What do you think?
Rate this book
Cedar Point #3
The Problem with Perfect
Bellamy Mitchell is a meticulous planner. When her old flame returns to Cedar Point engaged, blowing apart her vision for the future, she claims to have a serious boyfriend. The problem? The first single guy she can think of is her brother’s much older, closed-off best friend.
Rusty Fuller likes to keep people at a distance. He’s been through enough to know that letting anyone too close is a mistake, unless it’s only for a little fun. What he definitely doesn’t need is his best friend’s little sister turning him into anyone’s boyfriend, especially her own.
For some reason, helping Bellamy is a challenge Rusty can’t refuse, and he develops a reluctant soft spot for the woman beloved by everyone in town. She’s too young, too innocent, but also too hard to resist. So he promises himself this fake dating gig is just that: fake.
When Rusty and Bellamy find more in each other than either of them expected, they’re faced with a difficult question. Is what they share too flawed to be real? Or did they stumble upon their own kind of perfect?
___________________________________________
The Problem with Perfect is book three in the Cedar Point series, a series of interconnected standalone romance novels following five siblings as they find their happily-ever-afters in a lakeside small town in the mountains. While the books can be read in any order, readers will receive tidbits throughout the series about other couples. For the best, spoiler-free experience, it's encouraged to read the series in order.
Rusty Fuller likes to keep people at a distance. He’s been through enough to know that letting anyone too close is a mistake, unless it’s only for a little fun. What he definitely doesn’t need is his best friend’s little sister turning him into anyone’s boyfriend, especially her own.
For some reason, helping Bellamy is a challenge Rusty can’t refuse, and he develops a reluctant soft spot for the woman beloved by everyone in town. She’s too young, too innocent, but also too hard to resist. So he promises himself this fake dating gig is just that: fake.
When Rusty and Bellamy find more in each other than either of them expected, they’re faced with a difficult question. Is what they share too flawed to be real? Or did they stumble upon their own kind of perfect?
___________________________________________
The Problem with Perfect is book three in the Cedar Point series, a series of interconnected standalone romance novels following five siblings as they find their happily-ever-afters in a lakeside small town in the mountains. While the books can be read in any order, readers will receive tidbits throughout the series about other couples. For the best, spoiler-free experience, it's encouraged to read the series in order.
Unknown Binding
Published January 1, 2023
74 people are currently reading
394 people want to read
About the author
Jillian Liota
34 books440 followersJillian Liota is a Southern California native currently living in Kailua, Hawaii. She is married to her best friend, has a three-legged pup with endless energy, and acts as a servant to two very temperamental cats.
Jillian writes contemporary and new adult romance, and her books have been praised for depth of character, strong female friendships, deliciously steamy scenes, and positive portrayal of mental health.
She has a master’s in Higher Education and Student Affairs, and she is passionate about all things improvement, development and organization.
She’s also a big fan of taking walks with her husband, reading romance, watching a handful of horrible reality TV shows, and exploring the island she calls home.
Jillian writes contemporary and new adult romance, and her books have been praised for depth of character, strong female friendships, deliciously steamy scenes, and positive portrayal of mental health.
She has a master’s in Higher Education and Student Affairs, and she is passionate about all things improvement, development and organization.
She’s also a big fan of taking walks with her husband, reading romance, watching a handful of horrible reality TV shows, and exploring the island she calls home.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews
September 1, 2023
4.5 ⭐!!
I think this is my favorite in the series!!
Fake dating, grumpy sunshine, age gap. CHECK. I loved Rusty and his grumpiness! The beginning started out so so so so strong but then I felt like the ending was a bit rushed.
Still strongly recommend!
🌶️🌶️
I think this is my favorite in the series!!
Fake dating, grumpy sunshine, age gap. CHECK. I loved Rusty and his grumpiness! The beginning started out so so so so strong but then I felt like the ending was a bit rushed.
Still strongly recommend!
🌶️🌶️
August 18, 2023
For fans of Laura Pavlov and Elsie Silver, this one is for you!
The Problem with Perfect is the perfect combination of small town, fake dating, grumpy x sunshine, and brother’s best friend.
I absolutely loved Rusty’s character. He was grumpy but his soft side for Bellamy had me 🥲🥹. Bellamy was so sweet, intelligent, and the perfect counterpart to Rusty.
I’m always a sucker for the fake dating and grumpy x sunshine tropes and this one had both!! I loved getting to see the “fake” transform into anything but.
ALSO! Can we talk about Stace?! I thought I was going to hate her. Fake news. I absolutely LOVED her by the end 🫶
Thank you Jillian Liota and Grey’s Promotions for this eARC in exchange for my honest review <3
The Problem with Perfect by Jillian Liota is releasing August 21, 2023!
Preorder today on Amazon!
https://mybook.to/tpwp
The Problem with Perfect is the perfect combination of small town, fake dating, grumpy x sunshine, and brother’s best friend.
I absolutely loved Rusty’s character. He was grumpy but his soft side for Bellamy had me 🥲🥹. Bellamy was so sweet, intelligent, and the perfect counterpart to Rusty.
I’m always a sucker for the fake dating and grumpy x sunshine tropes and this one had both!! I loved getting to see the “fake” transform into anything but.
ALSO! Can we talk about Stace?! I thought I was going to hate her. Fake news. I absolutely LOVED her by the end 🫶
Thank you Jillian Liota and Grey’s Promotions for this eARC in exchange for my honest review <3
The Problem with Perfect by Jillian Liota is releasing August 21, 2023!
Preorder today on Amazon!
https://mybook.to/tpwp
September 3, 2023
***Actual Rating: 5/5 learn-to-love-again stars***
Oh, man. I miss Jillian Liota’s writing and Cedar Point series so much that I am extremely happy The Problem with Perfect does not disappoint. In fact, I think this book is one of the best reads I’ve had this year so far. For starters, The Problem with Perfect is the third instalment in Cedar Point series, with The Trouble with Wanting, The Opposite of Falling, and The Start of Someday being the first 1,2, and 2.5. Jillian’s stories are as beautiful and heartfelt as I remember so I’m beyond thrilled to have read and enjoyed this new addition.
The Problem with Perfect revolves around Rusty and Bellamy, who are 10 years apart in age, but somehow are obviously meant to be. Growing up, both of them acknowledge each other’s presence but they’ve never really had much interaction because of, well, being the best friend’s little sister AND big brother’s bestie kind of “concern.” Thus, color them shocked when Bellamy’s in desperate need to find a fake boyfriend just to irk her douchebag crush, Connor, she volunteers for Rusty and the latter surprisingly, happily acts along. *evil grinning*
That being established, here comes my first favorite part of the book: the realistic aspect of Bellamy and Rusty’s relationship, faux ou non. Since the very beginning, they’ve been on the same page regarding this faux romance prank they’ll be pulling on Connor; hence, I appreciate that aside from the steamy sessions, Bellamy and Rusty actually take the time to discuss the whole plan and down to the littlest details such as their age difference, childhood memories, and whatnot. It’s nice to know the protagonists do try to find something more plausible for their fake relationship, adding more depths into their own adventure. I know I shouldn’t compare this book with others, BUT I just have to say that this is such a rare-find considering most of the romance novels I’ve read usually skip these realistic parts and jump to the sex scenes like 5 minutes into the story instead. *eye rolling*
As more and more time Bellamy and Rustyare forced to have to spend together…well, again, to be more convincing to people around them since they’re supposed to be a couple, falling madly in love with each other, they both experience something major and completely refreshing in their lives. However cliché this may sound, I think they manage to find who they truly are in each other. For example, though Bellamy seems like the perfect girl next door, she is actually pretty inexperienced in the romantic/sexual field thanks to Connor ruining all the fun for her and her overprotective big brother. So with all the special lessons from Rusty, she definitely becomes much more confident and grows more mature as a person at the same time.
As for Rusty, that poor guy, it almost brings me to tears seeing how touched he is whenever Bellamy stands up for him or sides with him in public. Faux romance aside, Bellamy genuinely believes Rusty is a good guy despite his traumatic past and all those rumors their small town has been whispering.
Finding true love is never easy so when it’s hard to achieve in reality, the least we—as readers—can do is to seek solace in fictional world and cheer the protagonists on when they discover their soulmates. Bellamy and Rusty’s story is a real delight to read and I kid you not, by the end of the book, I feel empowered and filled with so much positivity.
On side notes, there’s another reason I think this book is a huge success. Not only can I easily resonate with the characters, Rusty’s struggles and inner feelings in particular, but I’m certain most readers will be able to as well. The quote above hits me hard when I come across it the moment Rusty finally realizes what a burden his baby sister involuntarily is for him, whether she knows it or not. (You’ll have to find out how or why or under what circumstances does Rusty come to that conclusion and realization, though. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!) For someone who has a hard time forming friendship or relationship with another person, I wonder if what Rusty says then is exactly what my family thinks about me in similar situations. For instance, am I their burden the entire time when I can’t or don’t want to find my significant other? Or if that’s what they truly feel from the bottom of their hearts despite the fact they never tell me that however many times I bug them with such questions? So in all honesty, I think to some extent, this book does get me pondering on real life problems and they may or may not be problems with perfect.
Anyways, I’m leaving you with my top favorite and most unforgettable quote in this book. I hope you’ll find someone who treats you the way you deserve, who’s willing to sacrifice and compromise for you, and above all, who makes you realize you can change just to be a better version of you, for yourself and for that special someone.
***Thanks to Grey’s Promotions and the author for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.***
Love isn’t some tangible thing that has to look perfect in order to mean something. You just have to feel it.
Oh, man. I miss Jillian Liota’s writing and Cedar Point series so much that I am extremely happy The Problem with Perfect does not disappoint. In fact, I think this book is one of the best reads I’ve had this year so far. For starters, The Problem with Perfect is the third instalment in Cedar Point series, with The Trouble with Wanting, The Opposite of Falling, and The Start of Someday being the first 1,2, and 2.5. Jillian’s stories are as beautiful and heartfelt as I remember so I’m beyond thrilled to have read and enjoyed this new addition.
The Problem with Perfect revolves around Rusty and Bellamy, who are 10 years apart in age, but somehow are obviously meant to be. Growing up, both of them acknowledge each other’s presence but they’ve never really had much interaction because of, well, being the best friend’s little sister AND big brother’s bestie kind of “concern.” Thus, color them shocked when Bellamy’s in desperate need to find a fake boyfriend just to irk her douchebag crush, Connor, she volunteers for Rusty and the latter surprisingly, happily acts along. *evil grinning*
”It’s not a stupid idea,” I tell her. “But when you were in high school, I was in my mid-twenties. We just have to find a different story.”
That being established, here comes my first favorite part of the book: the realistic aspect of Bellamy and Rusty’s relationship, faux ou non. Since the very beginning, they’ve been on the same page regarding this faux romance prank they’ll be pulling on Connor; hence, I appreciate that aside from the steamy sessions, Bellamy and Rusty actually take the time to discuss the whole plan and down to the littlest details such as their age difference, childhood memories, and whatnot. It’s nice to know the protagonists do try to find something more plausible for their fake relationship, adding more depths into their own adventure. I know I shouldn’t compare this book with others, BUT I just have to say that this is such a rare-find considering most of the romance novels I’ve read usually skip these realistic parts and jump to the sex scenes like 5 minutes into the story instead. *eye rolling*
My heart thunders in my chest, the overwhelm of her esteem filling up a well I didn’t even realize had run dry. Bellamy Mitchell just knocked me on my ass, and she did it while building me up.
As more and more time Bellamy and Rusty
As for Rusty, that poor guy, it almost brings me to tears seeing how touched he is whenever Bellamy stands up for him or sides with him in public. Faux romance aside, Bellamy genuinely believes Rusty is a good guy despite his traumatic past and all those rumors their small town has been whispering.
She seems like the kind of woman who, once you’re in with her, it’s a ride-or-die situation. That loyalty is hard to come by because it requires an element of self-sacrifice not everyone is willing to commit to.
Finding true love is never easy so when it’s hard to achieve in reality, the least we—as readers—can do is to seek solace in fictional world and cheer the protagonists on when they discover their soulmates. Bellamy and Rusty’s story is a real delight to read and I kid you not, by the end of the book, I feel empowered and filled with so much positivity.
It’s not that I (Rusty) consider my sister a burden in any way, but for the first time, I no longer feel the responsibility of being the only person she turns to for support.
…
My chest feels tight again as I lie in bed, thinking over all the things I want to do, all the ways I want to be different, all the love I want to give. It’s like taking this weight off my shoulders didn’t just make me feel lighter; it makes me feel like I can fly.
On side notes, there’s another reason I think this book is a huge success. Not only can I easily resonate with the characters, Rusty’s struggles and inner feelings in particular, but I’m certain most readers will be able to as well. The quote above hits me hard when I come across it the moment Rusty finally realizes what a burden his baby sister involuntarily is for him, whether she knows it or not. (You’ll have to find out how or why or under what circumstances does Rusty come to that conclusion and realization, though. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!) For someone who has a hard time forming friendship or relationship with another person, I wonder if what Rusty says then is exactly what my family thinks about me in similar situations. For instance, am I their burden the entire time when I can’t or don’t want to find my significant other? Or if that’s what they truly feel from the bottom of their hearts despite the fact they never tell me that however many times I bug them with such questions? So in all honesty, I think to some extent, this book does get me pondering on real life problems and they may or may not be problems with perfect.
There’s an element of selflessness that goes into loving others and caring about them, and selflessness is something translates into very specific behaviors.
Listening when they have something to say.
Helping when things are hard.
Communicating even when it isn’t easy.
Learning how to be more intentional.
And most importantly, changing when you realize you can be better.
Anyways, I’m leaving you with my top favorite and most unforgettable quote in this book. I hope you’ll find someone who treats you the way you deserve, who’s willing to sacrifice and compromise for you, and above all, who makes you realize you can change just to be a better version of you, for yourself and for that special someone.
***Thanks to Grey’s Promotions and the author for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.***
August 27, 2023
4⭐️
Just want to say that when I was sent this book as an ARC, I hadn’t read the first two books in the series yet so I obviously had to go back and read them so my review could be the best it could be 😊 First off all can I just say I loved this book and it is definitely my fave of the series thus far. There is just something about a grumpy man that just does it for me EVERY SINGLE TIME!!! Obsessed with the setting of Cedar point (If you like Elsie Silver books you’ll love these) and the found family vibes this story gave.
The story of Rusty and Bellamy was definitely a slow burner for me. Every moment I was hoping something would happen because there was just sooo much tension. Once it did, it did not disappoint but I do wish there was a little bit more spice. This book touched on a lot of real subjects such as losing parents at a young age, raising siblings, overcoming tragedy, and dealing with awful men. I really enjoyed reading this but I will say I wish we got to see more of Rusty and Bells outside of their fake dating because majority of the book they’d convinced themselves that nothing was going on. I also kind of wanted to see Connor flop harder😂 he deserves for both sides of his pillow to be warm (especially after the way he treated numerous girls). Overall I loved the story and if you like brothers best friend, age gap, grumpy x sunshine, or fake dating this is definitely the book for you!
Thank you to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Just want to say that when I was sent this book as an ARC, I hadn’t read the first two books in the series yet so I obviously had to go back and read them so my review could be the best it could be 😊 First off all can I just say I loved this book and it is definitely my fave of the series thus far. There is just something about a grumpy man that just does it for me EVERY SINGLE TIME!!! Obsessed with the setting of Cedar point (If you like Elsie Silver books you’ll love these) and the found family vibes this story gave.
The story of Rusty and Bellamy was definitely a slow burner for me. Every moment I was hoping something would happen because there was just sooo much tension. Once it did, it did not disappoint but I do wish there was a little bit more spice. This book touched on a lot of real subjects such as losing parents at a young age, raising siblings, overcoming tragedy, and dealing with awful men. I really enjoyed reading this but I will say I wish we got to see more of Rusty and Bells outside of their fake dating because majority of the book they’d convinced themselves that nothing was going on. I also kind of wanted to see Connor flop harder😂 he deserves for both sides of his pillow to be warm (especially after the way he treated numerous girls). Overall I loved the story and if you like brothers best friend, age gap, grumpy x sunshine, or fake dating this is definitely the book for you!
Thank you to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Want to read
March 16, 2022I AM SO READY TO BE BACK IN CEDAR POINT!!😭😭❤️❤️
August 17, 2023
“That’s the problem with perfect – it doesn’t leave room for something real.”
4 stars!
The fourth book (third full length) in the Cedar Point series, I was so excited to be back into this world with a read that is chock-full of some of my favourite tropes – a brother’s best friend, fake relationship, age gap romance with all the feels, this is a really sweet read.
Bellamy Mitchell is the younger sister of Boyd and Briar who have already had their stories told in the first two books of the series. Rusty Fuller is the older brother of Abby, who is the heroine from the novella The Start of Someday. So we’ve met these two before, and there is some crossover of characters from previous books, but you could easily read this one as a standalone.
Bellamy is devastated when Connor, the boy she’s loved for as long as she can remember, returns home for the summer with a brand new fiancée. The last time he was in town, they spent a lot of time together and hooked up before he went back to school, and she was hopeful that they would rekindle their connection and finally have a chance at a happily ever after. But her dreams are instantly shattered. When he calls her out on her crush, she needs to save face, so she tells him she’s involved with somebody else, and randomly chooses the man sitting right next to them – her older brother’s best friend, Rusty.
Rusty is ten years older than Bellamy, and where she is all brightness and sunshine, he is closed off and a bit of a grump. He has his reasons for keeping himself private, and doesn’t engage much with others, other than to hook up with random strangers that pass through town, avoiding relationships or forming an actual connection with somebody. Bellamy gives him the shock of his life when she declares him her boyfriend, but he’s not a fan of Connor so he agrees to help her out.
It's a great set up, and I loved watching the dynamic between these two shift and change. Though they’ve known each other for most of their lives, they’ve never really been close friends or felt any kind of attraction to each other, they’ve just existed in each other’s lives. So they really are starting from nothing, which means we get to watch it all grow from the beginning, and fake becomes ‘not so fake’ very quickly.
Their feelings for each other come as a big surprise to both of them, and though they start to fall, they just write it off as a side-effect of all of the public PDA. But the chemistry builds, and I particularly loved watching Rusty fall so damn hard.
