I need to really think about this one before I review it. It was definitely a choice....
********************
Ok, I literally had to sleep on it because I've never felt so conflicted about a book 😂 I know I've questioned character behaviour and decisions before, but that's more so because my neurodivergent brain doesn't understand the situation, the social behaviour, or I just can't relate to it and I hope that by mentioning what has me confused about a character, then someone may shine a light on why it actually makes sense! This book though.....
I'm going to warn again that there is a hefty spoiler in my review so if you don't want to see it please don't read it!!!
First though, I'm even more convinced, following my review of the previous book, that this is not actually a romance series. It's a love letter to the town of Stallion Ridge and the MCs are just showing us Stallion Ridge through their eyes whilst they meet their mate/partner. I've kept saying that the relationships are all pretty instalust/instalove, and honestly I feel like it's because we're not supposed to be concerning ourselves with their relationships too much. We're supposed to be falling in love with the character that is the town! All of the character growth and development is seen with the town transforming from a small community in the middle of nowhere, to a thriving and ever expanding haven for shifters and humans to live harmoniously together. It's basically an ideological town where no one's differences or disabilities matter, they make the community stronger and everyone is welcome as long as they abide by the values and beliefs of the town. I'd love to go live in Stallion Ridge!
I do wish we'd gotten an epilogue though because the story pretty much ends! I want to see how Stallion Ridge recovered from the final showdown; I wanted to see the aftermath and how certain people emotionally heal from the loss they suffered. I wanted to see Jack and Gideon actually settled down in Stallion Ridge, and I wanted to know what came of the allegations against Jack, Sky and West.
I loved the POV that was used for this book though. I love how the book begins and ends with Jack - I adored his and Gideon's short stories that are the prequel to the Stallion Ridge series, and I was always dissatisfied that they didn't get their HEA, so to have it now was perfect! We also get this story through the eyes of four people: Jack, Cal, West and Gin; and it just felt like the perfect ending was being built with no loose ends...
Second warning that this is the big spoiler, so please stop reading if you don't want to know!!! I just can't finish my review without talking about the biggest point of contention that I have!
Ok, you've been sufficiently warned so I now feel no guilt if I spoil this series for you!
Why the FUCK was Seb killed off??? He was an MC of one of the books, the ONLY book to feature a poly relationship, and he literally only just got mated to his two loves! It made no sense to me, and even after sleeping on it I still can't figure it out. Yes, he was haunted by what he'd done, but he never even got the chance to try and work through it now that he had Lucas and Elliott, he was just killed? Did it add emotional impact and trauma to the climax of the whole series? Yes, it did. But why get me so attached to a main character in the series just to kill him so unneccesarily? I have never questioned an author's choice in their plot before (unless it's a 1 star book and I just don't understand why the entire thing was published....) so this is new territory for me. I don't feel like the author owed us anything, or that they don't know their own characters, but I honestly don't understand why this choice was made. Seb's book was actually the only book in the whole series that I rated 5 stars, granted it was more because of Thayer who was outside of the relationship, but still! It felt to me like because Seb was part of an MMM relationship, it was ok to kill him because the other two still had each other? I don't consider a poly relationship to mean you have a spare partner if one dies or leaves! I also felt cheated that we didn't get to see the aftermath and what this death does to Lucas and Elliott. Is their grief going to bring them together, or is it going to drive them apart? Can they stay in Stallion Ridge after all of the emotional pain and trauma, or are they going to leave for good? There was just so much left unsaid and Seb deserved so much more than what he got after the life he'd been forced to live. There was also no after note from the author explaining or mentioning Seb at all so I'm even more flummoxed!
So yes, for me this is not a romance series because essentially the romance was minimal with all of the MC's - it was pretty much all instalove or all the falling in love had been done off page - and for me you can't call it a romance and kill one of the MC's. That's a romantic tragedy and I will die on my hill for that - my hill that is, in fact, located in the birthplace of Shakespeare, so romantic tragedies are something I've been learning about since I was a teeny child 😂
I did genuinely love this series though, Seb dying aside, and I really did fall in love with the town of Stallion Ridge and it's inhabitants. I just wish the ending had been slightly different and also more...
This review also made me laugh whilst I was writing it because it reminded me of one of those recipe websites where you get a lifestory about broccoli before you eventually make it to the extremely brief recipe at the very end 😂😂😂