I loved the style and concept of this book and it was perfect for reading in a snug little cabin in the woods, but I cannot wholeheartedly recommend this one, for reasons I’ll get into in a minute.
The basic idea here is that the author retells 30+ spooky legends and tales from around Virginia, stories purported by locals to be true. Some of these I knew, some I didn’t, and some are localized twists on old legends. My favorite was one about an Appalachian vampire. But she tells them in the style of a campfire story, in first person, rather than just drily documenting the legend. (Sometimes the narrator is telling an experience that happened to a friend or family member.) So for each story, she adopts a different character and voice. Some are modern hauntings and others are historical.
And therein lies the trouble, because as we all know, Virginia has some pretty dark history. Two of the stories are told from the POV of enslaved people, one of them in vernacular, and I think that’s a tone-deaf choice at best. One of the stories also featured a “beloved” mistress who all of the enslaved workers loved and were upset when she died. (Another similar one included a master’s young daughter who everyone loved, though it’s unclear whether the characters in that story are servants or enslaved or what year it’s set in.) I think that even if you’re trying to be authentic about the history of these ghost stories and how they’re traditionally told, you can do that without reinforcing myths about “happy” slaves with “good” enslavers. The kicker is that this edition of the book was published in 2023!
I did enjoy most of the stories in this book and really liked the atmospheric woodcut illustrations, but that handful of stories keep this from being my preferred resource for haunted Virginia folklore.