What do you think?
Rate this book
Her Pretend Courtship
Her real Amish love
Their Unpredictable Path by Jocelyn McClay
Despite pressure from his parents, shy stuttering widower Jethro Weaver does not want to remarry and has hatched the perfect plan—a fake courtship with an unsuitable partner. His senior by a decade, widow Susannah Mast has had enough of unwanted suitors and reluctantly agrees to Jethro’s scheme. But what happens when their fake relationship turns into something real?
An Unlikely Amish Match by Vannetta Chapman
Susannah Beiler is determined to protect the other young marriageable Amish women from falling for the new bad boy in town by pretending to date Micah Fisher herself! Their deal is she’ll keep him company if he stays away from her friends. It’s not long before she starts to see there’s more to Micah than his reputation…
USA TODAY Bestselling Author Vannetta Chapman
2 Uplifting Stories Their Unpredictable Path and An Unlikely Amish Match
Their Unpredictable Path by Jocelyn McClay
Despite pressure from his parents, shy stuttering widower Jethro Weaver does not want to remarry and has hatched the perfect plan—a fake courtship with an unsuitable partner. His senior by a decade, widow Susannah Mast has had enough of unwanted suitors and reluctantly agrees to Jethro’s scheme. But what happens when their fake relationship turns into something real?
An Unlikely Amish Match by Vannetta Chapman
Susannah Beiler is determined to protect the other young marriageable Amish women from falling for the new bad boy in town by pretending to date Micah Fisher herself! Their deal is she’ll keep him company if he stays away from her friends. It’s not long before she starts to see there’s more to Micah than his reputation…
USA TODAY Bestselling Author Vannetta Chapman
2 Uplifting Stories Their Unpredictable Path and An Unlikely Amish Match
448 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Published April 25, 2023
About the author
Jocelyn McClay
35 books125 followersNew York Times and Publisher's Weekly bestselling author Jocelyn McClay grew up on an Iowa farm, ultimately pursuing a degree in agriculture. She met her husband while weightlifting in a small town - he 'spotted her'. After thirty years in business management, they moved to an acreage in southeastern Missouri to be closer to family when their oldest of three daughters made them grandparents. When not writing, she keeps busy grandparenting, hiking, biking gardening, quilting, knitting and substitute teaching.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
May 7, 2023
Their Unpredictable Path by Jocelyn McClay
This was my first book by this author and I was impressed by the enjoyable storyline and the story engaged me from the very first page. It was a really sweet story with two people who created a pretend relationship to avoid the "attentions" of family, and other "well-intentions friends who want them both to find a suitable match. It is a really enjoyable story and I like the author's style and definitely want to read her books.
Together these two books make a great combo! You will love both stories!
An Unlikely Amish Match by Vannetta Chapman:
Susannah Beiler has decided to protect the other young Amish women from Micah Fisher. He is definitely not your model Amish man and Susanna decides that the other women won't seek after him if she decides to date him herself.
This was a really good book and has lots of touching and tender moments in it. And there was humor as well. It was one of those reads that you decide to read in one sitting because you don't want to stop reading. Micah was a lovable character even though he doesn't always abide by the strict Amish rules and regulations. There are some surprising twists in the story and the characters grow and learn about themselves and others. Kind of like we do! I enjoyed this story very much.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from an author. All thoughts are my own.
This was my first book by this author and I was impressed by the enjoyable storyline and the story engaged me from the very first page. It was a really sweet story with two people who created a pretend relationship to avoid the "attentions" of family, and other "well-intentions friends who want them both to find a suitable match. It is a really enjoyable story and I like the author's style and definitely want to read her books.
Together these two books make a great combo! You will love both stories!
An Unlikely Amish Match by Vannetta Chapman:
Susannah Beiler has decided to protect the other young Amish women from Micah Fisher. He is definitely not your model Amish man and Susanna decides that the other women won't seek after him if she decides to date him herself.
This was a really good book and has lots of touching and tender moments in it. And there was humor as well. It was one of those reads that you decide to read in one sitting because you don't want to stop reading. Micah was a lovable character even though he doesn't always abide by the strict Amish rules and regulations. There are some surprising twists in the story and the characters grow and learn about themselves and others. Kind of like we do! I enjoyed this story very much.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from an author. All thoughts are my own.
June 20, 2023
Her Pretend Courtship by Jocelyn McClay and Vannetta contains two enjoyable Amish stories. Their Unpredictable Path by Jocelyn McClay is a cute story that features two kind people. I enjoyed following the “pretend” courtship of Susannah Mast and Jethro Weaver. I could understand why Susannah and Jethro wanted to escape the pressure being put on them by the bishop (and Jethro’s mother) to marry. I like the author’s friendly writing style. I finished this story with a smile on my face. An Unlikely Amish Match by Vannetta Chapman is a touching tale. It is the fifth book in the Indiana Amish Brides series, but it can easily be read as a standalone. Micah and Susannah are complete opposites which leads to some humorous and playful moments. There are also some tender scenes that will touch your heart. I like how faith is incorporated into the story. Also, we see that each day is precious, and we should not waste a moment. I like Vannetta Chapman’s engaging writing style. I was quickly drawn into An Unlikely Amish Match. Her Pretend Courtship has two uplifting stories with pushy parents, strategic matchmaking, a troubled teen, a stubborn grandfather, an earnest maidel, and surprising situations.
April 30, 2023
A Great Double Hitter
This is one great double hitter! Each involves two people that are so unlike each other that you are left thinking, "There is absolutely no way these two will come together." And that is just exactly what makes each story so great.
Author Jocelyn McClay has brought together Susannah Mast and Jethro Weaver in a sweet, tug at your heart story. (Jethro won me over right from the start.)
Their Unpredictable Path - Book Quote:
"Everyone seems t-to have an opinion on what is gut for m-me. Like I'm incapable of d-dealing for m-myself." His voice was hoarse. Jethro swallowed against the ache in his throat. "I thought you were gut for m-me. B-but apparently I'm not gut for you. Or m-maybe just not gut enough."
Vannetta Chapman has brought together Susannah Beiler and Micah Fisher in a sweet and wonderful story of love, mystery, forgiveness, tenderness, sadness, joy, hope and faith. It will draw you in from the start, keep you hooked, and leave you with a feeling of contentment and a smile on your face.
This double hitter is definitely a read you won’t want to miss.
This is one great double hitter! Each involves two people that are so unlike each other that you are left thinking, "There is absolutely no way these two will come together." And that is just exactly what makes each story so great.
Author Jocelyn McClay has brought together Susannah Mast and Jethro Weaver in a sweet, tug at your heart story. (Jethro won me over right from the start.)
Their Unpredictable Path - Book Quote:
"Everyone seems t-to have an opinion on what is gut for m-me. Like I'm incapable of d-dealing for m-myself." His voice was hoarse. Jethro swallowed against the ache in his throat. "I thought you were gut for m-me. B-but apparently I'm not gut for you. Or m-maybe just not gut enough."
Vannetta Chapman has brought together Susannah Beiler and Micah Fisher in a sweet and wonderful story of love, mystery, forgiveness, tenderness, sadness, joy, hope and faith. It will draw you in from the start, keep you hooked, and leave you with a feeling of contentment and a smile on your face.
This double hitter is definitely a read you won’t want to miss.
June 10, 2023
Both of these stories feature couples who form a partnership of pretense but end up with more than they bargained for. The novels are well-written and sweep readers up into the drama. The characters make you care about them and what happens—they seem so real. You can’t help but long for everything to turn out well in these endearing tales. I received a copy from the author. All opinions are my own.
March 8, 2024
It’s always special to read an Amish Loved Inspired romance and extra special when you get two in one book! Two of my favorite authors joined together to share two wonderful stories.
What you think is going to happen always changes when the heart takes over. Both stories made me feel good and enjoying page after page. I feel in love with the characters and I most definitely feel it deserves all five stars!
What you think is going to happen always changes when the heart takes over. Both stories made me feel good and enjoying page after page. I feel in love with the characters and I most definitely feel it deserves all five stars!
May 9, 2023
Sweet stories of determination, love, and faith. I enjoy reading stories about the Amish people and their way of life. I received a complimentary copy of the book. No review was required.
October 7, 2023
Great stories
April 16, 2024
Superbly written. This book proves that age doesn't matter when the heart is involved.
January 22, 2026
two amazing stories they were very intense and loved.
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews