What do you think?
Rate this book
Dating on Ice
Plötzlich verliebt! Gefühlschaos auf dem Eis
Adriana weiß, was von ihr erwartet wird: dass sie genau wie ihre Eltern zuvor als Eistänzerin Goldmedaillen gewinnt. Denn daran hängt nicht nur die Familienehre, sondern leider auch die Eisbahn der Familie. Um mehr Sponsoren anzuwerben, lässt Adriana sich darauf ein, mit ihrem Tanzpartner Brayden ein Liebespaar zu mimen. Ein gefährlicher Tanz mit dem Feuer, denn Adriana muss nicht nur ihren eigenen Exfreund von der neuen Liebe überzeugen, sondern sie merkt plötzlich, dass ihre Gefühle für Brayden verrücktspielen …
Winterromantik im Blitzlichtgewitter
Die perfekte Lektüre zum Träumen
Adriana weiß, was von ihr erwartet wird: dass sie genau wie ihre Eltern zuvor als Eistänzerin Goldmedaillen gewinnt. Denn daran hängt nicht nur die Familienehre, sondern leider auch die Eisbahn der Familie. Um mehr Sponsoren anzuwerben, lässt Adriana sich darauf ein, mit ihrem Tanzpartner Brayden ein Liebespaar zu mimen. Ein gefährlicher Tanz mit dem Feuer, denn Adriana muss nicht nur ihren eigenen Exfreund von der neuen Liebe überzeugen, sondern sie merkt plötzlich, dass ihre Gefühle für Brayden verrücktspielen …
Winterromantik im Blitzlichtgewitter
Die perfekte Lektüre zum Träumen
304 pages, Paperback
First published February 8, 2022
600 people are currently reading
18493 people want to read
About the author
Jennifer Iacopelli
6 books681 followersJennifer Iacopelli writes about ambitious young women with big dreams and the guys who love them for it. Her novels include Game, Set., Match, Finding Her Edge and Break the Fall, along with a co-edited anthology, Out of Our League. Throughout her career her books have been published in over a dozen languages and Finding Her Edge has been adapted for television by Netflix. She lives in New York and invites you to follow her everywhere @jennifercarolyn or visit her website at jenniferiacopelli.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 979 reviews
March 25, 2022
✨HAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHHAHAHAHAAHAAHFUCKTHISBOOKAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHA✨
This was ABSOLUTELY, HORRENDOUSLY, ATROCIOUSLY, DISGUSTINGLY, INEXCUSABLY, VOCIFEROUSLY WORST. CASE. SCENARIO. This book is expired sushi left in a hot car. This book is your least favorite book’s best friend. This book is walking on legos. This book is having something in your cart and then as soon as you go to checkout “out of stock please remove from cart” pops up. This book is a beautiful cover on a dumpster fire of a manuscript. This book is the cheese touch. This book is pain. Physical pain.
✨✨MAJOR SPOILERS BEYOND THIS POINT✨✨
I
Am
Unwell
To do fake dating SO DIRTY like that is actually causing me bodily discomfort. I want to exorcise the memory of this book from my being. I cannot believe she made the love interest a cardboard cutout of THE ACTUAL, SHOULD’VE BEEN love interest. We didn’t fucking meet this raspy ass, dry ass mouth breather motherfucker until halfway through the book??? She had like three conversations with the crouton. How dare she do Brayden like this. The ending???? Brayden’s been pining for YEARS and he just shakes it off? Even Taylor Swift would be cursing this book out. I literally cannot believe Freddie Krueger is the one we were supposed to love. How DARE this book describe Brayden with such detail and devotion.
This had to have been an editor’s choice. I simply refused to believe the book was originally meant to be this wishy washy and laughable. Nothing was solid. No emotions or endings or conclusions were earned or achieved. You cannot give us pages of Brayden and expect us to just be okay with French Fry???? His love letter gave pennies of what it would’ve taken for me to be okay with this arc. This cemented my glorious exorcism of love triangles from my life.
I was able to push aside her horrible family and the fact that this book made zero sense, for the romance. I’m corrupt like that but NEVER have I been so horrified at the clear impending doom of a book. I know nothing about Frozen Peas besides the fact that he’s a hhhhhhwhisp of a crusty ass character.
Subverting tropes is fun but for that to happen YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND WHY THE TROPES ARE POPULAR IN THE FIRST PLACE. The connection! The forced proximity! The rightness of something that seemed wrong! This book fumbled the pass so hard the other team scored while blindfolded and dizzy from spinning around a baseball bat 10 times.
I’m so sweaty.
⭐️/5
This was ABSOLUTELY, HORRENDOUSLY, ATROCIOUSLY, DISGUSTINGLY, INEXCUSABLY, VOCIFEROUSLY WORST. CASE. SCENARIO. This book is expired sushi left in a hot car. This book is your least favorite book’s best friend. This book is walking on legos. This book is having something in your cart and then as soon as you go to checkout “out of stock please remove from cart” pops up. This book is a beautiful cover on a dumpster fire of a manuscript. This book is the cheese touch. This book is pain. Physical pain.
✨✨MAJOR SPOILERS BEYOND THIS POINT✨✨
I
Am
Unwell
To do fake dating SO DIRTY like that is actually causing me bodily discomfort. I want to exorcise the memory of this book from my being. I cannot believe she made the love interest a cardboard cutout of THE ACTUAL, SHOULD’VE BEEN love interest. We didn’t fucking meet this raspy ass, dry ass mouth breather motherfucker until halfway through the book??? She had like three conversations with the crouton. How dare she do Brayden like this. The ending???? Brayden’s been pining for YEARS and he just shakes it off? Even Taylor Swift would be cursing this book out. I literally cannot believe Freddie Krueger is the one we were supposed to love. How DARE this book describe Brayden with such detail and devotion.
This had to have been an editor’s choice. I simply refused to believe the book was originally meant to be this wishy washy and laughable. Nothing was solid. No emotions or endings or conclusions were earned or achieved. You cannot give us pages of Brayden and expect us to just be okay with French Fry???? His love letter gave pennies of what it would’ve taken for me to be okay with this arc. This cemented my glorious exorcism of love triangles from my life.
I was able to push aside her horrible family and the fact that this book made zero sense, for the romance. I’m corrupt like that but NEVER have I been so horrified at the clear impending doom of a book. I know nothing about Frozen Peas besides the fact that he’s a hhhhhhwhisp of a crusty ass character.
Subverting tropes is fun but for that to happen YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND WHY THE TROPES ARE POPULAR IN THE FIRST PLACE. The connection! The forced proximity! The rightness of something that seemed wrong! This book fumbled the pass so hard the other team scored while blindfolded and dizzy from spinning around a baseball bat 10 times.
I’m so sweaty.
⭐️/5
![Profile Image for Carly [A Beauty & Her Books].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1711660636i%2F17243629._UX200_CR0%2C39%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
January 17, 2022
#braydendeservedbetter
October 11, 2021
having a fake dating trope where they don't fall for each other and the girl ends up with the guy she had 2 interactions with really sucks
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Otros
[1.1⭐] 𝘽𝙖𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙙𝙤 𝙨𝙤𝙗𝙧𝙚 𝙝𝙞𝙚𝙡𝙤 es una novela juvenil de sport romance escrita por Jennifer Iacopelli y publicada en 2022. La historia nos presenta a Adriana Russo, una patinadora artística decidida a ganar a toda costa y a salvar el legado familiar. Cuando un imprevisto amenaza su carrera y su estabilidad en la pista, Adriana opta por una solución que promete drama y romance: fingir una relación con su compañero de patinaje para convencer al mundo (y a los jueces) de que la química entre ellos no se limita al hielo. En medio de campeonatos, conflictos familiares y un triángulo amoroso forzado, la novela intenta mezclar fake dating, segundas oportunidades y una supuesta inspiración en 𝙋𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙪𝙖𝙨𝙞𝙤́𝙣 de Jane Austen.
Tengo otras dos reseñas pendientes desde hace días y, aún así, este libro recién terminado se me hizo irónicamente más fácil de reseñar que uno que me haya gustado.
Vi que se había estrenado una serie basada en esta historia en Netflix, así que decidí leer primero la novela antes de ver la adaptación, pero fue un GRAN ERROR.
Voy a detenerme en algo que, como lectora, me molesta profundamente. Soy una gran fanática de Jane Austen. He leído 𝙋𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙪𝙖𝙨𝙞𝙤́𝙣 y puedo afirmar sin ningún problema que esto NO es un retelling de Jane Austen. No se parece en nada: ni en los personajes, ni en los conflictos, ni en el tono, ni en la construcción emocional. Llamar a esto un retelling de 𝙋𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙪𝙖𝙨𝙞𝙤́𝙣 es, sinceramente, un insulto a Jane Austen. De verdad, saquen eso de la descripción, por favor, porque lo único que logra es generar expectativas completamente erróneas y una decepción aún mayor.
Retomando la reseña, parto por lo más evidente: los personajes planos. En ningún momento logré conectar con ninguno de ellos, no hay profundidad emocional, no hay capas y no hay evolución real. Todos aburren, da lo mismo quién esté hablando o actuando porque sus voces se sienten iguales y sus conflictos no generan ningún tipo de implicación emocional en el lector.
Elisa, hermana de la protagonista, merece un párrafo aparte porque pocas veces he leído un personaje tan insufrible. Es incapaz de soltar a un hombre que claramente no le presta atención y que, además, se nota a kilómetros que está enamorado de la hermana de ella (Adriana, la protagonista). Sus actitudes son infantiles, repetitivas y cansinas, en vez de aportar tensión interesante al conflicto, lo único que logra es provocar hastío. Cada aparición suya era una prueba de paciencia.
En realidad, todos los personajes son bastante nefastos, con una única excepción: Brayden. Él es lo único medianamente rescatable del libro a nivel humano. El resto, especialmente la familia de Adriana, es un desastre. Lo más irónico de todo es precisamente eso: su familia. Ni el padre ni las hermanas la apoyan en el baile sobre hielo, siempre la ocultan, la minimizan y la niegan, siendo que Adriana es la única de las hermanas que ha ganado algún premio en su carrera. Esto no solo resulta frustrante como lectora, sino que además no tiene ninguna lógica interna. Es increíble cómo la novela insiste en invisibilizar a la protagonista dentro de su propio entorno, pero sin construir un conflicto sólido o verosímil a partir de eso. Todo se siente forzado, exagerado y mal planteado.
El fake dating es paupérrimo. Se supone que es uno de los pilares de la historia y, sin embargo, está tan mal desarrollado que apenas se sostiene. La relación fingida recién aparece alrededor del 35% del libro, lo cual ya hace que la lectura se sienta innecesariamente lenta. Durante ese primer tramo pasa poco y nada relevante, y cuando por fin se introduce el fake dating, no se explota como debería. Luego ocurre lo contrario: hay un punto en que se siente claramente que la autora pisa el acelerador y todo empieza a pasar demasiado rápido, es como si la historia no encontrara nunca su propio ritmo.
El final fue terrible, llegué a las últimas páginas comprometida únicamente por una cosa: terminar el libro con la esperanza de que el cierre salvara algo de la experiencia. Spoiler: no lo hizo. No hay recompensa emocional, no hay resolución satisfactoria y no hay sensación de “valió la pena”. Es un final que simplemente ocurre y ya, dejando una impresión aún más amarga de todo lo anterior.
¿Lo único rescatable? El patinaje sobre hielo como concepto y, nuevamente, Brayden. La ambientación del mundo del patinaje artístico podría haber sido muy interesante si se hubiera trabajado con más cuidado y detalle, pero queda en la superficie, como casi todo en esta novela.
Es una novela completamente olvidable y, peor aún, mal escrita. No puedo creer que Netflix haya gastado dinero en adaptar este libro teniendo tantas buenas novelas esperando una oportunidad, no la recomiendo. Dicho eso, probablemente igual vea la serie porque el tráiler vende una historia distinta, una que ojalá haya sabido corregir los errores del libro.
Finalmente, puedo decir que 𝘽𝙖𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙙𝙤 𝙨𝙤𝙗𝙧𝙚 𝙝𝙞𝙚𝙡𝙤 prometía fake dating, romance, tensión emocional y un homenaje a Jane Austen, pero no cumplió con nada de eso. Una lectura decepcionante, mal ejecutada y fácil de olvidar. Si pudiera, le daría 0 estrellas.
Tengo otras dos reseñas pendientes desde hace días y, aún así, este libro recién terminado se me hizo irónicamente más fácil de reseñar que uno que me haya gustado.
Vi que se había estrenado una serie basada en esta historia en Netflix, así que decidí leer primero la novela antes de ver la adaptación, pero fue un GRAN ERROR.
Voy a detenerme en algo que, como lectora, me molesta profundamente. Soy una gran fanática de Jane Austen. He leído 𝙋𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙪𝙖𝙨𝙞𝙤́𝙣 y puedo afirmar sin ningún problema que esto NO es un retelling de Jane Austen. No se parece en nada: ni en los personajes, ni en los conflictos, ni en el tono, ni en la construcción emocional. Llamar a esto un retelling de 𝙋𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙪𝙖𝙨𝙞𝙤́𝙣 es, sinceramente, un insulto a Jane Austen. De verdad, saquen eso de la descripción, por favor, porque lo único que logra es generar expectativas completamente erróneas y una decepción aún mayor.
Retomando la reseña, parto por lo más evidente: los personajes planos. En ningún momento logré conectar con ninguno de ellos, no hay profundidad emocional, no hay capas y no hay evolución real. Todos aburren, da lo mismo quién esté hablando o actuando porque sus voces se sienten iguales y sus conflictos no generan ningún tipo de implicación emocional en el lector.
Elisa, hermana de la protagonista, merece un párrafo aparte porque pocas veces he leído un personaje tan insufrible. Es incapaz de soltar a un hombre que claramente no le presta atención y que, además, se nota a kilómetros que está enamorado de la hermana de ella (Adriana, la protagonista). Sus actitudes son infantiles, repetitivas y cansinas, en vez de aportar tensión interesante al conflicto, lo único que logra es provocar hastío. Cada aparición suya era una prueba de paciencia.
En realidad, todos los personajes son bastante nefastos, con una única excepción: Brayden. Él es lo único medianamente rescatable del libro a nivel humano. El resto, especialmente la familia de Adriana, es un desastre. Lo más irónico de todo es precisamente eso: su familia. Ni el padre ni las hermanas la apoyan en el baile sobre hielo, siempre la ocultan, la minimizan y la niegan, siendo que Adriana es la única de las hermanas que ha ganado algún premio en su carrera. Esto no solo resulta frustrante como lectora, sino que además no tiene ninguna lógica interna. Es increíble cómo la novela insiste en invisibilizar a la protagonista dentro de su propio entorno, pero sin construir un conflicto sólido o verosímil a partir de eso. Todo se siente forzado, exagerado y mal planteado.
El fake dating es paupérrimo. Se supone que es uno de los pilares de la historia y, sin embargo, está tan mal desarrollado que apenas se sostiene. La relación fingida recién aparece alrededor del 35% del libro, lo cual ya hace que la lectura se sienta innecesariamente lenta. Durante ese primer tramo pasa poco y nada relevante, y cuando por fin se introduce el fake dating, no se explota como debería. Luego ocurre lo contrario: hay un punto en que se siente claramente que la autora pisa el acelerador y todo empieza a pasar demasiado rápido, es como si la historia no encontrara nunca su propio ritmo.
El final fue terrible, llegué a las últimas páginas comprometida únicamente por una cosa: terminar el libro con la esperanza de que el cierre salvara algo de la experiencia. Spoiler: no lo hizo. No hay recompensa emocional, no hay resolución satisfactoria y no hay sensación de “valió la pena”. Es un final que simplemente ocurre y ya, dejando una impresión aún más amarga de todo lo anterior.
¿Lo único rescatable? El patinaje sobre hielo como concepto y, nuevamente, Brayden. La ambientación del mundo del patinaje artístico podría haber sido muy interesante si se hubiera trabajado con más cuidado y detalle, pero queda en la superficie, como casi todo en esta novela.
Es una novela completamente olvidable y, peor aún, mal escrita. No puedo creer que Netflix haya gastado dinero en adaptar este libro teniendo tantas buenas novelas esperando una oportunidad, no la recomiendo. Dicho eso, probablemente igual vea la serie porque el tráiler vende una historia distinta, una que ojalá haya sabido corregir los errores del libro.
Finalmente, puedo decir que 𝘽𝙖𝙞𝙡𝙖𝙣𝙙𝙤 𝙨𝙤𝙗𝙧𝙚 𝙝𝙞𝙚𝙡𝙤 prometía fake dating, romance, tensión emocional y un homenaje a Jane Austen, pero no cumplió con nada de eso. Una lectura decepcionante, mal ejecutada y fácil de olvidar. Si pudiera, le daría 0 estrellas.
December 14, 2025
ˏˋ°•*⁀➷ 2.75/5
I'm super conflicted. While, it was an entertaining YA book, the fake dating trope was really off in this one to start. This next part might be a spoiler, so I'll put it inside the spoiler tag, but
I also think this book ends off too quickly. There were a lot of loose threads that didn't get a wrap to it. I don't know if it makes sense, but somethings were not properly concluded. What happens to Elise? Maria and Charlie? The relationship between Elise and Adriana? The dad? I'm just left with a lot of questions and I think those were questions that were vital to my enjoyment of this book. If addressed, I might have upped the rating more.
That's not to say it was bad, because there were things I enjoyed. For example, I thought the love triangle angles were really interesting and this is coming from someone who absolutely despises love triangles, so I was pleasantly surprised with that.
And to end off, this part wasn't factored into my rating, but the formatting of this book really annoyed me. I haven't had that problem before, but it seriously deterred my reading experience.
Thank you to Jennifer Iacopelli, Penguin Young Readers Group, and Netgalley for this arc.
---------
pre-read: I totally forgot about this arc, reading it asap.
I'm super conflicted. While, it was an entertaining YA book, the fake dating trope was really off in this one to start. This next part might be a spoiler, so I'll put it inside the spoiler tag, but
I also think this book ends off too quickly. There were a lot of loose threads that didn't get a wrap to it. I don't know if it makes sense, but somethings were not properly concluded. What happens to Elise? Maria and Charlie? The relationship between Elise and Adriana? The dad? I'm just left with a lot of questions and I think those were questions that were vital to my enjoyment of this book. If addressed, I might have upped the rating more.
That's not to say it was bad, because there were things I enjoyed. For example, I thought the love triangle angles were really interesting and this is coming from someone who absolutely despises love triangles, so I was pleasantly surprised with that.
And to end off, this part wasn't factored into my rating, but the formatting of this book really annoyed me. I haven't had that problem before, but it seriously deterred my reading experience.
Thank you to Jennifer Iacopelli, Penguin Young Readers Group, and Netgalley for this arc.
---------
pre-read: I totally forgot about this arc, reading it asap.
November 26, 2025
3.25 ⭐️
It is Adriana Russo’s dream to win the Junior World Championships and uphold the family legacy of being a Russo. Born to gold-medalist parents and having an older sister who is going to the Olympics, Adriana feels the pressure of what her winning the skating competition could mean for her and her family, especially when they are struggling financially and might lose their rink.
But when the other skaters arrive to train for the competition, Adriana tries to stay as far away as possible from her former partner and first crush, Freddie O’Connell, who seems to make it his life mission to stay away from her. What makes matters worse is that everyone believes she and her skating partner, Brayden, are into each other due to their chemistry on and off the ice, so Brayden comes up with a plan to use the interest to their advantage: pretend to be dating for the sponsorships and money the Russos desperately need. Adriana agrees to the plan, unaware of the fact that she might actually have feelings for Brayden while harboring feelings for Freddie.
I love, love, love Persuasion! I know this sounds a little wrong, but I love it a smidge more than Pride and Prejudice because I relate to Anne Elliot more than I do to Elizabeth Bennet. I know, I know. Sue me. 😂 So when I began reading, I noticed some similarities in names and plot, and that’s when I realized that, oh my gosh, it’s a retelling (not adaptation–I get those two mixed up all the freaking time) of Persuasion! With that knowledge in mind, I looked at the reviews and winced a little at the negative things said about it. I read both good and bad reviews, and continued reading, interested to see what I thought about it at the end.
Well, folks. The book was pretty good. Now, I don’t know anything about skating, and what goes into it, so I can’t say if the book is accurate or not. But I do know that something was missing here. The plot was interesting enough to keep me engaged through its entirety, even though I felt it was a little longer than it needed to be, and that was due to the fact that it was kinda repetitive. But I understand why a lot of other readers felt mad about Adriana ending up with a certain someone and not the one she had more chemistry with. I don’t know if they read Persuasion (you don’t really need to), but that helped me understand the plot, and I knew from the beginning who she was going to pick at the end.
HOWEVER, Freddie was as bland as an unsalted cracker, Brayden was a chump that had potential, and everyone else had no depth and lacked that spark that makes characters so memorable. I wanted to root for Adriana and Freddie, I really did, but how could I when they hardly talked to each other DURING THE ENTIRE BOOK? Look, it was kind of the same thing in Persuasion, but it was so different because there was depth, character, and personality in Austen’s work. Wentworth was still looking out for Anne, even though he was mad at her, because he still cared about her and wanted her to be happy, because he knew she deserved it. Ugh! It makes me want to cry. If you haven’t read Persuasion, I cannot recommend it enough. 🥹🫶🏼
You know what this book needed to make me root for Freddie and Adriana? Background and context. Showing is very different from telling, and it makes a world of difference. Show me why I should care for them. Instead of telling me that they were good friends as kids and were perfect for each other, either have a dual timeline of them, either in Adriana’s or Freddie’s perspective, when they were kids, so we can see how close they were, or have Freddie’s pov in the book to add that emotional depth to their friendship that was shattered. I know Austen didn’t have Wentworth’s pov in her book, but it’s kinda hard to make teenagers deal with this kind of stuff maturely. It would have been so worth reading the entire book if I got to see the situation in both of their eyes, so I could understand and even like Freddie the way Adriana does. Because Brayden, although he was a chump, was easier to root for because we saw him more and got to see his character a bit better than we did with Freddie.
Phew! I hope I made sense! 😅
All right. I covered all the negatives. What I liked about this book was, first of all, the cover. I mean, it’s cute! 😍 As I said before, the whole Persuasion retelling was really, really fun, and I liked how the author made it modern and YA. The writing was easy to read (very YA), and the whole skating competition plot line was super interesting. ☺ I also liked Adriana. She was trying to be responsible and put her family first before herself, which reminded me of…well, me. So I related to her more than I did the other characters, that’s for sure. 😅 Her dad and sister sucks. 😂
Overall, I enjoyed it, and if you think this will tickle your fancy, then I recommend it! I know it’s not for everyone because it is a YA novel, so keep that in mind. 🩷
Thank you to Penguin Young Readers Group and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own.
❗Content Warnings❗
Blood & mentions loss of a parent.
Swearing: Yes
Spice: No–only kissing. (🌶/5)
#FindingHerEdge #NetGalley
It is Adriana Russo’s dream to win the Junior World Championships and uphold the family legacy of being a Russo. Born to gold-medalist parents and having an older sister who is going to the Olympics, Adriana feels the pressure of what her winning the skating competition could mean for her and her family, especially when they are struggling financially and might lose their rink.
But when the other skaters arrive to train for the competition, Adriana tries to stay as far away as possible from her former partner and first crush, Freddie O’Connell, who seems to make it his life mission to stay away from her. What makes matters worse is that everyone believes she and her skating partner, Brayden, are into each other due to their chemistry on and off the ice, so Brayden comes up with a plan to use the interest to their advantage: pretend to be dating for the sponsorships and money the Russos desperately need. Adriana agrees to the plan, unaware of the fact that she might actually have feelings for Brayden while harboring feelings for Freddie.
I love, love, love Persuasion! I know this sounds a little wrong, but I love it a smidge more than Pride and Prejudice because I relate to Anne Elliot more than I do to Elizabeth Bennet. I know, I know. Sue me. 😂 So when I began reading, I noticed some similarities in names and plot, and that’s when I realized that, oh my gosh, it’s a retelling (not adaptation–I get those two mixed up all the freaking time) of Persuasion! With that knowledge in mind, I looked at the reviews and winced a little at the negative things said about it. I read both good and bad reviews, and continued reading, interested to see what I thought about it at the end.
Well, folks. The book was pretty good. Now, I don’t know anything about skating, and what goes into it, so I can’t say if the book is accurate or not. But I do know that something was missing here. The plot was interesting enough to keep me engaged through its entirety, even though I felt it was a little longer than it needed to be, and that was due to the fact that it was kinda repetitive. But I understand why a lot of other readers felt mad about Adriana ending up with a certain someone and not the one she had more chemistry with. I don’t know if they read Persuasion (you don’t really need to), but that helped me understand the plot, and I knew from the beginning who she was going to pick at the end.
HOWEVER, Freddie was as bland as an unsalted cracker, Brayden was a chump that had potential, and everyone else had no depth and lacked that spark that makes characters so memorable. I wanted to root for Adriana and Freddie, I really did, but how could I when they hardly talked to each other DURING THE ENTIRE BOOK? Look, it was kind of the same thing in Persuasion, but it was so different because there was depth, character, and personality in Austen’s work. Wentworth was still looking out for Anne, even though he was mad at her, because he still cared about her and wanted her to be happy, because he knew she deserved it. Ugh! It makes me want to cry. If you haven’t read Persuasion, I cannot recommend it enough. 🥹🫶🏼
You know what this book needed to make me root for Freddie and Adriana? Background and context. Showing is very different from telling, and it makes a world of difference. Show me why I should care for them. Instead of telling me that they were good friends as kids and were perfect for each other, either have a dual timeline of them, either in Adriana’s or Freddie’s perspective, when they were kids, so we can see how close they were, or have Freddie’s pov in the book to add that emotional depth to their friendship that was shattered. I know Austen didn’t have Wentworth’s pov in her book, but it’s kinda hard to make teenagers deal with this kind of stuff maturely. It would have been so worth reading the entire book if I got to see the situation in both of their eyes, so I could understand and even like Freddie the way Adriana does. Because Brayden, although he was a chump, was easier to root for because we saw him more and got to see his character a bit better than we did with Freddie.
Phew! I hope I made sense! 😅
All right. I covered all the negatives. What I liked about this book was, first of all, the cover. I mean, it’s cute! 😍 As I said before, the whole Persuasion retelling was really, really fun, and I liked how the author made it modern and YA. The writing was easy to read (very YA), and the whole skating competition plot line was super interesting. ☺ I also liked Adriana. She was trying to be responsible and put her family first before herself, which reminded me of…well, me. So I related to her more than I did the other characters, that’s for sure. 😅 Her dad and sister sucks. 😂
Overall, I enjoyed it, and if you think this will tickle your fancy, then I recommend it! I know it’s not for everyone because it is a YA novel, so keep that in mind. 🩷
Thank you to Penguin Young Readers Group and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own.
❗Content Warnings❗
Blood & mentions loss of a parent.
Swearing: Yes
Spice: No–only kissing. (🌶/5)
#FindingHerEdge #NetGalley
February 3, 2026
I hate when beautiful art is wasted on a shitty book.
don’t waste your time.
don’t waste your time.
July 22, 2025
An update I never dreamed of making: FINDING HER EDGE IS GOING TO BE ON NETFLIX!
Check out the announcement here!
And if you're reading Finding Her Edge for the very first time, FOR REASONS, you should probably ignore that epilogue. Just...put your hands over your eyes and pretend it does not exist.
Check out the announcement here!
And if you're reading Finding Her Edge for the very first time, FOR REASONS, you should probably ignore that epilogue. Just...put your hands over your eyes and pretend it does not exist.
January 27, 2026
I have a lot to say about this book. First you set up the perfect love interest Brayden and Adriana doesn’t even end up with him? They do the whole fake dating thing and nothing comes of it. I’m so confused why she chose for Adriana to end up with Freddie instead. It literally comes out of nowhere like 80% into the book. I get she used to have a crush on the guy. But they had like no chemistry. A majority of the book seemed to be setting up Adriana and Brayden ending up together but then a curve ball is thrown at you and they don’t. If Freddie had more time in the book and more interactions with Adriana then it would have made a little more sense for her to choose him.
It’s like the writer had a whole book written in her head about Adriana and Freddie’s relationship but decided not to show more of it. I really hate leaving such a bad review but I had such high hopes for this book. I love the fake dating trope so much and I was just let down because usually the two people who fake date end up together…
It’s like the writer had a whole book written in her head about Adriana and Freddie’s relationship but decided not to show more of it. I really hate leaving such a bad review but I had such high hopes for this book. I love the fake dating trope so much and I was just let down because usually the two people who fake date end up together…
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 14, 2025
I thought I was getting myself into a heart fluttering, feet kicking, sweet romance on ice. I was wrong.
Sure, it had all the elements in it- fake dating, childhood friends, love triangles, it had all the elements of becoming a sweet, heart fluttering, mind numbingly absolutely diabetes causing romance. So then, I ask myself, what went wrong.
There were so many tropes that it seemed there was no time for all of them to be done justice. I was constantly agitated by the main character, who, it seems, does not give any shits about any of the people around her. Her personality and the way she treated EVERYONE around her got on my nerves. I kept waiting for her to redeem herself for her actions, but instead of doing something to make her at least a tiny bit likable, she kept doing things that made me hate her more, with no repercussions or regret, and on the contrary, receiving ENCOURAGEMENT for her actions instead of someone just CALLING HER OUT.
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𝓟𝓻𝓮 𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
Reading this cause I need a meaningless lighthearted read. Hope this delivers!
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for providing me with this book in exchange of my honest review.
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
Sure, it had all the elements in it- fake dating, childhood friends, love triangles, it had all the elements of becoming a sweet, heart fluttering, mind numbingly absolutely diabetes causing romance. So then, I ask myself, what went wrong.
There were so many tropes that it seemed there was no time for all of them to be done justice. I was constantly agitated by the main character, who, it seems, does not give any shits about any of the people around her. Her personality and the way she treated EVERYONE around her got on my nerves. I kept waiting for her to redeem herself for her actions, but instead of doing something to make her at least a tiny bit likable, she kept doing things that made me hate her more, with no repercussions or regret, and on the contrary, receiving ENCOURAGEMENT for her actions instead of someone just CALLING HER OUT.
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𝓟𝓻𝓮 𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
Reading this cause I need a meaningless lighthearted read. Hope this delivers!
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for providing me with this book in exchange of my honest review.
𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲𑣲
January 31, 2026
#justiceforbrayden
February 5, 2026
thanks you to netgalley and the publisher for providing me with this arc. all thoughts are my own.
UPDATE i watched an edit of the show and im team Brayden (hes not giving wet sock in the show 🫶🫶🫶)
2.75 (rounded up for the cover)
I guess this book was for me during a time of my life where I havent written a rant review in a hot second. you know when you have the unearthly desire to just argue with someone for the fun of it? my name is not Karen I swear.
well finding her edge made me find something to cope if im gonna be honest. I freaking love figure skating. so much so that I had the desire for a brief stint in time to become professional.
until I remember I was 15 at the time and lived in a place where it snowed once in a blue moon.
yeah figure skating was not a life goal. but I do love reading about it. and ice dancing? sign me the heck up. I love watching th4 Olympics (yuzuru hanyu😌) but I digress. I wasnt here to talk about hot guys in figure skating.
this book should have stayed on wattpad. and I say that with the utmost respect to wattpad btw.
but some things just need to chill and NOT BE TURNED INTO A NETFLIX SHOW!? guys guys chill. its okay to let things stay on dead trees okay?!?
I think this book had a love triangle but the author didn't know how a triangle was shaped so she truly just winged it like a toddler.
because I hated both of them. like u gotta fake a relationship with the guy who is ur skating partner for....sponsorships?
if times are that tough just sell feet pics because Brayden was a wet sock.
and Freddie was like the guy you rejected in third grade but he lowk still hasn't gotten over it.
the chemistry was lacking. ive had more chemistry with the guy at my boba shop when he says "your order number is "34" than what I was reading this which is a romance novel.
it ended too fast and wrapped up everything a little too neatly. what happened with her dad and all the other side characters that im too lazy to list bc it doesnt deserve my time.
so if u really like reading ice skating romance novels that lowk suck. id say pick up this book! dont come for the love interests tho, they will not deliver. but diGiorno will.
UPDATE i watched an edit of the show and im team Brayden (hes not giving wet sock in the show 🫶🫶🫶)
2.75 (rounded up for the cover)
I guess this book was for me during a time of my life where I havent written a rant review in a hot second. you know when you have the unearthly desire to just argue with someone for the fun of it? my name is not Karen I swear.
well finding her edge made me find something to cope if im gonna be honest. I freaking love figure skating. so much so that I had the desire for a brief stint in time to become professional.
until I remember I was 15 at the time and lived in a place where it snowed once in a blue moon.
yeah figure skating was not a life goal. but I do love reading about it. and ice dancing? sign me the heck up. I love watching th4 Olympics (yuzuru hanyu😌) but I digress. I wasnt here to talk about hot guys in figure skating.
this book should have stayed on wattpad. and I say that with the utmost respect to wattpad btw.
but some things just need to chill and NOT BE TURNED INTO A NETFLIX SHOW!? guys guys chill. its okay to let things stay on dead trees okay?!?
I think this book had a love triangle but the author didn't know how a triangle was shaped so she truly just winged it like a toddler.
because I hated both of them. like u gotta fake a relationship with the guy who is ur skating partner for....sponsorships?
if times are that tough just sell feet pics because Brayden was a wet sock.
and Freddie was like the guy you rejected in third grade but he lowk still hasn't gotten over it.
the chemistry was lacking. ive had more chemistry with the guy at my boba shop when he says "your order number is "34" than what I was reading this which is a romance novel.
it ended too fast and wrapped up everything a little too neatly. what happened with her dad and all the other side characters that im too lazy to list bc it doesnt deserve my time.
so if u really like reading ice skating romance novels that lowk suck. id say pick up this book! dont come for the love interests tho, they will not deliver. but diGiorno will.
July 23, 2025
13 year old figure skater me would’ve loved this, current me thinks she picked the wrong guy lol
January 22, 2026
Just finished the show as well, the ending is actually even worse than before.
October 15, 2022
Two Things About Me:
1. I LOVE Jane Austen. Teaching my unit on Austen to my students is one of my most favorite things to do as a teacher. Persuasion is in my top three of her novels, where it falls specifically depends on my mood.
2. I am a FAN™️ of Ice Dance-not just figure skating in general but specifically Ice Dance. The other three disciplines I watch casually during Nats, Worlds, and the Olympics (sometimes also Europeans and 4CC if time permits). Ice Dance I schedule into my weekend during every Grand Prix of the season and as much as I possibly can during Challenger and Junior comps.
This book was always going to be a love it or hate it for me. I did firmly tell myself that I would let inconsistencies about the skating that wouldn't be noticeable to casual fans slide as long as they weren't too egregious. While I have a major quibble with the skating, my bigger problem with this book is all the reasons it is a subpar Persuasion retelling.
Every novel Austen wrote has a dichotomy between a Bad Man and a Good Man. (Those two descriptors are bland and reductive, but I'm not currently writing that essay.) Every single one of her villains falls on the spectrum of sexual predator (some to more extremes than others). The villain in Persuasion is the mildest form this takes, but he is still very much not a good person who sees women as disposable in his quest for what he wants. Iacopelli made the mistake of turning the foil for her Wentworth character into an actual decent person she spent more time developing than she did Wentworth's counterpart in this book. I was not at all surprised to skim the reviews on this and discover that so many people were outraged about how the romance pans out. Freddie is mayonnaise on white bread with the crusts cut off. (Frederick Wentworth deserves so much better. UGH.) I think in many ways the author was leaning into this being a reworking of Persuasion to do the work for her in selling the Adriana/Freddie ship, but the problem there is her target audience is teenagers, and none of my students have ever walked into my English class having read Persuasion. If they have experience with Austen, it's Pride and Prejudice or Emma. And of course they would be outraged. Brayden is the one with the personality, charm, and evident care for Adriana. He is the other half of the fake dating scheme, and the first half of the book focuses on his relationship with Adriana. Zero surprise people are mad.
The family dynamic part of this succeeds in being both an excellent reflection of the dynamics in the source work AND an interesting look at the pressures and nepotism prevalent in skating overall. Too bad this book wasn't just about that. It could have been great.
Regarding the figures skating. Here's the thing that bothered me the most. Iacopelli grounded her FS world in real world skating by placing the 2022 Olympics in Beijing, the 2026 Olympics in Milan, AND name dropping Gabriella Papadakis and Guillaume Cizeron. I could have moved past the first two. Throwing real live people in the mix means we're now truly grounded in real life skating. If P/C exist in this world, then don't all the US Senior Ice Dance Teams, who Iacopelli had the audacity to say tanked in Beijing? (I know she was writing this before the Olympics actually arrived, but what does she have against H/D, C/B, and H/B that she would send those kind of vibes their way?) The US Olympic Team comes in 5th in the Beijing team event somehow in this book, and (here's where it got really annoying) the USFSA* is toying with the notion of sending Adriana/Braden to Senior Worlds because of how bad the Senior teams competed at the Olympics, which is RIDICULOUS. First, it's ridiculous because there is nothing FS audiences love more than a redemption narrative arc, so Olympic failure doesn't mean diddly squat when it comes to attending Worlds. Second, Worlds assignments are determined at Nationals. At the end of Nats weekend, USFSA chooses the teams that will compete at Worlds AND THEIR ALTERNATES. The US Senior Ice Dance bench is DEEP. For a team that had only ever competed as Juniors to be sent to Senior Worlds, all the Senior teams would have to be tragically blown up on a boat during a party a la Will Ferrell's Eurovision movie. Even then why would they bother when the required technical elements are not the same? They would need TWO new (or at the very least greatly reworked) programs. The most annoying part is this didn't need including to raise the stakes, and it just kept getting brought up for the last 1/4 of the novel, so I couldn't ignore it either.
Either your skating world needs to be made up out of whole cloth or grounded in reality. Don't straddle.
*Called something else in this book probably for trademark reasons. (Me giving the benefit of the doubt about author's research skills.)
1. I LOVE Jane Austen. Teaching my unit on Austen to my students is one of my most favorite things to do as a teacher. Persuasion is in my top three of her novels, where it falls specifically depends on my mood.
2. I am a FAN™️ of Ice Dance-not just figure skating in general but specifically Ice Dance. The other three disciplines I watch casually during Nats, Worlds, and the Olympics (sometimes also Europeans and 4CC if time permits). Ice Dance I schedule into my weekend during every Grand Prix of the season and as much as I possibly can during Challenger and Junior comps.
This book was always going to be a love it or hate it for me. I did firmly tell myself that I would let inconsistencies about the skating that wouldn't be noticeable to casual fans slide as long as they weren't too egregious. While I have a major quibble with the skating, my bigger problem with this book is all the reasons it is a subpar Persuasion retelling.
Every novel Austen wrote has a dichotomy between a Bad Man and a Good Man. (Those two descriptors are bland and reductive, but I'm not currently writing that essay.) Every single one of her villains falls on the spectrum of sexual predator (some to more extremes than others). The villain in Persuasion is the mildest form this takes, but he is still very much not a good person who sees women as disposable in his quest for what he wants. Iacopelli made the mistake of turning the foil for her Wentworth character into an actual decent person she spent more time developing than she did Wentworth's counterpart in this book. I was not at all surprised to skim the reviews on this and discover that so many people were outraged about how the romance pans out. Freddie is mayonnaise on white bread with the crusts cut off. (Frederick Wentworth deserves so much better. UGH.) I think in many ways the author was leaning into this being a reworking of Persuasion to do the work for her in selling the Adriana/Freddie ship, but the problem there is her target audience is teenagers, and none of my students have ever walked into my English class having read Persuasion. If they have experience with Austen, it's Pride and Prejudice or Emma. And of course they would be outraged. Brayden is the one with the personality, charm, and evident care for Adriana. He is the other half of the fake dating scheme, and the first half of the book focuses on his relationship with Adriana. Zero surprise people are mad.
The family dynamic part of this succeeds in being both an excellent reflection of the dynamics in the source work AND an interesting look at the pressures and nepotism prevalent in skating overall. Too bad this book wasn't just about that. It could have been great.
Regarding the figures skating. Here's the thing that bothered me the most. Iacopelli grounded her FS world in real world skating by placing the 2022 Olympics in Beijing, the 2026 Olympics in Milan, AND name dropping Gabriella Papadakis and Guillaume Cizeron. I could have moved past the first two. Throwing real live people in the mix means we're now truly grounded in real life skating. If P/C exist in this world, then don't all the US Senior Ice Dance Teams, who Iacopelli had the audacity to say tanked in Beijing? (I know she was writing this before the Olympics actually arrived, but what does she have against H/D, C/B, and H/B that she would send those kind of vibes their way?) The US Olympic Team comes in 5th in the Beijing team event somehow in this book, and (here's where it got really annoying) the USFSA* is toying with the notion of sending Adriana/Braden to Senior Worlds because of how bad the Senior teams competed at the Olympics, which is RIDICULOUS. First, it's ridiculous because there is nothing FS audiences love more than a redemption narrative arc, so Olympic failure doesn't mean diddly squat when it comes to attending Worlds. Second, Worlds assignments are determined at Nationals. At the end of Nats weekend, USFSA chooses the teams that will compete at Worlds AND THEIR ALTERNATES. The US Senior Ice Dance bench is DEEP. For a team that had only ever competed as Juniors to be sent to Senior Worlds, all the Senior teams would have to be tragically blown up on a boat during a party a la Will Ferrell's Eurovision movie. Even then why would they bother when the required technical elements are not the same? They would need TWO new (or at the very least greatly reworked) programs. The most annoying part is this didn't need including to raise the stakes, and it just kept getting brought up for the last 1/4 of the novel, so I couldn't ignore it either.
Either your skating world needs to be made up out of whole cloth or grounded in reality. Don't straddle.
*Called something else in this book probably for trademark reasons. (Me giving the benefit of the doubt about author's research skills.)
![Profile Image for kimi [semi-ia] ‧₊˚ ⋅.](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1703590167i%2F154144215._UX200_CR0%2C0%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
Currently reading
November 8, 2025 ⁀➴༯ pre-read
♒︎ thank you netgalley for this arc !! ♡
♒︎ thank you netgalley for this arc !! ♡
January 24, 2026
Fake dating trope but no endgame? Jail. Justice for Brayden.
October 9, 2021
So sweet and swoony… this was the perfect read for all those who were captivated by Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir!
January 29, 2026
Não sei se ia com as expectativas tão baixas que me surpreendi mas eu gostei! Tirava o triângulo amoroso como é óbvio, mas adorei a parte da patinagem, o grupo e as personagens
Não sei se quero ver a série da Netflix tou com medo
Não sei se quero ver a série da Netflix tou com medo
January 30, 2026
this is the worst thing I’ve ever read
March 7, 2023
Wenn man mich fragen würde ob dieses Buch besonders tiefgründig war, einen tollen Plot hatte oder mit nicht kindischen Charakteren überzeugen könnte dann müsste ich diese Fragen (leider) verneinen. Es war eine sehr flache Geschichte mit einem sehr vorhersehbaren Ende, sehr viel künstlich erzeugtem Drama und (aufgrund des Alters) wahnsinnig kindischen Reaktionen auf Dinge. Hab ich die Geschichte trotzdem absolut verschlungen, wollte immer weiterlesen und hab so etwas wie Spannung verspürt? Absolut! Zum Ende hin wurde es sogar richtig emotional, und ich hatte Gänsehaut bei den Dingen, die so passiert sind. Das Buch konnte mich also richtig richtig gut unterhalten, und da ich Storys über Eiskunstlaufen bzw. Jegliche Art von Sport Wettkämpfen in Büchern total gerne lese waren die oben benannten Punkte total irrelevant. Ich wollte sie euch trotzdem nicht vorenthalten, weil man einfach nicht mit einer großen Erwartung an das Buch gehen sollte. Wenn man diese allerdings runterschraubt und sich einfach ein wenig berieseln oder unterhalten lassen will: Go for it! Ich habe es tatsächlich sehr genossen!
June 26, 2020
I absolutely shipped the WRONG team, but nonetheless I could not put this book down! Jen is one of the best YA sports writers for girls. Her books are feminist and fun and they never pit the girls against each other, which I love! This one is a delightful retelling of my favorite Austen book PERSUASION, set against a backdrop of Boston & figure skaters headed to the Olympics. Complete with an adorkable letter. (But yeah I still rooted for the wrong ship bahaha!). Cannot wait to see what the final book is like!!!
January 24, 2026
Sabem à quanto tempo é que não ficava do lado que perde no triângulo amoroso? Estou chateada, é que isto nem fez sentido mas pronto
Review of advance copy received from Otros
Comencé este libro porque vi que Netflix estrenó su adaptación pero antes de ver la serie quería leer el libro y al ser super corto le di prioridad. No sabía que era un Retelling de "Persuasión" de Jane Austen ❤️ hasta que lo terminé al final me hizo click jajaja. 🤭
Es la primera vez que leo a la autora, no sabía que esperar al ser un drama de patinadores sobre hielo la cosa sé vuelve aún más interesante. Todo apuntaba a un buen drama con lo de la relación falsa.
Todo es desde la perspectiva de Adriana, todo es muy de adolescentes de hecho demasiado rayando lo infantil al menos para mi. Hay momentos donde sé me hacía muy pesado y me desesperaba 😫 fue cuando dije: ¿Porqué sé empeñan en hacer adaptaciones de los peores libros que encuentran? ¿Acaso los derechos son más baratos? Porque sigo esperando la adaptación de libros buenísimos. Con decir que ya quería que terminara. 😬🫠 Adriana sobre piensa todo el tiempo y me parece muy aburrida.
La hermana de Adriana es insoportable una mean girl a toda regla. Para su mala suerte Adriana sé roba la atención por ser más simpática y sé ve en la necesidad de fingir una relación con su compañero de baile Brayden. Por su parte este es super simpático y la verdad es la alegría de la historia. Me encantó.
Luego tenemos a Freddie un excompañero de Adriana y antiguo amor. La verdad este último no ne gustó. Creo que me acostumbré tanto a Brayden que Freddie me cayó muy mal. Al ser un triángulo amoroso conforme avanzaba la trama todo sé complica más y más. La verdad el final del libro no me gustó en mi mente eso no pasó 🤭 me niego a pensarlo.
Por otra parte agradezco infinitamente que Netflix haya hecho su magia con la serie ya que le da más profundidad a los personajes de la hermana y el papá. Porque en el libro tienen la profundidad de un charco. Aunque hay notables cambios y más tramas en la serie mantiene la esencia e incluso los mejora. Sobre todo a la no rivalidad entre mujeres. No tiene spicy.
De tanto que no me gustó el libro hasta pensé seriamente en no ver la serie. Esto para no volver al mal sabor de boca que me dejó la novela. Pero aquí el triángulo amoroso tiene más construcción sobre todo con Freddie. La verdad sufrí con la serie pero hasta cierto punto me gustó el final que le dieron. Espero la renueven.
Me habría encantado que la adaptara HBO para ver la secuencia inspirada en Game of Thrones. 🤭 Y ame las referencias a Jane Austen.❤️
En general este es otro me gustó más la adaptación que el libro. 😬
Es la primera vez que leo a la autora, no sabía que esperar al ser un drama de patinadores sobre hielo la cosa sé vuelve aún más interesante. Todo apuntaba a un buen drama con lo de la relación falsa.
Todo es desde la perspectiva de Adriana, todo es muy de adolescentes de hecho demasiado rayando lo infantil al menos para mi. Hay momentos donde sé me hacía muy pesado y me desesperaba 😫 fue cuando dije: ¿Porqué sé empeñan en hacer adaptaciones de los peores libros que encuentran? ¿Acaso los derechos son más baratos? Porque sigo esperando la adaptación de libros buenísimos. Con decir que ya quería que terminara. 😬🫠 Adriana sobre piensa todo el tiempo y me parece muy aburrida.
La hermana de Adriana es insoportable una mean girl a toda regla. Para su mala suerte Adriana sé roba la atención por ser más simpática y sé ve en la necesidad de fingir una relación con su compañero de baile Brayden. Por su parte este es super simpático y la verdad es la alegría de la historia. Me encantó.
Luego tenemos a Freddie un excompañero de Adriana y antiguo amor. La verdad este último no ne gustó. Creo que me acostumbré tanto a Brayden que Freddie me cayó muy mal. Al ser un triángulo amoroso conforme avanzaba la trama todo sé complica más y más. La verdad el final del libro no me gustó en mi mente eso no pasó 🤭 me niego a pensarlo.
Por otra parte agradezco infinitamente que Netflix haya hecho su magia con la serie ya que le da más profundidad a los personajes de la hermana y el papá. Porque en el libro tienen la profundidad de un charco. Aunque hay notables cambios y más tramas en la serie mantiene la esencia e incluso los mejora. Sobre todo a la no rivalidad entre mujeres. No tiene spicy.
De tanto que no me gustó el libro hasta pensé seriamente en no ver la serie. Esto para no volver al mal sabor de boca que me dejó la novela. Pero aquí el triángulo amoroso tiene más construcción sobre todo con Freddie. La verdad sufrí con la serie pero hasta cierto punto me gustó el final que le dieron. Espero la renueven.
Me habría encantado que la adaptara HBO para ver la secuencia inspirada en Game of Thrones. 🤭 Y ame las referencias a Jane Austen.❤️
En general este es otro me gustó más la adaptación que el libro. 😬
February 24, 2026
Mais c’était très cute tout ça ! J’ai beaucoup aimé le personnage principal et toute l’histoire de sa famille et l’aspect sport qui était hyper bien mis en avant ! La romance est mignonne, bien green flag aussi et ça fait du bien ! Pas de smut, c’est du YA très chouette et j’ai passé un très bon moment de lecture ! Je serai curieuse de voir l’adaptation à l’écran maintenant 👀
February 7, 2026
2,5/2,75 ⭐ z perspektywy czytelnika dorosłego, ale dla młodzieży będzie w sam raz - nic toksycznego czy wulgarnego, dynamiczna akcja, bohaterowie, z którymi łatwo się związać, aktualne problemy nastolatków.
January 22, 2026
Decided to read this because I saw that Netflix is adapting it into a show and I have to say, this is one of those rare times when I hope the show diverges from the book. The book felt very rushed and bland, and I agree with all the reviews saying that the love triangle was very poorly done. Overall, there was potential but it fell very very flat.
January 19, 2026
Girl, are you kidding me? I was so excited to read this book because of the Netflix show coming out, but it was a huge disappointment. I mean, Adriana, while I didn't think she was a great protagonist, wasn't annoying, and the love triangle was ridiculous. How can you have a fake dating (with the best guy) and then have the endgame be with the guy she hasn't seen in like two years and with whom she only had like three (super awkward) conversations in the whole book? I don't know if I should watch the show anymore
February 15, 2022
Just finished reading Finding Her Edge! ✨
I absolutely flew through this book, stayed up until after midnight (something I haven’t done for quite some time) and the romance brought me back to my Wattpad days where I would devour romance after romance 🤌🏻💓 It had the fake dating trope, extremely cute love interest BUT also a love triangle which sadly didn’t end the way I wanted it to which extremely disappointed me. Why set readers up with such an amazing love interest (I was 100% invested y’all) when she’s just going to leave him hanging? And let me tell you, that guy was absolutely head over heels! I did not vibe with the other love interest at all and did not see this coming for a second. I even got to, like, despise the main character for her actions and stringing others along towards the end of the book.
Brayden is the absolute sweetest and deserved so so so much better!
But, because the first 70% of the book was really good, was extremely promising in the romance department and for the fact that the main character was actually likeable (which sadly couldn’t be said for the last 30%) I’ll still give this book 🌟🌟🌟 (3) stars.
I absolutely flew through this book, stayed up until after midnight (something I haven’t done for quite some time) and the romance brought me back to my Wattpad days where I would devour romance after romance 🤌🏻💓 It had the fake dating trope, extremely cute love interest BUT also a love triangle which sadly didn’t end the way I wanted it to which extremely disappointed me. Why set readers up with such an amazing love interest (I was 100% invested y’all) when she’s just going to leave him hanging? And let me tell you, that guy was absolutely head over heels! I did not vibe with the other love interest at all and did not see this coming for a second. I even got to, like, despise the main character for her actions and stringing others along towards the end of the book.
Brayden is the absolute sweetest and deserved so so so much better!
But, because the first 70% of the book was really good, was extremely promising in the romance department and for the fact that the main character was actually likeable (which sadly couldn’t be said for the last 30%) I’ll still give this book 🌟🌟🌟 (3) stars.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 28, 2022
This was... fine? I think contemporary Persuasion retellings are hard, and translating that to YA is even harder. This kind of worked, but also kind of didn't. And really the romance of it all felt like a B or C plot in the grand scheme of things. The way all of it wrapped up kind of felt flat, and the big emotional moment of The Letter didn't pack the punch it should have. I don't know what I wanted from an epilogue, either, but... not that??
I also found the blending of this fake figure skating world and the actual sport to be a bit strange and didn't hit the right balance for me. There were also a few mistakes that I think should have been caught in editing by someone who has basic knowledge of the sport (or the ability to Google, for example, the differences between ice dance and pairs), and I admit those stood out for me.
One thing that was great for me here was the references to how Adriana cared for/dealt with her curly hair. Genuinely appreciated the handful of those references we got!
I also found the blending of this fake figure skating world and the actual sport to be a bit strange and didn't hit the right balance for me. There were also a few mistakes that I think should have been caught in editing by someone who has basic knowledge of the sport (or the ability to Google, for example, the differences between ice dance and pairs), and I admit those stood out for me.
One thing that was great for me here was the references to how Adriana cared for/dealt with her curly hair. Genuinely appreciated the handful of those references we got!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 979 reviews