What do you think?
Rate this book
The Four Pillars #3
Barrow of Winter
Thray is the Last Daughter of Winter, half immortal and haunted by the legacy of her blood. When offered a chance to visit the northern land of Duamel, where her father once ruled, she can't refuse – even if it means lying to the priesthood she serves and the man she loves.
In Duamel, Thray’s demi-god siblings rule under the northern lights, worshipped by arcane cults. An endless winter night cloaks the land, giving rise to strange beasts, terrible storms and a growing, desperate hunger. The people of Duamel teeter on the edge of violence, and Thray’s siblings, powerful and deathless, stand with them on the brink.
To earn her siblings’ trust and find the answers she seeks, Thray will have to weather assassinations, conspiracies and icy wastelands. And as her siblings turn their gaze towards the warmer, brighter land she calls home, she must harness her own feral power and decide where her loyalties lie.
Because when the spring winds blow and the ice breaks up, the sons and daughters of Winter will bring her homeland to its knees.
In Duamel, Thray’s demi-god siblings rule under the northern lights, worshipped by arcane cults. An endless winter night cloaks the land, giving rise to strange beasts, terrible storms and a growing, desperate hunger. The people of Duamel teeter on the edge of violence, and Thray’s siblings, powerful and deathless, stand with them on the brink.
To earn her siblings’ trust and find the answers she seeks, Thray will have to weather assassinations, conspiracies and icy wastelands. And as her siblings turn their gaze towards the warmer, brighter land she calls home, she must harness her own feral power and decide where her loyalties lie.
Because when the spring winds blow and the ice breaks up, the sons and daughters of Winter will bring her homeland to its knees.
336 pages, Paperback
First published January 17, 2023
31 people are currently reading
5142 people want to read
About the author
H.M. Long
11 books1,103 followersHannah (H. M.) Long is a Canadian fantasy author. She inhabits a ramshackle cabin in Ontario with her family, but she can often be spotted snooping about museums or wandering the Alps.
Hannah writes for Titan Books and is the author of the Four Pillars Quartet (Hall of Smoke), the Winter Sea Trilogy (Dark Water Daughter), the Entwined Duology (2026/27), Ashmarked (2027), and more.
For the latest updates, follow Hannah on TikTok (@hmlongbooks), Instagram (@hmlongbooks), and Twitter (@hannah_m_long).
Hannah writes for Titan Books and is the author of the Four Pillars Quartet (Hall of Smoke), the Winter Sea Trilogy (Dark Water Daughter), the Entwined Duology (2026/27), Ashmarked (2027), and more.
For the latest updates, follow Hannah on TikTok (@hmlongbooks), Instagram (@hmlongbooks), and Twitter (@hannah_m_long).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews
May 28, 2023
Thray is a demi-god, a daughter of Winter, who serves as a priestess for a local clan. But when unexpected visitors arrive on their shores and offer her a chance to visit the northern land where her father once ruled, she realizes this may be the only chance she has to learn about her bloodline. She travels with a couple of her demi-god siblings and learns that there are many more who rule the northlands. Upon her arrival, Thray finds herself torn between her former loyalties, her siblings, and the secrets and power struggles she becomes immersed in as she learns that her southern homeland may not be as safe as she always believed.
Apparently, this is book three in a series, though that certainly wasn’t mentioned on the site where I requested it. It does make me wonder what my experience would have been like if I’d read the preceding books. That being said, I still quite enjoyed it, so I guess this can be read as a standalone with minimal issues!
The world building was fascinating and well incorporated. Details surrounding the immortals, demi-gods, and religion were included throughout the plot and descriptions in ways that brought the world to life. I enjoyed the mythology of this fictional world and how thoroughly it was incorporated into the lives of the characters. I also enjoyed how well the setting and the dangers of the terrain/weather were utilized to add to the tale. The author did an excellent job with the atmosphere, creating an immersive story.
This was by no means a quick read though. And not just related to length (it’s not that long), but more related to the pacing of the plot. It’s slow. There’s not much action, though there is some scattered throughout. The book is much more focused on Thray’s character, the intricacies of being a demi-god, and the power struggles related to that, especially surrounding having siblings who are 100+ older than you. It also emphasized politics, religion, and conflicting loyalties and desires. It took me a little bit to get into the read as I was expecting a more fast-paced, action-filled read, but once I adjusted my expectations, I quite enjoyed this read.
If you enjoy slower fantasy reads that focus on worldbuilding more than action and are set in a Norse-like world, then this would be the read for you. My thanks to NetGalley and Titan Books for allowing me to read this work. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Apparently, this is book three in a series, though that certainly wasn’t mentioned on the site where I requested it. It does make me wonder what my experience would have been like if I’d read the preceding books. That being said, I still quite enjoyed it, so I guess this can be read as a standalone with minimal issues!
The world building was fascinating and well incorporated. Details surrounding the immortals, demi-gods, and religion were included throughout the plot and descriptions in ways that brought the world to life. I enjoyed the mythology of this fictional world and how thoroughly it was incorporated into the lives of the characters. I also enjoyed how well the setting and the dangers of the terrain/weather were utilized to add to the tale. The author did an excellent job with the atmosphere, creating an immersive story.
This was by no means a quick read though. And not just related to length (it’s not that long), but more related to the pacing of the plot. It’s slow. There’s not much action, though there is some scattered throughout. The book is much more focused on Thray’s character, the intricacies of being a demi-god, and the power struggles related to that, especially surrounding having siblings who are 100+ older than you. It also emphasized politics, religion, and conflicting loyalties and desires. It took me a little bit to get into the read as I was expecting a more fast-paced, action-filled read, but once I adjusted my expectations, I quite enjoyed this read.
If you enjoy slower fantasy reads that focus on worldbuilding more than action and are set in a Norse-like world, then this would be the read for you. My thanks to NetGalley and Titan Books for allowing me to read this work. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
February 13, 2023
Barrow of Winter is out now! Though set in the same world as Hall of Smoke, BARROW OF WINTER stands alone and follows a new main character in a new land. You don't have to read the other books in the HOS World first, though some readers may prefer to.
