Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

On Sundays, She Picked Flowers

Rate this book
When Judith Rice killed her mother, she thought she put an end to the woman's hold on her. Seventeen years later, secluded deep in the woods of northern Georgia, Jude knows that the past isn't all that easy to discard.


Alone with her strange house and even stranger woods, Jude must grapple with ghosts, haints, beasts, and an enigmatic woman who threatens to undo the tentative peace Jude's built for herself by fanning the violence that lives just underneath her skin.

142 pages, Paperback

First published October 18, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Yah-Yah Scholfield

3 books563 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,359 (27%)
4 stars
1,979 (40%)
3 stars
1,192 (24%)
2 stars
329 (6%)
1 star
87 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,340 reviews
Profile Image for DianaRose.
1,328 reviews528 followers
September 7, 2025
a favorite read of 2025🩵

edit: 2/3/26 - full review BEWARE OF SPOILERS:

I finished ON SUNDAYS SHE PICKED FLOWERS in just under a day – this was absolutely horrifying in so many ways: the incest, the abuse, the racism, the crushing of hopeful souls, the secret cannibalism… and I mean, the first 25 pages?! Truly the goriest pages I have ever read (and I am a relatively new horror reader so those descriptions… WOW so gross but SO SO GOOD).

I loved all the different POVs and interludes from Ma’am, Auntie Vivian and Phyllis, Candle (before Jude names the house Candle), but especially the beast/Nemoira. While I admit that I am still a tad confused as to what the beast/Nemoira symbolizes (death and rebirth?/something very cyclical, at least), she was just a perfect morally gray character, if we can even call her “morally gray” because she is so far removed from social mores and is more of the natural world than anything else.

Ugh, and Jude’s journey of self-acceptance and love was just so crushing. Her pain and urgency to be loved by anyone, but especially her mother was so heartbreaking and tangible. Her character growth was spectacular – her forgiving her mother and trying to love her as her sister…

---

one of THE best sapphic, southern gothic horror novels i’ve ever read, aside from beloved, of course; i’ve been thinking about it for months.

on sundays she picked flowers is insanely gory from quite literally page one, full of twisted family dynamics, and ultimately left me chilled to the bone.
Profile Image for Gabriela.
126 reviews81 followers
April 1, 2026
“Violence was her birthright, anger her first gift”

If you were to ask me what I thought of horror a year ago my mind immediately would have jumped to something like Texas Chainsaw Massacre (I know it’s a movie but still). Nope, no thank you, not my brand of entertainment. And then I recently discovered the subgenre that blends the psychological with monstrous and magical manifestations. Stories that allow you to experience and process trauma and pain in a way that feels restructured and cathartic.

That is exactly how I would categorize this Southern gothic novel. Essentially this story is about the devastating and far reaching effects of slavery on families even after emancipation in the Deep South. It is about one woman’s struggle to break the chain of violence she has been born into. This is the type of story that I probably wouldn’t be drawn to in historical or nonfiction because it is so bleak, but the monstrous elements actually helped me take in the true graphic violence.

Jude lives with her abusive mother for 41 years before she decides to call it quits, and runs away into the Okefenokee woods in Southern Georgia. She fixes up a haunted house and lives in relative peace, trading plant based medicines for necessities in the nearest town, until a mysterious woman named Nemoira shows up at her door.

Now imagine the loneliness of running from the only home, only family you’ve ever known (albeit an abusive one) and building a life from scratch in a house in the woods haunted by haints and the memories of a slave plantation. Then one day a beautiful stranger shows up asking for shelter for the night. Of course she stays for more than just one night. And her role is as puzzling as her identity. Is Nemoira a distraction from dealing with the past, a second chance at being loved, or an obsession through which to channel her inherited violence? Or maybe a manifestation of the pain she’s buried in those woods.

