I was going to wait a while to formulate a proper review with all my thoughts in order, but upon seeing so many negative reviews on the two Maracoor books I feel I owe it to Gregory Maguire to defend his honor a bit here.
Wicked is, and has always been, an incredibly particular piece of writing. You either get it or you don't, and if you make an earnest effort I believe you WILL get it. I first attempted to read Wicked when I was 18 and so much of it just read like gibberish to me because of Maguire's pompous and verbose writing style that sometimes seems to weave in archaic vocabulary for no other reason than to say it did, but every one of the Wicked books (particularly the first one) becomes richer and fuller with every subsequent re-reading. The first book, I feel, touches on every single aspect of the experience of living, something not many books can claim to have done.
Due to the unexpected success of the musical, Wicked became a quadrilogy, with two books in the middle that were a little bit of a slog but had bright moments, and a finale that I was genuinely surprised turned out to be so incredibly good, on par with the original honestly. I left Out of Oz feeling blown away and never thought we'd hear any more from Rain, so reading the first two Maracoor books was a treat in many ways, and only minorly tested my patience with the witty verbosity so common to Maguire's prose.
I think the Another Day series is ENTIRELY worth your time if you're a fan of the Wicked series, and it carries with it a new perspective that mirrors but is not the same as the original series. As well it makes sense to: Rain is the descendant of Elphaba, not Elphaba herself, and she is the new focal point of the story. Indeed a huge theme in the Maracoor books is about parents and children, about the differences, the bitterness, and the love between them. Rain left Oz bitter and heartbroken and Maracoor forces her to confront that heartbreak and try to make sense of it, and do something good in the meantime. The innocence of childhood and the loss therein is another big theme, with Cossy, Leorix, and the contentious relationship the two of them, along with Rain, all have with Lucikles, the only real adult in the room among the party. Iskinaary remains a standout favorite, he always had something pithy to say.
There are moments when Maguire's writing style will exhaust you, but there are also moments where his particular brand of witty stoicism and bitter reflection on the nature of existent leads to really profound insight on what the author is clearly trying to impart: the nature of growing up, of looking back on your own childhood and the childhood of the kids around you, be they your own or others, and trying to find meaning in a vast and seemingly indifferent world. Despite the veneer of aggrieved indifference toward the terrifying reality of life, there is meaning and hope to be plumbed within the pages of The Oracle of Maracoor. And also, it's fun to read about a world where everyone regardless of age, gender, or species, speak like an embittered drag queen smoking her last cigarette at 3am and making grand pronouncements about the futility of life. Like, where the hell else are you gonna find dialogue like this? I treasure it for it's uniqueness.
For me, The Bridges of Maracoor was a 3.5 stars that was closer to a 4 than a 3, so I rounded up. Here it's the same story in the opposite direction so I rounded down. My only real gripe with the story is that ultimately not much happened, up until the last 20% of the book which is when I got really invested and couldn't put it down (incidentally the same thing happened to me when reading Out Of Oz, although I suspect re-reading it now I'd find a lot more to chew on in the first half of the book).
My 20-year-old self would be positively outraged to hear me say this after slogging through what often felt like tediously long novels in the Wicked series, but I can't help but feel the Maracoor books didn't really NEED to be a trilogy, and that this tale could probably have all fit into one volume, or if the third book is to be incredibly lengthy then maybe it might have been a duology rather than a trilogy, but hey, I'm along for the ride. I was excited to see that the first book was announced and I grabbed it when it was on sale, and I was absolutely waiting for the second book and got it on the day it released, so I'll be happy to finish it when the third one releases in what I assume will be this time next year.
All in all, Gregory Maguire remains an incredibly unique voice in literature that I think the world would be a little duller without. The quirks that make his writing occasionally tedious or even infuriating are also what makes them so meaningful and provide such depth - but isn't that the way with every adult that has passed through blissfully ignorant childhood and into the crucible of adult life, from which one of us emerge unscathed? See what I did there that was the thing, anyway see you all in a year!