In Barrow of Winter you can expect:
-All the wintery atmosphere
-A clan of demigod siblings out for blood
-A fierce protagonist searching for answers
-Ravenous beasts you definitely should not try to tame
-A land locked in eternal winter night
-Dangerous cults, ancient tombs and dark magics
-All the epic battles you've come to expect from the Hall of Smoke world
You can get Barrow of Winter in print, ebook and audiobook!
Content warnings: violence, gore, blood sacrifice
In Barrow of Winter you can expect:
-All the wintery atmosphere
-A clan of demigod siblings out for blood
-A fierce protagonist searching for answers
-Ravenous beasts you definitely should not try to tame
-A land locked in eternal winter night
-Dangerous cults, ancient tombs and dark magics
-All the epic battles you've come to expect from the Hall of Smoke world
You can get Barrow of Winter in print, ebook and audiobook!
Content warnings: violence, gore, blood sacrifice
December 5, 2023
While this would probably have made more sense had I read the first two books, I don't remember this clearly being labeled a sequel when I requested it. Thray is the Last Daughter of Winter and half immortal. While this is mentioned rather often, I don't really feel as if I ever understood it to its full extent. She goes on a journey and meets her demigod siblings. This was the part of the story I enjoyed best. Mythology? Yes. Retellings? No.
December 20, 2022
What a book!
I just absolutely loved it.
I’ve read a lot of low fantasy recently and so I really enjoyed reading something a little more high fantasy again.
In Barrow of Winter, our protagonist is Thray, a demi-god – or at least she might be. To find out she needs to die and discover if she comes back to life. She doesn’t want to die though. She has a role to play in her village, a man she wants to marry – and life as a mortal is enough for her.
However she has a clan of half siblings who seem intent on bringing her into their fold. The only problem is that her grandfather (the god of winter) has warned her not to trust them.
Who is right? What schemes are at play? Why is the land her half-siblings control trapped in perpetual winter? And what power (if any) does Thray possess?
The premise was intriguing to be sure, but what really delivers such a complex setting is H.M. Long’s prose. It’s amazing, and it does such a good job of ramping up the tension. Similar to Anthony Ryan in this regard, the pieces are slowly put into place and built on and built on. Barrow of Winter is a slow burn of a novel that quickly catches fire – and there was one particular scene involving an ice covered pool that had me on the edge of my seat.
I believe the book is out in January – the coldest month of the year – which is very apt! It’s the perfect winter read. Atmospheric and richly detailed, I think fans of fantasy will adore this book.
I just absolutely loved it.
I’ve read a lot of low fantasy recently and so I really enjoyed reading something a little more high fantasy again.
In Barrow of Winter, our protagonist is Thray, a demi-god – or at least she might be. To find out she needs to die and discover if she comes back to life. She doesn’t want to die though. She has a role to play in her village, a man she wants to marry – and life as a mortal is enough for her.
However she has a clan of half siblings who seem intent on bringing her into their fold. The only problem is that her grandfather (the god of winter) has warned her not to trust them.
Who is right? What schemes are at play? Why is the land her half-siblings control trapped in perpetual winter? And what power (if any) does Thray possess?
The premise was intriguing to be sure, but what really delivers such a complex setting is H.M. Long’s prose. It’s amazing, and it does such a good job of ramping up the tension. Similar to Anthony Ryan in this regard, the pieces are slowly put into place and built on and built on. Barrow of Winter is a slow burn of a novel that quickly catches fire – and there was one particular scene involving an ice covered pool that had me on the edge of my seat.
I believe the book is out in January – the coldest month of the year – which is very apt! It’s the perfect winter read. Atmospheric and richly detailed, I think fans of fantasy will adore this book.
February 2, 2023
This was definitely a yes for audiobook lovers. I’m giving this a high 4⭐️. This is a stand-alone and narrated by Samara Naeymi. She was excellent and I really enjoyed her voice.
This was interesting and written well. This epic fantasy had twists and turns that just made me want to know more about this story.
Thanks Recorded Books via NetGalley.
This was interesting and written well. This epic fantasy had twists and turns that just made me want to know more about this story.
Thanks Recorded Books via NetGalley.
November 1, 2022
Beautifully written ARC. Don't have to read preceeding novels to pick this one up.
January 18, 2023
Thank you to Titan Books for an e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!
Happy UK release day (I finished just in time!). The book comes out in the USA/Canada on the 31st of January.
H.M. Long is easily one of my top ten favourite authors after this book, and it's definitely my favourite of what she has published so far. I've been following this series for three years now, and I am so grateful to have received e-ARC's of Temple of No God, and now this one. Here's hoping I can get ARC's of Pillar of Ash and Dark Water Daughter!
This book builds on all the minor issues I had with the previous two instalments to create an absolutely magnificent novel. The wintery atmosphere was incredibly strong and cinematic, the characters journey's were emotionally heightened and charged (to a greater extent), the action was even more cinematic. I could go on forever. It has everything I want from a fantasy novel: a complex and emotional plot, betrayals, gods and cults, believable character relationships, fantastical creatures, and more.
Thray is definitely my favourite main character out of the three books - sorry Hessa! - because I loved how multifaceted she was. She was both a hero and the villain and it made for such an interesting dynamic with the supporting cast to see how she changed her personality and loyalties around them. I highlighted and annotated so many beautiful lines that highlighted her personal and external battles, this book was a wild ride of tender moments and thrilling action. I'm struggling to put my thoughts into words because I enjoyed it that much. She is such a strong person, and the ending made me really upset, even though it's fitting and bittersweet. She knows what she did was wrong but was necessary to herself and the greater good - I hope she makes cameo's in Pillar of Ash like Hessa and co. did here. (The epilogue makes me think she will.)
The attention to detail in these books is wonderful. You can truly feel the temperature, hear the sounds etc., it is an engrossing experience to read a H.M. Long novel. My only wish is that we got to see more of Thray's relationships with Vistic and Arune (an old and new favourite character), and see more of the cult aspect as it was pretty central to the plot resolution. Other than that, this book was an absolute blast. And the best part? You don't have to read any of the previous books because they're all standalones - but I highly encourage you to read them all as they're fantastic.
If you're looking for an action-packed, cinematic, viking-inspired story about immortality, seeking out your fate, magical creatures, cults, and old gods then this is the book (and series) for you!
Happy UK release day (I finished just in time!). The book comes out in the USA/Canada on the 31st of January.
H.M. Long is easily one of my top ten favourite authors after this book, and it's definitely my favourite of what she has published so far. I've been following this series for three years now, and I am so grateful to have received e-ARC's of Temple of No God, and now this one. Here's hoping I can get ARC's of Pillar of Ash and Dark Water Daughter!
This book builds on all the minor issues I had with the previous two instalments to create an absolutely magnificent novel. The wintery atmosphere was incredibly strong and cinematic, the characters journey's were emotionally heightened and charged (to a greater extent), the action was even more cinematic. I could go on forever. It has everything I want from a fantasy novel: a complex and emotional plot, betrayals, gods and cults, believable character relationships, fantastical creatures, and more.
Thray is definitely my favourite main character out of the three books - sorry Hessa! - because I loved how multifaceted she was. She was both a hero and the villain and it made for such an interesting dynamic with the supporting cast to see how she changed her personality and loyalties around them. I highlighted and annotated so many beautiful lines that highlighted her personal and external battles, this book was a wild ride of tender moments and thrilling action. I'm struggling to put my thoughts into words because I enjoyed it that much. She is such a strong person, and the ending made me really upset, even though it's fitting and bittersweet. She knows what she did was wrong but was necessary to herself and the greater good - I hope she makes cameo's in Pillar of Ash like Hessa and co. did here. (The epilogue makes me think she will.)
The attention to detail in these books is wonderful. You can truly feel the temperature, hear the sounds etc., it is an engrossing experience to read a H.M. Long novel. My only wish is that we got to see more of Thray's relationships with Vistic and Arune (an old and new favourite character), and see more of the cult aspect as it was pretty central to the plot resolution. Other than that, this book was an absolute blast. And the best part? You don't have to read any of the previous books because they're all standalones - but I highly encourage you to read them all as they're fantastic.
If you're looking for an action-packed, cinematic, viking-inspired story about immortality, seeking out your fate, magical creatures, cults, and old gods then this is the book (and series) for you!
February 7, 2023
Wicked Good Books Arc Review
Barrow of Winter by H.M. Long
Publisher: Titan Books
Nick’s Book Track: In the Woods Somewhere by Hozier
There is something profound about the way HM Long conjures such tangible atmosphere around so many incredibly three-dimensional characters. All three of her books in this series are so character driven but never sacrifice their strong sense of setting and environment. I grew up around the woods and mountains of New England and this world makes me home sick. I don’t think there has been another fantasy series that has gripped my heart in such a way and made me miss home with all five senses just through prose.
The Hall of Smoke world is a fully immersive sense of escapism for me and I know that may not be helpful to most who are reading this but I needed to record it. The crunch of snow underfoot and the taste of snow as it brushes past your face during a dusting. The smell of moss and tree bark and the way they feel in your hand or under your toes. That’s what it feels like to read Long’s prose. Her details aren’t just saved for the environment either, it’s during the scenes of combat or danger that you can really feel it too. The way ice feels in your hand when you’ve held it too long, almost hot and cutting. You’re right there with these characters as they struggle just to survive not just each other but the harsh lands they make their home in.
The plot for this entry follows Tray, daughter of Sixnit and Ogam, raised by Hessa, the lead protagonist from the first two books, as she grapples with who she is and what it means to be immortal. Asking herself the difficult question of this: is it worth building a life and a family with mortals when in the end you will have to watch them grow old and die? This story feels more introspective than the previous two. Leaning heavier on Tray and her ties to the Eangi and her connection to the sons and daughters of winter. Essentially demigods whom she is introduced to and forced to confront her worst fears about her mortal family and must decide if these blood ties are stronger than those bonds forged with the family she made herself. This is adult fantasy at it’s finest and it makes reading her work a great adventure and well-worth the sojourn into her worlds every time.
We get to see some familiar faces throughout that I won’t name here for fear of unintentionally spoiling the other two books but I will say that fans of the characters in the first two books will appreciate the appearances. Completely unrelated, I love how empowering Long’s female characters are and without the need to put down the male characters and vice versa. I also appreciate the body positivity and subtle bisexual rep in Barrow of Winter. I wasn’t expecting it and I found it refreshing and a great step forward from some of the other norse-flavored fantasy I’ve read and seen recently. I don’t want to say too much about the supporting characters, but, for those who have read it or are about to, I was unsure about Thray’s half siblings and despite not trusting the lot of them, I still found myself drawn to and won over by Arune. I even enjoyed Kyga and Siru, despite how they treated Thray in the end. I found these characters to all feel like they had weight to them more than just cut-outs so that the lead could stand out. They all made Thray stand out because of the depth Long gave them and the emotion and personality she poured into them. Just, a breath of fresh winter air.
I loved Thray’s weapon too. Reminded me of a trick weapon you’d see in Bloodborne (game) or Castlevania (Netflix) and I liked that Long didn’t make it into a gimmick either. It came in handy but did not make it’s wielder invincible either. Though she did wield it with precious and confidence. I absolutely loved how confident Thray was, despite her naivety, she is such a fully-realized character and this was something I was worried about not being the case once I’d learned that Tessa would not be the main character in BoW. She was brilliantly crafted and totally and unapologetically herself, just like her aunt.
The creatures stood out in this one too. Maybe it’s because I had been playing God of War Ragnarök while reading this but I could’t help but love the Savn. They really stood out to me and I hope we see more of them. I was constantly aware of what their presence would be like and how their fur would feel and smell and it made them, again, tangible, in my minds eye but to my other senses too while reading. If you haven’t figured this out already, this book, Long’s prose, is a snowed-capped gift for those who like immersive and atmospheric reads.
