What do you think?
Rate this book
Inspector McLean #12
All That Lives
Two victims. Nothing connects them, except that someone buried them in the exact same way.
Seven hundred years apart.
An archaeological dig at the old South Leith parish kirkyard has turned up a mysterious body dating from around seven hundred years ago. Some suspect that this gruesome discovery is a sacrifice, placed there for a specific purpose.
Then a second body is unearthed. This victim went missing only thirty years ago - but the similarities between her death and the ancient woman's suggest something even more disturbing.
Drawn into the investigation, Inspector McLean finds himself torn between a worrying trend of violent drug-related deaths and uncovering what truly connects these bodies. When a third body is discovered, and too close for comfort, he begins to suspect dark purpose at play - and that whoever put them there is far from finished.
Seven hundred years apart.
An archaeological dig at the old South Leith parish kirkyard has turned up a mysterious body dating from around seven hundred years ago. Some suspect that this gruesome discovery is a sacrifice, placed there for a specific purpose.
Then a second body is unearthed. This victim went missing only thirty years ago - but the similarities between her death and the ancient woman's suggest something even more disturbing.
Drawn into the investigation, Inspector McLean finds himself torn between a worrying trend of violent drug-related deaths and uncovering what truly connects these bodies. When a third body is discovered, and too close for comfort, he begins to suspect dark purpose at play - and that whoever put them there is far from finished.
451 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 17, 2022
102 people are currently reading
363 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews
February 17, 2022
I always look forward to the latest addition to what is a favourite crime blended with the supernatural series by James Oswald featuring his Edinburgh based DI Tony McLean series. This is a intensely dark novel, with Tony really going through the wringer, his hip is troubling him, the number of detectives under his command have been seriously depleted with budget cuts, leading to increasingly heavier workloads, leaving him and his team in a constant state of tiredness, and to top it all, he is left flailing as Emma collapses in front of him, and as he visits her in hospital, the prognosis is far from reassuring, bringing back the trauma of his time when his grandmother, a pathologist, slipped away from him after an inordinately long period of time in hospital. That is not all, shockingly Chief Superintendent Gail Elmwood is back, despite the horrifying injuries she suffered, and her return does not bode well.
She is planning to have his team working closely in partnership with charities run by the pure evil that is Jane Louise Dee of Saifre Industries, Dee is being lauded as a saint as she picks up the slack in funding cuts in the charitable and voluntary sector, using her dirty money to grease palms and offering favours. Her tentacles have grown, a cancer that has spread into every crack of the establishment, even Police Scotland with Elmwood's Project Tantulus, forcing Tony to submit to her plans, despite his resistance. The severe pressure Tony is under has him understandably distracted when it comes to being on the ball at work. There is the worrying body of young Rory Devlin found at a derelict lumber yard, that on first appearances looks like murder, but turns out to be related to a nightmare new drug, referred to on the streets as Demon Breath or Zombo, more victims are to follow. Coincidentally, buried ancient bones of a woman are uncovered in a parish kirkyard, followed by the recovery of other old buried bones, one rather too close to home for Tony.
At first sight, the investigations appear to have little to connect them, but sinister evidence slowly accumulates that suggests that not only are they linked, they pose grave dangers to Tony and his team. DS Janie Harrison finds herself coming into her own, she has taken on the many traits of her boss and mentor, Tony, including being a thorn in the side of the police hierarchy. She might not understand or necessarily believe in the weird and odd aspects of their investigations, but like Tony, she is coming to accept them. It is her sheer determination and abilities that lead to a tense and thrillingly nailbiting finale. This is a wonderfully dark addition to this brilliant crime series, such a joy to see Janie's character development and the return of established characters, such as the medium Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob. Highly recommended. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.
She is planning to have his team working closely in partnership with charities run by the pure evil that is Jane Louise Dee of Saifre Industries, Dee is being lauded as a saint as she picks up the slack in funding cuts in the charitable and voluntary sector, using her dirty money to grease palms and offering favours. Her tentacles have grown, a cancer that has spread into every crack of the establishment, even Police Scotland with Elmwood's Project Tantulus, forcing Tony to submit to her plans, despite his resistance. The severe pressure Tony is under has him understandably distracted when it comes to being on the ball at work. There is the worrying body of young Rory Devlin found at a derelict lumber yard, that on first appearances looks like murder, but turns out to be related to a nightmare new drug, referred to on the streets as Demon Breath or Zombo, more victims are to follow. Coincidentally, buried ancient bones of a woman are uncovered in a parish kirkyard, followed by the recovery of other old buried bones, one rather too close to home for Tony.
At first sight, the investigations appear to have little to connect them, but sinister evidence slowly accumulates that suggests that not only are they linked, they pose grave dangers to Tony and his team. DS Janie Harrison finds herself coming into her own, she has taken on the many traits of her boss and mentor, Tony, including being a thorn in the side of the police hierarchy. She might not understand or necessarily believe in the weird and odd aspects of their investigations, but like Tony, she is coming to accept them. It is her sheer determination and abilities that lead to a tense and thrillingly nailbiting finale. This is a wonderfully dark addition to this brilliant crime series, such a joy to see Janie's character development and the return of established characters, such as the medium Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob. Highly recommended. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.
July 15, 2022
Hard to believe this is the 12th book in this enjoyable and unique series featuring DI Tony McLean. Nothing new about police procedurals set in Edinburgh, of course, but the cast of unusual characters and hints of the supernatural set this series apart, and, on the strength of this latest installment, it looks like the series is far from running out of steam.
One central theme of this book is the discovery of buried bodies in unusual sites. The first dates from 700 years ago, the second from 30 years – therefore, technically a cold case – but the third discovery is uncomfortably close to home.
To further add to the heavy caseload for Police Scotland, people are dying from a powerful new narcotic called “Demon’s Breath”. To make matters even worse for Tony, his boss Gail Elmwood has returned and wishes for Police Scotland to partner up with the sinister Dee Foundation, run by Tony’s arch nemesis, Mrs Saifre. Then his partner Emma collapses in front of him and goes into a coma. It seems as if the poor guy never gets a break.
As investigations proceed, it soon becomes apparent that these seemingly unrelated cases are mysteriously and dangerously linked. Like Jussi Adler-Olsen and Fred Vargas, James Oswald has managed to create a highly memorable series through using a cast of colourful, almost over the top characters. As always, there are star turns by Angus Cadwallader, Grumpy Bob, Charles Duguid and, of course, Madame Rose. It was also good to see Tony’s main ally in Police Scotland, DS Janie Harrison get an enhanced role here.
One central theme of this book is the discovery of buried bodies in unusual sites. The first dates from 700 years ago, the second from 30 years – therefore, technically a cold case – but the third discovery is uncomfortably close to home.
To further add to the heavy caseload for Police Scotland, people are dying from a powerful new narcotic called “Demon’s Breath”. To make matters even worse for Tony, his boss Gail Elmwood has returned and wishes for Police Scotland to partner up with the sinister Dee Foundation, run by Tony’s arch nemesis, Mrs Saifre. Then his partner Emma collapses in front of him and goes into a coma. It seems as if the poor guy never gets a break.
As investigations proceed, it soon becomes apparent that these seemingly unrelated cases are mysteriously and dangerously linked. Like Jussi Adler-Olsen and Fred Vargas, James Oswald has managed to create a highly memorable series through using a cast of colourful, almost over the top characters. As always, there are star turns by Angus Cadwallader, Grumpy Bob, Charles Duguid and, of course, Madame Rose. It was also good to see Tony’s main ally in Police Scotland, DS Janie Harrison get an enhanced role here.
April 3, 2022
This is the twelfth novel in the Inspector McLean series by author James Oswald. This is a quirky series that is a little bit different to many other crime series in that it has a touch of the supernatural. Love the characters and they continue to develop while continuing with the intriguing cases.
There is an archaeological dig taking place in South Leith when a body is discovered dating back 700 years. The experts are unsure whether the person was murdered or some kind of human sacrifice. But then a second body is uncovered and this time it is far more up to date. The victim went missing thirty years ago but there are definite similarities between the two dead bodies. Inspector Tony McLean is leading the investigation and needs to discover what the connection is between the two bodies, but when a third body is then found he starts to seriously wonder if something far more sinister is occurring and how many more are in danger.
This is an exciting addition to this series and it goes from strength to strength.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Wildfire for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
There is an archaeological dig taking place in South Leith when a body is discovered dating back 700 years. The experts are unsure whether the person was murdered or some kind of human sacrifice. But then a second body is uncovered and this time it is far more up to date. The victim went missing thirty years ago but there are definite similarities between the two dead bodies. Inspector Tony McLean is leading the investigation and needs to discover what the connection is between the two bodies, but when a third body is then found he starts to seriously wonder if something far more sinister is occurring and how many more are in danger.
This is an exciting addition to this series and it goes from strength to strength.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Wildfire for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
March 17, 2022
All That Lives (kindle edition) by James Oswald.
This series has always received 5 stars in my reviews, this time 4 stars. It was well written as expected from this wonderful author but I've grown tired of some aspects in the story. Inspector Tony McLean's significant other, Emma. She's been around the world while Tony was hanging by a thread waiting for her to get her act together and come home.. Then she was poisoned or near death, but made a slow recovery. This story had Tony and Emma's relationship getting to the point where she was contributing to an early investigation while glowing with excitement. Finally they could bond his work regarding bones recently discovered and her elation over old bones at the university's department of archeology.
Unfortunately it was not to be. Another set back was in the forecast for Emma and another recovery. I love this series and the main character, but it's time to move on with or without Emma.
One of my favorite characters who only appears every now and then is Madame Rose. She's such an over the top medium of sorts, but all in a loving way. She did make a brief appearance...too brief. There was only one book that I recall where Madame Rose was a main feature. Sorry to complain but I want more of Madame Rose! She adds so much to the story.
The story itself was interesting with a touch of the supernatural. Interesting but a bit predictable. I'm staying with this series and I hope by being honest about my feelings no one is thrown off. J.O. is a gifted author and this is a great series. I'm looking forward to a new adventure with Tony McLean.
This series has always received 5 stars in my reviews, this time 4 stars. It was well written as expected from this wonderful author but I've grown tired of some aspects in the story. Inspector Tony McLean's significant other, Emma. She's been around the world while Tony was hanging by a thread waiting for her to get her act together and come home.. Then she was poisoned or near death, but made a slow recovery. This story had Tony and Emma's relationship getting to the point where she was contributing to an early investigation while glowing with excitement. Finally they could bond his work regarding bones recently discovered and her elation over old bones at the university's department of archeology.
Unfortunately it was not to be. Another set back was in the forecast for Emma and another recovery. I love this series and the main character, but it's time to move on with or without Emma.
One of my favorite characters who only appears every now and then is Madame Rose. She's such an over the top medium of sorts, but all in a loving way. She did make a brief appearance...too brief. There was only one book that I recall where Madame Rose was a main feature. Sorry to complain but I want more of Madame Rose! She adds so much to the story.
The story itself was interesting with a touch of the supernatural. Interesting but a bit predictable. I'm staying with this series and I hope by being honest about my feelings no one is thrown off. J.O. is a gifted author and this is a great series. I'm looking forward to a new adventure with Tony McLean.
March 2, 2022
Ahhhh. It's a bittersweet feeling writing this review. The sweet part is that I have just read the latest book in one of my favourite crime series, complete with enhanced appearance (at least compared to recent books) from one of my favourite characters, Grumpy Bob. The bitter part ... well, I need to savour the feeling of contentment that follows the reading another brilliant foray into the world of Tony McLean and co as this is the last we'll be seeing of him for a wee while. I know! But let's not dwell on that. They're all still here right now, and back with a case that sees the return of possibly McLean's longest standing nemesis - Jane Louise Dee or Mrs Saifre as he less than affectionately calls her.
Violent deaths due to new, lethal, drugs, unmarked graves and centuries old bones, and a touch of the supernatural - this book has all the hallmarks of a classic McLean investigation and from the very beginning drew me into the sense of mystery and uneasiness that I have come to expect and love from these books. I can think of nothing worse than. the fate which befalls the first 'victim' in this particular novel, and the urge to open a few windows and breathe in fresh air may well prove overwhelming for some. And this is before we even get to the main crux of the team's investigation - the suspicious death of a young man who initially looks like the victim of a very vicious attack but, it turns out, may have been the master of his own fate. There is a new, highly deadly drug on the scene, but just who is behind its creation and distribution proves very challenging to pin down. Alongside this, Janie Harrison is called to a building site where an unmarked grave has been discovered. Annoyingly the ownership of the site proves equally as troublesome to pin down ...
There is a kind of weariness to this book, reflected in McLean's demeanour - and that is before his personal life takes a dramatic turn for the worse. You can see how he has been ground down by the job, the constant cuts, the politics and the constant sense of corruption and wrongdoing that hangs around certain members of the constabulary like a bad smell. Enter stage left, Detective Superintendent Gail Elmwood, with her new found camaraderie with the aforementioned Mrs Saifre, and fans of the series will have more than an inkling of just what it is that is grinding McLean's gears. I like seeing the exploration of this side of McLeans' nature, exacerbated as it was by a dark turn in his personal life. He has always been a character who refuses to kowtow to management demands, taking his own line of investigation no matter what the potential repercussions. And believe me, this time around, they have the potential to cost him very dearly.
Once again, Janie Harrison take a much more pivotal role in proceedings and the continued to development of her character really adds something to the story. She is every bit as sceptical as the next copper about some of the more unusual aspects of the case, but, as with anyone who spends a significant amount of time in the strange world of Inspector McLean, ready to roll with the punches. She's really coming out of herself and proving to be a very astute and dedicated Detective Sergeant, stepping into the big shoes of Grumpy Bob as McLean's go to partner in crime fighting.
There is a wider cast of characters, our faithfuls like Angus Cadwallader, Duguid, and Emma, as well as Mrs McCutcheon's Cat and newcomer Cecily Slater's cat, who are on hand to keep McLean in check when Emma can't. Madame Rose plays a small but vital role in proceedings as always, but it falls to Janie to get to the crux of the issue and root out the real evil that is overwhelming Edinburgh, one seemingly charitable offering at a time. It did give me great pleasure to see Grumpy Bob step out from behind the desk one more time, showing us once again his canny, nature. It might have been a very different ending to the story if not for old Bob.
As ever, this is a standalone story but in truth is better read at the end of your McLean journey. So much of what happens in this book has links back to earlier novels that even though much is recapped for readers (and new Detectives to the team) throughout the book, it adds more weight if you understand the journey McLean and the team have been on to reach this point. I can't say that this proved to be an absolute conclusion to a long standing series arc, but it certainly draws a lot of the underlying threads together, and there will be more than the odd knowing nod from those who have been there from the start.
So, yes. A bittersweet experience. Did I love it? Of course I did. What's not to love in a story that is a police thriller with an undercurrent of the supernatural, one that features memorable characters I've really come to care about and that helps transport me to the darker, mystical side of a city I love too? But I am still sad. the ending to the book leaves a strange feeling - a small sense of hope, but at an unquestionable point of change. I just hope the wait for more, if it comes, is not too long.
Violent deaths due to new, lethal, drugs, unmarked graves and centuries old bones, and a touch of the supernatural - this book has all the hallmarks of a classic McLean investigation and from the very beginning drew me into the sense of mystery and uneasiness that I have come to expect and love from these books. I can think of nothing worse than. the fate which befalls the first 'victim' in this particular novel, and the urge to open a few windows and breathe in fresh air may well prove overwhelming for some. And this is before we even get to the main crux of the team's investigation - the suspicious death of a young man who initially looks like the victim of a very vicious attack but, it turns out, may have been the master of his own fate. There is a new, highly deadly drug on the scene, but just who is behind its creation and distribution proves very challenging to pin down. Alongside this, Janie Harrison is called to a building site where an unmarked grave has been discovered. Annoyingly the ownership of the site proves equally as troublesome to pin down ...
There is a kind of weariness to this book, reflected in McLean's demeanour - and that is before his personal life takes a dramatic turn for the worse. You can see how he has been ground down by the job, the constant cuts, the politics and the constant sense of corruption and wrongdoing that hangs around certain members of the constabulary like a bad smell. Enter stage left, Detective Superintendent Gail Elmwood, with her new found camaraderie with the aforementioned Mrs Saifre, and fans of the series will have more than an inkling of just what it is that is grinding McLean's gears. I like seeing the exploration of this side of McLeans' nature, exacerbated as it was by a dark turn in his personal life. He has always been a character who refuses to kowtow to management demands, taking his own line of investigation no matter what the potential repercussions. And believe me, this time around, they have the potential to cost him very dearly.
Once again, Janie Harrison take a much more pivotal role in proceedings and the continued to development of her character really adds something to the story. She is every bit as sceptical as the next copper about some of the more unusual aspects of the case, but, as with anyone who spends a significant amount of time in the strange world of Inspector McLean, ready to roll with the punches. She's really coming out of herself and proving to be a very astute and dedicated Detective Sergeant, stepping into the big shoes of Grumpy Bob as McLean's go to partner in crime fighting.
There is a wider cast of characters, our faithfuls like Angus Cadwallader, Duguid, and Emma, as well as Mrs McCutcheon's Cat and newcomer Cecily Slater's cat, who are on hand to keep McLean in check when Emma can't. Madame Rose plays a small but vital role in proceedings as always, but it falls to Janie to get to the crux of the issue and root out the real evil that is overwhelming Edinburgh, one seemingly charitable offering at a time. It did give me great pleasure to see Grumpy Bob step out from behind the desk one more time, showing us once again his canny, nature. It might have been a very different ending to the story if not for old Bob.
As ever, this is a standalone story but in truth is better read at the end of your McLean journey. So much of what happens in this book has links back to earlier novels that even though much is recapped for readers (and new Detectives to the team) throughout the book, it adds more weight if you understand the journey McLean and the team have been on to reach this point. I can't say that this proved to be an absolute conclusion to a long standing series arc, but it certainly draws a lot of the underlying threads together, and there will be more than the odd knowing nod from those who have been there from the start.
So, yes. A bittersweet experience. Did I love it? Of course I did. What's not to love in a story that is a police thriller with an undercurrent of the supernatural, one that features memorable characters I've really come to care about and that helps transport me to the darker, mystical side of a city I love too? But I am still sad. the ending to the book leaves a strange feeling - a small sense of hope, but at an unquestionable point of change. I just hope the wait for more, if it comes, is not too long.
February 19, 2022
UNBELIEVABLY GOOD
First, if I could give 10 stars in this review I would! Second, why did it take so long for us to receive another Inspector McLean novel? Third, I enjoy the supernatural element of the Inspector McLean storylines. These books are just so bloody good! I urge you to get your hands on any of the unread Inspector Tony McLean novels and devour them without delay!
First, if I could give 10 stars in this review I would! Second, why did it take so long for us to receive another Inspector McLean novel? Third, I enjoy the supernatural element of the Inspector McLean storylines. These books are just so bloody good! I urge you to get your hands on any of the unread Inspector Tony McLean novels and devour them without delay!
February 23, 2022
The Inspector McLean series is one of my favourites and only one of a few series novels that I will actually read from the very first book and patiently await the next.
All That Lives did not disappoint and I was gripped from start to finish.
I thoroughly enjoyed DS Janie Harrison being more front and centre, and showing a lot of the Tony McLean characteristics we know and love.
I’m intrigued to see where the next book goes and I’ll have it on my TBR pile as soon as it’s announced.
All That Lives did not disappoint and I was gripped from start to finish.
I thoroughly enjoyed DS Janie Harrison being more front and centre, and showing a lot of the Tony McLean characteristics we know and love.
I’m intrigued to see where the next book goes and I’ll have it on my TBR pile as soon as it’s announced.
April 6, 2023
The latest in the series doesn't disappoint and with a crime thriller with a touch of darkness and the series still maintains itself
February 22, 2022
James Oswald writes fantastically gripping crime novels with wonderful supernatral twists and All That Lives is no exception.
The twelfth book in the Tony McLean series is dark, compelling and absorbing as always, with plenty of twists and turns. Characters such as Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob add to the cast of familiar favourites who are all wonderfully written and add their own unique charm to the series.
The various subplots within the story are weaved together to form a thrilling, tense and edge of your seat conclusion that kept me guessing and is wonderfully executed. I'm now left wondering what is next for McLean and can only hope we don't have to wait to long to find out.
Thanks to Headline, Wildfire and NetGalley for the ARC.
The twelfth book in the Tony McLean series is dark, compelling and absorbing as always, with plenty of twists and turns. Characters such as Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob add to the cast of familiar favourites who are all wonderfully written and add their own unique charm to the series.
The various subplots within the story are weaved together to form a thrilling, tense and edge of your seat conclusion that kept me guessing and is wonderfully executed. I'm now left wondering what is next for McLean and can only hope we don't have to wait to long to find out.
Thanks to Headline, Wildfire and NetGalley for the ARC.
March 11, 2022
Review to follow
February 25, 2022
4/5 Very Good.
All That Lives is the 12th book in James Oswalds inspector McLean series and is another fine and atmospheric read.
With all the trademarks of Oswalds excellent storytelling, this series set in Edinburgh with a big twist of supernatural continues to thrill and get even better.
From the outset this book has a feeling of darkness lurking in the background, ready to reveal its evil head at any time, as slowly and expertly, Oswald crafts an entrancing tale of Death, and drugs, of a sinister foundation and in particular one lady and her far reaching tentacles that continue to penetrate further and deeper into McLean’s life and that of Edinburgh as a whole.
Fans of the series will love this but for newer readers I would suggest starting earlier books to get a feel of what’s to come in this enthralling series.
All That Lives is the 12th book in James Oswalds inspector McLean series and is another fine and atmospheric read.
With all the trademarks of Oswalds excellent storytelling, this series set in Edinburgh with a big twist of supernatural continues to thrill and get even better.
From the outset this book has a feeling of darkness lurking in the background, ready to reveal its evil head at any time, as slowly and expertly, Oswald crafts an entrancing tale of Death, and drugs, of a sinister foundation and in particular one lady and her far reaching tentacles that continue to penetrate further and deeper into McLean’s life and that of Edinburgh as a whole.
Fans of the series will love this but for newer readers I would suggest starting earlier books to get a feel of what’s to come in this enthralling series.
April 16, 2025
This is the first book I've read by James Oswald, and I really enjoyed it. The characters were likeable (except for a couple, but you would work out who they are by reading it). The story was good and believable. This is the 12th book in the Inspector McLean series so I've now downloaded the first book (99p on Amazon) to read.
March 3, 2024
As if the endless budget cuts and staff shortages are not enough, Tony has to deal with Chief Superintendent Gail Elmwood returning to the fold, newly repaired courtesy of his nemesis, Mrs Saifre. The re-instated Chief Superintendent is keen on a new plan to drive closer collaboration between the Dee Foundation and the Police, but Tony is focused on a series of drug-related deaths and Emma who is back in hospital with an uncertain prognosis. DS Janie Harrison is progressing well in her career and many of the team including Madame Rose make strong appearances in this instalment. Although these could be read as stand-alones, I highly recommend reading the series in order to appreciate the developments over time.
February 24, 2022
Showdown with an old enemy
Another fantastic Tony McLean story, I enjoyed the way the story was told partly by another prominent character to good effect.
Another fantastic Tony McLean story, I enjoyed the way the story was told partly by another prominent character to good effect.
February 6, 2022
The Seedier Side of Edinburgh
James Oswald has written the twelfth outing for Inspector McLean in yet another absorbing thriller. Taking you through the seedier side of Edinburgh, possible drug overdoses, charities doing the work of the Government. With a cast of world-weary detectives who never accept coincidences and an ever-increasing workload.
The body of Rory Devin is found in what is thought to be a drug overdose and Detective Sergeant Janie Harrison has been sent out with a detective to find out what is going on. When she reports back to Detective Inspector McLean that it looks like an overdose and a straightforward case.
When more bodies start appearing around the North side of Edinburgh McLean is trying to work out what links the deaths. As all of the victims had not been drug users but had died due to drugs. He knows that he currently cannot see the woods for the trees. He needs a break of some kind, even if those further Police Scotland might not be happy.
The Dee Foundation is the one thing that really is starting to get on the nerves of McLean especially as Jane Louise Saifre is involved. McLean and Saifre have history, especially as she had previously attempted to kill him, and managed to get away with it.
As the Police leadership try and maintain a healthy and close relationship with The Dee Foundation, the more McLean and his team have to investigate it. McLean tries not to let his prejudices cloud his judgement, especially when he goes missing, as his personal life is in turmoil.
With McLean missing, Janie Harrison is trying to crack the case like her boss would do and she knows that she is in a race against time. Will she be able to find her boss and more importantly will she be able to solve the case without him.
James Oswald has written the twelfth outing for Inspector McLean in yet another absorbing thriller. Taking you through the seedier side of Edinburgh, possible drug overdoses, charities doing the work of the Government. With a cast of world-weary detectives who never accept coincidences and an ever-increasing workload.
The body of Rory Devin is found in what is thought to be a drug overdose and Detective Sergeant Janie Harrison has been sent out with a detective to find out what is going on. When she reports back to Detective Inspector McLean that it looks like an overdose and a straightforward case.
When more bodies start appearing around the North side of Edinburgh McLean is trying to work out what links the deaths. As all of the victims had not been drug users but had died due to drugs. He knows that he currently cannot see the woods for the trees. He needs a break of some kind, even if those further Police Scotland might not be happy.
The Dee Foundation is the one thing that really is starting to get on the nerves of McLean especially as Jane Louise Saifre is involved. McLean and Saifre have history, especially as she had previously attempted to kill him, and managed to get away with it.
As the Police leadership try and maintain a healthy and close relationship with The Dee Foundation, the more McLean and his team have to investigate it. McLean tries not to let his prejudices cloud his judgement, especially when he goes missing, as his personal life is in turmoil.
With McLean missing, Janie Harrison is trying to crack the case like her boss would do and she knows that she is in a race against time. Will she be able to find her boss and more importantly will she be able to solve the case without him.
February 21, 2022
Another great book in the series. Good. And unexpected twists. Interesting new police characters
February 24, 2022
It’s hard to believe that this is the 12th book in the Tony McLean series. What an amazing journey James Oswald has taken us on. And after reading this, it’s clear that Oswald has absolutely no intention of resting on his laurels.
All That Lives is a dark, intense book full of malevolent forces. Oswald creates an atmosphere of high pressure where everything feels slightly off kilter and events lead readers down a difficult and crooked path.
At the heart of all this darkness is of course Tony McLean’s nemesis, Jane Louise Saifre. When I think of her, it is as a kind of cross between an octopus and a Medusa figure. She is not someone you want to look directly in the eye because while you do, one of her tentacles is probably stealing your soul.
During the construction of a tram line at the South Leith graveyard an ancient body is uncovered. Then a second body – a woman who went missing 30 years ago – is unearthed. There are disturbing similarities between these bodies despite the fact that they died some 700 years apart.
DS Janie Harrison is to the fore in this case and it’s terrific to see her stand her ground in the face of pretty fierce pressure from above. And what’s going on in the higher echelons of the force is incredibly worrying.
Budget cuts have seriously impacted the department and McLean’s workload is huge. He is knackered, his team equally so. It’s not good news either when he hears that Chief Superintendent Gail Elmwood has returned to duty. Her horrifying injuries seem to have been healed through an innovative trial process and though her face has a plastic sheen, her intentions are far more shocking than her appearance.
Elmwood has plans – project named Tantalus – to relieve the pressure on the detective force by going into partnership with he is planning to have his team working closely in partnership with charities run by the Dee Foundation. Tantalus, you will recall, got into trouble when he tried to serve up his own son at a feast with the gods. He was punished by Zeus to forever go thirsty and hungry in Hades. His terrible punishment was set as a warning for humanity not to cross the line between mortals and gods.
Tony is horrified but Elmwood is implacable. Troubles are piling up at Tony’s door but these are as nothing when personal issues come to the fore and leave him devastated. So Janie Harrison takes point on the terrible spate of drug deaths that have begun in the capital. A devilish drug is circulating in Edinburgh and it is killing people in a terrible way. On the streets it’s called Demon Breath and its impact is devastating.
It’s a powerful concoction of death and destruction and Tony is understandably creaking under the pressure. His team have to work out how these bodies are related and where the devil drug is coming from if more deaths are to be prevented.
Something has to give and what it is shocking and unexpected. It is only the tenacity of Janie Harrison that gives the team what it needs to follow this case through to a conclusion, but not before she has to listen to Madame Rose in order to prevent another, potentially even more horrifying, death….
With darkness pervading the heart of this book, James Oswald offers up a shocking, riveting storyline that is both tension filled and deeply disturbing. There’s a sense and a force behind the evil here that feels as if it is seeping into every corner of our lives and which strangely echoes some of the worst excesses of our own political existence at the moment.
Verdict: All That Lives is an engrossing, layered and deeply chilling story with all the characters we have come to love from this series. It is shocking and heart-wrenching and its impact will reverberate for years to come. It is an absolutely unmissable book in a series that I love.
All That Lives is a dark, intense book full of malevolent forces. Oswald creates an atmosphere of high pressure where everything feels slightly off kilter and events lead readers down a difficult and crooked path.
At the heart of all this darkness is of course Tony McLean’s nemesis, Jane Louise Saifre. When I think of her, it is as a kind of cross between an octopus and a Medusa figure. She is not someone you want to look directly in the eye because while you do, one of her tentacles is probably stealing your soul.
During the construction of a tram line at the South Leith graveyard an ancient body is uncovered. Then a second body – a woman who went missing 30 years ago – is unearthed. There are disturbing similarities between these bodies despite the fact that they died some 700 years apart.
DS Janie Harrison is to the fore in this case and it’s terrific to see her stand her ground in the face of pretty fierce pressure from above. And what’s going on in the higher echelons of the force is incredibly worrying.
Budget cuts have seriously impacted the department and McLean’s workload is huge. He is knackered, his team equally so. It’s not good news either when he hears that Chief Superintendent Gail Elmwood has returned to duty. Her horrifying injuries seem to have been healed through an innovative trial process and though her face has a plastic sheen, her intentions are far more shocking than her appearance.
Elmwood has plans – project named Tantalus – to relieve the pressure on the detective force by going into partnership with he is planning to have his team working closely in partnership with charities run by the Dee Foundation. Tantalus, you will recall, got into trouble when he tried to serve up his own son at a feast with the gods. He was punished by Zeus to forever go thirsty and hungry in Hades. His terrible punishment was set as a warning for humanity not to cross the line between mortals and gods.
Tony is horrified but Elmwood is implacable. Troubles are piling up at Tony’s door but these are as nothing when personal issues come to the fore and leave him devastated. So Janie Harrison takes point on the terrible spate of drug deaths that have begun in the capital. A devilish drug is circulating in Edinburgh and it is killing people in a terrible way. On the streets it’s called Demon Breath and its impact is devastating.
It’s a powerful concoction of death and destruction and Tony is understandably creaking under the pressure. His team have to work out how these bodies are related and where the devil drug is coming from if more deaths are to be prevented.
Something has to give and what it is shocking and unexpected. It is only the tenacity of Janie Harrison that gives the team what it needs to follow this case through to a conclusion, but not before she has to listen to Madame Rose in order to prevent another, potentially even more horrifying, death….
With darkness pervading the heart of this book, James Oswald offers up a shocking, riveting storyline that is both tension filled and deeply disturbing. There’s a sense and a force behind the evil here that feels as if it is seeping into every corner of our lives and which strangely echoes some of the worst excesses of our own political existence at the moment.
Verdict: All That Lives is an engrossing, layered and deeply chilling story with all the characters we have come to love from this series. It is shocking and heart-wrenching and its impact will reverberate for years to come. It is an absolutely unmissable book in a series that I love.
February 27, 2022
Reading Stuff 'n' Things
You would have thought that by book 12 things would be starting to get a little stale with Inspector McLean but let me reassure you that this is absolutely not the case. Let me also reassure you that this can be successfully read as a standalone although I would recommend you read previous books in the series just because they are great!
Once again, Mr Oswald writes a thoroughly riveting and engaging story that mixes the past, present and the 'strange' with ease. The plot is complex with a few strands but it all comes together in the end but not without twists, turns and some pretty 'hairy' and emotional moments along the way.
Mr Oswald creates excellent, believable and memorable characters that stay with you long after you have read the last page and I eagerly await the next.
Thank you to Headline Publishing and NetGalley for my copy in return for an honest, unbiased and unedited review.
You would have thought that by book 12 things would be starting to get a little stale with Inspector McLean but let me reassure you that this is absolutely not the case. Let me also reassure you that this can be successfully read as a standalone although I would recommend you read previous books in the series just because they are great!
Once again, Mr Oswald writes a thoroughly riveting and engaging story that mixes the past, present and the 'strange' with ease. The plot is complex with a few strands but it all comes together in the end but not without twists, turns and some pretty 'hairy' and emotional moments along the way.
Mr Oswald creates excellent, believable and memorable characters that stay with you long after you have read the last page and I eagerly await the next.
Thank you to Headline Publishing and NetGalley for my copy in return for an honest, unbiased and unedited review.
February 21, 2022
My thanks to Headline Wildfire for an eARC via NetGalley of ‘All That Lives’ by James Oswald in exchange for an honest review.
I was delighted to be invited to take part in the blog tour for this title.
‘All That Lives’ is Book 12 in Oswald’s highly acclaimed Inspector Tony McLean series of police procedurals set in Edinburgh. I complemented my reading with its unabridged audiobook edition, narrated by Ian Hanmore, for an immersive experience.
I have been a long-standing fan of this series and appreciate the way in which Oswald subtly integrates aspects of the supernatural into the narrative.
This proved a dark, complex tale with a number of investigations and subplots that eventually link-up. So, a few details….
When the battered body of a young man is discovered in a derelict lumber yard, it is assumed to be a murder but then evidence is found to link the death with a dangerous new street drug creatively named Demon Breath or Zombo. Yet he is just the first casualty as it appears that a sinister new player has entered the picture.
Add to this is the discovery during an archeological dig of a body dated from seven hundred years ago. While definitely a cold case there are indications that this may have been a sacrificial death. Then a more recent body is unearthed in similar circumstances.
Meanwhile, there are budget cuts effecting Police Scotland and McLean receives the unwelcome news that Jane Louise Dee of Saifre Industries is extending her nefarious influence into the City’s social services. While she is lauded in society as a saintly philanthropist, McLean has good reason to believe that she’s more akin to the Devil incarnate.
Certainly there was a lot going on though Oswald brought the various threads together in the kind of gripping conclusion that had me on the edge of my seat.
Aside from a number of familiar faces, including the enigmatic Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob, it was great to see DS Janie Harrison coming into her own. In addition, Tony is now clearly under the paw of two delightful cats.
While the McLean novels work fine as stand-alones, it is such a wonderful series that I would recommend it to any crime fiction aficionados who enjoy a touch of the Gothic with their police investigations. In addition, reading the series in order allows for a deeper appreciation of its themes and the characters’ individual journeys.
While ‘All That Lives’ has a melancholic ambiance, it will be interesting to see where James Oswald takes the series next. I know that wherever the journey leads, I shall be there.
Highly recommended novel and series.
I was delighted to be invited to take part in the blog tour for this title.
‘All That Lives’ is Book 12 in Oswald’s highly acclaimed Inspector Tony McLean series of police procedurals set in Edinburgh. I complemented my reading with its unabridged audiobook edition, narrated by Ian Hanmore, for an immersive experience.
I have been a long-standing fan of this series and appreciate the way in which Oswald subtly integrates aspects of the supernatural into the narrative.
This proved a dark, complex tale with a number of investigations and subplots that eventually link-up. So, a few details….
When the battered body of a young man is discovered in a derelict lumber yard, it is assumed to be a murder but then evidence is found to link the death with a dangerous new street drug creatively named Demon Breath or Zombo. Yet he is just the first casualty as it appears that a sinister new player has entered the picture.
Add to this is the discovery during an archeological dig of a body dated from seven hundred years ago. While definitely a cold case there are indications that this may have been a sacrificial death. Then a more recent body is unearthed in similar circumstances.
Meanwhile, there are budget cuts effecting Police Scotland and McLean receives the unwelcome news that Jane Louise Dee of Saifre Industries is extending her nefarious influence into the City’s social services. While she is lauded in society as a saintly philanthropist, McLean has good reason to believe that she’s more akin to the Devil incarnate.
Certainly there was a lot going on though Oswald brought the various threads together in the kind of gripping conclusion that had me on the edge of my seat.
Aside from a number of familiar faces, including the enigmatic Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob, it was great to see DS Janie Harrison coming into her own. In addition, Tony is now clearly under the paw of two delightful cats.
While the McLean novels work fine as stand-alones, it is such a wonderful series that I would recommend it to any crime fiction aficionados who enjoy a touch of the Gothic with their police investigations. In addition, reading the series in order allows for a deeper appreciation of its themes and the characters’ individual journeys.
While ‘All That Lives’ has a melancholic ambiance, it will be interesting to see where James Oswald takes the series next. I know that wherever the journey leads, I shall be there.
Highly recommended novel and series.
February 23, 2022
In Edinburgh DI Tony McLean has his hands well and truly full. There have now been three shocking and disturbing deaths, all seemingly from this new drug called Demon’s Breath or Zombo, one that no one appears to be selling. Those that have made enquiries about it have met sticky ends and the people taking it suffer horrific self-inflicted injuries from convulsions before they die. But how are the victims getting hold of it? The drug, a vapour which is inhaled, brings back nasty memories of former Sergeant Needham’s crimes years ago. Professor Hattie Turner from the forensic archaeology department at the university where Emma (McLean’s girlfriend) is working is looking at a set of seven-hundred-year-old female bones found buried in an old undiscovered graveyard. Strangely (or maybe not so in her case as she always seems to be ahead of McLean) Madame Rose knows the woman’s name. Another set of bones with definite similarities to the first is unearthed at the building site of a new housing estate but these are much younger and pose more of a question to the cold case unit and McLean. Like how and why she got there from a hospice? Oh, and Chief Supt Elmwood is back part time after receiving what seems like miraculous treatment from Jane Louise Dee (formerly the evil Mrs Saifre, McLean’s nemesis and all too well known to the detectives) for the injuries she received when someone tried to burn her as a witch. The Dee Foundation seems to be everywhere McLean turns at the moment and it makes him feel uneasy. And then the cases all get far more complicated and sinister. So can McLean and his excellent loyal team of dedicated detectives get this awful poison off the streets before it kills more people and solve the mystery of the buried bones, all whilst dealing with heartache close to home and having the shadow of Mrs Saifre looming over him?
I love the appearance of all the recurring characters such as Grumpy Bob and Madame Rose who give this series a terrific continuity and add much colour to the story. There is a lot of history between many of the people involved in McLean’s personal and professional life. While it’s always better to read in order and I’d recommend every single book in this brilliant series of stories, most of what’s necessary to know about is well explained so that the reader can definitely enjoy this as a stand-alone. Beautifully written with intricate plot lines and a wealth of well-defined fascinating characters, this is a perfect addition to a series which is both hard hitting and also sometimes carries that mystic element of things that cannot quite be explained rationally. Completely and utterly recommended!! 5*
I love the appearance of all the recurring characters such as Grumpy Bob and Madame Rose who give this series a terrific continuity and add much colour to the story. There is a lot of history between many of the people involved in McLean’s personal and professional life. While it’s always better to read in order and I’d recommend every single book in this brilliant series of stories, most of what’s necessary to know about is well explained so that the reader can definitely enjoy this as a stand-alone. Beautifully written with intricate plot lines and a wealth of well-defined fascinating characters, this is a perfect addition to a series which is both hard hitting and also sometimes carries that mystic element of things that cannot quite be explained rationally. Completely and utterly recommended!! 5*
February 20, 2022
All That Lives was a phenomenal read. I have to admit that although this is the 12th book in the Inspector McLean series I have only read a couple of them. That said I found them easy to read as a standalone tale.
Inspector Mclean is a complex character, he has health issues, department budget cuts and he and his staff have an overwhelming caseload.
Set in Edinburgh, bones are found during a new housing development. when another body is found and it is discovered that they were buried 700 years apart, this book starts to get very dramatic very quickly,
I loved the pacy thrill of this read, it is very easy to lose your sense of time, I sat for most of the day reading.
All That Lives has a little of everything, it is dark, chilling and at times disturbing, I always enjoy a book that has an ‘edge’ and with the variety of characters, the plot and a gothic flair, this book is one I would highly recommend.
Inspector Mclean is a complex character, he has health issues, department budget cuts and he and his staff have an overwhelming caseload.
Set in Edinburgh, bones are found during a new housing development. when another body is found and it is discovered that they were buried 700 years apart, this book starts to get very dramatic very quickly,
I loved the pacy thrill of this read, it is very easy to lose your sense of time, I sat for most of the day reading.
All That Lives has a little of everything, it is dark, chilling and at times disturbing, I always enjoy a book that has an ‘edge’ and with the variety of characters, the plot and a gothic flair, this book is one I would highly recommend.
February 20, 2022
I love the blend of crime and the supernatural in the DI Mc Lean series and I think this has to be the best so far! Set in Edinburgh, it's dark, compelling and absolutely fascinating to see the story unfold. This is a multi layered read with an intricate and complex plot and excellent characterisation. I love the way Janie is developing and stepping up, especially when Mc Lean goes missing. The body count rises, with all victims seemingly connected to the charitable Dee Foundation and Jane Louise Saifre, an old adversary. It's an excellent 5*read in one of the best crime series around, written by an author at the top of his game. I highly recommend the whole series to lovers of the genre. Thanks to the publisher and Net Galley for my ARC.
February 18, 2022
As always James Oswald's novel is dark, disturbing and compelling. His books are so much more than police procedurals. He writes with such an assured, distinctive voice. His characters demand empathy. His plots have shocks and surprises and a touch of the Grand Guignol. I greatly enjoyed the growing tension as the plot unfolded and darkness descended on the innocents. He makes one ready, indeed eager, to believe the unbelievable.
I think most crime fiction fans would agree that Val McDermid is the queen of Scottish crime writing and now we should surely acknowledge that James Oswald is the king.
I think most crime fiction fans would agree that Val McDermid is the queen of Scottish crime writing and now we should surely acknowledge that James Oswald is the king.
February 15, 2022
My Rating ~ 4.5*
All That Lives by James Oswald will be published February 17th with Wildfire and is the twelfth book in the Inspector McLean series, one that receives great accolades with the Daily Express stating that ‘Oswald’s writing is in a class above most’. I have read a few books by James Oswald and I always know that when I pick one up I am guaranteed a great experience so I had high hopes for this one and I was not disappointed.
All That Lives mixes crime fiction with a healthy dose of the gothic, as is expected in a James Oswald novel. Edinburgh is under siege as a new deathly drug appears on the scene leaving a trail of dead bodies in its wake but these are not the only bodies surfacing. During a local architectural dig, bones are uncovered. With initial dating suggesting over 700 years old, this is well outside the remit of McLean and his team but he is intrigued.
‘He saw that the subject of their study was lying on its side, knees bent and arms half drawn up to where its chest would have been. He was no expert, but that didn’t look like any Christian burial. A quick glance at the kirk confirmed that the orientation of the grave was all wrong too.’
On a new housing development, bones are uncovered, buried deep in the earth but, this time, it is suspected that they are more recent, probably from within the last thirty years. In its own right it would be an investigation that would have to be followed through with as it’s less than seventy years old but not one that would usually fall under McLean’s remit. He is already caught up in a spate of drug-related deaths and his hands are full. Under pressure, stressed to the max and working for a superior that he clearly has issues with, McLean is feeling the strain of his job. But when another body is discovered, the investigation escalates, with McLean and his team flat out to get to the bottom of these very sinister discoveries. What links these eerie discoveries? How can a 700 year old skeleton be connected to all this? And where does the drug angle fit in?
‘He can’t get the image out of his head. The shock and the fear in that young man’s eyes as he lay at the bottom of the pit. Why did he not fight? Why did he not climb out? And why did they all do exactly as they were told? Like zombies, like good little drones. They picked up the spades and shovelled the earth even as the young man begged for them to stop.’ – Pg1, Chapter 1
McLean always looks beyond the norm and asks questions about the darker side, the supernatural. He has a certain level of respect for the occult that has developed over the years with many investigations he gets entangled in leading him down some very obscure paths. His nemesis is always there in the background, a very powerful business woman, who has her gaze turned on everyone but who’s like Teflon, in that nothing ever sticks to her. McLean does not like her but greater powers decree that he has to acknowledge her, something that really sticks in his craw.
McLean faces some very personal challenges this time around that could be the breaking of him leaving his team very concerned for his wellbeing. He is juggling way too many balls and his focus is slipping. He has a good trustworthy team that he can rely on but there is pressure mounting from the top and McLean soon finds himself in serious danger.
All That Lives is a chilling and very ominous tale of powerful individuals with bad intentions. With little regard to life, these people very much believe in the end justifying the means at any cost, using and disposing of human life at will. McLean is a brilliantly drawn main protagonist with his life spiralling somewhat out of control. He can see the deck slowly collapsing around him but even he can’t stop its trajectory.
This is a complex read, with layer upon layer expertly integrated into an engrossing and disturbing tale. James Oswald yet again nails it as he takes his reader on a threatening and twisty journey full of nasty characters and things that do go bump in the night.
All That Lives is a superb and spellbinding read packed with nefarious goings on, odious individuals and some really shocking scenes, mixed in with some very personal and heartrending events.
Exciting. Thrilling. Macabre.
All That Lives by James Oswald will be published February 17th with Wildfire and is the twelfth book in the Inspector McLean series, one that receives great accolades with the Daily Express stating that ‘Oswald’s writing is in a class above most’. I have read a few books by James Oswald and I always know that when I pick one up I am guaranteed a great experience so I had high hopes for this one and I was not disappointed.
All That Lives mixes crime fiction with a healthy dose of the gothic, as is expected in a James Oswald novel. Edinburgh is under siege as a new deathly drug appears on the scene leaving a trail of dead bodies in its wake but these are not the only bodies surfacing. During a local architectural dig, bones are uncovered. With initial dating suggesting over 700 years old, this is well outside the remit of McLean and his team but he is intrigued.
‘He saw that the subject of their study was lying on its side, knees bent and arms half drawn up to where its chest would have been. He was no expert, but that didn’t look like any Christian burial. A quick glance at the kirk confirmed that the orientation of the grave was all wrong too.’
On a new housing development, bones are uncovered, buried deep in the earth but, this time, it is suspected that they are more recent, probably from within the last thirty years. In its own right it would be an investigation that would have to be followed through with as it’s less than seventy years old but not one that would usually fall under McLean’s remit. He is already caught up in a spate of drug-related deaths and his hands are full. Under pressure, stressed to the max and working for a superior that he clearly has issues with, McLean is feeling the strain of his job. But when another body is discovered, the investigation escalates, with McLean and his team flat out to get to the bottom of these very sinister discoveries. What links these eerie discoveries? How can a 700 year old skeleton be connected to all this? And where does the drug angle fit in?
‘He can’t get the image out of his head. The shock and the fear in that young man’s eyes as he lay at the bottom of the pit. Why did he not fight? Why did he not climb out? And why did they all do exactly as they were told? Like zombies, like good little drones. They picked up the spades and shovelled the earth even as the young man begged for them to stop.’ – Pg1, Chapter 1
McLean always looks beyond the norm and asks questions about the darker side, the supernatural. He has a certain level of respect for the occult that has developed over the years with many investigations he gets entangled in leading him down some very obscure paths. His nemesis is always there in the background, a very powerful business woman, who has her gaze turned on everyone but who’s like Teflon, in that nothing ever sticks to her. McLean does not like her but greater powers decree that he has to acknowledge her, something that really sticks in his craw.
McLean faces some very personal challenges this time around that could be the breaking of him leaving his team very concerned for his wellbeing. He is juggling way too many balls and his focus is slipping. He has a good trustworthy team that he can rely on but there is pressure mounting from the top and McLean soon finds himself in serious danger.
All That Lives is a chilling and very ominous tale of powerful individuals with bad intentions. With little regard to life, these people very much believe in the end justifying the means at any cost, using and disposing of human life at will. McLean is a brilliantly drawn main protagonist with his life spiralling somewhat out of control. He can see the deck slowly collapsing around him but even he can’t stop its trajectory.
This is a complex read, with layer upon layer expertly integrated into an engrossing and disturbing tale. James Oswald yet again nails it as he takes his reader on a threatening and twisty journey full of nasty characters and things that do go bump in the night.
All That Lives is a superb and spellbinding read packed with nefarious goings on, odious individuals and some really shocking scenes, mixed in with some very personal and heartrending events.
Exciting. Thrilling. Macabre.
August 4, 2022
A decent crime thriller with supernatural themes. It starts out really well, but gets a bit fudged towards the end.
The main story is based around a series of drug-related deaths in modern day Edinburgh. A mysterious new drug called Demon Breath has appeared on the scene. People who overdose on it seem to die in a very horrible way. No-one seems to know where it’s come from, and who’s behind the supply.
Police investigation by DI Tony McLean and DS Janie Harrison soon leads to a link with the Dee Foundation, an organisation funded by the mysterious Jane-Louise Dee. Fans of this series will know her as the antagonist in some of the previous books. She’s a tech billionaire with loads of political influence and hinted at demonic associations.
Running alongside this story, a series of archaeological finds uncover the bones of long-dead women who all seem to have been buried in a similar way. Even though their deaths were years, even centuries apart. This is a more supernatural driven part of the story as we slowly work out why these women were buried that way.
It’s an intriguing and interesting set-up, and it works well until we start to get towards the end.
As the story starts to try to pull together the different plot points, Tony suddenly vanishes. We mostly follow Janie’s attempts (with help from recurring characters Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob) to find out what’s happened to him. We get a series of events which tells us what happens. But you’re left at the end with many why questions. This might add to the mystery, but it feels like several plot lines are left open or not well explained. The last chapter in particular feels very odd and unsatisfying.
Plus some of these story elements feel very similar to events in previous books. DI Tony is put in yet another perilous situation, but manages to survive for future books. It’s clear Jane Louise Dee is a threat, but never actually being explained what her purpose is. And the people who do get “caught” for the crimes in the end seem unlikely criminal types. It’s never properly shown why they did the things they did.
Plus, we’ve also got his partner Emma spending most of the book in a coma as she has a stroke early on. It feels like this should relate to the events of the main story (especially the supernatural ones), but unless I missed it, it doesn’t. This keeps her out of the story which also happened in previous books where her character is sent travelling or on an archaeological dig. It also means there’s a lot of trips to the hospital for DI Tony where to be honest, not much happens.
The writing also feels a bit rough around the edges at times. Like it could have done with another sharp round of editing. It’s most noticeable in some of the dialogue, especially when the police interview some of the less middle-class professional characters.
It’s a hard to make slang and local dialect sound right. At times here, it just feels off. Like what a middle class well off author thinks “common people” talk like rather than how they actually talk. (there’s another famous Edinburgh based crime writer who’s guilty of this too).
Plus, there’s a lot of using people’s names in dialogue so you know who’s talking to who. Done occasionally to orient the reader is fine. But here it’s used so much, it sounds awkward and clunky. In real life, it’s obvious who you’re talking to so you don’t use their name.
Overall, it’s a decent enough read, that feels like it might have been rushed out to meet a publishing deadline. A bit more polish and it could have been a belter. But those rough edges put it into being a middling read overall.
The main story is based around a series of drug-related deaths in modern day Edinburgh. A mysterious new drug called Demon Breath has appeared on the scene. People who overdose on it seem to die in a very horrible way. No-one seems to know where it’s come from, and who’s behind the supply.
Police investigation by DI Tony McLean and DS Janie Harrison soon leads to a link with the Dee Foundation, an organisation funded by the mysterious Jane-Louise Dee. Fans of this series will know her as the antagonist in some of the previous books. She’s a tech billionaire with loads of political influence and hinted at demonic associations.
Running alongside this story, a series of archaeological finds uncover the bones of long-dead women who all seem to have been buried in a similar way. Even though their deaths were years, even centuries apart. This is a more supernatural driven part of the story as we slowly work out why these women were buried that way.
It’s an intriguing and interesting set-up, and it works well until we start to get towards the end.
As the story starts to try to pull together the different plot points, Tony suddenly vanishes. We mostly follow Janie’s attempts (with help from recurring characters Madame Rose and Grumpy Bob) to find out what’s happened to him. We get a series of events which tells us what happens. But you’re left at the end with many why questions. This might add to the mystery, but it feels like several plot lines are left open or not well explained. The last chapter in particular feels very odd and unsatisfying.
Plus some of these story elements feel very similar to events in previous books. DI Tony is put in yet another perilous situation, but manages to survive for future books. It’s clear Jane Louise Dee is a threat, but never actually being explained what her purpose is. And the people who do get “caught” for the crimes in the end seem unlikely criminal types. It’s never properly shown why they did the things they did.
Plus, we’ve also got his partner Emma spending most of the book in a coma as she has a stroke early on. It feels like this should relate to the events of the main story (especially the supernatural ones), but unless I missed it, it doesn’t. This keeps her out of the story which also happened in previous books where her character is sent travelling or on an archaeological dig. It also means there’s a lot of trips to the hospital for DI Tony where to be honest, not much happens.
The writing also feels a bit rough around the edges at times. Like it could have done with another sharp round of editing. It’s most noticeable in some of the dialogue, especially when the police interview some of the less middle-class professional characters.
It’s a hard to make slang and local dialect sound right. At times here, it just feels off. Like what a middle class well off author thinks “common people” talk like rather than how they actually talk. (there’s another famous Edinburgh based crime writer who’s guilty of this too).
Plus, there’s a lot of using people’s names in dialogue so you know who’s talking to who. Done occasionally to orient the reader is fine. But here it’s used so much, it sounds awkward and clunky. In real life, it’s obvious who you’re talking to so you don’t use their name.
Overall, it’s a decent enough read, that feels like it might have been rushed out to meet a publishing deadline. A bit more polish and it could have been a belter. But those rough edges put it into being a middling read overall.
February 20, 2022
‘All That Lives’ is the twelfth book in the bestselling series featuring Detective Inspector Tony McLean. Now I have a little confession to make- although I own all of the books in the series I haven’t read them all yet. Stupid me. Having enjoyed reading ‘All That Lives’ as much as I did and having rediscovered how brilliant the McLean series is, I can guarantee that those unread books in the series will not be unread for long. I thoroughly enjoyed reading ‘All That Lives’ but more about that in a bit.
I was drawn into this story from the synopsis alone. I made the fatal mistake of starting to read the book shortly before I went to bed. Let’s just say that bedtime was delayed somewhat and that I had a ‘lack of sleep’ hangover the following morning but it was so worth it. This was one of those stories that stayed with me irrespective of whether or not I had the book itself in my hand or not – if I had to put the book down for any reason then I would immediately look forward to being able to pick the book up again, if I wasn’t reading the book then I was thinking about it. You get the picture. I would start reading the book only intending to read a chapter or two but I would become that wrapped up in the story and in the investigation that I would still be sat there reading over an hour or so and many chapters later. I found ‘All That Lives’ to be a gripping, tense and dramatic read, which certainly kept me guessing and kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.
‘All That Lives’ is brilliantly written but then I have come to expect nothing less from James Oswald. He certainly knows how to grab the reader’s attention and draw the into what proves to be one hell of a read and then some. For me, the story hit the ground running and maintained a fairly fast pace throughout. To say that it was an intense and dramatic story is a tad of an understatement. Whilst reading ‘All That Lives’ I felt like I was on an at times scary and unpredictable rollercoaster ride with several twists and turns along the way. I love the way in which the author makes the reader feel as though they are part of the story and at the heart of the action. That’s how I felt at any rate.
In short, I thoroughly enjoyed reading ‘All That Lives’ and I would recommend the book to other readers. I will certainly be reading more from this author in the future. The score on the Ginger Book Geek board is a very well deserved 5* out of 5*.
I was drawn into this story from the synopsis alone. I made the fatal mistake of starting to read the book shortly before I went to bed. Let’s just say that bedtime was delayed somewhat and that I had a ‘lack of sleep’ hangover the following morning but it was so worth it. This was one of those stories that stayed with me irrespective of whether or not I had the book itself in my hand or not – if I had to put the book down for any reason then I would immediately look forward to being able to pick the book up again, if I wasn’t reading the book then I was thinking about it. You get the picture. I would start reading the book only intending to read a chapter or two but I would become that wrapped up in the story and in the investigation that I would still be sat there reading over an hour or so and many chapters later. I found ‘All That Lives’ to be a gripping, tense and dramatic read, which certainly kept me guessing and kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.
‘All That Lives’ is brilliantly written but then I have come to expect nothing less from James Oswald. He certainly knows how to grab the reader’s attention and draw the into what proves to be one hell of a read and then some. For me, the story hit the ground running and maintained a fairly fast pace throughout. To say that it was an intense and dramatic story is a tad of an understatement. Whilst reading ‘All That Lives’ I felt like I was on an at times scary and unpredictable rollercoaster ride with several twists and turns along the way. I love the way in which the author makes the reader feel as though they are part of the story and at the heart of the action. That’s how I felt at any rate.
In short, I thoroughly enjoyed reading ‘All That Lives’ and I would recommend the book to other readers. I will certainly be reading more from this author in the future. The score on the Ginger Book Geek board is a very well deserved 5* out of 5*.
May 15, 2025
This is another in the series of Inspector Tony McLean novels set in Edinburgh. Back in his Inspector's seat, having briefly become a Chief Inspector, he becomes involved when old bones are dug up and bodies start to appear, having succumbed to a "new" drug. Soon, an old nemesis appears, and the inspector begins to worry when his partner Emma is taken ill. What is going on? Some interesting characters, Detective Sergeant Harrison has taken over from Grumpy Bob, who is relegated to the basement. The station commander, Chief Superintendent Elmwood, makes a return from injury and is bent on making his life difficult.
A good mix of the realistic and the supernatural makes a good read. Following the series helps with the back story, although there are sufficient catch ups within the story to bring readers up to speed. Well worth a 4 star rating.
A good mix of the realistic and the supernatural makes a good read. Following the series helps with the back story, although there are sufficient catch ups within the story to bring readers up to speed. Well worth a 4 star rating.
September 14, 2024
When I picked up Natural Causes, (the first book in the DI Tony McLean series), in November 2023, I remember thinking that it would take me a long time to catch up with author. 🙄 Fast forward to September 2024, book 13 was released earlier this year, and I am about to review book 12. 😊
And so to All That Lives. What can I say about this book that I haven't said about its predecessors? Well, it took years off me, for starters. I don't think my nerves can take much more. Mrs. Saifre was back, you see, and that's never a good thing.
The dark forces seemed a shade darker in this book, and the tension and suspense were cranked up to the max. All of my favourite characters were there; Grumpy Bob, Madame Rose and Jo Dalgliesh. The latter may not be to everyone's taste, but I like her.
I loved this book, I love this series, and I can't wait to see what Mr. Oswald has in store for poor old Tony next. 🖤
And so to All That Lives. What can I say about this book that I haven't said about its predecessors? Well, it took years off me, for starters. I don't think my nerves can take much more. Mrs. Saifre was back, you see, and that's never a good thing.
The dark forces seemed a shade darker in this book, and the tension and suspense were cranked up to the max. All of my favourite characters were there; Grumpy Bob, Madame Rose and Jo Dalgliesh. The latter may not be to everyone's taste, but I like her.
I loved this book, I love this series, and I can't wait to see what Mr. Oswald has in store for poor old Tony next. 🖤
February 27, 2022
#12 in the interesting DI McLean series of police+paranormal novels.
I savored this novel by reading parts over three days, rather than reading the entire book right away as I've done with previous books in this series.
I feel like "All That Lives" is a bit different, as there are many scenes w/o DI McLean -- instead featuring a different detective. That's fine, just noting the narrative felt less McLean-centric than other books in the series (tho he is the main character), especially w/ Mrs. McCutchen's cat not showing up until close to 100 pages in.
This is a good tale, nice wrap-up, and I love the way the McLeans history is exposed. Foundational, mystical stuff!
Recommend this book, and the entire McLean series.
I savored this novel by reading parts over three days, rather than reading the entire book right away as I've done with previous books in this series.
I feel like "All That Lives" is a bit different, as there are many scenes w/o DI McLean -- instead featuring a different detective. That's fine, just noting the narrative felt less McLean-centric than other books in the series (tho he is the main character), especially w/ Mrs. McCutchen's cat not showing up until close to 100 pages in.
This is a good tale, nice wrap-up, and I love the way the McLeans history is exposed. Foundational, mystical stuff!
Recommend this book, and the entire McLean series.
February 19, 2022
An archaeological dig at the old South Leith parish kirkyard has turned up a mysterious body dating from around seven hundred years ago. Then a second body is unearthed on a building site. This victim went missing only thirty years ago - but the similarities between her death and the ancient woman's suggest something even more disturbing. Drawn into the investigation, Inspector McLean finds himself torn between a worrying trend of violent drug-related deaths and uncovering what truly connects these bodies. When a third body is discovered, and too close for comfort, he begins to suspect dark purpose at play - and that whoever put them there is far from finished.
This is the twelfth book in this brilliant series & once again I was drawn in from page one & found it very hard to put down until it was finished. Tony McLean is once again pulled in multiple directions, the workload is getting heavier, his old boss is back as is Mrs Saifre, his personal life is in upheaval, no one is talking about a new drug that’s killing people & then there’s the old bones. The characters are very well portrayed & have lovely depth, old favourites return & Janie Harrison is coming into her own. Not a light read & for most of the book I was wondering how on earth things were connected but gradually things came together & the climax of the book was tense, nail biting, edge of the seat & almost disastrous. A very well written, engrossing read, which I highly recommend
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
This is the twelfth book in this brilliant series & once again I was drawn in from page one & found it very hard to put down until it was finished. Tony McLean is once again pulled in multiple directions, the workload is getting heavier, his old boss is back as is Mrs Saifre, his personal life is in upheaval, no one is talking about a new drug that’s killing people & then there’s the old bones. The characters are very well portrayed & have lovely depth, old favourites return & Janie Harrison is coming into her own. Not a light read & for most of the book I was wondering how on earth things were connected but gradually things came together & the climax of the book was tense, nail biting, edge of the seat & almost disastrous. A very well written, engrossing read, which I highly recommend
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews