What do you think?
Rate this book
Anything but Plain
It's not easy being the bishop's daughter, especially for Lydie Stoltzfus. She's not like other Amish girls, as much as she wishes she were. The only thing she does well is disappoint others. Leaving her family and church seems unbearable, but staying might be worse.
Knowing Lydie is "between" jobs, the local doctor asks her to fill in at the front desk for a few months. To Lydie, this is a boon. It gives her time to figure out how she's going to say goodbye to her neighbor, Nathan Yoder--the main reason she needs to leave Stoney Ridge. Nathan claims he's in love with her, but she knows she's not good enough for him. If in doubt, Nathan's father reminds her frequently.
As Dok spends time with Lydie, she recognizes symptoms of a disorder rare among the Amish. She offers treatment for Lydie. But will it be enough to make her stay? Or has help come too late?
Bestselling and award-winning author Suzanne Woods Fisher invites you back to Stoney Ridge, a small town that feels like an old friend.
***
"Readers will be won over by the delightful leads, and the nuanced treatment of Lydie's ADHD and crisis of faith brings depth to the narrative. This is another winner from Fisher."-- Publishers Weekly
Knowing Lydie is "between" jobs, the local doctor asks her to fill in at the front desk for a few months. To Lydie, this is a boon. It gives her time to figure out how she's going to say goodbye to her neighbor, Nathan Yoder--the main reason she needs to leave Stoney Ridge. Nathan claims he's in love with her, but she knows she's not good enough for him. If in doubt, Nathan's father reminds her frequently.
As Dok spends time with Lydie, she recognizes symptoms of a disorder rare among the Amish. She offers treatment for Lydie. But will it be enough to make her stay? Or has help come too late?
Bestselling and award-winning author Suzanne Woods Fisher invites you back to Stoney Ridge, a small town that feels like an old friend.
***
"Readers will be won over by the delightful leads, and the nuanced treatment of Lydie's ADHD and crisis of faith brings depth to the narrative. This is another winner from Fisher."-- Publishers Weekly
320 pages, Paperback
Published October 4, 2022
91 people are currently reading
3596 people want to read
About the author
Suzanne Woods Fisher
73 books3,966 followersSuzanne Woods Fisher is the bestselling, award winning author of fiction and non-fiction books about the Old Order Amish for Revell Books, host of the radio-show-turned-blog Amish Wisdom, a columnist for Christian Post and Cooking & Such magazine.
Her interest in the Amish began with her grandfather, who was raised Plain. A theme in her books (her life!) is that you don’t have to “go Amish” to incorporate the principles of simple living.
Suzanne lives in California with her family and raises puppies for Guide Dogs for the Blind. To her way of thinking, you just can't life too seriously when a puppy is tearing through your house with someone's underwear in its mouth.
Suzanne can be found on-line at: www.suzannewoodsfisher.com
Her interest in the Amish began with her grandfather, who was raised Plain. A theme in her books (her life!) is that you don’t have to “go Amish” to incorporate the principles of simple living.
Suzanne lives in California with her family and raises puppies for Guide Dogs for the Blind. To her way of thinking, you just can't life too seriously when a puppy is tearing through your house with someone's underwear in its mouth.
Suzanne can be found on-line at: www.suzannewoodsfisher.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews
March 16, 2023
This is a Clean Amish Romance. I loved that this book has ADHD awareness, and I think it did a good job showing how ADHD can affect your life. I enjoyed getting to know the characters in this book. I also loved seeing the person all the other Amish people think little about starts to overcome and shine. I think the romance in this book was slow to get moving, but it was cute and sweet. This book was a good Amish fiction read. I was kindly provided an e-copy of this book by the publisher (Fleming H. Revell Company) or author (Suzanne Woods Fisher) via NetGalley, so I can give an honest review about how I feel about this book. I want to send a big Thank you to them for that.
October 13, 2022
This story is about two endearing young people who have been friends since they were six years old. Lydia's life is frustrating to her and to her family. She cannot hold down a job, cannot stay focused and finish tasks. On the other hand, she is humble, creative, thoughtful, and handles crisis well. Lydia began working for her aunt, a doctor who left the Amish faith to study medicine, Dok Ruth realizes that she and Lydia share a common disorder, ADHD. She wants to help Lydia find ways to make her life better.
Nathan Yoder loves to farm and would like to see his family go back to his grandfather's way of organic farming. His dad and brother are into using chemicals. His dad decides to allow each brother to farm one half of the farm their way. Whoever turns out the best harvest gets to farm the whole farm as they wish.
Nathan loves Lydia. And she loves Nathan but, in her mind, she doesn't deserve him. This book is about the two but so much more. Lydia's dad, David, is bishop of the Amish district and has his own issues to deal with, including his mom moving in, causing problems. A lot goes on in the inspiring story bringing out all the emotions, happy, sad, funny, frustrating, anger, jealousy, and fear but all coming together to make a great read with some important spiritual life lessons. Highly recommended for lovers of Amish and Christian romance fiction.
I received a complimentary copy from Revell Publishing and NetGalley for the purpose of an honest review. All thoughts are mine only.
Nathan Yoder loves to farm and would like to see his family go back to his grandfather's way of organic farming. His dad and brother are into using chemicals. His dad decides to allow each brother to farm one half of the farm their way. Whoever turns out the best harvest gets to farm the whole farm as they wish.
Nathan loves Lydia. And she loves Nathan but, in her mind, she doesn't deserve him. This book is about the two but so much more. Lydia's dad, David, is bishop of the Amish district and has his own issues to deal with, including his mom moving in, causing problems. A lot goes on in the inspiring story bringing out all the emotions, happy, sad, funny, frustrating, anger, jealousy, and fear but all coming together to make a great read with some important spiritual life lessons. Highly recommended for lovers of Amish and Christian romance fiction.
I received a complimentary copy from Revell Publishing and NetGalley for the purpose of an honest review. All thoughts are mine only.
October 17, 2022
ANYTHING BUT PLAIN hooked me from the very first page! I’ve never read a story about Amish special needs children and this one really will pull on the reader’s heart strings. ANYTHING BUT PLAIN is filled with forgiveness, family, and love and had me staying up way too late one night to finish! I had to know where Suzanne Woods Fisher was taking us and what would happen to this family. There is so much heart in Suzanne’s writing that I was left with a huge smile on my face and my heart very happy. All of the characters are very interesting and believable, so much so that I felt as if I’ve known them for a long time. Now I need to figure out how to fit more of Suzanne’s books into my reading plans!
ANYTHING BUT PLAIN is not the first book I’ve read by Suzanne Woods Fisher and it won’t be the last. She has a way of grabbing her readers and she never lets us go and now I’m kicking myself for not making time to read all of her books! Shocking twists and turns I never saw coming blew my mind and the humor kept me laughing so much. As with all of Suzanne Woods Fisher’s books, this is another awesome read! Filled with a host of secrets coming from all directions, ANYTHING BUT PLAIN is sure to capture your attention and give you several hours of enjoyable entertainment.
Once I started reading ANYTHING BUT PLAIN it was very hard to stop. Even though it is 320 pages it was a very quick read. My emotions were all over the place and the special needs Lydie is dealing with, won my heart right away. My heart broke for Nathan with him not understanding what kept Lydie away from him and his heart. He never gave up on her and I was cheering for him all the way! I’m so excited to read more by this wonderful author. Suzanne has a way of telling a story that completely absorbs the reader and makes them feel like they are part of the story. Suzanne Woods Fisher is one of my favorite Amish authors and I love devouring her books.
I was given a copy of this book by CelebrateLit and Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
ANYTHING BUT PLAIN is not the first book I’ve read by Suzanne Woods Fisher and it won’t be the last. She has a way of grabbing her readers and she never lets us go and now I’m kicking myself for not making time to read all of her books! Shocking twists and turns I never saw coming blew my mind and the humor kept me laughing so much. As with all of Suzanne Woods Fisher’s books, this is another awesome read! Filled with a host of secrets coming from all directions, ANYTHING BUT PLAIN is sure to capture your attention and give you several hours of enjoyable entertainment.
Once I started reading ANYTHING BUT PLAIN it was very hard to stop. Even though it is 320 pages it was a very quick read. My emotions were all over the place and the special needs Lydie is dealing with, won my heart right away. My heart broke for Nathan with him not understanding what kept Lydie away from him and his heart. He never gave up on her and I was cheering for him all the way! I’m so excited to read more by this wonderful author. Suzanne has a way of telling a story that completely absorbs the reader and makes them feel like they are part of the story. Suzanne Woods Fisher is one of my favorite Amish authors and I love devouring her books.
I was given a copy of this book by CelebrateLit and Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
November 10, 2022
Lydie Stoltzfus, she doesn't have an easy life. Feeling like the square peg in a round hole she's the Bishops daughter and that gets her constantly judged. She doesn't fit in with the other Amish girls, sometimes she doesn't care,sometimes she feels left out. She usually takes a bit longer to do things,getting distracted easily and needing a detailed list for things. She understands things a bit differently.
I have learned a lot about ADHD , (Adult attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a mental health disorder that includes a combination of persistent problems, such as difficulty paying attention, hyperactivity and impulsive behavior.) I feel a strong compassion towards those having this. The author explained it so well and handled it so respectfully.
I was impressed with the idea of organic farming, no spraying of crops and how well the son who did this type of farming does with sales. I am all for organics, so much tastier and healthier.
Like all of us the characters are mightily flawed and may not be at first but they seek redemption,forgiveness,God and to better not only themselves but themselves for others. I was so touched by the forgiveness that was asked for and also given. A Lot of characters started out one way and changed to a much better God seeking way.
I always feel so good when I read one of this author's books.
Pub Date 04 Oct 2022
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
I have learned a lot about ADHD , (Adult attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a mental health disorder that includes a combination of persistent problems, such as difficulty paying attention, hyperactivity and impulsive behavior.) I feel a strong compassion towards those having this. The author explained it so well and handled it so respectfully.
I was impressed with the idea of organic farming, no spraying of crops and how well the son who did this type of farming does with sales. I am all for organics, so much tastier and healthier.
Like all of us the characters are mightily flawed and may not be at first but they seek redemption,forgiveness,God and to better not only themselves but themselves for others. I was so touched by the forgiveness that was asked for and also given. A Lot of characters started out one way and changed to a much better God seeking way.
I always feel so good when I read one of this author's books.
Pub Date 04 Oct 2022
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
September 19, 2022
I so enjoyed reading this captivating and beautifully written book. First I want to say how much I appreciated that the Author put at the books very beginning the names of each of the characters and told a little bit about each one of them. So even before the first chapter I had been introduced to the characters and felt I already knew them. I also felt the Author did an excellent research about ADHD and I learned things about it that I didn’t know before I read this story. I thought the book was almost impossible to put down because I was so drawn into what was happening in the book. I found this book to be original, entertaining, unpredictable and realistic. The ending left me feeling good and satisfied with my reading experience with this book.
Lydia Stoltzfus is a 19 year old single Amish girl. She’s never been able to hold a job for very long . Lydia is very forgetful and she never seems to be able to finish anything she starts. She feels she’s a big disappointment to her father, who is the Bishop of their Amish Community. Lydia is very gifted in certain ways and some of her friends tend to use her and try to take advantage of her. She has a hard time saying no to these friends. Lately Lydia feels she of little use to anyone and she feels it would be better for her family and the man who loves her if she would leave the Amish Community and go out into the English world.
Nathan Yoder is a 19 year old Amish man who wants to become a organic farmer. He’s willing to work hard to change his father’s farm over to an organic farm but the problem is his father and older brother want to use chemicals the keep their crops pest free. No amount of convincing on his part can change their minds even though in the last few years the farms crop yield has been failing and his father has been losing money. He’s also been unlucky in love because the woman he loves only wants to be friends with him. He wonders what he did wrong in their relationship and Lydia refuses to discuss it with him. Is there someone else in her life that she loves more than him?
I recommend this book to readers of Amish fiction and fans of the Author. I read this book as a standalone. This book is scheduled to be released on 10/4/22.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here are my own.
#AnythingbutPlain#NetGalley
Lydia Stoltzfus is a 19 year old single Amish girl. She’s never been able to hold a job for very long . Lydia is very forgetful and she never seems to be able to finish anything she starts. She feels she’s a big disappointment to her father, who is the Bishop of their Amish Community. Lydia is very gifted in certain ways and some of her friends tend to use her and try to take advantage of her. She has a hard time saying no to these friends. Lately Lydia feels she of little use to anyone and she feels it would be better for her family and the man who loves her if she would leave the Amish Community and go out into the English world.
Nathan Yoder is a 19 year old Amish man who wants to become a organic farmer. He’s willing to work hard to change his father’s farm over to an organic farm but the problem is his father and older brother want to use chemicals the keep their crops pest free. No amount of convincing on his part can change their minds even though in the last few years the farms crop yield has been failing and his father has been losing money. He’s also been unlucky in love because the woman he loves only wants to be friends with him. He wonders what he did wrong in their relationship and Lydia refuses to discuss it with him. Is there someone else in her life that she loves more than him?
I recommend this book to readers of Amish fiction and fans of the Author. I read this book as a standalone. This book is scheduled to be released on 10/4/22.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed here are my own.
#AnythingbutPlain#NetGalley
Want to read
September 1, 2022I'm not usually into reading Amish, but this has ADHD rep. I'm all down for that! <3
October 12, 2022
Remember When ADHD Was So “New” No One Believed It Existed?
I was thirty-five when I saw a list of Adult Attention Deficit Disorder symptoms. I don’t know what other people think when they run across those kinds of lists, but my first thought was, “Wait. Everyone doesn’t do this?” Suddenly, so many things made sense.
In Anything but Plain, Suzanne Woods Fisher explores what ADD and ADHD would look like in a community where steadiness, purposefulness, and diligent attention to tasks is a way of living out faith. Poor Lydie just doesn’t understand that much of what she despises in herself is hardwired into her brain. She also can’t see that the things she thinks she needs to “fix” most are part of what Nathan Yoder loves most about her.
Mix up a father who only wants the best for his daughter (misguided as he is) and another father who only wants the best for his son (even more misguided and less sympathetic), and you’ve got a mess on your hands.
Can I just say that I love how while Suzanne Woods Fisher doesn’t idolize the Amish, neither does she grab onto unjust stereotypes and exploit them? I’m sick to death of the evil bishop trope, and here she shows a bishop who could be “the bad guy” but instead, is a loving father who just doesn’t understand. Ironic, isn’t it? How often do young people think their parents “just don’t understand” when those parents really do! (And it’s often why they are so determined to send their kids in another direction!) However, this father’s motives, deep down, are loving rather than solely self-serving, and I appreciated that.
Anything but Plain will capture your heart from the first page until the last–even if Amish Fiction isn’t your jam. Because this isn’t just genre fiction–it’s Christian fiction at its finest. Bravo, Ms. Fisher!
I was thirty-five when I saw a list of Adult Attention Deficit Disorder symptoms. I don’t know what other people think when they run across those kinds of lists, but my first thought was, “Wait. Everyone doesn’t do this?” Suddenly, so many things made sense.
In Anything but Plain, Suzanne Woods Fisher explores what ADD and ADHD would look like in a community where steadiness, purposefulness, and diligent attention to tasks is a way of living out faith. Poor Lydie just doesn’t understand that much of what she despises in herself is hardwired into her brain. She also can’t see that the things she thinks she needs to “fix” most are part of what Nathan Yoder loves most about her.
Mix up a father who only wants the best for his daughter (misguided as he is) and another father who only wants the best for his son (even more misguided and less sympathetic), and you’ve got a mess on your hands.
Can I just say that I love how while Suzanne Woods Fisher doesn’t idolize the Amish, neither does she grab onto unjust stereotypes and exploit them? I’m sick to death of the evil bishop trope, and here she shows a bishop who could be “the bad guy” but instead, is a loving father who just doesn’t understand. Ironic, isn’t it? How often do young people think their parents “just don’t understand” when those parents really do! (And it’s often why they are so determined to send their kids in another direction!) However, this father’s motives, deep down, are loving rather than solely self-serving, and I appreciated that.
Anything but Plain will capture your heart from the first page until the last–even if Amish Fiction isn’t your jam. Because this isn’t just genre fiction–it’s Christian fiction at its finest. Bravo, Ms. Fisher!
