What do you think?
Rate this book
Alice in Kyoto Forest #1
Alice in Kyoto Forest, Volume 1
Orphaned at a young age, Alice has lived with her aunt for most of her childhood. But her uncle is abusive and resentful, and at fifteen years old, Alice decides to return home to Kyoto and train as a maiko, eventually hoping to become a geisha.
But when she arrives back to the city where she was born, she finds that Kyoto has changed quite a bit in the eight years since she left it. Almost as if it's a completely different world...
But when she arrives back to the city where she was born, she finds that Kyoto has changed quite a bit in the eight years since she left it. Almost as if it's a completely different world...
Kindle Edition
First published December 22, 2021
9 people are currently reading
303 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews
March 13, 2022
I wasn’t sure how this was going to go since the last Alice retelling/variation I read was awful. But this was soooooo super cute!!! Alice is so sweet and I wanted her story to go well once I read about her sad past. And her uncle sucks. So I was ready for some good things to happen to her.
The storyline is a bit different than our regular old Alice tales, which is probably why I love it so much! I adore Alice in Wonderland as it is, so fresh take is totally right up my alley!! We still have some of our favorite characters, like the rabbit, but there’s some additional characters added that I already adore. The frog is especially fun and sassy.
The setting is especially magical and I love that we’re in a place connected with Alice’s childhood. While it’s reminiscent of her past, the world is also very different. Basically the best of both worlds.
I highly recommend this to Alice in Wonderland lovers who are ready for a new view of a favorite tale. Thank you so much to NetGalley, Tokyopop, and Mai Mochizuki for the opportunity to read this for my honest and unbiased opinion.
The storyline is a bit different than our regular old Alice tales, which is probably why I love it so much! I adore Alice in Wonderland as it is, so fresh take is totally right up my alley!! We still have some of our favorite characters, like the rabbit, but there’s some additional characters added that I already adore. The frog is especially fun and sassy.
The setting is especially magical and I love that we’re in a place connected with Alice’s childhood. While it’s reminiscent of her past, the world is also very different. Basically the best of both worlds.
I highly recommend this to Alice in Wonderland lovers who are ready for a new view of a favorite tale. Thank you so much to NetGalley, Tokyopop, and Mai Mochizuki for the opportunity to read this for my honest and unbiased opinion.
March 23, 2023
An isekai manga where orphan Alice Shirakawa is resented by the uncle who is fostering her, so she travels to Kyoto to train to be a geisha so she can be independent of him. But in Alice in Wonderland fashion, the Kyoto in which she arrives seems to be on the other side of the looking glass, where the buildings and dress of the people are old fashioned and the animals -- like the frog and rabbit who accompany her -- can talk. And, hey, doesn't that crown prince look a lot like a boy she used to know?
It's not particularly original -- how many riffs on Alice in Wonderland do we really need? -- but it's well done and has some engaging characters. I like that the act of reading aloud plays a key part in the story and am intrigued by how the mythos being teased is going to pull together.
Apparently, this is the first half of a two-manga adaptation of the first light novel of the same name. If it ends well, I can hope the other two light novels in the series will get adaptations also.
It's not particularly original -- how many riffs on Alice in Wonderland do we really need? -- but it's well done and has some engaging characters. I like that the act of reading aloud plays a key part in the story and am intrigued by how the mythos being teased is going to pull together.
Apparently, this is the first half of a two-manga adaptation of the first light novel of the same name. If it ends well, I can hope the other two light novels in the series will get adaptations also.
January 23, 2022
Mai Mochizuki clearly loves Kyoto - this is her second series to be set there and feature the city's name in the title. And since the other one is Holmes of Kyoto: Volume 1, which I didn't love, color me pleasantly surprised that I enjoyed this so much. Very possibly that's because it takes a folkloric angle, and arguably is much more faithful to its inspirations (Lewis Carroll's Alice duology and fairy tales) than the other series is to its (Sherlock Holmes). I also really enjoyed the way it works with ideas of story and how books can help shape or soothe us. I'm very excited for the next volume.
February 6, 2022
This was a very cute story! It was different then I expected, but I really enjoyed the wholesome of this and learning a little bit more about Japanese culture.
I thought Alice to be a very sweet character and instantly felt my heart strings pulled on her behalf. She totally deserved better and want to say I hope she finds something better, but I think that still remains to-be-determined. However, one thing I really loved concerning her story is how she needs to find her true calling and that she can't lie to herself or settle for less than what her true calling is. That was such a compelling and touching message! I didn't except it to be woven in, but it resonated with me as an adult nonetheless.
And speaking of finding one's true calling, that is where my interest really went up when reading this story! I would not say I found the first half boring, but I was really tired when I started this and I didn't feel completely invested into Alice's story even if I was intrigued in the beginning. The first half presents different "things" (for a very vague non-spoiler) and situations that leaves the reader just as confused as Alice. (I would not say a bad confusion as it leads to asking questions right alongside Alice.) It felt like we are on this journey of questioning and wondering what is really going on.
While I liked the Alice tidbits and story inspiration, I really did enjoy the parts involving historic Kyoto. Outside the message I mentioned above, this was definitely my favorite part! It was very fascinating and thoroughly enjoyed the setting, fashion, and everything in between. I would be very interested seeing even more of that in the next volume!
Overall, this was a good story! I am unsure if I would purchase the next volume, but I will be seeing if my local library will get it so I can read more of Alice's story. I want to see if she will realize her true calling and if she will meet one certain character again.
I would recommend this to fans of Alice in Wonderland, those interested in a story largely centering around historic Kyoto, and a touch of whimsy!
*(I received an e-ARC from the publisher. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
I thought Alice to be a very sweet character and instantly felt my heart strings pulled on her behalf. She totally deserved better and want to say I hope she finds something better, but I think that still remains to-be-determined. However, one thing I really loved concerning her story is how she needs to find her true calling and that she can't lie to herself or settle for less than what her true calling is. That was such a compelling and touching message! I didn't except it to be woven in, but it resonated with me as an adult nonetheless.
And speaking of finding one's true calling, that is where my interest really went up when reading this story! I would not say I found the first half boring, but I was really tired when I started this and I didn't feel completely invested into Alice's story even if I was intrigued in the beginning. The first half presents different "things" (for a very vague non-spoiler) and situations that leaves the reader just as confused as Alice. (I would not say a bad confusion as it leads to asking questions right alongside Alice.) It felt like we are on this journey of questioning and wondering what is really going on.
While I liked the Alice tidbits and story inspiration, I really did enjoy the parts involving historic Kyoto. Outside the message I mentioned above, this was definitely my favorite part! It was very fascinating and thoroughly enjoyed the setting, fashion, and everything in between. I would be very interested seeing even more of that in the next volume!
Overall, this was a good story! I am unsure if I would purchase the next volume, but I will be seeing if my local library will get it so I can read more of Alice's story. I want to see if she will realize her true calling and if she will meet one certain character again.
I would recommend this to fans of Alice in Wonderland, those interested in a story largely centering around historic Kyoto, and a touch of whimsy!
*(I received an e-ARC from the publisher. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
March 9, 2022
I requested to read this book through Netgalley mainly because of its beautiful cover, but the story itself was absolutely delightful as well.
It's not exactly a retelling of Alice in Wonderland, but more likely to be inspired by the classic fairytale. Instead of entering Wonderland, our Alice here entered a sort-of-magical Kyoto Forest, where its nothing like the Kyoto that she used to be familiar with. And not only she got a white rabbit in a waistcoat as her companion, she also got a cute frog in traditional Japanese clothing.
Alice returned to Kyoto to escape the harsh treatment by her uncle, and she planned to become a maiko, an apprentice geisha. But her plan did not work when she learned that this Kyoto she fell through was not the Kyoto in the normal world, and she had to go through a journey to find the truth about this world, and how she would be able to stay in it.
I love how sweet Alice is, but she also carries a great pain in her and all I want is for her to be happy. Since this is only the first volume of the story, there are much to be uncovered, but there's also a prospect of Alice reuniting with a childhood friend from Kyoto, whom made a promise to marry her when they meet again.
It's rather obvious who they boy might be, but I'm curious and excited to know how they're going to meet again, and how their relationship can work because Alice is still an outsider at this point, and the boy has a rather high social ranking in this Kyoto Forest.
I'm definitely considering getting the paperback because the illustrations are just stunning! I'm dying to know follow Alice's next adventures too ♡
Many thanks to Netgalley and Tokyopop for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
It's not exactly a retelling of Alice in Wonderland, but more likely to be inspired by the classic fairytale. Instead of entering Wonderland, our Alice here entered a sort-of-magical Kyoto Forest, where its nothing like the Kyoto that she used to be familiar with. And not only she got a white rabbit in a waistcoat as her companion, she also got a cute frog in traditional Japanese clothing.
Alice returned to Kyoto to escape the harsh treatment by her uncle, and she planned to become a maiko, an apprentice geisha. But her plan did not work when she learned that this Kyoto she fell through was not the Kyoto in the normal world, and she had to go through a journey to find the truth about this world, and how she would be able to stay in it.
I love how sweet Alice is, but she also carries a great pain in her and all I want is for her to be happy. Since this is only the first volume of the story, there are much to be uncovered, but there's also a prospect of Alice reuniting with a childhood friend from Kyoto, whom made a promise to marry her when they meet again.
It's rather obvious who they boy might be, but I'm curious and excited to know how they're going to meet again, and how their relationship can work because Alice is still an outsider at this point, and the boy has a rather high social ranking in this Kyoto Forest.
I'm definitely considering getting the paperback because the illustrations are just stunning! I'm dying to know follow Alice's next adventures too ♡
Many thanks to Netgalley and Tokyopop for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Read
March 31, 2022Alice in Kyoto Forest is a retelling of the classic Alice in Wonderland. It’s very loosely based as far as the first volume goes, with the manga leaning more heavily towards Japanese culture, which I find interesting. The first volume gives a glimpse of what Alice went through growing up and how it gave her the courage to move forward with her life independently - but in doing so, she ended up in a world unknown to her.
The manga is beautifully illustrated, especially with its historical Japanese setting. The story is fascinating because there’s a lot of mystery in this volume that has yet to unfold. We are introduced to a different world and mysterious characters. This volume is just an introduction to Alice and her surroundings, and I’m looking forward to what happens next.
Thank you, NetGalley and Tokyopop, for the e-ARC.
The manga is beautifully illustrated, especially with its historical Japanese setting. The story is fascinating because there’s a lot of mystery in this volume that has yet to unfold. We are introduced to a different world and mysterious characters. This volume is just an introduction to Alice and her surroundings, and I’m looking forward to what happens next.
Thank you, NetGalley and Tokyopop, for the e-ARC.
March 29, 2022
Thanks to NetGalley and TOKYOPOP for providing the e-ARC in exchange of an honest review.
This story is about Alice who lived with her aunt's family after the death of her parents. As an orphan, she was treated badly by her uncle and seen as a burden. When she saw an opportunity to escape from the house, she immediately took the chance and went to Kyoto to be a maiko, an apprentice. geisha. However, the surroundings there weren't the same anymore; talking animals, human with tails and no cars. In a way, this story actually makes me think of the movie 'Spirited Away'.
I'd honestly say that this premise is really interesting! With a captivating art style, I am definitely invested in the story. As I read it, I also feel heartwarming vibe and smile a lot because the setting of the story, with peaceful air and friendly strangers. The main character, Alice, is also really adorable! She really loves reading and that is something that I can relate to. I really hope that she will find what she's looking for and be happier after this journey.
Just when I thought it will be all bubbly, suddenly Alice faces a problem due to the rules of living in that world. Not only that, she also realised that her childhood might be an important person there but she have yet to actually confirmed it. I am genuinely curious to see how this will turn out when they meet each other, and will her journey brings any luck in finding her true self or only more misfortunes.
Overall, definitely recommended to fantasy and slice of life manga lovers!
This story is about Alice who lived with her aunt's family after the death of her parents. As an orphan, she was treated badly by her uncle and seen as a burden. When she saw an opportunity to escape from the house, she immediately took the chance and went to Kyoto to be a maiko, an apprentice. geisha. However, the surroundings there weren't the same anymore; talking animals, human with tails and no cars. In a way, this story actually makes me think of the movie 'Spirited Away'.
I'd honestly say that this premise is really interesting! With a captivating art style, I am definitely invested in the story. As I read it, I also feel heartwarming vibe and smile a lot because the setting of the story, with peaceful air and friendly strangers. The main character, Alice, is also really adorable! She really loves reading and that is something that I can relate to. I really hope that she will find what she's looking for and be happier after this journey.
Just when I thought it will be all bubbly, suddenly Alice faces a problem due to the rules of living in that world. Not only that, she also realised that her childhood might be an important person there but she have yet to actually confirmed it. I am genuinely curious to see how this will turn out when they meet each other, and will her journey brings any luck in finding her true self or only more misfortunes.
Overall, definitely recommended to fantasy and slice of life manga lovers!
March 14, 2022
This book is a classic retelling of Alice in Wonderland with a twist. Main character carries the name of Alice who is an orphan living with her aunt and her abusive uncle. At the age of 15, Alice decides to return home to Kyoto and train as a maiko, eventually hoping to become a geisha.
When she arrive at Kyoto that she thought she knew, it's definitely different from where she been in her past 8 years since she left.
It's just the first volume and i'm intrigued to find out how's the story goes in the following volume.
Definitely will follow Alice's journey of her adventure in Kyoto Forest.
Thank you Netgalley for approve on my request for this ebook in exchange for honest review.
When she arrive at Kyoto that she thought she knew, it's definitely different from where she been in her past 8 years since she left.
It's just the first volume and i'm intrigued to find out how's the story goes in the following volume.
Definitely will follow Alice's journey of her adventure in Kyoto Forest.
Thank you Netgalley for approve on my request for this ebook in exchange for honest review.
