A reread to see if there was anything else in here I could try. Found even more mistakes, a cauliflower and rice dish that looks from the photos that cauliflower is the main ingredient doesn't even have cauliflower on the list of ingredients.
This was a really disappointing experience. After rereading the 5 star rave reviews I've noticed they all seem to thank the author for a free copy and they don't seem to have tried the recipes. I should have read more carefully. I paid £25.99 for my copy and was really excited to try these out after experiencing some amazing Vegan Nepalese food in York.
There is some nice photography in this book and although there aren't many recipes (35 I think, but several desserts, teas, salads, and dishes you wouldn't necessarily associate with Nepalese food like rice pudding and chips) so not many mains but I had high hopes for the ones that were included.
There are some basic mistakes with the recipes, steps are numbered and explained in detail- things like make sure the potatoes are washed well so you don't get any grit, but then nowhere in the recipe does it tell you to add fluids. I thought maybe this is a dry curry where you don't add any liquid, but in the tips it says to add some mashed beans or mashed potatoes to thicken up the gravy, so evidently at some point you were meant to add water. I thought this was an oversight for one recipe, but after trying over 10 recipes, I found that only one mentioned liquids.
All the recipes I tried used the same spices, this meant that all the dishes tasted very similar.
These recipes use US measurements, I was left confused by some of these, half a cup of coriander? How tightly do I pack it? How finely do I cut it? The amounts would vary widely according to your preparation. Recipes asked for small, medium, or large of each item, I would say a small tomato would be the size of a ping pong ball, but in some recipes a small tomato (the ingredients are pictured) was about twice the size of a whole bulb of garlic cloves, which would make the tomato at least the size of a large orange, if not bigger, that's not what I call small. What would a medium or large tomato be equivalent to, a small pumpkin? Each recipe talked of 3 or 4 slices of ginger, in my mind that is similar to how long is a piece of string?
Several of the recipes were very heavy on cumin, a dish that contained a cup of cooked beans used a teaspoon of cumin seeds and a tablespoon of ground cumin, that was quite a lot and left the dish with a bitter taste.
On the plus side these recipes were quite simple, they might be good with some tweaking but I was left wondering about this book, the author claims a list of other accomplishments and occupations which made me wonder how much work had gone in to refining these recipes and seeing of they actually work.