Barrow of Winter comes to an end with a crash like two sheets of ice colliding on water. There is a lot going on and it feels like you’re thrust into the thick of it, into the mist and snow-blind of it all. It made for an excellent seasonal read and, while it still would be just as good if read in the summer, it still emanates with cozy (and harsh) winter vibes. You will undoubtedly feel cold while reading this so dress in layers or pull on some thick socks and a scratchy but comforting wool blanket. H.M. Long’s latest will transport you into a snowy glade in the middle of the night with a dying torch and you’ll thank her for it should you not freeze to death first.
4.5/5 Stars
WGB Score: 95/100
Barrow of Winter by H.M. Long
Publisher: Titan Books
Nick’s Book Track: In the Woods Somewhere by Hozier
There is something profound about the way HM Long conjures such tangible atmosphere around so many incredibly three-dimensional characters. All three of her books in this series are so character driven but never sacrifice their strong sense of setting and environment. I grew up around the woods and mountains of New England and this world makes me home sick. I don’t think there has been another fantasy series that has gripped my heart in such a way and made me miss home with all five senses just through prose.
The Hall of Smoke world is a fully immersive sense of escapism for me and I know that may not be helpful to most who are reading this but I needed to record it. The crunch of snow underfoot and the taste of snow as it brushes past your face during a dusting. The smell of moss and tree bark and the way they feel in your hand or under your toes. That’s what it feels like to read Long’s prose. Her details aren’t just saved for the environment either, it’s during the scenes of combat or danger that you can really feel it too. The way ice feels in your hand when you’ve held it too long, almost hot and cutting. You’re right there with these characters as they struggle just to survive not just each other but the harsh lands they make their home in.
The plot for this entry follows Tray, daughter of Sixnit and Ogam, raised by Hessa, the lead protagonist from the first two books, as she grapples with who she is and what it means to be immortal. Asking herself the difficult question of this: is it worth building a life and a family with mortals when in the end you will have to watch them grow old and die? This story feels more introspective than the previous two. Leaning heavier on Tray and her ties to the Eangi and her connection to the sons and daughters of winter. Essentially demigods whom she is introduced to and forced to confront her worst fears about her mortal family and must decide if these blood ties are stronger than those bonds forged with the family she made herself. This is adult fantasy at it’s finest and it makes reading her work a great adventure and well-worth the sojourn into her worlds every time.
We get to see some familiar faces throughout that I won’t name here for fear of unintentionally spoiling the other two books but I will say that fans of the characters in the first two books will appreciate the appearances. Completely unrelated, I love how empowering Long’s female characters are and without the need to put down the male characters and vice versa. I also appreciate the body positivity and subtle bisexual rep in Barrow of Winter. I wasn’t expecting it and I found it refreshing and a great step forward from some of the other norse-flavored fantasy I’ve read and seen recently. I don’t want to say too much about the supporting characters, but, for those who have read it or are about to, I was unsure about Thray’s half siblings and despite not trusting the lot of them, I still found myself drawn to and won over by Arune. I even enjoyed Kyga and Siru, despite how they treated Thray in the end. I found these characters to all feel like they had weight to them more than just cut-outs so that the lead could stand out. They all made Thray stand out because of the depth Long gave them and the emotion and personality she poured into them. Just, a breath of fresh winter air.
I loved Thray’s weapon too. Reminded me of a trick weapon you’d see in Bloodborne (game) or Castlevania (Netflix) and I liked that Long didn’t make it into a gimmick either. It came in handy but did not make it’s wielder invincible either. Though she did wield it with precious and confidence. I absolutely loved how confident Thray was, despite her naivety, she is such a fully-realized character and this was something I was worried about not being the case once I’d learned that Tessa would not be the main character in BoW. She was brilliantly crafted and totally and unapologetically herself, just like her aunt.
The creatures stood out in this one too. Maybe it’s because I had been playing God of War Ragnarök while reading this but I could’t help but love the Savn. They really stood out to me and I hope we see more of them. I was constantly aware of what their presence would be like and how their fur would feel and smell and it made them, again, tangible, in my minds eye but to my other senses too while reading. If you haven’t figured this out already, this book, Long’s prose, is a snowed-capped gift for those who like immersive and atmospheric reads.
Barrow of Winter comes to an end with a crash like two sheets of ice colliding on water. There is a lot going on and it feels like you’re thrust into the thick of it, into the mist and snow-blind of it all. It made for an excellent seasonal read and, while it still would be just as good if read in the summer, it still emanates with cozy (and harsh) winter vibes. You will undoubtedly feel cold while reading this so dress in layers or pull on some thick socks and a scratchy but comforting wool blanket. H.M. Long’s latest will transport you into a snowy glade in the middle of the night with a dying torch and you’ll thank her for it should you not freeze to death first.
4.5/5 Stars
WGB Score: 95/100
January 25, 2023
This is the 3rd book in the Hall of Smoke series. The world build-up in the complete series is great and meets up to the standards of epic fantasy. However, before jumping into this one, would recommend my readers to read the other 2 books as this one can't be picked up as a standalone.
I was rooting for the main protagonist to succeed, but I found her actions quite confusing as we move along with the story. I feel that to fully appreciate the author's work the series needs to be read one after another without much gap in the story to enjoy it to the fullest. Because I read the other parts a long time back and had some memory holes around the story.
Overall a decent read, but I still like the first part better.
Genre: #epicfantasy #fantasy #adult
Rating: 3/5 ⭐️
Thankyou @netgalley @hmlongbooks for the Digital ARC
I was rooting for the main protagonist to succeed, but I found her actions quite confusing as we move along with the story. I feel that to fully appreciate the author's work the series needs to be read one after another without much gap in the story to enjoy it to the fullest. Because I read the other parts a long time back and had some memory holes around the story.
Overall a decent read, but I still like the first part better.
