Thank you to Netgalley, the publishers and the author for this advanced reader copy ebook.
So, I read the first book in this series purely based its cover – I saw it in the window of Waterstones and just had to have it. And I was blown away by how much I enjoyed it. So I devoured the second and was chuffed to pieces to be able to read the third one before publication date.
And what a book! The imagination of Ms Harrison is quite astounding – I absolutely loved the idea of a secret room and the Tick Tock forest. Some of her ideas are just so original and are handled with perfection. We still have the nesting dolls, which, lets face it, have always had a deep charm but now in mind will always be linked with this series. And Betty and Charlie use them to their advantage, even when facing less good magic.
So after the events of the last novel, the girls and their father and brilliant Granny have left the Sorrow Isles and have found a new home in Pendlewick – a rather clever reference I felt to the Pendle witches in Lancashire – but it’s not the end of their days of adventure, Pendlewick is a village with a dark secret, and Betty, strong, unsuperstitious Betty, must find out what is going on.
The plot is brilliant – so well worked out, so clever, so surprising – I really didn’t see the twist coming and I almost always notice twists! The characters are just as good as always: the girls are warm and supportive of each other, but with distinct personalities. I adore Charlie and her stubborn streak with her love of all animals. Betty, whose point of view the story is told from still adores her maps, feels quietly jealous of Fliss but who is less annoyed by her younger sister is growing into a well rounded character, full of verve but with traditional teenage doubts. And whilst there is less of Fliss in this book (for reasons that will become apparent as you read it) her kind nature is in evidence again, and her pure hatred of boats! I’d have liked more Granny because she could easily be the star of the show – could she go on one of their adventures next? And Barney is barely a footnote. And Spit? He really should have come with them to Pendlewick!
This is a perfect book for children aged 8+ my own daughter at 6 is too young for it but she is starting to be fascinated by some of the concepts – especially the nesting dolls and I look forward to reading all of them with her in the coming years. However, these aren’t in anyway patronizing, I feel like they were written for me as much as for a child. Yes they are about children, but all of us were that age once and this is just a great story with believable characters and females that act on their own agency. This novel passes the Bechdel test in spades.
Clearly the ending, whilst very satisfying leaves way for another story and I really hope there is one.