As is almost always the case, wrestling books are graded on a death-defyingly steep curve. Nitro is a really interesting and daunting project, and it I think fails its premise, but is still valuable as something really different. It focuses a lot on the corporate dealings of Ted Turner's company and the AOL-Time Warner merger. But a) that stuff is generally pretty boring and b) it doesn't go far enough into it to contort it into something interesting. Relies on too many bland and repetitive quotes from those willing to participate. The tidbits about Ted Turner's life and character were really interesting, and since the book has "Ted Turner" in the title, you would have expected a lot more biography on Turner himself. This book really could have been 1,000 pgs, which is ridiculous, but at the same time, I read this, a 566 pg. wrestling book, in a little over a week. So what are we quibbling over?
The wrestling stuff is all old-hat at this point. The Monday Night Wars have been covered. And, really, I read wrestling books to get the gossip, the dirt, the lies, the in-fighting, the insane stories, and Nitro has a decent amount of that stuff, but not nearly enough to make this one of the all-time wrestling books. I give it four stars for just how much it crams in. The Vince Russo section in the last 150 pgs. or so is the best by far.
I'd say this is better than Bryan Alvarez's The Death of WCW, the other definitive WCW book, because that book deals way too much in TV ratings and PPV buy-rates (I know wrestling was always obsessed with these figures, but it is so boring to read about), but then again, this isn't about the whole of WCW. It covers the Monday Night Wars (1997-1999) thoroughly to the bitter end. It doesn't actually cover WCW or even the Nitro beginnings in much depth. Ric Flair is barely mentioned in this book, and he isn't quoted much beyond a promo transcript, and he's Ric Flair. He is WCW. Nitro is lacking in a lot of key areas, but again, as a wrestling book, and as something different trying to cover the business and TV side of things from a bygone era (cable TV, wrestling's mainstream hayday, the WCW/WWF battles), it is worth a read for those freakish readers who are like me.