Genre: #epicfantasy #fantasy #adult
Rating: 3/5 ⭐️
Thankyou @netgalley @hmlongbooks for the Digital ARC
November 5, 2022
I loved Barrow of Winter. The world building was top notch, but honestly it was Thray and her journey that stuck with me.
In the beginning I did not like her, because she was making bad decisions I couldn't quite understand, but by the end I loved everything about her and her journey. She's such a good heroine!
And HM Long, your plotting and how you know how to move your reader along is truly impeccable. I can't give more detail without spoilers, but that 66% mark was truly outstanding - both inevitable and totally surprising.
Definitely check this book out when it comes out.
In the beginning I did not like her, because she was making bad decisions I couldn't quite understand, but by the end I loved everything about her and her journey. She's such a good heroine!
And HM Long, your plotting and how you know how to move your reader along is truly impeccable. I can't give more detail without spoilers, but that 66% mark was truly outstanding - both inevitable and totally surprising.
Definitely check this book out when it comes out.
April 28, 2023
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an e-arc.
3.5 stars. I enjoyed the previous two books in this world, particularly for HM Longs wonderfully descriptive and atmospheric writing. This was still present in this book, but unfortunately I struggled a bit more with this one.
For me, it took almost to 60/70% to feel like anything happened , however after that it was fast paced and interesting I just would have liked to feel more invested a bit sooner.
The main character Thray, the daughter of Sixnit and Ogam, was a step away from Hessa the usual main character. I admired certain qualities in her but mostly it was hard to feel connected and to like her.
I did enjoy the immersive world and seeing some familiar characters, and this did have a dark undertone and takes you on an adventure. The ending as well is particularly emotional and beautiful in its own way.
If you liked the previous instalments of this series I would recommend and I'll continue reading the series.
3.5 stars. I enjoyed the previous two books in this world, particularly for HM Longs wonderfully descriptive and atmospheric writing. This was still present in this book, but unfortunately I struggled a bit more with this one.
For me, it took almost to 60/70% to feel like anything happened , however after that it was fast paced and interesting I just would have liked to feel more invested a bit sooner.
The main character Thray, the daughter of Sixnit and Ogam, was a step away from Hessa the usual main character. I admired certain qualities in her but mostly it was hard to feel connected and to like her.
I did enjoy the immersive world and seeing some familiar characters, and this did have a dark undertone and takes you on an adventure. The ending as well is particularly emotional and beautiful in its own way.
If you liked the previous instalments of this series I would recommend and I'll continue reading the series.
January 17, 2023
Just posted my quick, spoiler-free video on YouTube here: https://youtu.be/wrakc3UIU4E
This was the perfect wintry read for the turn of a brand new year.
The third novel in the Hall of Smoke series reads as the start of a new duology, and follows Thray, the niece of Hessa (the protagonist from books 1 and 2), who is the last daughter of Winter whose legacy lies in ruin due to his treachery earlier in the series.
As it's been 2 years since I read Hall of Smoke, and a year since I read Temple of No God, some of the events and details were growing a bit hazy, but Long was able to work in the important things in a way that felt organic and not info-dumpy at all—I really appreciated how she managed to sprinkle in context from the conflict with the Old Gods and who specific people were. It helped ease me into Thray's world where she is a grown woman, facing her own challenges and having her own questions about her identity and place in the world.
We get to see Hessa and Uspa and Nui, as well as Gadr and others I grew to love in the first books, which is a treat. And I really appreciated the complex familial themes this third installment grapples with. Thray exists within the question of whether she has inherited any of her father's immortality, and she is scared of finding out the answer. To learn it has the potential to upend everything she has built for herself—her home, her friendships, her priesthood, her marriage to Havar. The latter left me with an ache in my chest for how things turned out. Maybe we'll get to see more in Hall of Smoke 4??
Apart from the themes and characters, the action scenes are awesome, too. I have loved Long's depictions of flawed yet powerful women, and the manifestation of scream power is so much fun. There are also huge bear-wolf creatures, enormous sea serpents, frigid winterscapes, a land of eternal night, enchanted weapons, shield surfing (or sledding). Reading Barrow of Winter offers a few days to explore a bone-cold northern wilderness, take in its northern lights, stay the night in forlorn tombs, and learn whether family is an obligation bound by blood or something other.
It's hard for me to pick which book is my favorite so far—I've loved all for their own themes and contained stories.
Really looking forward to book 4!
This was the perfect wintry read for the turn of a brand new year.
The third novel in the Hall of Smoke series reads as the start of a new duology, and follows Thray, the niece of Hessa (the protagonist from books 1 and 2), who is the last daughter of Winter whose legacy lies in ruin due to his treachery earlier in the series.
As it's been 2 years since I read Hall of Smoke, and a year since I read Temple of No God, some of the events and details were growing a bit hazy, but Long was able to work in the important things in a way that felt organic and not info-dumpy at all—I really appreciated how she managed to sprinkle in context from the conflict with the Old Gods and who specific people were. It helped ease me into Thray's world where she is a grown woman, facing her own challenges and having her own questions about her identity and place in the world.
We get to see Hessa and Uspa and Nui, as well as Gadr and others I grew to love in the first books, which is a treat. And I really appreciated the complex familial themes this third installment grapples with. Thray exists within the question of whether she has inherited any of her father's immortality, and she is scared of finding out the answer. To learn it has the potential to upend everything she has built for herself—her home, her friendships, her priesthood, her marriage to Havar. The latter left me with an ache in my chest for how things turned out. Maybe we'll get to see more in Hall of Smoke 4??
Apart from the themes and characters, the action scenes are awesome, too. I have loved Long's depictions of flawed yet powerful women, and the manifestation of scream power is so much fun. There are also huge bear-wolf creatures, enormous sea serpents, frigid winterscapes, a land of eternal night, enchanted weapons, shield surfing (or sledding). Reading Barrow of Winter offers a few days to explore a bone-cold northern wilderness, take in its northern lights, stay the night in forlorn tombs, and learn whether family is an obligation bound by blood or something other.
It's hard for me to pick which book is my favorite so far—I've loved all for their own themes and contained stories.
Really looking forward to book 4!
Read
November 30, 2022"A world so vividly rendered you'll feel the ice on the pages"
July 25, 2023
Sharp as the winter wind, Barrow of Winter grabbed my attention and wouldn’t let go. Long’s latest is a compelling portrait of a woman coming to know herself—woven through with betrayal, darkness, thunderingly epic stakes, and a cast of prickly immortals I couldn’t get enough of. It’s fantasy at its very best.
January 18, 2023
Barrow of Winter is the third book in the Hall of Smoke series. It follows Thray, a priestess who is plagued by the question of if she is immortal or not. When her half-sister arrives on her shores and promises answers, Thray is intrigued and sets out on an epic journey to discover the truth about her immortality. In Barrow of Winter, Thray meets siblings she never knew she had, tests the strength of her current relationships, and discovers hidden strengths. But how far will she go for her blood family when they set their sights on her homeland?
I loved Barrow of Winter!! H.M. Long paints a vivid picture of an unforgiving & eternal winter. This is a world filled with dangers that feel tangible. Thray is a fascinating character to watch on her challenging journey to find answers. All the senses are engaged from the sting of cold ice to the cloying smoke of a fire. Thray is determined that she will never stop fighting for her homeland, bound by blood or not.
H.M. Long writes thoughtfully about both blood and found family, as well as what it means to find people who understand you. My favorite side characters were Thray’s brothers who look out for her as she encounters siblings who are less welcoming. The conclusion felt a bit rushed to me, but I also just wanted to spend more time in the world.
If you love Viking-inspired fantasy, secrets laced with betrayal, and epic quests then you need to read Barrow of Winter! Barrow of Winter could be read as a standalone, but you will have much more context if you have read the first two books in the series. I would recommend this for readers of Adrienne Young, Shea Ernshaw, and Meg Long. I look forward to reading what H.M. Long writes next!!
Thank you to H.M. Long and Titan Books for a free ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I loved Barrow of Winter!! H.M. Long paints a vivid picture of an unforgiving & eternal winter. This is a world filled with dangers that feel tangible. Thray is a fascinating character to watch on her challenging journey to find answers. All the senses are engaged from the sting of cold ice to the cloying smoke of a fire. Thray is determined that she will never stop fighting for her homeland, bound by blood or not.
H.M. Long writes thoughtfully about both blood and found family, as well as what it means to find people who understand you. My favorite side characters were Thray’s brothers who look out for her as she encounters siblings who are less welcoming. The conclusion felt a bit rushed to me, but I also just wanted to spend more time in the world.
If you love Viking-inspired fantasy, secrets laced with betrayal, and epic quests then you need to read Barrow of Winter! Barrow of Winter could be read as a standalone, but you will have much more context if you have read the first two books in the series. I would recommend this for readers of Adrienne Young, Shea Ernshaw, and Meg Long. I look forward to reading what H.M. Long writes next!!
Thank you to H.M. Long and Titan Books for a free ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 19, 2025
4.5 ⭐
I have not felt this emotional over a book's conclusion in a long time. I am so....... devastated? But also warm in my heart? Wrecked in both a good and a bad way?
Long has done something remarkable here. The main character in books 1 and 2 is a classic heroine: noble, grieving, driven. This book's main, Thray, is traumatized and so flawed. Her actions are infuriating at the same time that her motivations are unnervingly relatable. It really is a complicated and fascinating experience. And as in the other two books, the romantic subplot (if you can call it that) dodges your expectations completely. I loved being so far from the typical fantasy formula throughout Thray's journey.
Long's writing deserves more publicity. I love this series. Complex character work, vivid Norse/Celtic imagery, duplicitous gods and layers of lore. I highly recommend the audiobook - Samara Naeymi is insanely talented. I do not recommend reading this book as a standalone, however. There is too much relevant detail from previous books.
Finally: if [redacted] doesn't find someone to love him back in book 4, I am going to 1) scream, and 2) write a fanfic. I am not a writer and it will be terrible. You have been warned.
I have not felt this emotional over a book's conclusion in a long time. I am so....... devastated? But also warm in my heart? Wrecked in both a good and a bad way?
Long has done something remarkable here. The main character in books 1 and 2 is a classic heroine: noble, grieving, driven. This book's main, Thray, is traumatized and so flawed. Her actions are infuriating at the same time that her motivations are unnervingly relatable. It really is a complicated and fascinating experience. And as in the other two books, the romantic subplot (if you can call it that) dodges your expectations completely. I loved being so far from the typical fantasy formula throughout Thray's journey.
Long's writing deserves more publicity. I love this series. Complex character work, vivid Norse/Celtic imagery, duplicitous gods and layers of lore. I highly recommend the audiobook - Samara Naeymi is insanely talented. I do not recommend reading this book as a standalone, however. There is too much relevant detail from previous books.
Finally: if [redacted] doesn't find someone to love him back in book 4, I am going to 1) scream, and 2) write a fanfic. I am not a writer and it will be terrible. You have been warned.
September 17, 2023
Barrow of Winter is the third of H. M. Long's The Four Pillars novels, and the first to move past Hessa as the focal point--although everyone's favourite axe-wielding priestess does appear in a brief supporting role.
Our main protagonist is Thray, Hessa's niece. She's a less battle-driven but equally intense character whose journey is more interior, particularly in the first section of the book. A child of mortals and gods, she has a lot of understandable questions about who she is and how she fits into her world's complex pantheon.
Long excels at combining landscape imagery with a character's emotional life, and Thray's journey into vastness and increasing isolation matches well with the icy imagery in this novel. I enjoyed it and the ways in which Long doesn't pull punches about her characters' choices and the fallout stemming from them.
There is also one straight-up joyful scene that reminds me of a very memorable moment in Willow in the best of ways.
You could read this book standalone, but you'd be losing so much--about Hessa, about the High Halls, and the considerable god lore Long has built--that it would be a real shame to start your journey here.
