In 1938 T.S. Eliot struck up a friendship with Mary Trevelyan, a passionately curious woman and intrepid traveller. Their relationship was cosy and domestic - characterised by churchgoing, record-playing, day trips with Mary at the wheel or Eliot in his rolled shirt-sleeves cooking up sausages for dinner. Over the years, Mary came to believe that their friendship might lead to something more . . . but their journey together did not end as she would have hoped.
Trevelyan left a unique document - of diaries, letters and pictures - charting their twenty-year-long relationship in her vivid prose. Erica Wagner has brought this untold story together for the first time. Mary and Mr Eliot is a revelatory tale of joy, misunderstanding and betrayal that feels utterly modern and deeply human.
Mary Trevelyan (1897–1983) was a British activist for foreign students, seeking to ease their lives in England, and also a keen traveler who went to many of the places in Asia from which those students hailed. She maintained a close friendship with T.S. Eliot between 1938 and 1956, when she was essentially the woman of his life, though he never committed to a romantic relationship with her and (we now know) he was long grappling with feelings for his childhood friend Emily Hale. Following the Eliot’s marriage to his secretary Valerie Fletcher, after which he rather coldly cut off ties with Trevelyan, she wrote a memoir of her time with Eliot entitled “The Pope of Russell Square”. Trevelyan drew on her own diaries to give a detailed year-by-year account. Though this typescript was unpublished, it could be consulted over the years by scholars, and details within it found their way into various Eliot biographies.
This book aims to present a much larger amount of the “The Pope of Russell Square” material to readers, with editor Erica Wagner’s commentary giving some wider context for the events described. Now, this often delves into the minutiae of Eliot’s life at this time and is not the sort of general biography that most readers are looking for – Robert Crawford’s two-volume biography is the most recent major one and can be recommended. However, Trevelyan’s account does provide a more detailed sketch of the man behind the literary figure than perhaps any other biography. We get a sense of Eliot’s sense of humor, his fashion sense, his religious routines, his foibles and personal flaws. Poignantly, we learn how Eliot was also grappling with depression during these years, and Trevelyan describes him growing increasingly old and infirm.
All in all, this book is an entertaining read for passionate fans of T.S. Eliot who have already read the big biographies. However, it must be emphasized that in the years that this book covers, Eliot was no longer an active poet but merely an elder statesman of literature and a writer of not highly esteemed plays; we are a long way from The Waste Land and, soon, even Four Quartets.
As I read the book, I sometimes felt that its author was more interesting than her subject – Mary Trevelyan was a remarkable figure, and I am grateful for the opportunity here to learn about her, too.
It’s the humdrum details that are such a joy, however. Tins of beef falling out of Eliot’s coat pocket, how he launches into a phone conversation without saying hello, his anxieties about the suitability of his gentleman’s bathing drawers, his pleasure in new gadgets and his announcing of intimate personal ailments at dinner." So writes Country Life about this informative, stunning and smart work by Erica Wagner, and I couldn't agree more I was swept away with how
"He does the washing up in rolled-up sleeves, has the key to her flat so he can let himself in without disturbing her, rings just to say goodnight and talks to her through the bathroom door. "
Who else but Wagner -- author of one of the most arresting biographies, Chief Engineer -- could capture such intimacies, so credibly and movingly. as CL said "Reading this feels like standing on the landing out-side the apartment, with the door left slightly ajar." I hope to stand at Wagner's door again.
I was never convinced that Wagner's impositions were a better prospect than a straight version of Trevelyan's diary would have been. All too often, Wagner needlessly breaks in after a paragraph to parrot, sometimes word for word, what Trevelyan has just said, overexplaining the most surface level emotions and politics. Besides, even if she had been more insightful, I think that something major is lost in the extraction of these quotes from their quotidian, cumulative context. But I often find literary biography an obnoxious and frustrating practice.
“One of the most astonishing things about Eliot is that a poet with such a strong dramatic style should seem so blinded to the existence of people outside himself.”