Nancy Springer’s Blood Trail follows a highschool boy named Jeremy as he struggles to overcome the murder of his best friend. The story begins with Jeremy and his best friend Aaron hanging out together just as they always do. However, on their way home, Aaron tells Jeremy that he is scared. When Jeremy asks Aaron what he is scared of, Aaron replies with Nathan, the name of his brother. Aaron then enters his home leaving Jeremy worried and confused. It turns out Jeremy was right to be worried because the next day Jeremy wakes up to see tons of police cars and ambulances a few streets down; his worst fears come to reality when he is informed by the police officers that Aaron had been murdered. Jeremy went home to cry. However, he was not given much alone time before reporters started appearing at his house constantly. Eventually, even detectives showed up; they asked Jeremy if he knew anything about the murder and who could have done it. Jeremy lies and tells the detectives he knows nothing. Jeremy spends the next week debating what to do with the information he kept hidden from the detectives. It would not matter though as he is later forced to take a lie detector test; in which Jeremy’s suspicion of Nathan is revealed to the police. Eventually, Nathan is detained and put on trial. Word gets out that Aaron’s friend told the police it was Nathan. This leads to even more emotional trauma as Jeremy now has people showing up to his house and approaching him on the streets harassing him about how horrible of a person he is for putting the Grinch's (Aaron and Nathan’s family) in an even worse situation. Jeremy becomes even more conflicted with himself. He is not sure of what happened, nor is he sure that he should have revealed his suspicion of Nathan. Aaron’s family turns on Jeremy which upsets him even more. He thinks back on all the memories he made with Aaron, Nathan, and the rest of their family. In the end, Jeremy takes a moment to think by himself at the very waterhole where the book begins: where Aaron informs Jeremy of his fear of Nathan. Jeremy is eventually joined by his mom and sister who help him come to terms with what happened. Finally, the family leaves together to go get a bite to eat.
Blood Trail is a book that takes a certain acquired taste. Some may like this book while others might not. I, myself, was not overly intrigued by this book. The plot really seemed to be missing something; the biggest event of the book happened within the first twenty pages. The story sort of feels as if it is unfinished as well. The ending to the book didn’t feel like the internal conflict had been resolved within Jeremy. Some of Jeremy’s last lines in the book reflect this. For instance Jeremy says, “I’m never going to understand”, he continues saying,”Even if [Nathan] did confess, I still wouldn’t get it” (Springer 104). An argument could be made, however, that Jeremy’s resolution is that he accepts that he will never understand why Nathan did what he did. However, I feel like there was much more that needed to be resolved like the situations revolving around the Gringichs who now hate Jeremy and send their daughter away, separating her from Jeremy’s sister. On a good note, the main focus of the story is Jeremy’s mental health and how he is dealing with the trauma he has gone through; I think there are some good aspects derived from this. Jeremy can be very relatable to someone like me who is a highschool kid. He struggles throughout the book and although the reason he is struggling might not be relatable, the way he reacts to said struggles can be. Furthermore, this book does a great job at gradually helping readers understand more and more about Jeremy and the way he feels. For instance, shortly after Jeremy decides not to talk to the detectives about Aaron’s fear of Nathan, he tries to convince himself what he did was right: “The truth was, I’d told him everything except who Aaron had said he was afraid of. I wasn’t going to snitch on Nathan, because he couldn’t have done it. I mean, I’d known him as long as I’d known Aaron. When we were kids, we all played snow forts together, hunted fossils together . . . went camping, and told ghost stories together” (Springer 22). Jeremy initially has a lot of doubt concerning whether or not Nathan really killed Aaron. However, over time, Jeremy comes to terms with the fact that the Nathan he once knew was no longer the current Nathan. Jeremy matures throughout the story as he is exposed to the harsh realities of the world. In short, Blood Trail follows a very relatable character’s process of overcoming and accepting a very tragic event in his life. Although it is not the most interesting book, it has many deep meanings and lessons throughout as readers are exposed to the struggles one may face inside themself.