Ultimately the horror here doesn’t lie with the monsters and haints, but in the truth of the chain of brutality that bleeds from slavery into a family’s legacy. And I know that people carry responsibility for their own actions, but there is an undeniable cycle. The true horror is visible in the way that violence steals the innocence and joy from each generation.

The writing that frames this devastating story is beautiful and poetic without being flowery. And despite the heartbreaking subject, this novel is not without hope. There is just no glossing over the pain. An acknowledgment that the only way out is through. I know I will be thinking about Jude’s story for a long time.

4.5 ⭐️’s kindle & Audio

—————————————————————

“I look at you and my mind goes quiet, and I know I’d die a thousand times by your hand if only for the joy of coming back to you and being killed again.”

This was stunning and heart wrenching 🥹

——————————————————————

Woman escapes her abusive mother and flees to a haunted house in a haunted wood and becomes a healer. There may also be a sapphic romance.
Profile Image for Jan Agaton.
1,615 reviews1,736 followers
October 21, 2025
honestly one of the best horror books I've ever read. I read a lot of horror so not many shock me as much as this one did. plus the writing is phenomenal & the exploration of toxic familial relationships, as well as the notion of scrounging for love despite everything was really well done. the fact that this is a debut novel is unbelievable. I can't wait for more people to read this when it comes out in January. I'm going to be thinking about this one for a very long time.

Thank you to Saga Press for sending me an early copy!
Profile Image for Chelsea.
655 reviews1,434 followers
March 25, 2026
I wanted to like this SO BAD, like Sapphic horror? Brutal murder? Cannibalism? Incest? Abuse? Generational trauma? Slavery? Gothic-vibes and Ghosts!?

Sign me up for a fucked up tale.......



**Spoilers**

The whole plot in dot points.

•Jude is beaten.
•Jude murders mother.
•GORY AF. (I can't handle anything to do with eyeballs 🤢)
•Jude runs away.
•Jude finds and moves into a haunted af house.
•Feels watched by ‘beast’
•Women arrives at door.
•Woman stays.
•Jude and her fall into relationship because ✨unknown reasons✨ because Jude is fkn awful.
•Woman says "come forest with me"
•Jude says "I don't fucking want to"
•Woman disappears for 2 months.
•Jude sad as she thinks woman died.
•Woman reappears, Jude is abusive.
•Woman says "come forest with me"
•Jude says OKAY FINE.
Nek minit,
•Woman is a bear........ (um what?)
•Bear been bringing human meat for Jude to eat for years.
•Jude is mad, kills bear, eats bear.
•Bear comes back to life.
•Happily ever after.
•Sporadically add random POV's of Jude's mums cunt-head sisters as well.

Wtf is happening.......



This book put me in a constant state of uncomfortable that didn't feel good...

I felt 0 connection with Jude.

Honestly, Jude was pretty fucking awful, unlikable and even after her tragic backstory lore forced it's way into the story, it still wasn't enough to give me 1 ounce of ........ care factor for Jude?

The sapphic element was terribly under-explored, and the writing was so weird for the fact that it was STUNNING, but simultaneously made me feel like I was having a stroke and it was my first time ever reading a word before.


The horror/gore was for sure the best parts.
Incest, assault, no sapphic development and no character development arc for Jude was the worst parts.
Profile Image for Sadie Hartmann.
Author 25 books8,346 followers
February 25, 2026
Title/Author: On Sundays She Picked Flowers by Yah Yah Scholfield
Format Read: Physical
Pub date: January 27th, 2026
Publisher: S&S/Saga Press
Page Count: 240
Affiliate Link: https://bookshop.org/a/7576/978166809...
"When Judith Rice fled her childhood home, she thought she'd severed her abusive mother's hold on her. Drawn to the forests of southern Georgia, Jude finds shelter in a house as haunted by its violent history as she is by her own. And over the next thirteen years, Jude blossoms from her bitter beginnings into a wisewoman, a healer. But her hard-won peace is threatened when an enigmatic woman shows up on her doorstep. The woman is beautiful but unsettling, captivating but uncanny. Ensnared by her desire for this stranger, and as the woman stirs up memories of her escape years ago, Jude must confront the calls of violence rooted in her bloodline."--NoveList
Recommended for readers who enjoy:
- Abandoned Haunted Isolated Houses (Place: Georgia) Haints
- Body Horror & Transformation
- "Special Meat"
- Southern Gothic
- Intergenerational Trauma-Legacy of Violence
- Magic/Fairytale/Shapeshifters
-Sapphic desire, longing, sex
__
There is a playlist for this book curated by the author:
https://largeheartedboy.com/2026/02/1...

"i’m just a soul whose intentions are good / oh lord, please don’t let me be misunderstood"

Final recommendation: This impressive debut leaves its mark. A forty-one year old woman living at home who has been viciously and apathetically abused by her own mother her whole life finally takes an opportunity to escape her situation and run far from the only place she has ever known. She seeks solace at this diner where the server tells her about an abandoned house in the woods that nobody goes to because witches lived there and it's haunted.
Jude's journey of self-discovery and healing in these woods and in this house she names "Candle" is nothing short of a magical fairytale--the evil queen is gone and the princess has escaped her prison in the castle tower...now, a mysterious stranger shows up unexpectedly and changes Jude's life.
The story transitions into a blend of fable/Southern Gothic/Folk horror--much like The Lamb by Lucy Rose. Elements of all three sub-genres dance.
This story is red & violent, dark & feral. I really enjoyed it.
Comps: The Lamb by Lucy Rose, My Darling Girl by Jennifer McMahon, Woodworm by Layla Martinez
Profile Image for Cervidaeda.
1 review3 followers
June 15, 2020
Five stars for just the first chapter? Yes. Five stars for the whole book? Absolutely. I’ve been cured of gay illiteracy forever, I can’t thank the author enough.
1 review
May 27, 2020
The author has put up the first chapter for previewing on Medium, and just a glance at it tells you exactly why you should pick this book up and read it cover to cover.

https://medium.com/@ariesconceptss/on...

Yah Yah Scholfield has an impeccable grasp of atmosphere and horror, and the skill to create an immersive experience with the two.

A culmination of their previous work in the genre of horror (particularly notable in their range, from the gripping and subtle fear present in their science-fiction story 'It's Warm In Here' to the death-and-devotion turned on its head of 'Cherry Wine', to stories shot through with terrible joy, of becoming, with 'What The Water Gave Me') Scholfield paints a picture of their protagonist and her world masterfully, giving us just a taste of the horrors yet to come.

This reader has already pre-ordered their copy of On Sundays, She Picked Flowers and is eagerly awaiting its arrival and the subsequent revisiting of this review.
Profile Image for Zana.
1,066 reviews450 followers
October 23, 2025
3.25 stars.

I wanted to really love this since the horror and the bleak Southern Gothic atmosphere were on point, but the dark romance ended up being nonsensical and relied a lot more on vibes than I liked.

I loved the evocative storytelling and the graphic horror in this short novel. If you want something really dark and really visceral, then I'd definitely recommend this novella.

The descriptions of gore and death felt like I was either there with Jude, or watching a Guillermo del Toro film. (The haunted house that Jude moves into was giving Crimson Peak vibes.) Hell, even the extremely toxic familial relationships were engrossing.

But then the romance happened.

I won't lie. I didn't get it. There were too many time jumps and it made the relationship flow so unnaturally. I wanted to root for Jude and Nemoira so badly, but the whole thing felt more like a dream sequence or a hallucination than anything that actually happened.

Idk.

I wanna say props to the author for writing an older FMC. But I'm not really sure if this made any difference in the end.

I'd still recommend this because the author's prose is lovely and the vibes were so deliciously creepy.

Thank you to S&S/Saga Press and NetGalley for this arc.
Profile Image for Gyalten Lekden.
852 reviews238 followers
February 15, 2026
Verdant, emotional writing explores generational trauma in ways both literal and metaphoric, and it is really hard to put down. Look, this novel may be categorized as “horror” due to the fact that there are paranormal and fantastic elements, but those are not the horrific parts of the story, and it feels more like magical realism that isn’t afraid to look in dark, bloody corners. She does such a wonderful job at building characters that feel personal and intentional, it is hard to look away from them and help but fall for them. Maybe what is most compelling about the characters, though, is how she manages to be both honest and gentle with the way she depicts them. There is no character that is relocated to being just one thing, be it victim or abuser or anything else. There is a recognition that we are complicated and broken and resilient in very personal, varied ways, and that makes the characters and relationships between them so much more compelling. The world building and atmosphere are great, you feel lost in the fecund swamp or trapped in the sweaty suburbs, the sense of time and place is profound and compelling. The writing is thick and emotional but still feels jagged and stripped back. It never feels self-indulgent but instead follows a density that matches the character’s emotional journey, more relaxed and open at some points and tense and hurried and anxious at others, really letting the writing styles tell the story. The narrative is actually kind of simple, and while there are a few really significant bits of external action the story is mostly about an inner journey. There is very little external that is “achieved” by the end of the story, but that doesn’t make the journey not breath-taking, tense, terrifying, and empowering in various measures.

I appreciate that this story doesn’t allude to generational trauma but instead addresses it directly, giving the reader enough to figure out on their own while later making some things specific and clear, and then letting the characters react to that disclosure of specificity. I also appreciate that the fantastic elements complement the story, but they don’t make the story. In fact, it would be possible to read all of the fantastic elements as metaphor or as imagined or some combination thereof. I don’t think that is the narrative intention, but the way they work in the story they are not the hinge point, they just add to the character’s understanding of self, their exploration of how to escape both personal and societal violences and define themselves on their own terms. They are not trying to exorcise their ghosts they are learning to live with them, to favor community instead of self-cherishing, to learn how self-worth and a personal sense of value can come from the ways you see yourself reflected in those who you care about, even if they are haints or other wild, fantastical forest beasts.

This story is emotional and feels genuinely uninterested in perpetuating any idea of the status quo. It is bold and heartfelt and most terrifying not when there are eruptions of violence, but when personal histories are denied and repressed and we are left without the chance to determine how we want to be in the world.
Profile Image for Dana.
505 reviews25 followers
February 13, 2026
This was beautifully told, and the only reason I gave it 3 stars rather than more is 100% on me and my personal feelings. I am finding more and more that books with a strong foundation in trauma and abuse passed down from generation to generation do not sit well with me.

Completely my own thoughts and opinions. I firmly believe others will love this book with all of its beauty and scars.
Profile Image for Laurie .
2,023 reviews825 followers
October 13, 2026
This is a story that never shies away from the darkness of violence. It marinates in it and surprises with moments of horror and gore but is more a character study about a complex woman named Jude who has been harmed by the person (people) who should’ve (but couldn’t) love her.

Jude is 41 and has been living her entire life with a brutally abusive and controlling mother. One day she can no longer take it, and things go about as far as they can go and she flees to the woods where she sets up home in an abandoned (possibly haunted) cabin where she tends to an altar to satisfy the spirits and haints. She has a peaceful life considering all that came before it but generational trauma comes calling in unexpected ways, as it does. One day a woman shows up at her door and stirs feelings in Jude that she wasn’t expecting. Nothing is easy for Jude who learned that blood on her face was better than the humiliation of tears and who realizes she has a lot of shit to work through as she discovers the secrets of her family's past.

This is a beautifully written story that, at times, reminded me a little of Betty by Tiffany McDaniel but On Sundays She Picked Flowers leans heavily into the fantastical side of things unlike the straight up blunt reality of Betty. There is a whole lotta awful that happens between the pages so prepare yourself before jumping in. It’s like a nightmarish fairytale and I really did love the heartbreaking journey it took me on. It's one that'll haunt you after you put it down.
Profile Image for Neo_in_Libroland.
149 reviews20 followers
February 20, 2026
Have you ever read a book that made you so damn happy with the way it’s written—where you look at the page in awe and deep respect for how the story is being told? This is that kind of book.

Listen: if you like literary fiction, if writing matters more to you than plot, if you’re not squeamish, READ THIS BOOK RIGHT NOW!

If a writer can make the reader care about horrible people and actually love reading from their perspective, they are a damn good writer. I can’t wait to see what Scholfield comes up with next.

Here are some excerpts of the magnificent prose:

“There was no future, only Jude and Ma’am graying and decaying, Ma’am’s cane cracking her back and Jude standing there and taking it, smiling like an idiot even as she was mashed into a pulp.”

“The grounds, steeped with Black blood, released noxious gases; up, up they rose, through mud and rock, to squat over the house, to sicken it and its inhabitants. Malevolent and sticky, left too long to stew in its ugliness, the house churned as it adjusted to Jude’s presence. Jude, nauseous and vertiginous, felt the house’s discomfort as her own — together, woman and walls reeled with the sensation of invasion.”

“I wanted you dead, wanted to eat you whole, wanted to spend every hour of every day watching the lights in your window. I wanted to tear your flesh and to lap at every scar. Bring you meat. Make you into meat.”

Are you kidding me? How dare they write that damn well?
Profile Image for alyssa✨.
561 reviews591 followers
February 28, 2026
i will eat up a sapphic southern gothic horror every single time
Profile Image for Cristina.
391 reviews217 followers
February 2, 2026
On Sundays She Picked Flowers is a gory, twisted, evocative tale. We follow Jude, who escapes her mother’s abusive home and flees south before settling in an abandoned haunted house in the middle of the woods. For 13 years she makes peace with the ghosts she lives with and makes a life for herself. But when a beautiful yet uncanny woman shows up on her doorstep, the simmering violence in her veins and memories of her past rise to the surface once again.

It was really refreshing to see an older female main character. Jude is 41 at the start of the book, but she’s 53 for the bulk of the story. She was raised by a mother born into slavery, and by the end of the book Jude sees a desegregated South. Seeing all those decades play out in the background of her story, and her brief interactions with society as it changed, was an interesting inclusion. The long lasting impact of slavery on Black families is a major theme within this book, and we see how Jude was both entangled within and secluded from that experience. As well as the incredibly complex relationship she has with her mother because of it.

Jude feels the cycle of violence within her blood, as she was born from it and socialized within it. We see her approach diverting pathways, as she is faced with a choice of how she wants to be defined. The conflicting natures within herself begging to be embraced. And we see how Nemoira plays a very important role in this decision. She is a reflection of Jude’s most base instincts. I love a good toxic lesbian entanglement, especially when a conflicting choice of morals is involved. Jude and Nemoira’s burning desire really emphasized the otherness that Jude feels in her life.

Even though there is so much evil and violence within this book, there were so many moments of beauty that I loved. I loved seeing Jude’s kinship with her home and the unique relationship she formed with the ghosts within it. The lovely descriptions of the quilts she worked on and the pride she gained from making them. The joy she got from cooking cultural dishes largely a part of her upbringing. Her foraging knowledge related to herbal remedies and ingredients. Picking flowers every Sunday. The exploration of her desire. And the very unconventional bond she had with her Aunt Phyllis. For a book that’s on the shorter side, it was bursting with so much life and complexity.
Profile Image for Aimee.
61 reviews4 followers
December 14, 2023
Only reason this didn’t get 1 star was because it was gay.

The pacing was really off, and I didn’t actually believe the love story at all. Probably because the author kept doing time jumps and just telling us things happened instead of actually showing us.

The two different chapters from the different POVs were the most interesting part of this book; I wish we got way more chapters like that and it could have helped the pacing.

I recognize that fantasy needs a suspension of disbelief but there are so many unanswered questions that I can’t get over:
- Why did no one report Jude’s mom’s murder?
- why did the aunts basically not care that Jude killed her? They said they loved her even knowing she was abusive.
- why did Nemoira wait 17 years to talk to Jude?
- how in the world did Jude buy things? She didn’t have a job and didn’t seem to sell anything
- why did the innkeeper own the cabin? Why did they pay for the utilities?


Jude immediately falling out of love with Nemoira and then falling back in love after she killed her made no sense. Sorry but if that’s the love of your life and the love of your life is a wolf… I feel like you gotta get over that the cannibalism

Also, I know this was an independent author but they couldn’t have gotten an editor or even a friend to read through it? There was a typo on almost every single page and some of them made sentences unreadable.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Get Your Tinsel in a Tangle.
2,395 reviews74 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
January 19, 2026
Something bad went down. I’m not gonna say what. But it was messy, it was deserved, and by the time Jude walks into that haunted swamp house, she is covered in blood and completely done with everyone’s nonsense, including her own. That’s the level of chaos we’re starting at in On Sundays She Picked Flowers, Yah Yah Scholfield’s feral, poetic, deeply unwell Southern Gothic debut that reads like a fever dream wrapped in Spanish moss and bone-deep grief.

This book is not gently haunted. It’s not “spooky creaking floorboards and a sad ghost named Martha.” No. The house bleeds. The woods whisper. The land remembers everything. And Jude? Jude doesn’t flinch. She makes tea. She talks to the furniture. She picks flowers while her hands still stink of generational trauma. She’s not just living in the haunted house, she’s bonding with it like it’s a traumatized cat that bites. Which honestly... same.

We meet Jude after a life spent under the thumb (and fists) of her violently abusive mother. At 41, she finally breaks free, committing an act of survival so brutal it echoes for generations. She flees into the woods of southern Georgia, where she discovers a decaying house filled with ghosts, memories, and just enough sentience to judge her cooking. Over the next 13 years, Jude transforms from a scared, isolated woman into a healer, a cunning-wild wisewoman tending her haunted acreage and making peace with the dead, and the ones that should be.

And then Nemoira shows up. Like a nightmare in silk. Gorgeous. Vaguely threatening. Possibly a cryptid. Definitely not someone who knocks before disrupting your entire life and reawakening the bloodlust in your bones. Jude’s desire for her is immediate, disturbing, and magnetic. Their relationship is tender in places and absolutely unhinged in others, like "horny vampire witch shows up at your trauma cabin and offers you mystery meat." You don’t say no. But you should ask more questions.

The real horror here isn’t just in the hauntings or the bloodletting. It’s in what Jude carries with her. The family secrets she was never meant to survive. The kind of trauma that sinks into the soil and rots your roots. There’s no clean redemption arc waiting in the wings. No tidy grief resolution. This is healing as reckoning. Survival that bites back. Jude’s rage is sacred. Her love is messy. Her choices are complicated. And her transformation is honestly breathtaking.

Also, the prose? The prose is feral and elegant at the same time. Yah Yah Scholfield writes like they are building a church out of rot and ribs. Every sentence pulses. Every paragraph is layered with grief and blood and longing. The house becomes a character. The land becomes a witness. You are not reading this book. You are walking through it barefoot, sweating, possibly cursed.

It’s weird. It’s brutal. It’s queer. It’s stunning. It is absolutely not for the faint of heart, and it does not give a single damn about your comfort. But it gave me everything I didn’t know I was looking for in a Southern Gothic horror story. I wanted revenge and tenderness and haunted furniture and a heroine who stares into the abyss and asks it what kind of tea it likes. Jude gave me all of that and then some. 4.5 stars.

Whodunity Award: Excellence in Feral Elegance and Horny Haunt Vibes

Massive thanks to Saga Press and NetGalley for the ARC and the emotional damage. I will be sending you the invoice for therapy, flower seeds, and one haunted porch swing.
Profile Image for Nina The Wandering Reader.
494 reviews537 followers
February 25, 2026
“She thought she knew, before, the difference between her voice and the voice of her mother, but they sang in harmony now. Mean songs, bleak songs—whether the music came from within her, [...] or from her mother’s restless spirit, Jude couldn’t say, but she heard it, all day and all night, in her nightmares and in the small hours, her mind a symphony of rage.”
Profile Image for Becky Q..
385 reviews5 followers
October 4, 2026
*3.5 Stars!*

This was a really interesting book for me...The writing was beautiful, but it was still pretty easy to follow and something about it just felt special and unique. I was especially into the family story/the exploration of generational trauma + cycles of abuse. The horror was VERY graphic at times definitely outside of comfort zone, but I can definitely still appreciate just how well it was done. I felt like I could imagine everything so vividly...maybe a little TOO vividly haha...

I think my only real big issue was the pacing. The beginning was almost captivating to me but after that it gradually felt slower with only a few moments where I felt like things picked back up again. I also wasn't as invested in the romantic relationship as I was in the family side of the story, and I feel like the ending was a little underwhelming compared to how strongly the story started. I'm still trying to find my spot in the horror genre and I think this book helped me figure out a little more about what I do and don't enjoy in horror and even though not everything in this book worked for me personally, I can absolutely see this being a huge hit for the right reader!
Profile Image for Mira.
1 review
October 22, 2020
Honestly, Yah Yah is on their way to becoming one of the best horror writers of this generation. There are not many with their ability to capture the atmospheric tension that is found throughout their work. I've read all of their short stories and the first chapter of On Sundays, and I am truly excited to read the novel once it comes out. There are a lot of people, white people, creating comments calling a black, non binary, lesbian racist and homophobic. And the question is, do you have this energy for actual racist and homophobic white people? Because ya'll truly went out of your way to try and make Yah Yah look bad when all they said was the truth. Like sorry, not sorry, but everyone in the comments acting stupid AND loud, need to go outside and find real problems to worry about. And just in case I've been unclear, you can't be racist to white people. Anyway, read On Sundays and give Mx Yah Yah their well deserved coin.
Profile Image for Coffee&Cliffhangers.
208 reviews109 followers
November 17, 2025
This hauntinly Dark and Intense story is both thought-provoking and horrifying. Centered on Violence, generational trauma, and the cost of self-actualization.
Judith lived her life under the physicial and psychological abuse of her Mother whom she refers to as "Maam." She finally escapes and flees drawn to the woods and a house as haunted as her own. But she embraces the house and soothes its ghosts and builds a new life becoming a healer. When one day she meets a woman who changes everything. Jude is inexplicably drawn to her. and takes her in. But things aren't what they seem and as the relationship blooms it also brings back the terror of what she escaped and is finally forced to see "what a sick thing love was.'
Just when you think you know how this will end Yah Yah Scholfield flips it on you and you will never be the same.
Profile Image for Amber.
2,416 reviews
March 2, 2026
What the hell is this? Part horror, part supernatural, part generational trauma/violence, and part WTF.
Profile Image for Dragos.
24 reviews6 followers
June 20, 2026
Someone who has me blocked on tumblr wrote a book and it wasn't even that bad
Profile Image for Denise Ruttan.
548 reviews77 followers
December 16, 2025
I wish I had loved this and in theory all the pieces were there of things I normally enjoy. I would recommend this to the right reader but this just wasn't for me. This was a beautifully written Southern gothic full of literary sapphic monster fucking, brutal murders, cannibalism, child abuse, rape, racism, the scars of slavery, and generational trauma. I thought I was prepared for the trigger warnings and I still found it pretty gross, even as I understood Jude's motivations in the end. It also did a wonderful job at evoking atmosphere.

The story opens with Jude brutally murdering her mother after she tries to choke her for leaving their physically abusive home at age 41. I understood her mother and her pain so even though that was bleak, I found that arc beautiful in its trauma in the end. I also liked how the FMC was older. Jude doesn't really seem to change her violent ways much other than she gains a deeper understanding of her past, and not much happens in the plot other than she adopts a haunted house in the woods and is visited by a beast that brings her gifts of meat and becomes even more of a loner.

I liked the idea of haunted objects that become friends, but I thought this would be more of a haunted house story and it was a misunderstood character-driven feminist witch in the woods story instead.

A strange woman named Nemoira stops by, and Jude asks no questions, which was strange. She just gives into her loneliness and falls madly in love. Then the cycle of violence begins anew. This is a story at its heart of people who look away and let things happen, and the people who are left behind. And the characters vomit quite a bit, for good reason.

There was just not much happening other than the gross body horror, cannibalism, and generational trauma, and despite the beautiful writing I also found it hard to get into the romance. It was a romance in the end, but I found it a desperate, gory, unsatisfying kind that often turned my stomach.

So if you like literary gross horror dripping with Southern atmosphere and trauma, this may be more for you than it was for me.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance review copy. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Lee (Books With Lee).
175 reviews723 followers
June 12, 2026
4.5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨

I originally read Sundays She Picked Flowers about three years ago, back when it wasn't getting much attention, and I remember absolutely loving it. Seeing it now get picked up by a traditional publisher honestly makes me so happy.

This is one of those books that stayed with me long after I finished it. The story is emotional, thoughtful, and beautifully written without ever feeling overly sentimental. It has the kind of heart that makes you slow down and really sit with the characters.

One of my favorite things as a reader is watching a book find the audience it deserves, and that's exactly how I feel about this one. It's been incredible to see more people discovering it because it truly deserves its flowers.

If you missed it the first time around like many readers did, this is your sign to pick it up
Profile Image for spicykatzreads.
264 reviews333 followers
October 28, 2026
i couldn’t have imagined where this story was going to take me and how many tears I would shed both in happiness and extreme sadness
Profile Image for Asha.
276 reviews223 followers
July 7, 2026
“Couldn’t she see that there was no such thing as home, only miserable rooms and walls and halls that hated?…Violence was her birthright, anger her first gift…”

What an incredible debut! So beautifully written, I can’t wait to see what they publish next.
Profile Image for Tyler Hancsak.
652 reviews209 followers
February 17, 2026
Let’s start with some positives: I was obsessed with Part 1 of this book. It was shocking, horrific, and provided such a stellar hook for the reader. Jude felt so well established in the story and it gave us a phenomenal starting point. The writing was SO rich and poetic, but wasn’t too fluffy; it was easy to understand and still gave such a great description of the events that took place. I really liked how we went back and forth in different perspectives because it gave more light to the other characters and their reasoning to be in the story.

The negatives: parts 2 + 3 dragged — and I mean dragged. The writing became fluffier, almost not making much sense in certain parts. Jude’s story became a major lull and it NEEDED something to help it. Yes, this was a lot of time to deconstruct all her trauma, but that never actually happened. Maybe that wasn’t the goal, but the story became so stagnant and repetitive because she was dealing with so much trauma and never tried to understand any of it or come out of it.

The small romance became a hopeful part of the story, but it ended up being a confusing part for me. The romance wasn’t shown well at all, and the author opted for more “tell” than anything. In certain moments, this became the normal type of storytelling, so it wasn’t easy to see anything develop naturally — everything became extremely factual. There also wasn’t much horror at all. Family and generational horrors? Yes, but not much of anything else.

I really wanted to like this, but honestly I would have probably DNF’d if it wasn’t for my book club.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,340 reviews