Aliens was a core part of my childhood, so much so that the titular Vasquez was a role model of mine as a kid, so I was looking forward to this book all year!
Did I enjoy the book? You bet your balls (testes or ovaries, whichever you have/prefer) that I did! It’s fun, fast-paced, and begins with a poignant punch.
This novel does fully situate the original four Alien movies within the Prometheus timeline, in that we have some Vickers people (Charlize Theron’s character in Prometheus) and Weyland-Yutani. These two corporations and their nepotism have survived almost 200 years (which is not unbelievable, really). I'm not sure how I feel about this enmeshing of what I always considered to be separate universes, but this is not GoodMovies, so moving on.
In terms of good stuff, the first 20% of so deals with Jeanette’s backstory, which was engrossing and compelling and so rich in detail. I both understood and was furious for Jeanette, as well as impressed and proud of her grit and tenacity. The first quarter of this novel really is fantastic, and I wish it were longer. I kind of hoped for some scenes with her crew before her demise (spoiler alert?) Aliens but we don’t really get that.
I loved the LGBTQ+ rep in the story, the gender parity, and the authenticity of Jeanette’s Latinx heritage that definitely righted the wrongs in terms of the casting of Vasquez in Aliens. I liked the emphasis on the bonds of family and the positive and negative outlook toward the future. We have humanity still kicking around on earth as well as dystopian elements that are not far-fetched. The wealth gap is going strong, as well as the restriction of rights towards society’s “undesirables.”
In terms of the aliens though, if you were hoping for an action-packed marines vs xenomorphs novel, this has that much in the way grocery stores had toilet paper at the start of COVID. That’s to say, in short supply. While the xenos are part of the story, they are barely part of the story, and all the action with them is in the last 15%. The alien attacks are fairly standard, the attempt to make them more dangerous was a little flimsy, and the action is too fast-paced. While the description of a disfigured alien queen was quite creepy and unique (I can see why Castro writes horror), the final battle was so rushed I have whiplash.
It felt like this novel should have been a trilogy or at the very least a duology. We could have gotten a full-blown Jeanette novel, or at least her story interwoven with her twins as children/teenagers, as a first book, then the core of this book under discussion as the second and really include the aliens.
While the twins did have distinct personalities and motivations, it just wasn’t enough to really build out all the characters. We get that Leticia is a badass with confidence and grit, but we don’t get enough of Leticia’s military friends to actually care about them. The relationship surrounding Ramon, Mary Anne, and Julia had so much potential to be hard-hitting regarding the corruption of power and sociopathy, but it was competing with Leticia’s military rise and her own (unnecessary) romance. I also had no idea how much time had passed in the novel as it progressed. Were the twins in their mid-twenties or late forties when the last scenes take place? I have no idea.
These reasons are why I think the book should have been a duology - there just wasn’t enough space for three major storylines as well as an alien plot that was fully fleshed out. In truth, I don’t “blame” the author for this. I think - and this is just speculation on my part - the publisher only wanted to make one of these but told her she had to include all these plot points but keep it around 400 pages (the page count of all these recent Alien and Predator and AVP books). If this is what happened, I think she did an admirable job but it’s shame the novel wasn’t longer. I would have had no issue reading an extra 100-200 pages. I’ll definitely be checking out Castro’s other work.
The best part of the novel is the first part with Jeanette. It’s poignant to many issues plaguing our world today - such as racism, police brutality, youth in prison systems, sexuality, reproductive justice, immigration, and poverty - and, as such, I was more heavily invested in Jeanette than I was her children. Which, to be fair, was what I wanted to read about anyway.
All of these critiques aren't to say I didn't enjoy it (I gave it 4 stars!) but to explain why it wasn't a 5-star read for me. These things are more reflective analyses based on retrospection - while reading it, I was definitely enjoying it. It's a fun and easy-to-read adventure that I do recommend for fans of the Alien universe.