What do you think?
Rate this book
When the Roses Bloom Again
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
February 25, 2025
I did enjoy seeing this through to completion, although it never quite hit the spot in terms of quality I've seen from other authors. There was an inevitability to the whole thing somehow, which failed to get my blood pumping.
The niggles jiggled, to. over 80 times someone "knew not", the same issue I had with the other of TBR's books according to my review. And whilst I'd like to believe that the subtle changes, like the misspelling of Abraxas or the constant inaccuracy of calling the ICW the International Confederation of warlocks rather than wizards are a gentle nod to us actually being in a parallel universe, it feels more likely they were just changed on a whim.
For all it's a war fic, it lacks pace or even serious constraint because it's a time travel story, too. I liked seeing the Minerva pairing, although she is a surprisingly minor character. neither of the dark lords show any serious surprises, and Dumbledore is sidelined to little impact.
not a bad story, but it's taken me a week to get through it at an average of about 3 and a half hours a day, which is a lot of investment for something I liked but probably won't want to read again.
The niggles jiggled, to. over 80 times someone "knew not", the same issue I had with the other of TBR's books according to my review. And whilst I'd like to believe that the subtle changes, like the misspelling of Abraxas or the constant inaccuracy of calling the ICW the International Confederation of warlocks rather than wizards are a gentle nod to us actually being in a parallel universe, it feels more likely they were just changed on a whim.
For all it's a war fic, it lacks pace or even serious constraint because it's a time travel story, too. I liked seeing the Minerva pairing, although she is a surprisingly minor character. neither of the dark lords show any serious surprises, and Dumbledore is sidelined to little impact.
not a bad story, but it's taken me a week to get through it at an average of about 3 and a half hours a day, which is a lot of investment for something I liked but probably won't want to read again.
February 6, 2025
Excelente historia. El drama y la acción sin duda hicieron que la lectura se disfrutara, cada capítulo era sentirlo en carne propia y AMÉ eso. Igualmente un excelente manejo de los personajes, a pesar de ser muchos y varias veces cruzar las narrativas, el control de la redacción fue impecable. Un punto a considerar fue lo rápido que terminó el arco final, se sintió muy apresurado en comparación con la primer guerra e igualmente el final se sintió más agridulce que feliz.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 10, 2022
Longest work yet not boring that is the way of writing a story
January 26, 2023
Amazing book! One of the best I have ever read. Love this work!!
June 24, 2024
Por lejos el mejor fanfic de HP que he leído, además de uno de los mejores libros que he leído en mucho tiempo.
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews