative. I haven’t read any books that deal with the topics the author addressed in the same way, or even a similar way, as she did. Without spoiling anything, just know you’re in for a treat!
One thing I wish was done a little differently was maybe more of a clue or hint as to who the mysterious woman was who asked about the scrapbook and threatened several characters. Also, who or what was responsible for the hotel burning down. Unless I missed something, I don’t remember there being specific clarification on if it was the mystery woman or something else that started it. These two instances felt lacking a little in detail/clarity in my opinion (this may have just been me, though).
However, this is a small detail and does not take away from the beauty of this story!
One of my favorite quotes: “Count your nights by stars, not shadows. Count your life with smiles, not tears.”
With intrigue, surprising twists, and tender scenes that leave you teary-eyed, this book is a must-read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 6, 2024
I absolutely could not put this book down as it had me enthralled from the beginning. Split time books are quickly becoming my favorites especially when they are exceptional like this. I loved that both time settings were in the past and that scrapbook had me wanting to sit and look through it as that would be fascinating. It took me back in time to experience the exposition and also brought to light that evil existed even in those simpler times. Learning about the Maxwell Hotel was fascinating. So many things in this story gutted me and left me needing tissues. It is hard to put a review into words without spoilers so I will just say run to pick up a copy and settle in for words that leap off the page and into your heart and characters that you wish were in your life. I highly recommend reading.
I was blessed to win a copy of this book and made the mistake of not moving it to the top of my TBR pile. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I was blessed to win a copy of this book and made the mistake of not moving it to the top of my TBR pile. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
February 13, 2025
This had such a good storyline to it. I listened to it, so I do feel like I missed some parts. *I, sometimes, struggle with audio books because I get distracted.* I think I would’ve enjoyed this better if I read a hard copy.
I liked the dual timeline and thought the author did a great job at going back and forth without feeling like I was being jerked around.
I liked the dual timeline and thought the author did a great job at going back and forth without feeling like I was being jerked around.
February 13, 2022
This was a most anticipated book for me.
I wasn't disappointed not by far.
Lots of good things in this book along with the spiritual messages. My favorite thing of course.
The true message and theme of this book could be a reminder for us all in real life. The world would be a much better place in my opinion.
I finished this book in one day because it was so good!
5 stars for a well written story and unforgettable characters.
The dual time line was awesome too of course.
I used to not like them because they confused me at times but now I do. I love seeing how they wrap up into one.
I admired Audra and Priscilla very much. Their strength and endurance are amazing.
I enjoyed their journey and I learned a lot!
The descriptions the author writs made me feel like I was along for the ride.
Thank you for another wonderful story. I didn't want to put it down. I was sad when it ended.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own
I wasn't disappointed not by far.
Lots of good things in this book along with the spiritual messages. My favorite thing of course.
The true message and theme of this book could be a reminder for us all in real life. The world would be a much better place in my opinion.
I finished this book in one day because it was so good!
5 stars for a well written story and unforgettable characters.
The dual time line was awesome too of course.
I used to not like them because they confused me at times but now I do. I love seeing how they wrap up into one.
I admired Audra and Priscilla very much. Their strength and endurance are amazing.
I enjoyed their journey and I learned a lot!
The descriptions the author writs made me feel like I was along for the ride.
Thank you for another wonderful story. I didn't want to put it down. I was sad when it ended.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own
May 20, 2022
I first noticed Count the Nights by Stars because of the beautiful cover, and even though I don't often read Christian fiction, the premise appealed to me as well. I wasn't sure what to expect from this book, but when I borrowed it from the library, I found it so gripping that I didn't want to put it down. This is one of the strongest dual timeline novels I have ever read, and I was deeply invested in both the 1897 and 1961 storylines, especially as they overlap with shared settings and a sense of mystery. The author does an amazing job building suspense throughout the book, allowing the reader to know some aspects of what is coming while still holding back major reveals until the perfect time.
The characters are all realistic and sympathetic, and Michelle Shocklee creates a vivid sense of time and place in both time periods. I especially appreciated her attention to period details in the 1897 part of the story, since her heroine is convincingly invested in certain social causes while still belonging to a turn-of-the-century world of ideas. This character never seems too modern, and the author did an amazing job with the setting, bringing the Tennessee Centennial Exposition to life in a vivid way. I knew nothing about this event, but could picture everything vividly based on the author's descriptions. She included just the right amount of research, helping the reader feel like they're there without bogging the story down in too many details. The 1961 storyline is also pitch-perfect, and its mystery elements are incredibly engaging.
I highly recommend Count the Nights by Stars to teens and adults who enjoy historical fiction, novels with social themes, and stories about strong women. The novel also includes a touch of romance, and shares powerful messages about forgiveness, family, love, and justice. Also, although this is a Christian book, it has crossover appeal for mainstream audiences. The characters' faith is authentic to who they are, without ever seeming like a preachy add-on, and the book handles a variety of heavy and complex themes in a meaningful way. I found this book incredibly gripping and moving, and highly recommend it.
The characters are all realistic and sympathetic, and Michelle Shocklee creates a vivid sense of time and place in both time periods. I especially appreciated her attention to period details in the 1897 part of the story, since her heroine is convincingly invested in certain social causes while still belonging to a turn-of-the-century world of ideas. This character never seems too modern, and the author did an amazing job with the setting, bringing the Tennessee Centennial Exposition to life in a vivid way. I knew nothing about this event, but could picture everything vividly based on the author's descriptions. She included just the right amount of research, helping the reader feel like they're there without bogging the story down in too many details. The 1961 storyline is also pitch-perfect, and its mystery elements are incredibly engaging.
I highly recommend Count the Nights by Stars to teens and adults who enjoy historical fiction, novels with social themes, and stories about strong women. The novel also includes a touch of romance, and shares powerful messages about forgiveness, family, love, and justice. Also, although this is a Christian book, it has crossover appeal for mainstream audiences. The characters' faith is authentic to who they are, without ever seeming like a preachy add-on, and the book handles a variety of heavy and complex themes in a meaningful way. I found this book incredibly gripping and moving, and highly recommend it.
March 26, 2022
Such a beautifully written book about prejudice and judgement. A time slip novel that weaves back and forth seamlessly and is very easy to follow. A book of self sacrificing love and what results from seeing people for who they truly are. I read Under the Tulip Tree , loved it also, and this novel is even better! Can't wait to see what she writes next.
December 9, 2025
A beautifully written dual-time novel that tugs at your heart strings as the author carefully confronts the sensitive topics of prostitution and down syndrome. I was drawn in from the very beginning and brought to tears several times. This was my first time reading this author, and I will definitely be reading more. I listened to the audio version, and I really enjoyed the narrator Sarah Zimmerman. Her reading of the book was excellent and definitely added to the experience.
My favorite genre is historical fiction, and this was an absolutely perfect example of that. The history of the Maxwell House Hotel in both time periods was so interesting as well as the Tennessee Centennial Exposition which I knew nothing about before but now feel like I have been there.
The love stories portrayed were both beautiful. The lessons learned by the parents in both time periods were exceptional.
I highly recommend this book. Although the serious topics were dealt with very well, I would not give this to younger readers.
My favorite genre is historical fiction, and this was an absolutely perfect example of that. The history of the Maxwell House Hotel in both time periods was so interesting as well as the Tennessee Centennial Exposition which I knew nothing about before but now feel like I have been there.
The love stories portrayed were both beautiful. The lessons learned by the parents in both time periods were exceptional.
I highly recommend this book. Although the serious topics were dealt with very well, I would not give this to younger readers.
August 22, 2024
I'm not sure how to rate this book. It is very sad, and yet has so many life lessons and quotes about struggles and getting through hard times with God that it helped. From a historical perspective it was interesting learning about the big Nashville centennial celebration, I didn't even know that was a thing. All the other historical stuff around it was sad but interesting. It was also interesting learning about the Maxwell Hotel and where the Maxwell coffee brand comes from. I overall liked the time shift from past to future. It's interesting to hear about the hotel in it's days of glory and then it's later years. There were a few things left undone. It really left it open about the cause of the disaster and the threats. I did like how it resolved on some areas, but it was not a happy ending for most. I was very disappointed that at the end the author didn't have notes about what was fact and what was fiction. I looked a few things up but it only gives generalities. It might be good as a book club book for discussion, but not a feel happy book.
March 24, 2022
"That is our mission, dear. To see people for who they are beneath the pain. Beneath the sin. To see them as God sees them: a beautiful creation, with plans and purposes only he knows."
Count the Nights by Stars is a gripping split-time novel, bringing Nashville history to life in both the 1890s and 1960s. The iconic Maxwell House hotel plays a role in both timelines, as does the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Both Priscilla and Audrey are strong, compelling heroines - both coming to terms with their places in their families and their purpose in life. The story also shines a light on the dark subject of human trafficking in a powerful, eye-opening way. If you are looking for a poignant story that is rich with history, heartbreak, and hope, you have found it in Count the Nights by Stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Count the Nights by Stars is a gripping split-time novel, bringing Nashville history to life in both the 1890s and 1960s. The iconic Maxwell House hotel plays a role in both timelines, as does the Tennessee Centennial Exposition. Both Priscilla and Audrey are strong, compelling heroines - both coming to terms with their places in their families and their purpose in life. The story also shines a light on the dark subject of human trafficking in a powerful, eye-opening way. If you are looking for a poignant story that is rich with history, heartbreak, and hope, you have found it in Count the Nights by Stars.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
April 15, 2022
4.5 stars
April 1, 2022
Just like in the heart-felt, memorable novel, Under the Tulip Tree, the author takes readers to a moving and emotional time. This dual timeline story has readers experience the Tennessee Centennial Exposition in 1897, up close and personal through the eyes of, Priscilla Nichols twenty-five-year-old, whose father has spent lots of time and money on the celebration. Priscilla’s parents are concerned about this gathering and hire Luca and his sister Gia Moretti to be her guide throughout the festivities. Priscilla begins to see things she’s never noticed before.
Readers then get to know Audrey Whitfield in 1961. She’s a young lady grieving the death of her mother. She has put her plans on hold to help her father out at the Maxwell Hotel, at the same time caring for her special needs brother Emmett. He’s just witnessed an older woman collapse on the floor of a stroke. He runs to his sister for help.
While the woman is in the hospital recovering, Audrey and her friend Jason, helps sort out her things. It’s then they come across a fascinating scrap book that includes love letters to and from “Peaches” and “Luca” Both are intrigued by the letters, this love story, and the mystery behind it all. They want to know more (so did I).
Jason and Audrey read a story about six young immigrant women that disappeared during the exposition. No foul play is suspected and there is no investigation. Audrey says, “How could the police assume that there was no foul play? Six or more women gone, just like that. Their families or friends were obviously worried and reported them missing otherwise the newspaper wouldn’t have picked up the story.” So, the drama unfolds.
I loved learning about the Maxwell Hotel, and all that went into celebrating the 1897 Tennessee Centennial. I liked the sensitivity in which the author handled Audrey’s disabled brother, Emmett, and the human trafficking situation. She does a compelling job of shining light into the grim subject of human trafficking. It’s an eye opener!
This moving story is rich in history, filled with intrigue, great relatable, mysterious characters, with a few surprising twists, turns and tender scenes that leave you teary-eyed. This book is a must-read, for yourself and for book club!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I have received a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog www.bookfun.org
Readers then get to know Audrey Whitfield in 1961. She’s a young lady grieving the death of her mother. She has put her plans on hold to help her father out at the Maxwell Hotel, at the same time caring for her special needs brother Emmett. He’s just witnessed an older woman collapse on the floor of a stroke. He runs to his sister for help.
While the woman is in the hospital recovering, Audrey and her friend Jason, helps sort out her things. It’s then they come across a fascinating scrap book that includes love letters to and from “Peaches” and “Luca” Both are intrigued by the letters, this love story, and the mystery behind it all. They want to know more (so did I).
Jason and Audrey read a story about six young immigrant women that disappeared during the exposition. No foul play is suspected and there is no investigation. Audrey says, “How could the police assume that there was no foul play? Six or more women gone, just like that. Their families or friends were obviously worried and reported them missing otherwise the newspaper wouldn’t have picked up the story.” So, the drama unfolds.
I loved learning about the Maxwell Hotel, and all that went into celebrating the 1897 Tennessee Centennial. I liked the sensitivity in which the author handled Audrey’s disabled brother, Emmett, and the human trafficking situation. She does a compelling job of shining light into the grim subject of human trafficking. It’s an eye opener!
This moving story is rich in history, filled with intrigue, great relatable, mysterious characters, with a few surprising twists, turns and tender scenes that leave you teary-eyed. This book is a must-read, for yourself and for book club!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I have received a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog www.bookfun.org
July 20, 2025
3.5 rounded up to 4
This is a dual-timeline story starting with the Tennessee Centennial Exposition of 1897 featuring Priscilla and then picks up in 1961 featuring Audrey working at the hotel that Priscilla stayed at in 1897. In the 1961 timeline we are learn about the Exposition through a scrapbook Audrey finds and as puzzle pieces are put together we eventually learn all about Priscilla's time at the expo and how her life changed after this event. I was interested in the setting and it has made me really want to visit Nashville to see the Parthenon that was talked about so much in the book, but I did find that the story moved slow at times and did not keep me engaged the whole way through. I liked the characters, but I didn't fully connect with any one person in particular. I loved the scrapbook and the role it played and it gave me the urge to return to scrapbooking.
The theme I took away from the story is aim to see everyone - get to know your neighbour and treat everyone equal (men & woman, different races, those with special needs, etc.).
This is a dual-timeline story starting with the Tennessee Centennial Exposition of 1897 featuring Priscilla and then picks up in 1961 featuring Audrey working at the hotel that Priscilla stayed at in 1897. In the 1961 timeline we are learn about the Exposition through a scrapbook Audrey finds and as puzzle pieces are put together we eventually learn all about Priscilla's time at the expo and how her life changed after this event. I was interested in the setting and it has made me really want to visit Nashville to see the Parthenon that was talked about so much in the book, but I did find that the story moved slow at times and did not keep me engaged the whole way through. I liked the characters, but I didn't fully connect with any one person in particular. I loved the scrapbook and the role it played and it gave me the urge to return to scrapbooking.
The theme I took away from the story is aim to see everyone - get to know your neighbour and treat everyone equal (men & woman, different races, those with special needs, etc.).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 444 reviews