August 8, 2022
It’s not easy being Lydie Stoltzfus. She’s a sweet Amish young woman, friendly and kind. She’s smart, but she can’t hold a job, some lasting less than a couple of hours. She’s a hard worker, but she often doesn’t finish tasks. She means to arrive on time for functions, but she is often late for everything. She is active, almost like a whirling dervish, if she is not staring into space. Though she expects to be fired sooner rather than later, she takes on a another temporary job, working as a receptionist for her aunt Ruth. Ruth, or Dok as her beloved patients call her, had left the Amish community years before to become a doctor. Dok sees something special in Lydie, something she herself has had to deal with. Lydie has felt like a failure all her life. Indeed, her grandmother has made it her goal in life to “fix” Lydie. But Dok knows Lydie has many sterling qualities, and just needs some help with the things she struggles with, but she doesn’t need “fixing.” But quirks in her personality that bother Lydie the most are the ones that made her next door neighbor, Nathan Yoder, fall in love with her. Through an unfortunate chain of events, Nathan’s father extracted a promise from Lydie to stay away from his sons, or he would expose a secret she has been keeping. Anyway, he believes she is not good enough for his sons, or really, to be anyone’s wife. Much more happens in this well told Amish tale. More than just a romance, it deals with a real disorder which is largely ignored in the Amish community. The story also talks about the benefits of organic farming versus the over-use of pesticides. The tale is intriguing and intricate. The characters are real and the main characters are likable. Some of the secondary characters are not so likable, but that just makes them more life-like. The story was so entertaining, I couldn’t put it down. I started it in the afternoon and finished it in the evening. My only complaint is that I wish it had been longer. I would have loved an epilogue to see what Lydie’s life held in store for her, but I guess I can hope for a sequel!
November 11, 2022
It's been a while since I've read an Amish Fiction story and this one did not disappoint. This was nothing I have ever read and the author tackles a topic that I don't think has been tackled to this detail in Christian Fiction.
In this story we meet Lydie who suffers from ADHD. This is something that the Amish don't believe can happen to them and pretty much ignore. Sadly this causes Lydie to be misunderstood and categorized into something that she isn't. She can't help the way her mind works. Having a kiddo with ADHD myself I definitely could see the similarities. It became that much more enjoyable for Lydie to find a resolution because we have lived this.
I really enjoyed Dok and how she helps her see the potential that is inside her once she applies herself. Another character I enjoyed was Nathan. He was perfect for her despite her staying away from him I was so glad that he never gave up on her and kept on pursuing her in his own way.
Overall I thought this was a great story and if you are in the mood to go into Amish country then definitely grab this book!!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher Revell. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
In this story we meet Lydie who suffers from ADHD. This is something that the Amish don't believe can happen to them and pretty much ignore. Sadly this causes Lydie to be misunderstood and categorized into something that she isn't. She can't help the way her mind works. Having a kiddo with ADHD myself I definitely could see the similarities. It became that much more enjoyable for Lydie to find a resolution because we have lived this.
I really enjoyed Dok and how she helps her see the potential that is inside her once she applies herself. Another character I enjoyed was Nathan. He was perfect for her despite her staying away from him I was so glad that he never gave up on her and kept on pursuing her in his own way.
Overall I thought this was a great story and if you are in the mood to go into Amish country then definitely grab this book!!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher Revell. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
partial-read
November 12, 2022Suzanne Woods Fisher is one of my favorite authors of Amish fiction, but I really struggled with this one. I don't think I was in the best place emotionally to read it, because I felt the hidden hopelessness and despair of Lydie keenly, and the injustice of Nathan's father's cruelty was too much. Nathan has commendable goals to improve the farm, but Mick and their father are persuaded by the easier way with empty promises, and Nathan is not given enough regard to present his plan or enough time to actually execute it. I will have to finish this book when I'm able to wade though the hardships they are sure to endure.
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
October 20, 2022
MY THOUGHTS ON THIS BOOK
I have been reading books by Suzanne Woods Fisher for a long time and have loved every one of them, just as I love this one. I felt so bad for Lydia because she never felt she belonged. She didn’t feel she was good enough for her Beau, and she just didn’t want to be in the community anymore. But when she started work for the local Dr., the more time Lydia spends there the more the Dok recognizes her symptoms. Will Lydia take the treatments she needs in order to help her condition?
I like that Ms. Fisher deals with a very difficult issue, that doesn’t happen with the Amish so much, but still here it is. Fisher does am amazing job with crafting her characters and writing them into the story so well. The Sweet Amish community was well detailed and I think the new medical issue made a difference in Lydia and her family. I’m always excited to read a Suzanne Woods Fisher and I am honored I can read and review this one. If you enjoy a clean Amish fiction with the Christian faith running through its characters, you will love this one. I’m giving Anything But Plain 5 Stars. And doesn’t that name fit the story so well?
A special thanks to the author/publisher for a copy of this book. I am not required to write a positive review, the opinions here are mine alone. I am disclosing this with my review in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
I have been reading books by Suzanne Woods Fisher for a long time and have loved every one of them, just as I love this one. I felt so bad for Lydia because she never felt she belonged. She didn’t feel she was good enough for her Beau, and she just didn’t want to be in the community anymore. But when she started work for the local Dr., the more time Lydia spends there the more the Dok recognizes her symptoms. Will Lydia take the treatments she needs in order to help her condition?
I like that Ms. Fisher deals with a very difficult issue, that doesn’t happen with the Amish so much, but still here it is. Fisher does am amazing job with crafting her characters and writing them into the story so well. The Sweet Amish community was well detailed and I think the new medical issue made a difference in Lydia and her family. I’m always excited to read a Suzanne Woods Fisher and I am honored I can read and review this one. If you enjoy a clean Amish fiction with the Christian faith running through its characters, you will love this one. I’m giving Anything But Plain 5 Stars. And doesn’t that name fit the story so well?
A special thanks to the author/publisher for a copy of this book. I am not required to write a positive review, the opinions here are mine alone. I am disclosing this with my review in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
April 16, 2023
Rating: 5 Stars!!
Review:
Its been awhile since i last read a Amish Fiction Novel by Suzanne so i kind of knew what to expect even tho i didnt totally know what this story would be about even tho i knew it was set in Lancaster County PA.
The Characters were so fun and interesting to read about. Lyndie was definately my favorite since she tried her hardest to be punctual despite having ADHD.
The Setting was beautifully described which made me feel like i was actually in Lancaster County PA since my parents and i vacationed there in the 2010s.
Overall a Good and Informative Amish Fiction Novel by Suzanne Woods Fisher!! Can't wait to read more by Suzanne in the future!!
Review:
Its been awhile since i last read a Amish Fiction Novel by Suzanne so i kind of knew what to expect even tho i didnt totally know what this story would be about even tho i knew it was set in Lancaster County PA.
The Characters were so fun and interesting to read about. Lyndie was definately my favorite since she tried her hardest to be punctual despite having ADHD.
The Setting was beautifully described which made me feel like i was actually in Lancaster County PA since my parents and i vacationed there in the 2010s.
Overall a Good and Informative Amish Fiction Novel by Suzanne Woods Fisher!! Can't wait to read more by Suzanne in the future!!
September 19, 2022
Welcome back to Stoney Ridge and all of its colorful characters! This delightful story is full of insight into family relationships, friendship, and faith, with subtle humor. It was fun to see mentions of returning characters, but easy to read as a stand alone.
Lydie is a wonderfully unique character, bursting with energy, creativity, and a concern for others. I just wanted to hug her, cheer her on, and reaffirm what people finally realized, that she was special and loved just as she was, something many need to hear. The hurtfulness of gossip, comparison, and deceptions makes her story especially heart tugging, as she struggles with trying to fit in and please others.
The author does a great job of showing other points of view, i.e. Lydie's father, David, and her friend Nathan. Research into Attention Deficit Disorder was clearly evident and naturally woven into the story. The organic gardening topic is quite relevant to today and made an interesting point of contention between the siblings. I liked all of the Amish sayings with gardening that held extra meaning, like "walking the beans".
A charming story that kept me reading quickly to the end. Highly recommend! 5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
Lydie is a wonderfully unique character, bursting with energy, creativity, and a concern for others. I just wanted to hug her, cheer her on, and reaffirm what people finally realized, that she was special and loved just as she was, something many need to hear. The hurtfulness of gossip, comparison, and deceptions makes her story especially heart tugging, as she struggles with trying to fit in and please others.
The author does a great job of showing other points of view, i.e. Lydie's father, David, and her friend Nathan. Research into Attention Deficit Disorder was clearly evident and naturally woven into the story. The organic gardening topic is quite relevant to today and made an interesting point of contention between the siblings. I liked all of the Amish sayings with gardening that held extra meaning, like "walking the beans".
A charming story that kept me reading quickly to the end. Highly recommend! 5 stars!
(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)
October 7, 2022
“God does not see you for what you are. God sees you for what you can be.”
Stoney Ridge and especially Bishop David Stoltzfus’s home is my favorite setting that Suzanne Woods Fisher has penned. While Anything but Plain could be read as a stand-alone, it is sweeter if you have read the preceding books.
Everyone loves Lydie, but having the Bishop’s youngest daughter work for them is another matter. As Edith says, ”Everyone says you’re an accident waiting to happen.” (How can some people be so cruel to others?)
Mammi, David’s widowed mother, comes for a visit. Before long, she informs Lydie, “‘You’re the reason I’m here.’ Mammi smiled. ‘You’re going to be my special project. We are going to fix you.’” Oh, the angst in that household , and not just for Lydie, as Mammi settles in! I love how Fisher weaves that one event into so many subplots.
I was slightly dismayed to find in this book that David himself is not perfect. He has always been such a humble, wise, and godly bishop. To find he has faults was indeed sad. May it be a reminder to all of us that we cannot put church leaders on pedestals. The only one we worship and adore is God. He alone is perfect.
I loved Nathan. He is humble, kind, knowledgeable about his organic farming, and eloquent as well. He is very forgiving, more than most.
One plot twist did throw me for a loop. I did not feel the reader had been properly prepared or armed with enough understanding to receive that twist as plausible.
Still, this is probably my fave Fisher novel so far for the unusual subject matter, (ADHD among the Amish) and the way Fisher deals with it.
I received a copy of the book through Celebrate Lit, and also NetGalley, plus I bought a copy to give away. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Act first and think later. Lydie’s life in a nutshell.”
“He needed to seek things to be grateful for, something Birdy was always reminding him of. Search for them like a lost coin, she would say, because his mind didn’t naturally go to gratitude.”
“The Lord God did not make a mistake when he made you. Everything about you was ordained from the beginning. You have to start believing that.”
“She had a knack for solving problems, for seeing things he couldn’t see.
Stoney Ridge and especially Bishop David Stoltzfus’s home is my favorite setting that Suzanne Woods Fisher has penned. While Anything but Plain could be read as a stand-alone, it is sweeter if you have read the preceding books.
Everyone loves Lydie, but having the Bishop’s youngest daughter work for them is another matter. As Edith says, ”Everyone says you’re an accident waiting to happen.” (How can some people be so cruel to others?)
Mammi, David’s widowed mother, comes for a visit. Before long, she informs Lydie, “‘You’re the reason I’m here.’ Mammi smiled. ‘You’re going to be my special project. We are going to fix you.’” Oh, the angst in that household , and not just for Lydie, as Mammi settles in! I love how Fisher weaves that one event into so many subplots.
I was slightly dismayed to find in this book that David himself is not perfect. He has always been such a humble, wise, and godly bishop. To find he has faults was indeed sad. May it be a reminder to all of us that we cannot put church leaders on pedestals. The only one we worship and adore is God. He alone is perfect.
I loved Nathan. He is humble, kind, knowledgeable about his organic farming, and eloquent as well. He is very forgiving, more than most.
One plot twist did throw me for a loop. I did not feel the reader had been properly prepared or armed with enough understanding to receive that twist as plausible.
Still, this is probably my fave Fisher novel so far for the unusual subject matter, (ADHD among the Amish) and the way Fisher deals with it.
I received a copy of the book through Celebrate Lit, and also NetGalley, plus I bought a copy to give away. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Act first and think later. Lydie’s life in a nutshell.”
“He needed to seek things to be grateful for, something Birdy was always reminding him of. Search for them like a lost coin, she would say, because his mind didn’t naturally go to gratitude.”
“The Lord God did not make a mistake when he made you. Everything about you was ordained from the beginning. You have to start believing that.”
“She had a knack for solving problems, for seeing things he couldn’t see.
October 6, 2022
An engaging Amish fiction! Having a somewhat similar situation in my life, this book was great at depicting the ADHD life. I loved everything about the book. And I understood. And it felt real. And it gave me new perspectives as to how to deal with the circumstances that arise. It was good to read and a beautiful telling. Lydie definitely had her challenges and keeping a job was a big part of them. The book was a great example of faith and I just plain enjoyed it!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts are my own.
September 14, 2022
I enjoy reading Suzanne Woods Fisher's books. Her Amish fiction is well-researched and light-hearted. Her contemporary fiction is truly compelling. Suzanne often takes on real world problems and then provides real world solutions to the problem while wrapping it in engaging fiction.
In this novel, the situation is undiagnosed ADHD and the overbearing grandmother who wants to "fix" the issue. Lydie has never held down a job, often getting fired the same day she gets hired. Her father's sister, the local doctor, needs a fill-in receptionist. Lydie wants to leave the Amish because she just doesn't fit in. Nathan loves Lydie and can't understand why she wants to jump the fence.
Lydie's aunt gets an inkling of what's going through her mind and how it works, because she suffered the same thing and understands why Lydie is so flighty. She goes to Lydie's dad, who is also the bishop of the community, and explains what Lydie is feeling and how she can use some techniques to overcome her lack of focus.
In a parallel story to the main plot, Nathan's father pits him against his brother, Mick, to see who will "win" the farm. Nathan wants to get back to organic farming instead of using chemicals all the time. He feels that the chemicals are leaching the soils of nutrients and causing some health problems. It's not until his mother is hospitalized with a severe asthma attack that his father concedes that the chemicals MIGHT have something to do with her issues.
When all the pieces are wrapped up and put together into a cohesive whole, the reader is loving Lydie for who she is and the reader is left satisfied with how things turned out also . Five Stars, Two Thumbs Up, and a tidy desk with a full planner.
Revell Publishing provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
In this novel, the situation is undiagnosed ADHD and the overbearing grandmother who wants to "fix" the issue. Lydie has never held down a job, often getting fired the same day she gets hired. Her father's sister, the local doctor, needs a fill-in receptionist. Lydie wants to leave the Amish because she just doesn't fit in. Nathan loves Lydie and can't understand why she wants to jump the fence.
Lydie's aunt gets an inkling of what's going through her mind and how it works, because she suffered the same thing and understands why Lydie is so flighty. She goes to Lydie's dad, who is also the bishop of the community, and explains what Lydie is feeling and how she can use some techniques to overcome her lack of focus.
In a parallel story to the main plot, Nathan's father pits him against his brother, Mick, to see who will "win" the farm. Nathan wants to get back to organic farming instead of using chemicals all the time. He feels that the chemicals are leaching the soils of nutrients and causing some health problems. It's not until his mother is hospitalized with a severe asthma attack that his father concedes that the chemicals MIGHT have something to do with her issues.
When all the pieces are wrapped up and put together into a cohesive whole, the reader is loving Lydie for who she is and the reader is left satisfied with how things turned out also . Five Stars, Two Thumbs Up, and a tidy desk with a full planner.
Revell Publishing provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed are solely my own.
September 10, 2022
I enjoyed this book very much. Lydia is the bishop’s daughter and always seems to be forgetting things and being late. It’s not until the bishop’s sister who is a doctor. She left the Amish community and was never baptized so she wasn’t shunned. She believes she can help Lydia and diagnoses her with ADHD. This book has it all forgiveness, second chances and romance. A delightful book. Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the E-ARC. This is my own opinion.
September 12, 2022
What an interesting book. While I was able to guess early on with this book what the main character was dealing with, what an informative book. I loved the subplots and learned as much (or more) from them, including a way to help control asthma! I loved Nathan and Lydie and how sweet and caring Lydie was for everyone, including Patsy Glick (who in my opinion didn’t deserve her sweetness). I even loved how the author worked out the situation between Mitch and Nathan at the end. It was an amazing book that kept me reading to find out more and I loved, loved, loved David’s talk with his mother. That is a conversation that many need to have with others but it’s a hard and difficult one to start. I felt like it was a hug straight from God.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was under no obligation to review it. All opinions are mine.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but was under no obligation to review it. All opinions are mine.
September 5, 2022
I always find joy in reading books by Suzanne Woods Fisher, especially her Amish fiction good. I was excited to find out that she had another one releasing and jumped at the opportunity to read Anything But Plain. I was not disappointed. I believe this may be my new favorite by her. I adored Lydie’s story so much. I liked watching her grow and finding herself all throughout. There are great reminders and lessons to be learned within the book, as well. I loved it.
I am giving Anything But Plain five stars. Fans of clean romantic Amish fiction will want to pick this one up. As always, I will be eagerly awaiting for future releases by Suzanne Woods Fisher.
I received a paperback copy of Anything But Plain from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
I am giving Anything But Plain five stars. Fans of clean romantic Amish fiction will want to pick this one up. As always, I will be eagerly awaiting for future releases by Suzanne Woods Fisher.
I received a paperback copy of Anything But Plain from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
Want to read
August 21, 2022I think that this is the best quote ever!
A perfect reminder that God cares even though we aren't perfect.
"God does not see you for what you are. God sees you for what you can be."
Fisher definitely kept the wows coming from every page in this story and made me sort of snicker at the same time if that's possible.
There's just no way to satisfy everyone but I thought that certain people got their just.
I'm hoping that the Stoney Ridge series never ends because it feels like home to me. I really loved my visit here and meeting Dok. She was my favorite and Lydie fell next in line.
I stayed up til 6 am to finish this novel and I felt that Fisher has done a fantastic job with the subject at hand.
Did I lose sleep? Of course I did! But it was oh so worth it and I loved the subject at hand and the Amish view on it.
There were some shady things going on in this novel that I didn't like but it has to happen in order to make the story interesting. I want say what they are because I don't want to give it away.
There wouldn't be anything that I would change about this novel. I truly loved every minute of it and I was sad when I finished it. I will say the ending was satisfying. I'm not not just saying because it really was!
Oh and no one is perfect including Perfect Patsy lol!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
A perfect reminder that God cares even though we aren't perfect.
"God does not see you for what you are. God sees you for what you can be."
Fisher definitely kept the wows coming from every page in this story and made me sort of snicker at the same time if that's possible.
There's just no way to satisfy everyone but I thought that certain people got their just.
I'm hoping that the Stoney Ridge series never ends because it feels like home to me. I really loved my visit here and meeting Dok. She was my favorite and Lydie fell next in line.
I stayed up til 6 am to finish this novel and I felt that Fisher has done a fantastic job with the subject at hand.
Did I lose sleep? Of course I did! But it was oh so worth it and I loved the subject at hand and the Amish view on it.
There were some shady things going on in this novel that I didn't like but it has to happen in order to make the story interesting. I want say what they are because I don't want to give it away.
There wouldn't be anything that I would change about this novel. I truly loved every minute of it and I was sad when I finished it. I will say the ending was satisfying. I'm not not just saying because it really was!
Oh and no one is perfect including Perfect Patsy lol!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 26, 2022
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher. Opinions conveyed are my own.
Scripture Connection
…and to make it your ambition to lead a quiet life: You should mind your own business and work with your hands, just as we told you…
1 Thess. 4:11
Don’t worry about anything; instead, pray about everything. Tell God what you need and thank Him for all He has done. Then you will experience God’s peace, which exceeds anything we can understand. His peace will guard your hearts and minds as you live in Christ Jesus.
Phil. 4:6-7
Spiritual Themes
Through the farm-based subplot, the author also ruminates on the importance of “walking the beans,” a metaphor for taking stock of one’s life. She emphasizes living in the moment, as well as filling our minds with praise, rather than worry. This, is a powerful, important message that I really benefitted from.
Woods Fisher highlights the importance of stewarding the earth well, as the narrative follows a young farmer who is trying to go pesticide-free. The character, Nathan Yoder, encounters a good deal of opposition, in his efforts to do so.
What I Liked
Suzanne Woods Fisher is my favorite author for Amish fiction, not only because of the fun stories, but because the Lord usually uses her books to speak to me. Anything but Plain was no exception. At one point in the story, one of the characters describes another character as “convicting him, but without the sting” (p. 124). And that’s how the Lord speaks to me through Woods Fisher’s books. The message is sweet and gentle, but moving.
Many of the author’s books are set in the same community of Stoney Ridge. In fact, all of the books I’ve read by her, thus far, take place in this setting. This makes me so happy, because it really fleshes out the characters, so that they feel like friends to me. Rather than getting to know a handful of people through the course of a single book, or even a series, I have the opportunity to deepen my “relationships” with them as they continue to emerge in the newer books. Even those characters with smaller roles have become familiar. Take Hank Lapp. I haven’t read a book where he’s one of the protagonists, but whenever I see a string of capitalized words, I know he’s entered the scene. (In fact, I think that’s how I recognized that I was reading about the same Stoney Ridge community, last year when I read A Season on the Wind).
The farming emphasis is delightful and, as my mom pointed out while we were reading together, has a bit of a permaculture bent. It’s so neat to see a Christian author emphasizing stewardship, and the importance of allowing the land God has given us to thrive.
I found Lydie to be a very relatable character, to the extent that I wondered if I share her unique gifting (I am undiagnosed but fairly certain that I’m on the autistic spectrum; however, this is not what the book discusses). With that said, Woods Fisher does include an Author’s Note in which she discusses distractedness, in general. As is clear in the note and through the book itself, people, in general can benefit from the message of the novel.
And that message is both meaningful and practical. I really appreciate that Woods Fisher, rather than simply mentioning sweeping principles, provides specific, tangible strategies. These are very helpful suggestions (and some of them are a lot like the ones my mom, who taught special ed, had suggested for me, over the years). For instance, one of the characters encourages Lydie to write down all of her activities. The Lord had put it on my mom’s heart, and she encouraged me to write things down, even before we thought I was autistic.
Also regarding the novel’s message, Woods Fisher does a fantastic job of crafting a robust, moving message that permeates throughout the novel. We don’t just see a few lines scattered here and there. Instead, it’s apparent that the entire plot comes together around the same ideas, as the narrative gently drives the point home. And it’s beautiful and refreshing, a blessing and encouragement to me. I praise God for how He has gifted this author to relay words of truth.
Content Notes
There’s a line or so about a character being “empty” without the other character. Overall, though, there’s a HUGE emphasis on relationship with God.
From the doctor, we see a lot of emphasis on the importance of characters being diagnosed, as if this is the only way a person can effectively understand their unique way of thinking. As my mom pointed out, the Lord can speak to people without them having a diagnosis.
Recommendation Status
Highly recommended for readers who enjoy Amish fiction. Suzanne Woods Fisher is my favorite author in the genre, and I so appreciate how the Lord ministers to me through the gentle encouragement in her books.
Scripture Connection
…and to make it your ambition to lead a quiet life: You should mind your own business and work with your hands, just as we told you…
1 Thess. 4:11
Don’t worry about anything; instead, pray about everything. Tell God what you need and thank Him for all He has done. Then you will experience God’s peace, which exceeds anything we can understand. His peace will guard your hearts and minds as you live in Christ Jesus.
Phil. 4:6-7
Spiritual Themes
Through the farm-based subplot, the author also ruminates on the importance of “walking the beans,” a metaphor for taking stock of one’s life. She emphasizes living in the moment, as well as filling our minds with praise, rather than worry. This, is a powerful, important message that I really benefitted from.
Woods Fisher highlights the importance of stewarding the earth well, as the narrative follows a young farmer who is trying to go pesticide-free. The character, Nathan Yoder, encounters a good deal of opposition, in his efforts to do so.
What I Liked
Suzanne Woods Fisher is my favorite author for Amish fiction, not only because of the fun stories, but because the Lord usually uses her books to speak to me. Anything but Plain was no exception. At one point in the story, one of the characters describes another character as “convicting him, but without the sting” (p. 124). And that’s how the Lord speaks to me through Woods Fisher’s books. The message is sweet and gentle, but moving.
Many of the author’s books are set in the same community of Stoney Ridge. In fact, all of the books I’ve read by her, thus far, take place in this setting. This makes me so happy, because it really fleshes out the characters, so that they feel like friends to me. Rather than getting to know a handful of people through the course of a single book, or even a series, I have the opportunity to deepen my “relationships” with them as they continue to emerge in the newer books. Even those characters with smaller roles have become familiar. Take Hank Lapp. I haven’t read a book where he’s one of the protagonists, but whenever I see a string of capitalized words, I know he’s entered the scene. (In fact, I think that’s how I recognized that I was reading about the same Stoney Ridge community, last year when I read A Season on the Wind).
The farming emphasis is delightful and, as my mom pointed out while we were reading together, has a bit of a permaculture bent. It’s so neat to see a Christian author emphasizing stewardship, and the importance of allowing the land God has given us to thrive.
I found Lydie to be a very relatable character, to the extent that I wondered if I share her unique gifting (I am undiagnosed but fairly certain that I’m on the autistic spectrum; however, this is not what the book discusses). With that said, Woods Fisher does include an Author’s Note in which she discusses distractedness, in general. As is clear in the note and through the book itself, people, in general can benefit from the message of the novel.
And that message is both meaningful and practical. I really appreciate that Woods Fisher, rather than simply mentioning sweeping principles, provides specific, tangible strategies. These are very helpful suggestions (and some of them are a lot like the ones my mom, who taught special ed, had suggested for me, over the years). For instance, one of the characters encourages Lydie to write down all of her activities. The Lord had put it on my mom’s heart, and she encouraged me to write things down, even before we thought I was autistic.
Also regarding the novel’s message, Woods Fisher does a fantastic job of crafting a robust, moving message that permeates throughout the novel. We don’t just see a few lines scattered here and there. Instead, it’s apparent that the entire plot comes together around the same ideas, as the narrative gently drives the point home. And it’s beautiful and refreshing, a blessing and encouragement to me. I praise God for how He has gifted this author to relay words of truth.
Content Notes
There’s a line or so about a character being “empty” without the other character. Overall, though, there’s a HUGE emphasis on relationship with God.
From the doctor, we see a lot of emphasis on the importance of characters being diagnosed, as if this is the only way a person can effectively understand their unique way of thinking. As my mom pointed out, the Lord can speak to people without them having a diagnosis.
Recommendation Status
Highly recommended for readers who enjoy Amish fiction. Suzanne Woods Fisher is my favorite author in the genre, and I so appreciate how the Lord ministers to me through the gentle encouragement in her books.
October 2, 2022
Suzanne Woods Fisher has taken us back for another visit to the Amish community of Stoney Ridge. This book focuses on Lydie Stoltzfus, one of the daughters of Amish bishop David Stoltzfus. Lydie is liked by everyone, but in the Amish community’s view, she’s a daydreamer and irresponsible. All attempts to turn her into a “typical” Amish woman have failed. Nathan Yoder has his own struggles with his father and brother over the management of their farm, but his greatest dream is to marry Lydie. Even though Lydie feels like a failure, help is coming for her in an unexpected source, and this will change the course of life for both Nathan and Lydie.
I liked how the author explains Lydie’s struggles with compassion and insight. This book could be an encouragement for anyone who is personally struggling with ADHD. This is an entertaining story with a heart for those who struggle to fit in, and a reminder to us to “be still” and keep our eyes focused on God. I loved this book and look forward to reading another book soon by this very talented author.
I voluntarily received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
I liked how the author explains Lydie’s struggles with compassion and insight. This book could be an encouragement for anyone who is personally struggling with ADHD. This is an entertaining story with a heart for those who struggle to fit in, and a reminder to us to “be still” and keep our eyes focused on God. I loved this book and look forward to reading another book soon by this very talented author.
I voluntarily received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
October 12, 2022
When I see a book by Suzanne Woods Fisher, I just know I’m in for a sweet and tender story. Anything But Plain is that and more.
I don’t read a lot of Amish fiction, nevertheless, there are a select few authors that are go-tos. I love the clean, wholesome, inspirational feel of Ms. Fisher’s work.
The word that comes to mind to describe the main character, Lydie, is sweet. Or perhaps it would be misunderstood. Anyway, she exhibits signs of ADHD and is treated poorly, even by those who might not mean to. She is so easy to connect with and empathize for. And then there’s Nathan—the epitome of kindness.
I just love it when a story makes me feel strongly and stays with me long after I finish reading it. This story developed nicely, captured my full attention, and offered a rewarding end.
Disclosure: #CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book.
I don’t read a lot of Amish fiction, nevertheless, there are a select few authors that are go-tos. I love the clean, wholesome, inspirational feel of Ms. Fisher’s work.
The word that comes to mind to describe the main character, Lydie, is sweet. Or perhaps it would be misunderstood. Anyway, she exhibits signs of ADHD and is treated poorly, even by those who might not mean to. She is so easy to connect with and empathize for. And then there’s Nathan—the epitome of kindness.
I just love it when a story makes me feel strongly and stays with me long after I finish reading it. This story developed nicely, captured my full attention, and offered a rewarding end.
Disclosure: #CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book.
Read
October 15, 2023 Anything but Plain by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Topic or themes I saw: Standing firm when people pressure you. Feeling different and misunderstood. Finding ways to praise, even in harder circumstances. Being known and loved.
Read it if you love:
✔️Amish fiction
Story: I loved the unique angle of Lydia having ADHD. I’ve never read a fiction book that highlights that. And from what I know about ADHD, I felt it was a very accurate representation of it. The characters in this book were lively and unique and I enjoyed that. I really appreciated David’s character. How he got anxious over things but always returned to the Lord to ground him instead of letting the worries carry him away.
Topic or themes I saw: Standing firm when people pressure you. Feeling different and misunderstood. Finding ways to praise, even in harder circumstances. Being known and loved.
Read it if you love:
✔️Amish fiction
Story: I loved the unique angle of Lydia having ADHD. I’ve never read a fiction book that highlights that. And from what I know about ADHD, I felt it was a very accurate representation of it. The characters in this book were lively and unique and I enjoyed that. I really appreciated David’s character. How he got anxious over things but always returned to the Lord to ground him instead of letting the worries carry him away.
September 12, 2022
Lydie Stoltzfus.is the Bishop's daughter. She is flighty and she can not keep a job. She never finishes things she starts. After she loses her last job her Aunt who is a doctor hires her. Her Aunt left the faith to become a Doctor and her mother does not speak to her for that decision. She has two friends who are brothers Nathan and Mick. Nathan loves Lydie and she loves him but she feels she is not good enough for him. Her and mick are suppose to leave the faith. As she works for Dok her Aunt recognizes symptoms of a disorder that she believes Lydie has. This is a beautiful story. Lydie's family love 's her and they want the best for her. I love the characters in this book and also the topic of the disorder. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read it and this is my own opinion.
November 9, 2022
In the midst of all the crazy going on in the world today, a trip to Stoney Ridge is a breath of fresh air. I was so excited to dive into this idyllic world when the book arrived on my doorstep. Suzanne Woods Fisher has created some endearing characters that make you eager to catch up on the latest in their lives.
This time the story centers on Lydie Stoltzfus who is the daughter of the Bishop. She's absolutely delightful but she's also a disaster just waiting to happen. These mishaps not only bother Lydie but they also frustrate those around her. The arrival of her grandmother just exacerbates the situation. Actually the arrival of grandma throws the whole household into chaos.
In the midst of this storm the only calm seems to be with Lydie's neighbor and childhood friend Nathan Yoder. He's been smitten with Lydie for some time but has been thrown for a loop when she suddenly decides to distance herself from him.
The story itself allows the reader to step inside the world of someone with ADHD. It's something that we hear about in the English world quite frequently but probably don't think much about it being present among the Amish. I thought it was very enlightening to picture how this disorder would be handled among the Plain community.
Of course the subject is serious, but do not fear that it would be an emotionally heavy read. Just when things get to be depressing you can always count on Hank Lapp bulldozing onto the scene to lighten thing up.
I absolutely adore a trip to Stoney Ridge and recommend this and other Stoney Ridge books to anyone who needs a little lift to their spirit.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
This time the story centers on Lydie Stoltzfus who is the daughter of the Bishop. She's absolutely delightful but she's also a disaster just waiting to happen. These mishaps not only bother Lydie but they also frustrate those around her. The arrival of her grandmother just exacerbates the situation. Actually the arrival of grandma throws the whole household into chaos.
In the midst of this storm the only calm seems to be with Lydie's neighbor and childhood friend Nathan Yoder. He's been smitten with Lydie for some time but has been thrown for a loop when she suddenly decides to distance herself from him.
The story itself allows the reader to step inside the world of someone with ADHD. It's something that we hear about in the English world quite frequently but probably don't think much about it being present among the Amish. I thought it was very enlightening to picture how this disorder would be handled among the Plain community.
Of course the subject is serious, but do not fear that it would be an emotionally heavy read. Just when things get to be depressing you can always count on Hank Lapp bulldozing onto the scene to lighten thing up.
I absolutely adore a trip to Stoney Ridge and recommend this and other Stoney Ridge books to anyone who needs a little lift to their spirit.
I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
November 28, 2022
I am so glad I read this book. It was a wonderful story and I loved the ADHD aspect. I can relate!
"Die Sunn scheint as hinnich de Wolke. There is sunshine also behind the clouds."
"Die Sunn scheint as hinnich de Wolke. There is sunshine also behind the clouds."
November 9, 2022
Thank you in advance to the publisher, Revell Books (a division of Baker Books), for providing a complimentary review copy through their Revell Reads blogger program. A positive review was not required nor requested, and all words are my own.
I’ve actually read more of the author’s contemporary romances (total of 4) than I have her Amish fiction. This is only the second one I’ve read.
And, while it is set in Stoney Ridge, it is a standalone title. As of note, Fern Lapp was introduced in The Keeper, the first book of THE SEASONS OF STONEY RIDGE. Though it isn’t necessary to read that series, I would be interested in reading it.
Getting back to this story …
What makes this unique is why I was drawn to it – Lydie and her ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder). While researching online, I came across a few resources that actually had the quote “Amish kids don’t get ADHD”. That isn’t entirely true – they are just not diagnosed with it.
There is a debate that ADD (attention deficit disorder) and ADHD is the result of bad parenting or a reliance on tech devices such as cell phones, tablets, even computers that tend to mess with attention spans. I have seen some ADD or ADHD tendencies with my mother, and I have to admit – I am seeing a slight issue with my reliance on my phone and internet. Then again, I’m always expecting an email, shipping information, or writing. Perhaps it is a good idea I read physical books and NOT eBooks.
Of course, the technology issue isn’t a viable reason in Lydie’s home. She’s Amish and her dad is the the bishop. He isn’t too strict, but Lydie lives within the ordnung.
After seeing the interesting and “reflective” cover, I wondered how the author was going to work an interesting “disorder” into a Plain community. And, for those worried, she does it in a way that is respectful to the community, yet highlights how many – plain and Englisch tend to overlook it.
On this visit to Stoney Ridge, Fisher introduces us to:
👒 Lydie – daughter of David, love interest of Nathan
🍅 Nathan Yoder – son of Walt and Sarah; brother to Mick; loves Lydie
🏡 Mick – Nathan’s brother
🏡 Walt – Nathan and Mick’s father
⛪ David – Bishop in Stoney Ridge, father to Lydie and other children
🏡 Birdy – mom of two boys, mother of Lydie, wife of David
🏡 Tillie – David’s mother
🏡 Hank – Edith’s husband, Fern’s son
🧵 Edith – Hank’s wife
🩺 Dok (Ruth) – David’s sister, left the order, has a clinic in Stoney Ridge
🏡 Sarah – Nathan and Mick’s mother, Walt’s wife, inherited Black Gold Farm
🏡 Patsy – interested in Nathan; Mick is interested in her
🛩️ Owen – Englischer who peddles chemicals to the farmers, sprays the Yoder farm
🏡 Fern – Hank’s mother
With all of the characters, Fisher keeps it simple with Lydie, Nathan, and David’s POVs. Thankfully, she does put a “meet the cast” list at the front of the book so we can see who is who.
While the main story is about Lydie and her “struggle”, there are other plot lines that could be confusing to some readers:
✳️ Nathan and his organic farming
✳️ Nathan’s interest in Lydie
✳️ Mick’s interest in Patsy
✳️ Patsy’s interest in Nathan
✳️ Drug-Selling (this is a reference towards the end of the book, but thought readers should be advised)
Lydie knows she doesn’t fit in and wants to leave as soon as she can. She doesn’t want to disappoint anyone anymore as she always messes things up, despite her good intentions.
Right off there is a mishap involving Edith Lapp and a “mini skirt”. I had to laugh with Hank. Of course, that is ANOTHER job poor Lydie has lost.
Nathan – despite Lydie’s “problems” – has feelings for her, and a longing for her. Yet, she won’t tell him why she insists on being “just friends”. Yet, his father makes his feelings about Lydie known … to her. There’s something he can’t (or won’t) forgive her for. (It’s actually, once known, quite trivial).
Lydie isn’t the only one having issues with Walt – his own son, Nathan does; only on the farming technique.
Nathan sees the benefits in organic farming, yet his father and brother Mick do not. Walt gives them each half to do with as they please with the “winning” brother ending up running the farm. Mick too sets his sights on leaving though.
Lydie’s Mammi (Tillie) is planning to stay in Stoney Ridge indefinitely. That doesn’t sit well with Birdy (Lydie’s mom), who ends up leaving – with the younger boys – to help out David’s oldest daughter who is pregnant. Tillie has a major project – fix Lydie. Her method is “harping” on her and “managing” her.
Dok (Ruth) – David’s sister, estranged from her Mother for leaving the plain community – gives Lydie a job. After a few mishaps, Ruth sees herself in Lydie and makes the ADHD connection. David won’t hear of testing Lydie as he doesn’t like labels – they’re for jars and cans, not people.
Ruth decides to work with techniques without the diagnosis. After all, Lydie shows promise and the patients love her. Tillie listens to Ruth despite thinking Lydie needs to try harder and apply herself. Tillie is honest about what Lydie is going through.
In the middle of trying new strategies, including “mindfulness” to manage her wandering mind, she is asked by Mick to talk to Patsy on his behalf, while Patsy wants Lydie to help “get” Nathan, going so far as to present Lydie’s work on some Farmer’s Market signs as her own. And, Lydie’s doodles end up causing a few issues as well.
Nathan and Mick are also arguing about the use of chemicals on crops.
Nathan is still trying to figure out what happened between him and Lydie. And, she is still determined to leave until something happens causing her to stay long enough to sort it out.
To say Fisher keeps readers reading until the end is an understatement. This really did run to the last few pages. And, my honest thought is that this had an abrupt and “open” ending. So much so, I am left wondering if the author plans a series or sequel to this book. If so, I would probably read it to see what’s next for everyone.
The book, like Lydie’s mind – in my opinion – tended to wander as well. It was almost as if the author was trying to replicate how Lydie’s mind worked so we, the readers, would get a sense of it.
In researching the book, I noticed that one reviewer had mentioned that the author brought a “new age” technique of “mindfulness” to the plot and from what I perceived based on their 3-star reviewed, they were not pleased with the inclusion in the plot.
What does mindfulness mean? There are multiple definitions. But, one definition is “the quality or state of being conscious or aware of something”, another is “living in the present moment”. If Lydie’s mind was wandering and she was getting distracted – she isn’t in the present moment and not “aware” of the task she was on. Examples? Leaving doors open, not paying attention, and starting tasks before she was done with what she was working on.
Mindfulness is a key component of Buddhism, which dates back to 5th century BCE – hardly “new age” which actually pertains to the early 1970’s.
However, it does seem that mindfulness has a reference in the bible with Psalm 46:10 – “be still and know that I am God”. The “be still” part is actually what Dok was trying to help Lydie with – stilling her mind through non-medical intervention, and to concentrate on what needed to be done, and when.
Being mindful isn’t inherently evil, nor a bad thing. It can, in Lydie’s case, give her a calming perspective in which to manage her day and tasks better, especial given her tendency to wander. And, she can be fully “present”. I found the idea refreshing, especially opposed to medication which can have adverse effects.
I completely understood Lydie as a person. I too use a planner not only to keep track of appointments, but to chart my photos, writing word counts, and to keep up with my book obligations. I definitely use lists to run multiple errands (anything over 3 places to go), lists for chores or “to-do” lists. I do tend to take things out and leave them, or I often start a few tasks here or there. However, it isn’t all the time, but I understood how she felt.
Ruth’s approach to assisting Lydie, despite the lack of a proper diagnosis, was beneficial and unique – treat her like she has it, without going against David’s wishes.
It was also interesting to see Tillie go from the crotchety, smothering, bossy person to stepping back and accepting Ruth’s approach. In addition, Tillie’s acknowledgment of Lydie’s progress was heartwarming.
It also proved that one does need a diagnosis in order to “manage” their life, only a desire to do so.
That said …
Aside from the serious aspects, there were some moments of humor – Mick building a still inside the bishop’s shed. The still explodes, causing Mick to have to rebuild it, which ends up being a blessing by the end of the book.
With regard to the “drug-selling”, while I hate revealing part of a book, it is in reference to an arrest made at the end, with regard to a theft at Ruth’s office. Only baking soda was taken though, but the person selling it didn’t know.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read. There were times I found it hard to put down. I did feel slightly overwhelmed with the information Ruth kept putting out there for Lydie and it which felt more educational than entertaining. That slightly hampered it a bit. Thankfully, the author’s use of short chapters and her easy flow writing kept the story moving for the most part.
Since this is not only distributed by a predominately Christian publisher, it is also a book regarding the Amish community. As a result, tenets of their faith and mentions of God and the bible will be noticeable.
Fans of Fisher’s Amish stories will probably enjoy this read.
(3.8 stars -> rounded up to 4.0)
I’ve actually read more of the author’s contemporary romances (total of 4) than I have her Amish fiction. This is only the second one I’ve read.
And, while it is set in Stoney Ridge, it is a standalone title. As of note, Fern Lapp was introduced in The Keeper, the first book of THE SEASONS OF STONEY RIDGE. Though it isn’t necessary to read that series, I would be interested in reading it.
Getting back to this story …
What makes this unique is why I was drawn to it – Lydie and her ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder). While researching online, I came across a few resources that actually had the quote “Amish kids don’t get ADHD”. That isn’t entirely true – they are just not diagnosed with it.
There is a debate that ADD (attention deficit disorder) and ADHD is the result of bad parenting or a reliance on tech devices such as cell phones, tablets, even computers that tend to mess with attention spans. I have seen some ADD or ADHD tendencies with my mother, and I have to admit – I am seeing a slight issue with my reliance on my phone and internet. Then again, I’m always expecting an email, shipping information, or writing. Perhaps it is a good idea I read physical books and NOT eBooks.
Of course, the technology issue isn’t a viable reason in Lydie’s home. She’s Amish and her dad is the the bishop. He isn’t too strict, but Lydie lives within the ordnung.
After seeing the interesting and “reflective” cover, I wondered how the author was going to work an interesting “disorder” into a Plain community. And, for those worried, she does it in a way that is respectful to the community, yet highlights how many – plain and Englisch tend to overlook it.
On this visit to Stoney Ridge, Fisher introduces us to:
👒 Lydie – daughter of David, love interest of Nathan
🍅 Nathan Yoder – son of Walt and Sarah; brother to Mick; loves Lydie
🏡 Mick – Nathan’s brother
🏡 Walt – Nathan and Mick’s father
⛪ David – Bishop in Stoney Ridge, father to Lydie and other children
🏡 Birdy – mom of two boys, mother of Lydie, wife of David
🏡 Tillie – David’s mother
🏡 Hank – Edith’s husband, Fern’s son
🧵 Edith – Hank’s wife
🩺 Dok (Ruth) – David’s sister, left the order, has a clinic in Stoney Ridge
🏡 Sarah – Nathan and Mick’s mother, Walt’s wife, inherited Black Gold Farm
🏡 Patsy – interested in Nathan; Mick is interested in her
🛩️ Owen – Englischer who peddles chemicals to the farmers, sprays the Yoder farm
🏡 Fern – Hank’s mother
With all of the characters, Fisher keeps it simple with Lydie, Nathan, and David’s POVs. Thankfully, she does put a “meet the cast” list at the front of the book so we can see who is who.
While the main story is about Lydie and her “struggle”, there are other plot lines that could be confusing to some readers:
✳️ Nathan and his organic farming
✳️ Nathan’s interest in Lydie
✳️ Mick’s interest in Patsy
✳️ Patsy’s interest in Nathan
✳️ Drug-Selling (this is a reference towards the end of the book, but thought readers should be advised)
Lydie knows she doesn’t fit in and wants to leave as soon as she can. She doesn’t want to disappoint anyone anymore as she always messes things up, despite her good intentions.
Right off there is a mishap involving Edith Lapp and a “mini skirt”. I had to laugh with Hank. Of course, that is ANOTHER job poor Lydie has lost.
Nathan – despite Lydie’s “problems” – has feelings for her, and a longing for her. Yet, she won’t tell him why she insists on being “just friends”. Yet, his father makes his feelings about Lydie known … to her. There’s something he can’t (or won’t) forgive her for. (It’s actually, once known, quite trivial).
Lydie isn’t the only one having issues with Walt – his own son, Nathan does; only on the farming technique.
Nathan sees the benefits in organic farming, yet his father and brother Mick do not. Walt gives them each half to do with as they please with the “winning” brother ending up running the farm. Mick too sets his sights on leaving though.
Lydie’s Mammi (Tillie) is planning to stay in Stoney Ridge indefinitely. That doesn’t sit well with Birdy (Lydie’s mom), who ends up leaving – with the younger boys – to help out David’s oldest daughter who is pregnant. Tillie has a major project – fix Lydie. Her method is “harping” on her and “managing” her.
Dok (Ruth) – David’s sister, estranged from her Mother for leaving the plain community – gives Lydie a job. After a few mishaps, Ruth sees herself in Lydie and makes the ADHD connection. David won’t hear of testing Lydie as he doesn’t like labels – they’re for jars and cans, not people.
Ruth decides to work with techniques without the diagnosis. After all, Lydie shows promise and the patients love her. Tillie listens to Ruth despite thinking Lydie needs to try harder and apply herself. Tillie is honest about what Lydie is going through.
In the middle of trying new strategies, including “mindfulness” to manage her wandering mind, she is asked by Mick to talk to Patsy on his behalf, while Patsy wants Lydie to help “get” Nathan, going so far as to present Lydie’s work on some Farmer’s Market signs as her own. And, Lydie’s doodles end up causing a few issues as well.
Nathan and Mick are also arguing about the use of chemicals on crops.
Nathan is still trying to figure out what happened between him and Lydie. And, she is still determined to leave until something happens causing her to stay long enough to sort it out.
To say Fisher keeps readers reading until the end is an understatement. This really did run to the last few pages. And, my honest thought is that this had an abrupt and “open” ending. So much so, I am left wondering if the author plans a series or sequel to this book. If so, I would probably read it to see what’s next for everyone.
The book, like Lydie’s mind – in my opinion – tended to wander as well. It was almost as if the author was trying to replicate how Lydie’s mind worked so we, the readers, would get a sense of it.
In researching the book, I noticed that one reviewer had mentioned that the author brought a “new age” technique of “mindfulness” to the plot and from what I perceived based on their 3-star reviewed, they were not pleased with the inclusion in the plot.
What does mindfulness mean? There are multiple definitions. But, one definition is “the quality or state of being conscious or aware of something”, another is “living in the present moment”. If Lydie’s mind was wandering and she was getting distracted – she isn’t in the present moment and not “aware” of the task she was on. Examples? Leaving doors open, not paying attention, and starting tasks before she was done with what she was working on.
Mindfulness is a key component of Buddhism, which dates back to 5th century BCE – hardly “new age” which actually pertains to the early 1970’s.
However, it does seem that mindfulness has a reference in the bible with Psalm 46:10 – “be still and know that I am God”. The “be still” part is actually what Dok was trying to help Lydie with – stilling her mind through non-medical intervention, and to concentrate on what needed to be done, and when.
Being mindful isn’t inherently evil, nor a bad thing. It can, in Lydie’s case, give her a calming perspective in which to manage her day and tasks better, especial given her tendency to wander. And, she can be fully “present”. I found the idea refreshing, especially opposed to medication which can have adverse effects.
I completely understood Lydie as a person. I too use a planner not only to keep track of appointments, but to chart my photos, writing word counts, and to keep up with my book obligations. I definitely use lists to run multiple errands (anything over 3 places to go), lists for chores or “to-do” lists. I do tend to take things out and leave them, or I often start a few tasks here or there. However, it isn’t all the time, but I understood how she felt.
Ruth’s approach to assisting Lydie, despite the lack of a proper diagnosis, was beneficial and unique – treat her like she has it, without going against David’s wishes.
It was also interesting to see Tillie go from the crotchety, smothering, bossy person to stepping back and accepting Ruth’s approach. In addition, Tillie’s acknowledgment of Lydie’s progress was heartwarming.
It also proved that one does need a diagnosis in order to “manage” their life, only a desire to do so.
That said …
Aside from the serious aspects, there were some moments of humor – Mick building a still inside the bishop’s shed. The still explodes, causing Mick to have to rebuild it, which ends up being a blessing by the end of the book.
With regard to the “drug-selling”, while I hate revealing part of a book, it is in reference to an arrest made at the end, with regard to a theft at Ruth’s office. Only baking soda was taken though, but the person selling it didn’t know.
Overall, this was an enjoyable read. There were times I found it hard to put down. I did feel slightly overwhelmed with the information Ruth kept putting out there for Lydie and it which felt more educational than entertaining. That slightly hampered it a bit. Thankfully, the author’s use of short chapters and her easy flow writing kept the story moving for the most part.
Since this is not only distributed by a predominately Christian publisher, it is also a book regarding the Amish community. As a result, tenets of their faith and mentions of God and the bible will be noticeable.
Fans of Fisher’s Amish stories will probably enjoy this read.
(3.8 stars -> rounded up to 4.0)
January 27, 2025
This was a book with some of the characters that have been in other books written by Suzanne Woods Fisher. This book dealt with Dok, who is a female Doctor who has both plain and English patients. Lydie, who is Dok’s niece, comes to work for her to fill in for someone for a few months. During this time it is noticed that Lydie has ADHD. This was very interesting to me since I have a grandson with this condition. The bishop who is the father of Lydie, did not want her to take medication so they explored other ways for her to control the condition. There was also a lot of information in the book about organic farming, which I enjoyed.
April 13, 2023
Another home run for Suzanne. I love how she always can pick topics outside the norm for the Amish genre. This time she takes on ADD, I have a grown son who has struggled with this his entire life, so a topic close to my heart.
Lydie, the main female character has always been different. She struggles to stay on task, can’t hold down jobs, disappoints her father. But when she goes to work for her aunt — things get better. She still messes up a lot, but her aunt is able to give constructive criticism.
Until this happens she had been wanting to leave the faith this is just a wonderful book. There is a romance as well. But since I broke my wrist I can’t write more and don’t want yo spoil the story.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for this opportunity to review this ARC. All opinions are my own
Lydie, the main female character has always been different. She struggles to stay on task, can’t hold down jobs, disappoints her father. But when she goes to work for her aunt — things get better. She still messes up a lot, but her aunt is able to give constructive criticism.
Until this happens she had been wanting to leave the faith this is just a wonderful book. There is a romance as well. But since I broke my wrist I can’t write more and don’t want yo spoil the story.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for this opportunity to review this ARC. All opinions are my own
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews