2/5 - okay, verging on bad.
I got this book for my birthday as I love reading and libraries and I was excited to read it and so wanted to love it. Unfortunately, it fell flat for me.
Positives:
- It's a really interesting, fun premise - to collect library cards from around the UK - and I enjoyed reading about the libraries he visited.
- The photos of a few libraries throughout the book. I wish all libraries had been photographed as I found this part fascinating.
- The subject matter. I love the subject matter of books and libraries and that's probably why it's a 2 rather than a 1.
Negatives:
- The focus of the writing. A lot of this book isn't actually about the libraries he visits, with many sections not even mentioning the library he got the card at. I think, for a book entitled 'Library Journey', this is a huge downfall. I wanted to learn about the libraries across the UK, not the drive to them, or the town they're in.
- The sheer amount of complaining throughout. While I understand that the situation around libraries (their funding, their closures etc.) is dire, I didn't enjoy reading the author's complaints about it on every second page. Also, there were no alternative solutions provided and those which have happened (such as community libraries, or sharing building space with other services) were also complained about!
- He never addresses how many people use (or don't use) libraries in the UK, which I think is the pertinent issue. I found out how many books Finns borrow but not British people! The copious complaining makes it seem like funding is being pulled for no reason and while this may be true, I would suspect that fewer people use libraries now than in the past, which has to be linked to the decline in funding. Surely this, then, is the central issue. Or one of them, at least.
- He never mentions borrowing books from the libraries he visits (and some places - like Northern Ireland - he does reside in for a while) but instead mentions buying books. I found this deeply ironic in a book about libraries as how does buying books support libraries? I even highlighted the quote because it shocked me: 'the time I spend in the library happily skim-reading convinces me I should buy the book'. Why not borrow it from your local library? Is this not a root of the problem for libraries - that people buy so don't need to borrow?
- Finally, I felt he was quite dismissive of wealth inequality. In Richmond-upon-Thames, he lauded their fantastic library and their ability to 'ride austerity with ... the wealth of its populace', never mentioning that this wealth disparity is deeply unfair. Meanwhile, when he goes to Hull and Blackpool, he mentions their poverty but, I feel, only in a disparaging way. While he discusses the need to 'cure Blackpool', he still doesn't mention the wealth disparity that I think is at the heart of the issue.
Overall:
- I wanted to enjoy this so much; I was so hoping it would be a 5* but it just wasn't. I think the only reason I got through it (and gave it 2*) was the subject matter.
- I unfortunately wouldn't recommend to people.
- I wouldn't read again but I'll probably keep the book as it was a well-intentioned birthday present.