I picked this up from the library as background reading for the upcoming election cycle. It’s pretty short, so I didn’t think it would take long to read. My expectation turned to be accurate (although I did find it kind of boring, so I put it down for a while in the middle), partly due to the page count and partly due to the writing’s surprising lack of density.
Haley is a mediocre writer. This work is serviceable at best, and trite and simplistic if I’m less charitable. A lot of sentences are clumsy and repetitive. Ideas are not woven together so much as hammered into shape, with arguments falling next to each other like a mosaic instead of building a compelling whole. It’s fine, I guess, but it’s nothing special.
This book does do one of the things I was hoping it would: it reveals a lot about Haley’s assumptions, values, and stances on many of the issues that will be relevant in the upcoming election. She doesn’t list off her policy opinions, but she explains her approval or condemnation of various figures in ways that show her political beliefs. The book also gives the audience a picture of Haley’s leadership style, management style, and attitude toward foreign affairs. It’s a decent look at her as a candidate.
My last point is an emotional reaction. Is this really still where we are with women in American politics? That’s disheartening to think about. This book is written like it’s supposed to be optimistic, but the “girl power” message largely falls flat for me. Women’s empowerment is a worthy cause, and some chapters of this book manage more sincerity than others. (Nadia Murad’s chapter is very illustrative of how far there is still to go for women’s equality on a global scale.) However, when Haley tries to transpose the lessons she pulls from these women’s stories onto present-day American politics, she ends up oversimplifying until her rhetoric sounds like a child on the playground saying anything a boy can do, a girl can do better. American politics as old boys’ club is a well-known reality, but we’re working on additional layers of the fight for equality now, not just on having women run for office. Haley’s message is a flattened version of feminism, and while her writing has conviction, it lacks the power I expected from the first minority female governor of South Carolina. Girl power is no longer the revolutionary concept it once was, and in relying on it, Haley loses a lot of punch. We’ll see how her angle performs in the public eye over the next several months.
Three stars, which is a bit generous. This book is clunky and unmemorable, but it is coherent.