Our main protagonist is Thray, Hessa's niece. She's a less battle-driven but equally intense character whose journey is more interior, particularly in the first section of the book. A child of mortals and gods, she has a lot of understandable questions about who she is and how she fits into her world's complex pantheon.
Long excels at combining landscape imagery with a character's emotional life, and Thray's journey into vastness and increasing isolation matches well with the icy imagery in this novel. I enjoyed it and the ways in which Long doesn't pull punches about her characters' choices and the fallout stemming from them.
There is also one straight-up joyful scene that reminds me of a very memorable moment in Willow in the best of ways.
You could read this book standalone, but you'd be losing so much--about Hessa, about the High Halls, and the considerable god lore Long has built--that it would be a real shame to start your journey here.
January 17, 2023
Thray is the last Daughter of Winter, haunted by the legacy of her blood. When she is offered a chance to go to Duamel, the land her father once ruled, she can’t refuse, even if it means lying to the man she loves and the priesthood she serves.
In Duamel, Thray’s half-siblings rule under the northern lights. An endless winter night cloaks the land, with the people of Duamel teetering on the edge of violence. When Thray’s siblings turn their attention towards the warm, brighter land she calls home, she must harness her own feral power and decide where her loyalties lie.
Wow! I am a huge fan of Hannah’s books and Barrow of Winter is her phenomenal third published novel. This book literally had me on the edge of my seat from the very first line. Packed full of adventure, terrifying creatures, Old gods versus young half-gods, magic, savage battle scenes and a protagonist who struggles to choose between the two sides of her family, Barrow of Winter has it all.
Hannah’s beautifully descriptive style propels you into this world and although it is a standalone novel, I would highly recommend you read her debut Hall of Smoke and also Temple of No God to see Hannah’s world-building ability.
Thray is another fierce female protagonist by Hannah (she ties with Hessa as my favourite characters in the world of the Eangi) and Hannah excels at giving her readers well-rounded and thoroughly fleshed out protagonists.
Fast-paced with an epic conclusion that was absolute perfection, Barrow of Winter is the perfect adult fantasy read for fans of John Gwynne, Margaret Owen and V.E Schwab.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Barrow of Winter is out now! Thanks to NetGalley and Titan Books for the arc.
In Duamel, Thray’s half-siblings rule under the northern lights. An endless winter night cloaks the land, with the people of Duamel teetering on the edge of violence. When Thray’s siblings turn their attention towards the warm, brighter land she calls home, she must harness her own feral power and decide where her loyalties lie.
Wow! I am a huge fan of Hannah’s books and Barrow of Winter is her phenomenal third published novel. This book literally had me on the edge of my seat from the very first line. Packed full of adventure, terrifying creatures, Old gods versus young half-gods, magic, savage battle scenes and a protagonist who struggles to choose between the two sides of her family, Barrow of Winter has it all.
Hannah’s beautifully descriptive style propels you into this world and although it is a standalone novel, I would highly recommend you read her debut Hall of Smoke and also Temple of No God to see Hannah’s world-building ability.
Thray is another fierce female protagonist by Hannah (she ties with Hessa as my favourite characters in the world of the Eangi) and Hannah excels at giving her readers well-rounded and thoroughly fleshed out protagonists.
Fast-paced with an epic conclusion that was absolute perfection, Barrow of Winter is the perfect adult fantasy read for fans of John Gwynne, Margaret Owen and V.E Schwab.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Barrow of Winter is out now! Thanks to NetGalley and Titan Books for the arc.
February 4, 2023
Barrow of Winter by H. M. Long
Pub Date
Thank you to NetGalley and Titan Books for the arc.
All good fantasy books start with a map, so we are introduced to a map before the story. Thray our protagonists may be a demi-god. To find the truth, she has to sacrifice herself to come back alive. The wintery atmosphere was intensely intense and cinematic, the characters' journeys were emotionally charged, and the action was even more so. It has everything a fantasy novel should have: a highly complicated and expressive plot, corruptions, supernatural beings and sects, believable character relationships, mythical creatures, and more.
Pub Date
Thank you to NetGalley and Titan Books for the arc.
All good fantasy books start with a map, so we are introduced to a map before the story. Thray our protagonists may be a demi-god. To find the truth, she has to sacrifice herself to come back alive. The wintery atmosphere was intensely intense and cinematic, the characters' journeys were emotionally charged, and the action was even more so. It has everything a fantasy novel should have: a highly complicated and expressive plot, corruptions, supernatural beings and sects, believable character relationships, mythical creatures, and more.
January 24, 2023
A fun next instalment into the Hall of Smoke series offering an interesting new character and setting. A little too much questing for the pace but sets up what I believe is the final book in the series
Full review - https://www.runalongtheshelves.net/bl...
Full review - https://www.runalongtheshelves.net/bl...
May 4, 2023
A Canadian fantasy author is an automatic yes for me and HM Long did not disappoint. I enjoyed it so much. A true standalone, i received an arc and also listened to it on audio. The MC was unlikeable in the beginning but they grew on me. Have been recommending all over. SUPER pretty cover in real life too.
July 22, 2024
3.5 stars. Overall pretty good. I think I've just lost interest in this series.
January 27, 2023
4.5 stars
March 10, 2022
I'm so excited to read this! The title has completely captured my imagination <3
February 13, 2023
What stands out most is the atmosphere, the writings amazing! This is adult Adrienne Young. I love the winter Norse theme. This has very complicated lore and religion systems that while this can be read as a standalone I bet it is much more understandable if you read at least the first one, Hall of Smoke.
To me this is very character driven because while there is plot, the focus is on Thray's internal conflicts. I do think that H.M. Long kind of opted out of writing romance because she didn't want to. If she didn't want to write romance she should not have included a love interest and instead created a childhood friend that had growing pains with Thray. She also created tension and prolonged conflicts by saying a version of "I don't want to take about this right now" repeatedly.
It is hard to put into words but the relationships are weird. She is distant from the Egan, she pines for her siblings love in an almost creepy way, and there were great potential relationships that she threw away. That being said the Hessa relationship is top tier so maybe she just needed to edit down the character list.
I loved the writing, and the ending so much I recommend to any norse fantasy lover. H.M. Long is one to watch!
To me this is very character driven because while there is plot, the focus is on Thray's internal conflicts. I do think that H.M. Long kind of opted out of writing romance because she didn't want to. If she didn't want to write romance she should not have included a love interest and instead created a childhood friend that had growing pains with Thray. She also created tension and prolonged conflicts by saying a version of "I don't want to take about this right now" repeatedly.
It is hard to put into words but the relationships are weird. She is distant from the Egan, she pines for her siblings love in an almost creepy way, and there were great potential relationships that she threw away. That being said the Hessa relationship is top tier so maybe she just needed to edit down the character list.
I loved the writing, and the ending so much I recommend to any norse fantasy lover. H.M. Long is one to watch!
January 30, 2023
HM Long is one of those auto-buy authors for me. I am grateful to have received an ARC for the 3rd book of this series and will soon purchase a physical copy also.
The book was excellent. A true high fantasy adventure (I do not want to be near snow anytime soon!).
I was easily able to picture the surroundings, enjoyed the dialogue between characters and the pacing was set at the perfect pace for me. Easily one of my favorite fantasy reads since ACOTAR.
TYSM for the opportunity to read this ARC.
The book was excellent. A true high fantasy adventure (I do not want to be near snow anytime soon!).
I was easily able to picture the surroundings, enjoyed the dialogue between characters and the pacing was set at the perfect pace for me. Easily one of my favorite fantasy reads since ACOTAR.
TYSM for the opportunity to read this ARC.
January 28, 2023
I was a little too excited when I saw this on Netgalley and didn't realize it was third in a series. Luckily it can be read as a standalone. But I will definitely be going back to read the first two.
I really enjoyed the setting and the magic system. H.M. Long did a fantastic job. I was able to listen to an advanced copy of the audio book and also really liked the narrator Samara Naeymi.
I really enjoyed the setting and the magic system. H.M. Long did a fantastic job. I was able to listen to an advanced copy of the audio book and also really liked the narrator Samara Naeymi.
June 26, 2023
A tenderhearted, plot driven folklore tale with a strong female lead - perfect for fans of Katherine Arden's The Bear and the Nightingale for it's wintery atmospheric backdrop, and light magical elements. I listened to the audiobook under the covers to stay warm and cozy during this chilly adventure.
Our main character, Thray, reminds me of Madeline Miller's Circe in the best possible way. A woman stepping into her power, choosing her own path, and keeping us walking beside her on an uncertain journey to an unexpected, but satisfying ending.
I listened to the audiobook, and cannot speak highly enough of the art behind Samara Naeymi's voicing. There are many characters, both male and female, and each is given a distinct cadence, tone and pitch which brings the reader further into the story.
I follow H.M Long on TikTok and Instagram, because her content is on point and she often recommends other amazing fantasy, action and female-lead books. Find her @hmlongbooks.
#BarrowofWinter #NetGalley
Our main character, Thray, reminds me of Madeline Miller's Circe in the best possible way. A woman stepping into her power, choosing her own path, and keeping us walking beside her on an uncertain journey to an unexpected, but satisfying ending.
I listened to the audiobook, and cannot speak highly enough of the art behind Samara Naeymi's voicing. There are many characters, both male and female, and each is given a distinct cadence, tone and pitch which brings the reader further into the story.
I follow H.M Long on TikTok and Instagram, because her content is on point and she often recommends other amazing fantasy, action and female-lead books. Find her @hmlongbooks.
#BarrowofWinter #NetGalley
October 12, 2022
H. M. Long has done it again!
Barrow of Winter is possibly even more captivating and transportive than the gorgeous first two installments in the Hall of Smoke series.
This unputdownable tale features cinematic action, lush worldbuilding, and a conflicted main character who is deeply relatable despite her demigod status. Barrow of Winter offers all the action and adventure of high fantasy while also taking the time to offer deep, thoughtful exploration of the meanings of life and death, family and enmity.
Barrow of Winter is the perfect read for any reader looking for fascinating magic, adventurous heroines, and a fantasy world that feels real enough to book a plane ticket to visit.
tl;dr: preorder this book now :)
Barrow of Winter is possibly even more captivating and transportive than the gorgeous first two installments in the Hall of Smoke series.
This unputdownable tale features cinematic action, lush worldbuilding, and a conflicted main character who is deeply relatable despite her demigod status. Barrow of Winter offers all the action and adventure of high fantasy while also taking the time to offer deep, thoughtful exploration of the meanings of life and death, family and enmity.
Barrow of Winter is the perfect read for any reader looking for fascinating magic, adventurous heroines, and a fantasy world that feels real enough to book a plane ticket to visit.
tl;dr: preorder this book now :)
December 29, 2025
Thank you to Titan Books and Edelweiss for an ARC in exchange for this review!
This book follows Thray as she goes on a journey to learn what it means for her to be the daughter of a God.
This is the fourth H.M. Long book I have read and, sadly, it is my least favorite. The first two books in this series really built a beautiful, magical Nordic-inspired world, and this book felt so lacking in comparison. When Thray would have flashbacks, I would remember how much fantasy there was in the previous two books and would yearn for that. This felt like a meandering journey with no real goal, with a character who I didn't like. It was a struggle, and I missed Long's first two works.
This book follows Thray as she goes on a journey to learn what it means for her to be the daughter of a God.
This is the fourth H.M. Long book I have read and, sadly, it is my least favorite. The first two books in this series really built a beautiful, magical Nordic-inspired world, and this book felt so lacking in comparison. When Thray would have flashbacks, I would remember how much fantasy there was in the previous two books and would yearn for that. This felt like a meandering journey with no real goal, with a character who I didn't like. It was a struggle, and I missed Long's first two works.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 168 reviews