I would like to thank Netgalley and Headline for an advance copy of The Night Singer, the first novel to feature Detective Hanna Duncker of the Kalmar police.
Hanna has returned to the island of Öland, where she grew up and where her father, a police officer, committed murder, after years of working as a detective in Stockholm. On her first day as a detective in her new job she is asked to investigate the murder of her childhood best friend’s son, 15 year old Joel Forslund. It is an uncomfortable start in a difficult situation as not everyone welcomes Hannah’s return.
I can appreciate The Night Singer as a well crafted novel with an interesting plot that focuses as much on the characters as the murder enquiry, if not more so. Unfortunately I found it slow going and it didn’t hold my attention, so it took me days rather than hours to finish.
The narrative has a split timeline, the present day and Joel’s last day. The present time narrative is split between the investigation, mostly Hanna and her partner Erik, and Rebekka, Joel’s mum. It’s not confusing but it is distracting as it’s hard to get immersed in the read when it continually switches point of view. When the reader cuts through all this the plot offers a few surprises (I hesitate to call them twists), several suspects and an unusual in some ways, but age old in others, conclusion. I thought this latter was the best bit in the entire novel.
I’m not going to lie, I really don’t understand Hanna returning to the scene of her father’s crime. Surely returning to the worst time of her life can’t offer comfort? It does, however, set up the next novel or an ongoing thread, as she vows to investigate. She seems to be a good investigator but hers is a life half lived, she has no friends and no life outside her job, and frankly that is her fault as she has allowed her father and his crime to overshadow her life, make her socially self conscious and unwilling to engage. Rebekka is probably well drawn but I found her dreary and self pitying and groaned every time she made an appearance. It’s safe to say I didn’t find them appealing.
The Night Singer has things to offer, like strong characterisation and nuanced reactions to events, alongside a logical investigation, but it fell short for me.