Situationship by Marina Adair is the story of two adult sisters who were separated as children in a misguided divorce decree. The sisters, Teagan and Harley, barely know each other now. They wouldn’t, in fact, even be together except that Harley is squatting in Teagan’s beach house when Teagan and her daughters arrive unexpectedly. The sisters are antagonistic but to move the story along, they continue to live together in the beach house. Oh, and maybe they’ll find love in the process. I mean, it’s a romance novel so of course they’re looking for love.
Teagan supposedly has everything working, all the time, and is highly critical of her less predictable sister. Harley, on the other hand, supposedly never does anything right; but despite what we’re told, the character arcs are completely reversed. Harley teaches early yoga classes, works with local businesses, helps Teagan with her kids and her business while Teagan can’t seem to brush her hair or manage her children. I’m just not getting how their character arcs are such a mismatch with their behaviors.
Overall, I have come to the conclusion that this book was not for me. The repartee between the older sister, Teagan, and her love interest, Colin, is mostly frustrating, frequently cringy. However, I suspect that some people might find their conversations believable. I just don’t know that many people – actually any – who talk in metaphors as much as these characters do.
In addition, there are things I would characterize as story development problems. For example, Harley, the younger sister, does a bunch of very secretive work to help her sister. Why is it a secret? It’s legal. It’s useful. Why doesn’t she share her plans? We don’t really get any explanation. This leads me to believe that the author needed Harley to be secretive in order to move the story forward.
Another example of anomalous story development is the author’s use of Colin’s daughter, Maddie. For a troubled, lying teen, she’s given really important responsibilities, like watching very young children. There’s also an awkward scene when Maddie catches her father and Teagan … er, in the act. Maybe the author doesn’t have any children. I can promise you, if any one of my three kids caught me having sex, they would not react by staying in the room, while the adults dressed under the covers. That’s just absurd.
Teagan and Colin were high school sweethearts who separated before college (to move the story forward). Supposedly, Teagan was being a bigger person by ending their relationship without even saying goodbye but why? It isn’t clearly explained. It also doesn’t make any sense. It does allow, though, for 20 years to pass so they can meet up again and rekindle their relationship. But how can they be in love? They don’t even know each other now, right?
I received a digital ARC through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
bookbuzzblog.com