Don Camillo is a cultural Icon, and one very found Childhood Memory of mine.
Written by Giovanni Guareshi, is serves as a political Satire focussing on Themes of religion, patriotism, and politics from a anti Communist right-wing Perspective.
His Storys play around the cold war Ära, and reference the Politics of that Time.
The older I get im more and more in odds whit his Worldview, and want to express this Points, but my respect for Camillo as a cult Figur, and positive Childhood Memory is not gone yet.
Therefore I am under a bit of pressure, to give the Story the Justice it deserves.
Something undeniable no matter which political, and moral Spectrum your on is Guareshis great talent as Storyteller. For him the Region itselfe is the most important Charakter of all, and all Figures in his Books are formed by it. By living, and by growing up in that Envioument.
He knows how to create real, living, breading People, while grabbing your Attention whit his Plots.
As a deeply conservative, and religious Man, daily Prayer, and the Sunday walk to Church is a natural Part of everyones live, and God is in the constant Mind of all Charakters, at all Times.
If someone denys good, its not because they are non Belifers, its an act of defiance.
While he loves, and straight up idealizes his Home, he despises the big City, and everyone who comes from there. There charakterized as loude, unfriendly, decadent, and boastfull.
The Story itselfe plays at the Cold war Ära, in the late years of Stalins Life, and years after his Death.
Im no political Historican, and cant tell you how the political Climate was at the Time, certainly not the Itanian one.
From what I gateered whit a short research, the Country was heavily devided by Communists, and pro Republic right Wingers, and as such the small little Village Brescello serves as Microcosmos of the conflict outside.
Lets talk about the Main Dynamic itselfe.
The Story, and later especially the Movies claim, the two Main Charakters, Don Camillo, and Peppone are very different in there Ideals, but ultimatically want the best for there little Town.
This is somewhat correct, but most of the Time, there more focused in making the other ones Life miserable.
In other Storys, actions from one Side are absolutely correct, and aknowledged as such by the other Side, but the other Side got mearly envious of the attention, and respect, and wants its Part of the Cake.
Its easy to see Don Camillo as just this Bud Spencer light harded Comedy whit all the Violence beeing purely humoristic. Thats certainly the best approach for enjoying the Books.
But as a Political Satire, its more important to look beyond that, and analyze the Intention.
Right wing conservatives have a History of glorifying, or trivializing violence.
In America, Prison Slavery, or solidary Confinement are justified, cause Prisoners souldnt have human rights, and its a Punishment after all.
The German Nazi Jugend, and many Conversion Therapy Camps motivated little Children to go into fights, to taffen up. Making them into Man, or beating the Gay out of them.
Therefore I cant just overlook how the Book Series just pretents there wouldnt be any consequences to violence.
Non expectingly Woman have a pretty big Role in the Franchise, from an old Teacher, multible young Girls who get engaged, a Translator, to the Mayors Wife.
While there having a whide variety of different, and well developed Personalitys, and roles, there still Woman. Besides Political Activists, and a Teacher, there mainly Housewifes, or work towards becomming one.
Significantly worse is the depiction of Minoritys, and Queer People.
Besides the Russians in Comerate Don Camillo, who whit one exception are all confined whithin there own Borders, I cant emember one single example of any Foreigner, or Gay Person in any of the four Storys I read, or the Movies.
(Probably for the Best)
The Communist Party of Peppone is basicly a Tanky Party.
Hes a big Fan of Lenin, and Stalin, but belifes truely in the Communist Dream.
Peppone glorifies Stalin as a strong autoritarian, despite him not reflecting Peppones actual Ideals.
Under Peppone, the KPI supports modern Ideals like Polyamorism, and Atheism, but is depicted as disshonest, and hypocritical.
Non of Peppones Staff is truely an Atheist, and most of them attent the Church each Week, but because of the Vaticans Action to excommunicate all Communist, and because of the lack of any strong opposition-Party in Town, they see the Church as the next biggest Enemy, and try to distance themselfe from God, out of principal as much as possible.
Im not sure how real Communists thought of the Church, nowadays its hard to immagine them going after Religion diectly.
Did the Communists of that Time truely see the katholic Church as an Enemy, and fought them?
Maybe its just the paranoia of a deeply religious Man, spoting People proposing Ideas contradicting religious Norms, and seeing it as an aimed Attack on his Belifes.
I follow religious Debates, and debates whit Appologetics, and as such reconize a few similaritys, but I cant say for sure.
While having some darker Chapters here and there, most Don Camillo Storys are very light hearted.
This makes it just the more confusing how incredible Dark this Book gets.
It feels straight up depressing at Times, and the corruption of certain Charakters isnt played for laughts anymore.
In "the spell of Fear breaks" the murder Case of Pizzi is closed. In a burst of Fear, the Murderer attacked Pizzis House, and tried to murder his Child, the only witness. Gets shot to death in selfe Defense.
Inn"The Ring" an old Major, and his Wife are getting murdered. The Murderer try to replace them, by buying the Support of the Communist Clan. Later get discovered by burrowing out the Ring of the old Madame.
In "The Innocent" a old homeless Man whit his little Pet Bird requests a holy mass for the former King, leading into him beeing beaten up by anti royalist Woman of the Communist Party, his little Birdy gets stepped on, and dies in the Process.
There seemns to be a shift in the writing Style as well. Many of this little Storys seemn to be alegorys.
"Madonna Bruta", and "the Ring" feel less like Events, and more like visualisations of Ideas, or political Events. Sadly I miss the Context to make sense of most of them.
I wonder if Guareshi was in a depressive Phase back then. He once lamented in one of his Books, how more and more of his Friends adapted to the Change in Time, ...and how more and more People got accepting towards Black Folks -.-
In this very specific Case, I decided to copy the main Bulk of the Review, and adjust a few Paragraphs for the respective Book.