Initial reaction: This was a whole journey of teens being terrible to each other and a steadily unfolding mystery with high stakes, but in a way that I think is meaningful and realistic for what it chooses to explore. The comparisons to "Ace of Spades" and "Tiny Pretty Things" make a lot of sense (of course the latter since the same authors penned this). I followed the characters in this very well and my heart ached for a few of them. Take the trigger warnings seriously, there are quite a bit here and they don't pull punches.
Full review:
"The Rumor Game" is an experience that I'd give a pretty solid 4 stars - immersive, intense, and while I wouldn't say it's necessarily a thriller, it definitely had a driving mystery and emotionally invested moments where you could feel the weight of events for what they were. I received this book as a galley, but I also listened to an audiobook copy of the novel after it was published, so I'm actually rounding this up to about a half-star more because of the strong audio performances by Joniece Abbott Pratt, Taylor Meskimen, Deepa Samuel, and Julie Nathanson.
Granted, this is not a book that is an easy read - take the trigger warnings seriously because there are quite a number of them to be had. To reiterate, content warnings for the book include bullying/cyberbullying, sexual abuse, sexual assault, weight loss/ED issues, body image, fatphobia, and racism (both in the form of microaggressions and overt displays). I do like that there's quite a bit of pushback/emotionally invested dialogue from the characters on these issues, especially when they come up.
This is a stand alone story from both Dhonielle Clayton and Sona Charaipota, authors of the "Tiny Pretty Things" series. I enjoyed that duology for what it offered for the intensely emotional mystery, setting, and the showcase of the cast of characters and their subsequent development through the series, dramatic twists in tow. "The Rumor Game" illuminates yet another competitive environment - Foxham Prep - centering on a group of three very flawed teens embroiled in a rumor scandal that shakes their respective lives in different ways. We have Bryn, former queen bee and political hopeful involved in causing a vehicular accident that put her Student Council presidency on the line, alongside a heavily tarnished reputation. We have Cora, Black cheerleading captain whose social status has improved, but strongly pushed rumors by a mysterious tipster threaten to tarnish her relationships, both with her boyfriend and a new girl. And then there's Georgie (oh Georgie...), an Indian teen who has transformed physically and emotionally with a weight loss journey and tries to strike the balance of navigating those changes while becoming a newfound target for scrutiny.
I think this is a realistic novel to portay the issues of bullying/cyberbullying and how cruel teens can be to each other, though it also has some events that are a little more out there and you can tell it's more for the driving conflict of the novel. Fair point to make: Bryn, Cora, and Georgie alike all are quite flawed characters where their fallibilities are put for full display online and at school. Told in a mixed media format combining prose, simulated text messages, articles, among other features, you follow Bryn, Cora, and Georgie as they navigate past and present events while also trying to determine who might be trying to sabotage their relationships with each other. The answer is a little more closer to home than any of them expect, and the game of trying to add on to the tide of rumors results in some horrible events that spiral out of control as the novel marches to its respective conclusion - revealing all and noting the fallout. I didn't think the consequences of said fallout were evenly handed when it was all said and done, but I did at least appreciate the journey overall.
The novel is a slow-burn in places, establishing the backgrounds of each of the girls and how they navigate some of the bigger conflicts at the center of their lives while also navigating the dialogue spiral the rumors become. I did not expect the twists, did not expect some of the respective players who had their hand in the conflict to be what they were, so it kept me guessing and wanting to find out who had the most to gain and lose. There were times I internally raged at some of the things the characters did, but I also understood emotionally where each of the teens were at the time (Georgie goes through...a lot. Whew. There were times I had to put my book down and re-center with all of her respective body issues and the blows she's dealt with her social reputation.) I think those who are familiar with "Tiny Pretty Things" will see parallels in the kind of dramatic and petty plays the teens make, alongside misunderstandings (*cough* lies, lies, LIES *cough*) the characters engage in.
I think teens will be engaged with this to see what happens and how far it goes, though it falls in line with having moments where its realistic and others are the more drama-style conflict you see in series like PLL, Gossip Girl, Private, etc. I would argue that there aren't as many moments to see the teens really flourish in happier spaces to round them out a little more from the heavier events, but I did like seeing their respective arcs in this.
Overall, I think it was an engaging read and it makes me want to see more collaborations and offerings from both of these authors alike.
Overall score: 4/5 stars.
Note: I received this as an ARC from NetGalley from the publisher.