To begin, this book is not like any other book I have read. It is filled with historical situations presented in a very magical and whimsical way. I think the audience this is intended for will really like the story and will definitely like the characters.
That being said, here is my review.
The story is about a group of animals, a sheep, a rooster and a duck, that talk. They are sort of like a super-hero team in the late 1700’s, early 1800’s. The duck is a master of strategy, the sheep is an artist, and the rooster is like Zorro, wielding a sword to dispense justice.
All in all it’s not a bad premise. My only concern is the advanced copy I read was supposed to be a graphic novel, read longer comic book, but there is more novel than pictures. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but it is a little confusing. I have come to the conclusion after reading it, that, this book would be better suited to a middle-grade novel rather than a graphic novel. For one, the descriptions are way more fleshed out, and you get a feel for the characters and how they think when it is written. That being said, it kept my attention, and I couldn’t wait to turn the page and see what was going to happen next.
I loved all the many historical references, because, I didn’t really know who some of the people talked about were; so I set off to google them, and was like, oh okay, nice. I think that they intended audience will want to research these characters and get to know a little bit more about them and how they were significant to history.
I liked, in one scene, the inside of the secret society of dreamers was described, saying there was various colors of clouds and it seemed like the character was descending from the heavens. That is a super magical and whimsical way of setting a mood and I could just imagine how that would look. Granted, in the final book, I’m sure it will be drawn and we can all see how truly spectacular that scene is, but, for me, the description was just spot on. That is one of the reasons, I think this book might succeed better if it was just written out as a novel. It will lose some of the author’s word magic in just being shown.
But, I have to say, the story is engrossing, all but a little slow to start. It soon turns into a real action-packed adventure that has a really good ending – which leaves it open for more stories of these super-hero animals to be told in the future. I think it will appeal to it’s target audience, boy, girl or inbetween. I would give this book three and a half stars as a graphic novel, solid four stars as just a novel.
My thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this ARC.