Veternarian Ally Winter is settled in her new, old home in Willow Bluff, Wisconsin. Her return to her childhood hometown was less than ideal with a murder mystery her grandfather was determined to solve and few clients for her veterninary practice. Now she has a system for getting clients and learning better how to get paid for her services. If only her old, OK current too, crush, Detective Noah Jorgenson would return her feelings and ask her out. A recent theft at a big box electronics store in town has Gramps playing detective again, much to Noah's dismay. Gramps is convinced the security camera were tampered with and the police will never solve the case without him. Then Ally, stuck boarding Domino, a poorly trained black Poodle, follows the pooch on the scent to a willow tree where Domino promptly returns a red and white polka dot high heeled shoe, last seen on the foot of Priscilla Green, the young cleaning woman for Legacy House. Unfortunately, the other shoe is still on Priscilla's foot attached to a very much dead body. Noah on the case and so is Gramps! When Priscilla's mother, city executive Hilda Green, accuses Ally of murdering her daughter and what's worse, Noah seems to believe the accusation, Ally sees red and is determined to help Gramps solve this case and clear her name. Then the clinic is robbed and Legacy House is broken into. Are the events connected to the robbery or the murder? Both? Coincidence? Ally is convinced Domino can help find the answers but is he really cut out for police work or just poorly trained?
This story is light and funny. I enjoyed following the clues and red herrings but when all was revealed, none of it made sense. The motive came out of thin air and is bizarre. I don't see why the murderer had to actually murder people. It was all very strange. If you aren't into veterinary medicine, like me, you'll find some scenes too technical and graphic (TMI). I'd rather stick to Domino, Roxy and Bandit. Bandit's human reminds me of Mrs. Pumphrey in All Creatures Great and Small. I don't need the technical details about how Ally is treating animals, plus this may spread misinformation and lead to more harm than good.
The animals are pretty cute. Roxy, who doesn't have much to do because she's confined while Domino is in residence, is a sweetheart. She's energetic and needs a lot more exercise than Ally gives her. Dominic does as well. He's young and in serious need of training. I don't understand why she didn't put a halter on him. My brother's dog walks much better with the halter, otherwise she's walking ME. She's a little smaller than Domino but strong. Domino also sniffs out clues which seems ridiculous but I like it. He's not a trained police dog so perhaps he's just behaving badly and not actually sniffing clues. If he is, it doesn't make sense in every scene. Bandit is a sweet little LabraDane puppy in need of a home. He may be big but he's adorable and can easily be trained. Cat lovers note that the few cats in the story don't get the same treatment. One cat is badly behaved and the other one is better but in both cases, the humans treat their furbabies like human babies.
Ally is a good dog mom for the most part. She works hard with Domino and tries to minimize the amount of time the dogs are crated even though they destroy her waiting room. However, a vet should understand dog body language and see that the nipping and pulling is playful puppy behavior, not fighting. Some good training for BOTH dogs would make Ally's life easier. Perhaps one or both was taken away from their mother too soon and never learned manners.
The human characters are less appealing than the animals. Ally isn't bad but she doesn't have a strong personality. She's not bold enough or brave enough to go after what she needs or wants. Ally gives in to her grandfather, enabling him. She loves him dearly and doesn't want to see him hurt. She makes suggestions but he doesn't listen. Ally whines to her friend Erica about her love life but doesn't actually try to talk to Noah about his intentions. Erica, thankfully, posesses inside information. Gramps annoys the heck out of me. Obsessed with true crime, Oscar thinks he's better than the police. He's an elderly man (at 78) and doesn't have the stamina to take an active involvement in a murder investigation. He still thinks he can solve it before the police do though. I do think there's some merit to his crack brained theories though and I suspect he's right on the nose with his early guess. I also suspect Noah is thinking along the same lines. Oscar is so infernally stubborn! He resists doing the right thing, like physical therapy, yet wants to be doing things like helping Ally in the practice or solving crimes, and he just won't admit he shouldn't. He won't back down from going and doing what he wants in pursuit of answers. The information Oscar obtains won't hold up in court. He turns on the charm and gossips with the ladies in town. That's all he knows-heresay and gossip. It's lucky that some of it might turn out to be right.
The Willow Bluff Widows are starting to take shape in my mind. Harriet is the bossy matronly type. She loves to cook and take care of people. She's a bit bossy with her sister but she does seem to love her sister and means well. Tillie is a sweetheart for the most part but even she has her moments where she snaps and when she does, it's at Priscilla! Uh oh! I know Tillie would never hurt anyone even if she was unhappy with Priscilla's cleaning. Lydia is the quiet, thoughtful one. Ally's thoughts about Lydia's knitting were riude and unkind. I'm glad she didn't hurt the widow by voicing them outloud.
Priscilla Green was an angsty young woman. She wanted to be free from her mother's rules and restrictions- to go where she wanted, do what she wanted, be with who she wanted. Hilda is a tough mother. She kicked her own daughter out of the house for not following her rules. Priscilla is an adult and shouldn't be forced to follow childish rules. It's clearly made her act out and behave like a rebellious teen, even though she's in her early 20s. There's nothing wrong with her style choices. It's her life, her body, her choice and all the criticism of her style is uncalled for. Her colorful clothes, piercings and high heels aren't my thing but clearly Priscilla feels she can express herself that way. Or she's thumbing her nose at her mother. Priscilla may have been prickly and rebellious but she didn't deserve to die.
Who killed Priscilla? Judging from her mother's bizarre reaction to the news, I'd say Hilda was the chief suspect. Hilda didn't like it when Priscilla left home and was no longer under her control. Hilda would prefer a model daughter who reflected her image of the perfect city executive. I HATE controlling mothers and the clues do seem to point to her. Hilda even prefers Priscilla's own best friend, Marlie, to Priscilla. Marlie is very upset at Priscilla's death and is determined to protect Hilda and stand by her. Marlie seems a bit too perfect like a mean girl/cheerleader type. She works at the electronics store with Priscilla's boyfriend Jake and seems to know him well. Of course the police find that more often than not, women are murdered by their significant others so Jake is a person of interest as well. He seems young and immature. At first I assumed he got into a fight with Priscilla and killed her but once we see him, he doesn't seem the type. He's just a kid trying to earn enough money to live independently.
Gramps suspects Darla, the waitress at the cafe of wrongdoing. He thinks she's involved with the electronics store robbery just because she's wearing long sleeves on a hot day. He's crazy! Ally says Darla is really nice and a loving cat mom. Darla may be covering up tattoos on her arms that look unprofessional. There may be a good reason for long sleeves. She isn't an excellent server but she does her job and I see no reason for suspicion. He also suspects Steve Norris, another electronics store employee, of being involved in the robbery and perhaps Priscilla's death. Another young employee, Colin, didn't seem too broken up about Priscilla's death or interested in talking to the cops and that makes Gramps suspicious. Who DOESN'T Gramps suspect? Colin, however, indicates her knew and really liked Priscilla. Which is it? Is he uncaring or did he like her enough to want to steal her away from Jake? He shares an apartment with Jake, giving Colin access to Priscilla. The final suspect is Darrel Steinbach, a visting property developer and Hilda's love interest. Could Priscilla's death have something to do with the old Thompson place and the potential development deal Steinbach is in town to make? He seems like a smooth customer, a typical businessman but he isn't in the story enough to guess whether he could or did commit murder.
The locals are a mixed bag. Some are nice, like Erica. Ally's best friend is stressed taking care of two small children and a dog all day, trying to earn extra money on the side. She doesn't get a break. Her daughter is old enough for preschool. It sounds like they could afford it. It would at least give Erica a slight break. She still has her son, who is a toddler but there would be a light at the end of the tunnel. Her husband seems like a nice guy but I totally get why she was angry with him. Typical male behavior. I wouldn't marry someone who didn't and couldn't communicate with me or help out equally with childcare and housework. Rosie at the library encourages Oscar's sleuthing. WHY? She's a librarian and provides him with true crime books but also a lot of gossip. The other women in town seem like big gossips too. The mayor, Martha Conklin, is friends with Hilda and putting pressure on Noah to solve this case NOW! I don't like that sort of elected official. She changes her tune. First she says Ally didn't have anything to do with it but then it seems like she's eager to have Ally arrested just to solve the case.
Noah is a good guy but like his friend, can't communicate. Ally should ask him what his intentions are and if he can stop being an arrogant cop when they're together. He doesn't always treat her nicely when he's working. Noah also needs to understand that it's not Ally's responsibility to keep Gramps from sticking his nose in. Legacy House is his home and it's assisted living. If Ally lived there or if Gramps lived with Ally, that would be different. Until Oscar is diagnosed with dementia or unable to care for himself, he's responsible for his own actions. Noah needs to remember that and stop harassing Ally. Can't he see it makes her dig her heels in too and she'll defend Gramps to the death? If it comes down to Noah or Gramps, she'll choose Gramps!
This isn't my favorite series but it's not bad. I'd probably read more.