A Taste Of Power
This book is a more than a memoir, it is a classic tragedy. In A Taste Of Power, Elaine Brown recounts her life and exeperiences in the Black Panther Party. From the very first chapter in which she is announcing her leadership status to the general assembly, I was intrigued. However, the first chip in the romantic picture of the Panthers also, occurs here. The next third of the book is spent discussing Elaine’s childhood. Raised in a poor neighborhoods in Philadelphia by her mother, we see the impact of poverty, her father’s absence and segregation in her life. She drops out of college and ends up in California working as a waitress at a club. After breaking up with a her famous, married boyfriend. She becomes involved with the Black Power Movement.
The second third of the book was my favorite part. The beginnings of the Black Panther Party and its goals were glorious and heady stuff. With the implementation of schools, free clinics, free bus rides to prisons and other social services, I understood how Elaine got caught up in the fever of the times. Also, I learned a lot about the Panther Party during this time. I had no idea that so many young, black men were killed by police during assaults on the Panther headquarters. The police with riot gear, tear gas, harassing and beating protestors, with people being hauled off to jail for trumped up charges, reminded me of Ferguson today. Unfortunately, you also start to see the chasms developing within the group. The demise starts subtle, with patriarchy and sexism. Next, problems of infighting and distrust. When violence or ‘discipline’ was added, I knew I was reading about an implosion.
The last third of the book was spent reading about the downward spiral of the party. Drugs, violence within and without, infiltration and cointelpro, sexism, patriarchy, it was all too much. The end was inevitable. Still, I’m glad this book exists. It is a lesson to the next generation on ‘What Not to do’. I’ve been told there was a lot of push back from former Panthers questioning the veracity of Elaine’s version of events. Well, like the cliche goes “There’s her side, his side and the Truth”. I don’t know if Elaine’s version of the Black Panther Party is completely accurate, but I think the overall picture and general feeling is probably true. She paints an unflattering picture of the Panthers but she includes herself and shares a lot of her personal life, personal choices and flaws. I kept wondering about her daughter and who was caring for this child? Was the father ever involved? There are parts where the tone is a bit self serving, or perhaps naive, which is another reason I did not rate this book a ‘5’.
In the end, I wanted a little more than the “flying into the sunset’ ending. An “Afterward” would have been perfect. Just two or three paragraphs on what happened after the end. Answering the questions: Did she ever hear from anyone in the group? How was her relationship with daughter affected? and What is she doing now?