Note: Some minor spoilers in my rant. This book has a TW for the loss of a parent, which I also mention below. Take care of yourself <3 by not reading this book that I do not recommend.
This book was terrible. Was it objectively terrible? Kind of. Like I get some things didn't work for me but they are tropes others love (fated mates, small town, cinnamon hero that can do no wrong). But god, the world-building was underwhelming and disappointing at best. I was so excited about potentially finding a new Urban Fantasy to fall in love with. Witches! Found family! Queer rep! But sadly, there isn't much about the witches' world.
There isn't much clarity about their culture; do they just "exist" in the United States? do they have their own language? are the elders the leaders of the community? how do they even know what the young witches are doing? If they hate mundanes (aka humans) so much, do they have their separate communities from humans then? Do they have their own economy, education, and society apart from the rest of the United States? If they do, we don't actually see it. For a book that has a strong conflict about elders' prejudice about humans, the culture of the witches is never that present in the story. Yes, yes, we hear about Danica's coven slash book club but that is it. We don't see the tight community that they go on and on about. And to be so hateful about humans, why do they even use human technology? Why do they even live in a small town of humans? It makes no sense. NO SENSE.
It was also deeply uncomfortable to hear Danica's grandmother go on and on about blood purity and keeping their family line. I just don't get it. What was the point of having grandma a strong side character in the story but completely forgetting to add the world-building she is defending so hard? Yeah, we are not supposed to root for her but I never completely get the stakes in the story, honesty. So what if Danica dates a human. So what if she tells him about magic. What's the point of anything in this story? Besides her friends, her community is not even that strong in the story, or in her life for that matter. So what if she loses it?
I'm frustrated because the point of Urban Fantasy is to have a strong world, maybe parallel to the real world, but a world with its own rules, history, and culture. And the world becomes a character of the story. So yes, it's frustrating. But especially here because without that strong world, the stakes are never that high. And the main conflict of the couple then falls completely apart.
Witch Please is full of tropes; fated mates, small town, meddling family, cinnamon roll hero. But their romance fell completely flat to me. There was no real substance. And you know, I get it. I'm not a fan of the "I saw you for the first time and I knew we were meant to be, you are going to be my wife and mother of my children." Excuse me, sir, you haven't even talked. You don't even know if she is interested in you! Or in a relationship! Or even in children. See, I get these are romantic lines for many people, I find it cheesy and uncomfortable. Their relationship goes like this on and on, with Titus imagining their life together after knowing each other for what? Two weeks? Dude, just calm the hell down!
If I had liked Titus, maybe I wouldn't have been this irritated. But I detested him. These cinnamon roll heroes that can do no wrong are starting to get on my nerves. I'm all here for cinnamon roll heroes! But Titus has no real depth, he is perfect in every way; he is kind, patient, a baker, he volunteers and cares for his neighbors, animals, and community, he hasn't had sex but it's extremely good at it... A list of good deeds is not a personality trait, sir.
Also, his relationship with his father is so weird. Yeah, his father is an ass but takes Titus so long to recognize that grief is different for each person that I was very frustrated. He is upset his father remarried after his mother passed away (too quickly in his opinion) and then moved to a different state with his family. Although he tells us he's upset with his dad, he treats his father's new wife like trash. Saying she stole his father from them and calling her hysterical when she's freaking PREGNANT. I don't know if I'm more upset about the stereotype (hysterical pregnancy) or from the disrespect of this ass. Everyone is going on and on about how good Titus is and then he's treating this woman (that hasn't done anything wrong to him) so condescending. And sure, his father is not great. But Titus is a grown-ass adult being upset because he feels abandoned and replaced. Instead of discussing any of these feelings with his father, like an adult, he proceeds to ignore his younger stepsiblings and being jealous of his unborn sibling. God, this is so freaking dumb. I can't take it. And the resolution to his whole conflict was so unsatisfying. There is no real discussion with his father, but still Titus decides to become a guardian? Like it's nothing. Seriously, what's the point of this book again?
Honestly, I couldn't care about Danica and Titus's love story any less. I wasn't root for them, I was frustrated by their main conflict and how it was resolved. Aka, it wasn't at all. Completely brushed aside after spending PAGES and PAGES agonizing about it. What was the point of so many words about how they couldn't be together to then be WHATEVER IT DIDN'T EVEN MATTER AFTER ALL? Yeah.