March 23, 2022
Thanks NetGalley and the publisher for giving me this arc!
Look, I can't give you a summary of what is this manga. I actually undertood nothing that happened in all this pages. We have some Alice inspiration, so if you like this type of thing, you will like it. For me, I was mostly lost and couldn't like almost nothing, although I got the impression that this one should make me feel emotional, what didn't happen. Two stars for the art, I actually liked the art style.
Look, I can't give you a summary of what is this manga. I actually undertood nothing that happened in all this pages. We have some Alice inspiration, so if you like this type of thing, you will like it. For me, I was mostly lost and couldn't like almost nothing, although I got the impression that this one should make me feel emotional, what didn't happen. Two stars for the art, I actually liked the art style.
March 8, 2022
Thank you, TOKYOPOP and NetGalley, for allowing me to read this manga in exchange for my honest review!
This was a cute and slightly interesting book, inspired but original by Alice in Wonderland. This story is heavily influenced by Asian myth and magic, and I enjoyed it; the only note is that it was a little long.
This was a cute and slightly interesting book, inspired but original by Alice in Wonderland. This story is heavily influenced by Asian myth and magic, and I enjoyed it; the only note is that it was a little long.
April 12, 2022
Many thanks to Netgalley and TokyoPop for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
I love retellings and this alice in wonderland retelling was done well. Enjoyed every aspect of this fantastical world created by the author. Alice loves reading books, she is an orphan and lives with her relatives. But she suffered through mental abuse by her uncles who kept viewing her as a burden and wanted to get rid of her. So to get away from the suffocating household, she decided to move back to Kyoto, her hometown and find a job as a maiko (i believe is a apprentice to geisha/young geisha in training).
She was unexpectedly entered into a different world set in old times Japan and at first she didnt notice the weirdness but once she got a revealation of the appearance of deity, she was strucked by the bizarreness. She was also turned older because of the rules in the world.
The world building was interesting. Im intrigued to know more of the place and to see Alice's character development. There are childhood backstory which i like since im expecting of the love interest to appear soon. Overall, an enjoyable read
I love retellings and this alice in wonderland retelling was done well. Enjoyed every aspect of this fantastical world created by the author. Alice loves reading books, she is an orphan and lives with her relatives. But she suffered through mental abuse by her uncles who kept viewing her as a burden and wanted to get rid of her. So to get away from the suffocating household, she decided to move back to Kyoto, her hometown and find a job as a maiko (i believe is a apprentice to geisha/young geisha in training).
She was unexpectedly entered into a different world set in old times Japan and at first she didnt notice the weirdness but once she got a revealation of the appearance of deity, she was strucked by the bizarreness. She was also turned older because of the rules in the world.
The world building was interesting. Im intrigued to know more of the place and to see Alice's character development. There are childhood backstory which i like since im expecting of the love interest to appear soon. Overall, an enjoyable read
March 8, 2022
(First of all, thank you so much NetGalley, publisher, and author, for providing me this ARC in exchange for an honest review)
Synopsis: After being orphaned when she was very young, Alice has lived with her aunt for most of her childhood, but her uncle clearly doesn't want her around. At 15 years old, Alice decides to return home to Kyoto and train as a maiko, an apprentice with the hopes of eventually becoming full-fledged geisha. But when she arrives back in the city where she was born, she finds that Kyoto has changed quite a bit in the years since she left it. Almost as if it's a completely different world...
This book caught my eye because of the cover. It was like watching Alice in Wonderland in manga version. I was curious because I love both Kyoto and Alice in Wonderland and I wanted to see how everything get along. I was intrigued by how Alice went to that book world, discover what she wants, and also by her friend Ren (get them married please). I think is a good manga for my child me version and I promiss you would enjoy it. Of course, the art was amazing.
Synopsis: After being orphaned when she was very young, Alice has lived with her aunt for most of her childhood, but her uncle clearly doesn't want her around. At 15 years old, Alice decides to return home to Kyoto and train as a maiko, an apprentice with the hopes of eventually becoming full-fledged geisha. But when she arrives back in the city where she was born, she finds that Kyoto has changed quite a bit in the years since she left it. Almost as if it's a completely different world...
This book caught my eye because of the cover. It was like watching Alice in Wonderland in manga version. I was curious because I love both Kyoto and Alice in Wonderland and I wanted to see how everything get along. I was intrigued by how Alice went to that book world, discover what she wants, and also by her friend Ren (get them married please). I think is a good manga for my child me version and I promiss you would enjoy it. Of course, the art was amazing.
April 1, 2022
This has the potential to be a really good series, but this first volume has so much setup and exposition that by the time you really start to get into it, it's over. I really like the concept fo the Kyoto Forest Alice is transported to, and am intrigued to learn more about her relationship with Ren, and how she'll find her purpose in this new land! As it is, I wish we'd have gotten there just a bit sooner so there could be more actual STORY in this volume. Also major content warnings for abuse, death of a parent.
A digital ARC of this book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley for review. All opinions are unbiased and my own.
Like this review?
Check out more of my reviews on my blog, Elley the Book Otter
A digital ARC of this book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley for review. All opinions are unbiased and my own.
Like this review?
Check out more of my reviews on my blog, Elley the Book Otter
March 27, 2022
Disclaimer: I work for a bookstore, all thoughts and opinions are my own and not affiliated with the store or company.
Thank you to Netgalley and TOKYOPOP for providing me with a digital version of this manga.
This volume has my whole heart. It's not often that the first volume of a series captures my attention this much but I absolutely adored this. Alice in Kyoto forest was whimsical and wholesome while maintaining an element of mystery as you try to figure this world out with Alice. It combined the magic of Alice in Wonderland with the wonders of Kyoto and I cannot give it enough praise. The illustrations only added to the beauties of this volume, adding unique twists to characters we know and love.
I absolutely cannot wait until the release of volume 2 and will be purchasing a copy of volume 1 for my own collection. For anyone looking for a quick fun retelling then this is the one for you.
Thank you to Netgalley and TOKYOPOP for providing me with a digital version of this manga.
This volume has my whole heart. It's not often that the first volume of a series captures my attention this much but I absolutely adored this. Alice in Kyoto forest was whimsical and wholesome while maintaining an element of mystery as you try to figure this world out with Alice. It combined the magic of Alice in Wonderland with the wonders of Kyoto and I cannot give it enough praise. The illustrations only added to the beauties of this volume, adding unique twists to characters we know and love.
I absolutely cannot wait until the release of volume 2 and will be purchasing a copy of volume 1 for my own collection. For anyone looking for a quick fun retelling then this is the one for you.
May 2, 2022
4/5 stars
I received an ARC of this book, and I am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
This volume was an interesting start for this series! Alice tries to return to her home in Kyoto, but she ends up in an alternate version where the rules of the normal world don't apply. The art is lovely, and I am curious about where the story will go from here.
My only issue with this volume is that it was mostly exposition, but I'm hoping things will pick up in future volumes!
Alice in Wonderland fans might enjoy this unique version of the story, and shojo fans should give this a shot as well!
I received an ARC of this book, and I am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
This volume was an interesting start for this series! Alice tries to return to her home in Kyoto, but she ends up in an alternate version where the rules of the normal world don't apply. The art is lovely, and I am curious about where the story will go from here.
My only issue with this volume is that it was mostly exposition, but I'm hoping things will pick up in future volumes!
Alice in Wonderland fans might enjoy this unique version of the story, and shojo fans should give this a shot as well!
March 29, 2022
Rating: 4.5 leaves out of 5
Characters: 4/5
Cover: 5/5
Story: 4/5
Writing: 5/5
Genre: Young Adult
Type: Manga
Worth?: Yes
First want to thank Netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review! This was a cute little play on Alice in Wonderland without actually just becoming a retelling. It was cute and also touching on a really sad subject. I think if you are looking for something that isn't really romance but nothing too adventure-y than this is for you.
Characters: 4/5
Cover: 5/5
Story: 4/5
Writing: 5/5
Genre: Young Adult
Type: Manga
Worth?: Yes
First want to thank Netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review! This was a cute little play on Alice in Wonderland without actually just becoming a retelling. It was cute and also touching on a really sad subject. I think if you are looking for something that isn't really romance but nothing too adventure-y than this is for you.
March 26, 2022
I received a copy of this manga through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Quite an interesting and pretty manga, a tribute to Alice in Wonderland! The magical world Alice enters in this manga is not quite the typical Wonderland but it is full of wonders and charming characters. I especially liked the frog and the rabbit and I am also intrigued by the secret of the boy she met in childhood. I would definitely read the future volumes, if I’ll get the chance! 😊😊
Quite an interesting and pretty manga, a tribute to Alice in Wonderland! The magical world Alice enters in this manga is not quite the typical Wonderland but it is full of wonders and charming characters. I especially liked the frog and the rabbit and I am also intrigued by the secret of the boy she met in childhood. I would definitely read the future volumes, if I’ll get the chance! 😊😊
March 15, 2023
Cute and heartfelt!
August 13, 2024
3.5/5 *
December 13, 2022
This review will cover both volumes 1 and 2 of Alice in Kyoto Forest. TLDR: The world-building and beautiful art style definitely set this manga apart from others. It’s a stand-out read, and perhaps one of the best things I’ve read this year. However, its fast pace and the rushed ending are a disappointment. Overall, I could have easily imagined this being a much longer series, which would have made my investment into the world-building all the more worth it. As is, I feel like I got swept up in a wondrous story that was over much too soon.
The story starts with Alice at her aunt's and her abusive uncle’s house. She was raised by them since her parents’ untimely death. Wanting to strike out on her own and make the most of her life, Alice embarks on a journey to Kyoto Forest in hopes of becoming a Maiko as a means of escaping her abusive uncle. However, when she arrives Kyoto is far different than she remembers. The story that unfolds is sweet, relatable, and even a bit harrowing as Alice navigates the magical world she has stepped into.
In this world, the currency is karma, which is perhaps the most fun element of the story, as it encourages all the inhabitants of Kyoto to live for their passions and be of service to others. Having escaped from an abusive situation, we watch as Alice figures out what she truly wants from her life. Her journey is beautifully told, and I only wish that the series had been longer so that it could have been explored in more detail. The side characters are memorable and compelling in their own way, which is quite an accomplishment in such a short series.
Aside from the hurried pace that happens toward the end of the second volume, my only real criticism is its darker moments, which feel tonally a bit out of place. As in, it feels like the darker parts escalate too quickly and without enough detail and buildup. I think with more groundwork the perilous part of volume two could have been all the more engaging.
The storytelling and art in this series are stellar. It makes me wonder why only two volumes of this story exist. There should be more. The ending of Alice’s journey is rushed and while plot twists are engaging and fun, it feels a bit too hurried for the audience to truly appreciate them. I thoroughly enjoyed reading Alice’s journey to self-actualization, and only wish there had been more of this to enjoy.
Overall, I think this story is definitely worth trying out. Its fun characters and inspiring leading lady make it a must-read. If you are interested in picking up a copy, and you would like to support my reviews, I encourage you to use my affiliate link:
https://amzn.to/3BwZD8L
[image error]
The story starts with Alice at her aunt's and her abusive uncle’s house. She was raised by them since her parents’ untimely death. Wanting to strike out on her own and make the most of her life, Alice embarks on a journey to Kyoto Forest in hopes of becoming a Maiko as a means of escaping her abusive uncle. However, when she arrives Kyoto is far different than she remembers. The story that unfolds is sweet, relatable, and even a bit harrowing as Alice navigates the magical world she has stepped into.
In this world, the currency is karma, which is perhaps the most fun element of the story, as it encourages all the inhabitants of Kyoto to live for their passions and be of service to others. Having escaped from an abusive situation, we watch as Alice figures out what she truly wants from her life. Her journey is beautifully told, and I only wish that the series had been longer so that it could have been explored in more detail. The side characters are memorable and compelling in their own way, which is quite an accomplishment in such a short series.
Aside from the hurried pace that happens toward the end of the second volume, my only real criticism is its darker moments, which feel tonally a bit out of place. As in, it feels like the darker parts escalate too quickly and without enough detail and buildup. I think with more groundwork the perilous part of volume two could have been all the more engaging.
The storytelling and art in this series are stellar. It makes me wonder why only two volumes of this story exist. There should be more. The ending of Alice’s journey is rushed and while plot twists are engaging and fun, it feels a bit too hurried for the audience to truly appreciate them. I thoroughly enjoyed reading Alice’s journey to self-actualization, and only wish there had been more of this to enjoy.
Overall, I think this story is definitely worth trying out. Its fun characters and inspiring leading lady make it a must-read. If you are interested in picking up a copy, and you would like to support my reviews, I encourage you to use my affiliate link:
https://amzn.to/3BwZD8L
[image error]
August 29, 2023
I was expecting to enjoy this manga from beginning to end but the story was kinda all over the place. It's obviously a retelling of Alice in wonderland but in a effort to be its own unique story it gets a little bit too much. The design of characters is beautiful and it incorporates the classic elements of Alice in wonderland story. I think it has potential, now that the first part is completed maybe in the future volumes we get to see a more well rounded story.
(ARC via netgalley)
(ARC via netgalley)
January 1, 2023
Given that I'm That One Friend that hates Alice in Wonderland, I was pleasantly surprised at how much I liked this rendition! (Probably because it's far, far removed from the original tale outside of the MC's name and, like, the inclusion of a white rabbit lol)
I think the premise is fun, the roadblocks are interesting, and the characters are cute. I'm excited to see where the story goes!
I think the premise is fun, the roadblocks are interesting, and the characters are cute. I'm excited to see where the story goes!
June 21, 2024
Avec son sujet et ses belles couvertures chatoyantes, cette énième réinterprétation du cultissime Alice in Wonderland a facilement trouvé son chemin jusqu’à moi. Vaut-il le coup ? Propose-t-il quelque chose de neuf ?
L’avantage du titre, c’est que cette réinterprétation de Mai Mochiduki et Niwa Haruki est courte : juste 2 tomes et que les dessins sont vraiment jolis, respectant bien les codes du shojo, versant « sweet lolita » avec tous ces froufrous, ces fleurs, ces peluches, etc. C’et une Alice à la fois très japonaise et très occidentale vue par des japonais qui nous est proposée. Il y a donc lieux connus et dépaysement tout à la fois.
Les autrices nous propose en effet de découvrir un Kyoto fantastique de carte postale en suivant la jeune Alice qui y part sur un coup de tête ne voulant plus rester à charge de la famille qui l’a recueillie à la mort de ses parents. Mais quand elle arrive, elle n’est pas exactement accueillie par le Kyoto qu’elle croyait, celui où elle pensait retrouver le doux Ren, garçon croisé dans son enfance. A la place, ce sont des peluches qui parlent qui la conduisent vers une maison de maiko, apprenties geisha, où elle va devoir trouver sa place.
Si j’ai trouvé le scénario un peu léger pour être gentille, reprenant très peu de codes de l’Alice de Lewis Caroll, j’ai beaucoup aim�� la façon dont les autrices développent leur atmosphère étrange et fantastique qui va venir peu à peu entourer et nourrir leur héroïne. C’est beau, charmant et triste à la fois. Il se dégage une vraie mélancolie, à la Princesse Sara de cette héroïne orpheline, passionnée de littérature, qui cherche sa place et avance en trébuchant à chaque fois mais se relève. Le décor où elle se retrouve est vraiment gentiment étrange, comme dans les contes traditionnels japonais où on voit ces animaux humaniser marcher et vivre comme nous, suivre des processions et faire preuve d’une magie brumeuse. On se sent aussi perdu qu’elle dans tout ça.
Je suis encore en train de chercher l’histoire, je le confesse, mais j’ai aimé ce voyage étrange. J’ai beaucoup aimé les décors et la narration confusante qui nous met vraiment dans la peau de l’héroïne et nous fait vivre l’aventure à son niveau. J’ai aimé les développements autour du pouvoir de la littérature pour les âmes seules et perdues. J’attends en revanche une critique plus franche de l’industrie des maiko/geisha qui est bien trop édulcoré et fantasmé ici, alors que la réalité…
Premier tome d’une aventure étrange, qui n’est pas tout à fait une revisite d’Alice à part quelques brefs marqueurs, mais qui offre son propre fantastique japonais saupoudré de cette fascination qu’ils ont pour la littérature occidentale. C’est charmant, très sweet lolita et sweet gothic. C’est surtout encore un peu superficiel malgré le thème fort de l’abandon et de la quête de soi. Je demande à voir la suite et fin dans le prochain tome.
Article complet : https://lesblablasdetachan.wordpress....
L’avantage du titre, c’est que cette réinterprétation de Mai Mochiduki et Niwa Haruki est courte : juste 2 tomes et que les dessins sont vraiment jolis, respectant bien les codes du shojo, versant « sweet lolita » avec tous ces froufrous, ces fleurs, ces peluches, etc. C’et une Alice à la fois très japonaise et très occidentale vue par des japonais qui nous est proposée. Il y a donc lieux connus et dépaysement tout à la fois.
Les autrices nous propose en effet de découvrir un Kyoto fantastique de carte postale en suivant la jeune Alice qui y part sur un coup de tête ne voulant plus rester à charge de la famille qui l’a recueillie à la mort de ses parents. Mais quand elle arrive, elle n’est pas exactement accueillie par le Kyoto qu’elle croyait, celui où elle pensait retrouver le doux Ren, garçon croisé dans son enfance. A la place, ce sont des peluches qui parlent qui la conduisent vers une maison de maiko, apprenties geisha, où elle va devoir trouver sa place.
Si j’ai trouvé le scénario un peu léger pour être gentille, reprenant très peu de codes de l’Alice de Lewis Caroll, j’ai beaucoup aim�� la façon dont les autrices développent leur atmosphère étrange et fantastique qui va venir peu à peu entourer et nourrir leur héroïne. C’est beau, charmant et triste à la fois. Il se dégage une vraie mélancolie, à la Princesse Sara de cette héroïne orpheline, passionnée de littérature, qui cherche sa place et avance en trébuchant à chaque fois mais se relève. Le décor où elle se retrouve est vraiment gentiment étrange, comme dans les contes traditionnels japonais où on voit ces animaux humaniser marcher et vivre comme nous, suivre des processions et faire preuve d’une magie brumeuse. On se sent aussi perdu qu’elle dans tout ça.
Je suis encore en train de chercher l’histoire, je le confesse, mais j’ai aimé ce voyage étrange. J’ai beaucoup aimé les décors et la narration confusante qui nous met vraiment dans la peau de l’héroïne et nous fait vivre l’aventure à son niveau. J’ai aimé les développements autour du pouvoir de la littérature pour les âmes seules et perdues. J’attends en revanche une critique plus franche de l’industrie des maiko/geisha qui est bien trop édulcoré et fantasmé ici, alors que la réalité…
Premier tome d’une aventure étrange, qui n’est pas tout à fait une revisite d’Alice à part quelques brefs marqueurs, mais qui offre son propre fantastique japonais saupoudré de cette fascination qu’ils ont pour la littérature occidentale. C’est charmant, très sweet lolita et sweet gothic. C’est surtout encore un peu superficiel malgré le thème fort de l’abandon et de la quête de soi. Je demande à voir la suite et fin dans le prochain tome.
Article complet : https://lesblablasdetachan.wordpress....
October 5, 2024
Sebenernya baca ini karena nyari buku The Full Moon Coffee Shop tapi malah munculnya manga. Yaudahlah coba baca aja karen artnya cantik dan halus ala-ala shojo. Menurutku ceritanya mirip retellingnya Alice in Wonderland dan nama FLnya juga Alice.
Alice adlh anak yatim piatu yg diurus sama bibinya tapi dia selalu dapat cemooh dr suami dan anak bibinya perihal dia numpang. Pdhl Alice juga bantu2 bibinya mengurus anak (bacain cerita) dan juga melakukan pekerjaan rumah tangga. Alice dianggap beban finansial oleh suami bibinya karena bibinya ingin menyekolahkan dia. Alice melihat sebuah iklan untuk menjadi Maiko di Kyoto dan tanpa berpikir dua kali, dia menghubungi pengiklan. Jadi tahu juga kalo Alice awalnya tinggal di Kyoto namun pindah ke Tohoku sejak orangtuanya meninggal.
Lalu, Alice dibawa ke Kyoto, tempat dimana dia akan dilatih untuk menjadi Maiko juga diberikan dua boneka, kelinci dan katak. Tapi kenyataannya tempat tersebut menolak dia, karena alasan menjadi Maiko bukanlah pilihan dari hatinya Alice dan dia berubah menjadi nenek-nenek. Dari situ Alice diingatkan kalo Kyoto yang dia datangi sekarang, bukanlah Kyoto yang ada di memorinya sejak kecil. Alice juga ingat saat kecil dulu, dia pernah ketemu sama anak cowok bernama Ren. Dia tidak pernah berbicara tp akhirnya berbicara karena diizinkan. Ren berkata dia hanya diizinkan utk berbicara dengan perempuan yg akan dia nikahi di masa depan dan berjanji akan menjemputnya jika saatnya tiba. Namun sampai saat ini Alice gak pernah ketemu dia lagi sampai akhirnya di tempat pelatihan Maiko dia melihat laki-laki yang mirip dengan Ren tapi gak tahu siapa.
Alice akhirnya pergi dari Kyoto dan berpetualang ke Kyoto Forest utk mencari seorang Carthographer, karena ingin kembali seperti semula dan hal itu dia dapatkan dari kemampuannya membacakan dongeng ke anak-anak. Kemampuannya ini terdengar ke laki-laki yang dilihatnya di Kyoto dan juga Alice hampir disekap oleh orang gak dikenal tapi ditolongin laki-laki yang juga seorang Carthographer.
Untuk cerita masih belum tahu sih mau dibawa kemana tapi secara art jujur rapih dan tipikal yg aku suka. Aku gak tau2 banget cerita asli Alice in Wonderland jadi yaa gak bisa bandingin bagus atau enggaknya secara story. Tapi kasihan banget sih ini Alicenya. Udah jatuh ketimpa tangga bener hidupnya.
Alice adlh anak yatim piatu yg diurus sama bibinya tapi dia selalu dapat cemooh dr suami dan anak bibinya perihal dia numpang. Pdhl Alice juga bantu2 bibinya mengurus anak (bacain cerita) dan juga melakukan pekerjaan rumah tangga. Alice dianggap beban finansial oleh suami bibinya karena bibinya ingin menyekolahkan dia. Alice melihat sebuah iklan untuk menjadi Maiko di Kyoto dan tanpa berpikir dua kali, dia menghubungi pengiklan. Jadi tahu juga kalo Alice awalnya tinggal di Kyoto namun pindah ke Tohoku sejak orangtuanya meninggal.
Lalu, Alice dibawa ke Kyoto, tempat dimana dia akan dilatih untuk menjadi Maiko juga diberikan dua boneka, kelinci dan katak. Tapi kenyataannya tempat tersebut menolak dia, karena alasan menjadi Maiko bukanlah pilihan dari hatinya Alice dan dia berubah menjadi nenek-nenek. Dari situ Alice diingatkan kalo Kyoto yang dia datangi sekarang, bukanlah Kyoto yang ada di memorinya sejak kecil. Alice juga ingat saat kecil dulu, dia pernah ketemu sama anak cowok bernama Ren. Dia tidak pernah berbicara tp akhirnya berbicara karena diizinkan. Ren berkata dia hanya diizinkan utk berbicara dengan perempuan yg akan dia nikahi di masa depan dan berjanji akan menjemputnya jika saatnya tiba. Namun sampai saat ini Alice gak pernah ketemu dia lagi sampai akhirnya di tempat pelatihan Maiko dia melihat laki-laki yang mirip dengan Ren tapi gak tahu siapa.
Alice akhirnya pergi dari Kyoto dan berpetualang ke Kyoto Forest utk mencari seorang Carthographer, karena ingin kembali seperti semula dan hal itu dia dapatkan dari kemampuannya membacakan dongeng ke anak-anak. Kemampuannya ini terdengar ke laki-laki yang dilihatnya di Kyoto dan juga Alice hampir disekap oleh orang gak dikenal tapi ditolongin laki-laki yang juga seorang Carthographer.
Untuk cerita masih belum tahu sih mau dibawa kemana tapi secara art jujur rapih dan tipikal yg aku suka. Aku gak tau2 banget cerita asli Alice in Wonderland jadi yaa gak bisa bandingin bagus atau enggaknya secara story. Tapi kasihan banget sih ini Alicenya. Udah jatuh ketimpa tangga bener hidupnya.
June 8, 2022
C’est un premier tome tout à fait intéressant.
Ce qui m’a tout d’abord attiré avec ce titre, c’est qu’il était inspiré de l’histoire d’Alice Aux Pays Des Merveilles. Alors j’étais curieuse de savoir comment la mangaka allait construire sa Alice et son histoire à Kyoto.
J’ai bien aimé découvrir notre jeune protagoniste. Si elle est reconnaissante d’avoir été recueilli par sa tante et son oncle car elle a perdu ses parents, elle est malheureusement consciente du ressentiment que son oncle ressent vers elle. Après plusieurs remises en question, Alice veut quitter la maison, retourner à Kyoto et trouver du travail en tant que Geisha. Et c’est sa route vers son ancien lieu de résidence que l’on va suivre.
C’est un premier tome et il est plutôt introductif. On découvre le personnage d’Alice et on la voit arriver à Kyoto. Au début de son intégration, il y a des petites choses, des petits détails qu’elle remarque et qu’elle trouve différents par rapport à ce qu’elle se souvenait de la ville. Ces différences piquent la curiosité du lecteur. Et si on n’en sait pas plus à la fin de ce premier tome, j’en ai su assez pour avoir envie de lire la suite, de connaître ce Kyoto différent et enchanté.
-----------------
ENGLISH REVIEW:
This is a very interesting first volume.
What first attracted me to this title was that it’s inspired by the story of Alice In Wonderland. So I was curious to know how the mangaka was going to build her Alice and her story in Kyoto.
I enjoyed discovering our young protagonist. If she’s grateful to have been taken in by her aunt and uncle because she lost her parents, she’s unfortunately aware of the resentment that her uncle feels towards her. After many questionings, Alice wants to leave home, return to Kyoto and find work as a Geisha. And it is her route to his former place of residence that we will follow.
This is a first volume and it’s rather introductory. We discover the character of Alice and we see her arrive in Kyoto. At the beginning of her integration, there are little things, little details that she notices and finds different from what she remembered about the city. These differences pique the curiosity of the reader. And if we don't know more at the end of this first volume, I knew enough to want to read the sequel, to know this different and enchanted Kyoto.
Ce qui m’a tout d’abord attiré avec ce titre, c’est qu’il était inspiré de l’histoire d’Alice Aux Pays Des Merveilles. Alors j’étais curieuse de savoir comment la mangaka allait construire sa Alice et son histoire à Kyoto.
J’ai bien aimé découvrir notre jeune protagoniste. Si elle est reconnaissante d’avoir été recueilli par sa tante et son oncle car elle a perdu ses parents, elle est malheureusement consciente du ressentiment que son oncle ressent vers elle. Après plusieurs remises en question, Alice veut quitter la maison, retourner à Kyoto et trouver du travail en tant que Geisha. Et c’est sa route vers son ancien lieu de résidence que l’on va suivre.
C’est un premier tome et il est plutôt introductif. On découvre le personnage d’Alice et on la voit arriver à Kyoto. Au début de son intégration, il y a des petites choses, des petits détails qu’elle remarque et qu’elle trouve différents par rapport à ce qu’elle se souvenait de la ville. Ces différences piquent la curiosité du lecteur. Et si on n’en sait pas plus à la fin de ce premier tome, j’en ai su assez pour avoir envie de lire la suite, de connaître ce Kyoto différent et enchanté.
-----------------
ENGLISH REVIEW:
This is a very interesting first volume.
What first attracted me to this title was that it’s inspired by the story of Alice In Wonderland. So I was curious to know how the mangaka was going to build her Alice and her story in Kyoto.
I enjoyed discovering our young protagonist. If she’s grateful to have been taken in by her aunt and uncle because she lost her parents, she’s unfortunately aware of the resentment that her uncle feels towards her. After many questionings, Alice wants to leave home, return to Kyoto and find work as a Geisha. And it is her route to his former place of residence that we will follow.
This is a first volume and it’s rather introductory. We discover the character of Alice and we see her arrive in Kyoto. At the beginning of her integration, there are little things, little details that she notices and finds different from what she remembered about the city. These differences pique the curiosity of the reader. And if we don't know more at the end of this first volume, I knew enough to want to read the sequel, to know this different and enchanted Kyoto.
July 7, 2023
Summary:
Alice was orphaned at a young age. She has known for nearly all that time that she wasn't precisely welcome at her new home with her aunt. It isn't that her aunt had a problem with her...but her aunt's husband? That's a different story.
Naturally, Alice jumped at the opportunity to return home to Kyoto. Best of all, going home comes with a chance to train as a maiko – something she has always dreamed of.
Review:
So, Alice in Kyoto Forest Vol. 1 is different. I'll give you that. It blends Alice in Wonderland with a geisha in training sort of story. I'm sure that this series gets better with time, but it failed to get my attention with this first volume.
Part of the reason is that there's a show/tell problem. Right away, we're told what Alice's backstory/problem is. And yes, we get to see a bit of it, but it rings hollow in comparison. And that makes it harder to get invested in her story.
That said, if you're looking for a different tale on Alice in Wonderland, this may be the story for you. I can only imagine it will get strong in the second volume (especially as the world has been established).
Highlights:
Alice in Wonderland retelling
Urban Fantasy
Will I continue the series? No.
You Can Also Find Me On:
Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks | Quirky Cat's Comics | The Book Review Crew | Monkeys Fighting Robots | Storygraph | Bookhype | Bookstagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Reedsy
Alice was orphaned at a young age. She has known for nearly all that time that she wasn't precisely welcome at her new home with her aunt. It isn't that her aunt had a problem with her...but her aunt's husband? That's a different story.
Naturally, Alice jumped at the opportunity to return home to Kyoto. Best of all, going home comes with a chance to train as a maiko – something she has always dreamed of.
Review:
So, Alice in Kyoto Forest Vol. 1 is different. I'll give you that. It blends Alice in Wonderland with a geisha in training sort of story. I'm sure that this series gets better with time, but it failed to get my attention with this first volume.
Part of the reason is that there's a show/tell problem. Right away, we're told what Alice's backstory/problem is. And yes, we get to see a bit of it, but it rings hollow in comparison. And that makes it harder to get invested in her story.
That said, if you're looking for a different tale on Alice in Wonderland, this may be the story for you. I can only imagine it will get strong in the second volume (especially as the world has been established).
Highlights:
Alice in Wonderland retelling
Urban Fantasy
Will I continue the series? No.
You Can Also Find Me On:
Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks | Quirky Cat's Comics | The Book Review Crew | Monkeys Fighting Robots | Storygraph | Bookhype | Bookstagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Reedsy
April 22, 2022
It’s a cute little book. I am always open to read new manga that involves, or is inspired by, Lewis Carroll’s works. This one definitely got my attention because of its setting and adorable cover illustration. Having already read it, I feel like this is more of a combination of Spirited Away and Howl’s Moving Castle with a protagonist that was named after the Alice books.
Alice, after her parents died in a traffic accident, was taken in by her aunt to finish schooling. Unfortunately, her uncle was a very unpleasant person and she decided that rather than going to high school, she was going to move back to Kyoto and be independent by becoming a maiko. Why exactly a maiko, I have no idea. Alice herself doesn’t even know why.
She made the necessary arrangements and to Kyoto she goes. Except… this is not exactly the Kyoto she remembers, and the habitants don’t appear to be normal people…
She soon enough finds out that this place is called Kyoto Forest and certain rules need to be followed in order to stay. One, you need to be true to yourself, and two, you need to have a purpose to be there. Since she insisted on becoming a maiko, even when she had no idea why, she found herself old and kicked out of her place. Determined to stay though, she will travel to get help to find her purpose… or is it porpoise?
Like I said, it is cute and I enjoyed reading it, but I found myself somewhat disappointed by how little of Alice in Wonderland this contains even if it supposed to be “inspired by”. This Alice is very naïve and not that smart, and certainly lacks the charm and wit of the book Alice. I do give her points for loving books and fairytales though. You can possibly count her companions the white rabbit Natsume, and the frog Hachisu as somewhat wonderlandish, but they haven’t contributed anything to the story so far. Of course, this is just starting, so later on the story can do an interesting turn.
Alice, after her parents died in a traffic accident, was taken in by her aunt to finish schooling. Unfortunately, her uncle was a very unpleasant person and she decided that rather than going to high school, she was going to move back to Kyoto and be independent by becoming a maiko. Why exactly a maiko, I have no idea. Alice herself doesn’t even know why.
She made the necessary arrangements and to Kyoto she goes. Except… this is not exactly the Kyoto she remembers, and the habitants don’t appear to be normal people…
She soon enough finds out that this place is called Kyoto Forest and certain rules need to be followed in order to stay. One, you need to be true to yourself, and two, you need to have a purpose to be there. Since she insisted on becoming a maiko, even when she had no idea why, she found herself old and kicked out of her place. Determined to stay though, she will travel to get help to find her purpose… or is it porpoise?
Like I said, it is cute and I enjoyed reading it, but I found myself somewhat disappointed by how little of Alice in Wonderland this contains even if it supposed to be “inspired by”. This Alice is very naïve and not that smart, and certainly lacks the charm and wit of the book Alice. I do give her points for loving books and fairytales though. You can possibly count her companions the white rabbit Natsume, and the frog Hachisu as somewhat wonderlandish, but they haven’t contributed anything to the story so far. Of course, this is just starting, so later on the story can do an interesting turn.
March 28, 2022
Alice in Kyoto Forest è l'ennesimo retelling della storia di Alice nel paese delle meraviglie. E' ambientata in una Kyoto di un mondo alternativo, dove Alice deve capire cosa davvero desidera fare nella sua vita.
Questa storia pare essere amata tantissimo dai giapponesi perchè ormai l'ho letta e riletta in vari manga, che la riutilizzano in ogni modo e maniera. Sopratutto in storie harem. Per fortuna non è questo il caso.
La protagonista è più un mix tra Alice e Cenerentola alla ricerca del suo obiettivo.
L'inserimento della storia d'amore l'aveva reso ad un certo punto particolarmente interessante. Peccato che non sia stato mostrato molto e che il primo volume si interrompa proprio sul più bello.
I disegni son stupendi. Adoro il chara design della protagonista e come vengono disegnati i volti dei personaggi. E il coniglio bianco è troppo carino!
-----------------------
Alice in Kyoto Forest is yet another retelling of the story of Alice in Wonderland. It is set in a Kyoto of an alternate world, where Alice must understand what she really wants to do in her life.
This story seems to be loved a lot by the Japanese people because by now I have read and reread it in various mangas, which reuse it in every way and manner. Especially in harem stories. Fortunately, this is not the case.
The protagonist is more of a mix between Alice and Cinderella looking for her goal.
The inclusion of the love story had made it particularly interesting at one point. Too bad that not much has been shown and that the first volume stops right at the most interesting point.
The chara design is gorgeous. I love the chara design of the protagonist and how the faces of the characters are drawn. And the white rabbit is too cute!
Questa storia pare essere amata tantissimo dai giapponesi perchè ormai l'ho letta e riletta in vari manga, che la riutilizzano in ogni modo e maniera. Sopratutto in storie harem. Per fortuna non è questo il caso.
La protagonista è più un mix tra Alice e Cenerentola alla ricerca del suo obiettivo.
L'inserimento della storia d'amore l'aveva reso ad un certo punto particolarmente interessante. Peccato che non sia stato mostrato molto e che il primo volume si interrompa proprio sul più bello.
I disegni son stupendi. Adoro il chara design della protagonista e come vengono disegnati i volti dei personaggi. E il coniglio bianco è troppo carino!
-----------------------
Alice in Kyoto Forest is yet another retelling of the story of Alice in Wonderland. It is set in a Kyoto of an alternate world, where Alice must understand what she really wants to do in her life.
This story seems to be loved a lot by the Japanese people because by now I have read and reread it in various mangas, which reuse it in every way and manner. Especially in harem stories. Fortunately, this is not the case.
The protagonist is more of a mix between Alice and Cinderella looking for her goal.
The inclusion of the love story had made it particularly interesting at one point. Too bad that not much has been shown and that the first volume stops right at the most interesting point.
The chara design is gorgeous. I love the chara design of the protagonist and how the faces of the characters are drawn. And the white rabbit is too cute!
March 22, 2022
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!
~*~
Alice in Kyoto Forest is a delightful retelling of the original Alice in Wonderland but set in 1800's Kyoto, Japan instead of 1800's Oxford, England. Alice is an orphan, looking for a new start in life, which leads her to return to Kyoto, except it is not the Kyoto she remembers. The art style is charming and has a soft and whimsical feel to it. It drew me in, starting on the first page. The author has shown that they have an appreciation of the aesthetics of late 1800's Kyoto, which is evident in their artistic style. When it comes to the story, the jumps from locale to locale can feel a bit quick. However, this is also how it feels in the original story, so it is accurate as a retelling of the original. This is the first volume and falls to the same small stumbling block most series do. The story elements all have to be set into place in this volume, and there are many. It can feel like the story is a tad front-loaded and there are a lot of story pieces that are disconnected. However, it smooths out by the 4th chapter, with more of the aforementioned pieces clicking into place. I'm sure it will fully smooth out in the next volume of the series. Finally, Alice, as a character is adorable! An earnest young girl who tries her best to make the best of life, with a love of stories. I am interested in how this character will grow as a person she journeys along. This story of this manga intrigued me, and I already am itching to find out what happens next!
~*~
Alice in Kyoto Forest is a delightful retelling of the original Alice in Wonderland but set in 1800's Kyoto, Japan instead of 1800's Oxford, England. Alice is an orphan, looking for a new start in life, which leads her to return to Kyoto, except it is not the Kyoto she remembers. The art style is charming and has a soft and whimsical feel to it. It drew me in, starting on the first page. The author has shown that they have an appreciation of the aesthetics of late 1800's Kyoto, which is evident in their artistic style. When it comes to the story, the jumps from locale to locale can feel a bit quick. However, this is also how it feels in the original story, so it is accurate as a retelling of the original. This is the first volume and falls to the same small stumbling block most series do. The story elements all have to be set into place in this volume, and there are many. It can feel like the story is a tad front-loaded and there are a lot of story pieces that are disconnected. However, it smooths out by the 4th chapter, with more of the aforementioned pieces clicking into place. I'm sure it will fully smooth out in the next volume of the series. Finally, Alice, as a character is adorable! An earnest young girl who tries her best to make the best of life, with a love of stories. I am interested in how this character will grow as a person she journeys along. This story of this manga intrigued me, and I already am itching to find out what happens next!
March 20, 2022
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher I was able to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
***
Alice in Kyoto Forest is the beginning of orphaned Alice’s adventures. When she was young her parents were killed in a car accident and she moved from Kyoto to Tohoku to live with her aunt and uncle. At fifteen and wanting to get away from her incredibly unpleasant uncle Alice decides to train as a Maiko, an apprentice geisha, in Kyoto. From the moment she gets into the car that starts her journey to her crossing the bridge on foot into Kyoto Alice notices things may not be quite what she thinks they are. Indeed they are not because the Kyoto she finds herself in is not the one she is familiar with and Alice needs to familiarize herself with the rules quickly because her life and her ability to stay in this world are in danger if she doesn’t.
A mostly cute soft story, so far Alice is a pleasant young girl looking for her place in the world after having lived so many years in the house she had with an adult that made it clear how unwanted she was. Alice longs to carve a place for herself and jumps at the first opportunity that gave it to her whether it was specifically something she wanted for herself or not.
As someone obsessed with Alice in Wonderland my eye was caught by the cover and title and while there is definitely a lot of play on Alice in Wonderland this story is proving to be a fun story itself and I look forward to seeing where it is going to go.
***
Alice in Kyoto Forest is the beginning of orphaned Alice’s adventures. When she was young her parents were killed in a car accident and she moved from Kyoto to Tohoku to live with her aunt and uncle. At fifteen and wanting to get away from her incredibly unpleasant uncle Alice decides to train as a Maiko, an apprentice geisha, in Kyoto. From the moment she gets into the car that starts her journey to her crossing the bridge on foot into Kyoto Alice notices things may not be quite what she thinks they are. Indeed they are not because the Kyoto she finds herself in is not the one she is familiar with and Alice needs to familiarize herself with the rules quickly because her life and her ability to stay in this world are in danger if she doesn’t.
A mostly cute soft story, so far Alice is a pleasant young girl looking for her place in the world after having lived so many years in the house she had with an adult that made it clear how unwanted she was. Alice longs to carve a place for herself and jumps at the first opportunity that gave it to her whether it was specifically something she wanted for herself or not.
As someone obsessed with Alice in Wonderland my eye was caught by the cover and title and while there is definitely a lot of play on Alice in Wonderland this story is proving to be a fun story itself and I look forward to seeing where it is going to go.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews