I have some mixed opinions about this book. Some good, some not so great. To start, I heard about this book through C.S. Pacat's social media and loved the cover! I mean look at it! Stunning art and all round amazing colours. And it really captures the setting of the book regardless of the time periods.
To start, I think the author lay a great foundation. Talking about culture within Australia, names that are hard to pronounce and the development of publishing within Australia. It took me a while to realise that the two male perspectives were not only different time periods, but also the father and son. I was a little confused at the beginning about how these two were going to link up but once it clicked I loved that! I wish there was a little more time period information sprinkled in at the start though, as the father's perspective felt extremely modern and I didn't feel like it was meant to be earlier in time.
I found the father's perspective FAR more interesting than his son's. When I think about the character development, the son didn't really do much for the whole story, while we get a beginning, middle and end for the father.
I also thought that the plot had ups and downs. Talking about a condition like dementia in a book can be a little difficult to discuss, but I think the author did it really well. To me, that storyline was very interesting and the reactions of the family. Other pros in the plot included the father having his first book launch, trying and failing to be published again and again and the discussion of younger authors having priority in the field, and how people can give too much of themselves in a relationship.
I really like that it was different from most things on shelves at the moment. I don't even know if I can actually compare this book to anything on the Australian market currently. While it talks about race and culture well, it's not done from a victim perspective. As someone with a hard to spell and pronounce name, I understand the frustration, and while it's brought up and discussed, it isn't complained about for 200 pages and fingers aren't pointed to specific groups of people. I've found people of all races and backgrounds struggle with my name so I'm glad they weren't trying to finger point because it's so frustrating.
I also liked the use of language like proyiayia. As someone who isn't Greek, it was nice to learn some new words and add them to my lexicon. Now I know what this means and it excites me a lot! I don't have many Greek friends so I haven't been as exposed to the language so it was great to pick some things up along the way!
Some of the cons included the fact that the plot didn't really go anywhere. While it was very 'slice of life', I found that I had no reason to re-read the book ever again. There's no romance story, there's no moment of triumph for any of the characters, and there's no real climax to the story. It's just a "and this happened and then this and the end". While the story was nice and relaxing to read, there's just no reason for me to think about it or have it on a re-read list later on. I feel like it could have benefitted from the father earning another publishing deal to seal off that ending so at least something happened. But alas. Also, the whole "my dads are breaking up" was a bit dull. It was interesting at the start of the story, and grew in interest as we learned their back story, but by the end of the book when you realised it's literally going no where it ended up feeling overplayed and boring. It also made me absolutely hate Sotiris in the modern era. He was so much fun to read about from his perspective in the past, but seeing him be nasty and obsessing over himself and his stories made me just disappointed. And the whole grindr thing? Super gross to do.
Harvey was a dull perspective. He likes a boy. He likes a girl. Then he likes a boy again. And then... that's really his whole personality explained. He doesn't want to go to school, works some shifts at the cafe, and then never really comes to any realisations or development.
Overall, while I enjoyed this book as a relaxing, light-hearted read and I liked that it was different from most things on the market, I also found it lacked substance and intrigue. A good book makes you want to re-read it, a bad book makes you want to throw it, but a dull book just makes you shrug and put it at the bottom of your bookshelf until you eventually forget all about it.
However, I will pick up books by this author in the future if they look like they feature a bit more plot.