What do you think?
Rate this book


320 pages, Hardcover
First published March 28, 2023
I am going to take a break here to say that as a generic white person, this is something I can empathize with, but not necessarily sympathize; this is not a bad thing. I think, in general, especially us white Americans need to do better at empathizing with our POC peers and really LISTENING to them, even if we do not experience the same generational trauma, racism, etc etc etc - look, I am by no means a subject matter expert, but I know enough sometimes I need to just shut up, amplify voices, and listen. This is one of those cases. So I am not going to dig deep into here as I don't necessarily think I'm the best voice to listen to.
I'm going to get a little personal here and say that I wholly disagree with some other reviews that seems to think Tison was being unrealistic in depicting both of these brothers as "geniuses" in their own rights. Listen... being good at math, or finding highschool math easy, does not make you a genius. Having some artistic talent doesn't make you a genius. Hell, when I was in highschool I rarely, if ever, studied, and still did well on exams. That doesn't mean **I'm** a genius. I found this to be such a bizarre thing to fixate on given, you know, the wider context of the book as a whole - but I also understand that literature is entirely subjective.
But also, that review was from an adult, and as I often say when reviewing YA... YA isn't really for adults. Sure we can read YA, enjoy it, get something out of it - but that doesn't mean it's for us. And this book especially is not entirely for the "white gaze" (idk if that is a thing but if the male gaze is to hell with it).