I loved the relationship between these two. There’s an honesty there that is really special, and they grow a lot together. I wish we could have seen a bit more one-on-one with them, to really feel the emotional build-up, but I did love watching them come together.
I loved Bellamy. She’s real and relatable, and she bravely puts herself out there, giving Rusty the push he needs, holding nothing back and embracing everything that is happening between them. It’s more of a challenge for Rusty, who has a slow awakening throughout the story. He’s been through a lot in his life. He’s lost so much and had to turn his life around, and he has a lot of soul searching to do when it comes to Bellamy and her potential place in his life. They have a 10+ year age gap, she’s inexperienced with all things love and sex, and he knows he hasn’t been living his best life. He’s the town “grump”, and he’s suddenly with the beloved golden girl, and I loved watching it change him, seeing how he reacts to having something so good in his life. He has a lot to wrestle with to come to terms with it all, which brings inevitable drama, but his journey is really well written. My heart hurt for them both, but I loved watching him figure it all out.
I enjoyed seeing glimpses of the couples from previous books, and loved the introduction of new characters who brought a lot to the story; and Rusty and Bellamy’s romance has a beautifully happy ending that left me smiling.
It’s a swoony love story, and while I would have loved to see just a little bit more of it, I did love this one.
4 stars.
An Advanced Review Copy was generously provided by the author in exchange for an honest review.
4 stars!
The fourth book (third full length) in the Cedar Point series, I was so excited to be back into this world with a read that is chock-full of some of my favourite tropes – a brother’s best friend, fake relationship, age gap romance with all the feels, this is a really sweet read.
Bellamy Mitchell is the younger sister of Boyd and Briar who have already had their stories told in the first two books of the series. Rusty Fuller is the older brother of Abby, who is the heroine from the novella The Start of Someday. So we’ve met these two before, and there is some crossover of characters from previous books, but you could easily read this one as a standalone.
Bellamy is devastated when Connor, the boy she’s loved for as long as she can remember, returns home for the summer with a brand new fiancée. The last time he was in town, they spent a lot of time together and hooked up before he went back to school, and she was hopeful that they would rekindle their connection and finally have a chance at a happily ever after. But her dreams are instantly shattered. When he calls her out on her crush, she needs to save face, so she tells him she’s involved with somebody else, and randomly chooses the man sitting right next to them – her older brother’s best friend, Rusty.
Rusty is ten years older than Bellamy, and where she is all brightness and sunshine, he is closed off and a bit of a grump. He has his reasons for keeping himself private, and doesn’t engage much with others, other than to hook up with random strangers that pass through town, avoiding relationships or forming an actual connection with somebody. Bellamy gives him the shock of his life when she declares him her boyfriend, but he’s not a fan of Connor so he agrees to help her out.
It's a great set up, and I loved watching the dynamic between these two shift and change. Though they’ve known each other for most of their lives, they’ve never really been close friends or felt any kind of attraction to each other, they’ve just existed in each other’s lives. So they really are starting from nothing, which means we get to watch it all grow from the beginning, and fake becomes ‘not so fake’ very quickly.
We might both need some time to cool down a bit and remind ourselves that this thing is supposed to be fake.
It’s fake for her, at least. For me, it’s been borderline real since the night she yanked me across the bar and planted a kiss on my lips.
Their feelings for each other come as a big surprise to both of them, and though they start to fall, they just write it off as a side-effect of all of the public PDA. But the chemistry builds, and I particularly loved watching Rusty fall so damn hard.
I keep telling myself I need to work on keeping a boundary so nothing happens between us, but that ship has sailed. It has sailed and crashed into a rock and sunk to the bottom of the ocean.
I’m falling for Bellamy Mitchell, and I don’t know how to stop it.
And the truth is…I’m not sure I want to.
I loved the relationship between these two. There’s an honesty there that is really special, and they grow a lot together. I wish we could have seen a bit more one-on-one with them, to really feel the emotional build-up, but I did love watching them come together.
“This is real,” she whispers. “I know it is, and so do you.”
She kisses me, and I’m lost in her.
No – I’m found in her.
I loved Bellamy. She’s real and relatable, and she bravely puts herself out there, giving Rusty the push he needs, holding nothing back and embracing everything that is happening between them. It’s more of a challenge for Rusty, who has a slow awakening throughout the story. He’s been through a lot in his life. He’s lost so much and had to turn his life around, and he has a lot of soul searching to do when it comes to Bellamy and her potential place in his life. They have a 10+ year age gap, she’s inexperienced with all things love and sex, and he knows he hasn’t been living his best life. He’s the town “grump”, and he’s suddenly with the beloved golden girl, and I loved watching it change him, seeing how he reacts to having something so good in his life. He has a lot to wrestle with to come to terms with it all, which brings inevitable drama, but his journey is really well written. My heart hurt for them both, but I loved watching him figure it all out.
“It’s real for me … “It’s the most real thing I’ve ever known, loving you.”
“I can’t imagine living in a world where I had you and chose to let you go.”
I enjoyed seeing glimpses of the couples from previous books, and loved the introduction of new characters who brought a lot to the story; and Rusty and Bellamy’s romance has a beautifully happy ending that left me smiling.
It’s a swoony love story, and while I would have loved to see just a little bit more of it, I did love this one.
4 stars.
An Advanced Review Copy was generously provided by the author in exchange for an honest review.
August 17, 2023
Thank you so much Jillian for trusting me with an ARC.
I couldn’t read this fast enough and at the same time I didn’t want it to end. The Problem With Perfect is that kind of book.
It has all my favourite tropes so I knew I would love it and Jillian made me fall in love with all the characters. I want so bad to read the other books in this series.
Bellamy is the sweetest and the town’s favourite daughter. Rusty is a bit grumpy but he has such a sad past that all I wanted was to bear hug him.
This is a sloooow burn but I’m a sucker for them. And Jillian made it so well and so mature. I can’t express how much I loved this book and you should totally give it a try.
Read if you like:
- Fake dating
- Age gap
- Brother’s best friend
- Grumpy vs Sunshine
- Small town
- Slow burn
- Spice
I couldn’t read this fast enough and at the same time I didn’t want it to end. The Problem With Perfect is that kind of book.
It has all my favourite tropes so I knew I would love it and Jillian made me fall in love with all the characters. I want so bad to read the other books in this series.
Bellamy is the sweetest and the town’s favourite daughter. Rusty is a bit grumpy but he has such a sad past that all I wanted was to bear hug him.
This is a sloooow burn but I’m a sucker for them. And Jillian made it so well and so mature. I can’t express how much I loved this book and you should totally give it a try.
Read if you like:
- Fake dating
- Age gap
- Brother’s best friend
- Grumpy vs Sunshine
- Small town
- Slow burn
- Spice
November 11, 2024
This series is so gooooood! I wasn’t too sure about the pairing of Rusty and Bellamy initially, I didn’t think they would make sense as a couple? But I was so wrong, this book was so cute and I loved the two of them together!!!!
August 25, 2023
Lemme just say, I LOOOOVE LOVVVE Rusty. His inner dialogue and the way he falls so hard for Bellamy, just soooo sweet😍😍. I just love this series and can’t wait for more!!!
November 28, 2024
⭐️ 3.5 ⭐️ Sweet story!
August 2, 2023
*ARC Review*
I LOVE a good brothers best friend book and everyone knows it! Add in Age Gap AND Fake Dating and it’s an automatic win for me!
Bellamy and Rusty were so fun though! I loved how grumpy he was and how much you could tell she was pulling him out of his comfort zone. It made me so happy to find out this was a “he fell first” love story.
I loved how patient he was with her and how protective they both were of each other. I loved the strip tease scene. I never would’ve expected it to come from someone like Rusty and I think that’s what made me love it even more.
I wish there was more spice! It was definitely a sloooow burn for sure. What we did get was good but I just feel like with a guy like Rusty we could’ve had so much more! Especially with Bellamy’s “teach me” attitude.
Secretly hoping to hear something more about Stace in the future too because she was great and deserves so much more than douche bag Connor could ever give.
I LOVE a good brothers best friend book and everyone knows it! Add in Age Gap AND Fake Dating and it’s an automatic win for me!
Bellamy and Rusty were so fun though! I loved how grumpy he was and how much you could tell she was pulling him out of his comfort zone. It made me so happy to find out this was a “he fell first” love story.
I loved how patient he was with her and how protective they both were of each other. I loved the strip tease scene. I never would’ve expected it to come from someone like Rusty and I think that’s what made me love it even more.
I wish there was more spice! It was definitely a sloooow burn for sure. What we did get was good but I just feel like with a guy like Rusty we could’ve had so much more! Especially with Bellamy’s “teach me” attitude.
Secretly hoping to hear something more about Stace in the future too because she was great and deserves so much more than douche bag Connor could ever give.
August 4, 2023
The Problem With Perfect is book 3 in the Cedar Point Series.
Bellamy Mitchell is the sweetheart of Cedar Point. She is kind, friendly, thoughtful, and hardworking. She dreams of a perfect future with a perfect job and the perfect guy. But, when the man of her dreams returns to town engaged to someone else, she impulsively says she is also in a serious relationship with someone. Her brother's best friend and serial "one night only" guy. Rusty Fuller has lived a life filled with sadness and loss. He deals with it by keeping people at a distance and only engaging in meaningless flings. But when Bellamy publicly declares they are in a relationship, he agreeds, and he goes along with it. The two quickly find more than they ever expected. Rusty is determined to overcome his reputation, and Bellamy seeks to get over her ex. These two have undeniable chemistry. The story is sweet, emotional, and funny. The characters are well written, and there is just the right amount of spice and angst.
I am enjoying this series. It is a simple, heartwarming, small town romance. I am looking forward to the next book in this series.
ARC was provided by the author, and this is my honest review.
Bellamy Mitchell is the sweetheart of Cedar Point. She is kind, friendly, thoughtful, and hardworking. She dreams of a perfect future with a perfect job and the perfect guy. But, when the man of her dreams returns to town engaged to someone else, she impulsively says she is also in a serious relationship with someone. Her brother's best friend and serial "one night only" guy. Rusty Fuller has lived a life filled with sadness and loss. He deals with it by keeping people at a distance and only engaging in meaningless flings. But when Bellamy publicly declares they are in a relationship, he agreeds, and he goes along with it. The two quickly find more than they ever expected. Rusty is determined to overcome his reputation, and Bellamy seeks to get over her ex. These two have undeniable chemistry. The story is sweet, emotional, and funny. The characters are well written, and there is just the right amount of spice and angst.
I am enjoying this series. It is a simple, heartwarming, small town romance. I am looking forward to the next book in this series.
ARC was provided by the author, and this is my honest review.
February 20, 2024
Oowee not going to lie... I had to learn to love Rusty Fuller, but that "he's a little bit older" situation always gets me in all the right feels.
I'm just usually not the biggest fan of playboy Hero's, and they have to work extra hard to win my love. But even though it was a rocky start, I softened up to him eventually. Especially when he begins to see his own worth, but then everyone brings him down again because of his reputation. My heart really hurt for him in those moments. But those were also the moments that brought him and Bellamy stronger together.
It's in no means 100% perfect, but I enjoyed their journey nonetheless.
What you can expect:
• fake dating
• slowburn
• he falls first
• age gap
• grumpy x sunshine
• brother's best friend
I'm just usually not the biggest fan of playboy Hero's, and they have to work extra hard to win my love. But even though it was a rocky start, I softened up to him eventually. Especially when he begins to see his own worth, but then everyone brings him down again because of his reputation. My heart really hurt for him in those moments. But those were also the moments that brought him and Bellamy stronger together.
It's in no means 100% perfect, but I enjoyed their journey nonetheless.
What you can expect:
• fake dating
• slowburn
• he falls first
• age gap
• grumpy x sunshine
• brother's best friend
Read
July 7, 2023
Grey’s Promotions is thrilled to be working with Jillian Liota on the release of The Problem with Perfect. If you are a reviewer or influencer, sign up here to be a part of its release: https://airtable.com/shrxIaUPZ7dY75vX4
September 22, 2023
SOLID 4.5 STARS!!
I absolutely LOVE this series! Each book in the Cedar Point saga (thus far) can be read as a standalone, however you get so much more from all the characters if you’ve followed them from their start in The Trouble With Wanting. Each member of the Mitchell family is hands-down amazing in their own way, and Bellamy Mitchell is no different. The third installment, The Problem With Perfect focuses on Bellamy and her love story with Rusty Fuller. And boy, did Bellamy give me way more than I ever thought she could.
Bellamy makes up one half of the Mitchell twins with her brother Bishop. Up until now, I’ve viewed her as a wide eyed, always down for an adventure type of girl. Rusty is the owner of Cedar Cider (an alcohol brand I’d love to taste test) and Boyd Michell’s (Bellamy’s older brother) best friend. It doesn’t take long reading this story before you realize that sometimes what seems to be shown to others isn’t always what’s hiding behind the surface of these two. Bellamy is indeed full of life, but you also realize that she can be very naive. But can’t we all? Learning more about Rusty in this story gave me a much deeper feeling for his character. The Rusty we’ve met prior to Book 3 has been, a fun guy that has cared for his younger sister after the death of his parents. He is protective of those he cares about and hopes to be successful in his brewery endeavors. The main storyline for our couple surrounds an old flame of Bellamy’s coming to town. The flame in this case is Connor, a guy that she slept with the summer prior to our setting. A guy she had hoped to rekindle a flame with upon his return to Cedar Point. All of that changes however when Connor returns with a fiancee named Stace. Bellamy, to soften the blow to her ego, decides to use Rusty to her advantage by lying and saying she’s been in a relationship with him. The story follows these two while they try to fool Connor and the town that they are “a real couple.” What happens instead is the most amazing character development I’ve read on not just one, but BOTH main characters in a long time. Oh yeah, there’s some steamy romance too.
Overall, this book has it all:
Small town, brothers best friend, age gap, fake dating, he falls first romance, and more!! Jillian Liota never fails in writing romances you’ll want to read AGAIN and AGAIN. I’m anxiously waiting for Book 4 to come out!
*I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Favorite Quote: “That’s how I feel when I’m with you, like I’m found in a way I couldn’t have understood before you, like I’m learning new ways to be the best version of me.”
I absolutely LOVE this series! Each book in the Cedar Point saga (thus far) can be read as a standalone, however you get so much more from all the characters if you’ve followed them from their start in The Trouble With Wanting. Each member of the Mitchell family is hands-down amazing in their own way, and Bellamy Mitchell is no different. The third installment, The Problem With Perfect focuses on Bellamy and her love story with Rusty Fuller. And boy, did Bellamy give me way more than I ever thought she could.
Bellamy makes up one half of the Mitchell twins with her brother Bishop. Up until now, I’ve viewed her as a wide eyed, always down for an adventure type of girl. Rusty is the owner of Cedar Cider (an alcohol brand I’d love to taste test) and Boyd Michell’s (Bellamy’s older brother) best friend. It doesn’t take long reading this story before you realize that sometimes what seems to be shown to others isn’t always what’s hiding behind the surface of these two. Bellamy is indeed full of life, but you also realize that she can be very naive. But can’t we all? Learning more about Rusty in this story gave me a much deeper feeling for his character. The Rusty we’ve met prior to Book 3 has been, a fun guy that has cared for his younger sister after the death of his parents. He is protective of those he cares about and hopes to be successful in his brewery endeavors. The main storyline for our couple surrounds an old flame of Bellamy’s coming to town. The flame in this case is Connor, a guy that she slept with the summer prior to our setting. A guy she had hoped to rekindle a flame with upon his return to Cedar Point. All of that changes however when Connor returns with a fiancee named Stace. Bellamy, to soften the blow to her ego, decides to use Rusty to her advantage by lying and saying she’s been in a relationship with him. The story follows these two while they try to fool Connor and the town that they are “a real couple.” What happens instead is the most amazing character development I’ve read on not just one, but BOTH main characters in a long time. Oh yeah, there’s some steamy romance too.
Overall, this book has it all:
Small town, brothers best friend, age gap, fake dating, he falls first romance, and more!! Jillian Liota never fails in writing romances you’ll want to read AGAIN and AGAIN. I’m anxiously waiting for Book 4 to come out!
*I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Favorite Quote: “That’s how I feel when I’m with you, like I’m found in a way I couldn’t have understood before you, like I’m learning new ways to be the best version of me.”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 1, 2023
It’s the first bonfire night of the summer, and Bellamy’s not sure why she decided to come. She’s guessing she feels bored…maybe a little impatient. Normally, she’s fairly relaxed, so this feeling is very unlike her. That’s why she was there, trying to find something to do, someone to talk to, something to take her mind off this feeling of stagnation. There are familiar faces from around town, people she knows of, but don’t know. Then, her eyes land on a familiar old Chevy Blazer in red with a white cover.
What are you doing here? She asks, her voice light and teasing as she approaches the broad-shouldered back of a man she’s known almost her entire life. Aren’t you too old to be at one of these things? Rusty Fuller pins me with a bored look, then returns to whatever he’s doing. At the tail end of his car. He’s not here to party, he tells, Bellamy Mitchell. Those days are in his past. She didn’t think he was there to party, she tells, Rusty. Besides, how long has it been since he graduated high school? Twenty years?
He pauses and looks back at her over his shoulder with narrowed eyes. Fourteen. Then he gives her his back again. Same thing. I lean against his Blazer and kick one foot over the other, tilting her head up to look at the sky, the stars slightly obscured by the smoke rising in the clearing between the trees. I hear, Rusty snort. It is most certainly not the same thing. He passes by me and thunks a box onto the hood. He tells her, thought you were supposed to be good at math.
So, what exactly are you doing here tonight? She asks him. Because it looks like you’re planning to dole out booze to Cedar Point’s youth. Does Boyd know you’re selling your product at the bonfire? However, when the guy she gave her womanly gift to arrived, it was only last summer, the guy who kept saying sweet nothings to her during the holidays, she lost sight of anything but him until a small brunette came out from around him, and they are holding hands. He introduces her, Stace as his fiancee. Then, he introduces, Bellamy as a classmate and then, Rusty as the owner of, Cedar Cider the best beer in town.
Rusty is the town grump, but you would never know he was only ten years older than her, twenty-two. He is also, best friends with her eldest brother, Boyd. Although nobody takes the time to look at the good man within the façade he cares to keep people at bay. Rusty lost two very important people in his life, his parents. He then gave up college and came home to raise his sister. None of which he regrets. Yet, he also found out the woman he thought he would marry one day, bailed on him in his time of need.
So, ‘one-offs’ are his thing, and not with women in town, only tourists. So, when, Connor ‘The Little Shite’ comes into the dive bar, where Bellamy works, after seeing how he broke her. Rusty is on alert, because it seems like he’s coming into gloat and he wants to drag, Bellamy's heart through the mud. He’s acting as if he’s worried, she had been waiting for him. Rusty was pissed at his assumption. Bellamy surprised them both. She started laughing out loud in his face. She tells him she’s seeing someone and he mockingly laughs back. He says, no he would have heard. She says, not if we were trying to keep it under wraps. Sending pleading eyes to, Rusty to understand. Then, boom he’s under the bus with her. But, gone is the cocky, incredibly arrogant prick who was sitting next to Rusty, who was trying to make, Bellamy uncomfortable. Now, he’s still a prick, but one a lot more uncertain. Like he doesn't like the idea of, Rusty dating, Bellamy. Life just got interesting. I enjoyed this book. I loved how these two brought out the best in each other. I was happy to see Bellamy stand up for him with Abby. I was glad her mom gave her two cents and her twin, too.
What are you doing here? She asks, her voice light and teasing as she approaches the broad-shouldered back of a man she’s known almost her entire life. Aren’t you too old to be at one of these things? Rusty Fuller pins me with a bored look, then returns to whatever he’s doing. At the tail end of his car. He’s not here to party, he tells, Bellamy Mitchell. Those days are in his past. She didn’t think he was there to party, she tells, Rusty. Besides, how long has it been since he graduated high school? Twenty years?
He pauses and looks back at her over his shoulder with narrowed eyes. Fourteen. Then he gives her his back again. Same thing. I lean against his Blazer and kick one foot over the other, tilting her head up to look at the sky, the stars slightly obscured by the smoke rising in the clearing between the trees. I hear, Rusty snort. It is most certainly not the same thing. He passes by me and thunks a box onto the hood. He tells her, thought you were supposed to be good at math.
So, what exactly are you doing here tonight? She asks him. Because it looks like you’re planning to dole out booze to Cedar Point’s youth. Does Boyd know you’re selling your product at the bonfire? However, when the guy she gave her womanly gift to arrived, it was only last summer, the guy who kept saying sweet nothings to her during the holidays, she lost sight of anything but him until a small brunette came out from around him, and they are holding hands. He introduces her, Stace as his fiancee. Then, he introduces, Bellamy as a classmate and then, Rusty as the owner of, Cedar Cider the best beer in town.
Rusty is the town grump, but you would never know he was only ten years older than her, twenty-two. He is also, best friends with her eldest brother, Boyd. Although nobody takes the time to look at the good man within the façade he cares to keep people at bay. Rusty lost two very important people in his life, his parents. He then gave up college and came home to raise his sister. None of which he regrets. Yet, he also found out the woman he thought he would marry one day, bailed on him in his time of need.
So, ‘one-offs’ are his thing, and not with women in town, only tourists. So, when, Connor ‘The Little Shite’ comes into the dive bar, where Bellamy works, after seeing how he broke her. Rusty is on alert, because it seems like he’s coming into gloat and he wants to drag, Bellamy's heart through the mud. He’s acting as if he’s worried, she had been waiting for him. Rusty was pissed at his assumption. Bellamy surprised them both. She started laughing out loud in his face. She tells him she’s seeing someone and he mockingly laughs back. He says, no he would have heard. She says, not if we were trying to keep it under wraps. Sending pleading eyes to, Rusty to understand. Then, boom he’s under the bus with her. But, gone is the cocky, incredibly arrogant prick who was sitting next to Rusty, who was trying to make, Bellamy uncomfortable. Now, he’s still a prick, but one a lot more uncertain. Like he doesn't like the idea of, Rusty dating, Bellamy. Life just got interesting. I enjoyed this book. I loved how these two brought out the best in each other. I was happy to see Bellamy stand up for him with Abby. I was glad her mom gave her two cents and her twin, too.
August 3, 2023
Overall rating 3.75 (round up for Goodreads to 4)
Thanks to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Tropes: (Read if you like)
- Grumpy/Sunshine
- Fake dating
- Age gap.
What is the logical course of action when you find out that the guy you've had a crush on for years, and had a summer fling with, comes back a couple of months later, engaged to another women? Well you start fake-dating your brother's best friend of course.
When Bellamy discovers that her ex is in a seemingly strong relationship, she tries to not only seem unaffected, but also that she has moved on to better things. Enter, Rusty. 10 years his senior, Rusty wants nothing to do with his best friend little sister. But after seeing how horrible her ex is, he decides that helping her out by showing him what he is missing, might not be a bad idea. Even more so, if dating the small town sweetheart can also help him prove to others that he can be more than a playboy everyone seem to believe he was. What can go wrong?
Its been a while since I've read a book in a day, which is a testament as to how much this book entertained me. Fake dating is one of my ultimate favorite tropes, so when I read the description I knew it was going to be a fun time. There is just something about a fake relationship that turns real that always gets me.
I want to start first with that what I liked. Bellamy and Rusty were SO fun to read about. Their whole dynamic was very sweet. I loved how Bellamy had this way of always making Rusty vulnerable and see right through him. On the other hand Rusty was so kind, so lovable, and a "secret softy" , characteristics that I love in mmc. Their relationship was very cute and I specially loved the way both of them (but specially Bellamy) were protective over each other. Rusty didn't have an ideal life, his parents died and he did his best to take care of his sister, putting all his desires and dreams aside, so it was refreshing to see someone take care of him like Bellamy did for him. I also liked the fact that our FMC, was direct and honest with the mmc, and was able to see through the BS, and not let that steal her joy for much. She was a fighter, and I appreciate that.
My complaint is that I wish I've more of them falling in love and dating outside of the "Fake dates". There were moments that I wish Bellamy did't mention Connor as much, because she deserved so much, and that idiot was not worth her tears but overall I was pleasantly surprised by the story. The side characters are also great, endearing and a treat to read about.
PS: I do got to say (although I know is intended) THAT EX BOYFRIEND WAS A LITTLE SHIT was AWFUL! Stace deserves so much moreeeee!!!!!!!
Thanks again to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thanks to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Tropes: (Read if you like)
- Grumpy/Sunshine
- Fake dating
- Age gap.
What is the logical course of action when you find out that the guy you've had a crush on for years, and had a summer fling with, comes back a couple of months later, engaged to another women? Well you start fake-dating your brother's best friend of course.
When Bellamy discovers that her ex is in a seemingly strong relationship, she tries to not only seem unaffected, but also that she has moved on to better things. Enter, Rusty. 10 years his senior, Rusty wants nothing to do with his best friend little sister. But after seeing how horrible her ex is, he decides that helping her out by showing him what he is missing, might not be a bad idea. Even more so, if dating the small town sweetheart can also help him prove to others that he can be more than a playboy everyone seem to believe he was. What can go wrong?
Its been a while since I've read a book in a day, which is a testament as to how much this book entertained me. Fake dating is one of my ultimate favorite tropes, so when I read the description I knew it was going to be a fun time. There is just something about a fake relationship that turns real that always gets me.
I want to start first with that what I liked. Bellamy and Rusty were SO fun to read about. Their whole dynamic was very sweet. I loved how Bellamy had this way of always making Rusty vulnerable and see right through him. On the other hand Rusty was so kind, so lovable, and a "secret softy" , characteristics that I love in mmc. Their relationship was very cute and I specially loved the way both of them (but specially Bellamy) were protective over each other. Rusty didn't have an ideal life, his parents died and he did his best to take care of his sister, putting all his desires and dreams aside, so it was refreshing to see someone take care of him like Bellamy did for him. I also liked the fact that our FMC, was direct and honest with the mmc, and was able to see through the BS, and not let that steal her joy for much. She was a fighter, and I appreciate that.
My complaint is that I wish I've more of them falling in love and dating outside of the "Fake dates". There were moments that I wish Bellamy did't mention Connor as much, because she deserved so much, and that idiot was not worth her tears but overall I was pleasantly surprised by the story. The side characters are also great, endearing and a treat to read about.
PS: I do got to say (although I know is intended) THAT EX BOYFRIEND WAS A LITTLE SHIT was AWFUL! Stace deserves so much moreeeee!!!!!!!
Thanks again to Grey's Promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 31, 2023
The Problem With Perfect – Cedar Point #3 - Review
Author: Jillian Liota
Couple: Bellamy Mitchel & Rusty Fuller
Tropes: brother’s best friend, best friend’s little sister, opposites attract, age-gap, fake dating romance, small town romance, innocent FMC
Review: A spicy new romance in Jillian’s Cedar Point series! I this dual POV small town novel we mee Bellamy who is the town’s golden girl and Rusty who is the black sheep. The two of them form a pact to pretend to be dating in order to protect Bellamy from the pain of facing her long time crush.
Jillian writes another enchanting romance again in this book and I loved reading Bellamy’s story of heartache, redemption and growth. The chemistry and communication between her and Rusty was perfect and I loved reading every sentence of it. Watching Bellamy grow and mature in this book was also a strong positive since she begins the book hurt and alone but ends up with a true partner. I loved how her character was more authentic and had steep learning curves at times but was graceful throughout the book. Bellamy and Rusty are a couple I want more bonus material from.
Rusty’s character also draws you in from the get go since his tortured past is ever present and looming. The way Jillian creates his persona across the pages of this book was devastating and perfect. I found myself wanting him to be able to forgive himself and admit he loved Bellamy but also understanding why he had his own fears. His inner turmoil made him POV stand out more in this book and I loved how when confronted with Bellamy’s brothers he stood his ground. I also liked how he was not afraid to go after what he wanted after he got a slight if not huge nudge from his sister.
These two have off the charts chemistry and the build up is intense. I loved how it was more of a slow build up even though Rusty told Bellamy he would give her tips. I also found the instant comradery they had to be a strong addition to the book. When it came time for Bellamy to admit her feelings changed though I found myself wishing she had done it sooner since it all blew up near the end. The HEA was well deserved and I was happy that we got to see them resolve everything!
Rating: 4/5, an angsty and emotional read!
Author: Jillian Liota
Couple: Bellamy Mitchel & Rusty Fuller
Tropes: brother’s best friend, best friend’s little sister, opposites attract, age-gap, fake dating romance, small town romance, innocent FMC
Review: A spicy new romance in Jillian’s Cedar Point series! I this dual POV small town novel we mee Bellamy who is the town’s golden girl and Rusty who is the black sheep. The two of them form a pact to pretend to be dating in order to protect Bellamy from the pain of facing her long time crush.
Jillian writes another enchanting romance again in this book and I loved reading Bellamy’s story of heartache, redemption and growth. The chemistry and communication between her and Rusty was perfect and I loved reading every sentence of it. Watching Bellamy grow and mature in this book was also a strong positive since she begins the book hurt and alone but ends up with a true partner. I loved how her character was more authentic and had steep learning curves at times but was graceful throughout the book. Bellamy and Rusty are a couple I want more bonus material from.
Rusty’s character also draws you in from the get go since his tortured past is ever present and looming. The way Jillian creates his persona across the pages of this book was devastating and perfect. I found myself wanting him to be able to forgive himself and admit he loved Bellamy but also understanding why he had his own fears. His inner turmoil made him POV stand out more in this book and I loved how when confronted with Bellamy’s brothers he stood his ground. I also liked how he was not afraid to go after what he wanted after he got a slight if not huge nudge from his sister.
These two have off the charts chemistry and the build up is intense. I loved how it was more of a slow build up even though Rusty told Bellamy he would give her tips. I also found the instant comradery they had to be a strong addition to the book. When it came time for Bellamy to admit her feelings changed though I found myself wishing she had done it sooner since it all blew up near the end. The HEA was well deserved and I was happy that we got to see them resolve everything!
Rating: 4/5, an angsty and emotional read!
November 3, 2024
The hits keep on coming in Jillian Liota's Cedar Point series, and The Problem with Perfect has been added to my small-town romance all-time favorites.
In this book, the focus is on the third Mitchell sibling, Bellamy. She's knowm Rusty all her life, as he is her older brother's best friend. One unexpected interaction with the man who broke her heart has her concocting an impromptu fake relationship with Rusty. Caught up in the moment, Rusty agrees, but soon thereafter realizes it's a mistake. He's grumpy, has never seen Bellamy as anything but his best friend's sister, and carries an overall facade of wanting to dismiss others as not worth his time. However, continued interaction with Bellamy prevents him from backing out from their hasty agreement, and he even eventually sees an unexpected advantage of their fake relationship. What he did not expect, though - and neither did Bellamy - that what initially started as fake is something they are beginning to want to be real.
Both Bellamy and Rusty, though, are held back in acknowledging their true desires. But it is Rusty who holds the most back, what with his deep-seated belief that he doesn't deserve to be happy, that self-sacrifice is the best way to atone for what he believes are his mistakes done in the past.
What we thus witness in this story is how another's genuine love for us, expressed in their caring ministrations, their declarations of pride for what we do and who we are, is nothing but profoundly uplifting to one's spirit. It is even powerful enough to lift us up from the pit of self-deprecation and instead allow us to find our inherent self-worth and to finally find a liberating pride in it.
Jillian Liota's storytelling is truly exceptional in this book, and I cannot wait to dive into the next book so I can witness the last and final Mitchell sibling find his happy ever after too.
In this book, the focus is on the third Mitchell sibling, Bellamy. She's knowm Rusty all her life, as he is her older brother's best friend. One unexpected interaction with the man who broke her heart has her concocting an impromptu fake relationship with Rusty. Caught up in the moment, Rusty agrees, but soon thereafter realizes it's a mistake. He's grumpy, has never seen Bellamy as anything but his best friend's sister, and carries an overall facade of wanting to dismiss others as not worth his time. However, continued interaction with Bellamy prevents him from backing out from their hasty agreement, and he even eventually sees an unexpected advantage of their fake relationship. What he did not expect, though - and neither did Bellamy - that what initially started as fake is something they are beginning to want to be real.
Both Bellamy and Rusty, though, are held back in acknowledging their true desires. But it is Rusty who holds the most back, what with his deep-seated belief that he doesn't deserve to be happy, that self-sacrifice is the best way to atone for what he believes are his mistakes done in the past.
What we thus witness in this story is how another's genuine love for us, expressed in their caring ministrations, their declarations of pride for what we do and who we are, is nothing but profoundly uplifting to one's spirit. It is even powerful enough to lift us up from the pit of self-deprecation and instead allow us to find our inherent self-worth and to finally find a liberating pride in it.
Jillian Liota's storytelling is truly exceptional in this book, and I cannot wait to dive into the next book so I can witness the last and final Mitchell sibling find his happy ever after too.
September 1, 2023
The problem with perfect is book 3 in the Cedar Point series. When I was given the ARC, I hadn’t read the other books in the series yet. Cedar Point gives the best small town vibes, and I’ve truly fell in love with this series!
Bellamy is Cedar Points favorite daughter, and when her crush from the previous summer shows up again with shocking news, she does what anyone would do. Fake dates their brothers best friend. 🫣
Insert Rusty. He’s the town grump and 10 years older than Bellamy. Shockingly enough he goes along with her plan, but in the beginning it’s just to piss the “little shit” off, but ultimately we know what’s bound to happen!
Rusty has been dealt some pretty heavy cards throughout his life, which has made him closed off. His main focus is his sister, his brewery, and his 2 friends. He never expects Bellamy to become part of the equation. She tests him in all the right ways, and makes him finally start feeling again.
I really did like this book! It has some of my favorite tropes! ( grumpy x sunshine , age gap, small town) However, I will say at times I had to remind myself that Bellamy was in her twenties not 16… sometimes she would give off High school vibes. Lol
Fingers crossed the next book is about bishop & emily 🤭🤭
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Also, we need to talk about Stace! I wanted to not like her. I really did, but she’s a side character I want to know more about. Here’s me petitioning for Stace to have her HEA! 💕
Thank you to Grey’s promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Bellamy is Cedar Points favorite daughter, and when her crush from the previous summer shows up again with shocking news, she does what anyone would do. Fake dates their brothers best friend. 🫣
Insert Rusty. He’s the town grump and 10 years older than Bellamy. Shockingly enough he goes along with her plan, but in the beginning it’s just to piss the “little shit” off, but ultimately we know what’s bound to happen!
Rusty has been dealt some pretty heavy cards throughout his life, which has made him closed off. His main focus is his sister, his brewery, and his 2 friends. He never expects Bellamy to become part of the equation. She tests him in all the right ways, and makes him finally start feeling again.
I really did like this book! It has some of my favorite tropes! ( grumpy x sunshine , age gap, small town) However, I will say at times I had to remind myself that Bellamy was in her twenties not 16… sometimes she would give off High school vibes. Lol
Fingers crossed the next book is about bishop & emily 🤭🤭
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Also, we need to talk about Stace! I wanted to not like her. I really did, but she’s a side character I want to know more about. Here’s me petitioning for Stace to have her HEA! 💕
Thank you to Grey’s promotion and Jilian Liota for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 21, 2023
Bellamy and Rusty
Bellamy is trying to make her “ex” leave her alone with she comes around with his fiancé!!! She and her ex got together last summer and had a nice fling but she thought it was more and hoped it would be more since she’s had a crush in him since being in school!! He lets her believe he is going to college and he’ll be back and they can hang out again. Only to find out when he returns he’s engaged!!
Bellamy tries not to be hurt by this so she pretends to be in a relationship with her brothers friend Rusty… Rusty is the kind of guy that only sleeps a with out of towners bc people From town her expecting more than he was willing to give.. at first he was hesitant in helping Bellamy, but ultimately after meeting the douche of an ex he agrees… they spend time together and their feelings grow! Neither expected to feel
What they do for one another it was very out of the blue but they have strong feelings…. The exs fiancé lives hanging out with Rusty and Bellamy she loves seeing how their feelings are so true and hopes that she can find that one day bc right now she doesn’t feel it… she eventually smartens up and leaves.
HEA— of course he was a playboy and she had only slept with her ex—- but whatever i have to get over this trope!— anyway come to find out down the line her ex also had a summer fling with one of the girls she works with at the bar!! He was a
Complete scumbag obviously and he eventually will learn that too!
Bellamy is trying to make her “ex” leave her alone with she comes around with his fiancé!!! She and her ex got together last summer and had a nice fling but she thought it was more and hoped it would be more since she’s had a crush in him since being in school!! He lets her believe he is going to college and he’ll be back and they can hang out again. Only to find out when he returns he’s engaged!!
Bellamy tries not to be hurt by this so she pretends to be in a relationship with her brothers friend Rusty… Rusty is the kind of guy that only sleeps a with out of towners bc people From town her expecting more than he was willing to give.. at first he was hesitant in helping Bellamy, but ultimately after meeting the douche of an ex he agrees… they spend time together and their feelings grow! Neither expected to feel
What they do for one another it was very out of the blue but they have strong feelings…. The exs fiancé lives hanging out with Rusty and Bellamy she loves seeing how their feelings are so true and hopes that she can find that one day bc right now she doesn’t feel it… she eventually smartens up and leaves.
HEA— of course he was a playboy and she had only slept with her ex—- but whatever i have to get over this trope!— anyway come to find out down the line her ex also had a summer fling with one of the girls she works with at the bar!! He was a
Complete scumbag obviously and he eventually will learn that too!
October 5, 2023
3-3.75⭐️s
First 2/3 of this book was possibly 4 star territory and then it just got a bit boring... The premise is typical though interesting enough (and yet another installment of falling in love with a brother's friend... the 3rd in this 3.5 book series so far). I'm a bit over that trope at this point and like I said, it started off interesting enough and then ended up being pretty much the same as the other earlier 1.5 books. I do like the little world of Cedar Point but it's clear that the only men worth knowing here are Boyd's best friends, lol. Still, it's steamy and has likable characters. Nothing to wow you but a generally easy going enough story, despite the heavy backstory of Rusty's parents' deaths. I think Bellamy might be my least favorite sister? She just seemed so uninteresting... I think I felt that way about Blaire too... Anyway, it's entertaining enough but maybe don't read one after another as it's getting a bit repetitive.
Not quite as good as Elsie Silvers books but a similar sort of vibe (without the horses!).
Book 1: The Trouble With Wanting
Book 2: The Opposite of Falling
Book 2.5: The Start of Someday
This Book: The Problem with Perfect
First 2/3 of this book was possibly 4 star territory and then it just got a bit boring... The premise is typical though interesting enough (and yet another installment of falling in love with a brother's friend... the 3rd in this 3.5 book series so far). I'm a bit over that trope at this point and like I said, it started off interesting enough and then ended up being pretty much the same as the other earlier 1.5 books. I do like the little world of Cedar Point but it's clear that the only men worth knowing here are Boyd's best friends, lol. Still, it's steamy and has likable characters. Nothing to wow you but a generally easy going enough story, despite the heavy backstory of Rusty's parents' deaths. I think Bellamy might be my least favorite sister? She just seemed so uninteresting... I think I felt that way about Blaire too... Anyway, it's entertaining enough but maybe don't read one after another as it's getting a bit repetitive.
Not quite as good as Elsie Silvers books but a similar sort of vibe (without the horses!).
Book 1: The Trouble With Wanting
Book 2: The Opposite of Falling
Book 2.5: The Start of Someday
This Book: The Problem with Perfect
August 8, 2023
Thank you Grey's Promotions and Jillian Liota for providing me an ARC!
•
"That's the problem with perfect - it doesn't leave room for something real."
•
•
I really enjoyed this! It was cute, funny, heartwarming and just all around a nice read! It was a simple, feel good story and it left me feeling warm and fuzzy and that's all I can really ask for.
It was a bunch of my favorite tropes wrapped up in one story - fake dating, small town, age gap, grumpy/sunshine, he falls first, brothers best friend (done really well!!) and even a lil bit of spice coaching. It was a sloooooow burn and while it was satisfying, I feel like we could have gotten so much more from Bellamy and Rusty (especially with Bellamy's "show me" attitude.)
Bellamy, Cedar Point's, favorite daughter is sweet, well liked and innocent. She decides to fake date her brothers best friend, Rusty, after she finds out that her long time crush has retuned home and is also engaged. Rusty is 10 years older, is in the middle of building his own brewery, and is the town grump/playboy. Rusty is determined to prove his reputation wrong and Bellamy seeks to get over her ex, so the two strike up a deal.
They were both so patient and sweet with each other and fought to make sure the other saw their worth and what they deserved, which of course, is each other!
•
"That's the problem with perfect - it doesn't leave room for something real."
•
•
I really enjoyed this! It was cute, funny, heartwarming and just all around a nice read! It was a simple, feel good story and it left me feeling warm and fuzzy and that's all I can really ask for.
It was a bunch of my favorite tropes wrapped up in one story - fake dating, small town, age gap, grumpy/sunshine, he falls first, brothers best friend (done really well!!) and even a lil bit of spice coaching. It was a sloooooow burn and while it was satisfying, I feel like we could have gotten so much more from Bellamy and Rusty (especially with Bellamy's "show me" attitude.)
Bellamy, Cedar Point's, favorite daughter is sweet, well liked and innocent. She decides to fake date her brothers best friend, Rusty, after she finds out that her long time crush has retuned home and is also engaged. Rusty is 10 years older, is in the middle of building his own brewery, and is the town grump/playboy. Rusty is determined to prove his reputation wrong and Bellamy seeks to get over her ex, so the two strike up a deal.
They were both so patient and sweet with each other and fought to make sure the other saw their worth and what they deserved, which of course, is each other!
August 18, 2023
This is the first book I’ve read by Jillian Liota and it won’t be the last!
4.5⭐️
1.5🌶️
Tropes
Fake dating
Slow burn
Brother’s best friend
Age gap
Small town romance
Grumpy/sunshine
Bellamy and Rusty seem to be on completely different life paths. Belle my is finishing college and Rusty is running a successful business which he is expanding.
They have known each other for a long time as Rusty is best friends with Bellamy’s older brother. At a bonfire Bellamy crosses paths with Connor, a guy she thinks she is in love with and has a future with. That all comes crashing down when he introduces his fiancée!
I loved the dual pov as I think it adds depth to the their story. Rusty is a grump but a sweetheart underneath who needs someone to really notice who he is and remind him that it’s okay to want things for yourself. His tragic past holds him back but Bellamy slowly opens his eyes and his heart.
Bellamy is driven and determined about the things that she wants. She stands her ground and doesn’t shy away from difficult conversations. She is ride or die and exactly what Rusty needs just as he is what she needs too.
The slow burn is torturous in the most delicious way. I just loved it. I will be going back to read the other books in the series, which are interconnected standalones.
4.5⭐️
1.5🌶️
Tropes
Fake dating
Slow burn
Brother’s best friend
Age gap
Small town romance
Grumpy/sunshine
Bellamy and Rusty seem to be on completely different life paths. Belle my is finishing college and Rusty is running a successful business which he is expanding.
They have known each other for a long time as Rusty is best friends with Bellamy’s older brother. At a bonfire Bellamy crosses paths with Connor, a guy she thinks she is in love with and has a future with. That all comes crashing down when he introduces his fiancée!
I loved the dual pov as I think it adds depth to the their story. Rusty is a grump but a sweetheart underneath who needs someone to really notice who he is and remind him that it’s okay to want things for yourself. His tragic past holds him back but Bellamy slowly opens his eyes and his heart.
Bellamy is driven and determined about the things that she wants. She stands her ground and doesn’t shy away from difficult conversations. She is ride or die and exactly what Rusty needs just as he is what she needs too.
The slow burn is torturous in the most delicious way. I just loved it. I will be going back to read the other books in the series, which are interconnected standalones.
August 22, 2023
Bellamy Mitchell is loved throughout Cedar Point. She is kind to everyone, friendly, thoughtful, but a bit innocent. She dreams of perfect which doesn't exist. When the man she has had a crush on for years returns to town with a fiance, she acts impulsively and says that she is seriously involved with someone, Rusty.
Rusty has a reputation in town, "Cedar Point's most attractive tourist destination" and isn't known for committed relationships. Rusty has lived with sadness and loss in his life, and it changed him. He lost people he cared about and his girlfriend at one time and he doesn't want another serious relationship, until Bellamy. These two have undeniable chemistry and those looking in from the outside know that there is more to relationships and want what they have. Their faux relationship helps them find something unexpected but perfect for them.
This was my first book by Jillian Liota and she did not disappoint. I really liked getting to know Rusty he seemed like a grumpy, unsocial person but really he just protected himself from getting hurt again. The more time that he and Bellamy spend together, he realizes she would never be like his ex-girlfriend. The Problem with Perfect is heartwarming, has drama, and a small town romance. I enjoyed this book and recommend it.
Received ARC in exchange for voluntary honest review
Rusty has a reputation in town, "Cedar Point's most attractive tourist destination" and isn't known for committed relationships. Rusty has lived with sadness and loss in his life, and it changed him. He lost people he cared about and his girlfriend at one time and he doesn't want another serious relationship, until Bellamy. These two have undeniable chemistry and those looking in from the outside know that there is more to relationships and want what they have. Their faux relationship helps them find something unexpected but perfect for them.
This was my first book by Jillian Liota and she did not disappoint. I really liked getting to know Rusty he seemed like a grumpy, unsocial person but really he just protected himself from getting hurt again. The more time that he and Bellamy spend together, he realizes she would never be like his ex-girlfriend. The Problem with Perfect is heartwarming, has drama, and a small town romance. I enjoyed this book and recommend it.
Received ARC in exchange for voluntary honest review
August 24, 2023
Thank you to the author for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
🌶️🌶️🌶️
CW
🟢 Parent Death
Tropes
🍺 Faking Dating
🍺 Best Friend’s Sister/Brother’s Best Friend
🍺 Grumpy/Sunshine
🍺 Age Gap
🍺 Dual POV
The Problem With Perfect is the third book in a series. I went in having not read the previous two, and I now plan to backtrack and read them, because this book was great. This one follows Rusty, a man in his 30s working on opening his own brewery, and Bellamy, a college graduate who’s considered the town darling. What starts as a fake dating scheme turns into real feelings on both sides.
Of course, that isn’t without problems, but because this is a dual POV, we get to see how both Rusty and Bellamy feel, which is what elevates this book. If it had been one-sided, it wouldn’t have been as effective. As a reader, I was waiting to see when they would officially come together, and that would not have happened with a single POV.
I really enjoyed the character development, particularly with Rusty. Watching him realize what his “image” is and why he wants to change that was a great journey to be on. It felt natural and pretty realistic for a man at his stage in life. It was also really fun to see his business come to life and see him find what makes him happy. Too few of us really set aside the time to do that.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
🌶️🌶️🌶️
CW
🟢 Parent Death
Tropes
🍺 Faking Dating
🍺 Best Friend’s Sister/Brother’s Best Friend
🍺 Grumpy/Sunshine
🍺 Age Gap
🍺 Dual POV
The Problem With Perfect is the third book in a series. I went in having not read the previous two, and I now plan to backtrack and read them, because this book was great. This one follows Rusty, a man in his 30s working on opening his own brewery, and Bellamy, a college graduate who’s considered the town darling. What starts as a fake dating scheme turns into real feelings on both sides.
Of course, that isn’t without problems, but because this is a dual POV, we get to see how both Rusty and Bellamy feel, which is what elevates this book. If it had been one-sided, it wouldn’t have been as effective. As a reader, I was waiting to see when they would officially come together, and that would not have happened with a single POV.
I really enjoyed the character development, particularly with Rusty. Watching him realize what his “image” is and why he wants to change that was a great journey to be on. It felt natural and pretty realistic for a man at his stage in life. It was also really fun to see his business come to life and see him find what makes him happy. Too few of us really set aside the time to do that.
August 14, 2023
Thank you to Jillian Liota and Grey's Promotions for the e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Bellamy and Rusty were so enjoyable to read about! I really enjoy Cedar Point and this book did not disappoint. It had me smiling, laughing and tearing up throughout it. My heart felt for Bellamy as she was dealing with heartbreak at seeing her crush engaged. It was fun to watch her become more confident in herself and her relationship. I have loved Rustys character so I was so glad to see him develop and open up. He was patient and put her above himself. He loves fiercely and is dedicated to those in his circle.
I enjoyed the moments with Briar and Bellamy as they continued to deepen their relationship as well. The friendship with Boyd, Andy and Rusty was also intriguing to read about and I loved Rustys relationship with the three men at the Pines. Cedar Point has some really strong secondary characters and I enjoy the relationships the main characters have with them.
The Problem with Perfect was sweet, funny, and heartfelt. Bellamy discovered what she deserves and Rusty reopened his true self.
I am a huge fan of this series and would highly recommend it!
Bellamy and Rusty were so enjoyable to read about! I really enjoy Cedar Point and this book did not disappoint. It had me smiling, laughing and tearing up throughout it. My heart felt for Bellamy as she was dealing with heartbreak at seeing her crush engaged. It was fun to watch her become more confident in herself and her relationship. I have loved Rustys character so I was so glad to see him develop and open up. He was patient and put her above himself. He loves fiercely and is dedicated to those in his circle.
I enjoyed the moments with Briar and Bellamy as they continued to deepen their relationship as well. The friendship with Boyd, Andy and Rusty was also intriguing to read about and I loved Rustys relationship with the three men at the Pines. Cedar Point has some really strong secondary characters and I enjoy the relationships the main characters have with them.
The Problem with Perfect was sweet, funny, and heartfelt. Bellamy discovered what she deserves and Rusty reopened his true self.
I am a huge fan of this series and would highly recommend it!
August 21, 2023
𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰
🏔️The Problem with Perfect🏔️
Cedar Point # 3
By Jillian Liota
⭐ 5/5 ❤️ 5/5
🏔️ Small Town Romance
🏔️ Age Gap
🏔️ Fake Dating
🏔️ Older Brother’s best friend
Bellamy gets her heart broken when the boy she fell for returns home with someone else. Rusty is grumpy and closed off but he has deep rooted reasons for that.
When Bellamy needs to save her face and Rusty is by chance there, she takes him involuntarily as her way out. Or fake boyfriend, in that case.
But Rusty is a tough nut to crack, or persuade to play along.
Only, Bellamy has a way he can’t fully turn her down.
The way she brings him out of his comfort zone was fascinating, and he couldn’t escape falling for his best friend’s younger sister.
Rusty has had a reputation he thought he could overcome by dating the town’s sweetheart. And showing Connor what he is missing out on.
The story behind Rusty’s closed off behavior is a really sad one. Gladly he changed his opinion.
Bellamy took care of Rusty in her way by being protective and caring.
The side characters we know from the previous books were a wonderful addiction here and I enjoyed them in their appearance.
Lovely and wonderful, sweet, slow burn, deep, love story.
🏔️The Problem with Perfect🏔️
Cedar Point # 3
By Jillian Liota
⭐ 5/5 ❤️ 5/5
🏔️ Small Town Romance
🏔️ Age Gap
🏔️ Fake Dating
🏔️ Older Brother’s best friend
Bellamy gets her heart broken when the boy she fell for returns home with someone else. Rusty is grumpy and closed off but he has deep rooted reasons for that.
When Bellamy needs to save her face and Rusty is by chance there, she takes him involuntarily as her way out. Or fake boyfriend, in that case.
But Rusty is a tough nut to crack, or persuade to play along.
Only, Bellamy has a way he can’t fully turn her down.
The way she brings him out of his comfort zone was fascinating, and he couldn’t escape falling for his best friend’s younger sister.
Rusty has had a reputation he thought he could overcome by dating the town’s sweetheart. And showing Connor what he is missing out on.
The story behind Rusty’s closed off behavior is a really sad one. Gladly he changed his opinion.
Bellamy took care of Rusty in her way by being protective and caring.
The side characters we know from the previous books were a wonderful addiction here and I enjoyed them in their appearance.
Lovely and wonderful, sweet, slow burn, deep, love story.
August 22, 2023
ARC review
This is my favorite in the Cedar Point series so far, but I love them all.
Bellamy was born and raised in the small town and unlike the rest of her siblings, she’s never left. She got her degree online and doesn’t plan to move away now that she’s working her way through the tests required to become an accountant.
Rusty did move away to go to college, but came back ten years ago to raise his little sister when their parents died. He’s been kind of a grump ever since.
When Bellamy’s long-time crush (and more) shows up for the summer with a fiancé, she panics and claims to have a boyfriend. Since her brother’s best friend Rusty is sitting at the bar at the time, she names him as the guy, even though he’s ten years older and has a rep from bouncing from tourist bed to tourist bed. Surprisingly, he goes along with her story. Their fake dating soon turns into some real feelings, along with sex lessons for the inexperienced Bellamy. But Rusty thinks Bellamy deserves better than him…
Interconnected standalone, third in the series
Things you’ll find in this book:
Brother’s best friend
Fake dating
Sex lessons
Age gap
Grumpy/sunshine
Small town
Slow burn
He falls first
This is my favorite in the Cedar Point series so far, but I love them all.
Bellamy was born and raised in the small town and unlike the rest of her siblings, she’s never left. She got her degree online and doesn’t plan to move away now that she’s working her way through the tests required to become an accountant.
Rusty did move away to go to college, but came back ten years ago to raise his little sister when their parents died. He’s been kind of a grump ever since.
When Bellamy’s long-time crush (and more) shows up for the summer with a fiancé, she panics and claims to have a boyfriend. Since her brother’s best friend Rusty is sitting at the bar at the time, she names him as the guy, even though he’s ten years older and has a rep from bouncing from tourist bed to tourist bed. Surprisingly, he goes along with her story. Their fake dating soon turns into some real feelings, along with sex lessons for the inexperienced Bellamy. But Rusty thinks Bellamy deserves better than him…
Interconnected standalone, third in the series
Things you’ll find in this book:
Brother’s best friend
Fake dating
Sex lessons
Age gap
Grumpy/sunshine
Small town
Slow burn
He falls first
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews